ML20107J274
| ML20107J274 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Comanche Peak  |
| Issue date: | 11/07/1984 |
| From: | Gallo J GALLO, J., OLIVER B. CANNON & SON, INC. |
| To: | Bloch P, Grossman H, Jordan W Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| References | |
| CON-#484-054, CON-#484-54 OL-2, NUDOCS 8411090476 | |
| Download: ML20107J274 (52) | |
Text
_eM:
..r ISHAM, LINCOLN & BEALE RELATED CORRESPONMO COUNSELORS AT LAW Ch .[U Um THREE FIRST NATIONAL PLAZA CHICAGO, ILUNOIS 60002 g g ?,8 2 1 = = ""TuS*E f IU! -9 A10 :54 *^
,,,, con 7laS'g=0.
c N.,
WILUAM G. 8EALE. 1885 1923 SUITE 840 WASHINGTON. O.C. 20036
(. ,.L'.'...
s 00MN 4 ne <
- 3h AND1 November 7, 1984 Peter B. Bloch, Usquire Herbert Grossman, Esquire Chairman, Atomic Safety and Alternate Chairman Licensing Board Atomic Safety and Licensing U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Board Commission U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Washington, D.C. 20555 Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Dr. Walter H. Jordan Administrative Judge t 881 West Outer Drive Oak Ridge, Tennessee 37830 Re: In the Matter of Texas Otilities Electric Company, et al. (Comanche Peak Steam Electric StatTo E Units 1 and 2)
Docket Nos. 50-445-2 and 50-446-2 Gentlemen:
The testimony of 0.B. Cannon & Son, Inc., i.e.,
Messrs. Roth, Trallo, Norris and Lipinsky was filed on November 5, 1984 by mail from Philadelphia. Attachments A.
through D. to Mr. Norris' testimony were inadvertently, omitted from the mailing. Copies of the Cannon Testimony l that were hand-delivered yesterday to the Licensing Board and counsel for the Intervenors, Applicants and NRC Staff included the attachments to Mr. Norris' testimony.
i I
8411090476 841107 PDR ADOCK 05000
. c. -.
November 7, 1984-Page.2 The' purpose of this letter is to provide the Norris' attachments to the other persons on the service list. I apologize for any' inconvenience.
Sincerely, JwA Gsa/tv Joseph Gallo Counse'l to Oliver B.
Cannon & Son, Inc. e JG:sv cc: Peter Bloch w/o encl.
Herbert Grossman Walter Jordan Stuart Treby Anthony Roisman "
Nicholas Reynolds McNeill Watkins Ellen Ginsberg The balance of service list with enclosures I
I I
(
1 i
'[/P ** ] TEXM QILITIES GENERATi.,G ($1F. r PAGE } OF 5
- DATE 8-1-83 SHIP TO TEXAS UTILITIES GENERATING COMPANY, ATTN: BROWN & ROOT INC. ATTACHMENT A c/o COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION PURCHASE ORDER FM 701_ r,IFN ROSF_ TEYAS 76043 ORIGINAL
(4.TO
,' TEXAS UTILITIES GENERATING COMPANY ;. NOTIFICATION CONFIRMATIOZ P.O. BOX 1002, GLEN ROSE. TEXAS 76043 * -
5"'**
'..X e.O.e.
SHIPPING POINT 1"'.*':".".?a . . '".".*.':::. N/A PREPAY AND ADD SHIPMENT PROMISED BY TERMS REQ.NO. ACCOUNT NO.
N/A NET 30 DAYS R 21928 3-2-9230-940000-108 CPF 16245 I 7 T OLIVER B. CANNON & SON, INC. g,,. g ..m,.g y ,..; g g....,
, o 9001 AIRPORT BLVD. .-
u v..-. ... .... ... ....
~ ~ ' ' " " " " * "
- l_ SUITE 801 _j HOUSTON, TEXAS 77061 REASE RENDER INVOICES IN DUPLICATE THE TERMS AND CCNDITCNS SET OUT ON THE BACK HEREOF AND ANY ATTACHMENTS HERETO ARE A PART OF THIS ORDER AND ITEM OUANTITY ET U/1 DESCRIPTION TOTA 1.
NO. % ANTED UNIT PRICE ITEM PRICE THIS PURCHASE ORDER IS ESTABLISHED WITH OLIVER B. CANNON AND SON, INC. FOR THE PURPOSE OF ANALYZING THE PROTECTIVE C0ATING PROGRAM AT
~
THE CPSES JOBSITE. THIS WILL BE ACCOMPLISHED l BY TWO PHASES OF WORK.
PHASE I - SCOPE OLIVER B. CANNON AND SON INC. WILL SEND A TEAM 0F TWO TO THREE INDIVIDUALS (CORPORATE LEVEL .
MANAGEMENT PERSONNEL) TO THE J0BSITE BEGINNING JULY 19, 1983 FOR A DURATION OF APPR0XIMATELY THREE (3) WEEKS TO DO A GENERAL SURVEY AND GET '
A GENERAL FEEL FOR OUR PROTECTIVE C0ATING PROGRAM.
OLIVER B. CANNON AND SON INC. WILL ORGANIZE THEIR ANALYSIS INTO THE FOLLOWING CATEGORIES:
PRODUCTION - WORK PROCEDURES - SCHEDULING -
TRAINING & PAINTER QUALIFICATION - QUALITY CONTROL-MANAGEMENT OF C0ATING EFFORT - SPECIFICATIONS THE ABOVE SERVICES SHALL BE IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE FOLLOWING:
E!'e."i/s7'r".'s5"u',"la*'ii iuifhS!.".**oI't.T.Sie itT'o$ tbNSer'.'Pu '
by Statute. Authorized Signature r g es to "cr e a dYa t tax o eC p e of bee 'ts as e's
, 0F E i L . TECHNICAL SERVICES (PMG) TEXAS UTILITIES GENERATING COMPANY IP 'R J. YOUNGBLOOD/1r ~- l(a171897-4881 EXT 347
.. lSITIO N E R J. YOUNGBLO0D l1817) 897 4881 EXT 347 8y ,4
[ hRCHASING AGENT VENDOR'S COPY BRJ 1170
._- .,__a . _ _m -
~
? =r*;*2",
TEXQTILulES gel. tATINGsjoMPANY Pact j CF' g l P.O. N Q PURCH ASE ORDER CONTINUATION SHEEV w ,
_pF 167AE k u
U/I DESCRIFTION %. h CE I CE FEE SCHEDULE OLIVER B. CANNON AND SON, INC. SHALL INVOICE j TUGC0 FOR THEIR SERVICES IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE FOLLOWING SCHEDULE.
- A. MANAGEMENT PERSONNEL $500.00/ DAY (CORPORATELEVEL)
- 8. LINE PERSONNEL 400.00/ DAY (WORKING LEVEL CRAFT)
C. TECHNICAL PERSONNEL
- 1. SITE 350.00/ DAY
- 2. 0FFICE 250.00/ DAY D. CLERICAL PERSONNEL COST E. TO A,B,C, & D AB0VE ADD -
16% FOR OVERHEAD F. TEST EQUIPMENT PER OBC LIST XIII (IF NECESSARY)
EXPENSES SHALL BE INVOICED AT ACTUAL COST TO OLIVER B. CANNON AND SON, INC. AND SHALL COMPLY WITH COMANCHE PEAK TRAVEL POLICY AS FOLLOWS:
- 1. MEALS - ACTUAL COST BUT NOT TO EXCEED TWENTY-FIVE (25) D0LLARS PER DAY..
- 2. RENT CAR - RENTAL CAR SHALL BE A FORD FAIRMONT, CHEVROLET MALIBU, OR NOVA,0R AND EQUIVALENT SIZED CAR.
IF ONE OF THE AB0VE MENTIONED CARS IS NOT AVAILABLE, A SMALLER CAR SHALL BE USED. IF ONLY A -
LARGER CAR IS AVAILABLE IT SHALL BE S0 NOTED ON THE RENTAL RECEIP".
- 3. FLIGHT ARRANGEMENTS - AIR TRAVEL SHALL BE BY ECONOMY CLASS ONLY.
s
- 4. ENTERTAINMENT - NOT REIMBURSABLE EXPENSES.
- 5. MOTEL /H0TEL - ACCOMMODATIONS SHALL BE IN i
GRANBURY, GLEN ROSE, OR
' ClFRURNF ONLY.
ALL TERMS AND CONDITIONS SHOWN ON THE FA EAN EVERSE OF THE SIGNED SHEET OF THIS ORDER ARE EFFECTIVE COVERING VENDOR
- COPY l
TEXAQUTILITIES GENERATINMI)AIPANY cAir 3 eF 5 P.O. NQ PURCHASE ORDER CONTINUATION SHf;
[ 'CPF 16245
~Ig %g N U/I - DESCRIPTION , . ,_
~
IP - #
UN G I PROPER DOCUMENTATION AND RECEIPTS SHALL ACCOMPANY ALL INVOICES.
(ie: TIME SHEETS, AIR FARE RECEIPT, AND MOTEL RECEIPT)
THE AB0VE RATES ARE FIRM AND NOT SUBJECT TO ESCALATION.
OLIVER B. CANNON AND SON, INC. IS REQUIRED TO REFERENCE PURCHASE ORDER NUMBER ON ALL INVOICES AND CORRESPONDENCE PERTAINING TO THIS PURCHASE ORDER.
FIXED FEE TUGC0 SHALL PAY OLIVER B. CANNON AND SON, INC.
A FIXED FEE OF $63,000.00. THIS FIXED FEE IS -
OVER AND AB0VE THE DAILY RATE STRUCTURE OUTLINE IN THIS PURCHASE ORDER. FIXED FEE IS PAYABLE TO OLIVER B. CANNON ON SEPTEMBER 15, 1983. IF WORK IS CONTIHUED PAST SEPTEMBER 15, 1983 A NEW -
FIXED FEE WILL BE NEGOTIATED.
PERSONNEL QUALIFICATIONS .
OLIVER B. CANNON.AND SON.INC. SHALL FURNISH QUALIFICATION DATA AND RESUMES FOR THE C PERSONNEL ASSIGNED TO WORK UNDER THE SCOPE OF THIS PURCHASE ORDER.
THE ESTIMATED PURCHASE AMOUNT OF PHASE I 0F THIS PURCHASE ORDER IS NOT TO EXCEED $100,000.00 UNLESS AUTHORIZED BY WRITTEN SUPPLEMENT.
PHASE II '
THE SCOPE OF PHASE II IS DEFINED AS A COMPRE-HENSIVE STUDY OF THE PROTECTIVE C0ATINGS PROGRAF WITH ASSOCIATED RECOMMENDATIONS AND OBSERVATIONS .
IF THIS SCOPE OF WORK IS REQUIRED IT WILL BE ADDED BY A SUPPLEMENT TO THIS PURCHASE ORDER.
TERMS AND CONDITIONS TERMS AND CONDITIONS ON THE REVERSE SIDE OF THI5-PURCHASE ORDER DO NOT APPLY. FOR TERMS AND CONDITIONS REFER TO ATTACHMENT NO. 2.
INSURANCE REQUIREMENTS BEFORE WORK CAN COMMENCE, SELLER MUST FURNISH TO BUYER COMPLETED CERTIFICATE OF INSURANCE, FORM N0. 4500-0008, ATTACHED, SIGNED BY AUTHORIZED REPRESENTATIVE OF INSURANCE COMPANIES AFFORDING C0VERAGE.
ALL TERMS AND CONDITION 5 5HOWN ON THE F ACE AND REVERSE OF HE SIGNED SHEET OF THIS ORDER ARE EFFECTIVE COVERING VENDOR' COPY 541,.m r r:e - __ - . s %. - ~.::, : _ , .- . m -.m , - - _ . - - . ~
, [ *
- TERMS AND CUNDITCNS ,
- 1. INTERPRETATION 4. PATENTS - --
In case of any confilet or inconsistency between those Supplementary The Seller warrants that it will have title to sit Equioment furnished--
Terms and Condetions, the Purchase Order or Contract to whsch they are (A* t;ttached and the Spec!fications Drawings and other docussients,ifhereunder any, theand the right to sell such Equipment. The Seller shatt, at its own .
expense, defend any suit or proceedsng brought against the Purchaser ao I
\
~ Ourchase Order or Contract, and the Specifications. Drawings and other far sa said suit or proceeding is based on a claim that any Equipment or documents, if any, shall prevail over these Supplementary Terms and any part thereof, orany use thereof in the ressenable contemplation of the Condelions.
parties at the time of its purchase, fumished under this Order constitutes Att provisions hereof, in tavar of the Purchaser, which constitute *
- an infrtngement of any Umted States patent,if notified promptly in writing acceptance of responsibility by the Seller, waive:s of roeponeebli8ty of the and given authonty,information and assistance (at the Seller's expensel for Purchaser, indemnification of the Purchaser and agreements to defend or the defense of same, and the Seller shall pay all damages are costs sive harmless the Purchaser, shalt likewise inure to the benefit of Agent awarded thereen against the Puchaser. In case the Equipment or any part andfor Engineer.
