ML19341D681
| ML19341D681 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Catawba  |
| Issue date: | 03/31/1981 |
| From: | Parker W DUKE POWER CO. |
| To: | James O'Reilly NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION II) |
| References | |
| 10CFR-050.55E, 10CFR-50.55E, NUDOCS 8104080410 | |
| Download: ML19341D681 (49) | |
Text
{{#Wiki_filter:r- r i DUKE POWER COMPANY Powen Butt.ntxo 420 Sot:Tri Curucu STnerr. Criant.oTTr. N. C. 2c242 m u 3. . , c . . . March 31, 1981 v.cc pacs.oc - c.c.. s cs.c. m 5'can RecoucT1oas 3
- 3- 4C 3 3 Mr. James P. O'Reilly, Director D U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Cocmission 8
'
Region II 101 Marietta Street, Suite 3100 @f uf Atlanta, Georgia 30303 k $[p~ b' Q s$ . A g i
/ '
Re: Catawba Nuclear Station .N Units 1 and 2 gf , 's 8 i V
'
Docket Nos. 50-413 and 50-414
Dear Mr. O'Reilly:
Please find attached a final response to Significant Deficiency Report SD 413-414/80-10. Very truly yours,
. .
William O. Parker, Jr. RWO:ses Attachment ec: Director NRC Resident Inspector Office of Inspection and Enforcement Catawba Naclear Station 50/1 s ll 0104080 g S -
/
DUKE POWER COMPANY CATAWBA NUCLEAR STATION , FINAL REPORT ON
-USE OF hlN-NORMALIZED '0NE-HALF INCH PLATE MATERIAL THAT WAS NOT IMPACT TESTED IN CONSTRUCTION OF ASME CODE STAMPED PERSONNEL AIR LOCKS Unit 1 Air Lock Marks C-100 and C-300 -
Unit 2 Air. Lock Marks C-100 and C-300
-REPORT N0. SD 413-414/80-10
!- [
'
,
- I
.
l-
'
L- !
- .
r l
.
l-March 31, 1981'- [ l ! L.
_
* ,
Report No. SD 413-414/80-10 March 31, 1981
- 1. Introduction
- 2. Background and Investigation
- 3. Description of Deficiency
- 4. Safety 1.5plications I
- 5. Corrective Action to be Taken
- 6. Attachments 6.1 W. J. Woolley Co. letter dated November. 20, 1979
, 6.2 W. J. Woolley Co. Drawing No. 32'50 6.3 W. J. Woolley Co. Corrective Action Request #1047-1, Rev. 3 6.4 Nonconforming Item Report S/N 7999
- 6. 5_ Hartford Steam Boiler letter dated June 5,1980 6.6 ASME letter dated May 28, 1980
- 6. 7 W. J. Woolley Co. letter dated July 7,1980 6.8 W. J. Woolley. letters dated August 7 and 8, 1980 6.9 Table of Mechanical and Impact Test Properties 6.10 W. J. Woolley Co. Sample Removal Procedure 6.11 Certified Charpy -Impact Test Reports
.
e
.
}
Report No. 50 413-414/80-10 March 31, 1981 Page 1
- 1. Introduction Non-normalized one-half inch plate materials (SA-516 Gr. 70) purchased without Charpy impact testing were used in fabrication of ASME Code stamped personnel
' air locks for the Catawba Nuclear Station. The personnel locks, therefore, did not meet the specified requirements of the Catawba PSAR, Section 3.8.2.1 (2). This final report is being filed as required'by 10 CFR 50.55(e) to document this deficiency and to provide Duke Power Company's evaluation and the corrective action taken. A possible deficiency was first discovered by W. J. Woolley Company in November, 1979 (Attachment 6.1). A review, by the parties involved, of the material documentation including interpretive inquiries to ASME indicated that a deficiency did exist, applicable to Catawba personnel locks, Units 1 and 2 (Serial Numbers 32360, 32385, 32290 and 32335). Duke Power Company reported the deficiency to the NRC, Region II, as a 10 CFR 50.55(e) item on July 11, 1980. An interim report (No. 50 413-414/80-10) was submitted in August,1980.
- 2. Background Information ,
The four (4) personnel air locks for the Catawba Nuclear Station were designed by the W. J. Woolley Company of River Forest, Illinois. This company also supervised the, fabrication of the locks by their subcontractor, Lamco Industries, Inc. of El Cajon, California. -The general arrangement of the personnel locks is the same for all locks and is shown on drawing 32360 (Attachment No. 6.2). One-half inch SA-516 Grade 70 plate material was used in fabrication of the lock barrel, bulkheads, , stiffeners, and miscellaneous attachment supports and mounting plates. Cn November 16, 1979, Duke ' Power Company was informed by telecon (and follow-up letter dated November 20,1979) from W. J. Woolley Company of a possible ASME Code violation concerning this material. Since-that time, the problem has been under investigation by Duke Power Company, W. J. .Woolley Company, Lamco Industries, Inc. and Hartford Steam Boiler, the Authorized Inspection Agency. During the cour.- of the investigation, an apparent conflict was noted between paragraphs NE-2121(c) and NE-2311(a) of Section' III and the ASME material specification. Accordingly, an inquiry was sent to the ASME for a code interpretation. The response received indicated that the material :in question did deviate: from the ASME Code requirements,
. thus resulting in a 50.55(e) deficiency (See Attachments 6.5, 6.6 and 6.7).
.
Report No. SD 413-414/80-10 March 31, 1981 Page 2
- 3. Descriotion of Deficiency One-half inch ASME SA-516 Grade 70 PVQ carbon steel plate used in the fabrication of Catawba personnel locks S/N 32350, 32385, 32290 and 32335 was purchased-by Lamco Industries, Inc. in violation of ASME Section III, Subsection NE, Paragraph 2121.2, 1971 Edition, Summer of 1972 Addenda.
