ML20141E185
| ML20141E185 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Vogtle  |
| Issue date: | 12/05/1985 |
| From: | Advisory Committee on Reactor Safeguards |
| To: | Advisory Committee on Reactor Safeguards |
| References | |
| ACRS-2338, NUDOCS 8601070625 | |
| Download: ML20141E185 (25) | |
Text
I .
i .I o G 6 d5' 4 2 8 0 CERTIFIED COPY DATE ISSUED:- Dec. 5,1985
~~O~ ?
1 ()f)$
psifs l
6[_u u JJ $7 MINUTES OF THE JULY 18-19, 1985 l MEETING OF THE ACRS SUBCOMMITTEE ON THE V0GTLE ELECTRIC GENERATING PLANT, UNITS 1 AND 2 l
The ACRS Subcommittee on the Vogtle Electric Generating Plant, Units I and2(PlantVogtle)metonJuly 18-19, 1985 at the Augusta Hilton Hotel in Augusta, GA. The purpose of this meeting was to review the request of the Georgia Power Company (GP) for Ifcenses to operate Plant Vogtle, Units 1 and 2. Notice of this meeting was published in the Federal Register on Tuesday, July 2, 1985 (Attachment A). A list of persons attendingthemeetingisattached(AttachmentB). A copy of the sched-ule of discussions is also attached (Attachment C). Material distribut-ed to the Subcommittee during this meeting is listed on Attachment D.
Copies of these documents are on file in the ACRS office. The entire meeting was open to public attendance. One written statement was l
received from a member of the public (Attachment E) and two oral state-l ments were heard.
About five members of the public were present during portions of this meeting.
i
_ Attendees ACRS NRC Staff J. C. Ebersole, Subcom. Chainndn M. A. Miller, NRR -
G. A. Reed '
R. W. Hernan, NRR ~
D. A. Ward J. C. McKinley, ACRS Staff M. V. Sinkule. Reg. 11 W. F. Sanders SRI-Vogtle l
T. Quay, NRR f ,, , 1
~
i IRIcrna calci!:AL d.. u n d 6 $23={20 p estaos cuune v 25##
l rtrw y ,
m
Minutes /Vsgtle Generating Plant
,' July 18-19, 1985 Meeting 2
' K. Campe, NRR Georgia Power / Southern Company Services J. Rogge, Reg. II J. A. Bailey, SCS K. E. Brockman, Reg. II E. G. Adensam, NRR R. A. Thomas, SCS W. Ramsey, SCS D. O. Foster, GP Public G. Bockhold, GP Mrs. R. H. Davis III T. N. Epps, SCS T. Johnson P. D. Rice, GP J. E. Gordon J. Glick J. T. Beckham Jr. GP W. F. Lawless P. D. Rushton, GP W. K. Kitchens, GP E. Kozinsky, GP L. B. Glenn, GP
- 0. Batum, SCS C. Benton, Westinghouse T. Luke, Bechtel Power Corp.
R. L. George, SCS D. L. Houghton, Bechtel P.C.
J. J. Holmes, Bechtel P.C.
G. E. Lang, Westinghouse M. Kamenic, Westinghouse M. Troy, Westinghouse W. D. Tauche, Westinghouse Opening Statement Mr. Ebersole, Subcommittee Chairman, opened the meeting at 1:15 p.m. on Thursday, July 18, 1985 with a statement regarding the conduct of the meeting, introducing the Subcomittee members present, and confiming the proposed schedule and topics to be addressed.
- 1. NRC Safety Evaluation The NRC Project Manager on the Vogtle Electric Generating Plant, Ms.
Melanie Miller, sumarized the status of the review. Overall, the NRC Staff concluded that Georgia Power and its supporting organizations had done a responsible job in meettpg NRC requirements. At this time there -
are no known issues that would prevent the issuance of an operating license. TheNRCSafetyEvaluationReport(SER)relatingtotheopera-tion of Plant Vogtle was issued in June 1985. It contained 14 open 6 $
' Minut':s/Vogtle Generating Plant July 18-19, 1985 Meeting 3 items, about 50 confirmatory issues, and 11 license conditions. Subse-quent to the issuance of the SER, two of the open ite .s have been resolved, in addition, about 5 of the confirmatory issues have also been resolved. The NRC Staff is confident that the remaining open issues can be resolved prior to the issuance of an operating license. The issues discussed were:
o Containment sump capability - the applicant needs to prove that unacceptable flow blockage will not occur.
o Toxic gns protection for control room operators - the appif-cant needs to prove that the control room operators are protected from ammonia, hydrozine, and chlorine, o
Modifications to the reactor trip breaker circuitry - the applicant has curnitted to the modificatien, plant specific details need to be agreed upon, o
Cathodic protection for buried fuel oil tanks and associated piping - the applicant must either show that .;oll conditions do not lead to cathodic corrosion or provide protection o
Licensee qualification for operation - this is normally open at this stage of the review, no significant difficulties are anticipated in resolving this issue.
o Retesting of simulator response - the concern is that the simulator does not faithfully represent the true reactor response to transient,s. The applicant has taken action to -
resolve this issue and the staff expects the resolution to be acceptable.