- ' thereof or any use thereof in the reasonable contemplation of the parties at Whenever used in this Order, any supplements hereto, or related the t6me of its purchase is in such suit heid to constitute infringement and correspondence-its use in enjomed, the Seller shell, promptly and at Gs own expense, either:
- 1. " OWNER"- Dallas Power & Light Company, Texas Electric 1) procure for the Purchaser the right to continue using said Equipment; or Service Company and Texas Power & Light Company. 2) replace same with noninfringing Equipment satisfactory to ths ;
- 2. " PURCHASER"-Texas utilities Generating Company which Purchaser; or 3) modify the Equipmerit, en a way satisfactory to the !
has been engaged by the Owner as its Purchaser and Operator (whenever it shall t,erve in such a capacity in relation to the Purchaser so it becomes noninfringing. The foregoing states the entire J liability of the Seller for patent infringement by said Equipment or any part Ownert or use thereof.
- 3. " AGENT"- Texas Utshties Services Inc., which has .boen .
engaged by Purchaser'as its Agent (whenever it shall serve in 9. GUARANTEE. . ..
Such capacity in relation to the Purchase 4 The Seller warrants to the Purchaser that all Eouipment furnished
- 4. " ENGINEER"-Texas Utilities Services inc, wh6ch has been under this Order shall be free from defects either in design, matertal or engaged by the Purchaser to act as its design engineer and shall workmanship and shall be suited in all respects both for the purposes for have authority to prepara drawings and specifications, make which it is specified hereunder to be sold and for all other uses for which it inquines for purchases, review Seller's design, and inspect and may be represented in writing by the Seller to be suited. The Seller also espedite factory production and such other authority as Owner warrants to the Purchaser the successful operation of all such Equipment.
or Purchaser may delegate to it. The Seller shall be required to correct any defects which may appear in S. " SELLER" or " CONTRACTOR" shall mean the party providing . such Equipment within one year from the date it is first put into service 6 Equipment pursuant to this Order.
such service to hogen within a reasonable time after the dullvery of such
- 6. "ORDEP" shall mean, collectively, the Purchase Order to which - -
Equipment. Except to the extent hereinafter in this paragraph otherwise these Supplementary Terms and Conditions are attaches, these provided, the Setter's liability under this Article shall in no case (except as Supplementary Terms and Conditions, Specifications and to implied warranty of title) exceed the cost of ropeering, or of supplying a Drawings, and all other documents, if any, attached to such . replacement for, any defective parts or matonale. If the Equipment Purchase Order.
- 7. " PRICE" shall mean the amount paid by the Purchaser to the fumeshed under this Order is installed by the Seller and any defect or defects in design, material or workmanship appears within the period of Seller in consideration of the provision of the Equipment.
- 8. " EQUIPMENT" shall mean all of the matenals, apparatus, time in tnis paragraph above set forth, then, in addition to repairin0, or furnishing a replacement for, any defective parte or materials, the Seller structures and related services provided pursuant to this Order, shall negotiate with the Purchaser as to the extent of the additional burden
- 9. " WORK" shail mean all of the supplies, equipment engineenng, or responsibility, if any, that Seller shall assume in completely and design, workmanship, labor and any other services or thing satisfactory correcting any such defect or defects.
i fumished or used by the Seller in providing the Equipment. The warranties irr this Article contained assumes that the Equipenent
- 2. SUPPLEMENTS fumished under this Order, if not installed by the Seller, is property Installed, and that such Equipment is properly used and maintained.
- Any revisions and amendments to the Order shall be effected by a Supplement to the Order, which supplement shall be furnished to the Seller 10. DELAY ~ 7 in writing.
In the event of any delay due to causes beyond the Seller's reasonable
- 3. PROVISION FOR CANCELLATION control, such as acts of God, acts of the Purchaser, acts of civil or military At any time after the acceptance of this Order the Purchaser shall have authority, priorities, fires, strikes, tioods, epidemics, quarantine the absolute nght to cancel the entire Order upon the payment to the Seller restnctions, war, riot, delays in transportation, car shortages, and inablinty for all disbursements and expenses which the Seller has incurred or due to causes beyond its reasonable control to obtain necessary labor become obilgated for prior to date of notice of. cancellation, less the motertals, or manuf acturing f acilities, the date of delivery shall be extended r3tsonable resale value of equipment which shall have been obtained or for a period equal to the time lost by reason of the delay, ordered to become an integral part of the Equipment plus a sum as profit 11. ASSIGNMENT be: ring the same ratio to the profit that the Seller would have received upon completing the Work as the Work done bears to the entire amount of Work Without the written consent of.tne Purchaser being first obtained the t3 be done by the Seller under this Order- Seller shall not assign this Order, or any part thereof, and any such con'sent shall not relieve the Seller from full responsibility and liability for trae due
- 4. FACTORY INSPECTION AND TESTS performance of all of the terms and conditions hereof. In the event that such The purchaser shall have the right to inspect any Equipment, consent Is given, the Seller shall remain fully responsible to the Purchasy workrnanshep, labor and any other thing furr'aeed cr used by the Seller for acts and omissions of the Seller's assignee and the Seiter shalt save the under this Order. Purchaser harmless from any and alliots and expense caused thersby.
~
- 5. OPERATING & MAINTENANCE INSTRUCTIONS 12. NO OTHER UNDERSTANDINGS Thirty (30) copies of Operating & Maintenance Instructions, to There are no other understandings between the parties other than as adequately define the Equipment fumished, shall be provided prior to set forth in the Order. All commun6 cations, either verbal or wntten,inade shipment, each bound in a separate folder and each clearly identified with prior to the date of this Order are hereby abrogated and withdrawn.
th3 project and the Order. Data sheets shall be included for each item of Equipment and ali standard bulletins or hterature shall define the specific 13. OSH A components furnished if mote than one model or type are described in the Seller represents and warrants that all articles and services covered by ssme document this Purchase Order meet or exceed the safety standard established arid promulgated under the Federal Occupational Safety and Health La's
- 6. ROUTING (Public Law 91-957) and its regulations in effect or proposed as of the date The Purchaser shall specify the carriers and routing to be used ,
of this Order. -- - -
providing the carrier (s) or routing specified does not increase the Seller's 14. E EO C coct; however the Seller shall not modify the Purchaser's instructions in this respect without prior approval by the Purchaser. The Seller agrees to Seller agrees to comply with alt applicable Federal and State laws and furnish the Purchaser careful estimates of not and gross weights, expected regulations forbidding discrimination against employees because of race, shipping points and shipping classifications. color, religion, national origin, sex, age, or physical or mental condition, or otherwise pertaining to employers and employment practices. The seven
, 7. DRAWINGS numbered subparagraphs of Section 202 of Subpart B of Executive Order i
r The rev.ew of the Seller's drawings by the Purchaser or comments of No.11246 are incorporated herein by reference and are binding upon the Seller, h3 Pur chaser thereon, as contemplated by the Order, shalt not relieve the k* Jstist from entire responsibahty for correctness of engineering design.
workrr anship, matenal and all other reatters or for any other liability hersunder. While the Seller agrees to follow any and all comments on dram,ngs rnade by the Purchaser, in so far as such comments are sccSplable to the Seller, this shall not relieve or release the Seller from sntire responsibility, unless otherwise agreed in wnling.
~_ _ _-
TE14$JTII_. .IES GENERATIN@MPANY ^]
pAaE 4 Or 5 .
P.Q NQ PURCHASE ORDER CONTINUATION SHEE' r ,
L .PF 16245 ,
8@ 0$T37 g ^ U/1 DESCR1FI1ON
-b'i [- Y- , UN CE ITE CE SELLER IS TO MAINTAIN AT HIS OWN EXPENSE, WITH SUBROGATION WAIVED AGAINST BUYER AND THE PRINCIPAL ON WHOSE WORK BUYER IS ENGAGED, THROUGHOUT THE DURATION OF THE AB0VE SERVICES' A MINIMUM INSURANCE AS FOLLOWS:
A. STATUTORY WORKMEN'S COMPENSATION.
B. COMPREHENSIVE GENERAL LIABILITY -
BODILY INJURY - $300,000.00 EACH OCCURRENCE PROPERTY DAMAGE - $100,000.00 .
EACH OCCURRENCE
$100,000.00 AGGREGATE C. COMPREHENSIVE AUTOMOBILE LIABILITY .
BODILY INJURY. - $100,000.00 EACH PERSON
- $300,000.00
(~ PROPERTY DAMAGE EACH OCCURRENCE
- $ 50,000.00 EACH OCCURRENCE D. EMPLOYER LIABILITY - $100,000.00 E. EXCESS LIABILITY - $1,000,000.00 COMBINED SINGLE LIMIT i SELLER SHALL FURNISH CERTIFICATE OF THE FORE-GOING INSURANCE TO BUYER, PROVIDING THIRTY (30) DAYS NOTICE BY REGISTERED MAIL TO BUYER l AS TO CANCELLATION OR MATERIAL CHANGES.
l MAIL CERTIFICATION T0:
TEXAS UTILITIES GENERATING COMPAN'Y P. O. B0X 1002 GLEN ROSE, TEXAS 76043 l
ATTN: EXPEDITING DEPARTMENT
( 4LL T ERMS AND CONDITION 5 5HOWN ON THE F ACE AN REVERSE OF HE SIGNED SHEET OF THIS ORDER ARE EFFECTIVE COVERING 1
VENDOR
- COPY
7" """ .-
TEXA@JTILITIES GENERATINGUOMPANY "rAaE 5 OF 5 P.Q NQ 9 PURCHASE ORDER CONTINUATION SHED
["CPF16245 k.iEM QUAh a s t f yg
- DESCRIPTION '
"" " NET TOTAL NOL WANTED .
.- , UNIT PRICE ITEM PRICE ATTACHMENTS ATTACHMENT NO. 1 - OLIVER B. CANNON & SON INC.'S CURRENT SCHEDULE OF.
REIMBURSABLE EQUIFMENT DATED JANUARY 1, 1983, LIST XIII .
ATTACHMENT NO. 2 - STANDARD TERMS & CONDITIONS
- REV. 0 ATTACHMENT NO. 3 - TUGC0 CERTIFICATE OF INSURANCE
, FORM 4500-0008 4
euo 9
m a
b s
9 k
( ~LL TERMS AND CONOtTIONS SHOWN THE ABOVEON ITEMSTHE FACE AND AS THOUGH REPEATEDREVERSEHEREON. OF THE SIGNED SHCET OF THIS VENDOR
- COPY
' ' ' ^ -
M R=. r = = : n ,. - w -:" v -_.__2m_-_---- - - . P *m ~ - - - , m m-, -~ .
l , . .
O- PA 10F 8 AT HMENT NO. 2 REY. 0 PURCHASE ORDER CPF 16245, ,
DATED: 8/1/83 LO
,e .
ATTACHMENT .. . '.J ; -
STANDARDS, TERMS AND C NDITIONS INTRODUCTION These Terms and Conditions define the relations and responsibilities of the va.rious parties involved in the purchase and supply of the services being specified. .
CONTRACT DOCUMENTS In case o'f any conflict or inconsistency between these Terms and
, Conditions, the Purchase Order or Contract'to which they are attached and the Specifications, Drawings and other documents, .if any, relating to the Purchase Order or Contract, Speci,fications, Drawings and other documents, if any, shall '
prevail over these Terms and Conditions.'
, All provisions hereof in favor of the Purchaser, or which constitute acceptance of responsibility by the Seller, or waivers of responsibility of the -
Purchaser, or agreements of indemnification of the Purchaser or to defend or y" save harmless the Purchaser shall likewise inure to the benefit of the Agent and/or Engineer.
DEFINITIONS ,
Whenever they appear in these Tems and Conditions, the Specifications or the Purchase Order, the terms listed will be used in the sense and shall have the meaning set forth below.
'0wner': Those parties named as Owners in the Joint Ownership Agreement for the Comanche Peak-Steam Electric Station, dated January 2,1979, as amended.
' Purchaser': Texas Utilities Generating Company which has been
, engaged by the.0wner as its Purchaser and Operator (whenever it shall serve in such a capacity in relation to the Owner).
' Agent': Texas Utilities Services Inc., which has been engaged by Purchaser as its Agent (whenever it shall serve in such capacity in relation to the Purchaser).
' Engineer': Texas Utilities Services, Inc. which has been engaged by the Agent to act as its design engineer and shall have authority to prepare drawings and specifications, review Seller's design and inspect
, and expedite factory production and such other authority as Owner or Purchaser may delegate to it.
. __________ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ____.___ ____._.__ _ _ ______a
O9
" ' ' ' (^'T P82 0F 8 -
ATlTCHMENT NO. 2 REV. 0 PURCHASE ORDER CPF 16245, DATED: 8/1/83-y .
C
'. : .p .
