ML20141N665
| ML20141N665 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Indian Point, Oyster Creek, Susquehanna, San Onofre, Maine Yankee, 05000000, Trojan |
| Issue date: | 03/11/1986 |
| From: | Stello V NRC OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR FOR OPERATIONS (EDO) |
| To: | Asselstine NRC COMMISSION (OCM) |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20141N666 | List: |
| References | |
| GL-83-33, GL-85-01, GL-85-1, TAC-64883, NUDOCS 8603170475 | |
| Download: ML20141N665 (23) | |
Text
~ ' ' ' - -
.i E p us
-- *g UNITED STATES
=
[ 2, NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION b 3 j WASHINGTON, D. C. 20655
- ,o MAR 111996 1
MEMORANDUM FOR: Comissioner Asselstine FROM: Victor Stello, Jr.
Acting Executive Director E for Operations
SUBJECT:
SECY 85-306 - STAFF RECOMMENDATIONS REGARDING THE
-_ IMPLEMENTATION OF APPENDIX R TO 10 CFR 50 By memorandum dated February 20, 1986, you requested the following infomation
_ regarding SECY 85-306:
[
=-
- 1. Which licensees are using the "new interpretations"?
y 2. How will any such use of the new interpretations affect the i compliance schedules contained in the ED0 memorandum to the
! Comission dated December 26, 1985?
E
- 3. How is such use of the new interpretations consistent with . repeated assurances by the staff that all fire protection SERs, including 7- those for plants licensed after January 1, 1979, have been based on Generic Letter 83-33 or the existing Branch Technical Position?
E' Through regional workshops and in Generic Letter (GL) 85-01 ino,3try was i informed of the "new interpretations" concerning Appendix R. In both the regional workshops and in GL 85-01 the industry was informed that the 2 information concerning the new interpretations was draft and would not 2 become final until Comission approval. The following is a list of plants
__ which have requested staff evaluation of their fire protection program based on the interpretations contained in SECY 85-306:
I 1. Indian Point Unit 3
.' 2. Maine Yankee E
- 3. Oyster Creek
=
- 4. Tro.ian Y
- 5. San Onofre Units 1, 2 and 3
=.
c E 6. Susquehanna Units 1 and 2 g
With the exception of Maine Yankee, the staff is holding the SERs on the above plants in abeyance until the Comission's final vote on SECY 85-306.
)/f
} g (.
l W
E e
CONTACT:
John Stang, NRR x28484 p
% $ $ $h0 bPDR o6
[{
R
-. ~ (p [f Comissioner Asselstine
-To the best of the staff's knowledge, the use of the new interpretations has not affected compliance schedules. However, compliance schedules for
-plant modifications have changed slightly since the EDO memorandum to the Comission dated December 26, 1985. The fire protection modification schedule has improved by three additional plants being completed in 1986 rather than 1987. Three plants have pushed back their completion schedule for alternative shutdown systems from 1986 to 1987. Enclosures 1 through 7 contain graphs .and tables showing updated completion schedules for all plants licensed prior to January 1,1979 as of March 1,1986.
Finally, as indicated above the staff is holding all SERs concerning evaluations of the new interpretations contained in SECY 85-306 until Commission approval of SECY 85-306. .To date with the exception of Maine Yankee all exemptions issued concerning issues covered in GL 83-33 have been based on GL 83-33 and not the new interpretations contained in SECY 85-306.
'In the case of Maine Yankee, should the Comission decide that the new interpretations are not to be used but rather the guidance of GL 83-33 the staff will reprocess the'affected issues as exemptions. For all plants licensed after January 1,1979 fire protection SERs are based on the SRP and all deviations from the.SRP are reviewed and justified in the SER.
Original signed by Victor Stollo Victor Stello, Jr.