This deficiency is noted on W. J. Woolley Company Corrective Action Request Number 1047-1, Rev. 3 (attachment 6.3). The air locks have been tagged at the jobsite in accordance with Duke Power Company Catawba Nonconforming Item Report S/N 7999 (Attachment 6.4).
- 4. Safety Imolications The material in question was not normalized or Charpy imoact tested.
Normalizing of material is done primarily to improve incact properties and enhance ductility. For non-normalized material, Charpy impact testing assures minimum requirements are met. This is particularly important fo low temperature applications. Examination of the maximum stress levels for the Catawba personnel locks indicates that they are well within the elastic range for all loading condi tions. In addition, steady state thermal analyses of the Reactor Building complex indicate that the minimum personnel lock temperature will be above 480F, Therefore, actual design conditions would preclude the need for normalizing
- or Charpy testing except to meet an ASME Code requirement.
'If this deficiency had gone. undetected, public safety would not have been jeopardized.
.
_ E. Corrective Action The personnel locks were-fabricated using non-normalized one-half inch plate material from 20 slabs taken from 8 different heats. This material
-is acceptable, however, to meet the requirements of paragraph NE-2121(c) of the ASME-Code, Charpy impact tests are required. A Charpy impact testing program 'for these materials was developed and has been completed.
. m
_ Report No. SD 413-414/80-10 March 31, 1981 Page 3 Some plate material common to personnel locks being fabricated for another utility was available in the fabricator's shop. In addition, some excess plate material used in the fabrication of the Catawba personnel locks was also available. Samples from this available material were Charpy impact tested in accordance with the requirements of ASME Section III, Subsection NE, Paragraph 2351, 1971 Edition, Summer of 1972 Addenda. This testing was done at Durkee Testing Laboratories, Gardena, California, and was witnessed by W. J. Woolley Quality As:urance personnel. For the remaining slabs, samples were secured from the personnel locks at the construction site. These samples were Charpy impact tested at Law Engineering Testing Company in Charlotte, NC and Atlanta, GA. Charpy testing and sample removal was witnessed by W. J. Woolley Co. and Duke Power Co. Quality Assurance personnel. The following infomation is included as documentation for the Charpy impact testing program: (a) Attachment 6.8 - W. J. Woolley Co. letters dated August 7 and 8,1980 concerning scope of required site sampling, testing and restoration of locks to full ASME Code compliance. ! (b) Attachment 6.9 - Summary table of mechanical and impact test properties for identified nonconforming material. (c) Attachment 6.10 - W. J. Woolley Co. sample removal procedure 1047-1A, Rev.- 2, including sketches of actual sample locations. (d) Attachment 6.11 - Certified Charpy impact test reports. The results of-the Charpy testing program indicate that all material previously identified as being deficient is now in full compliance with , , applicable ASME Code requirements and the Owner's Design Specification and l Safety Analysis Reports. - l l ihe personnel locks will be fully restored to their original state prior '
-to samp l e remova l . This work including materials, welding, NDE inspection and retesting, as required, will be done in accordance with the requirements i of Subsection NE, Section III of the ASME Code and under the provisions of l Section XI, including the Owner's site Quality Assurance Program for ASME Code work. All work will be inspected and approved by the Owner's Quality Assurance personnel and the site ASME Authorized Nuclear Inspector. .The restoration work will be completed by December 31, 1982.
r f a L
ATTACHMENTS
.
l I e 9 a ! ! 1 *
r CIVIL lEN u m ,~ sus: ' -~
--
STRUCTURAL SEC. =.u.... . 3 r n r ' ii , J.M';ff?!?E h. Jn, r-- a E b t ; y t, e , u:-- - a
; Wr jMErp.
'- ,
r - ... NOV2 61979 ) ry? Q: ja; . f.Mi ^, f %59iiEse.4;;p'.'shJ . DIVISIOllln~L:.--a CCPY M * " '*" **'^ ~
; FILE 110.__
November 20, 1979 -
]A'.J.]n]'oolle t'o.
Duke Power Conpany 422 South Church Street Charlotte, North Carolina 28242 Attention: Mr. N. C. Awada.1.la
Subject:
Catawba Personnel Airlocks Centlenen: This letter is to confirn our telecon of November 16, 1979 concerning a possible reportable item to the N.R.C. Our fabricator, Lacco Industries Inc., purchased one-half inch plate which we believe was received in a non-normalized condition. This material was ordered without the Charpy testing requirenent per NE2311 of the ASME. Paragraph NE2121(b) recuires in excess of one quarter inch that is not Charpy tested to be normalized, fully killed and fine grained. All conditions except the nornalizing have been met. , The W. J. Woolley Company is investigating steps that can be taken to establish the acceptability of this material. Please be assured that we will make every effort to bring this to a satisfactory conclusion. . Very truly yours,
.
'
W. J. WOOLLEY COMP "Y
,
s - C. A. Kucht Vice President CAK/t f- ' cc: 'VA Bicicchi. DA Codfrey-File 1047 _
.- J i. . . . . .
...- es f ' u. . . %. . ~l < ;
'
.
S 2 h EI e It 27 jo 4 8 3 l. M i wg .,9,n
~ -
H k s .$ Ikp
-
>. :
%. ..
.
O.t
.
1 3,.4 i e s ;; f.s.. a. 2 %, ,* 3,-MF W,
,
- ,
e) :;
'
.. J ;- s t'sr"5
;
.
. 1 1 g, .{
2 3'I o3 r'
'
N-1C%w/inwr "r 'l23:g--y ". 7-8 j - 1 O%.16 U!j
.
'
, %# . ,
, 'yy Y ;.
m* i._ll:,;;l Q N+ ;; g #, h 55U=c@ c_a!-i
.
