ML20091F273

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Requests Info Re Plans for Addl Inspectors at Site in Order to Reply to Lr Romo (Lone Tree Council) .Draft Reply Encl
ML20091F273
Person / Time
Site: Midland
Issue date: 02/23/1984
From: Goldsmith R
NRC COMMISSION (OCM)
To: Rehm T
NRC
Shared Package
ML17198A223 List: ... further results
References
CON-BOX-06, CON-BOX-6, FOIA-84-96 NUDOCS 8406020097
Download: ML20091F273 (11)
v • d • e


Text

-

i*

i 4

[* *""%,,

UNITED STATES

[y g;g NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION 3s j

WASHINGTON, D. C. 20556 s,.. /

OFFICE OF THE

..d i

comuissiONEn February 23, 1984

  • i i

NOTE FOR:

TOM REEM l

RE:

LETTER FROM LEO R. ROMO I would like to know what plans NRC has for increased _ inspection at Midland in order to' reply to the attached letter.

(See Marabito comments in enclosed press clipping.)

--- i

/ /t.<.JU,

~Q,

f)a. Yen : L Roxanne Goldsmith i

Attachment:

Ltr dtd 1/30/84 fm Leo R. Romo i

t s

t t

s s

P.

Q l

GQQ-8406020097 840517 PDR FOIA RICE 84-96 ppg

,e-I

}

LUWr t nr c. ww no.-

P.O.B x421 Essexville, Michigan 46732 S

,,,,,,e,,,,,,

w..cwN.arro=~rv Advisory Board

      • !yg**"r7e*d"o*IEE.'o, *we.ica j,^ *," [,",*,'a,,',^3de$,*,,

" =s o==='

.*a.aaA

="~ ~'=""

c

~ ' " -

.., ~,..... ~

='la'N..Wa^n'o*A**.'v^#

,. w w.o~~ ov u c~..v.

30, 1984 January Commissioner Gilinski

,6 United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C.

20555 Dear Commissioner Gilin I read with great dismay the enclosed article in our local press.

Mr. Marabito of Region III says the " extent of the quality assurance problems at Midland are not as pervasive asT citizens who for years have wanted increased NRC they were at Zimmer."

many Mr. James Keppler, Region III administrator, reviewed a involvement at Midland.

partial list of the Quality Assurance problems at Midland before 1983.

the Subcommittee on Energy and the Environment on June 16, Constr This, and the fact that the (which will identify problems) make Mr. Marabito's statement a I spoke with an of ficial in Mr. Richrrd bit premature.

On January 20, 1984, I

DeYoung's of fice on the subject of increased NRC inspectors.

DeYoung made to a citizen's was referred to a response Mr.In it he indicated that this would 1983.

(Docket No.

petition on October 6,be determined by "the Commission budget process.

50-329, 50-130, 10CFR 2206, p.3)

Marble Hill, Zimmer end With the recent decisions at Byron,inupectore could be added it would seem that additionalThere are only five inspectors

Limerick, expanding the bndget. Indeed, it would seem foolish for without working on 15 years of errors.

the NRC not to do this.

Will you please increase the number My request is simple, of NRC inspectors at Midlaud?I loom forward to your response.

1 i

t Sincerely, i

~

J

~

j Corre'sponNngSecretary

.o.s.~i:. ties.xseco,. at ~ tine.vios...nou s o~o i

u/ A A ( N l

l I

.w.

a 4l.;

0 }

' -.'n ; - * * ~ * -

~. *

. s.:..:. * ~; ~ - w ~ -. =,- -,_

~ _

!.w=.4 :. : ~w-k"0'#?%9, i Q g g

"** v m

.-s,,.

e..

r-g 3.. c_,,.,..w....-o

.y

.s.

s

.c

.;_,..., g

_u _

s..

..c,..n

. r.- -.;...,n,,c l

t h..

t

"~

_ v TiiURSDAY,IAAUARY26,1964 J.IheSaylnaw NEWS _E.

f NoreA BC insaec:orssouc itn.j

~

y

.t

1..Groupwants staffshifted-from nuke plants-that-floundered l.

=

i BY KEITH NAUGHTON '.

ticult reinspection in the nuclear in 1979 because it found quaDity l.

I

~

I ews Staff Wnter

. industry today," Ms. Garde said.. assurance and management prob ?

i N

    • It would take a minimum of a lems at the plant.

' A nuclearpower watchdog group is pressuring the U.S. Nuclear Reg. dosen people to effectively monitor ;if.the Midland stalf'is not in-

. i nlatory Commission to beef up its ' the (construction completion pro-creased in size, it w i

staff hspecting the Midland Nucle-gram). lass than that jeopardises plant's construction. program and *....j

heintegrityeftheprogram?

.. tually<lelay4be.oempletion.cf.j.,

JrPla' int t

Goverbment Accountability Pro.

A five-man fl5tC team monitors the project,Ms. Garde claimed. -.,

e t

kject. a Washington-based citizens the Midla'nd plant now, with two "You could tave a situation-l Igroup. Mll send a letter to the members of the team at the plant

  • where people are sitting around tcommission Triday urging it to 4 twiddling their th'umbs, waiting for :

i site full time.

The NRC has not determined. an NRC inspector."she said. i.

i shift inspectors sho had been as.

signed to nuclear projects that what it will do with the inspectors The utility does not believethe.

from Zimmer and Marble Hill, size of the NRC team will have an:

ll have floundered recently to 'the Midland team.

NRC spokesman Russ Marabito. impact on implementation of the; t

said.

! In the past two weeks. two Mid, construction program, Consumers.

western nuclear plants have halted "Some of thett may be shifted spokesmanJames Storey said.

l i

construction - the Zimmer Nucle-over to possibly the Midland "The NRC is not scheduled un '

t

'ar Plant in Ohio and the Marble. (plant),,Marabitosaid.

. der the plan we drafted to get that.

E101NuclearPlantinIndiana.

Zimmer had a staff of eight full-involved in the day.to-day, pro-l 4

8 The three Ohio ututtles that own time inspectors with three inspec. cess,"Storeysaid.

The NRC ordered Consumers )%,

!Zimmer announced Saturday the tots on call whenever needed, l;

Power Co. to draft a formal com ;.

'ptant will be converted to a coal. Marabito.

fired operation. Public Service of But Midland does not need as pletion plan forits plant after fed-l

{

2ndiana closed Marble HillJan.16 large a staff t ecause it is not as eral inspectors found several* "-

because the utDity ran out of men ' troubled asZimmer was.he said.

quality assurancepr.2blems at the!

1

'ey to enmplete it.

' "The extent of the quality assur-plant in 1982.'

l Ilulle Garde, an investigator ior,. ance problems f at Midlandi are Storey would not say if the utuity

  • Ithe citizens. group, said Midland not as grvastve as hey were at ' is pleased with the performance of
  • 3eeds a larger NRCMa!!&caan~ Zlinnier, Marabi'oslid.

uwTreaetFNRC"1!3Tf 5T1rydd!-7----

ici the " comprehensive" comple-Marble Hillis not similarin any tional staffmg ts necessary.

l ition program the plaat is way to Midland because it was net "That's really a question the.

tedergoing.

a troubled ' plant. Marabito NRC has to determinel.. It's their :

"The constructica co:npletmn' citined.

' role and responsib3.ty to deter.l

,. program is the most striegent, But the NRC stopped all safety-mine tne staff that is needed'here," '.

i Storey said.

i mest comprehensive and most dii-r-Isted constructior :1 Martle Hill

,i 1

~;

l w-. m73.1 -

- - ^ ~

l hM!fMN ?'.f4W'%MMW/*9?p*tW@A ~(a%.

' ^ W. J-~ WQ.'.barM2eGM.M i

e

i. -

\\

.w-...

_..;.. x p

~

' ~~

.a

.s s

s m.

s; 4

__m.

i s

e s

s

....j-

.:.........e...

LJNs TED'$TATES gs

.l ~. ' '. '.,,

/

,*g

_,f 3

NUCLEAR HEOULATORY COMMISSION

.1 ;C...

g ;. < p

. N wAssiwaTom. o. c. aosss

.J.

... s m

  • 7 Of FICE OF

\\

IN$PSCTION ANDE.-

ENPDActh48NT_

^

N s

\\

%. g r

'A 8

.7...

f

/ lf)\\0 / '

. ) [~~

  • 'k I' ', )'."

