IR 05000321/1998001: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(StriderTol Bot change)
(StriderTol Bot change)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{Adams
{{Adams
| number = ML20249A226
| number = ML20217N307
| issue date = 06/08/1998
| issue date = 04/21/1998
| title = Ack Receipt of Informing NRC of Steps Taken to Correct Violations Noted in Insp Repts 50-321/98-01 & 50-366/98-01.Violation 98-01-06 Revised 980601 to Require Documentation of Surveys Performed in Support of Work
| title = Discusses Insp Repts 50-321/98-01 & 50-366/98-01 Issued on 980420 & Informs That NRC Determined That Violation of NRC Requirements Occurred.Violation Resulted in Mcrec Sys Not Being Able to Perform Intended Safety Function
| author name = Skinner P
| author name = Reyes L
| author affiliation = NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION II)
| author affiliation = NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION II)
| addressee name = Sumner H
| addressee name = Sumner H
Line 10: Line 10:
| license number =  
| license number =  
| contact person =  
| contact person =  
| document report number = 50-321-98-01, 50-321-98-1, 50-366-98-01, 50-366-98-1, NUDOCS 9806160198
| document report number = 50-321-98-01, 50-321-98-1, 50-366-98-01, 50-366-98-1, EA-98-209, NUDOCS 9805050287
| title reference date = 05-21-1998
| document type = CORRESPONDENCE-LETTERS, OUTGOING CORRESPONDENCE
| document type = CORRESPONDENCE-LETTERS, OUTGOING CORRESPONDENCE
| page count = 3
| page count = 5
}}
}}


Line 19: Line 18:


=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:- -- -
{{#Wiki_filter:.
c;    .m
  <
  ,        l g;<"
l . .
June 8, 1998
    .
l Docket Nos. 50-321, 50-366 l  License Nos. DPR-57, NPF-5 L
Southern Nuclear Operating Company, Inc.


Mr. H. L. Sumner, Jr. .'
!
ATTN:
l April 21.1998 Southern Nuclear Operating Company. Inc.
Vice President P. O. Box 1295 Birmingham, AL 35201-1295 SUBJECT: NRC INSPECTION REPORT N0. 50-321/98-01 AND 50-366/98-01
 
ATTN: Mr. H. L. Sumner. Jr.
 
Vice President. Hatch Plant Nuclear Operations P.O. Box 1295 Birmingham AL 35201 SUBJECT: EXERCISE OF ENFORCEMENT DISCRETION t
  (NRC INTEGRATED INSPECTION REPORT 50-321/98-01. 50-366/98-01)


==Dear Mr. Sumner:==
==Dear Mr. Sumner:==
!  Thank you for your response of May 21, 1998 to our Notice of Violation, issued on A3ril- 21,1998, concerning activities conducted at your Hatch-facility. We have evaluated your response and found that it meets the requirements of 10 CFR 2.201.
On March 21. 1998, the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) completed an inspection at your Hatch facility. The results of that inspection were discussed at an exit meeting conducted on March 27. 1998. and documented in NRC Inspection Report No. 50-321/98-01. 50-366/98-01 issued on April 20.1998.
 
During the inspection, the NRC examined an issue related to the Main Control Room Environmental Control (MCREC) system. On February 16. your staff identified that a tem 3erature switch was not installed on each of the two MCREC trains. On eac1 MCREC filter train, the missing temperature switch left an approximately one-half inch diameter hole that was open to a conduit containing the wiring for each missing temperature switch. The holes left by
'
the missing temperature switches allowed bypass flow to enter the control room without filtration by charcoal filters installed in the affected MCREC filter trains. The design basis of the plant includes limiting thyroid dose to control room personnel to less than 30 Rem during and following a design basis accident. As documented in NRC Inspection Report No. 50-321/98-01.
 
50-366/98-01. and in your Licensee Event Report 50-321/98-001. Inoperable MCREC System Filter Trains Result in Entry Into LCO 3.0.3. dated March 18.
 
1998. with the charcoal filters in both MCREC trains bypassed as a result of l the openings created by the missing temperature switches. the thyroid dose I received by control room personnel would have exceeded 30 Rem in the event of
,
a design basis accident.
 
Based on the information developed during the inspection. the NRC has
; determined that a violation of NRC requirements occurred. 10 CFR 50 Appendix B. Criterion III. Design Control, requires that measures shall he
'
established to verify the adequacy of design, such as by design reviews, alternate or simplified calculational methods, or suitable testing. In this case. the requirements of Appendix B. Criterion III. were not met because measures were not established to verify the adequacy of the as-installed MCREC ,
system filter tr.in d a ign. This violation resulted in the MCREC system not being able to pe:Torm its intended safety function under certain design basis !
l conditions A violctirm involving a safety-related system which is unable to perform its intended safety function under certain conditions is generally )
  ~
98050502a7 980421 PDR ADOCK 05000321 G  PDR    {
      .1?O!
 