.n . - ,
' Seller', The party providing Services pursuant to this
' Vendor' or order.
' Contractor':
' Constructor' Brown & Root, Inc. which has been engaged by the Agent to construct the Plant.
' Order': The Purchase Order or Contrac't to which these Terms and Conditions are attached, these Terms and Conditions, and any Specifications and Drawings, and all other documents, if any, attached to or specifically made a part of such Purchase Order or Contract and any amendments or supplements thereto.
~
' Price': The contract price set forth in the Contract or '
Purchase Order whenever these Terms and Conditions are attached to or incorporated in a Contract or Purchase Order, and otherwise shall mean the amount paid by the Purchaser to the Seller in consideration -
for-the provision of the Services.
' Work': All of the testing procedures, engineering, design, workmanship, labor and any other services furnished-
/ or used.
~
TAXES All present or future Federal, State, Municipal or other lawful taxes applicable by reason of the sale or delivery of the Services purchased hereunder shall be for the Purchaser's account at cost, except that any tax imposed directly against the Seller shall be for the Seller's account.
TEXAS STATE SALES /USE TAX Texas Limitad Sales, Excise and Use Tax DIRECT PAYMENT EXEMPTION CERTIFICATE -
Permit Number 3-00007-5163-3 The services described herein are purchased under the above Direct Payment Permit, and Texas Utilities Generating Company Inc., will pay any such tax imposed therein direct to the State of Texas.
Texas Sales /Use Tax does not apply to charges for Transportation (except for Orders placed F0B Destination), Erection and/or Service Engineer.
Therefore, if such charges are included in the'0rder Price, these charges must be shown as separate items on the invoice.
l l k.
-Q P! 3 0F 8 AT CHMENT NO. 2 REV. 0 PURCHASE ORDER CPF 16245, DATED: 8/1/83
. a. ,
TERMINATION Either party upon fifteen (15) days prior written notice may terminate any purchase order issued under this Agreement and such termination can be either
. for convenience of TUGC0 or for the default of SELLER. In the event of any such termination, SELLER shall be paid reasonab.e and proper termination charges including any and all sums then due an payable hereunder plus the expen.ses associated with the termination, including any additional expense incurred by reason of termination of SELLER'S agreements with its subcontractors.and suppliers, and allocated in contemplation of purchase agreement performance. Upon such termination, all completed work and work in progress, prepared at the site and by SELLER specifically for TUGC0 in performing this Agreement shall become the property of TUGCO. Such materials shall be delivered to TUGC0 at time of te~rmination.
INSURANCE AND INDEMNITY A. SELLER will furnish proof of insurance on Texas Utilities Generating Company Form 4500-0008 which will meet the prescribed limits as set forth on this form. Insurance coverage must be kept current -
through the life of this Agreement. Such coverages shall contain pro-visions that no cancellation or material changes in the policies shall become effective except on fifteen (15) days advance written notice thereof to the office of TUGCO.
- 1. Site Insurance
- a. If TUGC0 Procures property damage insurance applicable to occurrences at the site and third party non-nuclear liability insurance, or either of such types of insurance, such insurance will either name SELLER and its sub-contractors and suppliers of any tier, as additional insureds or provide that they will be protected as their interest may appear.
- b. TUGC0 will, at his own cost, prior to the arrival of nuclear fuel at the site, secure and thereafter maintain in force, with respect to the project, protection against liability arising out of, or resulting from a nuclear incident (as defined in the Atomic Energy Act of 1954, as amended) as follows:
(1) Liability insurance from the Nuclear Energy Liability
,. Property Insurance Association (NEL-PIA) and/or the Mutual Atomic Energy Liability Underwriters (MAELU),
or equivalent insurance, in such amount and such form as will meet the financial protection requirements of the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) pursuant l to Subsection 170 (b) of the Atomic Energy Act of 1954, i as amended. This insurance will include the interest
! (~ of TUGC0 and any other person or organization that may l
have legal responsibility for damage caused by the nuclear energy hazard.
. (d~) PA 4 0F 8 AT CHMENT N0. 2 REV. 0 PURCHASE ORDER CPF 16245, DATED: 8/1/83 DL' j
(2) A Government Indemnity Agreement with the NRC pursuant to Subsection 170 (c) of the Atomic Energy- Act of 1954, as amended.
TUGC0 shall continue to provide such insurance and indemnity against the foregoing risks with coverage in
, such amount and form as may be required by the Nuclear Regulatory Commission; provided, however, that if the nuclear liability protection system in effect on the date of this Agreement expires or is repealed, changed, or modified, TUGC0 will, without cost to SELLER maintain liability protection through Government Indemnity, limitation of liability, and/or liability insurance which will not result in a material impairment of the protection afforded ,
SELLER, its subcontractors and suppliers, of any tier, by such nuclear liability protection system which is in effect as of the effective date of this Agreement taking into account the availability of insurance, customary practice in the United States electric utility industry for plants of similar size and -
character, and other relevant facters in light of the then existing conditions. In any event, the protection provided pursuant to this provision shall remain in effect until the decommissioning of the nuclear plant.
- 2. Waivers by TUGC0 Neither SELLER nor its subcontractors or suppliers of any tier, shall be liable for loss of, damage to, or loss of use of any property or equipment wherever located, including such loss, damage, or loss of use arising out of or resulting from a " nuclear incident." TUGC0 waives and to the extent permitted by its in-surers will require its insurers to waive all rights of recovery against SELLER, its subcontractors and suppliers of any tier, on account of any such loss, damage, or loss of use.
In addition, TUGC0 waives and will require its insurers to waive all rights of recovery against SELLER, its subcontractors and suppliers, of any tier, for any and all costs or expenses arising out of or in connection with the investigation and settle-ment of claims or the defense of suits for damage resulting from the nuclear energy hazard.
TUGC0 shall obtain for the benefit cf SELLER, its subcon-tractors and suppliers, of any tier, protection against liability for, arising out of, or resulting from damage to any property or equipment located at the plant site which is used or intended for
- use plantby(TUGC0 in connection including but not limitedwith thefuel) to the operation of theisnuclear and which ownedpower y by parties other than TUGCO.
l
(, j$.. h PA 0F 8 AT CHMENT NO. 2 REV. 0
- PURCHASE ORDER CPF 16245,
, ' DATED: 8/1/83 p
x.- -
.. = ,
-INDEPENDENT CONTRACTOR It is understood-and agreed that SELLER. shall be an independent. contractor in the performance of this Agreement and shall not act as an agent or representative of TUGCO.
COMPLIANCE WITH LAWS
- SELLER shall observe and abide by all applicable Federal and State laws
! including but not limited to such rules and regulations of the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, the Office of Federal Contract Compliance, the
- Department of Labor, the Fair Labor Standards Act and the Federal Occupational Safety and Health Law (Public Law-91957) as of the date of this order.
WORK RULE COMPLIANCE SELLER understand and agrees to abide by all established work rules and work periods established by TUGC0.
INDEMNIFICATION SELLER shall indemnify and hold harmless TUGCO, its Agents and employees from and against all damages, losses, and expense arising out of or resulting from the performance of the work, provided that any such damage, loss or expense (a) 1s attributable to bodily injury, sickness, disease or death or to injury to any person or destruction of tangible property belonging to a third party and
, (b) is caused by the sole negligence of SELLER; provided, however, that this indemnification will not apply to any such injuries (including death), damages, or losses which result from a " nuclear incident" as defined in the Atomic Energy Act of 1954, as amended.
, NONASSIGNMENT This Agreement or any Purchase Order issued pursuant to this Agreement will not l be assigned by either party without the prior written consent of the other party, which consent will not be reasonably withheld. Any purported assignment without such prior written consent shall be null and void.
NON-DISCLOSURE TUGC0 and SELLER may have a proprietary interest in certain portions of the information that will be furnished to the other pursuant to this Agreement.
Each party will keep in confidence and will not disclose any such information wh.ich is specifically designated as being proprietary to the other without the
. prior written permission of the other. The provisions of this paragraph shall 1 not apply to information, notwithstanding any confidential designation thereof, which is known to the other party without limitation or restriction at the time i
.- of disclosure, which is or becomes generally available to the public without v breach of the Agreement, or which is received from a third person without L
limitation or restriction at the time of disclosure.
l l
l
- - = - - - - _ - .
..~ a- O d PA 0F 8 ATT HMENT N0. 2 REV. 0 PURCHASE ORDER CPF 16245, DATED: 8/1/83 f.
b -
PATENT INDEMNITY SELLER will defend any suits or proceedings brought against TUGC0 so far as based on any allegation that any service or process furnished hereunder by
, or any part thereof or use thereof, for its intended purpose, constitutes an infringement of any patent, if SELLER is notified promptly in writing und given authority, information and assistance for the defense of such suit or proceeding. SELLER will not be responsible for any settlement of such suit or proceeding made without its written consent. SELLER will pay all damages and ,
costs awarded in any suit or proceeding so defended. In the event any service '
or process which is the subject hereof, or any part or use thereof, for its intended purpose, is determined, as a result of any suit or proceeding, to l constitute an infringement of a patent, or its use is enjnined, SELLER will at its own cost and expense, either: (a) procure for TUGC0 the right to continue using such service or process or part thereof, or (b) replace it with substantially equivalent noninfringing, or (c) modify it so it becomes non-infringing without detracting from its functional capability. This indemnity shall not apply to the extent that any service or process furnished hereunder, or any part thereof, is (a) supplied according to TUGC0's design or - l instructions wherein compliance therewith has caused SELLER to deviate from its normal course of performance, (b) modified by TUGCO, or (c) combined by TUGC0 with items not furnished hereunder and by reason of said design, instruction, modification, or combination or suit or proceeding is brought against TUGCO.
The foregoing states the entire liability of SELLER with respect to patent infringement.
WARRANTIES A. Services SELLER warrants that the recommendations, guidance and performance of its personnel will reflect competent professional knowledge and judgment. In the event any portion of the services supplied hereunder fails to comply with this warranty obligation and SELLER is so notified in writing prior to one (1) year after completion of such portion, SELLER will correctly perform such portion of the services at no additional cost to TUGC0 or, at TUGC0's option, will refund the amount of the compensation paid for such portion.
B. Limitation of Warranties and Remedies The WARRANTIES SET FORTH IN THIS ARTICLE ARE EXCLUSIVE AND ARE IN LIEU 0F ALL OTHER WARRANTIES WHETHER STATUTORY, EXPRESS, OR IMPLIED (INCLUDING ALL WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY AND FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE, AND ALL WARRANTIES ARISING FROM COURSE OF DEALING OR USAGE'0F TRADE). The remedies provided above are TUGC0's sole end exclusive remedies for any l
failure by SELLER to comply with the warranty provisions, whether claims by TUGC0 are based in contract, in tort (including negligence and strict liability), o- otherwise.
- [* . .
A CHM T NO. 2 REV. 0
.. PURCHASE ORDER CPF 16245, DATED: 8/1/83 1 p
. *O .
. FORCE MAJEURE A. . SELLER will not be liable for. failure torp~erform or delay in performance resulting from any cause beyond SELLER's reasonable control or acts of God, acts of civil or military authority,. acts.
,(including delays, failure to act, or priorities) of any governmental l authority or TUGCO, insurrection or riot, sabotage, fire, flood, strikes, '
work stoppage or other labor difficulties, embargoes, car shortages, fuel or energy shortages, wrecks, major equipment breakdown, delays in transportation, or failure or delay beyond its reasonable control in obtaining necessary manufacturigg faciliti,es, labor, or materials, from SELLER's usual sources; provided, however,' that SELLER will notify TUGC0 in writing of any such event within thirty (30) days after SELLER becomes aware of its occurrenc'. e .
B. In the event of a delay in performance due to.such causes, the time of performance of the work will be extended by a period of time reasonably necessary to overcome the effect of the delay. The cost of any special -
measures taken by SELLER at the request of TUGCO to overcome such effect or the cost to SELLER of delays resultin0from
~
any acts by TUGC0 will be for TUGC0's account.
C. Notwithstanding paragraph B, above, if TUGC0 is u'nable to sustain the necessary schedule delay, TUGC0 may terminate any affected Purchase Order upon reasonable prior written notice to SELLER- and payment of reasonable and proper termination charges.
LIMITATION OF LIABILITY Neither SELLER nor its subcontractors and suppliers, of any tier, will be liable to TUGC0 or TUSI whether in contract, in tort (including negligence and strict liability), under any warranty, or otherwise,. for any special, indirect, incidental, or consequential loss or damage, or loss of use of equipment or power system, expenses involving costs of capital, loss of profits or revenues or the loss of use thereof, cost of p'urchased or replacement power (including additional expenses incurred in using existing power facilities), or claims of customers of TUGCO. The REMEDIES set forth herein are exclusive; and the total cumulative liability of SELLER whether in contract, in tort (including negligence and strict liability), under any warranty, or othentise will be limited to the replacement value of the service or the market value of the service furnished under this Agreement on which such liability is based as of the date of. the claim or the expiration of the warranty period applicable to such service, whichever is earlier.