A 1 O1 s.

/

.3... h5. s.3 ar.

a

.:.y -..,,.. '.

.t.. ; h *:. q.,.

  • .
    ...., '.. v - n.-

.m. ~ -

7.

... ;v?. B.:.p.Aw.-

. J..s. :.

.e.

~

,. f* wi7 '

.. i..; $.,.. Q,)..E.'.*

26 /f/jt//t/* /

,7~~ /~~~

j,

,.t 3,'. ' d. '.: ;.;.;;.'/[.s.-

r,$. g ej 8 k,M['*

.- ~ ~.~ s;me~, -

i.d

......,~.e...

's

, e,a.s

'=.

s*

\\

a

. : 1.':*'.%l. :, r.p.. k.g..s*

. - =

'.i.<>,.... g r

..'.'.r'\\ A.* *,. : ;*,,e Pa* f.*N,,f'.P-1*.%

    • f.

-J

.. :i, n1..

s: &fa /A yn

~

E... :.. y.n

.' A

~

s..

i m

s

".=. 3

_1 y; w;

.~;..

~~

p. :%.y:~.

CC 1 n a 4. # /

y,/ p..

.. %g

/"u/vs t w s:-

t s ;...:.x s..

.s.. u.

x

/

~

+

....-, :,....x.,..

. ~.

'~

.. ' 'N-hl/t' j[

~

- (.-[,

?.

s

..s 3.

.. 3,. c. -

f.

4

):'ID

[

J

[

[- f(), d I.

~

.l...,

.,. y.

e A

ry*,.,. i..',... *,.

..r,.,

4

3..

c s.

I, i.i g

+

... s.

a.

3,. n...,.. p., s a......

.,..,.s.

.,...#r...,..,..,,.r. -. -

v g

,'..(.4

?. M: f.**.

y

' y. ',;t <, :'. ::q. *cs.f.

.-..--. _...y...,

f,.

.C

.:e

~.

.-.l-

.g.

,a

. m...

. s.

p

~

s

~..

.;s.

. s.

i

e..

a s.

i

\\

~

N ES 8411: 21 t '

~;

1 s

)

'lg 6

j=

9 Y

q%

p 5

4

_h

-l

.f w

s' qa.r;_.

3-s -,

+

~~'

=

o s-3 5

4--

,3 N.

t

A e

e.~~~~..

Cuf.31 Nr5' TfDa k}ev1ne.

C'.:M h.n e l

& yf%-hy_r,/A-mer/

.:> ri w.l s

2a

, w u.- n,--g& /??s// rad '

3Ye MC a

aa L grwkk hupe c}rku a.n n s k c.c.

2 l~fr c, f Q,c) h w y

t csnsracf 6 <
wit n-L,prxesr m

(&

n.,;4 a,/ 4 g,.,. &,

/

.- ~gr..

x W

wi.e& cx u,itY &

hchnda/. +.r,r e c h s fra

/ % I L 6.; yp <rn - A p n os - y-ycF pr - el e M.49 za tk i +eu, y

,,, +

k

(

+

1 I.

t J

s 9

~

)

,+,

b F

= W. s 4

g

+4-N g UNITED STATES

[

.r.

g NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION E

WASHINGTON. D. C. 20556' F

%++..+/

)

Occket Nos. 50-329 330 Lone Tree Council ATTN: Mr. Leo R. Romo Correspondfrig Secretary P. O. Box 421 Essexville. MI. 48732

Dear Mr. Romo:

This refers to your' letter of January 30, 1984, to Chairman Palladino request-ing an increase in the nusber of NRC irispectors at the Consumers Power Com-pany's (CPCo) Midland facility.

+

The NRC now has three resident inspectors located at the Midland site, an additional three individuals in the Region III office assigned full time to the Midland project, and additional inspection specialists from the Region III Division of Engineering who spend time onsite as needed. Currently allocated resources for Midland substantially exceed the 1.5 manyears that have been

. w ~s~tusbM & toi k ventS

- allocated for a normal nuclear plant consinction site.

gggw ~Qu w w u. " m ee s u m.-,- we In addiYion, the NRC required CPCo to have an independent third party overview the remedial' soils work activities and an independent third party overview the Construction Completion Program (CCP) activities. On February 24, 1983, Stone and Webster (S&W) was approved 4tlie NRC to overview the remedial soils activities. S&W currently has seson individuals onsite involved in this effort. On September 29, 1983, S&W was approved by the NRC to overview the CCP activities. S&W currently has @ individuals (completely different from those involved in the remedial sofis! overview) onsite involved in overviewing CCP activities. The S&W overview stgffs can be increased as the work load increases.

3 3--

The NRC inspection effort is further augmented by the NRC initiated and

}

approved Independent Design and Construction Verification Program being per-formed by approximately 10 professionals from the TERA Corporation. This i

program is currently ongoing and is to provide additional assurance regarding -

1 the adequacy of design and construction for Midland.

4

.c Also for your infonnation, this. office issued a Confirmatory Order on January-1 12, 1984 to the licensee. The order basically requires a review to be perfor-1 med by an inde' pendent consultant of the Midland corporate and site management structure,and supervisory personnel.,.We expect the licensee to submit his plan on this matter' in accordance with the order in the near future.

[

The cent 10 CFR 2.206' petition on the behalf of the Lone Tree Council by I

Billie Pirner Garde. Government Accountability Project, also addresses the l

1ssue of NRC inspection personnel at Midland, as well as other issues.

A-t.

decision in this regard will.be issued by me in a reasonable time, t

a

-e

. ~ - - -

Nw

,e--

,4

e e

e v

-e 9

9

r ~ ~ ' '-'

~-

-~

~g.-' y

~ ~ ~ ~

~ ~ ~ ~ -~

~~

- ~ ~ - - ~ ~ -

~~

.. Mr. Leo R. Romo In regard to your question on the utilization of resources which have been allocated to other facilities, this matter is currently under review by the NRC and your suggestions will be censidered -along with all other needs f or increase inspection effort.

Sincerely, R. C. DeYoung, Director Officet of Inspection and Enforcement a

f l'

i-i-

1

  • a e

e i

1 3

4 v

I,k

}

f}

!;i f

L,!

e 4

t 6

i 4!

it.

A

. !l

- a,,..

,.d a msg

m. _ ;

s-

n 7

/.*

7 MM 6

7 Qe < A.f.* "

h p!,

a i

e

\\

t'l

~v.

?l

.g.

1;} -

.U..

.s

.~.,.j

-t-

,,27 _

4e,

.. z - D.;i m * ',gfq ' q,

.l.'4.p" #1.', {,',, *. 5,{,t T,P4'(-Y~.

i I

l

].

7*

5 7

)

  • t
i. f.

['.

~

w.,-

.A 4

3 s

/ ROM:N'

- ACTICN CONTROL DATES CONTROL NO.

cou cosAouNa 3/9/c4 14133 Co:nmissioner Gilinsky cATE OF oOCuuENT (Roxanne Goldsmith)

,,1s.u.cgtv M

2/23/84 TO:

PREPARE FOR SIG84ATURE FINAc PcPLY op Tom Re b CMA!RMAN Fits LOCATION m ecurmao.aecron OTHER:

DESCRIPTION O terren 0 usuo O nepent O OTHER SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS OR REMARKS Requests it what plans NRC has for increased inspection at Midland fa order

.i

^

to reply to 1tr fk Leo R. Reno, Lone Tree PRIORITY i

Council ASSIGNEO TO DATE INFORMATION ROUrING

{ pp,.

.. CeYouno. IE 2/24/04 Dircks d.,_':..

_I u

~..

e

]/R t 3,.. ~~-

f MN T, Nfyh. ~.

stelle

r--ps

, rm--! r L-- -.

. J

-,u_

-. p.

.nj i--__,

l T@~f-~~-. In

.w...;-

'I) W.. +

k NRC FORM 232 EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR FOR OPERATIONS

-I._..

PRINCIPAL CORRESPONDENCE CONTROL

I s.

C011S' m STS.

J 3

Y.