. -
  .
SNC  2 characterized as a Severity Level III violation in accordance with the
" General Statement of Policy and Procedures for Enforcement Actions" (Enforcement Policy). NUREG-1600. However, as provided in Section VII.B.3 of the Enforcement Policy, the NRC may refrain from issuing a Notice of Violation (Notice) and proposing a civil penalty for a Severity Level III violation which involves old design issues.
 
After review of this violation and consultation with the Director Office of Enforcement, the NRC has concluded that while a violation did occur, enforcement discretion is warranted end issuance of a Notice is not appropriate in this case. The specific bases for the decision to exercise enforcement discretion are: (1) your staff identified the deficiency during planned testing and calibration of the MCREC filter trains, when a special effort was made to remove the charcoal filter beds out of Josition to look behind a portion of the system that was not easily accessi)le: (2) you promptly declared both MCREC system filter trains inoperable and entered the required action statement of Technical Specification (TS) 3.0.3: (3) as part of your immediate corrective actions, the Standby Gas Trer.tment Systems for both units, which have a similar configuration as the MCREC system, were verified to have no missing temperature switches: (4) you promptly implemented an appropriate temporary modification for each MCREC system filter train in accordance with plant procedures, and exited TS 3.0.3: (5) the temporary modification for each train was removed and a temperature switch for each train was installed and properly tested in accordance with plant procedures:
(6) the deficiency is considered an old design issue, was not likely to be identified through routine licensee efforts, and is not reflective of current licensee performance: and (7) the issue was reported to the NRC in Licensee
,
Event Report 50-321/98-001. Inoperable MCREC System Filter Trains Result in Entry Into LCO 3.0.3, dated March 18, 1998.
 
This letter closes apparent violation EEI 50-321,366/98-01-08, and no formal response to the apparent violation is recuired. NRC's final evaluation of your corrective actions will be addressec during the review and closeout of-LER 50-321/98-001.
 
*
!  .
i In accordance with 10.CER 2.790 of the NRC's " Rules of Proctice " a copy of I this letter will be'pbiced in the NRC Public Document Room.


With regard to Violation 98-01-06, on June 6. 1998, in a telephone conversation between NRC and Southern Nuclear Operating Company  -
*
representatives, the res)onse to Violation 98-01-06 was revised. It is our understanding that tie appropriate procedure was revised on June 1. I 1998 to require documentation of surveys performed in support of work activities instead of "in support of plant maintenance activities" only. ,
  .
        - - -
We will examine the implementation of your corrective actions durincj j%s(,b future inspections. Your cooperation in this matter-is appreciated. ~'ey


Sincerely
Sincerely
.
.
    (Original signed by H.O. Christensen L    for P.H. Skinner)  ;
  %
I s,  '
Original Signed by L. A. Reyes Luis A. Reyes Regional Administrator Docket Nos. 50-321 and 50-366 License Nos.. DPR-57 and NPF-5 cc: see Page 3
Pierce H. Skinner. Chief
 
. Reactor Projects Branch 2 i    Division of Reactor Projects
T
  - cc,: J. D. Woodard i
  , -
'
  .
Executive Vice President   i Southern Nuclear Operating Company, Inc. I-
SNC  3 cc:
      '
. J. D. Woodard Executive Vice President Southern Nuclear Operating Co., Inc.
P. 0.~ Box 1295 Birmingham, AL 35201-1295 cc cont'd: (See Page 2)
 
l  9906160198 990600 L  PDR ADOCK 05000321 l
P.. 0. Box 1295 Birmingham AL' 35201-1295 Mr. P. H. Wells General Manager. Hatch Southern Nuclear Operating Co., Inc.
8  PDR    !
        )
:-____________-_----_-______---___-_____-.
SU


          . _ - _ _ . _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ . __ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . __ __
; U.S Highway 1 North P. O. Box 2010
'
-
., ..
l Baxley, GA 31515 D. M. Crowe
s.
; Manager Licensing - Hatch l Southern Nuclear Operating Co., Inc.


J SNC'      2
; P. O. Box 1295 Birmingham AL 35201-1295 Ernest L. Blake. Esq.


