ML20106E383

Forwards C Brandt Affidavit & Original Nonconformance Rept Document Package.Certificate of Svc Encl

ML20106E383
Person / Time
Site:	Comanche Peak
Issue date:	10/26/1984
From:	Watkins M BISHOP, COOK, PURCELL & REYNOLDS, TEXAS UTILITIES ELECTRIC CO. (TU ELECTRIC)
To:	Bloch P, Grossman H, Jordan W Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
References
CON-#484-756 OLA-2, NUDOCS 8410290198
Download: ML20106E383 (10)

Text

- - -

DONETE?

U%RC law Orrlcts or BISHOP, LIBERMAN, COOK, PURCELL & REYNgDt0T 26 A11 :58 8200 SEVENTEENTH STREET, N.W. IN NEW YORK WA S H I N G TO N, D.C. 2 C O 3 6 elSMOP, LIBERMAN & COOK (202)857-9800 ,d,

.d l I'l r !- -

115 5 AVENU E O F TH E AM ERICAS t- m u '!-

sgw yong,ugw yong goose TELEX 440574 INTLAW UI *

(212)704-Oi00 TELEX 222767 WRITER'S OtRECT OI AL (202)

October 26, 1984 Peter B. Bloch, Esq. Dr. Walter H. Jordan Atomic Safety and Licensing 881 West Outer Drive Board Oak Ridge, TN 37830 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Herbert Grossman, Esq. .

Atomic Safety and Licensing Board

. U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C: 20555 Re: et al.

Texas (Comanche Utilities PeakElectric Steam Company, Electric Stat ion 7 Units 1 and 2), Docket Nos. 50-445-2, 50-446-2 Gentlemen:

-In his testimony in this proceeding on September 19, 1984, Cory; Allen identified an NCR that he wrote regarding reactor core-cavity coatings. The Board admitted the NCR package (tr. 17044-47) into evidence (tr. 17,052).

During Mr. Allen's examination regarding the NCR, the Board Chairman suggested that one of the draft NCR's may have been altered by erasures on the signature and date entries under

" disposition" (tr. 17059).. The Chairman accordingly requested that Applicants supply the originals of the NCR documents.

~We enclose the affidavit of C. Thomas Brandt, to which is

-attached the original NCR document package from the Permanent Plant Record Vault. Mr. Brandt will be available for cross-examination, if any, regarding these documents at his next appearance in this proceeding.

8410290198 841026 PDR ADOCK 05000445 1 0 PDR

e A copy of this letter and Mr. Brandt's affidavit are being served on all parties, albeit, for obvious reasons, without the original NCR package. For ease of identification, the ~

parties are being served with copies of the NCR package.

Respectfully submitted, McNeill Watkins II

, Counsel for Applicants cc: Service List t

I i

i

, . . . _ _ _ , , _ . , . ~ . _ . . _ _ . _ . , ..

D UNITED STATES OF AMERICA

1. !$$D '

NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD *g 00[ 26 All:5g In the Matter of: ) . ; h ';;-

) =n A r'- c' , t Docket Nos. 0 4 -2 and TEXAS UTILITIES ELECTRIC )

COMPANY, _e t _a l . )

(Application for (Comanche Peak Steam Electric )

Operating Licenses)

Station, Units 1 and 2) )

AFFIDAVIT OF C. THOMAS BRANDT My name is C. Thomas Brandt. I have testified several times in this proceeding.

Attached to this affidavit is the original NCR package for NCR C-83-00461 which~ includes: (1) a hand-written draft by Cory Allen, dated February 11, 1983; (2) the typed version of that draft, dated February 11, 1983; (3) Revision 1 dated February 15, 1983; (4) a telex to J.B. George from R.E.

Ballard dated March 10, 1983; and (5) the NCR showing disposition of Rev. 1. This is the entire NCR package that previously has been filed in the Permanen Plant Rec ds I

vault.

.5772 ee rer+3 C. Thomas Brandt V

. coewry an .S<wewee<. < .

Subscribed and sworn to before me this JP.rd day of October, 1984.

.Me9 Notary Public dw6

.n'f c'ennetste~ exwa&i suca 28, /98/.