J A Mooney

\\

/ CompanW*

  • - - = -

{

'4 A6Jiand hojecs Offia l

General offices: 194s West Parnell Road, Jackson, MI 49201 + (517) 788-0774 l

February 27, 1984 Mr J J Harrison Midland Project Section U S Nuclear Regulatory Commission Region III 799 Roosevelt Road Glen Ellyn, IL 60137 MIDLAND ENERGY CENTER GWO 7020 AUXILIARY BUILDING UNDERPINNING RESPONSE TO JANUARY 4-6, 1984 NRC AUDIT QUESTIONS File: 0485.16.1 UFI: 42*05*22*04 Serial: CSC-7375 0460.2 12*16-00211(S)

REFERENCE:

JAMooney letter to JJHarrison, serial CSC-7292, dated February 8, 1984.

Enclosed are Figure 8-8 and 8-9 for Attachment 8 to our February 8,1984 letter which were inadvertantly omitted.

IIt"L l

JAM /GMM/k1w Attachment I

CC RFWarnick, NRC Region III RBLandsman, NRC Region III RJCook, NRC Senior Resident Inspector, Midland Site DShood, Project Manager Midland l

s gSS gya&Db "l

x - __ --_ :______-___- _

l

e CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY Midland Units 1 and 2 Docket No 50-329/50-330 Letter Serial CSC-7375 Dated February 27, 1984 At the request of the Connaission and pursuant to the Atomic Energy Act of 1954, and the Energy Reorganization Act of 1974, as amended and the Commission's Rules and Regulations thereunder, Consumers Power Company submits J A Mooney letter to J J Harrison serial CSC-7375, dated February 27, 1984.

CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY t

/

By i

J A 1pooney Executive Manager SwornandsubscribedbeforemethisN day of M>j,r.A /,1984.

G

&2 0,,Da s Notary Pub 1'ic p g

~

i k

i My Commission Expires d-[

b ent ruGin.. FJi -o.

Netary Public. Bay County. Mr My Ccmmission Expires Mar.41986 j

i

.l i

l i-i

[

BP0284-0002B-CN01

-Ii

2 OM/0L SERVICE LIST l

Mr Frank J Kelley, Esq,;

Atomic Safety & Licensing Attorney. General of the Appeal Board i

State of Michigan U S Nuclear Regulatory Commission Ms Carole Steinberg, Esq

.. s ?"' Washington, DC 20555 Assistant Attorney General Environmental Protection Division Mr C R Stephens (3) i 720 Law Building Chief, Docketing & Services Lansing, MI 48913

- U S Nuclear Regulatory Consrission Office.of the Secretary Washington, DC 20555 Mr Myron M Cherry, Esq Suite 3700 Ms Mary Sinclair Three First National Plaza 5711 Summerset Street Chicago, IL 60602 Midland, MI 48640 Mr Wendell H Marshall Mr William D Paton, Esq

-RFD 10 Counsel for the NRC Staff Midland, MI 48640 U S Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 Mr Charles Bechhoefer, Esq Atomic Safety & Licensing Atomic Safety & Licensing Board Panel Board Panel U S Nuclear Regulatory Commission U S Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 Washington, DC 20555 Dr Frederick P Cowan Ms Barbara Stamiris 6152 N Verde Trail 5795 North River Road Apt B-125 Rt 3 Boca Raton, FL 33433 Freeland, MI 48623 Mr Fred Williams Dr Ierry Harbour i

Isham, Lincoln & Beale Atomic Safety & Licensing 1120 Connecticut Avenue, NW, Suite 325 Board Panel Wa'shington, DC 20036

.U S Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 t,

Mr James E Brunner, Esq Mr M I Miller, Esq Consumers Power Company Isham, Lincoln & Beale j

212 West Michigan Avenue Three First National Plaza

, Jackson, MI 49201 52nd Floor Chicago, Il 60602 Mr D F Judd Mr John Demeester, Esq l

Babcock & Wilcox,

Dow Chemical Building PO Box 1260 i

Michigan Division l

Lynchburg, VA 24505 Midland, MI 48640

~!

Mr Steve Cadler, Esq Ms Lynne Bernabei i

2120 Carter Avenue Government Accountability Project St Paul, MN 55108 1901 Q Street, NW Washington, DC 20009 t

i 9/3/83.

miO583dO429a100 I'

I

\\

BCC JWCook, P-26-336B DLQuamme Midland (3)

TABuczwinski, Midland-207 JNLeech, P-24-507 DAKommers, P-14-106 (For SER Related Issues)

DFLewis, Bechtel DJVandeWalle, P-24-6145 MIMiller. IL&B, Chicago JCWilliams,IL&B, Washington,DC GALow P-12-237A NRC Correspondence File, P-24-517 UFI, P-24-517 3JWalraven, P-24-517 Hearings File, P-24-517 O

t

-i

.l l

I i,

b i

}a

^t 1

i

\\

m_.

F gg

,+

i e#

%;5 h

i CON TROL Tou/ER f

i a

e 6

W i

t S

.a w__

3-_----_-__

17(ter Jacking & V6(trStst

- Baseline 6-L5 62 i Grill 9e and Prion lo -

Sching e EO Geillage Mnm eux.

=

1 i

I i

~j 8,

i E

o

_ _ _L._

__ _ __ _ _ _ __._ a i

i OEFopnEb SHAPES AT C OLUMM L mes G i

= We 6

F I Cru R E B-8

~'

r

G W

E

e. !

1 cournoc TOWER o

ss t

C O

__a

_._. __ 7 _ __ __

._a t_ _

Baseline e-zs et l

l After Jackng e W6(twf* K)

- nein Aug.

Grillage anct Pa-toe to -

Jacking e Eb Grillage

=

u

%o

~

\\,

m u _.__.t _ _ _ _ _ __ __ __ _ a t

m l

I DE FORM E b. Otfo4 PES AT Cowna Lines GiH 1

i FIGURE 8-9

+

,[-'

i g

,e,

,I 4

s

't STAft M vis titGAN j

14 i Si:T 5!! N'1 f.t 1 a OLN!) Gt Ni E Al kg'N' M t

$1 ASI E)

D. ST E l% EiOI(S NN Chkf Assistant Art.,nws General FR ANK J. KELLEY ATTORNEY GENER AL t

i.ANSING 489I3 February 7, 1984 Mr. James G. Keppler Regional Administrator U.S.' Nuclear Regulatory Commission Region III 799 Roosevelt Road Glen Ellyn, IL 60137 Re:

Midland Nuclear Power Plant

Dear Mr. Keppler:

I, and my division, the Special Litigation Division, represent Attorney General Frank J. Kelley as an intervenor in Consumers Power Company's pending electric rate case before the Michigan Public Service Commission, Case No. U-7830.

In that case, Consumers Power seeks ratemaking treatment for the Midland nuclear power plant.

We have hired engineering con-sultants to analyze and prepare testimony _on_the Midland-related.__

~

~

. aspects _of_the_ case./~Among the issues our consultants will address

!are when, if ever, the plant will be operable, the likely cost

, of the plant, the likely generating capacity of the plant, and i the extent to which substantial portions of the plant's costs are attributable, per. CPCo claims, to reasons beyond the contral g Cgnsumers Power Company management and its architect-engireer.,

~ _ _ _.. _.

I would like to discuss Midland, and have our consultants discuss Midland, on a periodic basis, with your people in the Office of Special Cases.

i e

y. Oh! pl h h ^

'FEB 13 1984 &e1 i_

.. ~

Mr. J a::.e s G. 1:epplcr February 7, 1984 Page Please let me know if telephone and/or personal discussions with j

that office present you with any difficulties.

I can foresee none, particularly since the Attorney General has been a party to the Midland dockets 50-329 and 50-330 for a number of years.

However, I thought a written request to you might be appropriate.

Very $ruky youg,

t/:

1 b! A

{

Alan J arak /

Assistant Attorney General Special Litigation Division AJB/fg k

i l

j k

b i

(

a so, e.- ee %

e a

A.