Acting Executive Director for Operations
Enclosures:
- 1. Footnotes
- 2. Fire Protection Status for Plants Licensed Prior to January 1, 1979
- 3. Plants with all Appendix R Modifications Complete I
- 4. Completion Status of Alternate Shutdown Systems
- 5. Completion Status of Fire Protection Modifications
- 6. . Bar Chart of Completion Status for Alternate Shutdown Systems
- 7. Bar Chart of Completion Status for Fire Protection Modifications cc: Chairman Palladino DISTRIBUTION RMinogue Comissioner Roberts LTntral File OCA (3) GCunninghsm Comissioner Bernthal NRC PDR w/cy of incoming SECY (3) JTaylor Comissioner Zech Local PDR w/cy of incoming VStello r SECY EDO #001453 PPAS (EDO#001453)
OPE EDO Reading w/cy of incoming OGC H. Denton/D. Eisenhut R. Bernero PD#1 Reading JStano w/cy of incoming (w/cy of incoming) CJamerson OELD FMiraglia PD#1 Green Ticket File JRoe TNovak TRehm
- SEE PREVIOUS PAGE FOR CONCURRENCE JSniezek DBL:PD#1* DBL:PD#1* DBL:PD#1* DBL:DD* DRL:DIR*
CJamerson JStang:jg JZwolinski RHouston RBernero 5 03/04/86 03/04/86 03/04/86 03/04/86 03/04/86 vp NR 0 'N DIR EDO:A/DI D hut HD ton VStello
/86 4; j/86 J ////86
Enclosure 1 FOOTNOTES The footnotes below will aid you in reviewing the following charts and graphs:
- 1 50.48 Schedular Extensions Exemption Granted
- 2 50.48 Schedular Extension, Exemption Requested and Under Review by NRR
- 6 Plants Following the 50.48 Schedule for Completion of F.P. Mods and Alt. SD SYS
- 7 Plants Operating in Noncompliance of the 50.48' Schedule with Approved Compensatory Measures
- 9 Plants in Outage Will Not Restart Until Modifications Complete
+
, , , ---v - m - .-,,,,,.- -. , 9m __ --- - +- - . - - - - - - - - - - , . - -
- p. ~
. {f ' . , , 2 p ', . it ;u- - . L ,
Encitsure 2
}'
APPEXDIX R ,
A.LTERNATE SHUTDOWN SYSTEMS COMPLETION STATUS FOR PLANTS LICENSED PRIOR TO JANUARY 1, 1979.
ALTERMTE SHUTDOWN SYSTEMS STATUS SCHEDULAR EXEMPTION GRANTED ss- -
3 m SCH ED'J LAR EXEL PTION UNDER REVIEW E
so- -
IN OUTAGE: RESTART AFTER MODS. COMPLETE OPERATING UNDER NON-COMPLIANCE A.C.M.*
COMPLETE '
ti. .
E COMPLYING WITH 50.48 SCHEDULE O 20-- ,
b m
h15-z C
to- - ,
m -
e e ;l :
5" "
5 ,
I.;_or ~ , .
o
.< fL _
i MARCH 1986
- A.C.M. - APPROVED COMPENSATORY MEASURES
Encitsure 2 '
, f,'
4 .
APPENDIX R STATUS OF FIRE PROTECTION MODIFICATIONS i FOR PLANTS LICENSED PRIOR TO JANUARY 1, 1979. ;
- FIRE PROTECTION STATUS SCHEDULAR EXEMPTION GRANTED
- ss- -
7 j N SCHEDULAR EXEMPTION UNDER REVIEW j 30- - COMPLYING WITH 50.48 SCHEDULE i
OPERATING UNDER NON-COMPLIANCE A.C.M.*
{
- g. .
COMPLETE
. g 4
i i 10- -
t I
- o_
l i
- 10- -
en ==
N f b
o- =
l< ==
- =
- ==
b /' bb 3
, o
= / == ssi j MARCH 1986
- APPROVED COMPENSATORY MEASURES i
4
w
) ,' ~ -
Enctsure 2 P:_g; No. 1 03/04/86 APPENDIX R STATUS FOR PLANTS LICENSED PRIOR TO JAN.-1, 1979
{ 50.48 FACILITY DATE ALT. DATE ALT. DATE 50.48 DATE FIRE
'NAME # SHUTDOWN SHUTDOWN TECHNICAL PROTECTION SYSTEM SYSTEM S/B EXEMPTION MODS APPROVED COMPLETE ISSUED COMPLETE ARKAiJSAS 1 05/01/83 COMPLETE 03/01/83 COMPLETE ARKANSAS 2 05/01/83 COMPLETE 03/01/83 COMPLETE BEAVER VALLEY 1 01/01/83 COMPLETE 03/01/03 COMPLETE 08/01/P4 BIG ROCK POINT 01/01/83 COMPLETE 04/01/ 2 COMPLETE 03/01/83 03/01/84 03/01/85 BROWNS FERRY 1 10/01/83 12/20/09 02/01/83 12/20/89
- 9 49 BROWNS FERRY 2 10/01/83 12/20/88 02/01/83 '12/20/88
- 2 *2 BROWNS FERRY 3 10/01/83 12/20/87 02/01/83 12/20/87
$9 49 BRUNSWICK 1 UNDER REVIEW 12/31/59 UNDER REVIEW 12/31/89
$6 $6 BRUNSWICK 2 UNDER REVIEW 06/30/90 UNDER REVIEW 06/30/90
$6 *6 CALVERT CLIFFS 1 09/01/82 COKFLETE 08/01/02 COMPLETE 03/01/84 CALVERT CLIFFS 2 09/01/82 CGMPLETE 08/01/82 COMPLETE 03/01/94 COOPER STATION 04/01/84 03/31/87 07/01/83 11/31/06
- 6 47 CRYSTAL RIVER 3 -01/01/83 COMPLETE FO REQUEST 03/31/06
- 1 D3C. COOK 1 09/01/83 COMPLETE NO REQUEST COMPLETE D.C. COOK 2 09/01/83 COMPLETE NO REQUEST COMPLETE DAVIS-BESSE 06/01/82 12/31/89 11/01/82 12/31/89
- 7 08/01/84 *7 DRESDEN 2 01/01/03 06/30/87 02/01/83 06/30/87
- 2 $2
=: -- .