'. . Tgx1S UTILITIES ^ ^ b^

CENERANING CO. NONCONFORMANCE REPORT (NCR) C-83-00461, R. 1 UNIT STRUCTURE / SYSTEM ITEM / COMPONENT TAG /ID NUMBER LOCATION OR ELEVATION RIR NO.

1&2 r Containment r Core N/A 783'-7" to 834'-0" N/A NONCONFORMING CONDITION X1 Test Control "A test program shall be establi6ed to assure that all testing required to demonstrate that structures, systems, and components will perform

_a satisfactorily in service is identified and performed in accordance with written E test procedures which incorporate the requirements and acceptance limits contained g in applicable design documents. ... test results shall be documented and evaluated g to assure that test requirements have been satisfied."

w A

Coatings applied on concrete and steel surfaces located in the reactor core cavity

@ and extending up the core wall, Elev. 834'-0", have not been proven to perform

- satisfactorily to the combined 40-year dosages of gamma and neutron radiation.

cc o

n.

E No hold tag applied. Work may continue in affected area.

REFERENCE DOCUMENT. 10CFR50. Anoendix B REV PARA REPORTED BY: DATE:

[ Cory A'121Fn/C. T. Brandt (Rev. 1) 2 / 11/ 83 V F DA l OE REVIEW /AP -

O ACTION ADDREM / // DEPARTMENT J. /Bf."eorge/Kissinger

/ Engineering DISPOSITION:

REWORK REPAIR USE AS IS XYY SCRAP See attached.

\

g Qh g COED a c5* , .

a ARMS <*- "yb.5 g INDEXED TT6" 5 'o .

< DATE:

EN R /IEW/ APPROVAL DATE:

D

\f ff // >

3/b/

w b/

, DISPOSITION VERIFICATIO'N&V RE: D i -- , ,ri COMMENTSR.1 issued to add to (fie disp 0S ~t1 .

,1 # ,. ,,,

.. .- .-u',-

&$ ,' L

,[ j)

IUCCO GHSE f k /

,j{

4P.9759 GHNY UI .

VSG ED394

/AnCH 10, 1983 TUSI SI TE  ;

Tk X NO. 9108908660 *5

.. p CTT-9572 K I S S ING E R/ F. . kELLS

.1 9 CEORGT/M.R.M.CPAY/R.F. -

TO RE ACTOR CAL ITY COATING sun g G IPBS AND HILL RESPONSE .

NCR C-83-00461, FEPR:JARY 11, 1961 y TEST PROGRAM HAS NOT DEEN THIS NCR ESSENTI ALLY IN STATES THAT ATHE REACTOR CORE CAVITY.

ESI APLISHEC F0F. COATINGS q .,

SERVE NO SAFEGUARD F UNCTION.Oh TO THEY ARE .'

CO AT ING S IN THIS AREA *[2 .

NOT NECESSARY TO PHOTECT SAFETY-HELATED EQUIPMENT, SINCE THE .a '

ITS SAFEGUARD FUNCTION.

.ATMOSPHERE ASSIST-[N IT CARRYING 00 TIS MAINTAINEDSURFACES IN THIS AREA DRY ANDb!LL ATNOT LESS THAN SOC RY AN HVAC- SYSTEM, CORROSION OF CARBON STEEL PE PERCEPTIPLE. THE CONCRETE NEEDS NO PROTECTION.

CONCERN HAS BEEN EXPRESSED THAT- THE SAFETY FAILED INJECTION C0ATINGS k ILL INTEHFERE k ITH POST-ACCIDENT OPERATION OF kHICH UUTILIZE P).

4 ATER SYSTEMS AND THE CONTAINMENT' SPRAY SYSTEF,ORAkING -

SUCH CONCERNS FORM THE .DASIS FOR COATING TESTS FOR OTHERIN SUCH OTHER LOCAT IONS IN THE CONTAINMENT; HOW EVER, SUCH CONCERNS DO THE RADIATION DOSE IS SIGNIFICANTLY L0kER. SINCE THE REACTOR NOT EXIST IN THE REACTOR CORE CAVITY LOCATION,IN DIRECT COMM CORE CAVITY IS NCT SUMP. IN CASE OF A LOCA, kATER KILL FL0k INTO, NOT GUT OF, THE REACTOR CORE CAVITY.

PLEASE ADV ISE.