Minutes /Vogtle Generating Plant
, July 18-19, 1985 Meeting 4 Illustrative of the issues that were more difficult to resolve, Ms.
Miller described the additional information the NRC Staff required the applicant to provide to support claims regarding the load bearing capabilities of the marl stratum under the plant site and of the com-pacted fill material placed over the marl. Unlike Midland, the utility appears to have monitored the backfill operation and assured adequate i
compaction, hence unacceptable differential settlement is not anticipat-ed. Settlement to date has been within expected values.
- 2. NRC Inspection Program Mr. Marvin Sinkule. NRC's Region II, Projects Section Chief, identified his principal duties as supervising the resident inspectors and manage-ment of the inspection program for the Vogtle plant. He reported that more than 12,500 staff hours had been expended by the NRC inspecting the Vogtle plant.
In addition to routine inspections; there are special inspections to cover specific areas of interest such as construction quality, mechanical and welding conformance, electrical system confor-mance, etc. The Vogtle project has also been the subject of several systematic assessment of licensee performance (SALP) appraisals.
Overall the licensee management has been responsive to NRC findings, licensee management has implemented adequate programs to ensure the 1 quality of the plant. An operating ifcense recomendation is contingent upon satisfactory completion of the inspection program.
The NRC Staff described and discussed how it handles allegations re-ceived from workers of other sources regarding construction at the Vogtle site. All allegations received are followed to some fonn of i
Minutes /Vogtle Generating Plant July 18-19, 1985 Meeting 5 resolution. The utility has its own independent concern follow-up
. . system.
Mr. Sinkule noted that the NRC was expending something like ten man-years of effort to review and follow the utility's readfaess review program.
- 3. _ Readiness Review Program Mr. W. Ramsey (Southern Company Services) described the situation leading up to the development of the Readiness Review Program. (see NUREG 1055) Other NTOL plants had made last minute discoveries of gaps in their quality assurance efforts and documentation. To preclude delays or questions developing in the-1 ate stages of construction and licensing, the utility decided to perfom an independent review of its design and construction. The objectives of the program were to provide additional assurance to Georgia Power management that the plant design was adequate and that the quality of the plant was adequate. The program required the participation of the NRC Staff to review and accept the work that was done.
The utility's self assessment includes a verification that FSAR commit-ments have been met, construction complies with design, and the design is adequate. Bechtel was the AE for the plant and Georgia Power has engaged Stone and Webster to pd,rfom an independent design verification. ;
The Readiness Review Program represents a significant comitment of resources by both the utility and the NRC Staff. Both groups were
_ .. 1
- . = .
Minutes /Vogtle Gen: rating Plant July 18-19, 1985 Me: ting 6 requested by the Subcommittee to discuss the program at the 304th ACRS meeting (August 8-10,1985).
- 4. Principal Design Features Mr. George Bockhold, Georgia Power, described the principal features of Plant Vogtle. It is a 3425 MWt four loop Westinghouse pressurized water reactor which utilizes the Model F Westinghouse steam generators. The turbine-generator is an 1800 rpm machine that produces 1,156 MWe, Each nuclear steam supply system is provided with four accumulators, two centrifugal charging pumps, two safety injection pumps, two residual heat removal pumps, and two nuclear service cooling water towers. Each tower contains about a 30 day supply of cooling water for a reactor in the shutdown mode. 'There are two electric motor driven and one turbine driven auxiliary feedwater pumps. The natural draft cooling towers, used for condenser cooling and non-vital cooling, are 540 ft. high. The
~
plant utilizes large dry containments for the nuclear systems.
Unit 1 is approximately 82% complete while Unit 2 is about 47% complete.
At the time of this meeting, fuel loading for Unit I was September 1986 with comercial operation planned for March 1987.
Mr. Epps, Georgia Power, described the preservice and inservice test program for pumps and valves and the inspection of the reactor coolant system. The plant utilizes centrifugally cast stainless steel pipe and statically cast stainless steel fittings. He described the ultrasonic inspectiontechniquebeingused(pitch-catchtransducers).
- Minut:s/Vogt7o Gen: rating Plant '
.' July 18-19, 1985 Mesting 7
- 5. Quality Assurance V.
Mr. Paul Rice, Georgia Power, described the quality assurance program.
One of the key points of the program was to prevent instances of unac-ceptable quality, the balance were to confirm that the desired quality was obtained or that remedial action was taken. The organization set up to accomplish these objectives was described in detail. The quality assurance program includes inspections and audits at vendor facilities.