TRANSFER Prior to the transfer to another party of any work product submitted as the
.(- result of any services performed or the transfer of any interest in such work product, TUGC0 shall obtain for SELLER written assurances from the
- /
-PA 'UF 8 ATT HMENT N0. 2 REV. 0 l
PURCHASE ORDER CPF.16245, DATED: 8/1/83 transferee of limitation of and protection against. liability following the proposed transfer at least equivalent to .that afforded SELLER, its j subcontractors and suppliers of any tier, under the provisions of this 4
Agreement. Transfer contrary to the provisions of this Article shall, in addition to any other legal or equitable rights of SELLER, make TUGC0 the indemnitor of SELLER, its subcontractors and suppliers of any tier, against any i liabilities incurred by SELLER, its subcontractors and suppliers of any tier, excess of 'those-that would have been incurred had no such transfer taken place.-
RIGHT TO AUDIT TUGC0 shall have the right to examine and audit the books and records of SELLER at any reasonable time. Such books and records of SELLER will be maintained in accordance with generally accepted principals of accounting and will be adequate to enable determination of; (1) the substantiation and accuracy of any payments required to be made under this agreement; and (2) compliance with the provisions of this agreement. l REVISIONS OR AMENDMENTS 1
Any revisions and amendments to the order shall be effected by a supplement to the order, which supplement shall be furnished in writing. All terms and conditions of the original purchase order remain in effect in full except those P items specifically addressed-in-the supplement.
g V
')
4 4
1 4
l y..
--- , . - - - , - _ . - - - . . _ - , - - _ _ - - _ .-.y -_c,,--.. _, . . . _ - - . _ _ _ , , - - . . - . , _ , _ _ . . _ . . - . - . _ - - - . , . . - _ . . - .
um
~'
jp g P DA g' ASE ORDER CPF 16245
- 8/1/83
' ~
(g c a= .. , - - , OLIVER B. CANNON Q SON. ~INC.-
~\ , IndustrialPainting Specialists *
~
5600 WOODLAND AVENUE PHILADELPHIA. PA 19143 ancA coot t2?n 7as.4eco Twx vio evo-o4ea Coraios w 1
l CURRENT SCHEDULE OF REIMBURSABLE EQUIPMENT i
_ January 1, 1983 LIST XIII C.,_
1 s
1 FOUNDED 1916
c v-Fr'53 .
LISTX],,
,, OLIVER B. C2 DON & SON, {
CURRENT SCHEDULE OF REIEURSABLE EQUIP!ENT CONTRACTOR OWNE0 .
3
.PER , PER . PER
,-DAY . WEEK MONTH l A. AIR SUPPLY EQUIPMENT :
AIR COMPRESSORS
- 1. 15 CFM 19.50 60.25 174.00
- 2. 4,0 CFM '
20.50 69.75 218.00
- 3. 55 CFM 20.50 69.75 218.00
- 4. 85 - CFM 34.25 109.00 315.00
- 5. 100 CFM 36.75 116.00 340.00
- 6. -125 CFM 40.25 130.00 377.00
- 7. 150 CFM 47.00 146.00 425.00
- 8. 185 CFM 64.25 189.00 ,548.00
- 9. 210 CFM 69.75 215.00 633.00
- 10. 250 CFM 82.75 253.00 746.00 ;
- 11. 315 CFM 96.75 307.00 888.00
- 13. 600 CFM 153.00 477.00 1,345.00
- 14. 750 CFM .
182.00 568.00 1,609.00
- 15. 900 CFM 212.00 639.00 1,901.00
- 16. 1050 CFM 244.00 778.00 2,197.00 4
- 17. 1200 CFM 298.00 874.00 2,514.00
- 18. 1500 CFM 300.00 1,040.00 2,900.00
~
- 19. 1600 CFM 302.00 1,043.00 2,952.00
- 20. 2000 CFM 450.00 1,400.00 4,200.00 AIR COMPRESSORS (SILENCED)
- 1. 85 CFM 42.00 120.00 345.00
- 2. 125 CFM 55.25 159.00 459.00
- 3. 250 CFM 97.50 281.00 810.00
- 4. 425 CFM 130.00 393.00 1,192.00
- 5. 600 CFM 165.00 484.00 1,390.00
- 6. 750 CFM '
201.00 596.00 1,738.00
- 7. 1000 CFM 290.00 880.00 2,695.00
- 8. 1200 CFM 315.00 955.00 2,713.00
- 9. 1750 CFM ,
467.00 1,414.00 4,285.00 l AIR SUPPLY ACCESSORIES
- 51. 3/4" X 50' Air Hose 4.40 11.75 28.50
- 52. 1" X 50' Air Hose 5.40 14.50 37.25
- 53. 1-1/2" X 50' Air Hose 10.50 28.75 80.75 54.' Air Manifold 7.25 22.00 66.00
- 55. 2" X 25' Air Hose 8.20 25.75 70.25
- 56. 3" X 25' Air Hose 11.00 33.00 90.00
(
l
,.- ,l OLlyER, u. CRMN & SON,. I LIST CURRENT SCHEDULE OF REIMBURSABLE EQUIPMENT I l
CONTRACTOR OWNED .
p.
( ,. PER PER PER
' b . DAY WEEK MONTH B. POWER TOOLS : .
- 1. Grinders / Sanders 14.50 43.50 132.00
- 2. , Chipping Hammers 13.50 41.00 124.00
- 3. Needle Guns 13.50 41.00 124.00
- 4. Floor Sanders 10.00 30.00 90.00
- 5. Scabbler - Type L-7 84.00 255.00 772.00
- 6. Roto. Peen (Desco Brader) 18.00 54.00 163.50 C. SANDBLAST EQUIPMENT :
BLAST UNITS 5
- 1. 100# Unit Only 24.25 72.25 198.00
- 2. 300# Unit Only 36.75 113.00 324.00
- 3. 600# Unit Only 48.50 145.00 393.00 3a. 900# Unit Only 67.75 205.00 622.00 -
- 4. 5 Ton Bulk Unit Only, Mobile 131.00 397.00 1,203.00
- 5. 6 Ton Bulk Unit Only, Mobile 140.00 425.00 1,287.00
- 6. 7 Ton Bulk Unit Only, Mobile 151.00 458.00 1,388.00
- 7. 22 Ton Bulk Unit Only, Stationary 165.00 500.00 1,516.00 C;' 8. 40 Ton Bulk Unit Only, Stationary 214.00 648.00 1,965.00
- 9. TR 4600 39 Ton Bulk Unit, Mobile 434.00 1,317.00 3,992.00
- 10. TR 4600 39 Ton Bulk Unit, Mobile with VRU 5600 700.00 2,124.00 6,438.00
- 11. Spin Blasting Unit 82.50 250.00 750.00
- 12. Hollow Blasting Unit 31.00 92.00 275.00 BLAST UNIT ACCESSORIES
- 21. Breathing Air Purifier 7.50 22.25 74.00
- 22. 50' Breath Line for Hood 1.60 4.75 14.50
- 23. Air Fed Blast Hood 18.25 47.75 132.00
- 24. Pneumatic Dead Man Control Valve 13.50 41.00 124.00
- 25. 50' Oead Man Hose 1/4" 1.75 5.25 16.00
- 26. Electric Dead Man Control Switch
- 14.00 42.50 129.00
- 27. 50' Electric Cord #214 1.75 5.00 15.25
- 28. 50' Blast Hose 3/4" 8.45 23.50 64.00
- 29. 50' Blast Hose 1-1/4" 1/2" 14.75 77.00 105.00
- 30. Whip (per 10' sections) 5.00 00 34.50
- 31. Moisture Separator 9.00 z/.75 84.00
- 32. Moisture Separator Above 1000 CFM 34.00 102.50 310.50
- 33. Nozzle 12.00* 33.00 89.50
- 34. Air Receiver 26.00 79.00 237.50 k-
ag2 3 3 ..:.'i,B.-CANrC . S34 . LIST X .
~
CURRENT SCHEDULE OF REIMURSABLE EQUIPENT .
CONTRACTOR OWNED .-
t < -
. ". .PER PER . PER
~ DAY WEEK MONTH STORAGE HOPPERS / TRAILERS
' 41. 35 - 40 Ton 101.50 306.00 927.00
- 42. Air Slide . 113.00 342.00- 1,036.00 43.' 4" X 25'Trar.sfer Hose 3.25 9.50- -28.50
- SAN 0' REMOVAL EQUIPMENT
- 50. Copus Mucking Pump '84.00 255.00 774.00
- 51. Sand Hog- 40.00 120.00 360.00
- 52. 2" X 50' Sand Hog Hose 11.75 35.50 107.00
- 53. "3" X 50' Sand Hog Hosa 15.50 42.00 127.50
- 54. 4" X 50' Sand Hog Hose 16.50 50.00 151.50 't
- 55. Auto Dump 71'.25 216.00 654.00
- 0. VACUUM RECOVERY EQUIPMENT :
- 1. Utility Blaster 71.25 216.00 654.00
- 2. Super Utility Blaster 136.00 441.00 1,246.00
- 3. Electric Oust Collector 103.25 313.00 948.00
- 4. 10" Vacuum Recovery Unit 264.00 799.00 2,423.00 C- 5. 15" Vacuum Recovery Unit - 627.00 1,899.00 5,753.00
- 6. 23" Water Vacuum - Electric, 650.00 1,970.00 5,968.00 BLAST UNIT AND RECOVERY EQUIPMENT ACCESSORIES
- 11. 4" X 20' Vacuum Pipe 2.65 8.00 24.00
- 12. 2" Vacuum Hose, per foot 3.95 13, 3" Vacuum Hose, per foot 4.60
- 14. 4" Vacuum Hose, per foot 5.85 E. WATERBLASTING EQUIPMENT :
- 1. Waterblast Unit 7,000 to 10,000 PSI, 274.00 830.00 2,514.00 '
- 2. Waterblast Unit 6,000 PSI 254.00 768.00 2,328.00
- 3. Waterblast Unit 10,000 PSI (2 lances)
! truck mounted - 20 gal. per minute 353.50 1,071.00 3,245.00 1 6. Hydro-clean Unit - 1,000 PS1 48.85 148.00 448.00 f
i WATERBLAST ' ACCESSORIES
) 11. 50' Oischarge Hose ' 15.00 45.25 137.00
- 12. 50' Suction Hose 2.00 6.00 18.50
- 13. Waterblast Gun 9.75 29.50 89.50
- 14. Foot Control Valve 10.50 32.00 97.00 L
-e,- - --, --,,c- - - , , . , - , , - - - -r- -- - - - -- , e , . , - - , . - - - - - , , - - - - - - - - - - - - - , . . . , , , - - - - - , - , , , - - - , - - - , , - -
p P ge 4 '
.,OLIVERB. CANNON & SON,hc .
LIST (,il CURRENT SCIE 00LE OF REIGRSABLE EQUIIMNT -
CONTRACTOR OWNE0 -
b' '
PER PER PER OAY WEEK . MONTH
\
F. STEAM CLEAERS (Chemicals Not Included) :
- l. Steam Cleaner - 100# 34.00 103.50
- 314.00 2., Steam Cleaner - 150# 1 38.50' 116.00 352.00
- 11. Steam Hose (per 25' Sections) 2.50 7.50 23.00
- 12. .
Steam Gun 1.00 3.00 8.75 G. CONVENTIONAL SPRAY EQUIPMENT :
CONVENTIONAL SPRAY UNITS
- 1. 2 Gallon Tank Unit Only 14.00 42.00 126.50
- 2. 5 Gallon Tank Unit Only 18.50 55.50 168.00
- 3. 10 Gallon Tank Unit Only .
23.00 69.50 210.00 t
- 4. 2 Gallon Agitated Tank Unit Only 20.50 62.50 189.00
- 5. 5 Gallon Agitated Tank Unit only 27.00 81.00 245.00
- 6. 10 Gallon Agitated Tank Unit only 37.00 111.00 336.00
~
CONVENTIONAL SPRAY UNIT ACCESSORIES
- 12. Orill' Mixer '
4.50 13.50 40.50
- 13. Conventional Spray Gun 5.00 15.00 45.00
- 14. Conventional Pole Gun 6.00 18.50 5<.00
- 15. Conventional Spray Heater 6.50 19.50 59.00
- 16. 3/8" X 50' Conventional Spray Hose -2.25 6.75 20.00
- 17. 1/2" X 50' Conventional Spray Hose 3.00 9.00 27.00
- 18. 5/16" X 50' Air Hose 2.00 6.00 17.50 H. AIRLESS SPRAY EQUIPMENT :
1 . AIRLESS SPRAY UNITS
- 1. Graco Electric 46.00 140.00 423.50 ,
- 2. Wagner Electric 46.00 140.00 423.50
- 3. Wagner Gasoline 46.00 140.00 423.50
- 4. Monarch -
22:1 20.00 60.00 181.00
- 5. President -
28:1 35.00 106.00 321.50
- 6. President -
30: 1 . 35.00 106.00 321.50
- 7. Bulldog -
30:1 46.50 140.25 425.00
- 8. Bulldog -
45:1 48.00 146.00 441.50
- 9. King -
45:1 48.00 146.00 441.50
- 10. King -
55:1 50.00 151.00 457.50
- 11. Speed Flow -
28:1 49.00 148.50 450.00 AIRLESS SPRAY, ACCESSORIES -
l 21. 1/4" X 50' Airless Hose 3.75 11.00 33.00 l ^,, 22. 3/8" X 50' Airless Hose 8.00 24.50 74.00
- 23. 1/2" X 50' 4irless Hose 11.00 33.00 100.00 b 24. Airless Gun' ,
5.50 16.75 50.50
- 25. Airless Pole Gun 7.00 _21.00 63.00
- 26. Airless Spray Heater 12.00 36.00 108.00 l 1
. LIST I
.I 'cs.IUEF. B.? C4#40N & SON { h.