!, ea r-
- a %
d;5Y
, ,
. . . . . . . . ,
'
. .
'
\ Ll5fL q- z kN 9M
'
- . :=hf!
;- %
J ' Cysj i m..I? e ; $]u )sU h j l5 , v,'w rn~~ y/
- -
3
,
.:
'
o, Rv%j3
- s ti W 1:
-
j ' ' i i IW
- . -
A
.
-
- /
"
% i
-
.m 5 ~'nTuiRR@
nun .w
;i
'.
QJw.
,
ij , f ,
.
[
*
#iM u
!!
y g
.
/ -
i ;
\b y
- .
q
' ,3 f t fjj s
3 /l i
.
,4 i@n
. .!!,k'.
Ith j
'
I '
'3 ? U 19$
.) a
*
- h a l3 3 .a .,,a g
.
j${ f, a y
.s d g;a; . ,..b ghp a .$
-I r 3
u- g$ 1 i$$ g. C $= h3 at .
@ah.%7h. : g,ty; iML' q
, ..
g- 3 8 G EE* it' ** i t : 8
.
s
!g i a<sj -9!r L =(e2 arj-n
- [
t / = = .h. I 1 sas a r-a _, 2
=-
t
.
-
-
8 -99dir n
- .!
m Y *h
,
\ '
/ ita!.sjMis 1
] I -
- i -
p#m k / .i
'
& s ~e
-
^" J I
.
.
- e. _
. -
.
/
/ -
-
.
- 9 g s(
-
-
W s $$!i!!o.Mili
~Ic *pa..
2 - m oo -
! k ~d Ed N 9 8 b 15hd {
.
' lC34 '.\. *ll,
.
~I g .. .
"
h *,
,
,
i z una un .g.6
>
p - - b M b .. .
'. .,
- I*. y1 5 *b R
' .'ll .
-
e: 9 ?.'
*-
5
-
* '
?- y
'
.[. }W
, ~ . . . . . .
'
.
!., iil /\ d t
r-s
.
h .q =
.
p il _4%, g
- --
, _
j g a .
,
- _
d h i--- I ~ e __' Ny M.
.
,I
}g }up... .f j
'
_
!
~ / -l s 4
- -
L ..
.:a '
W t t'
.-
M n. , T F -
, g.
,d, *l
, s. .
5lI-e
.
n3.-
, ,
.
,
H. 4 i u._. .& ^: {i
- - - - -
.-
i t
+1 a
a
;
( 3g 1
!
.
p tw - (1 - N q . ds =! s 'e N
'
l \f" o,j(,2 5
- m'
-
-
#h, N 1
; a s, aI '%,.,,,e
!Nx , w . = i--l i
,
i ' 7 ,.
.
i g rt u .,: A f
.k, r *gD i M_,y.-i._.h. 2 4 .si .'i i h( . 3$ # s' Z$, . l ze
,
. , _ y
,9 +
.
.,
s %
-
.;:' i '
d .s
- e ~i q f~[;. j- l [n N h *. .Y ----UNh. l %!fd f / .A
'
'
- - e [
p - , u e n. j a/
,, /
ti ., i' -'i,1.;
- y[ i
.
-
L"" , / 4
- 2
{v : 3 , g
,,,
'
- .. >f , /
-
, .my .
.
',-j -
/ f
.
,-
l- m, J "; ; r' ~j.-- ' li / 1 g , { a $' ? ' l . i <! / !
'
..
! Y. i ' -;':: -[If ,
we.
.
* < * '
.
.
.
li h q[ Y, i!
..
F -( f-. %
,
' ,- - % i -
l ;,'
.:
' '
. , , . ?' b *~~~4.'W =, ;G' , 3 ~*
' '.*, .
. ..s. __ _..o 3 . .
> .. + :
- 1
- Corrective Action Recruest 0DO MEMS
"
agug37 f,g, La=qo Industries 1047-1 Rev. 3 AS E Section III, Subsection NE, ' El Cajon, CA Paragraph 2121.2, 1971 Edition, SHCP ORCE3 AFFECTE] W .7. w o or a j c.o 101.7 AVGt. Aa scr , /4. t , Summer of 1972 Addenda DISCREPANCY Catawba Airlocks S/N 32360, 32385, 32290, 32335 1/2" AS!E-SA-516. CR.70 PVQ Carbon' Steel Plate It has been noted that the above centioned material, which was purchased by La=co
-
Industries, Inc., is in violation of ASME Section III,. Subsection NE Paragraph ,, 2121.2, 1971 Edition, Su=cer of 1972 Addenda. -
.
.
.
. .
.
REVIEW ED RESPO.1SE REQUIRED REQUEST INITIATED f)g , h / . ., . TITLE Manager 6f. Quality Assuranet U
- N/A
, ! DaTE 3/18/81 DATE 3/18/81 [ Cf* CORRECTIVE ACTION Corrective Action as defined.in Rev. 2 revised as follows: 4
- 1) Charpy test samples [or each heat / slab are identified on enclosed Sketch 1[6,7,8, 9.and 12. Heat / slab numbers shall be transferred to samples prior to removal
, , >_
from part. Duke Power will remove samples under W. J. Woolley supervision (See enclosed procedure 1047-1A)
- 2) Charpy i= pact test to be perfor:ed at 18*F or less (see enclosed Rev. 5 of Spec. CNS-ll44.13.1) test lab to be. subcontracted and approved by W. J. Woolley Co. (See enclosed test reports)
- 3) If tests are acceptable, lock parts where samples were removed shall be repaired in accordance with applicable spec. and code requirements.
'
__
,
.
.
-
..