-.n . . .- - . . . . . .- + w
( ~ ~ L.
[ .
-Pcg:'No.- 2 y: 03/04/86 '
APPENDIX RfSTATUS FOR PLANTS LICENSED PRIOR TO JAN. 1, 1 1979-50.48 h-
' FACILITY DATE ALT. DATE ALT. DATE 50.48 DATE FIRE NAME.# ' SHUTDOWN SHUTDOWN . TECHNICAL PROTECTION' SYSTEM SYSTEM S/B. EXEMPTION MODS APPROVED COMPLETE ISSUED COMPLETE DREEDEN 3 01/01/83 06/30/87 02/01/83 ,06/30/87 42 *2 DUANE ARNOLD. 01/01/93- COMPLETE. 09/01/83 COMFLETE FARLEY 11 08/01/83 10/01/86 12/01/83 COMFLETE
$1 FIT 2 PATRICK 04/01/84 04/30/87 02/01/84 10/31/86
- 1 88 FORT CALHOUN 08/01/82 COMPLETE NO REQUEST COMPLETE FORT ST VRAIN NONE SUBMITT 08/31/97 NO REQUEST 08/31/87-
- 7 . *7 GINNA 02/01/85 04/30/86 NO REQUEST 04/30/86
- 1 *1 H B ROBINSON 2 08/01/84 COMPLETE 11/01/82 COMFLETE 11/01/83 HADisAM ' NECK 11/01/94 04/30/86 11/01/84 04/30/86
- 6 46 HATCH 1 02/01/83 COMPLETE- 04/01/84 11/31/06 Al HATCH 2 02/01/83 COMPLETE 04/01/84 11/31/86
- 1 i
' INDIAN FOINT 2 10/01/84 03/31/96 10/01/84 COMPLETE
$6
- INDIAN POINT 3 04/01/84 COMPLETE O2/01/04 COMPLETE KEWAUNEE O2/01/84 06/30/87 02/01/84 06/30/87
- 1 *1 LACROSSE- 04/01/84 COMPLETE 03/01/82 COMPLETE 07/01/03 MAINE YANKEE O2/01/83 COMPLETE 08/01/82 COMPLETE O2/01/83 11/01/03 MILLSTONE 1 11/01/G5 12/31/87 11/01/85 12/31/07
- 6 *6
.-, . - - ,. . . . -. ._; _ . u .m _ _ _ .
' P.c o n No . - 3
.03/04/86
- APPENDIX R STATUS FOR PLANTS LICEN3ED PRIOR TO JAN. 1, 1979 p 50.48
' FACILITY DATE. ALT. DATE ALT. DATE 50.48 DATE FIRE.
'NAME #' , SHUTDOWN SHUTDOWN TECHNICAL PROTECTION SYSTEM SYSTEM S/B EXEMPTION MODS APPROVED. COMPLETE ISSUED COMPLETE, MILLSTONE 2 ~ UNDER REVIEW 12/31/87 UNDER REVIEW 12/31/87
- 6 *6 MONTICELLO 12/01/93 COMPLETE 06/01/d3 COMPLETE NINE MILE-PT.1 03/01/03 COMPLETE 03/01/83 COMPLETE
' NORTH ANNA 1 11/01/G2 COMPLETE NO REQUEST COMPLETE
-NORTH ANNA 2 11/01/82 06/30/06 NO RCQUEST 06/30/86
- 7 ~* 7 OCONEE 1 04/01/83 COMPLETE 12/01/84 COMPLETE OCONEE 2 04/01/83 COMPLETE 12/01484 , COMPLETE OCONEE 3 '04/01/83 COMPLETE 12/01/84 COMPLETE OYSTER CREEK 11/18/82 10/31/86 12/17/82 10/31/86
- 1 *1 PALISADES 05/01/83 COMPLETE O2/01/03 COMPLETE PEACH BOTTON 2' 05/01/84 02/01/87 01/01/83 COMPLETE
- 2 PEACH' BOTTOM'3 05/01/84 COMPLETE 01/01/83 COMPLdTE PILGRIM 11/01/83 11/31/86 11/01/81 11/31/06
- 6 12/01/84 *6 07/03/05 POINT BEACH 1 07/03/85 12/31/86 07/03/05 12/31/86 46 16 POINT BEACH 2 07/03/85 12/31/86 07/03/85 12/31/86
- 6 *6 PRAIRIE' ISLAND 1 NONE SUBMIT. COMPLETE 05/01/83 COMPLETE 01/01/04 07/01/04 PRAIRIE ISLAND 2- NONE SUBMIT. COMPLETE 05/01/03 COMPLETE 01/01/04 07/01/84 OUAD CITIES 1 12/30/02- 04/01/86 06/01/83 06/30/06
- 2 *2 4, .