IF YOU HAVE ANY F'JRTHER QUESTIONS, R. E. PALLARD/M. CHIRUVOLU/K. FALK GIPPSHILL, V.Y.

4297A9 GHNY UI TUGC0 GRSE 4297 69 - CHNY UI

s .... .

p.ra sg

j. ..

.- COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION

p A$NTruT

ES

., GENERATING CO. NONCONFORMANCE REPORT (NCR) C-83-00461, R. 1 0 00u' lk1 UNIT STRUCTURE / SYSTEM ITEM / COMPONENT ~ TAG /fD NUMSER LOC /?'0H OR ELEVATJON RIR NO.O Reactor Containment Reactor Core 1&2 Building Cavity N/A 783'-1" to 834'-0" N/A NONCONFORMING CONDITION

. X1 Test Control . "A test program shall be established to assure that all testing required to demonstrate that structures, systems, and components will perform J satisfactorily in service is identified and performed in ,.tecordance with written I test procedures which incorporate the requirements and acceptance limits contained Jg in applicable design documents.

. to. assure that test requirements have been satisfied."

. . . test results shall be documented and evaluated

. (E Q-Coatings applied on concrete and steel surfaces located in the reactor core cavity

@ ' and extending up the core wall, Elev. 834'-0", have not been proven to perform

- satisfactorily to the combined 40-year dosages of gamma and neutron radiation.

p c:

O

. a. - i-

$ No hold tag applied. Work may continue in affected crea.

REFERENCE DOCUMENT. 10CFR50. Anoendie B REV PARA ,

REPORTED BY: OATE:

s

[ 1 -

Cory A122n/C. T. Brandt (Rev. 1) 7/

2 / 11/ 83 OE REVIEW /AP V F -

DA O ACTION ADDREW / // DEPARTMENT g J . ,/3f.' eorge/Kissinger

/ ,

Engineering 1 A

DISPCSITION:

REWORK y' REPAIR

\\ SE A IS SCRAP li!

2 E

.O O

SW A GC O

~

. O P

O 4:

/ ,

A/ A ~

/

I / 7 - r w ~ // 1 - / 2 ll g

, C OISPOSITION VERIFICATION & CLOSURE: ' '

DATE:

COMMENTS:

t

__. . - . - _ , _ _ _ _ . . _ _ _ . . . _ . , . - _ , ,m_,, .

i. .

- COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION TEN UTILITIES " "*

'[EN. ERA [lN3 CO. NONCONFORMANCE REPORT (NCR)

. C-83-00461 UNIT STRUCTURE / SYSTEM ITEM / COMPONENT TAG /ID NUMBER LOCATION OR ELEVATION' RIR NO.

Reactor Contaihment Reactor Core 1&2 Building a C'vity N/A 783'-7" to 834'-0" N/A NONCONFORMING CONDITION X1 Test Control "A test program shall be established to assure that all testing required to demonstrate that structures, systems, and components will perform gj satisfactorily in service is identified and performed in accordance with written z test procedures which incorporate the requirements and acceptance limits contained o in applicable design documents. ... test results shall be documented and evaluated to

@ assure that test requirements have been satisfied."

E g Coatings applied on concrete and steel surfaces located in the reactor core cavity z and extending up the core wall, Elev. 834'-0" have not been proven to perform satis-

{O factorily to the combined 40-year dosages of gamma and neutron radiation.

w C

REFERENCE DOCUMENT, 1 CFR50, Appendix B REV PARA REPORTED BY: DATE:

/ y orgAllen 2 f 11, 83 I I s //- f DT l OE REVIEW /APPRO AL:

O ACTION ADDRESSEE I / hc , , . . . DEPARTMENT .

o. u.,

7 u;;;,.a;;i.p. Engineering DISPOSITION:

REWORK REPAIR USE AS IS SCRAP W

W W

W O

O z

9 H

0 ENG. REVIEW / APPROVAL DATE:

I /

CE REVIEW APPROVAL: DATE:

w

/ /

DISPOSITION VERIFICATION & CLOSURE: DATE:

C l / /

COMMENTS:

COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION

'iE AS UTILITIES NCR N1 CENERATING CO. NONCONFORMANCE REPORT (NCR) e-83cc%l UNIT STRUCTURE / SYSTEM ITEM / COMPONENT TAG /l0 NUMBER LOCATION OR ELEVATION Ri1 O.