,
""ti:n Approved Cort n rptquisey L' 8 ' ' ' -
- C T tl Tit lM[[M k c e -_ <
, Cate wCom unr0)f/~0l d t~ s. Ost, 5--/,Y#$'/
b hh Corrective Action a roved Verifica no 46G62 / b 0empt fica
/
/
WJW QUALili AQUdA.%c M4sAGtd , , _ ,
'# *'
DATE " 7-/hM/ Dats b/b
# .
. ,,l
_
~~
-
.
*
---7 y M (- ,k,, FORM O-IA lREVISICN 9 f.
;,.. .. s.r.: ss = o. 2. <c acca /tc< Arica (;cc' s ewrs vic( Arto DuxE PCwER CC'tPcNy U n 5 // W 1 3 -1 CC.NS TRUC TION C E Pa 't T V E N T
._ T'
^
'
l I L8 af - t 3.. ol '/ + pgesger cam,M aic t l g, u,s to =o
's ** Cia /ttt: srsion' 7bott xc t.cc cr- f!'P p.: C Q ' $ GET /8'2.
4'
,
,
A . 08 53 6
' h s =" " --
NONCONFORMING ITE.'.i REPORT
- Nst [f ts C P40
*
- t. :'g wiricAT::s m a is > '3-st?a C3 nC. anc
-
.
C Of *.f w IUSE SLACK SALL PCINT PEN ONLY) a or ac-:2L -
, ocan:,crsitas h / A % u s _L L t.. r m.tr. w h a i s. s s -'a' w h f. , , . . .f . 9 9 4/ ab cl 7 uc.- v.v /h.o cC u e~ W e 4 2. D9 a ,a euc..,rw c,rvo.4 osrm es.,re, ac uv v m
hj@,Ls Lt %.4 k W /YL Y Y .I ? e s/% b% W @ =' L lLL .ns.* l E 13 a zebu.L U.L+ da.L&c-- sul.w1G.w MeL c,v avm'ta_. At~Jr.-v
' c- ioo cm d_, UC.-3cO c.vt_ t.Actu-su % v d/tcu c t.i
'
.2 c A./ - / o 'i-2 - Y A x, (MaJrc c h c-4. A sin E.
-
J4,c L cm iu hC w N E (S EE T,IG Anc !WeD SW E F'I d A ' 5 y .
-
[ Y ELQ .? Lts M M- C L'Sh ! . . $ l % .J L.%2.C] A vLt M l.A.rtN.lt
'(q :'
c u nw sua m ucx ' '
-
CJ l k, . ev2mr 2~,:is,csir.: .es wie:orv o Cact cr .esic a c cA c ~sss ,. av_xmu _ _i@ b ,i t cue. nare s . cars it ses.cn e.g,a. arverw :.at e Di c. 4 s e vie w =4re
. W. Re6c%cw __ 3/Ms'c .21. G12 4L .3-44-fdl _ fJ,-C7?ctecw 3- 2 W [O__
'* cis :strics
(./ l'8 se, car to acor. C 'rs C 'o EYAL'Ja fl0 4/Ju t tlFIC ATaQ1 e e e _ e n@ 11
. - n u \ h \ D P '~-
.nM MV
-
Vg \.\UD
-
l = o
- _ __
."3 39 CT CATC 23 T10P4fC AI, A,840Vab OATE 28 Q A 458SCVAL OATO o
x
'
ACTSC*t/ s % 2
- tC TION n l0*Jt e tC r e
-
Catt o --
-
J . . . _ _ , c l l l 1 I l ' l l
.
. !
~
j ! a i, 2.r e cm j j 2 o . .,,. c< 6 a ,<1.e ,,,s.u ,.,
,,:,.r.n u . ...4..,
c .-. m s. c c . : u. u .I g eq . ... .nn ,s a _w ,
-
,3 r . , w , s ., ,.cacr
,
s a.c aci. g .c sver .p#...
- is... i it %.. T. .qs cae.i y ; j j tuve(w g'1_*aa.
.
. i l l 1 t i t I f a p .
1 4 g a s e CF C e* !? t 2 4 *:% , 1 * : l . . I e I ! a * .
- f I2'
, .,,,s ,,, ,. ******%" ** * *
.i
-
'.
. -
THE HARTFORD STEAM BOILER g; d. C T{% IN S P E CTI O N and INSURANCE COMPANY moo HARTFORD . CO N N ECTIC UT 06102 Cll!CAGO OFrICE SUITE 416,120 50. RIVERSIDE PLAZA, CHICACO, ILLINOIS 60606 i312 643 7000 , June 5, l'980 Ccry To; W.J. Woolley Co. d dO VNd 7425 West Lake Street gg a River Forest, Illinois 60305 Attn.: Mr. Charles A. O'Deay /J6 Manager of Q.A. gg
SUBJECT:
CATAWBA fiUCLEAR POWER PLAtiT cad -24 F/td (DUXEPOWERCOMPAfiY) Uti1TS 1 & 2 PERS0?ltiEL AIRLOCKS Dm g 4'
Dear Sir:
Please find attached a photocopy of an answer to an inquiry concerning SA-516 material,
,
According to the inquiry fiE-2121(c) allows that the material (SA-516) either be normalized or have impact testing performed which ceets the acceptance criteria of flE-2300. In order for the Personnel Airfocks in question for the Catawba tiuclear Power Plant to meet the requirements of the ASME Code the material of the lock would have to be either normalized or perfom impact testing as required. 'Therefore, the material used in the fabrication of the Personnel Airlocks must be impact tested if not normalized. An alternative would be to remove the ASME Code Stamping and furnish a ncn-code Data Report in lieu of the ASME Code Data Report if this would be acceptable to the owner. , If you have any further questions on the above, please do not hesitate to contact me. . Verytulyyours,j
$ "" .
D.P. Stewart Regional Manager " S.I.S. Division OPS:cel Q [,{ pj{ } Encl. JUN 0 91550 W. J. WOOLLEY CO.
. '.. .
*
..~.