~' ~
CURRENT SCHEDULE-0F REIMBURSABLE EQUIP!ENT .
CONTRACTOR OWNEO .-
1(. -
PER -
PER , PER DAY WEEK MONTH I. HEAVY MATERIAL SPRAY EQUIPMENT -
HEAVY MATERIAL SPRAY UNITS
- 1. Standard Pump - 8:1 24.50' 74.00 223.50
.2. High Capacity Pump - 10:1 42.00 127.00 384.00
- 3. . Bulldog Pump - 45:1 47.00 142.00 430.00~
- 4. - ' King Pump-45:1 with Ram Elevator 56.50 171.25 519.00
- 5. King Pump-45:1 with Modified Hopper Feed ~ 55.00 166.00 503.00 v 6. Grover Pump - 10:1 48.00 145.00 439.00
- 7. Binks - 30:1 Special Polyester 60.00 180.75 547.75
.- 8. Essex Model #9 Plaster Pump 57.00 172.50 522.50
- 9. King Pump 20:1 48.00 146.00 441.50 1 4 HEAVY MATERIAL SPRAY UNIT ACCESSORIES
- 21. 3/8" X 50' Air' Hose ~ 2. 00 ' 5.50 17.00
~22. 1/2" X 50 Material Hose 4.25 12.50 38.00 ,
23, 3/4" X 50' Material Hose 5.00 15.00- 45.00
- 24. 1" X 50' Material Hose 9.50 29.00 88.00 e 25. Mastic Gun 5.00 15.00 45.00
- 26. Mastic Pole Gun 6.50 20.00 60.00
{} J..
- 27. Drum Heater SCAFFOLDING Af0 RIGGING EQUIPMENT :
2.00 6.00 18.50 STEP LADOERS
- 1. 6' 2.50 7.00 21.25
, 2. 8' 2.50 7.25 22.00
- 3. 10'. 2.50 7.70 23.00
)
. 4. 12' 3.00 8.50 25.75
- 5. 14' and over 3.00 9.00 27.00 j EXTENSION LA00ERS
- 6. 20' and under 2.25 7.00 21.25
- 7. 24' . 2.75 8.00 24.25
- 8. 26' 3.00 9.00 27.00
- 9. .28' 3.25 9.75 29.50
- 10. 30' ~
3.50 10.50 32.00
- 11. 32' 3.75 11.75 35.50
- 12. 36' 4.25 13.25 40.00
'13. 40 4.75 14.50 44.00 SCAFFOLDItC AND RIGGING EQUIPMENT :
PICKS AND TRUSSES A 14. 10' - 16' 2.50 7.00 20.75 L 15. 3.25 14.00 18' - 24' ~ 43.00 L 16. 26' - 32' 5.50 16.50 50.00 l
17.. 34' - 36' 5.50 16.50 50.00
-18.- 38' - 40' 6.50 20.00 60.00
. - , - - , . ~ . . . - , . - . - . - . . - - . , _ . , , , - - -
r-
- 7- .,2 g b .04VER,0. CANNON & SON,(
LIST Q I '
CURRENT SCHEOULE OF RElMBURSABLE EQUIPMENT .
CONTRACTOR OWNED ,-
p
\ ,.- .PER - ,
.PER . PER DAY , WEEK MONTH RIGS
- 21. Block and Fall 2.00 6.00 18.50
- 22. . Air or Elec. Sky Climber / Power Climber 38.50 117.00 355.00
- 23. Air or Elec. Spider 42.00 127.00 385.00 MISCELLANEOUS ITEMS
- 61. 3/8" Wire Cable per foot _
.23
- 62. 50' Elec. Cord for Sky Climber 5.50 17.00 52.00
- 63. . . 50' Air Hose for Sky Climber- 3.25 9.75 29.50
- 64. . Boatswain Chair ,
1.25 4.00 12.00
- 65. Stirrup 2.00 5.50 17.00
- 66. Guard Rail 1.00 2.50 7.50 ,t
- 67. Hooks 1.00 2.50 7.50
- 68. Come Along 3.25 9.50 28.50
- 69. Aluminum Beams 2.50 7.50 22.50
- 70. Beam Clamps 1.50 4.00 12.00
- 71. Fly Decki per pair 5.00 15.00 46.00
- 72. Sky Climber Work Basket 7.50 23.00 69.25-
- 73. Rotating Rigging Frame (merry-go-round) 38.50 117.00 355.00 TUBE SCAFFOLOING
- 81. Tube Scaffolding per section 1.00 3.00 8.50
- 82. Platform (each) 1.50 4.00 12.00
- 83. Casters (each) 8" dia. heavy duty wheel / lock 1.00 1.75 4.75
- 84. Handrail Set 1.00 2.75 8.50 K. GENERATORS, DRYERS, AIR MOVERS, HEATERS ANO DEHUMIDIFIERS:
- 1. 115 Volt Generator 10,000 watt 47.00 142.00 430.00
- 2. 115 Volt Generator 5,000 watt 37.00 112.00 339.00
- 3. 115 Volt Generator 3,500 watt , 30.00 90.00 272.00
- 4. 115 Volt Generator 2.500 watt 25.50 77.50 234.50 i 11. Air Oryer -
100 CFM-Refrigerant 39.00 117.00 355.00
- 12. Air Oryer -
600 CFM-Refrigerant 86.00 260.00 787.00
- 13. Air Oryer -
1200 CFM to 1500 CFM Refrigerant / Desiccant 131.50 398.00 1,205.00 14 . ' After Cooler- 1200 CFM to 1500 CFM Air Cooled 113.00 342.00 1,035.00
\_'
- 21. Air Movers -
1500 CFM-Electric or air 10.00 30.00 92.00
- 22. Air Movers -
3000 CFM-Electric or air 16.50 50.00 151.50
- 23. Air Movers -
6000 CFM-Electric or air 20.50 62.00 188.00
- 24. Air Movers - 11000 CFM-Electric or air 32.00 97.50 295.00
E .'
" O' LIST /h
' .77. OQvnR e. CANNUN & SON, CURRENT SCEDULE OF REIM3 URSA 8LE EQUIPMENT .
CONTRACTOR OWNE0 .
., ;PER PER - -
PER DAY WEEK- MONTH .
- 30. Heater to 50,000 BTU-Electric .18.00 55.00-
- 36. Heater to 1,300,000 BTU 166.00 130.00 393.50 1,193.00
- 37. . Heater to 2,000,000 BTU
- 38. 151.00 457.00 1,384.00 Controlled Air Supply Trailer-includes 2,000 CFM Compressor, 2,400 CFM Air
, Dryers, 2-14.100 Oil Separators and l'-700 Gal. Air Receiver 1,050.00 3,182.00 9,642.00 39.- 9000 CFM Dehumidification Unit with
. Oust Collectors 998.00 3,023.00 9,161.00
- 40. 40,000*CFM Oust Collector System-Portable 847.00 2,566.00 7,776.00
- 41. 18,500 CFM Oust Collector System 393.00 1,190.00 3,300.00 i
M. TRAILERS:
- 1. Storage Trailer 21.00 63.50 '192.00 4
- 2. Office Trailer 16.00 49.00 149.00
- 3. Office / Storage Trailer 21.00. 63.50 192.00
- 4. Flat Bed Trailer. 12.50 38.00 114.00
- 5. Climate Controlled Storage ~56.50 '171.00 519.00 O N.
QUALITY ASSURANCE / QUALITY CONTROL EQUIPMENT:
- 1. Ory Film Thickness Gauge 6.00 18.00 54.00
- 2. Electronic Holiday Detector 5.50 16.50
- 3. Humidity / Temperature Recorder 50.00
- 4. 14.70 44.50 134.50 Surface Profile Comparator 2.25 6.50
- 5. Surface Thermometer 19.50 6.
1.50 4.00 12.00 Sling Psychrometer 1.50 4.00
- 7. Holsture Meter 12.00 3.25 9.50 28.50
- 8. Minmitector 150 12.50
- 9. Tooke Gauge 38.00 115.00
- 10. 3.75 11.00 34.00 Amprobe Fastemp Thermometer 1.75
- 11. Light Meter 5.25 16.00
. 5.00 15.00 45.00
- 12. Needle Pressure Gauge 1.00
- 13. Adhesion Tester 2.50 7.00 6.00 17.50 52.50
- 14. Explosimeter 6.00
- 15. 17.50 52.50 Pocket Thermometer 2.00 i
- 16. 5.50 16.50 NBS Calibration Standard Shims 1.75 5.00 15.00
( 17. Swedish Standards SS (VIS I) 18.
1.00 2.00 6.00 l Wet Film Gauge 1.25 3.25 l 19. Psychron 9.50 3.00 9.00 27.50 l~
O b . GENERAL TOOLS AND EQUIPMENT:
- 1. Flood Light Stands - Conventional
- 2. ~8.00 24.00 73.00 50' Electric Cord - Explosion Proof 3.00 6.00 16.00
- 3. 50' Electric Cord - Extension Card
. 1.00 2.25 6.50
- ,o __ .. - . - - , - _ , . ,, -
p
"9" l CQ.'IR B. CAMC. S3N, h LIST h CURRENT SCHEDULE OF REIMSURSABLE EQUIPMENT ~
CONTRACTOR OWNED (3 -
c,.,PER PER- -
PER
' OAY WEEK MONTH
- 4. Flexible Duct per 25' Section (8") 5.25 15.50 47.00
- 5. Flexible Duct Per 25' Section (12") 7.75 23.50 71.00
- 6. Flexible.0uct per 20' Section (18") 9.25 27.75
~
84.00
- 7. Portable Radios 7.25 22.00
- 9. 66.50 Vacuum Cleaner-Industrial Heavy Duty 20.00 60.50 183.00
- 10. . Heavy Octy Floor Vacuum w/ power brush 47.50 144.00 436.00
- 11. Communications - Base Station 15.25 45.75 138.75
- 12. Gang Boxes 6.50 19.50 59.00
- 13. Fuel Storage Tank 14.50 43.50 132.00
- 14. Stencil Machine 1" 12.00 36.00 109.00
- 15. Stencil Machine 4" 48.00 144.00 436.00
.i T. VEHICLES:
- 1. Ranchero 37.00 111.00
- 2. 333.00 1/2 Ton Van 37.00 111.00 333.00 .
- 3. 1/2 Ton Pick-up 37.00 111.00 333.00
- 4. 3/4 Ton Pick-up 40.50 123.00 372.50
- 5. 3/4 Ton Pick-up 4WD 43.50 131.50 398.50-
- 6. 1 Ton Pick-up 43.50 131.50 398.50
{.' -
8.
9,
- ~1-1/2 Ton Stake 2 Ton Van 44.00 38.00 133.50 115.50 405.00 349.00
- 10. 1-1/2 Ton Van 44.00 133.50 405.00
- 11. 2-1/2 Ton Stake 57.75 175.00 529.00
- 12. Single Axle Tractor 72.25 219.00 664.00
- 13. Twin Axle Tractor 80.00 242.50 734.50 CONSUMABLE EQUIPMENT ACCESSORIES:
The following accessories will be billed on a straight purchase basis at cost plus 10%.
00S8 WATERBLASTING Brushes Lances
! Gun Bodies Tips and Nozzles Nozzles Innercomes Vacuum Manifold SCAFFOLDING POWER TOOLS 3/4" Rope Chipping Chisels Plywood Sheets Brush Heads
\ Needles
, Roto Peen Pads ALUMINUM ADHESION 00LLIES
- r - -
p 9
~
4
-. . I 44.Ir4B.CA! SON & SON;g. LIST I -
CURRENT SCHEDULE OF REIM3URSABLE EQUIPMENT , '.
CONTRACTOR OWNED Q
t .