.~.

i gag

~

/RINCIPALSTAFF (RA FRP I

D/RA DE A/R' 3R'#5 To D'LQuamme, Midland Energy Center 73 3

RC CW PAQ SCS V

r SGA YL gggggggg FaoM BHPeck, Midland Energy Center TilF File Peter DATc March 16, 1984 Company SveJtet M'IDLAND ENEPGY CENTER GWO 7020 MEETING NOTES - IURBINE ROLL

,,,,,,u File: 0655 UFI: ~99*08 Serial: CSC-7470 comacs,anocuce 4

CC RAWells, MPQAD Meeting Attendees A

This memorandum documents the meeting held with the Nuclear Regulatory Com-mission (NRC) on March 5,1984 in Glen Ellyn, Illinois to discuss approval of Construction Completion Program (CCP) Phase I activities to support the Unit q

2 Turbine Roll milestone. The purpose of the meeting was to provide addition-al information to the NRC to supplement the February 15, 1984 letter from DLQuamme to JHarrision, Serial CSM-0734 which requested release of Phase I activities for the Turbine Roll milestone. Attachment 1 provides the meeting notes. Attachment 2 provides a list of attendees.

J

)

k l

I i

I

.a i

i i

I 1

4 h

i l

)

4 I

MAR 16 384 i

r p

-I

-r-r-..

i Attechent 1 i

t MEETING NOTES FROM TURBITE ROI.L 1

MEETING WITH NRC 1.

System OEAA - Need to do more than the 72'; i.e. part below water plus the part below the grating (whic'h will also be inaccessible after flood-

~

ing of the bay).

(*RRice) j 2.

Q TOES - Perform a complete reinspection on these - by MPQAD.

Must resolve any differences in dravir.gs for TOES before they go to GSO -

3.

i.e. make sure the hanger is of the right material before it is finished I

off.

4.

Some work items will be added as a result of Project Engineering stress walkdowns.

t 5.

System Interaction work by M. Jones: This will also add to the work scope.

I, 6.

Rigid hangers vs. snubbers This is a concern of Isa Yin. This is an ites for stress walkdown also.

7.

For turned over items / systems - No Status Assessment to be done (this was 1

actually done at the time of turnover).

i j

l a.

Closed irs - QVP i

I l

b.

Open IR - TOE and perform a complete reinspection of the work to a new PQCI.

t 8.

Interface between CCP and turned over items j

Arno Buhrer's chart could be useful in showing.this. Do we need to put

(

the CCP process for turned over items on this chart? (*BHPeck)

I i

4 9.

For non-turned over systems t

Closed IR - QVP only (Inspection Status Assessment) 1 3_

1 Open IR - QVP and Status Assessment r

t

10. What is the status of Arno Buhrer's chart?

(*BHPeck) i i

11. Discussion on going from Phase I to Phase II.

l Is everything in the module done? Need to be able to make a statement 1

about completeness of' work.

f

. 1 j

System commodities span and cross the boundaries of the area.

4 TR0384-0001A-CN02 4

t 4

9

.e L

. ~,..

l

)

12., Design changes on turned-over systems.

NRC needs to approve - Bruce Burgess (*REMcCue) i Two DCPs.were approved last summer by Ross Landsman.

Por future DCPs, write J. Harrison a letter asked for approval to per-form (*REMcCue)

I 13.

Possibility in the future about turning things back to consu:ruction for

}

completion of a large number of DCP type work. NRC would 1 Eke to be in-l formed about this.

(*REMcCue)

14. Discussed the supports for the traveling screen and slice gestes - these are Q.

Were these installed and inspected as Q7 (*BHPeck)

Need to follow-up on this week. Jay Harrison would like-soste-feedbsd on

~

this 3/7 or 8.

f

15. Reviewed Open Items from REMcCue/ Bruce Burgess inspection of* TOES conduc-ted week of 2/27/84.

Action Items here for REMcCue and BHPeck (*BHPeck/REMcCue)

16. Discussed " major and minor" T0Es.

T l

This category breakdown is not used. TOES are not considereid major items.

i

17. Work on Q TOES was stopped by REMcCue on 2/24/84, pending ountcome of j

discussions between REMcCue and Bruce Burgess.

I

18. Status of " Construction Ground Rules":

Cet a copy of the latest status of these and go over wf th Jaiy Harrison

.j on 3/7/64.

(*BHPeck) i 1

19. Best guess of a cold hydro date.

Depends on CCP activities.

i March or-April of 1985, at best - REMcCue i

j

_ NRC currently plans to start looking at us about October,1984.

j

20. Discussed draft letter.

i

. i Jay Harrison would like to see the results/get' a briefing om Phase I l

Management Review for the 2TR work. (*BHPeck) r i

~

l Send this letter out to NRC on 3/6/84 by telefax (*BHPeck) l TR038#-0001A-CN02 i

1*

,. _ _ L1

, ~., _

.1

--,_-_.2

.._~.:_,._.._..._...,_.,,_.

m

6 21.

Jay Harrison will try to bring us the approval for 2TR on 3/7/84.

22.

Brief discussion of futura CCP approvals / releases, and current status of CCP.

A three month backlog for Statu's Assessment is desired by CPCo.

This would be another 10-15 modules.

Go over this on 3/7/84 with J. Harrison.

Before we get the next release, NRC vants:

+ Lessons Learned

+ Changes Made to System as a result

+ Status of Items to date in Phase I

  • Denotes. follow-up item and responsible person.

BHPeck 3/16/84 k

O 5

6 e

TR0384-0001A-CN02 i

?

}

~

^

' Attcchmint 2 LIST OF ATTENDEES JJHarrison, USNRC RLandsman, USNRC BBurgess, USaRC BHPeck, CPCo DLQuamme, CPCo JClark,- CPCo-MPQAD -- --

DTaggert, CPCo-MPQAD RMcCue, CPCo i

RRice, CPCo JTMinor, Bechtel l

a 4

a.

i i

f 5

i r

i e

t 1

1 -.

\\

i 1:

TR0388-0001A-CN02 i

s 1

a m.

dlawd

[,

N ConSum8f3 i:.

. POW 8f a - s.o. =

'% _.,3 l' Company Nuclear operatsons Genere aces: 1945 Parnell Road, Jackson, Michigan 49201 e (517) 784-1217 March 23, 1984 i JRINCIPA!. STAFF LaqA jdRP D/RA-3d A/RA DRMSP RC 0%!A

. 0 PAO

$C3 V Harold R Denton, Director SGA office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation M

File

_/ 4.s US Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 DOCKETS 50-329, 50-330 - MIDLAND ENERGY CENTER -

REVISION TO NRC FACILITY STAFFING SURVEY FILE: 0505-2, SERIAL 27162

REFERENCES:

(1) LETTER FROM R J ERHARDT TO H R DENTON DATED 12/9/83, SERIAL 27136 (2) LETTER FROM M A MILLER (NRC) TO CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY DATED 12/30/83 (3) LETTER FROM J HANNON (NRC) TO ALL APPLICANTS FOR OPERATING LICENSES DATED MARCH 1, 1984 In Reference (1), Consumers Power Company provided the NRC with a response to the " Facility Staffing Survey", a questionnaire telecopied by the NRC on December 5,1983. It describes our current Midland Staff that is expected to be in place upon receipt of our Operating License. In light of the requested response time and as noted in Reference (2), the letter was submitted as a best effort response.

On January 26, 1984, an NRC Staff meeting (sususarized by Reference 3) was hald to discuss operating shift experience levels for Near Term Operating Licenses (NTOL). Revised forms, " Staffing Questionnaire" and " Staff Experience By Individual," were provided during the meeting by the NRC to the attending representatives from the various utilities. As a result of that meeting 33 representatives from 21 utilities met at the Institute of Nuclear Power Operation in Atlanta to form a working group to establish an industry position on the level and type of operating shift experience required for the initial start-up of the NTOLs. The results of the industry evaluation were presented to the NRC Commissioners on February 24, 1984. A follow-up NRC staff present-l ation to the Commissioners on February 28, 1984 supported the industry position for NTOLs that will start-up within a 1 to 2 year period. HoweYers NRC concern with the industry position was expressed in two areas: 1) the uses of contracted shift advisors should eventually be eliminated and 2) hot participation experience of 1 year should be a goal rather than the 6 month on-shift with 6 :eek at greater than 207, power as proposed by the industry.

oc0384-0357a142 Q'

h8 3 ) c q.g pfg&R

Harold R Denton, Director 2

Midland Energy Center NRC Facility Staffing Servey March 23, 1984 This letter forwards a revision to our December 9, 1983 submittal. The format of the staff experience forms distributed by the NRC during the January 26, 1984 meeting are included as revised by the working group. The attached 4

information incorporates specific shift operating experience data reflecting the industry position presented during the February 24, 1984 meeting. The revision also contains additional information not immediately available at the time of the first submittal. The following attachments are enclosed: - Staffing Questionnaire; Attachment 2 - Corporate Nuclear Experience (Off-Site Management); Attachment 3 - On-Site Management; - Operating Shift Experience.