/ n i
! C The American Society of Mechanical Engineers
\ %. @ S JJ I
United Engineering Center
- 345 E. 47th St.. New York. N.Y.10017 e 2124&4 7722
- TWX-710-5315257
/
For I ::a.- e i"V.'"; ' - THE BolLER AND --
" PRESSURE VESSEL COMMITTEE
.
$'b
! .f~i
',
'
,
- FID : :
t ceirm,, May 28, 1980 {,', [
.g ,
P. M. BRISTER
*~ f ,, __ y J . g - - -
r rfn ; . vice.cnoim,an ' ~ ~ ~
** ' "#R U'"U The Hartford Steam Boiler -
4 f :--- p t Inspection and Insurance Company
^
secretary <4, - G. M. EISEN BEPr; Hartford, CT 06102 '
,
,gg-; s
,
, . . . . . . .
, ,
B.W.BACE Att: DXP
- Mr. R. E. Feigel R. D. f ONNER ' ?6' t . ,
,
R. J. SOSNA K ' M. N. BR ESSLER
Subject:
Section III, Division 1, V.W.BUTLE? NE-2120 Pressure Retaining Material
- n. J. cEPLUCH t J.CHOCm gg.2311 Material For Which Impact Testing W. E. COOPER is Required.
W.D. DOTY
'
B. G. EARNHEART Ref: Your letter of April 1,1980 O.R. GALLUP ASME File # NI-80-55 R. M. GIBSON R. C. GRIF FIN . S. F. H AR RISON Gentlemen:
- E. J. H EMZY E. L. KEM M LER Our understanding of the question in your inquiry, and ot.r J. W. xlu E reply are as follows
J. E. LATTAN j,jC0F , eg,y Ouestion: Is it required that'SA-516 material, exempted by W.n.MIKESELL NE-2311(a) from impact testing, be normalized if impact test-R.H.uCELLER ing is perfomec as allowed in NE-2121(c)? F. N. MOSCHINI P [. ,9,p,RKER E. NOR " Reolv: No, NE-2121(c) allows that the material described in C. E. R AWLINS the inquiry either be normalized or have impact testing per-R.F.CEEDY fomed which meets the acceptance criteria of NE-2300. - W. R. SMITH. SR. W. E. SOMER3 Yours truly, i
. s.~ ,
John Millman k. [ (' E [ \[ E D Assistant Secretary ENG..v.,Elg (212) 644-8049 a <. . t lc
. E30
,
.
E. L VIMMLIR 3 D s- p . 4 .
.RL.Lr' eu 1 11 --
C. ' , l l JU,10 01930
t,tember of Engineers Council for Professional Development and Engineers Joint I an it i g Q,
-
.. ..
. ( < c\,ndt. .
- tan \\ -
, Eb,..";., ,: ra .c - a.
.D',. ; ~- . . n.-- - e. cw. . . :sm
.
.
s' 'e . i@h,.Ojr,t j,W! _
-
t .. m
. -em e"M
,
Ql l] y_ July 7, 1960-
.n Colcj Gs0
' JS i, t .s
'"p',iMdyM7/ii@c-
.. .
_- + m.ns\CV " CON. i;.\ ,\
,
v,\g.no. 7 )J. y Duke Power Company 422 Church Street Charlotte, NC 28242 Attention: Mr. N. C. Awadalla
Reference:
Catawba Nuclear Station Units 1 6 2 Personnel Air Locks Mill Power P.O.1 A-98536
Dear !!r. Awadalla:
With reference to Corrective Action Request 1047-1 Rev. 2. We have submitted our proposed disposition to our ANI (Hartford Steam Boiler Inspection Agency):
- They have reviewed and. submitted an inquiry to the ASME. , Please find the res-ponse enclosed.
It is the intent of the Woolley Company to meet the applicable require =ents based on the ASME Code interpretation. Therefore, we will have to take actual physical specimens for testing from the hardware. A complete list which will include size of specimens and location will be forthcoming (no later than 7-31-80 ). The actual cutting is to be performed by personnel supplied by Duke Power Co., which shall be under the supervision of a W. J. Woolley Co. representative. Your patience in this =atter has certainly been appreciated. Sincerely, .
'
W. J. WOOLLEY COllPANY ,
e7 o-C. A. O'Deay Manager of Quality Assurance CAD /nb
..
cc: K. L. Hladek V. A. Biciechi R. A. Maffei C. A. Diokno D. A. Codfrey ! C. A. Kuehl C. T. Blue L W.J. Wmiley Co.
.-. . _ . ~ . - . -
-
. _ . - _ _ - _ - - .a.
.!
'
! ,
i
-
k g.-_ wy g. , .-~. :s.. $h.
. . ,
j $ - \ ,~,\ ,p,;. T33C 7. 1980 ~D hAeswM6
.
WMimCW
? Duke Power Co=pany
- 422. Church Scroct
- Charlotte, NC 23142' .
j i '
'
.tttentico: E. G. Arada11a.
i Subjecr: Catawba.Airlocks s/Is 32360, 32385, 32290, 32335 t 1/2.* m 516 Ca.70 PVQ Carboe Steel Plata i Referencer correct:Ye Action Request - 1047-1 24w 2-
'
Centlemen: a
,
This is tot infor:s the Duke Pceme co the m===c In which the W J. Voolley Co.
',
- intends to renova and replace speci= ens from the above aubject airlocks; so
,
that Charpy "T hacch testing can. he perforced ca the subject starial in' ordsr that the specific. code and..specif testion requiracanca carr he: une.
,
j
'
It has been addressed' that onIr the heat nu=bers be Inde=tified. Please itad ! enclosed. Lance letter dated 2-25-30 with. concurrence by the IIsrtforti Steaar i Boiler Inspection and Insurssa= ca , The follcwing heats which were ident1fied to be in conf 1tet with the Ccdm m,e as follows: l A) Heze. f77175 D1 Rest #3L782. l [ E) ht (M014
>
s} N r.J75462 l C) h e #96152; T) Heat 113437 G) Rear 191503 Eeats A,, S. and C have been tasted',, the rennIts are enclosed.