[1
Shaw. Pittman. Potts and Trowbridge 2300 N Street. NW
'
-
scc: Continued P. H. Wells General Manager. Plant Hatch
Washington, D. C. 20037 j Charles H. Badger Office of Planning and Budget Room 610 270 Washington Street. SW Atlanta, GA 30334
      : Southern Nuclear Operating Company. Inc.
! Harold Reheis. Director Department of Natural Resources 205 Butler Street. SE. Suite 1252 Atlanta, GA 30334 I Thomas Hill Manager l Radioactive Materials Program i Department of Natural Resources !
l 4244 International Parkway 1 Suite 114 Atlanta. GA 30354  ;
Chairman
    !
Appling County Commissioners County Courthouse  1 Baxley. GA 31513


U. S. Highway 1 North P. O. Box 2010 Baxley. GA 31515 O. M. Crowe Manager Licensing  Hatch Southern Nuclear Operating Company. Inc.
.,
--
. .
l SNC  4 i
!
cc: Continued R. D. Barker Program Manager i
Fossil & Nuclear Operations i Oglethor3e Power Corporation
: 2100 E. Exchange Place
! Tucker, GA 30085-1349 Charles A. Patrizia. Esq.


-
Paul Hastings, Janofsky & Walker 10th Floor 1299 Pennsylvania Avenue Washington, D. C. 20004-9500
P. 0, Box 1295
, Steven M. Jackson Senior Engineer - Power Supply i Municipal Electric Authority of Georgia
''
~
      . Birmingham. AL 35201-1295'
.
Ernest L. Blake. Esq.
1470 Riveredge Parkway NW l Atlanta, GA 30328-4684


Shaw. Pittman Potts and Trowbridge -
l l    ;
2300-N Street. NW  .
l i
Washington, D. C. 20037 Office of Planning-and Budget
l
      ' Room 610
      .270 Washington Street. SW Atlanta, GA '30334      3 Director Department of Natural Resources 205 Butler Street..SE. Suite 1252
,      At1anta. GA' 30334 Manager. Radioactive Materials Program
'
              .,
      ' Department of Natural Resources      !
              "
4244 International Parkway Suite 114
    ..
Atlanta. GA 30354.


l      Chairman L      Appling. County Commissioners      i o      County Courthouse      '
1 j
      :Baxley, GA 31513 Program Mnager        i Fossil &:Wuclear Operations      !
I
              '
- -
,    OglethorpePowerCorporation1 2100 E. _xchange Place Tucker..GA -.30085-1349'
              ;
,
cc cont'd: .(See Page 3)
L
- _ _ - - - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _  . _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ -


I . .
u p
*
  .
  .
k A
+ a.
SNC    3 cc: Continued Charles A. Patrizia Esq.


Paul, Hastings Janofsky & Walker 10th Floor 1299 Pennsylvania Avenue
l r. Distribution:
,
l' LJCallan. EDO-HThompson DEDR AThadani. DEDE LChandler. OGC l JGoldberg OGC EJulian,:SECY BKeeling CA l Enforcement Coordinators l RI. RIII. RIV
Washington, D. C. 20004-9500 Senior Engineer - Power Supply Municipal Electric Authority of Georgia 1470 Riveredge Parkway NW Atlanta, GA 30328-4684 Distribution):
!
L. Plisco. RII P. H. Skinrer, RII R. P. Carrion, RII W. P. Kleir sorge. RII L. Olshan, NRR l  PUBLIC NRC Residem Inspector U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 11030 Hatch Parkway-North Baxley, GA 31513 A
JLieberman. OE l WBeecher. OPA l GCaputo. 01 l TMartin. AE0D l HBell. OIG i CEvans. RII
  ,0 L OFFICE Elj d $5% \ $ p S:PSS SIGIATLRE \' ) ]Qm IIAIE RPdardon-da 10 Fr, DATE 6/ D /98 6/ h /98 6/ /96 6/ /98 6/ /98 6/ /98 . 6/ /98 m? YES IID IEST 11 0 YES IID YES 11 0 YES 11 0 YES 11 0 l__ _ _ YES 11 0 0FFICIAL RECORD COPY DOCIDENT IIANE: G:\llATCHTAQtt15-01.LTH I
!
KClark RII
.
' LPlisco. RII BMallett. RII PSkinner. RII MTschiltz. OEDO l ABoland. RII
! SSparks. RII LOlshan NRR
'TReis. OE RCarrion. RII l
'
OE:EA File (BSummers. OE)(2 letterhead)
PUBLIC i
'
  .NRC Resident Inspector
, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission   ,
11030 Hatch Parkway North-l Baxley GA 31513   .
    (  ,
sh
    +9  ge
    /  / .
SENDTOPUBLICDOCUMENTR00M7[ YES  [ [/ //
OFFICE di! +pWP - Rll:0k / RilhtpS [ RI/ydR[  RI!:0[[
A L EVAN D DATE 4/ N /98 I/ /98 4/ d[/ /98 4/ M /98- k/ N /9 0 COPY? YES - k YES No fES) NO YES h YES [0) YES NO OfflCIAL RECORD M Y DOCUMENT NAME:H'I\1980 PEN.ENF\98209 HAT.DIR\DISCLTR.HA V
}}
}}