4

', Operating Shift Experience specifies both current and projected i

(at receipt of our operating license) experience for the Shift Engineer (SRO),

Shift Supervisor (SRO), Control Operator (RO) and Auxiliary Operator (RO) positions. Current experience indicates a considerable amount of hot license experience has been gained at the Shift Supervisor level from the Navy Nuclear Pmgr-H - ;j ret zd,._r.. b

,.c is based upon utilization of our Palisades

[

Plant for purposes of obtaining the industry recommended hot participation experience. Eight didland assigned individuals are currently involved in the Palisades training program which provides for obtaining an SRO license and

- participating on shift for six months following receipt of the license. It is planned that another eight individuals will be commencing the program in the fall, 1984. In order to obtain Midland specific training and license prior to start-up necessitates that these individuals return to Midland after obtaining 6 months shift operating experience at the Palisades Plant. This program is consistent with the industry proposal. Pending NRC acceptance of the industry proposal we, therefore, do not plan to use contracted chift advisors.

Our proposed six shift rotation will require a minimum of twelve SRO's and twelve RO's.

It is presently planned to license forty-two personnel (R0's and SRO's) to provide staffing flexibility and operating reserves. The additional personnel included in the attachments should provide adequate reserve to accommodate the normal losses from attrition and promotion prior to receipt of the operating license.

R B DeWitt (Signed)'

R B DeWitt Vice President, Nuclear Operations CC JGKeppler, Regional Administrator TMNovak, USNRC, Assistant Director for Licensing DSHood, USNRC, Licensing Branch No 4 RJCook, Midland Resident Inspector HThompson, USNRC, Director, Division of Human Factor Safety DFSchnell, Union Electric Company Attachments oc0384-0357a142 1

.s E

m a

e

.n1aa a

.J1

-_n

-a 2

a ma&~

-t l

CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY j.

Midland Energy Center Dockets 50-329, 50-330 1

Letter Serial 27162 Dated March 23, 1984 At the request of the Commission and pursuant to the Atomic Energy Act of 1954, j

and the Energy Reorganization Act of 1974, as amended, and the Commission's j

Rules and Regulations thereunder, Consumers Power Company submits a revision to the Midland Energy Center response to the NRC Facility Staffing Survey.

4 CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY By R B DeWitt (Sinned)

R B DeWitt, Vice President Nuclear Operations 1

ij' Sworn and subscribed to before me this 23th day of March,1984.

l Sherry L Durfey (Sinned)

(SEAL)

Sherry L Durfey, Notary Public Jackson County, Michigan 1

My commission expires November 5,1986, i

i i

i i

I 1

i i

j au0384-0357d142 i

l t

STAITING QUESTIONNAIRE Plant Name: Midland Unit 2 Total number of Shift Supervisors (the person in charge of operating shift) presently on operating shift work N/A Proposed total number of Shift Supervisors on operating shift work at time of fuel load 6

Total number of Shift Supervisors on plant staff other than normal operating shift (e.g., substitutes) N/A i

Proposed total number of Shift Supervisors on plant staff other than normal operating shift at time of fuel. load. 2

~

Total number of licensed SR0s presently on operating shift work (do not include those listed above as SS) N/A Proposed total number of SR0s on operating shift work at time of fuel load (do not include those listed above as SS) 6 Total number of licensed SR0s presently on plant staff other than normal operating shift work (e.g., training instructors, engineers, substitutes) N/A Proposed total number of licensed SR0s on plant staff other than normal operating shift work 6

Total number of licensed R0s presently on operating shift work N/A Proposed total number of R0s on operating shift work at time of fuel load 12 Total number of Shift Technical Advisors (or others who perform STA function) on operating shift work N/A Type of shift rotation schedule for STA (24 hour2.777778e-4 days <br />0.00667 hours <br />3.968254e-5 weeks <br />9.132e-6 months <br />, 8 hours9.259259e-5 days <br />0.00222 hours <br />1.322751e-5 weeks <br />3.044e-6 months <br />, etc.) 8 hours9.259259e-5 days <br />0.00222 hours <br />1.322751e-5 weeks <br />3.044e-6 months <br /> / shift:

6 shift rotation Total number of STAS not on operating shift work (e.g., substitutes) 2 i

Our STA will be the Shift Engineer and will be in charge of the operating shift. There will be sin Shift Engineers. This number is included in the i

Shift Supervisor on shift category.

i i

i

.i i

f i

miO344-4046a-66-142 I

9 l

3 ATTACHMENTS Consumers Power Company i

Midland Energy Center Dockets 50-329, 50-330 Attachment I

~ '

STAFFING QUESTIONNAIRE CORPORATE NUCLEAR EXPERIENCE ON-SITE MANAGEMENT 4

and OPERATING SHIFT EXPERIENCE 1

i I

I March 23,1984 i

22 pages i

ic0384-0357bl42 i

-}

- ~ -.. -

CORPORATE NUCLEAR EXPERIENCE i

(ie, "0FT-SITE" NANAGEfENT)

(Indicate Whether BWR or PWR)

(On-Site)

(Off-Site)

Years at Other Nuclear Operator Lic Years at Nuc. Support /

Degrees Navy (if ever held) Operating Nuclear Management Level Position Name (years)

RO/SRO/None Stations Position

(_A/B/K/D)

Executive BSPS Vice President JWReynolds 3

BSIE Vice President RO/SRO l

1 4.

Nuclear Operations RBDeWitt (BRP) 10 13 BSME (FSAR pl3A.1-1)

(PWR & BWR) i Director of Nuclear Plant Support DREngbes SRO 9

9 BSEE (FSAR pl3A.1-23)

(BRP & PAL)

(PWR & BWR)

Director of Reactor Engineering WJBeckius 5

13 BS/MS (FSAR pl3A.1-19)

(PWR & BWR)

Ezec Director of Nuclear Activities GBSlade 5

7 BSME/MSNE (FSAR p134.1-7)

(PWR)

(PWR)

Ezec Director Planning &

Administration TWElward SRO 5

6 BSchem/MSNE (FSAR pl3A.1-3)

(PAL)

(PWR & BWR)

Director Radiological Services RWSinderman 3

15 BSSE/MSEHS/

(FSAR pl34.1-11)

(1 PWR MPHHP 2 BWR) miO384-0357d142

~-

--..n CORPORATE NUCLEAR EXPERIENCE i

~

(ie, "0FF-SITE" MANAGEMENT)

(Indicate Whether BWR or PWR)

(On-Site)

(Off-Site)

Years at Other Nuclear Operator Lic Years at Nuc. Support /

Degrees Navy (if ever held) Operating Nuclear Management Level Position Name (years)

-RO/SRO/None Stations Position (A/B/K/D)

Executive Engr Nuclear Activities i

Plant Department DABixel SRO 7

16 BS (PWR & BWR)

Director Nuclear BSNE/

Licensing DJVandewalle 10 MSNE Director Quality Assurance IDEsch BSEE/

Nuclear Operations 16 MBA (FSAR pl3A.1-40)

Director Plant Projects

.JCLewis RO/SRO 5-BWR 4

BSEE (FSAR pl3A.1-8) 12-PWR Director Nuclear Operations Training Department WLBeckmen 5

1-PWR 7-PWR BSchem Director Nuclear Planning DWJoos 2

5 BS/MS (BWR & PWR) miO384-0357d142

~. -

P DN-SITE MANAGEENT Fill in Table (Use Appropriate Titles)

Operations Plant Maintenance QA Sept.

Sept.

Supt.

Supt.

(Operations (Assistant Plant Technical.

(Maintenance (QA/QC Supervisor)

Plant Mar)

Manager Supt.

Manager)

Manager)

To have license at time of OL Yes Yes**

No No No No Previously Licensed 30/SR0 SRO RO No No No No Type Plant FtEt-CE Test Reactor Number Years 2

3 Number Years "Not" Exp

-0 3

Degreed Yes*

Yes Yes*

Yes Yes*

Yes

-Type (Discipline (s))

E CE ENG TECE CNENISTRY ELEC ENG, ELEC ENG, E CH ENG ETALtRGICAL ELEC ENG TECM BUSINESS BUSINESS ENG t

Level (A/B/N/D)

BSET/

BSchen BSEE/

BSEE/

BSEE/

BSiff MSEET MBA HBA HSEE Registered Professional Engineer - State of Michigan SRO desired but not required r

I.

miO384-0357d142 L

2

~.