-
i ! 1
The heats which remais to be, ta=ced are as follows:
~
' l Henc t
'
. D) 3I732 '
j E y G: a t h..
! F1 13437' I G) 91803
>
i Enclosed. please: find Sketches 1, 2. II. sud 12 Re r.1 shich gI.ves all per:1:ee infor:stion; Ic relation. to the above heat nu=hers. These sketches. alser depi~ce. l[ che. size 'and. Incatioit of the- tast spec.imens.
- -
.
I
! (I.)
E
- ,
*
!
.a
!
' WLWoolferCo. -.
; ,
1
~
I - W.. J. WO OI. LEY CDM2?_.'N
!
i l l Duke Power Company l Attention: Mr h C.. Aradalla ' i Page 2. ' i
h , ! ! I 1 MATERIAL RIM 07AL
, '
1 I W J'. Woolley Company (Mr.. Ales Pocius) will be on the job site 3/21/3G to , I suparvlac,. the locating, markin./ident.ifyinn
= and curring; of the test speci= ens l As we agreed, Duke. Ecwer: persone=1. shall. perform the abov- activfeins, under -
L J.. Wealley company supervision..
.
t
,
II. )MTEZIAI.' TESTING
.
Cnce the specimens have beerr remavad' and properly identified, they shall be pro-scuted. to x quaWied' testing Isherstorf to Charpy V Yotch the spect= ens is. arder
-
ca mess. Code and. apecificacion. requir*eents.
! ,
l
- The laboratory to be used vill be forthcoming. prior to the enceing af. the: speer:-
mena, aIsa to include tentative schedule for testing.- Upon cc=pletion af testing the spec 1= ens and its related documents:ica. shatI be rerieved. by the L J Vanlley Co. and Duke, Pcuer ConpanT to again as= urn. en:qli.- ance. with Code..and agecification. requirements.
'
III M.CT.IIAL. 2Z70 NTr t t i- , Picco ro. 32292-9' (Sketch 2) a=d Frece No. 32293-3 (Sketch.1) ars the anly air - l Iock segssnes where specin**ue vill have been renoved which will require replace-- nones.by wcIding. A.U. repair welding. shall. be done in accordance with the Code
. and specification. requirements - Piece. No.- 32305-5 (sketchi 2),
( !
,
This. specI=ca is. shipped loose froa the airlocks and will be replacod: congletery i by supplying Duke. Pwer Company with. a new piece.
.
[ Pieca No. 32293-I & 10 (C -e-h 11). f The mounting bracket can be used with the piece cut out of. the: support This cut i out has no erect onc the functrom af. this bracket. ' I
! This Ite:s is separate and not an. ittegral part of the airIcck.
-
l : ! *
.
The Hartford Steau Hof.ler In.spection .sgency ha. heen contacresi. Ther have sca.ted
; (W J. ITigginbotham) that. the pieces which a2e requ. ired to be. re;tlaced by wcIding
- l. y
, shall be done tw accordance with. Se.ctroa XI of the ASME Code.- Since the airloc!c.
~ ;- bas already been stanped with the "N." symbol.
l j
- i ,
P00R ORIGINAL. i 1. i , . _ _ _ . . . . _ . _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
_ l
.
. . . .. . . . u v L A.L 4 .....t2 .
'
e
- l. Duke Fever Cecpacy-
.' Attention: F.:. E.. G. Avada1Ls i Pager 3 i ! A meeting shal.L be scheduled between the W. J. Voolley Co:pany and Duka Ecuer j ta discuss schadole sud reyhemment. of the abow specified natorials-I
! Upon cc=pletion. of. the. weld repair the air locks shall be pressure: a-4 lesh I decrf tested in, accordance with,7 J Voolley approved procedures *
.
I If.' you-hase any questions, plesse courset. =4..
-
I ' - Tours truly f
; - -
! j vg4vvccu.iT. ID3Atfr ' g Q' 1
,
,
, .
-
cN .' f x. se.e omauty-u.;irone.. t - ' i CACP l ( i
!' .
cc:: V. .i. 31ciecht
} r.. L nIadek.
! R A. Maffei
'.
i 'G 7 31ue.
! C A. Dickno
' i D.. A. Codf sy-I . , l i '
!.
I t .
,
.
1 i i l !
-
t l ' 1 i ' t
'
.
l : l I i -
!
i
! ,3
=
i ' iI > $ '
!, P00R ORIGINAL.
L-
-
.
_- __ . . . . _ . ._ _
CiYiLJ5!yiR0::';g'-[ STRUCTURAL SEC1\c;I R E C E / V E f) ..*Aam.e
'
AUG 1219c0 r
;
[ August 8, 1980 DIVISlonl RECORDS Co?Y FILE NO. 22.usevwle N hM r}. Duke Power Cocpany 432 Church Street . Charlotte, NC 28242 Attention: N. C. Awadalla
Subject:
Catawaba Airlocks !!. J. Woolley* S/N 32360, 32335, 32290, 32535 Lanco S/N 963, 964, 965, 966 Corrective Action Request 1047-1 Rev. 2
Reference:
Catawba Nuclear Station Units 1 & 2
. Personnel Airlocks Mill Power PO il A-98536 Item: CN 1144-13-1 Gentlemen: . This is an Addendum to the letter previously submitted dated August 7,1980.