Revision as of 14:55, 26 January 2022

Discusses Insp Repts 50-321/98-01 & 50-366/98-01 Issued on 980420 & Informs That NRC Determined That Violation of NRC Requirements Occurred.Violation Resulted in Mcrec Sys Not Being Able to Perform Intended Safety Function
ML20217N307
Person / Time
Site: Hatch  Southern Nuclear icon.png
Issue date: 04/21/1998
From: Reyes L
NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION II)
To: Sumner H
SOUTHERN NUCLEAR OPERATING CO.
References
50-321-98-01, 50-321-98-1, 50-366-98-01, 50-366-98-1, EA-98-209, NUDOCS 9805050287
Download: ML20217N307 (5)
v • d • e


Text

{{#Wiki_filter:. 

<

l . .

! l April 21.1998 Southern Nuclear Operating Company. Inc.

ATTN: Mr. H. L. Sumner. Jr.

Vice President. Hatch Plant Nuclear Operations P.O. Box 1295 Birmingham AL 35201 SUBJECT: EXERCISE OF ENFORCEMENT DISCRETION t 

 (NRC INTEGRATED INSPECTION REPORT 50-321/98-01. 50-366/98-01)

Dear Mr. Sumner:

On March 21. 1998, the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) completed an inspection at your Hatch facility. The results of that inspection were discussed at an exit meeting conducted on March 27. 1998. and documented in NRC Inspection Report No. 50-321/98-01. 50-366/98-01 issued on April 20.1998.

During the inspection, the NRC examined an issue related to the Main Control Room Environmental Control (MCREC) system. On February 16. your staff identified that a tem 3erature switch was not installed on each of the two MCREC trains. On eac1 MCREC filter train, the missing temperature switch left an approximately one-half inch diameter hole that was open to a conduit containing the wiring for each missing temperature switch. The holes left by ' the missing temperature switches allowed bypass flow to enter the control room without filtration by charcoal filters installed in the affected MCREC filter trains. The design basis of the plant includes limiting thyroid dose to control room personnel to less than 30 Rem during and following a design basis accident. As documented in NRC Inspection Report No. 50-321/98-01.

50-366/98-01. and in your Licensee Event Report 50-321/98-001. Inoperable MCREC System Filter Trains Result in Entry Into LCO 3.0.3. dated March 18.

1998. with the charcoal filters in both MCREC trains bypassed as a result of l the openings created by the missing temperature switches. the thyroid dose I received by control room personnel would have exceeded 30 Rem in the event of , a design basis accident.

Based on the information developed during the inspection. the NRC has

determined that a violation of NRC requirements occurred. 10 CFR 50 Appendix B. Criterion III. Design Control, requires that measures shall he

' established to verify the adequacy of design, such as by design reviews, alternate or simplified calculational methods, or suitable testing. In this case. the requirements of Appendix B. Criterion III. were not met because measures were not established to verify the adequacy of the as-installed MCREC , system filter tr.in d a ign. This violation resulted in the MCREC system not being able to pe:Torm its intended safety function under certain design basis ! l conditions A violctirm involving a safety-related system which is unable to perform its intended safety function under certain conditions is generally ) 

  ~

98050502a7 980421 PDR ADOCK 05000321 G PDR { 

     .1?O!

. -
.

SNC 2 characterized as a Severity Level III violation in accordance with the 

" General Statement of Policy and Procedures for Enforcement Actions" (Enforcement Policy). NUREG-1600. However, as provided in Section VII.B.3 of the Enforcement Policy, the NRC may refrain from issuing a Notice of Violation (Notice) and proposing a civil penalty for a Severity Level III violation which involves old design issues.