-~.

ON-SITE MANAGDENT Fill in Table (Use Appropriate Titles)

Shift Shift Shift Shift Shift Shift Engineer Engineer Engineer Engineer Engineer Engineer (STA)

(STA)

(STA)

(STA)

(STA)

(STA)

To have license at time of OL Yes Yes Yes Yes (Vacant)

(Vacant)

Previouly Licensed N0/S80 No no No No Type Plant Number Years Number Years "Not" Exp Negreed Yes Yes Yes Yes Type (Discipline (s))

NUCLEAR NUCLEAR IECMANICAL NETALLIRIGAL ENGUEER ENGIIEER ENGINEER ENGINEER level (A/3/N/D)

BSIE BSIE BSIE BSMET STA - Staff Technical Adviser miO384-9357d142

~

u

l List of Abbreviations 35

- Bachelor of Science N5 Chem - Bachelor of Science in Chemistry BSEE - Bachelor of Science in Electrical Engineering BSEIE - Bachelor of Science in Engineering, Nechanical Engineering BSIE - Bachelor of Science in Industrial Engineering BSIE - Bachelor of science in Mechanical Engineering BEIET - Bachelor of Science in Netallergical Engineering BSIE - Bachelor of Science in Buclear Engineering BESE - Bachelor of Science in Science Engineering ISA

- Master of Basiness Administration M - Master of Public Bealth in Nealth Physics MS

- Nester of Science NSENS - leaster of Science in Eavireemental Realth Sciences IEEEIE - Nester of Science la Engineering, Nechanical Engiacering IESIE - Nester of Science in Baclear Engineering MP

- Big Beck Feist (CFCo BR Baclear Plant)

PAL

- Palisades (CFCe Fl4 IInclear Plant) l I

i

' - - " ~

~~ -'

" ~ '

^

w 5

s.-

x s

\\

L

r s

s e

E 0

{

_8 3,

a g g

<c

=

e.

g g

g

. g j I I,

g J

=

g g

=

I

_g g

=

g gg

_3

=

2 a

~

P_

M C

I c

t.

e n

e

=..'

i

=

a

~

l -lI 1 1 3 1

e e

1-s s

a I l'j s 1 =] 1 l j i

] l j I I" '!

-g nr.sB a!!!)

l1-g_

aaa=

= = e x = =.. = =.

_=

c N

la, ' g -l R. R. .' m. =. =.

3 8:

R. C.

3,8 R

4 a

ll

-i t

c.

I c

g

~

8 3

j i

s j

i M.i !. g' g

a a

j:

l 3 1.1, = 1 sag;y;5 E s

1 g-y-

t

,t

.st.:a-l n

,.l1,i:leslr a

n y

E J.,

! l

.s l

12

.j3:j-s3g-c

i

-1 s

e e -l.<) k.

= s,

l'3.j. j i. i i st 1 r g _:y33 g

1:

Ij 1

-s.,3 4 I 'l i l l1 885F'3..j8j:=))]-- l I jj i i Ilgg l I s;; aaese. a e eegas ~ s E i A A l \\" A -\\ i +

I T : = i il=l 2r L2 g =ili s 8

  • = _:
  • 3
  • I a

i=g : ea5- .-lz==*8-g 8 1 i ,i ~3 3 3 "a :l.. =I: 5==3 2 = 4 L 5 A $4a1 3 5 4 A a ti l I x1 l ! W i j = * = = = = a = = s a = = = = = , 3e .i s = = 5 = = g = g ;. d g = = = = g g j ~ a = 2 g 1-g = = = gg d. =. l gg s = y , 3 g g = = I s3 = = E = a r g a = = i4 = = = 11 g' lI = 3_ = .s 8

====8 2 i 2 i: 4 is 11}}Eil'iii 1IJ l is 5e nf 3 0 3353J l1 AIf aaaaa

===s==-==-

==e _i, = a Ej la gg" sa =. a =.

a. =.

a: =. m. a. =. =. =. a 9, 5 5 c{ II g 1 y c I=:s c g g M. m _= 3-eee 5 B Ia: 13- .l a j a 813!r=l!=z l e t 5 j "e j I a 3I jatii};; E c g: a n jj !,i jj }ce"jjjj-! ji g g l g !!jaj, y 5 ' 2 isimyg g~Ig! i n= c 4 a s : I E 3:38 ,1_3EEE_!!=!!.!2 f.i rj s 1 i- )j)j:I ~ 5 8 n ~ " 1! 1 1

y l =l a

s JajijIsil$*E}1_ji il!! t 2 ^,! 3~, 8 i l g i 1== llsi q s = 2 =- a 'a'Ja e a aJiii ii i 3 1

mi--

--mme--in-- e eum ---m

g e o o o y. e e 3 o o e o e g 2 .. o o 3 o o a o g 3 o. o o o. R l 5 . o. e e, e o . e p.. e o e j = 4 g

g_

o _ s I I g g o = = o o o : s g 2 A g a o a o j 2 a d e o y 3 J a: ~ ' I. .. g o a g g g 3 y IR = G e e e e y a o e o y y o e o o e IA 4 d g = e o o ~ a E ~ a n g a 9 o a, ,t e. z = ,= 11 = = = i e s. h$$ hh$ M u se a E I~ !!! ! J 1III))IJI] }}} In 5 1 ama n x

.= = = =.

= = - =.= e EE I _~ 8se gg g. ;s e.

s. :.

sa

e. a. a. e. n. :.

13 jg J-I E 1 I 1 m c 3 .i 8 1 --j l see t d 33 1_* 3 i = l 5j}Jgg!=g "g l Ia l8*i } si i " l } j" =$ ,1 2 5-s i 3- -I 3' 383 a 3 - i ~l g ) { 4 v.! r_: a j:]j=e.3 i 3 e e y _i l ' g 5g-l1r}}G}2.IgJ}!3 5jI E - j s: ) l.iig i 11111 i 8-18*3yjjji]ll2j8*i 1 l 8 a i i- = llg: aaa ; a a a ..a 4 3 3 l t I t .I' ~

\\ g.... p. . e . +, y... a \\ g. . = ;... 4 i I e e . e .. a h 4 d gg-s I I

g

= i g g A i d 4 4 c q g s i! 3 l:1 4 i 3 II A E g = o 45 4 i g a E ~ n g t i g .. e e g y a 3 a ,3 = = i ll .t a a2 22 2 222 l' !!! ! 1 1 1111 1 111 = I I maa a z

: es==-: :-

==e ~yl 8 9 8. q aq

s. 3 qz: qqq s-l 1

E 1 5 i !=EE ~I i331!g!! g 3 j 833!': l881:r}j$ l Ia g-a s g s, 1 [l ja#}. a an.i a[g 1 '3 5 1 8 : 3 r es i 3 .Ej =g

l:

I5U irk!.: 8 3 .ilj i r -l l a =3 y j j j _1 2i-,31]}}ja l [ 83 .i j a s.- a I n a llg:i g aar;a a ..e g a 3 s, e I 1 k -l ?