- 6. Management, Organization, and Training Mr. Don Foster, Vice President and General Manager for the Vogtle project for Georgia Power, described the corporate organization and functional relationships. Mr. Bockhold described the operating orga-nization and Mr. Rushton described the training program for the operat-ing staff. The key points to successful training are suitable facil-ities, competent staff, and qualified students. The training facility 4
has about 40,000 square feet of space which is larger than many high schools. It has well equipped classrooms and laboratories. It also houses the plant simulator. All users of the simulator are given an opportunity to offer human factors improvement suggestions. To obtain qualified personnel Georgia Power uses a preemployment screening process which includes aptitude testing. Background investigations and drug screening are also utilized.
i The training facility is used (o train both licensed and nonlicensed I operators, senior reactor operators, shift technical advisors, and fire brigade members, and eventually for general employee training. In order to improve the experience of the plant personnel, the operators participate
Minutts/Vogtle Generating Plant July 18-19, 1985 M:eting 8 e
in the preoperat[ional equipment and systems test program. Operator candidates are assigned to the control room for a minimum of six weeks.
The test program is being controlled from the control room.
Mr. Rushton, Georgia Power, expressed the corporate belief that training is the foundation of quality operations, he cited the fact that in 1984, about 125 man years of training were provided. That is about 125 people per workday engaged in training, not counting instructors. One objec-tive is to achieve INPO accreditation of the training program by fuel loading although the corporate conunitment to achieve accreditation two years after fuel loading.
- 7. _ Emergency Operating Procedures Mr. Kitchens, Georgia Power, presented an overview of the emergency operating procedures, how they were prepared, how they were validated, and how the operators are trained in their use. The emergency operating procedurcs are based on the Westinghouse Owners Group recommended emergency response guidelines, revision 1. The Safety Parameter Display System is an integral part of the operation. The plant simulator is used extensively for training in and validation of the procedures. The simulator itself is continually evaluated and updated as necessary to truly reflect reactor performance.
- 8. Control Room
- Mr. Bockhold, Georgia Power, described the control room design review, the safety parameter display system, the remote shutdown capability, and the control room habitability studies. Georgia Power built a mockup of
__ w .
._ -- . . . . ~. - .-
Minutes /Vogtle Generating Plant July 18-19, 1985 Meeting 9 the control room where operators from the' Hatch' units and operators with PWR operating experience experimented with relocating various controls until a configuration was decided upon. Following the TMI-2 accident a i detailed control room design review was undertaken. Two hundred for-ty-two (242) potencial improvements has been identified. Fifty-three have been acted on and 189 remain open. Mr. Bockhold gave exa@9 of various classes of improvements that are being evaluated.
He also described the two separate trains of heating, ventilating and air conditioning equipment that serve the control room. The intakes for the two trains are separated by about 150 ft. Chlorine, smoke, and radiation detectors are provided in each train and initiate action to minimize the consequences.
- 9. Quality Concerns Program Mr. L. Glenn, Georgia Power, described the program that Georgia Power had implemented to identify, investigate, and resolve any quality concerns brought forward by employees or members of the public. The system provides for confidentiality and feedback. Thus far, there have been 404 quality related concerns expressed as well as about 270 com-ments relating to administrative matters such as traffic and parking problems. Of the 404 quality related concerns, 279 have received a full review. The program is well publicized.
- 10. Nuclear Service Water Cooling Towers Mr. O. Batum, Southern Company Services, described the nuclear service cooling water towers which serve as the ultimate heat sink. .Two towers .
-- ; =- _ .-
Minutes /Vogtle G:nerating Plant July 18-19, 1985 Meeting 10 e
are provided for each unit, each tower is capable of dissipating 100% of the shutdown cooling load. Each tower is provided with four forced air fans only three of which are required for full tower capacity. Each tower has three 50". capacity circulating ' water pumps. Each tower holds 3.6 million gallons of cooling water with the capability of transferring
-water between the two towers assigned .to a particular unit. The towers are designed to withstand all of the design basis natural phenomena (earthquakes, tornadoes,etc.). In part to assure operability, at least one tower will be operating during normal nuclear unit operations and will be dissipating heat from all of the safety related equipment.
- 11. _ Steam Generators Mr. Batum noted that the plant was originally designed using Westinghouse model D steam generators, these were later changed to model F which include ~ separate nozzles for the auxiliary feedwater system.
- 12. Other Topics A number of other topics were discussed briefly, none of them appeared to present safety problems.
Vogtle will utilize incineration to reduce the volume of its radwaste and cement to solidify it.
Fire protection features include separate ventilation systems for each train of protection equipment and fire protective coatings on structural steel that might be exposed to a fire. Part of the analysis included the spilling ~and ignition of five gallons of acetone any place in the '
, Minutes /Vogtle G:nerating Plant July 18-19, 1985 M: sting 11 plant. In the cable spreading room the utility has provided smoke detectors, pre-action sprinklers, hose stations, and portable extin-guishers.
The utility demonstrated that the plant was adequately protected from external flooding from both surface and ground water. Internal flooding is being evaluated as part of the readine.>s review program.
The feedwater system and its control system are designed to minimize the difficulty that others have encountered in maintaining steam generator water level at low power levels. Reactor trips from full power will require initiation of auxiliary feedwater flow.
Each unit has four safety grade batteries to . supply vital DC power.