The following is a list.of heat numbers to include the slab numbers which were not previously submitted with the above letters. It is the W. J. Woolley Co=pany intent to perform Charpy "V" Notch testing on all heats and slabs which are in conflict with the code and specification require-ments. This shall be perforced in the same =anner as written in WJW sub=ittal dated August 7, 1980. HEAT # SLABir ITEM LOCATION - LAMCO S/N 817o2 408 Mounting Plate 963,964,965,966 77175 007 Mounting Bracket 963,964,965,966
- 77275 006 Outer' Shell 964,965 77175 005 Station B Bracket 963,964,965,966 77175 -001 Stiffner 966-77175 002 Stiffner Pads 963,964,965,966.
44014' 3-1 Cencer Shell 963
.44014 7-1 Center Shell 966 44014 2-1 Center Shell 964 All sketches to reference the above items are with the W. J. Woolley letter which was sub=itted to Duke Poser on March 13, 1980. Except for Sketch 12 Rev. I which is included in this submittal.
(1)
-
. W.J. Woolley Co.
_ . . . _ _ . . . . - __ . . . . . _ . . - . . . - - . _ - - . . _
-
_ . . . . . _ . _ _ _ . . - . _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ - - I I' . , I J i W. J. WOOLLEY CO.MPANY a ,: r . - Duke Power Company Attention: Mr..N. G. Awadalla - - Page 2 . .
j.
- .
'
- Should yo's have any questions please contact me.
I Sincerely, ,
'
., W.'J.-WOOLLEY' COMPANY . ,
.
l [, .
,
.
4
..C. A. O'Deay '
, Manager:of Quality Assurance i ~
. CA0/nb'
- Encl. .
! ~ cc K. L. liladek - I
.-G. T. Blue
.
<
.
R.'A. Maffei-
, .
- ,
,
6 i- . i
*
, , i $, + , d
. L'-
}.
- -
'
.
L6 r 1 T 4
,_
.
's
!: ...
~
.
-
*p-
~
I. -. .
,
p % ".
..e
'_.y 1 j,; - Fr
"
L_. --
_ _ Catawba Nuclear Station, Units 1 & 2 Personnel Locks - tion-normalized 1/2" Thick flaterial Table of liechanical and Impact Test Properties lleat Chemistry Mechanical Properties impact Properties
& C Mn Yield ! Tensile Elongation Grain Test Charpy Test Lateral Exp.
Slab No. (%) (%) (KSI) (KSI) % in 8" Size Temp. (ft-lbs) (mils) 96352- 1/2 .21 1.05 1 51 .1 78.3 , 23 7 00F 42,30,39 39,31 .38 96352- 1/4 .21 1.05 S0.2 78. 'L 22 7 0"F 59,35,42 54,35,39 96352- 2/1 .21 1.05 51.4 78.9 t 24 7 0"F 46,38,40 44,38,39 96352- 2/2 .21 1.05 48.9 78.5 24 7 0F 54,35,37 49,35,36 96352- 2/3 .21 1.05 S0.5 78.8 24 7 0F 44,45,55 42,43,51 96301'- 1/1 .20 1.02 47.7 74.2 24 7 0"F 27,35,32 30,39,35 91808-044 .22 1.06 52.0 77.1 28.5 8 15 F 77,26,28.5 30,30,30 81782-408 .23 1.03 59.7 81.5 22 8 0F 39,39,39 45,43,42 77175-001 .18 1.11 56.6 75.0 28.5 7 0F 21.5,22,22.5 20,22,22 77175-002 .18 1.11 52.0 75.6 27 7 0F 24,25,24 26,29,26 77175-005 .18 1.11 54.9 75.7 27 7 0F 21,42,22 16,45,22 77175-006 .18 1.11 55.5 76.0 25.5 7 15 F 33,32,31 33,37.34 _ 77175-007 .18 1.11 55.4 76.0 26 7 0F 19,30,31 20,30,30 77175-008 .18 1.11 54.3 75.8 26 7 0F 24,18,31 24,16,29 75462-313 .19 1.07 51.4 75.8 8 0 21 18 F 22.29.26 20,26,24 75462-314 .19 1.07 48.3 74.4 21.5 8 0F 27.40,32 31.40.32 44014- 2/1 .22 1.11 52.0 80.6 19 - 15 F 10,33.5,40 37,28,40 44014- 3/1 .22 1.11 50.9 80.1 23 - 18 F 26.5,24.5,22.5 24,27,25 44014- 7/1 .22 1.11 51.1 80.2 26 - 0F 33,43.5.37 30.35.32 13437- 9/2 .25 .96 51.8 80.5 22 - 18 F 122,122.122 84,84,87 4
- . .- . -
. . .
WJ.h!by Co.
- 11. J. WOOLLEY MATERIAL REMOVAL PROCEDURE 4
1047-1A Rev. 1 Dated 3/23/81 SCOPE: Remove designated specimens from the plate material to identify heat and slab numbers so that Chcrpy V Notch Testing may be performed; to assure that the material is qualified to meet the Code and Specification Requirements. (Ref. CAR 1047-1 Rev. 3, Rev. 1 dated 3/18/81).
- 1. Specimen Removal
.
- A. The specimens shall be removed by Duke personnel', under the supervision of a W. J. Woolley representative.