~
TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF; RENTAL
- TIME BASIS OF RATES:
Rentalratesarebasedonnorma}workhoursconsistingof:
. 8 hours9.259259e-5 days <br />0.00222 hours <br />1.322751e-5 weeks <br />3.044e-6 months <br /> per day 40 hours4.62963e-4 days <br />0.0111 hours <br />6.613757e-5 weeks <br />1.522e-5 months <br /> per week 176 hours0.00204 days <br />0.0489 hours <br />2.910053e-4 weeks <br />6.6968e-5 months <br /> per month The rate for hours in excess of the above will be 1/8,1/40, or 1/176 of the daily, weekly or monthly rates, respectively. ,
EQUIPMENT OPERATION AND MAINTENANCE: .t The leasee is responsible for all normal operating and maintenance costs, '
including fuel, lubricants, filters, etc.
REPAIR COSTS: .
The leasee is responsible for all repair costs beyond " Normal Wear and Tear."
" Normal Wear and Tear" is defined as that which wo'uld be expected to result from C'l the use of the equipment under normal circumstances, provided the equipment is properly maintained and serviced.
RENTAL PERIOD:
The rental period starts when the equipment leaves the leasor's warehouse and stops upon return to such warehouse.
FREIGHT CHARGES:
All freight charges are to be borne by the leasee. k Contractor-owned vehicles used for delivery will be charged as follows:
- 1. Pick-up Truck. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Daily Rental Plus $ .45 per mile.
- 2. Stake Truck. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Daily Rental Plus $.55 per mile. -
- 3. Tractor. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Daily Rental Plus $ .83 per mile.
s e
4 ug O
, e. . --
l 7 'a r24 -
TEXAb 'ITIES GENERATING t PANY
, AD ION OETEXAS UTILITIES ELEC1'RIC O. '..
I 100.000_00 0"tNTs $Na"Ev "oEs'v"* EM$NE " PURCHASE ORDtiR SUPPLEMENT l w est n nn acomon av s sumptemENT , ,:
, ) .*f '~- _
0.00 -
osouction av rwis sun trutur
' ~"
Texas Utilities cen rating ca. -
P.O. Box 1002, Glen Rose, Texas 76043 100.000.00 ,,,u yor -
l 1 " * "* CPF 16245 rm .c= a ~o- -
, u i .. .~ r . . . . . .. . v . . . . . . .....r..
6/25/84 1-2-9230-940000-108' HOT APPLICABLE "*T"*" u f OLIVER B. CANNON AND SON, INC. 7 no cwances in on cancri.tarious oc f gacys(o,a,o,E,a,s g wys,ayocuikeo p
9001 AIRPORT BLYD., SUITE 801 usur roau issuco out.y av rue nua.
""^5'"" ""^" ""'-
HOUSTON, TEXAS 77061 R 31414
.i
- n z euncusina ozral"Mr"u'I's'h 'o"c"T*?r"SL*tcM"c"&7s rL",1?iMEE'L'u".*fa'co ruacuasc oncen (TEM QUANTITY TOTA 1.
U/t DESCRifTION NO. WANTED UNIT PRICE ITEM PRICE THIS SUPPLEMENT NO. 1 IS ISSUED TO AUTHORIZE PAYMENT OF ADDITIONAL TRAVEL EXPENSES PER :
- 0. B. BANNON'S INV0 ICE NO. B-04002 DATED 4/1/84, NO. B-04002 DATED 4/30/84 AND
- NO. B-01001 DATED 1/31/84 AND C. R. GRAVES, TUGC0 AND J. J. NORRIS,
) 0. B. CANNON AGREEMENT OF 5/31/84.
NOTE:
ADDITIONAL RELATED EXPENSES WHICH MAY BE INCURRED BY 0. B. CANNON PERSONNEL ATTENDING HEARINGS AND GIVING TESTIMONY AS
- DIRECTED BY TUGC0 MANAGEMENT WILL BE RE-IMBURSED UNDER THE SCOPE OF THIS PURCHASE ORDER AT ACTUAL COST INCURRED.
PAYMENT AUTHORIZED BY THIS SUPPLEMENT NO.1 AS FOLLOWS:
1 1 LOT 50". OF ACTUAL EXPENSES (PER ABOVE INVOICES) $7,800.33/LT $7,800.33 TOTAL THIS SUPPLEMENT NO.1 $7,800.33 THE AB0VE PRICE IS FIRM AND NOT SUBJECT TO ESCALATION.
Escept as hcma unended, this Supplement carries forth and proer.es a3 Ter: ts arid Condidons af the original Purchase Order and previous Supplements.
A ^
eus Fon c. NGE TO AUTHORIZE PAYMENI
~
/A ne a nn r, rcm, ro au er cycemee' TEXAS UTILI ES GENERATING COMPANY CH ANGEp ST / $' h.)h.', ,$[..'jh, 1517I B9f'188i5XTy
, (81712971881 ext tod Sk /u REQUtsiirlON)R $
- Tt$kvDhh[/ [TM -'
~
Pt.18 'HASING AGENT VENDOR' COPY
! m .=, p P
- ,ayl+l:n
== av' F
. g, - - . OLIVER B. CANNON Q SON INC.
(' f . .
- ^
- '....*J A /ndus/riall'aintinti .9nrin/ist.s. ATTACHMENT'B
(~s, -e i
*
- 9o01 AIRPORT DLVD. . SUITE Bot . HOUSTON TEXAS 77o61 y,7pdf(.// PHONE 713 947 5,67o .
Omhc/e,fErtica.
.c k.d \ REPLY TO:
P.O. IsOX lee . SOUTH HOUETON TX 77637 C8301:001 Texas Utilities. Services, Inc.
P.O. Box 1002 Glen Rose, Texas 76043 .
Attention: Mr. 3. T. Merritt, Jr., P.E.
Engineering & Construction Manager
Reference:
Texas Utilities Generating Company Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station 1981 2300 MW Installation Gibbs & Hill Project No. 2323 05277 Protective Coatings Specification No. 2323-AS-31 Gentlemen: ,
f -
Thank you for the time and courtesies extended to me during my visit to the jobsite on July 13, 1983. We are organizing our analysis of the Service Level One coating effort into the following categories:
1-Production 5-Quality Control 2-Work Procedures 6-Management of Coating Effort 3-Scheduling .
7-Future Maint. Censiderations 4-Training and Painter Qualification 8-Specifications Per the above breakdown, we will send you our recommendaticos and observations, individually as we perceive the need, rather than wait until we complete our analysis.
Please promptly indicate your acceptance, rejection or "needs further study" so that we don't waste time on recornmendations that can't be implemented for reasons we might not be aware.
l 1 have reviewed the commercial terms with John Youngblood and confirm them on Exhibit A (attached). TUSI General Terms and Conditions are acceptable except for the Hold Harmless Clause. A limited Hold liarmless Clause is acceptable.
We will, of course, send you a weekly report, indicating rnanpower, work in process, etc.
\_ .
l FOUNDED 1916
- l
~ ~
- ; OLJ) ,E R _ R. C A N N O N f. S - . I N C. .
- * - . . .i y ,;
July 15,1983 -
f4 Texas Utilities Generating Company-Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station . ,
Page 2 O erts te of Insurance was mailed to Mr. Gentry's attention on July 14, 1983.
Very truly yonars, 5
J. 'J. Norris .
Vice Presid
/d .
cc: R. B. Roth A. P. Mcdonald -
T. F. Rogers
Attachment:
Exhibit A O
x e
9 8
/
'\ . ,
,-----,.c, ,,, ----,-..-,,---.,...,,,,,.,g __ ,,- - --n---.. - - , . ,,, ,. - --e,-., ,, . , - , - , - , ,-, -, ,--r-,
- w. ; m. ,
.l -
"U .
EXHIBIT A , -
FEE SCHEDULE a
A. Management Personnel $500/ day + reasonable expenses B. Line Pers6nnel -
$400/ day + reasonable expenses C.- Technical Personnel .
- 1. Site $350/ day + reasonable expenses
- 2. Of fice $250/ day D. Clerical Personnel Cost E. T6 A, B, C & D above add 16% for overhead F. FIXED FEE thru 9/15/83 $63,000 (Negotiable af ter 9/15/83) .
G. Test Equipment (if necessary) Per OBC List. Xill(attached)
H. Terms: Net 30 G
/
, . i. , -
- ,_ , - - - - , , - , - - , , ~ -,s, , - - - , . , . . - - , , , , - - . - . - - - - . - , .-n . - ~n,. <- -
OLi\ r : B. C4N.N O.4 Q S ON. ll2C.
, ATTACHMENT C RECOMMENDATION INDEX
- 1. PRODUCTION
- 2. WORK PROCEDURES
- 3. SCHEDULING
- 4. TRAINING & PAINTER QUALIFICATION 5 QUALITY CONTROL ,
- 6. PN'AGEMENT OF COATING EFFORT
- 7. FUTURE ?!AINTENANCE CONSIDERATIONS
- 8. SPECIFICATIONS
! e i
July 25, 1983
R;v. Ns. 0 OL:VE?. B. CANNON & SON, INC.
F.E DMHENDATION INDEX .
REC. NO. TITLE APPROVED DISAPPROVED UNDER STUD 1 1-001 Job Description / Manpower Inbalance .
1-002 Employee Identification 2-001 -
Reduce Safeway Scaffolding 3-001 Tie Aux. Bldg. into Start-up Schedule 3-002 B&R (Ineffect to analyze their problems) 6-001 Subcontract BOP 6-002 Realign management structure 6-003 Improve painter /CI morale 6-004 Indicate detailed daily force reports 8-001 Go to conventional coating system for BOP, Complete rewrite of AS-31
)8-002 t.
0
~
Prg; 1 of 2 Dat; July 25, 1983 Originator J. Norris L
RECOMMENDATION NO.: 1-001
SUBJECT:
Production
REFERENCE:
Texas Utilities Generating Co./ Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station SAFETY RELATED DOCUMENT: YES NO DESCRIPTION:
As of 7/15/83 the painting crew was as follows:
Level 1 Helper - 49 Sandblast - 5 Level 2 Helper - 54 Foreman - 38 Level 3 Helper - 165 Gen. Foreman - 5 Painter (Brush) - 53 Operator - 2 Painter (Spray) - 69 Laborer - 4 8,564 Manhours for str3 1gQt time and 2,984 Manhours for premium time APPROVAL SIGNAT ES:
Originator: ,h ! Date:
p 7 JS f 3
/
OBC OC: ((A Date:
TUSI Representative: Date:
Distribution: '
J. J. Norris J. J. Lipinsky R. A. Trallo R. B. Roth R. G. Posgay J. T. Merritt t ;.
,- u; -
.-- Mk
er
-is Pcg2- 2 2 ll D&EE: July 25, 1983 OriginatorQ. Norris RECOMMENDATION NO.: 1-001 ,
SU3 JECT: Production
REFERENCE:
TUGCO/ Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station DESCRIPTION:
Jecommend that the Level 3 Helper count be significantly reduced and=the SprayPaintercountbeincreasedby70[.
e 9
mm G
V .
, ee wm
- Pzg3 1 of 1 Data- July 25, 1983 Originator J. Norris L
RECOMMENDATION NO.: 1-002.
SUBJECT:
Production
REFERENCE:
Texas Utilities Generating Co./ Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station SAFETY ,RELATED DOCUMENT: YES NO DESCRIPTION:
Hard Hat Identification: Most painters do not have numbers on hard hats.
I recommend ht' at painters have numbers so that employees cast be properly identified.
t APPROVAL SIGNA RES:
- N Originator: l /
7 Date: 7J5//3
/
OBC QC: V/,Q Date:
i TUSI Representative: Date:
Distribution: '
J. J. Norris J. J. Lipinsky 4
R. A. Trallo R. B. Roth R. G. Posgay J. T. Merritt i t i
W,.~.._.
Pcp 1 of 1 Data July 25, 1983 Originator J. Norris fiECOMMENDATION NO.: 2-001
SUBJECT:
Work Procedures
REFERENCE:
Texas Utilities Generating Co./ Comanche Peak Steam Electric ~ Station SAFETY RELATED DOCUMENT: YES / NO DESCRIPTkON:
Painters are requiring 100% safeway type scaffolding in almost all situations.
Consistent with safety considerations, we recommend that more use be made of spiders, sky climbers &nd similar devices when appropriate.
d APPROVAL SIGNATU S:
Originator:
Date: 7 J 7/[3
/ '
OBC OC: Date:
TUSI Representative: Date:
Distribution: '
J. J. Norris J. J. Lipinsky R. A. Trallo R. B. Both R. G. Posgay J. T. Merritt
- t m.
Pcg3 1 cf 1 Dato July 25, 1983 Originator J. Norris RECOMMENDATION NO.: 3-001
SUBJECT:
Scheduling n
REFERENCE:
Texas Utilities Generating Co./ Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station SAFETY RELATED DOCUMENT: YES NO DESCRIPTION:
There is a great amount of work to do in the Aux. Bldg. I recommend that the painting in the Aux. Bldg. be tied into the start-up schedule on a room-by-room
\
basis.with a specific amount of time allocated to each room.