Each battery is provided with redundant chargers, each of which is capable of supplying all DC loads while charging the battery. The battery charges are provided with an overvoltage trip that is indepan-dent of the voltage regulation function.
Actuation of the power operated relief valves (PORV) on the pressurizer can result from signals from the normal reactor coolant system pressure control, the low temperature over pressure mitigation system, and manual action by the control room operator. The PORV is backed up by a motor operated block valve. Mr. Reed expressed his concern for the potential effects of hydrogen and boron on the reliability of operation of the pilot o'perated PORVs, he asked the utility to discuss this at the August meeting of the ACRS. .
Minutes /Vogtle Generating Plant
, July 18-19, 1985 Meeting 12 e With a loss of all AC electrical po*er, all cooling to the reactor coolant pump seals .is lost. Under these conditions a "best estimate" of seal leakage is about 21 gpm with a large uncertainty. The " worst case" estimate could be as high as 480 gpm. Using the "best estimate" value of 21 gpm it would be 16 hours1.851852e-4 days <br />0.00444 hours <br />2.645503e-5 weeks <br />6.088e-6 months <br /> before core uncovery would be likely. If AC power was restored in less than 16 hours1.851852e-4 days <br />0.00444 hours <br />2.645503e-5 weeks <br />6.088e-6 months <br /> no core uncovery will occur.
Test results on a 7" seal show leak rates well below the "best estimate" values.
The utility had Dr. Harry Seed evaluate the compacted backfill at the Vogtle site for its liquification potential. Dr. Seed concluded that liquification was unlikely up to magnitude 71 earthquakes, well above the design basis.
- 13. Statements from Members of the Public The Subcommittee heard oral statements from two members of the public.
One from Mr. Tim Johnson that challenged the utility's Readiness Review Program and pointed out that there is a growing list of allegations. He was unable to be very specific at the Subcommittee meeting and promised to provide a written statement, no such statement has been received. He also complained that the intervenors had not been given adequate notice of the Subcomittee meeting. The second speaker from the public was Mr.
Lawless who expressed concerns regarding radioactive contamination from the DOE Savannah River Plant an,d also concerns regarding the assurance _
of the integrity of the marl layer, under the Class I Vogtle structures, as a barrier between plant releases and the Tuscaloosa aquifer and for the modeling of ground water flow rate and direction. A copy of his
- '
- Minutes /Vogtle Generating Plant July 18-19, 1985 Meeting 13 t statement is att' ached. No other written statements have been received regarding Plant Vogtle. '
NOTE:
A complete transcript of the meeting is on file at the NRC Public Document Room at 1717 H St., NW., Washington, D. C. or can be obtained at cost from ACE Federal Reporter, Inc.
N. Capitol St., Washington, D. C. 20001, Telephone (202} 444 347-3700.
1 4
~
, /,N V R( E L M A _ ,
' ~ 5-
{
Federal Registir / Vcl. 50. No.127 / Tuesday. July 2. Sees / Notions .
. . m7 a
i NATIONAL AERONAtmCS AND . .
purposee as well cs launching of spece grill hold a ineeting on Jihts and St.
SPACE ADMINISTRATION vehicles. ~
i 1985, at the Augusta Hilton Hotel. 840 INotice 85-431 Lw.vesel. Board Street. Augusta.CA. " ^ i '
[ Director.Icgistia Manqrementand Agency Report Forms Under OMB "6 '8" De entire nog Oll!heh'h Pu h nendance. . %
g,g,,
[nt Dx as.15773 Fded 7-1-ek 44s am) enAma coca rs*4ws De agenda for the ambloof saasting .
actuer: National Aeronautics and -
shall be as follows: -
- I l Space Admmistration. 7%ursday,fulyJA asus-Jmpas. J' , !
ACTioM: Notice of agency report forms F NONMM ""#i/ #h' '*##f"#/## #Ib"*d*****
oy fuly 2A M s.h M under OMB revfew. AMS AND THE HUMANITIES .
the conclusion of A& ^
p:isemany: Under the provisions of the inter Arts Advisory Pened; Meeting The Subcomm!ttee will begin review Paperwork Reduction Act (44 U.S C. of Gergia Pown Company's .
Chapter 35). agencies are required to Pursuant to section 20(a)(2) of the.
Federal Advisory Committee (Public application for an operating flamana for somit proposed information collection Law 92-483), as amended, notice la Vogtle Units 1 and 2.
requsts to GMB for review and hereby given that a meeting of the Inter. Oral stateents may be pmeented by appmval, and to publish a notice in the Arts Advisory Panel (Dance / Inter. Arts / members of the public with the Federal Register notifying the public that Touring. Presenting Initiative) to the concumnce of the Subcosamiuse the agency has made the submission.
Cepies of the proposed forms. the National CouncD on the Arts will be Chaiman: wrinen statements will be held on July 19,1985 from 900 a.m.- accepted and made available to the reque:ts for clearance (S F. 83's). 6:00 p.m. In room M-07 of the Nancy supporting statements. Instructions.