} g o e o o g e o e o e e o e o o o g 4 3 g l =. 3 o o = 3 o o o 3 g e [ M 7 g g o o e e g o o o g 3 g o e o o g y ; e o g s g g e o e o y g o e o = 3 e e o e o Ig e o o e g a o a g e o o o o g II J d ~ Cm gg 3 o o e e g g e o = g e o e o o g ~ I, e e e g g = = e o a o g e 3 o e a e = e o e o o i s a a a = o o o e o = g : = o e o a = = b lg 23^23 233 3 [E I" }}} g ]}}}}122}2} }}} 31 I}} nf H E aaaaa = gex==*==-

==e t u 8 -8

e. ;s =.
a. n.

aa

a. a. =. n. =.

gg ig g g .s 1E 1 1 I 1 ~ 522 5 5 l Isa1]g!! g 8 8 3 1 I r r. I a 3-jt*11}ig E I s a 3 [- n a. 1:.ia1 f 3 s 3 lscig a l i 1 a i n, 2-l 1 - _i ! mi a1

  1. ; :: I E

3; v.e.. s n =g-l: sjja l.3 :rf83:r -i 1 E E E.is e 1 1 88!!=i;jgjijj}&j3 l ~ ' Igg i }j]!I i -, ii: -i i t( e 4 .I

e 4 6 9 e o o o 9 o e 1 a 6 r s o o o e 9 s t e t t a 4 9 i o o o o o P f o o 1 a a 6 o o o o e t t t t s e 4 ase g a o e o e 5 r s o a 5 s o o o o o s t e - a 6-t t ( ll t e-e t a d e' t o a I i e o e o e o o L a t 6 e s o E o s u 3 t t s r t t ) d t' o s M t ee 1 e o o o e 9 o e t a a 6 o s o o e 9 1 t 5 g C 0 a t t t a e f s 3 4 e R s 6 e e o o s s o 5 a s 4 e t e o o 1 I 3 t' t 9 s 3 S 3 f t g W e O 8 e o o e e 6 5 o E s s o s o I o s ON t s s' s / s' S t ( M s g Z 1 o o a o e o a L a a 6 o 9 o o e s 3 aK t t t t 6 0 e* r 1 2 0 1 6 s 9 ) B 9 e o o e 9 4 o t 4 s .a 1 T t-s o o o 1 o s T 3I 1 e t gG s 1* t 9 2W s e o e e 4 o t a a s o o o o o s 1 5 sD t t o e w ef t' r3 o i lE II 9 o o o o s 3 a o t a s s o o o o o s t t t 4 t tu s' t a t d 8 e e e e 9 a e t a s 9 e o e o o E Es t t s' e J 9* d 9 s o I 9 s o I o I o s t a o e o e s t M e t t S ( s* e i t t t t 1 e o e e o a e E a 4 6 e e e a o o e a R 9 v i t t 1 u 3p s / o 3 s t d

)

t 1 ( ( ( ( / e 3 s e m a o m e o m o o o e e e ( ( t 1 2 i a a s g g g g e g g g g g g g 3 0 I s s s t a a es a i a i i is s1 3 0 s8 eee a n s s m e u e e s ww i i l g 1 6 s s s s e m e e e1 3 4 ec s e s s s e s s s s g g e 31 G3 i1i i s s s e es s s s ia a ie e is eD e 9 1 s e t e n i 30 1: 3 s s e e 9 a a s e I 3 6 I a a a 2 9 eun s 5 t t ) t t 1 t t t 1 ) p8 y ) ) ) g 2 ) g4 MN t aN 1 o ssc s o s o o s e e s s s gS 2 I ot o-t s t o-g- t s s i t t o i 8 3 nD DV t t s g u a 4 y t tt t gS ( yu t 3 a e 3 d ( r go e e s t 3 e 0 l e 4 d so J u ) e so u s ) - s a ( ( e m a 1 us e s 4 t f s p u a a g e e a o e s E s s s s s t s a a e P N + m a e a a 8 e s o s E m s n s e s s s e l t e 3 s o l v s e s s t g* a E e e s e m ( a e n e e e B 4d a s s d s d d s s e e s e e e e y I m s e s s a s t ct t i i mo e a m s a e ( S s oue o n d ( a J s e s S' ( e s s i el s s s' e d A a e e e g m e r o d a = 8 m = at a t se t e s a J 9 e a m o s s e o s u = s e s e

  • s t

n 6 e e m sms em i s i t s % %

  • e e s o

( o m e a 1 1 s d a sr n e t t e u d o 9 s g o s a s a a v e ws as me a' t e 0 a e ( s w e a6 d e e 1 s a s a u 2 m i e' s ( e e. t n e t m a a s 0 g l s1 I e s s s l g g a s t s e e e e a e e I emo mt s t i ( a e e d t g e e e s g g l s R e g M de d e s s p e nt w II aeli d 4nd s e a P e e s ) e e m s G g' g ws e s

  • s s s a e g

a t a

  • a o s n

s a g s s e g a ) a e a a u V n t e s e e s s s e s 3 3 s z e o e s e t t es e i a s a e s e 1 W emms m* t gS soe o s s s 1 d e s g E e a' S i es e ) ) m ) ) z ) ) 3 s gs d a t s t 9 I e S s ) ) 3 W nt a e i e 3 e n e e 0 m Et E e ENt W R T: 1 8 p E43o g 9' S 1 3 t C 4 e s e t t W-t t t w ~ s p e c a es r e au g w -g w r ,. m I-4

1 j g 3 g g g = a = 7 4 4 a 2 3 ; = = = 0 4 g I ! g 2 = = = 2 2 32 j e 2 4 4 I g g 3 g ;g g 1= = = 4 g' "g _I n e g ;. g = = = gg = 3 = s g ;3 = = g -G I 3 = = s o g,s = E = n = 3 2 3 , t2 t R i d i = x = = = = + =

: s 8

--=* =e n g l$ i E 3 22 422 328 1I1))REE22 J))

s: 2 5

E I.E =3 3 3 3 1 111}J II is aaaaa

ex

==-

==e E a _s

=. s =.

. =. as =. a. n. =. =. =. Ig gg g g i -I i E I E .) I g i ?EE I } l 13: 1 1 8 j 83IIg=g Il g a i j E e j: 3g l * *,i x } i l I a n = g _e Il 1 n. a l a _3 l- -e-1 --t-t _3 l =r 1a s 3 IJ: g l [ 3 E c: $a$2I. ~ r53}3!=g~a. ' b I y *I _I a! l 5 c E i 1 s.1 3 -) i' E I E .: s l=3* l 1 s n a I ,1 IIIII'sE 2 3 *3" 3 1 l 2=.] l'I 8 ~ $ *g l 35) a 4 m

  • I2 l

]~3 I~- I E ~!~ lllij ~ g: aaaaa a a .agge g e p 1 ... - ~ k v I

l 1 .... g.. -. = g o.. .. g I ... e = =... d i =.... a = g o.. .. g i . = g... j i t d 2 g 3 * *

  • i i

g g m g g e... . a g g.. .. g I jl 4 S E = - = . a a g... ] = A J 3 l l . = . = :... a e i =g . = =... gi e i 3 . : =... Ha J g n-gg o g . =,... i . = . = ; y n .. g E i i E . = . = q g g g c {Il 3 ys=-8 822 1))32f!28! 22! [E !i s!!!1 I311111 lll uf 15 aaaan = = e s _= = - = = - = _= e ,,l3 v# 828 gg g"g a. a :. R. :. ,8,8 R. R. R. =. =. =. I e i 1 1 fi c g I ~ eee5 5 Ess1]g!! g 8 i j 831!r: aa g l2245L25 r_a. _-s s y [- 18 a1A A. _- 3 m t _3 8 r I g l g a_ 1 es! ~l:l } $ 2 Il. I c a ~ I E E i=g_ _jsltrlj'!!: ~ 9 1 h 53 5.l'i a. y i _ll =. 3 :rlil m! .: s ~ - r n I 1 a !ja L.f l i s Isis!a 1_sesjI i i i ! a 1 l si i g i Eh$2 .'ad24 4 a esiis l i 1 ~ -.... OA 4 w + r

I t 8 i E t ~ 6 i s 1 - l" 5-o o o o e e a o o o. g g o o g e g k- ~j g o o o o g o o a o = 7 e o o o o - h1 4 i j*i = o o - ,.. o o o, i i g

o o o.