~1 n '
2 APPROVAL SIGNA RES:
Originator: [ Date:
l 7 j S'// 3 OBC QC: /, ,M Date:
TUSI Representative:
Date:
I Distribution: *
~
J. J. Norris J. J. Lipinsky R. A. Trallo R. B. Both R. G. Posgay J. T. Merritt t
Pz;- 1 of _1 D3t2 July 25, 1983 O Originator J. Norris
(.
RECOMMENDATION NO.: 3-002
SUBJECT:
Scheduling
REFERENCE:
Texas Utilities Generating Co./ Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station SAFETY RELATED DOCUMENT: YES NO DESCRIPTION:
At the present rate of progress the coating work inside the containment and the Aux. Bldg. will not be done by the time you expect to load fuel. I recommend that a detailed daily work plan and schedule for the remaining five (5) months be submitted by Brown & Root for TUGCO's approval for the remaining five (5) months.
. )
APPROVAL SIGNAT ES:
Originator:
/
Date: 7 JJ/93 OBC QC: d, N Date:
TUSI Representative: Date:
Distribution:
- J. J. Norris J. J. Lipinsky R. A. Trallo R. B. Roth R. G. Posgay J. T. Merritt
(
Piga 1 ~ of 1
~
- Data - July 25, 1983-
. Originator J. Norris RECOPMENDATION NO. : 6-001-
SUBJECT:
Management of Coating' Effort
~
REF,ERENCE:- T'exas Utilities Generating Co./ Comanche-Peak Steam Electric Station SAFETY RELATED DOCUMENT: YES NO.
-DESCRIPTION:
Because of lack progress on'the balance of plant, recommend that TUGC0 Purchasing go out for bids on remaining work.
~
1 APPROVAL SIGNA ES: 1 Originator:- "
, [ Date: 7 ff /.3 OBC QC:' d/[M Dater
/
TUSI Representative Date:
Distribution:
J. J. Norris ,
J. J. Lipinsky R. A. Trallo R. B. Roth
,R. G. Posgay J. T. Merritt
(,,
Pig] 1 of 1 Data July 25, 1983 Originator J. Nerris RECOMMENDATION NO.: 6-002
SUBJECT:
Management of Coating Effort
REFERENCE:
Texas Utilities Generating Co./ Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station SAFETY _RELATED DOCUMENT: YES NO DESCRIPTION:
Project organization, ie; TUGCO Managers for each area places severe strains on Jr. Haley's a6111ty to manage the painting program.
I recommend that the chain of command be revised so that Haley reports to one person.
j APPROVAL SIGNATURES: -
Originator:
/
~ Date: 7 ) 7 [3 OBC OC: d)[,4 Date:
/
i TUSI Representative: Date:
Distribution: '
~
J. J. Norris J. J. Lipinsky R. A. Trallo R. B. Ro.th R. G. Posgay J. T. Merritt s.
,- P;g; 1 cf 1 D:ta July 25, 1983
. Originator J. Norris
\.
RECOWINDATION NO.: 6-003 l
SUBJECT:
Management of Coating Effort
REFERENCE:
Texas Utilities Generating Co./ Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station SAFETY RELATED DOCUMENT: YES NO DESCRIPTION:
Relations between painters and inspectors need to be improved. I recommend that joint meetings be held so that each discipline understands the problems of the other. Emphasize cooperation and not confrontation.
( APPROVAL SIGNATU S:
Originator: L. - Date:
f
[ Jf 93' OBC QC: dA Date:
/ /
TUSI Representative: Date:
Distribution:
J. J. Norris J. J. Lipinsky R. A. Trallo R. B. Both R. G. Po3 Fay J. T. Merritt t
g g g
, '. Dato July 25, 1983 g Originator
( '
RECOMMENDATION NO.: 6-004
SUBJECT:
Management of Coating Effort
REFERENCE:
Texas Utilities Generating Co./ Comanche Peak Steam Elect'ric Station SAFETY RELATED DOCUMENT: YES NO DESCRIPTION:
On the next business day, B&R should submit daily force rt 7rts indicating manpower by classification, disposition of forces, overtime and perceived problems.
Based on Recommendation 3-002, report should indicate how many days behind or ahead of schedule for each item of work.
I consider this recommendation to be critical to the overall coating effort, as well as determining Whether or not B&R can complete the coating work inside the containment and Aux. Bldg. prior to the loading of fuel.
- APPROVAL SIGNATU. S
Originato::
Date: 7 y/f3 OBC OC: // A Date:
TUSI Representative: Date:
Distribution: '
J. J. Norris J. J. Lipinsky R. A. Trallo R. B. Both R. G. Posgay J. T. Merritt
(~
Q,~J
(
"-F _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
m Page 1 cr 1
. . Data July 25, 1983 g Originator J. Norris c
RECOMMENDATION NO.: 8-001 SU3 JECT: Specifications
REFERENCE:
Texas Utilities Generating Co./ Comanche Peak Steain Electric Station SAFETY RELATED DOCU.",NT: YES V NO DESCRIPhION:
On balance of plant, we recommend that the painting system be changed from phenolic epoxy top coat to a more conventional system such as a rust inhibiting s
barrier coat and a silicone alkyd top coat.
A acrylic latex system should also be considered.
APPROVAL SIGNATUSS:
(~ ,
'l Originator: Date: 7 g/[3 OBC OC: (, /A Date:
TUSI Representative: Date:
I Distribution: '.
J. J. Norris J. J. Lipinsky R. A. Trallo R. B. Both R. G. Posgay J. T. Merritt
(
- - ~ ~ ~ - . . . __ _ _ _ _
- P:52 1 cf 1 Dat9
. July 25, 1983 g '
Originator J. Norris
/.
'~
RECOMMENDATION NO.: 8-002
SUBJECT:
Specifications
REFERENCE:
Texas Utilities Generating Co./ Comanche Peak Steam Electric' Station SAFETY RELATED DOCUMENT: YES [ NO DESCRIPTkON':
Specification AS-31 needs to be rewritten so as to eliminate workaday procedural problems that are presently being encountered. While the use of a completely revised specification may be impractical for Unit 1 at this late date, it should make work proceed more smoothly in Unit 2.
APPROVAL SIGNATU S:
Originator:
Date: 7 Af [3
/
OBC OC: h/A Date:
TUSI Representative: Date:
Distribution: .
J. J. Norris J. J. Lipinsky R. A. Trallo R. B. Both R. G. Posgay J. T. Merritt
,r3
./ ~)
\
m _ .- . . _ _ . . . _ _ . _ . ..
._..-_..-.---..--....._.-_m - . - - - - - . . - - - - - - - -
P;ge 1 cr 1 Dato July 25, 1983 Originator J. Norris RECOMENDATION NO. : 8-003
SUBJECT:
Specifications
REFERENCE:
Texas Utilities Generating Co./ Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station SAFETY RELATED DOCUMENT: YES NO DESCRIPTION:
Recommend that the philosophy for service level I coatings be revised so that a limited percentage of the coating work can be used as is when the coating is obviously usable and acceptable, but cannot be applied exactly per the specifications.
\
APPROVAL SIGNAT ES: l Originator: Dater . 7 .)[ [3 7 /
OBC OC: Date:
TUSI Representative Date:
Distribution:
J. J. Norris J. J. Lipinsky R. A. Trallo R. B. Roth-R. G. Posgay J. T. Herritt vi
cWoi, June 1973 U. [**,,,so.)
~
555. ib RY DIRECTORATE OF REGULATORY STANDARDS GU DE l
. REGULATORY GUIDE 1.54
)
l OUALITY ASSURANCE REQUIREMENTS FOR PROTECTIVE COATINGS APPLIED TO WATER-COOLED NUCLEAR POWER PLANTS
. A. INTRODUCTION Coatings Applied to Nuclear Facilities,"' for protectia coatings apphed to ferritic stecis, aluminum, str.inicey Appendix 0 to 10 CFR Part 50," Quality Assurance stect, zinc. coated (galvanized) steel, concrete, or masonry
- Criteria for Nucicar Power Plantsand Fuel Reprocessing surfaces of watercooled nuclear power plants are Plants," establishes overall quality assurance program generally acceptable and provide an adequate basis for requirements for the design, fabrication, construction, complying with the pertinent quality assurance and operation of safety.related nuclear power plant requirements of Appendix B to 10 CFR Part 50 subject structures, systems, and components. This guide to the following: .
describes an acceptable method of complying with the .
- Commission's quality assurance requirements with 1. ANSI N101.41972 should be used in conjunctior regard to protective coatings applied to ferritic steels, with ANSI N45.21971. " Quality Assurance Prograns aluminum, stainless steel, zinc-coated (galvanized) steel, Requirements for Nuclear Power Plants."8 concrete, or masonry surfaces of water. cooled nuclear power plants. The Advisory Committee on Reactor 2. Subdivision 2.7 of ANSI N101.41972 states tha-Safeguards has been consulted concerning this guide and when references are made to other standards, thest
, has concurred in the regulatory position. references shall imply the most recent or curren-editions of the referenced standards. The specifk Ih B. DISCUSSION spplicability or acceptability of referenced standards wil be covered separately in other regulatory guides, whert
{U) Subcommittee N101.5.7 of the American National appropriate.
Standards Institute (ANSI) Standards Committee N101, Atomic Industry Facility Design, Construction, and 3. Subdivision 1.1.2 of ANSI N101.41972 states that Operation Criteria, under the sponsorship of the quality assurance, as covered by this standard compriset American Institute of Chemical Engineers, has developed all those planned and systematic actions necessary tc
' a standard which includes quality assurance provide specified documentation and adequatt requirements for protective coatings applied to ferritic confidence that shop or field coating work for nuclesi stects, aluminum, stainless stect, zinc coated (galvanized) facilities will perform satisfactorily in service. Thi steel, concrete, or masonry surfaces of nuclear facilities. statement should not be interpreted as implying that the This standard was approved by the American National end product of quality assurance actions is tis Standards Committee N101 and its Secretariat. It was production of specified documentation. The ters subsequently approved and designated N101.41972 by the American National Standards Institute on November 28,1972. ' Copies may be obtained from the American Institu;c o Chemical Engineers, 345 East 47th Street, New York, N.Y .
C. REGULATORY POSITION 10017.
' Copies may be obtained from the American Society o The requirements and guidchnes included in ANSI ILfechanical Engineers. United Engineering Center,345 East 47tl N 101.41972 " Quality Assurance for Protective Street, New York, N.Y.10017.
N
! USAEC RECULAToRY CUIoES c.p.n .t
,b..hm, e..*. n., em .h...a.d e, . and. .a. h. d.
! s h. cmam.n a. wnh.. ..a. 0 4. 20s.5
- n. .
,,.e,,_,- c .. ,- .. ,, . .-,, ~.... ...,..-.. .-..
.........c................
. . . . . . . . . . , , . e.namd.e.
i-
,. . . A . a.e 3 .,. ..
e.a.,,,o. ..,..
u sc .,. ~ . ,. .. . ..
- s. ..
n :, *"';"l'.*O
. , "::::'*." " .* =: Ji'"?" ,'l%*:,.','*.1% ,'"
, ,,'O **,"c';,%.. ..".1.',e'."s.M.'"""""*"' """'"" ' "'
r '",,'."'.",'.",**.',7* '.*~';' '"': 1,. .. - ,.. n me. u :
\: t :5l",".". "'t",L" '.n",.fl'..".*,'.'t
- .". *".
- ;*.",,"."::: %.7::::.:::;',?;l;' :%".2.'."#"" ~ ,.r. .. .. .,.
a.n. .
. . .r...
z , . 1. v .. . .. , .,
Ped,lae).ed yve,9y. go.l. . , p...d ul,V. .s .ppr.pf..M, D.fnMed.4 9. A m. .. tug, R.ympe, l
t,. t
. gyne.A, .re, ,. e.f l.d n.u, o.,s.ge f ..on .e get..ac..
- 4. e #.k.nin.M,.I
- 5. M.i.eI.se .r.l.
eng
..iu Pi.no Pe...c,en se,.. 10. C.a.e.,
', . . = - - , ,
" quality assurance" as used in ANSI N101.41972 'TriddiaTs" use(~w'ith stainless steel should at he should be cimsidered to comprise all those planned and compounded from or treated with chemical compounds h
t systematic . actions necessary to provide adequate confidence that shop or field coating work for nuclear containing elements that could contribute to corroskm, intergranular cracking, or stress corrosion cracking.
h facilities will perform satisfactorily in service. In this Examples of such chemical compounds are those connection it is emphasized that records and documents containing chlorides, fluorides,1 cad, zinc, copper sulfur,
., listed in Subdivisions 7.4 through 7.3, and included in or mercury where such elements are leachable or where 6 ,
the standard, are suggested forms only. Alternate they could be released by breakdown of the chemleal documentation consistent with the requirements of . compounds under expected environmental conditions Appendix B.to 10 CFR Part 50 is also considered '(e.g., by radiation). This limitation is not intended to acceptable. prohibit the use of trichlorotrifluoroethane which meets the requirements of Military Specification
- 4. Sections 3,and 4 of ANSI N101.41972 delinente uit.c.81302b for cleaning or degressing of austenitic i quality assurance requirements for coating materials and stainless steel provided adequate removalis assured prior
'. surface preparation,of substrates. Coatings and cleaning to painting.
f
-gg jI , .
l.
i e.**
G 8
I
. N 9
9 s..