Commluu. Recwenge wiD be pemined Hanks Center.1100 Pennsylvania only during those portions of the t+snsmittalletters, and other documents Avenue.NW Washington.DC2050s.
submitted to OMB for review, may be mting when a transmipt is being kapt, A portion of this meeting will be open and questions may be asked only by cbtained from the Agency Clearance to the public on July 19. from 3.30-600 mmbers of the Subcommittee. ita Officer. Comments on the items listed p.m. to discuss policy and guidelines.
shoald be submitted to the Agency conauf tanta, and Staff. Pereens desiring ne remaining sessions of this to make oral statementa should motify Clearance Officer and the OMB meeting on July 19. from 900 a.m.-3.30 Reviewer. the ACRS staff member named below as p.m. are for the purpose of Panel review. far in advance as is practicable so that satt: Comments must be reccited in &scussin, evaluation and appropriate arrangements can be made, writing July by 12,1985. If >ou anticipate recommendation on applications for During the initial portion of the cmmenti:'g on a form btrt find that time financist assistance under the National to p epa *e will prevent you from meeting. the Subcommittee, along with Foundation on the Arts and the any ofits consultants who may be submitting comments promptly, you dfumanities Act of1965, as amended.
including discussion ofinformation pment.may exchange pretiminary should advise the OMB Reviewer and views regarding matters to be the Agency Clearance Officer of your given in cordidence to the agency by
! intent as early as possible. grant applicants. In accordance with the considered during the hatanam'of the E meeting.
ADorm;CarlSteinmetz NASA determination of the Chairman Ayg Clearance Officer. Code NIM. ublished in the Federal Register of ne Subcommittee will then hear' NASA Hes.dquarters, Washington. DC february 13,1980, these sessions will be PmenMW and W h 20546; Mike Weinstein. Office of closed to th bli "E"*" * "I'*
[f Inforraation and Regulatory Affairs. subsections (c) 4) htt fe ) of section Power Company, NRC Staff, their OMB. Room 3235, New Executive Office 552b of Title 5. Urif ted States Code. Pens nga' ra"ng &ia mdew.
I" I
' Building. Washington, DC 20403. Further information with reference to this meeting can be obtained from Mr. Further information regarding topics pon ruwTwsn euromuarioes contact: John H. Clark. Advisory Committee J
Carl Steinmetz, NASA Agency Me &scussed, whethe the meeting Management Officer. National has been cancelled or rescheduled, the
' i CI:arance Officer. (2020 454-2941. Endowment for the Arts. Washington. Chaiman a ruling on mqmts for the
) R* Ports D.C. 20506, or call (202) 682-5433. Opportunity to present oral statements
!* g,g, and the time allotted therefoe can be
Title:
Radioactive Material Transfer Durctor. councilandpbne/ Operations. obtained by a prepaid telephone call to l Recelpt.
L Type of request: Extension. NationalEndowmentfortheAns. e cogni1 ant ACRS sta!Iamber, Mr. .
June 2r. leas. }ohn Schiffgena Delephone 202/s34-Frequency of Report: On occasion.
p} Type of Respondent Business or other [FR Doc. 85-15817 Ed 7-1-e6; 8-45 am]
na a i:r. profit, federal agencies or an m onee wr.eH8 end is are urged tocontact the above named employees, non. profit institutions, individual one or trwo days before the small businesses or organizations.
NUCLEAR REQU4 TORY scheduled meeting to be advised of any -
Annual Responses:500.
Annual Burden Hours:200.
COMMISSION Ws in schedulm wikW have occurred.
Abstract.Need/Uses: De NASA ]SC 1825 form is used to furnish the Sakguwds, SubcommNtee on Vogue mvm necessary records on the possession, Electric Genersung Plant UnNs 1wid %
location, and use of radioactive material h%
- AssistantLacutiveDuecdarAchepsw A'"l'"-
91 temporary job sites throughout the %e ACRS Subcommittee on Vogtle S. for research and development IFR Doc, as-1ams Filed 7-1-es; ads am]
Electric Generating Plant Unita 1 and 2 . samma coon sanoews -
Y.
i
. ATTACHMENT B l I
ACRS SUBCOMMITTEE MEETING ON V0GTLE ELECTRIC GENERATING PLANT UNITS 1 & {
LOCATION AUGUSTA, GEORGIA DATE July 18-19. 19R 5 '
ATTENDANCE LIST PLEASE PRINT:NAME AFFILIATION J. C. Eeerrm? ACK9 Suscomrree ceriusu G A Rrro 8CXS AfE/18st DA W/)so ~
tle M %xize //esr srser Neu~ a naue #Rc ivas cAIAL/) (0. l [/?A I A/) /)fC ~ li$k"ff/?b M V. Samu-- Ain- Em ia .[-
nA m a w s 6 -&%;s-rammJdrs.)
Nfs.Sohn f H w A s M m- e Ns.