. . . . . o. . +. . . . . . ~ . . .. .. . . . . +
+ .
I',*
ki '
- l?; go No.- 4
[ 03/04/86' APPENDIX R STATUS FOR PLANTS LICENSED PRIOR TO'JAN. 1, 1977 50.48 FACILITY DATE ALT. DATE ALT. DATE 50.48 DATE FIRE NAME # SHUTDOWN SHUTDOWN TECHNICAL PROTECTION SYSTEM' SYSTEM S/D ' EXEMPTION MODS APFROVED COMPLETE . ISSUED COMPLETE
' QUAD. CITIES 2 12/20/82 04/30/86 '06/01/03 06/30/87
- 2 *2 RANCHO SECO NONE SUBMIT. ' COMPLETE 06/01/83 COMPLETE SALEM 1- 05/01/83 COMPLETE 09/01/82 COr1FLETE 06/01/83 SAN ONOFRE 1 UNDER REVIEW 06/01/06 v3/01/03 06/01/86
- 1 *1 ST LUCIE 1 09/01/84 COMPLETE' 02/01/US COMPLETE SURRY 1 11/01/82 07/01/86' 11/01/82 07/31/86
- 7 47 SllRRY 2 11/01/82 12/31/86 11/01/82 12/31/86
- 7 *7 TMI 1 06/01/84 06/30'86 06/01/84 06/30/86
- 6 46 TROJAN NONE SUDMIT. 12/31/87 12/01/82 12/31/86
- 7 07/10/83 47
. TURKEY POINT 3 04/01/84 12/31/86 03/01/84 12/31/86
- 2 *2
' TURKEY POINT 4 04/01/94 12/31/06 03/01/84 12/31/86
- 2 *2 VERMONT YANKEE 01/01/83 COMPLETE 05/01/82 COMPLETE YANKEE ROWE UNDER REVIEW COMPLETE 08/01/82 COMPLETE
. ZION 1: 03/17/83 COMPLETE 03/07/83 10/30/86
- 7 ZION,2 03/17/83 COMPLETE 03/07/83 10/30/86
$7
Enclosure 3 f
^
Page No. 1 T 03/04/86
[ APPENDIX R STATUS FOR PLANTS LICENSED FRIOR TO JAN. 1. 1979
/ WHO HAVE COMPLETED BOTH FIRE PROTECTION MODIFICATIONS p AND ALTERNATIVE SAFE SHUTDOWN SYSTEMS FACILITY ALT. SAFE FIRE PROTECT.
NAME ti SHUTDOWN MODIFICATION STATUS IS STATUS IS CO!1PLETE COMF LETE ARKANSAS 1 COMPLETE COMPLETE ARKANSAS 2 COMPLETE COMPLETE BEAVER VALLEY 1 COMPLETE COMPLETE RIG ROCI: POINT COMPLETE COMPLETE CALVCRT CLIFFS 1 COMPLETE COflPLETE CALVERT CLIFFG 2 COMPLETE COMPLETE D.C. COOK 1 COMPLETE COMFLETE D.C. COOK C COMPLETE COMPLETE DUANE ARNOLD COMFLETE COMPLETE FORT CALHOUN COMPLETE COMPLETE H B ROBINSON 2 COMPLETE COMPLETE INDIAN POINT 3 COMPLETE COMPLETE LACROSSE COMPLETE COMPLETE MAINE YANKEE COMPLETE COMPLETE MONTICELLO COMPLETE COMPLETE NINE MILE PT 1 COMPLETE COMPLETE NORTH Ar.NA 1 COMPLETE COMPLETE OCONEE 1 COMPLETE COf1PLETE OCONEE 2 COMPLETE COMPLETE OCONEE 3 COMPLETE COMPLETE PALISADES COMPLETE cot 1PLETE PEACH DOTTOM 3 COMPLETE col 1PLETE PRAIRIE ISLAND 1 COMPLETE cot 1PLETE
, y , . . - . s. . ._ . _ ~ . . . , ,
I
- I:. i3
,l-[i ' '
. ~
p., ..g.
p h Page i No. 2 ,
f::, ,
05/04/86
. APPENDIX R STATUS FOR PLANTS LICENSED PRIOR TO.JAN. 1, 1979
'WHO HAVE COMPLETED BOTH - FIRE PROTECTION MODIFICATIONS ,
k /AND ALTERNATIVE SAFE SHUTDOWN SYSTEMS
' FACILITY -ALT. SAFE -FIRE PROTECT.