. e o - o =,. o., [ 4 I E g g o e o - g o o o o o g E 4 5 5 g o o o o o c s a o g g o o o o o g 3 i a2 E tit 32.2E.... E 225at o .E t^t" S jE le af Il sisil illfililli il aaaan agezag== =ge t li H o g" 8 8: R. :. 88 2 2 2. :. 2. :. g.;. gg lE = = = lI l 1 r I 5 5 =22 3: 213 8 ..~ 5 :P F. ~~15_2~ o a :-

    • is il S t 2

a. s sa I Et 1 1-- g a zz- ~..less_g 13 . g a as. z 3 l e _y 1.: = s c :1 I 1"3 a OI r 2" 8 i a

s. 3g 3

1 3 3..t} ' :I. 3 i 3 l4 i it!.jse 8 I ilsi a sa 3 szs E g Io aaaaa a a saidi l i .i

l

.1 -.~ =

9 ... o g. c a = = o 0.. o. o g a ........ = = g... .. g i ae ..... =. a = =.... o. g ...... a g a.... a. = W .g g. . a g g.... .. g .v.i . a = =. g.. g y g g . a g a .. g I E a . = . a = =.... l . a = = g... g y. d g e . a = =.... gg . a = =..... h a . = . a g g... a g i s 2 a . a g g. e. e .. g e a e a . = . a = =. e.. s e i g e g 5 2 O ta %^ 1 mI S.I f3*III..* 283 g. 3:2 2 i is sj siss"a 111111111'1 111 EI E AAAAA

  • 2=.=*

4 4 3 8 82 g. 8.. 22 88 C. R. R. C. C. :. y g gg ~ a r t = E c g a g

e-!

i z e sms11 8 -1 E 813 ! ~r:1 ! =i I ~- a 4 gy ( =1aza;125 B z 3 '- 32,-g A}1~

-- uzig g

l y i:1. 1 5 I y : y 1,a l 1 2- :el 1 g-gl_=rjj35 mi-11gfjgs!- a I E 3 I o-3d" 2 4 G j }5 j =m. 3 a r ts g e . :}3gi ,,s Isl2I.jaeEI rz I. g I m 8[g-E a. s- -1 2 lb$'l s ses g iis l ) o1 s. .,.e v

i 2I= Eri E h E i 1 - 5u gg g. o g = = e e.. .. g g2

  • j g.

3. . a g g.... .. g Na Egg 3. . a g g.... g = . a = =.... t 2 g. . a g g.... .. g t E . e . a = =.... .. e g n s e n [ R S . =. ? Il

====s sesss-s.. 2 ss2 ss lE I-inink lilllllill ill I uf Ic aaaam

ex

==-

==e v 8 gl" 8:

. 8.
.

R.. 88 E. R. R.. :.. .g El5 i' II 1 I g 1 .l mee..I 1. a 8-- i Ehair:y!=i l c ".,o Ia y- [22 I

i111$

s l n g [- d n E::a1 a. I 3 a l.18y : g 1 l -e- _1 -Ir.] .a cca -Ig.s_ 18 e g 5 E s=I: l:yE a:=: r e s s: E

= =- 2 a I j = I _r - = a 3 c 1 a s. 1 1 s.Eijj! .as-3 Isisa!!]!e3: 8li i it k-- a* I e a llsi$3 n e, a i isidi i i h 4' .i l

i i i 5 3 . e e. . - e... .. + 1 l f l n ' d i \\ 1-s..v g g g i -.j e, g 2 i J n g g a g e = 2 i lI J d

  • '3 gg 3

= = .a I = [ 4 5 ~ g = 2 2 a e a = g = g i e it s2:si:111111 s e e ! s.. se

=

s EE I~- e IIi1 1ll nf I I !!!!1 aaaaa

cz

==- = =e Wl";a e. ;s =.

a. n.

aa

e. a. a. n. =. =.

a l g s [ 1 1I 1 E c g t g - e. e J i i a21 1 3 833Ir ! =i I 1 ) : H I a 3-l22ii i$ E I 3 3 l[- t = 2 -I =a-a. E 3 I I F 2 g .g l }cz*I.cj=g: 8 a3 1 3 g aI f c 2 I: s-gey a1

= = m r s )*E*=I: 3 Ieet I 1 a a.2 sasy: : 2 41 a a #w IE 2 3 28*23 3 = 252 --j-3-2 g El I aK g 8 8 = - a l hy JJJJJ J 4 JJfyf g i l 4 4

d l l 1j 2 e g g g o g = I l = = I !j g = = CN 3- = = sg a i = = .i a = g g ,g = = I ~ = E i n g = = g g i e v a = .I = = e i E lg 23^ll312222 ill 233 3 I" !!!!g 11 111111 a is I I I aaaaa = = c a =.= - a : =.:'e 83 I8

es=
a. n.

a =. m. a. =. =. =. gg g 4 Ig i 1 lE 1 E c g g 122 5 j ia 1}g!! g 8 i 813Jy i3 j 1"**ial}yly. 1 E I a I-B

l_aa_3([

a n l.J. ",

E 3

s 52 l I }j I j 8 s s-sc jij~Ei1s!iyjjjll:el!!! 5j3 lilII8:ags} f g ~~ S i a 1 a i- ~! i 11111 883'*i .s))}}*ji l !l ' I E gll: aaasa e e ...: 4 3 3 l i i t i l i i i i L

INSIRUCTIONS FOR M USE OF M NUCLEAR POWER PIAhT EXPERIINCE FACIORS OPEPATING SHIFT POSITIONS (OL APPLICAhTS). 1. Comercial Plant SRO/RD - See Tvoe Plant mis experience factor is applicable when the individual was assigned to . licensed operator duties at a counercial nuclear power plant of the see type as the one for which the operating license is sought. 2. Cmmercial Plant SRO/RO - Not Fran the See Tvoe Plant nis experience factor is applicable when the individual was assigned to licensed operator duties at a cannercial nuclear power plant which is not of the see type as the one for which the operating license is sought. 3. Military Nuclear operatino 6 2ience mis experience factor is eWele when the individual was assigned in - l 1 the positions as listed at a military nuciear pcner plant. Position Weightino Factor RO, Bes, 20CW, PPHS 0.5 i other 0.25 i me maximun canbined credit given to any individual for this experience is 36 months. i t i i i i. l ~i l l i .I

s

l 4. n:11 Scoce Nuclear Power Plant Simulator his exparience factor is applicable for the actual time spent in the simulator control rom in a structured training progre. When a plant reference simulator is used in the training progre, the 5.0 weighting 4 factor is used with a maximum credit of 12 months. When a similar simulator is used in the training progre, the 3.0 weighting factor is used with a maxima credit of 9 months. If both a plant reference simulator and a similar simulator are used _ in the training program, the. ~ weighting factors are applied as indicated above but the cabined total maximun credit may not ecceed 12 months. 5. Nuclear Power Plant Experience on Shift at Own Plant mis experience factor is applicable when the individual is actually assigned on-shift operating duties at his own plant. S e weighting factors are applied as indicated for the periods in question and the cabined -4== credit for both may not exceed 24 months. 6. License Classrom Training and Examination at Own Plant 21s experience factor is applicable when an individual successfully l l participates in a license training program including an examination for e I r the position for which the license is being sought. 21s experiere is applicable to the classrom portions for the license training program as the simulator and on-the-job training is addressed in one of the other experience factors. So weighting factor and==ri== credit is applied as indicated. i i . 4 i i ij L . 2 L .qe,, .m -,,_.-,.,_.,. gyp,,,%7-.---..,,upg9y9. p--.,g, 79,- --y9 se w _ -.-y .p..- 9

7. Particication in Ooerational Duties at an Ooeratine Ccr=ercial Nuclear Power Plant tis experience factor is applicable when an individual has participated in operational duties. In determining participation for this experience factor, either direct hands-on operation or as direct participation in review and discussions leading to decisions relative to operating a nuclear power plant can be used. Personnel assigned as equipnent or auxiliary operators would realize experience under this category and could ? f be assigned a maxima of 12 months experience credit. 8. Other Nuclear Power Plant Experience his experience factor is applicable when the individual has performed his job duties related to design, construction, operation, startup testing, maintenance or preoperational testing of any nuclear power plant. We weighting factor and maxima credit shoind be applied as indicated. 9. Conductirs License Training his experience factor is applicable for those individuals who provide training in license training programs. nis experience is applicable for individuals who provide this training on-site or at any other facility. he weighting factor and maxima credit should be applied as indicated. 3 k ~ l l l ~ 1 .,., - +,. -,.. +, -., - * -,....... - -. -__m... _ _

\\

10. Decree Encineerine or Atelied science) 21s experience factor is applicable for cernpletion of degree rm.uirments

. and credit for aquivalent college work. For Bachelors and Associate degrees, credit may be assigned as indicated. Experience credit for college work toward a degree may be assigned at the rate of one (1) month-t experience credit for each ten (10) seester hours college credit earned. His experience credit may only be assigned for the technical subjects in the engineering or applied science degree progres. The maxistrn credit that may be assigned to this experience factor is 12 months. 2 I f i l j r-}}

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20091F273&oldid=4336998"