( .
4 l .$d*
r
! ; , .: )
e y \
f- v
, exa: U.ili.i6s 5:rvicol Inc. l C: ar.cne Pcck Steam Elcctr'ic Staticn i specification No. 2323-AS-31 I i
.y -l o t.
RECOMMENDATION LOG EECOMMENDATION NO. DATE APPROVED REJECTED PENDING COMPLETE
/- 00/ b Slgg
/- COL 1/A5 c2 - 00 / /45' 3- 00/ ' l/D S~
3 - 00h */p S-6 - 00/ lA_S~
6 - 6 0.2, %r -
6- 603 - 9/ag -
6-004 %r l JL f- 00/-' 7/A5
/ - OOS-h.f I
A-
.s i.
- r--,,
w e A m. m .,ce m .,
...o e.,n w ce Q ATTACHMENT D o
DEPARTMENTAL CORRESPONDENCE I
('
DATE October 31, 1983 SUBJECT TUSI IOM 10/27/83 and J. T. Merritt* Letter of 10/28/83 73 R. B. Poth FROM 3 NorriB -
Bob, confirming our telecon of 10/30/83 I have a qwipped copy of Mr. Chapman's 10/27/83 memo to John Merritt regarding Joe Lipinsky's trip report of 8/28/83.
I never dreamt that Joe's report would be communicated to anyone outside of our organization or I would have taken issue with it.
Reasonable people differ in their perceptions of problems. I saw
.the problems at Comanche Peak differently than Joe did. As you know, over the years we have had problems from time to time with the objectivity of FQCI'S. The ones involved in doc'umenting the goating effort at nuclea.r installations tend to get involved in engineering .decisionc as a group and 'in my' opinion, therein lies the lion's share of'the problem.
Using Mr. Chapman's numbering system the following are my observations at Comanche Peak:
- 1. I believe Joe met with some line type FQCI'S and garnered his impressions from those inspectors. Joe, of course, did not audit so his comments are at best second hand information. I'm not saying the allegations are true or false, but it is my impression subject to an audit that there is alot of'" sour grapes" conversations taking place among the line inspection personnel. I sensed a way of thinking amongst the inspection personnel that indicated, at least to' me, that they had no loyalty to their supervisors. For example; in the QA/QC machinery to document problems and provide a means for rectifying same there exists at Comanche Peak an NCR and another document that does not stop work, but allows remedial work on an on-going item l of work. It wcs my understanding that Mr. Tolson simply aske6 l the inspector or inspectors to quit' issuing NCR'S and issue the i other document instead. That was a reasonable request in my l opinion and in no way compromised quality or integrity.
2a. I interviewed the foreman in charge of the material storage warehouse in the company of Jr. Haley, Brown & Root Paint
, Superintendent. The "C" portion of the warehouse was, if anything, a, model for proper storage of material. There are temperature records, limited access, expiration dates on all containers, neat and orderly and with a reasonable inventory. I' did not formally audit but I would be very surprised if they got V- many gigs.
2
- 3 '- one 115 . _ _ _ - . - - - _.
. v 4 , '
u -
2b. As I recommended to TUSI I. felt like the ratio of.holpers to -
Q V
journeyman was too high. However, they were doing a tremendous k-amount _ of mauking of unistrut and other items not requiring paint and previously painted nurfaces thht were not compatible with tho-acurront syntom. ,
. 2c. The progra'm coating seems to be in compliance with ANSI requirenants, but again I'd have to audit to be sure. .
1
- 2d. . I made a canual inspection, of. t.ho Unit I and. Unit II
. , containuents cand ' the AUX sUuilding. I caw cvidence of destructive 1 testing of. the coating systems that far cxeceds anything .I have over experienced. '
scemingly. every fcw square foot of the concrete coating system had evidence of destructive' testing and film thicknesucs recorded in Magic Markor. Additionally, the cc.me statement can be made. of a .significant amount of structural-stool. Tho . coating.onspractically.cvery stair stringer had br.un destroyed with aTooko. Gauge. .If thoro.were any concerns in this area it was that .the ' obvious over-inspection could 3ca'd to
~
failuro by' substrate or intercoat contamination from sweat, body oil, dirty hands, ole.
- 20. I havo 'no ' knowledge of any document . deficiencies.
.6 y. T.-g m.Qg::n ? .
.: ..-~ ~ .. .- .
2f. LInddyD.(opinion, a36od..part of' # .the problem 'at' Comanche reak.
is-theisfact.. that . Inspector's rare <<workin'g7 'long -hours. o n _- . a 0,, continuing. . basis. It's-jbeen-my. experience ovary time that'when you got1 yourself =into.. scheduling continuing. overtime.pnopic get
.t tired and ir r itab1'e',... . iot . . "' < . A morale problem" . . You and.I both
. know 'how difficult.;it '1s to' secure ~trai~ned inspectors as 'they are simply not aval)nble at thisj. time.
- 3. I think that Joe too5c Mr.
statement "That's not my concutn". Tolson out of context on'the Perhaps Mr. Tolson was referring to the fact that the licensing of Unit I was not his area of responsib)ity.
- 4. I have no knowledge of the T.L. Miller subject.
- 5. Many have concerns for what we feel are good reasons,then so lot- the individual voice those concerns and address it objectively.
- 6. Regarding "only 34 out of 452 indiv'iduals are of any value as painters", as I utated previour.ly, thoro s.as a largo nucN r of helper types on the payroll becauce of the operation. It. was my impression that a intensive masking number of otherwise
. ' qualified paint ors had slowed drain considerably because of real
" or imagined quality control restraints, jo
- 7. Sco paragroph 2f above.
P a g ', J G t. 4 r .
I ') 8. Brown '& Root was having trouble with moisture ~ in'the V . compressed . air during QC. checks. of' the air supply early in onc ~or .
. Stwo of the. shifts. It'was;a simple.. matter.of upgrading the air j
", 2 drying bomponents' whi,ch I~ believe ,was taken ca re 'imraediately.c ' - '
x .. mjf 4..
, . 7 , 7. .,. . . . .y w .. , 4- , . . . ,: . .g m. .
- 9. I' I sce. 'n o parallel. between 'Comancho Peak a'nd Zimmer. ' As I understand tho Zimmer situation from Nuc1 conics .We6k and The Wall
.- Street. ' Journal lhore .was a completc .and total.becakdown of 10 CPR
],[.50/. ; Appendir B. requircinents' bdcauue .locaI%anagement was treatin '
- gthe? aprojecti as
- ;most people,Twould' treat'a fossil.~ plant. ~
That;
.~~ S
' F~' -certainly}ilisi p :; . y.% fiot"the.. " qy,q canew~dt" .y +. Con.nnche e 7 2 :n Pcak.- . -
" ~ ~ ~
- 10. I. 'd'icagree entirely with the statement that " Comanche is doingi. inspections to tho' ' degree that they (Comanche Peak) are comfortable :with iorit.will. .
tole ra t e" . .The coating effort,-. if-
'idfove'ri idsp5ct'ed
- See..sparagraph :2d 'above. . :- ,
anything,Qk%:QQ?Q'
. V g; y~N4Q:=QR .~: l .
"3 - l;:-:~ l 11..
I disagree with.'this .. .
statement.
. ? .. L ': .2 12 s. My .isprincion of. Comanche Peak: management differs from that of Joc T,ipir.uky 's. .
7' .n . .
.a ? y y 5 ..M d .3.M Q 5:5% .~+ . - -
.; lh hIWhavoyino^knosiddge-llof z Couancho Peak.. management-. attempting-Y
.i toRTpi$a.dh*':yGC%8blessWM$ihi3fe.GionXist that .they;want' to..do g- .Ithingd f!jc6ry{66W.5bdtM1tieyhcr6'kbe'cominky.; t'i~redJ. ',of. T havin~g .h t o a ting o.f f~or.t. S
ton,:$thC.c'o~
t (J r einv.e. n tu.w.hc .. .w, d3j,.1Ateh.c,.cl.r.ev,e ryi.
M ydan y,g3
,.u _.d . . . .
.. w, :., . 9 6 c ., .u. . , f g t::n? ..
. .. . 3 z. .9.:r,t'havn
- . . @ m% e. g yQ;, [e n o j ,.,: o.. ..::thefinspection ' staff 's;trying l to
.14j nowRdge.;c
-i .G . .P; t . . -' -
'. lcave
>.,.:.q.;the."
,.g a. .
.qggy~rasse*r site.'"cni;5M.. g' " M7
- Df.g&,V.M'. .r.~ 6
~
- -. ' .- .R. : 4. ,
I57, Di'tto. . . . .?.'$.. M. b, ~m ?,""
. oi.g .
~
p ;' ?x. +: . ; _.
- 16. The internal disagreement is self-explanatory por the responses above and below.
- 17. I did not perceive this. hostility. I heard that TUSI/B&R has recently undergone an audit and has received a passing grade accord *ng.to Tolson. -
- 18. That's for C.icholine to ptovide guidelines as CZ-ll their product.
- 19. Dit to.
- 20. I don't aurce bere. TUSI was of course alarmed that painting taight rnd e up en the project's critical rath, indeed, become the cri ti ca l pa th.' They wanted advice on how best to get the painting effort on the right track, but certainly within t.he spirit and 1ctter of the law.
21,. I can't clarify the "revork contraet" stalcracnt.
Pago 4 of 4 .
o .
w ,
q- -
. ( 0,. ) ,
\' ;-22.- I' would'.disagrc'e 'because of'the. purported results of the a-Wtesting : effort. -Additionally,.I had not ccviewed the adequacy or ~
~
.s'.Tresults of.the< retrofit program.
,.P ** y . , ,
.- , , . ._ :. .. .st. . . ,
.. ..,.i. .
239.;~I. only;know that I. received a copy of Joc's report, which I
.have not" released from my office. '
. gRiG,k . . : .. -
g.~24 A a iI di '. .Rc2.Q ~;j; .;..i!;3d not: communicate .with Sny.on$ abotit' .
nor th g f Kfdfd.";I; [ send .aicopyyof.jthe trip report to anyone.
My secretary is
- .7-5theif.]only-T otherR percon . 'inL IIoust.on that could pocuibly have seen
'the report and' che says' that she did not. -
... . :/ _,..
. Dur' in'g - Tmy.. . . visits, .. consultations, ~
site interfaces, etc. I would
- noti ' describe- -the- site sctivitics, convercation's and meetings as -
" Ea'nythingi but a"$6hkadhy.Gattempt'* by .TUSI t.o recolvo perceived
~
'1problemsf in.~th'e' .' coa ting:. 'lcf fo r t.. To imply anything else is irresponsible .; With fuel 'lood'. approaching and the attendant pressures.. there disi bounde to be. a '
nervous, somewhat cautious ateiosphere.- c*.' ' .-?.;.; *
'~ ~ . .
. :S ~.
. Ll.:!...$ L >;g %: ......: ~17.'QC.i .cn;.,.: .'; :4 .,.
. s.m . . , . . ,
- Mye.u g* ltpa%
p d c. .n s. _ t m - K -*i ..;+',;; 3.;.,;c3 v
~*
. , :E::
.QiWi4 X t , ,fff,JK ;%:p.3a1;;l?
yy,s ~ n ~~..;:c
- 2.M.y.t:9%% %f$vt
, =L u a w; 2.:~s%
-Wgs.'p:.&::
.t*~', gm. Q' %~%Qe% c . 5,1R. . -
w l~~. %; y,. ,'
x . -
.g 2gg,y, .g, .,4z k ' '
2 '"?w;.'.*IQ: ..
- ;-'.;ad;g,Q:'W;Q?q%h.m? ? +%./.*@&. v.s.W i'; ' NQil:f?*if]:'Xy ,
- Vpr '. "HiQsb' ;-
.- r: . s W. ..
.m 2 ' s ,:.v u. ,:::W;n.a
.- m :, s ~ .,,.
c' .d .. ,z: *
,~
. .p:,.'.s ;p.y5. .n..-:..i.~S. Qf .,Q*hg}gk.3.. ;?a! '.&,> .p-l.'w h, ".-..'-w. r W.e,***:;'.i ; ;, v% .. *. ,1 Oj k 'U:.^:;R s
- <
- ~i 3 X 7..L'!.%C~'5
- f rz j
. .: q;d y 3.;.,...r.$tg
.". - : .1.p. o.< rp 3,:. .. . , . . . , ..: ; , . .
...s.~. g.::: .,:,.% ,u. t s .
,. - ( + ,:,,
- g.-* c. . ., k- . .y, g .. .s,q ?~ -, . .
. g c ,. - 3.,.. . .~
e .
4 g.
\
O . .
l .
_.