MODIFICATION
~
~NAt1E #- SHUTDOWN STATUS.IS STATUS IS COMPLETE COMPLETE FRAIRIE' ISLAND 2 COMPLETE. COMPLETE.
T
, RAtlCHO SECO COMPLETE ' COMPLETE 't-SALEM 1 COMPLETE COMPLETE ST[LUCIE 1 cot 1PLETE COMPLETE
' VERMONT YA*JIJEE cot 1PLETE COMPLETE
-YANKEE ROWE COMPLETE COMPLETE o
P 5
sf'
46%"** m
,. "~ -e - __ m .
Encl 1sure 4 k
" Page flo. 1 03/04/86
. APPENDIX R STATUS FOR PLANTS LICENSED PRIOR TO JAN. 1, 1979 COMPLETION STATUS OF ALTERNATE SHUTDOWN SYSTEMS
{'
FACILITY DATE ALT. IF NOT NAME # SHUTDOWN COMPLETE, SYSTEM S/B FOOTrJOTE COMPLETE ARKAr4SAS 1 cot 1PLETE ARKANSAS 2 COMPLETE BEAVER VALI,EY 1 COMPLETE BIO ROCK POINT COMPLETE CALVERT CLIFFS 1 COMPLETE CALVERT CLIFFS 2 -COMPLCTE CRYSTAL RIVER 3 COMPLETE D.C. COOK 1 COMPLETE D.C. COOK ? COMPLETE DUANE ARNOLD COMPLETE FORT CALHOUtJ COMPLETE H B ROBINDOrJ 2 COMPLETE HATCH 1 COMPLETE HATCH 2 COMPLETE INDIAN POINT 3 COMPLETE LACROSEE COMPLETE MAINE YANKEE rOMPLETE MONTICELLO COMPLETE NINE MILE PT 1 COMPLETE NORTH ANNA 1 COMPLETE OCONEE 1 COMPLETE OCONEE 2 COMPLETE OCONEE 5 COMPLETE n-
,pp y. c - - -- --
f- .e <
[ .Page No. 2 h .,03/04/06
{
~
AFFENDIX R STATUS-FOR PLANTS LICENSED PRIOR TO JAN. 1, 1979
' COMPLETION STATUS OF ALTERNATE SHUTDOWN SYSTEMS T
FACILITY DATE ALT. IF NOT NAME #- SHUTDOWN COMPLETE, SYSTEM S/D FOOTNOTE.
cot 1PLETE d
PALILADES' COMPLETE' PEACli DOTTOti 3 - COMPLETE
- PRAIRIE ISLAND 1 COMPLETE PRAIR!E.ISLAf1D 2 COMPLETE PANCHO SECO COMPLETE GALEM 1 COMFLETE ST LUCIE 1 COMPLETE
. VERMONT YANNEE COMPLETE ,
YANITEE ROUE- COMPLETE ZION 1 COMPLETE ZIOtt 2 COMPLETE GINNA 04/30/06 *1 SAN ONOFRE'1 06/01/06 *1 FARLEY 1 '10/01/86 *1 OYSTER CREEK 10/31/86 *1 FITZPATRICK 04/30/07 *1
'KEWAUNEE 06/30/07 *1 OUAD CITIES 1 04/01/86 *2 OUAD CITIES 2 04/30/06 *2 TURKEY POINT 3 12/31/06 *2 TURKEY POINT 4 12/31/86 *2 PEACH BOTTOM 2 02/01/87 42 DRESDEN 2 06/30/97 $2 DRESDEN 3 06/30/87 *2 k
y . ., . . --- .-
1
. .? , h s 'D '- .y,
, Page No. 3-p
' 03(04/86
' APPENDIX R-STATUS FOR PLANTS LICENSED PRIOR TO JAN.