TED 0Jt1Y N (L c. - rJ R K Y4E 04 W E Ntc- WM& ,
Tes n Sc'<CeCE 'A /f) d ~ A m ti k '1 T lbu E'. ito e XM A N k $ (. ~ CG/O& .5 /EfblC}
fnnFs A OR/t--Ey DCu ri/GLA) 80. SEiz v/ces -
?
A UBLE A. Ystoiv?iss Eecasin Rua&buiries,1a rse. ices i
it Beunsu da. Grow Powd %wy Gcocac%cxilein 3rc. G r o c cii1 9 &co r a cs 0xt0 BATun S oa r m us (S. Szwch ArtAPM .T AfRf6HIAlo ' OGartt hnwtA [otrogwtw 14 uD. k',7 cf <
SArn Cmp,j Srsim,
. % m 3 m u w ,v w s ,)vc u re ut. T. kMchen.s Geows kw co. .
l l
~
~
< - , - - e 4e **-,wwe,,,-,,,- ,--,,y r- ,-----m- .-----e - - - - - - . . - . ,
l l
l ACRS SUBCOMMITTE,E MEETING ON V0GTLE ELECTRIC GENERATING PLANT UNITS 1 & 2 l LOCATION AUGUSTA, GEORGIA DATE ' )ulv la_19.1995 ATTENDANCE LIST PLEASE PRINT:NAME AFFILIATION Paul D /Tus A L ' Georia /10, C.
bon fos /er- " ' ~
iTioAas [e & .. - ..
DAM h//06M6d--
h, "B g..
Eovi m A'. _ a1 e t '- "
hiacru b.7%cea- L]swnw Ew , are n-,
bt Tokasa .
a a "
WoAEAT k. ScMir ur/G $&Nilt lc w l 4 Q A ?.
Ln m. Som e_ E cc 13eeMa power Coro.
Luee T. M m ~Becaer M owen ( b v.
- MEMDI 6ux/An,$ <5 as>-sa Po es.a< do .
C i- A l a sJ t a % _ ,a m u
[/ja on,. nac a::,c3 A .c__cytic cepp.
Fel ty L E GA Sri AECHTEL fd20Ec. Cocp.
5 40 .T. 14o uds ., ., ,,
$hL P// C. SAfDkl BCO/7E t- StJM 0xP '
bvtND b ACb b-seem s'm e- bem 7hos Lvk.c.
%1.Sl fm 00
- MAex rAmrsir WecTE'ese accxtc.ra e -
IHO WHeLes.s courseed coupAw sesances
.N. /CEAEl '7/In,V ,///CS77/tM/MtJJL~ If &Y. 0KI).
III (2 969-14iM (Mern os. becEE 1
6e +.g g- -
ACRS SUBCOMMITTE,E MEETING ON V0GTLE ELECTRIC GENERATING PLANT UNITS 1 & 2 LOCATION , AUGUSTA, GEORGIA DATE ' Jul v 18-19.1988; .
ATTENDANCE LIST PLEASE PRINT:NAME AFFILIATION D .s . J A G Ays3ATM A b4 06UITEL 70WER- 04 Pol:AT10
'h NJ t D L 1-\00G WToO 9 Cc4,TCL SchTetlb?A'TtM
-7'. W. 6 PPG hvt$u Ge wvCw?n1 / /
aCHgn( " BEL f-cRD bo M W @g Sq,u4cpr faw A. %mnkle. U Po E t Co.
R.Y. G5c ra e Grt-he r n ('4aa Services TSETH tWL L. tJEs rtOc,4ousE ELECTruC dorp.
J L ARRv ]o rA tuEsrtMcMoUSEE/.Ecraic 69AA A a!w. Geosav ~Brentsi -Gee av
&az /l &m~ P c m - n e.v
- J k es C. % sce b. kr eo.
C.:.': %:. ,;A r ro w'c a m.u E G.w v. h .
G . C. % tJul6,e t(edoe (sco.
11% NAc4/en taer0~L,we.- n r b, .
- b. 5 [c %u' G e<c ,ic b es Co.
OS 1)ISda(( haa
\l%a i P deco:
34a OA c. L /4F-mach 60se k'?2.temN c a
CoF.,P.
fML / Vies $14. Poisep Go.
T8 Abanks/ '
d d fastswe' l/fH r b i T D 3 btr1.- 3)o&oan=dsart%
w e an 4,LA
~
JK n.
00t & /3ros,ttoos oootoecce. skW
. . ~ . = ~
a L*ED -
l ACRSSUBCOMMlTTEIMEETINGON G V0'TLE ELECTRIC GENERATING PLANT UNITS 1 & 2
- LOCATION AUGUSTA. GEORGIA
)
DATE July 18-19.1995 ATTENDANCE LIST l
PLEASE PRINT:NAME AFFILIATION C. E. Ewing Duquesne Light Comony Io .
YAs..elitk vs'N2' btGk r OwPMV M' -
D C2OOM WTC.DeuPdy l
$.f $//,QA7A/A/
h s/4 e!!3NE bM7 bMMW .