1 & 2. c NiNhEEN T-Gou O#NG g

e M rrY 78 7 " m 8345 o' b NONCONFORMING CONDITION y TEgy poq7RgL.

A TEST PROGRAM JH Au GE ESTAGL!SHED '70 A550RE ~P.AT ALL TESTING REGylREO TO DEMcHSTRATE THAT sTeotroRes, JYSTeMs, AN0 comPariENTs witL PER'FbRM g SATISTAC. TOE)LY IN dERNICE IS #DENmF#EO AND PERFORMEQ lN ACCORCANCE 8

"' WITH MRI o EN TEST PRocE00REs WRtc.H INCORPORATE THE REQ 0iREM g AND ~ A CccPTANCE L.imiTS cos7Aig ED ig App'ICAOLE DESl%N DOC 01YLEgrS,

• *

• TEST RESOt_TS , SHAT L BE Coco MENTE g ,qq Q gygggg9 y g Ass 0RE e THAT TEST iREQOtREMENTS M ANE BEEN dATlS AEd " .

O g d oATING S APPL 1EO oN CONC.RFTE ANO JTEEL SoRFACES Lo cA nEO fH THE REACTOR CORE cay (TY AND EXTENOIN6, 09 'O-)E C_O r4E V/A LL, IEL. 854'O'* HAVE NOT GEEN PROVEN To PERFORM sATSFAC.TORit_Y To wE Com GlN ED 40 - YEAR Dca sE.s or y AM f4 A ANO NEUTRON RACIAm cN.

REFERENCE DOCUMENT. 10 CFR 60; APPENOtY R REV PARA REPORTED BY: DATE:

/I OM $LM

- //

2. f l l f g3 gl , /

O ACTION A%DMlfSSEI DEPARTMENT DISPOSITION:

REWORK REPAllt USE AS IS SCRAP b

8 e

Q Z

9 E

ENG. REVIEW / APPROVAL DATE:

/ /

OE REVIEW APPROVAL: DATE:

uJ / /

O DISPOSITION VERIFICATION & CLOSURE: DATE:

/ /

COMMENTS:

J

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of )

)

TEXAS UTILITIES ELECTRIC ) Docket Nos. 50-445-2 and COMPANY, et al. ) 50-446-2

)

(Comanche Peak Steam Electric ) (Application for Station, Units 1 and 2) ) Operating Licenses)

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that copies of the foregoing document in the above-captioned matter was served upon the following persons

'by deposit in the United States mail, first class, postage prepaid, this 26th day of October, 1984:

• Peter B. Bloch, Esq. *** Chairman, Atomic Safety and Chairman, Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Panel Licensing Board U. S. Nuclear Regulatory U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Washington, D.C. 20555

• Mr. William L. Clements

• • Dr. Walter H. Jordan Docketing & Services Branch 881 West Outer Drive U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Oak Ridge, Tennessee 37830 Commission Washington, D.C. 20555

• Herbert Grossman, Esq.

U. S. Nuclear Regulatory *Stuart A. Treby, Esq.

Commission Office of the Executive Washington, D.C. 20555 Legal Director U. S. Nuclear Regulatory

• • • Mr. John Collins Commission Regional Administrator 773 5 Old Georgetown Road Region IV Room 10117 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Bethesda, MD 20814 Commission 611 Ryan Plaza Drive *** Chairman, Atomic Safety and Suite 1000 Licensing Board Panel Arlington, Texas 76011 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555

• • • Renea Hicks,-Esq.

• Anthony Z. Roisman, Esq.

Assistant Attorney General Executive Director Environmental Protection Trial Lawyers for Public Justice Division 2000 P. Street, N.W.

P.O. Box 12548 Suite 600 Capitol Station Washington, D. C. 20036 Austin, Texas 78711

• Ellen Ginsberg, Esq.

• • • Juanita Ellis Atomic Safety and Licensing President Board Panel CASE U. S. Nuclear Regulatory 1426 S. Polk Street Commission Dallas, TX 75224 Washington, D. C. 20555 McNeill Watkins II cc: Homer C. Schmidt John W.-Beck Robert Wooldridge, Esq.

- - - - - - - - - , , - , , , - - -,,,-m-,-- -- m ----e , --,,<,---m c---- ,