1, 1979 7 COMPLETION STATUS OF ALTERNATE SHUTDOWN SYSTEMS
,- : FACILITY- DATE ALT. IF NOT- i NAME.# SHUTDOWN COMPLETE,
~
SYSTEM S/D FOOTNOTE.
k COMPLETE
' BROWNS FERRY 2 ~12/20/88 *2 #
INDIAN POINT'2 03/31/06 *6
'HADDAM NECK '04/30/06 *6 TMI 1 06/30/96 *6
]h
- PILGRIM .11/31/86 *6 POINT BEACH 1 12/31/06 46
- FOINT DEACH 2 12/31/86 *6
' COOPER STATION 03/31/07' *6 .
V;. MILLSTONE 1 12/31/07 i6
~
MILLSTONE 2 12/31/87 *6' BRUNSWICK 1- 12/31/89' $6 BRUNSWICK.2 06/30/90 *6 NORTH ANNA 2 06/30/86 *7 SURRY 1 07/01/86 *7 SURRY 2 12/31/86 *7 FOR'T ST VRAIN 08/31/07 *7
. TROJAN- 12/31/87 $7 DAVIS-BESSE 12/31/89 *7 DROWNS FERRY 3 12/20/07 *9 EROWNS' FERRY 1 12/20/89 49
~
..wa-
+ . . . .,-
Enclosure 5
(
Page No. 1 i 03/04/06
[. APPENDIX R GTATUS FOR PLANTS LICENGED PRIOR TO JAN. 1. 1979 j- COMPLETION STATUS OF FIRE PROTECTION MODIFICATIONS
(
- FACILITY DATE FIRE IF NOT NAME # PROTECTION COMPLETE, MODIFICATIOt1 FOOTfJOTE S/B cot 1PLETE ARKANSAS 1 COMPLETE ARKANSAS 2 COMPLCTE BEAVER VALLEY 1 COMPLETE z
BIG ROCK POINT COMPLETE CALVERT CLIFFS 1 COMPLETE CALVERT CLIFFS 2 CONFLETE D.C. COOK 1 COMPLETE D. C. COOK 2 LOMPLETE DUANE ARNOt.D COMPLETE FARLEY 1 COMPLETE FORT CALHOUt1 COMPLETE H B ROBINSON 2 COMPLETC INDIAN POINT 2 COMPLETE INDIf4i-J POINT 3 CDMPLETE LACROSSE COMPLETE MAINE YANKEE COMPLETC MOtJTICELLO COMPLETE NINE MILE PT 1 COMPLETE tJORTH ANNA 1 COMPLETE OCONEE 1 COMP 1.ETE OCONEE 2 COMPLETE OCOrlEE 3 COMPLETE PALISADES COMPLETE L
gy -
x-f PAge No. 2_ -
03/04/86'
> APPENDIX'R STATUS FOR PLANTS LICENSED PRIOR TO-JAN..1, 1979 r
COMPLETION STATUS'OF FIRE PROTECTION MODIFICATIONS FACILITY DATE' FIRE 'IF NOT:
NAME # PROTECTION COMPLETE,;
- t10DIFICATION FOOTNOTE-
.S/B COMPLETE-PEACH BOTTOM 2' CCMPLETE -s
~FEACH BOTTOM1 3' COMPLETE PRAIRIE ISLAND 1 COMPLETE.
FRAIRIC ISLAND 2 'EOMPLETE RANCHO SECO COMPLETE' SrLCM 1 COMPLETE .
STLLUCIE 1 COMPLETE VERf10NT. YANKEE COMPLETE ,
' YANKEE ROWE COMPLETE CRYSTAL? RIVER 3' 03/31/86 *1 GINNA 04/30/86 *1 SAN ONOFRE 1 06/01/86 *1 OYSTER CREEK 10/31/86 *1 HATCH 1 11/31/86 *1 HATCH 2 11/31/86 *1 KEWAUNEE 06/30/e7 *1 OUAD CITIES 1 06/30/86 *2
-TURKEY POINT 3 12/31/86 *2 TURKEY POINT 4 12/31/86 *2 DRESDEN 2 06/30/87 *2 DRESDEN 3 06/30/87 *2 OUAD CITIES 2 06/30/87 *2 BROWNS FERRY 2 12/20/88 *2 HADDAM NECK ~ 04/30/86 *6
7 e:
k,
)
h: .
s.E Pago No. -
3 x,'- '03/04/86 f APPENDIX R STATUS FOR-PLANTS LICENSED-PRIOR TO JAN. 1, 1979 l ,
COMPLETION STATUS OF, FIRE PROTECTION MODIFICATIONS'
' FACILITY DATE FIRE IF NOT NAME'M- - PROTECTION. COMPLETE, MODIFICATION FOOTNOTE
-S/B COMPLETE
> TiMI 1 06/30/86 46 PILGRIM 11/31/86 *6
. . POINT.EEACH-1 12/31/86 *6 POINT.DEACH 2 12/31/86 *6 .