Lo . T6.D 4 5 pit E . I. -bw Po w'T
% J.(y, 4,q., S. , Swy-y G .,j, GiabL0 Geor 8 L [teera Clab
/e m s a ' W,9,v w i V wpsnuc.aov.se U Kuerz Dur,uesaia &ser a ,e.:s
/9/lem e hsLaD 47e S.,eSw z <.
0 ll kvlIn e GeoNi Pe w do.
<lw
_ %,u i G$L.
TF71 lEnkin 10 & STinu cersoe) s e Mr L. larov krmsam wnumu TE-RI boLkEr fr1%tKM Cb f&nidt 4 tA k g M ,
O U m
e k - - - - - ,
AL.Nb buBCOMMITTEE MEETING ON V0GTLEELECTRICGENFRAThNGPLANTUITS &
.,LOCATIO:1: AUGUSTA, GA DATE: July W19,1985 l ATTENDANCE LIST l
PLEASE PR1hT:
( NAME BADGE NO. AFFILIATION .
J t Eseern e N ES S e0"mirre CH*r"'w i
G. A Hero ACE.S D.A Wasp "
tl.C N 'A%ier &&rs sr"r
-E. G. A oc h o c s/Ac/s/Rie/pl _
_l1A.(hdlcr dCL /A)RRI OL M f 5,ower .
Arab /Rejs~r
- 1. l~ Ro&GE Nec //?e+Av1T l s Te e i GrI,c r rss poe.uNo ehs~,;cle +- & %>h M I O v F- 6. MAtasM B scHrGL Pawste catap.
& [/As '
Ab GeorO< & Erin- Club Tun 3.k..w Ce nN' y & < f~rie,o.a Geg;, .
y W Le sal o
W. D345Pl T E , I %~Po .,T E, F'. ku n 2 @ Dd40Esce $tGn r do.
$ $ $ll-MAAid buq ucsric De,a, d.
1 9E.Bentkoa 4 "
1
/ . A A /s o m o beau v ac bow 4 C. E. Ewine Duauess a Lt d+ Co. -
3,2 . C su , e_ k hm, .e we Locw r Ce
~
% e L, #w 6:-ma v's- &. !
h)M.S. Lacey huesue twdr Co.
7Daus wwiaa .
~
I C.S OkCaII om le%a L ee %.
l I l
L. .
E-__ . __: . _ _ _ -. _ .._1 . . . _ _ _ . ,
. . .. . n ,-a.us waa18 LOCA110'l: AUGUSTA, C,A DATE: July 18=19,1985 ATTENDANCE LIST .
? LEASE PRINT:
l NAME BADGE NO.
AFFILIATION .
n rf . fntn & ow s. dh wr4com Vom ('aca0+ ;
Dani s $ hod 6+ %c-- Co wmv uesaww eter. 'cbee.
M. Ski ban; GJ'C C. Wells GPG
_c.se aroJ ,. m ..,v l s u o d e c u = ~ . <= a e
_ 2>4 4 aue .
M r.rnnc 4 ore. re o a.o 64CK66 Ars?Ani Ww.srpw&vcv.se esmW-. CacP dw.e %e os. Genet,A 70ukt CD.
J K C,i,=,ia " " "
d A . S r> R a u M . C 6 " " _
VL. Geer 9e ,
6oe ra lemoaoq Services M.t L4xcoxi Becervi. Powrx rm/
MicMACL 4Ao V W1-1 Tm4;;JMtXf A2.FC . ~ UAA F;r r H HALL (Gori O 6 H-oOG6 E LErc.T w.i c_. co RP.
1 M SPE 4-1 A-Lgi i i mm o c 4-m os 6 deie MT1ust BMM/--
72&r 6:es 8 Y ErcpML Tl.ARAv fora t.oESTtOG/{oes16 $EcRte. 0 4f.
$ELPlE d. $d6LJ AbctJret m a r s c a n p.
)c'E L t >c L. E GASP I " " "
Aureev x T- lM ux f>cewts. 3 ws(0o,f.
iga J. korscs r - "
l h - ro6scJ Nc M @ se E W c. C. q .
ne
_ . .. _ o %
LotAl10:1:
AUGUSTA, GA DATE: July 18=19,1985 ATTENDANCE LIST .
PLEASE PRINT: '
NAME BADGE NO.
AFFILIATION .
- 4. E. m W o.sde % b r o 0 )
i Y b T us.a c A YKr~nN ll0a12
% 1vk& Mnw rcG Poudek RAP Raw v W W GhMA
~Joas Pu~eker 13ecMe.\ Power Cer c.
Vother A. Scati.uaic Accura ~/swti con.
ll1xE N/TCA/L //C- -
W1271M6/oer56
$ T.lboz!'SSKY Qo4,a f4 (.