After review of this violation and consultation with the Director Office of Enforcement, the NRC has concluded that while a violation did occur, enforcement discretion is warranted end issuance of a Notice is not appropriate in this case. The specific bases for the decision to exercise enforcement discretion are: (1) your staff identified the deficiency during planned testing and calibration of the MCREC filter trains, when a special effort was made to remove the charcoal filter beds out of Josition to look behind a portion of the system that was not easily accessi)le: (2) you promptly declared both MCREC system filter trains inoperable and entered the required action statement of Technical Specification (TS) 3.0.3: (3) as part of your immediate corrective actions, the Standby Gas Trer.tment Systems for both units, which have a similar configuration as the MCREC system, were verified to have no missing temperature switches: (4) you promptly implemented an appropriate temporary modification for each MCREC system filter train in accordance with plant procedures, and exited TS 3.0.3: (5) the temporary modification for each train was removed and a temperature switch for each train was installed and properly tested in accordance with plant procedures: 

(6) the deficiency is considered an old design issue, was not likely to be identified through routine licensee efforts, and is not reflective of current licensee performance: and (7) the issue was reported to the NRC in Licensee

, Event Report 50-321/98-001. Inoperable MCREC System Filter Trains Result in Entry Into LCO 3.0.3, dated March 18, 1998.

This letter closes apparent violation EEI 50-321,366/98-01-08, and no formal response to the apparent violation is recuired. NRC's final evaluation of your corrective actions will be addressec during the review and closeout of-LER 50-321/98-001.

! . i In accordance with 10.CER 2.790 of the NRC's " Rules of Proctice " a copy of I this letter will be'pbiced in the NRC Public Document Room. 

 .

Sincerely . 

 %

Original Signed by L. A. Reyes Luis A. Reyes Regional Administrator Docket Nos. 50-321 and 50-366 License Nos.. DPR-57 and NPF-5 cc: see Page 3

T 

, -
 .

SNC 3 cc: 

. J. D. Woodard Executive Vice President Southern Nuclear Operating Co., Inc.

P.. 0. Box 1295 Birmingham AL' 35201-1295 Mr. P. H. Wells General Manager. Hatch Southern Nuclear Operating Co., Inc.

U.S Highway 1 North P. O. Box 2010

- l Baxley, GA 31515 D. M. Crowe

Manager Licensing - Hatch l Southern Nuclear Operating Co., Inc.
P. O. Box 1295 Birmingham AL 35201-1295 Ernest L. Blake. Esq.

Shaw. Pittman. Potts and Trowbridge 2300 N Street. NW 

-

Washington, D. C. 20037 j Charles H. Badger Office of Planning and Budget Room 610 270 Washington Street. SW Atlanta, GA 30334 ! Harold Reheis. Director Department of Natural Resources 205 Butler Street. SE. Suite 1252 Atlanta, GA 30334 I Thomas Hill Manager l Radioactive Materials Program i Department of Natural Resources ! l 4244 International Parkway 1 Suite 114 Atlanta. GA 30354  ; Chairman 

   !

Appling County Commissioners County Courthouse 1 Baxley. GA 31513 

.,
--
. .

l SNC 4 i ! cc: Continued R. D. Barker Program Manager i Fossil & Nuclear Operations i Oglethor3e Power Corporation

2100 E. Exchange Place

! Tucker, GA 30085-1349 Charles A. Patrizia. Esq.

Paul Hastings, Janofsky & Walker 10th Floor 1299 Pennsylvania Avenue Washington, D. C. 20004-9500 , Steven M. Jackson Senior Engineer - Power Supply i Municipal Electric Authority of Georgia ~ . 1470 Riveredge Parkway NW l Atlanta, GA 30328-4684

l l  ; l i l

1 j I

u p 

.
+ a.

l r. Distribution: l' LJCallan. EDO-HThompson DEDR AThadani. DEDE LChandler. OGC l JGoldberg OGC EJulian,:SECY BKeeling CA l Enforcement Coordinators l RI. RIII. RIV ! JLieberman. OE l WBeecher. OPA l GCaputo. 01 l TMartin. AE0D l HBell. OIG i CEvans. RII ! KClark RII . ' LPlisco. RII BMallett. RII PSkinner. RII MTschiltz. OEDO l ABoland. RII ! SSparks. RII LOlshan NRR 

'TReis. OE RCarrion. RII l

' OE:EA File (BSummers. OE)(2 letterhead) PUBLIC i ' 

.NRC Resident Inspector

, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission , 11030 Hatch Parkway North-l Baxley GA 31513 . 

    (  ,

sh 

   +9  ge
   /  / .

SENDTOPUBLICDOCUMENTR00M7[ YES [ [/ // OFFICE di! +pWP - Rll:0k / RilhtpS [ RI/ydR[ RI!:0[[ A L EVAN D DATE 4/ N /98 I/ /98 4/ d[/ /98 4/ M /98- k/ N /9 0 COPY? YES - k YES No fES) NO YES h YES [0) YES NO OfflCIAL RECORD M Y DOCUMENT NAME:H'I\1980 PEN.ENF\98209 HAT.DIR\DISCLTR.HA V }}

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=IR_05000321/1998001&oldid=3420642"