MILLSTONE 1 12/31/87 *6
-MILLSTONE 2 12/31/87 $6 DRUNSWICK 1- 12/31/G9 *6
_DRUNSWICK 2 06/30/90 *6 ,
NORTH ANNA 2 06/30/86 *7 SURRY 1 07/31/06 47
. ZION 1 10/30/06 $7 A
ZION 2 10/30/06 47 COOPER STATION 11/31/96 *7' SURRY 2 12/31/86 *7 TROJAN 12/31/86 *7 FORT ST.VRAIN ' 08/31/87 . *7 DAVIS-BESSE 12/31/89 *7 FITZPATRICK 10/31/86 *8 BROWNS FERRY 3 12/20/87 *9 BROWNS FERRY 1 12/20/89 *9
. .o - .. . ..
Encl:sure 6 s
COMPLETION SCHEDULE FOR ALTERNATE SHUTDOWN SYSTEMS (FOR PLANTS LICENSED PRIOR TO JANUARY 1, 1979.)
7o 66 Ol 63 b 62 .
G, @$ .:.
s
- X:-
Y'M>x COMPLETE 6x 80 "
h"$
p;3h3$x 0 .E5 p g$s.i v
d ,s .j:j NOT COMPLETE L"" "$ :s'$
51 .e. g;;g g;j-g a-- .. se; s;g cn :
$i0 D:V
- e:: xu xy :
Z '
h3 9 3
c ..
80 [%s
- .:4 $
h o 3. Ih'!D i
- h
, ; 3" 333g cr - -
i[%. q I E m- -
- s'< :- Egg:: ,. x< -
b z !Eq Pb ?bN {
X
. -- egg' sis'M >X'-
16 > "
. >x m+
f' .6-S;::::$ '-%
$+ ~23 4X
".N$ gg l!,.
f(.$.:
1o- - - -
x: .
4 ,
3 +: -
s 46 1 : s: si4@@
6 h: %58 1
($@ o 1986 1987 1988 1989 1990 YEARS
__ . 1 ..&: -
Enclosure 7 .
COMPLETION SCHEDULE FOR APPENDIX R FIRE PROTECTION MODIFICATIONS (FOR PLANTS LICENSED PRIOR TO JANUARY 1, 1979.)
70 6G 67 M $$2 62 ji:~gj : :5.oSpy1 COMPLETE d'$$2.
s
- "4., >' 'h i;+f,% A SO- - far. - %, rv..
+m 83 ? 6.6'S
..v NOT COMPLETE
!gy 54 S:g %<4 39:
7 3 i$'R i' sis s
- - && 3<632
-:O X-: -
r.-
50- -
- -qf
.:., - +;f ree,,&,- -
" <.f.
< 0:5 3'X'" :p;g y-;j$
cn s -
ex p .sy
. r<4.-
g SE : 'i'h )" 35 G 40 -
>58 y, 4, * :p2 )9.3 .y [.A -
/ 5
(
.- a u 3 4. - >~+- ' $$2 $333 - :
O .- ;f& $$$ $,,
e- R:2 x-:-: : p:
E 30- -
N - - 'E- e :0 X
$s:+-;
4.0
>X-:
p;XX+-: -
pp>:
2 As, 4 $>X N o s -
vw <m: +d.c z , .-".: 3:
~
ve:-
33;. $.y$;.
v- '$)c%~ ~ .y: : v-
- v.-
A- $d+s
- r. ,$ w v--,
20-- - - -
de .v ,y
.; 8%,g < 8,$,$ 8,E8., 0 n4.,4 .-
4 R.: .v.
.- - ..v y%;:
hij$ e q$:
35 ($g: -
2664 -
Au $$$: evy;::
3 1o- - - e a+ $m:-
3' $sg :-%O 89;-
" b.-"
5 X""4
- b"s X<6' kJ;
- $.,
" 4
$"h'::
- h 9X y.> s
.s. -
-,&t ... y 3 93,-
u s.
> >x_: Ev 0 0
1986 1987 1988 1989 1990 YEARS
r _ ,
,a c. - ,.
Commissioner Asselstine To the best of the staff's knowledge, the use of the new interpretat ns has not affected compliance schedules. However, compliance schedul s for plant modifications have changed slightly since the EDO memorandu to the Commission dated December 26, 1985. The fire protection modific ion schedule has improved by three additional plants being complet in 1986 rather than 1987. Three plants have pushed back their comole on schedule for alternative shutdown systems from 1986 to 1987. Enclos es 1 through 7 contain graphs and tables showing updated completion sched es for all plants licensed prior-to January 1, 1979 as of March 1, 1986.