Y d . N5. L W' dm %. )Th e b .
n3 mR C d" m~TL s Pas /dJ L " *
- w. f. ki+che ws creo rah hu r Rd,= 5 mace, - verruhu Srewn 7 Cgeswo &c sa. Awa OsJsennoa L A to. brecl<a s O 6m r n. , L an.<
a A,b. '
&, A a. r . A ' 5c v:ca ,
h rs LhL)) '
M, a f-a w LN c'r-~. <>
4 Nahl-
, Spar,t,,* om er CALv -
1 J , .
D MA 4 #M faf An- WGf k 4 b n s< h1 .E V norn M d idlCE.Y i
t
,. , ATTACHMENT C l July 12,, 1995
/
/ ,
FROPOSED SCHEDULE FOR THE JULY 18-19, 1'9 8 5 '
SITE VISIT AND MEETING OF THE ACRS SUBCOMMITTEE ON VOGTLE, ALVIN W., PLANT, UNITS 1 & 2
~
FOR OPERATING LICENSE REVIEW .
Thursday: July 18, 1995 6:15am Hotel Coffee Shop open for Breakf at Site Visit -
Plant Tour-7:00 Leave Hilton Hotel for Plant Site 60 min
! B:00 Site Fly-over by Helicopter 30 8:20 Plant Tour (f ore two groups) 135 10:45 -
Lunch - 60 11:45 Leave Plant Site fbr Hilton Hotel 60 12: 45 - Break - 15 Sybcommittee Meetino - OL Review 1:OOpm Opening Statements 15 min NRC Staff Presentation 1:15 Open Items 60 In Particular Containment Sump Toxic Gas Evaluation of Chemicals Generic Letter B3-28 .
Training of Emergency Diesel Generator Personnel
- Diesel Fuel Oil Storage Tank Cathodic Protection Licensee Qualifications dor Operation Items "
Retestingjof-Simulator
Response
2:15 Items of Interest 50
- Technical Specification .
for Maximum Permissible ,
1-g '- - _,_e w,-cc,, .e- +ge. , . - -w. *p..-.y- ,,w,,v---,- -, , - - . , , _ , - . - - .
, '. VOGTLE MEETING July 12, 1995 i JULY 18-19, 198D -
SCHEDULE
- Temperature Mismatch ,
Operating Experience on .. ,. ~
/ 'e ,~
Shift Several Issues that were ,,' .'
Difficult to Resolve 3:05 Regional Evaluation of Construction 25 min Issues a) History b) Open Items 3:00 - Break -
15 Utility Staff Presentation 3:45 Open Items 60 In Particular Fire Protection Items
- Equipment Qualification
- Preservice Inspection Program Emergency Response Capability Safe and. Alternate Shutdown Capability Emergency Preparedness Human Factors Engineering Items 4:45 Readiness Review 45 5:00pm -
Recess -
Friday: July 19, 1985 Subcommittee Meetino -
OL Review
- 8:30 Over vi ew *15 a) Principal Design Features b) Plant Status c) Startup Schedule vi:45 Management, Philosophy 10 y8:55 Organization and Man agement 65 a) Project Management (const.)
b) Corporate Support (oper.)
c) Plant Operation
- p d) Nuclear Quality Assurance (construction & operation) 9 M M I
l .
W .
I VOGTLE MEE11NG July 12, 1995 JULY 18-19, 1985 -
SCHEDULE t -
~
eTO:OO Emergency Operating Procedures 30 min
./
_ 10:30 - Break - s f5
/ ~
l p46: 45 Unique Plant Features 90 l
a) Nuclear Service Cooling Water Towers b) Auxiliary Feedwater Steam .
j Generator Nozzle c) Radwaste Solidification Building d) Refueling Water Storage Tank e) Main Steam Isolation Valves .
12:15 - Lunch - 60 min p '1:15pm Control Room 60 a) Detailed Control Room Design Review b) Safety Parameter Display System c) Control Room Habitability d) Remote Shutdown Capability uH5: 15 Fire Protection Systems 15 v'2:50 Pr coperati onal and'1nservice Testing of Pumps and Valves 15 6-2: 45 Main Feedwater Control System 5 S 2:50 Ground water level (concrete seals) 5 p-2:55 AC/DC Power Systems Reliability 10 e8105 Compressed Air System (Safety Grade /
Non-safety Grade Interface) .5 3:10 - Break - 15 5-5:25 Training 60 m) Simulator .
b) Initial Operator Training Program ,
c) Requalification Training Program d) RO and SRO Experience e) Training for Non-licensed Staff v4:25 Fitness for Duty 15 y
.. ~.
p4T40 Duality Concerns 30 5:10 - Adjourn -
. l 6
b 4._ - _
. i
.- ATTACMENT D DOCUMENTS PROVIDED/ HANDOUTS
- 1. 29 Viewgraphs used by the NRC Staff
- 2. 169 Viewgraphs used by Georgia Power / Southern Company Services
- 3. Letter, H. Bolton Seed to Walter R. Ferris dated July 3, 1985 re liquification potential at Vogtle Nuclear Project
- 4. Statement and Addendum by W. F. Lawless dated 7/19/85 I
l D
r i
- - . _ - - _ . -- . - . . . - --