Finally, as indicated above the staff is holding all s concerning evaluations of the new interpretations contained in CY 85-306 until Commission approval of SECY 85-306. To date with e exception of Maine Yankee all exemotions issued concerning issues co red in GL 83-33 have been based on GL 83-33 and not the new interpretation contained in SECY 85-306.
In the case of Maine Yankee, should the Connis on decide that the new interpretations are not to be used but rather he guidance of GL 83-33 the staff will reprocess the affected issues as xemptions. For all plants licensed after January 1, 1979 fire protec on SERs are based on the SRP and all deviaticns from the SRP are reviewed d .iustified in the SER.
Vi tor Stello, Jr.
ting Executive Director for Operations
Enclosures:
! 1. Footnotes
- 2. Fire Protection Status fo Plants Licensed Prior to January 1, 1979
- 3. Plants with all Appendix Moc'fications Complete
- 4. Completion Status of A1.e' ate Shutdown Systems
- 5. Completion Status of re Protection Modifications
- 6. Bar Chart of Complet on Status for Alternate Shutdown Systems
OGC RC PDR w/cy of incoming SECY (3)
SECY local PDR w/cy of incomino VStello EDO #001453 PPAS (E00#001453)
EDO Reading w/cy of incoming H. Denton/D. Eisenhut R. Rernero/L. L. .1 PD#1 Reading (w/cy of incoming) J. Stang w/cy of incomino OELD CJamerson PD#1 Green Ticket File FMiraglia q
TNovak
[
DBL:PD# !) 1 0 p DBL:DIR M .
CJame r o yJ .jg Zwolinski fybbsthn RRernero
)
3/q /86
/86 3 / 4 /86 g/ *//86 3/V/86 i l
NRR:DD NR :DIR EDO:A/DIR DElsenhut HDenton VStello
/ /86 / /86 / /86
~
Enclosure 1 FOOTNOTE The footnotes below will aid you in rev ewing the followina charts and graphs:
- 1 50.48 Schedular Extensions Exem tion Granted
- 2 50.48 Schedular, Extension, E emption Requested and Under Review by NRR N
- 6 Plants Following th 0.4 Schedule for Completion of F.P. Mods and Alt. SD SYS
- 7 Plants Operating in No comp nee of the 50.48 Schedule with approved Compensatory Measures
- 8-PlaM0pefaiingj -Non%f ance, 'th'e O chedule M ##,[*~'!5 "i '
y Approved Compensa ory Measures / L'.s <<-,",'-f a d yoff(
- 9 Plants in Outa e Will Not Restart Until Modifications Complete yg
_ _ _ _ _ _ - _ - _ - _ _ - _ - - _ _ ~
1 ..
Encl sura 2 APPENDIX R STATUS OF FIRE -PROTECTION MODIFICATIONS FOR PLANTS LICENSED PRIOR TO JANUARY 1, 1979.
- FIRE PROTECTION STATUS
\ SCHEDULAR EXEMPTION GRANTED 35-- '
N SCHEDULAR EXEMPTION UNDER REVIED.V 30- - I- COMPLYING WITH S0.48 SCHEDULE N
OPERATING UNDER NON-COMPLIANCE A.C.M.*
25- -
COM ETE h- 4 c, u fric s & c g qt<3a-gN Q p W p ;g f ~ o e'4 fr I 20
// /
, , . . 7 DE y 'n,f; IN OUTAGE: RESTART AFTER MODS. COMPLETE 10- -
10- -
m n
ll.
C- ~
%w l&j ,/
f) ':; $N O
[31 / -
-7 h
MARCH 1986
- APPROVED COMPENSATORY MEASURES
. . . m- - -
, 7.
g, .
b; k'g UNITEJ STATES
! g.- NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
{ t WASHINGTON, D. C. 20586
% * ..*/
EDO PRINCIPAL CORRESPONDENCE CONTROL
/'
FROM: DUE: 03/07/06 EDO CONTROL: 0c1453 DOC DT 02/20/86 t
COMMISSIONER ASSELSTINE FINAL, REPLY: i TO:
STELLO
/ FOR SIONATURE OF ** PRIORITY ** SECY NO:
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR DESC: ROUTINO:
STAFF RECOMMENDATIONS REOARDING THE IMPLEMENTATION STELLO OF APPEMDIX R TO~10 CFR 50 (SECY-85-306) ROE RFHM LATE: 02/24/86 SNIFZEK A~ SIGNED TO: NnR CONTACT DI:NTAN r MINOGUE
/ [,f TAYLOR OCUNNINGHAM CPECIAL INSYRUCTIONS OR REMARKS: j f y'
) I ps NRR RECEIVED: 2/24/86, v ACTION:
J f-NRR ROUTING: . DENTON/EISENHUT PPAS HOSSBURG V
b L '
.