B. The specimens shall be cut to the size es designated in W. J. lloolley sketches 1 through 14 as submitted to Duke Power on 3/18/80 where applicable. C. The-folleaing is a list of heat and slab numbers and the
~
air lock from which they will be removed. Heat 3 Slab 8 Item- 963 964 966 965 44014 2/1 Center Shell Sketch 1 44014~ 3/l Center Shell Sketch 1 L 44014 7/1 Center Shell Sketch 1 77175 001 Stiffner Sketch 6 77175 002 Stiffner Pad Sketch 7 Sketch 7 Sketch 7
-77175 005 Station Bracket Sketch 8 Sketch 8 Sketch-8 77175 006 Outer Shell Sketch 9 77175 007 Mounting Plate Sketch 7 Sketch 7 Sketch 7 91808 044 Outer Shell Sketch 12 Sketch 12 81762 408 Mounting Plate Sketch 11 Sketch 11 Sketch 11 74562- .31 3 Clevis (Test Clamp) Sketch 4 Sketch 4 Sketch 4 Sketch 4 Rev. 1 13437- 9/21 Center Shell Sketch 1 i- 2. Specimen Identification
! A. The specimens after removal shall be marked in a manner to I facilitate traceability to the designated heat and slab numbers, and the air lock from which they are being removed. Material 'shall be stamped before removal. L 3.- 'Speciman Testing A. Upon completion of Items 1 and 2, the specimens shall be . hand carried to a W. J. Woolley approved testing facility. ' (Law' Eng. , Charlotte, N.C. ) . ! l B. . These specimens shall be tested in accordance with ASME Section III, Subsection NE, Paragraph 2351, 1971. edition,. L Suniner 1972 Addenda. t .
WJ.hhy Co. W. J. Il00LLEY MATERIAL REMOVAL PROCEDURE (Continued)
.
e
- 3. Specimen Testing (Continued)
C. The certi#ied naterials test results shall be submitted
-
to Duke Power Company for review and acceptance for compliance code and their specification. , MAtlAGER OF EfiGINEERING - W. J. WOOLLEY CO. 2- 2 3-f/
,, --
MANAGER OF QUALITY ASSURAtlCE - W. J. WOOLLEY CO. _$ f bA3l8"l
..
AUTHORIZED NUCLEAR INSPECTOR - JOBSITE . 1 s- ar K,A L 7-2 P W ; f I
;
CUSTOMER APPROVAL hde y J-2T-8 / 9 9
.
*
!
l-
e
.
,.
e
- -
- . ,3
. g.
-
.~ ...-
. ., . . . . . ...
,
-
. q .- ;
3 7 pL ' cl i&. 4 i il
- -
I L.' -E" ~J --)p
.sfDi 11 .,..L__ ,' - .
-
.
i -Lg
-
__. i . .
- i. i' -
= sg t+ 1 s i q- -
a
-
O,t
- _.
I Q
- 4 s;
.
. i,:! - j; Q, e e
-
_ . _ _ _ - . __ y
,
_1 .. s t . .
=
r-.
.= tJ
-
. . .
. .
,
>
.
- - .
.
.>
-
v
.-
- .
~~t
- .
.-
O') A _.
. '. .
.. . .
.
% %. .:.
- - ..
(q
.
. .
, .
.
. . . . , , . r
*
-
. . . .
1 ;
-
.i
. .-
,
.
..
.
.
.. . . . .- -
00 .
.
w
. . . _
;
- .
. ..- ..
.
. . -
.
m
. .
.....
.
.
,. .
' ^ ~
, . .. .
.. '~._t
- : .
,- ed l -
- -
.- p ;).
.
. .
.
.
.
.._ .. . ; .. . .; ... ... .
. ..
- -
u
- -
, .
- .-,
, f . p .
.
- O
-
.
*
. . . _m ,Q
*
...
', +_, - -
,
,_2
. p
-- t gbm
-
. . .
.- .
al
."
'
j' ,
..
,
,
-
.
*
,
- - -
s t as
..
- .. :
-
. : . .
. . - . .
.v
, .. .*
,
.<
'
, k .
O_. iJJ
' - -
l : g%g .
. .
1;
- - -
.
..
_
.
.. i..
.,- -
..
-
- y. 7
.. .
.
.
. .
' ' '
. . .
1.d
-
.- -
- -
. '.=. .
o .' W*
. .
...
'
- g. c,
\n \n m @o
. .
+ z c) l
-
.o .
(n' n,o Qy . fy -s.
<> q - '3;. rn ca N
.
NNN O'. u,: GN O4 sG 0 .i G o 7 h O
.
. ,_
, en en'm b G.\D Q c3d O N CA tgo tD 0 i Gi 'nM ! \o cn i O.
'3
.
. s' b ig U k Y3b I O 6 Y Od U o'
' I 3O '2 y 4 to
.
.c i ('9 Q J G G OJ
. '%
.Q.'i . n c.: F:! T s*Q .;:hd 69 i ,_2._ w.@a. h H OV S\3 $ e i .. g.
~
'
. Q %. .
T " n % ;.; n,,412 ct 4 JC-Qc .$ u QM/ ,
~
- -- .--...:_...~ . . . . . . . . - _-
.. , :... .:: - .. - - . . . . ,. .-.----
tPI o E.
,
cg W Y: O l_r) >l th 4*
~
2 l -- 9 5
%q 43
-
.
w 4 h
.
.
.
o -J
<6 [),
W w
.
.t n* O .O , y nM
.-
M ci _ r f t&A mm 3$$ g b cQ @ O N'2 >I k P'
-, i r 2 Vo og . 6 e . +. @ O - - . - -.
,
- 3. m m ce
. -
. / i La h y v
.
'o .- CG c m+o
-
M , l6 -.-
- i. lD M w .< .=Ao .
N 2 :d b l n 24 9 m tn yc. ] 2 ct U- 2 Q / N E u - o oo e- e - uJ si
.
v e . e. 5 -
-
i n . l \ 7
.
.
.
6
',-
,
7- x gp
..
-
-9 o (L a G w <y.
)> _, - -
-
~
.
[
'
l1 ** 03 .
? g'i '
6! SI.}m,
-
~
j=. g
- .
-
m ,
. . -. . . q ..
.. o
,
.... .
4>-
- -
...
.
- -
~
.- .c - .
.
,,d-e
-
- -
' .__ q h [. / / 4 0' &2
/ Y c0 m Q
. -
'
'
-
.
f( . .: T'?
.
.
.
_
,< .
.
..
2-
.
~
( .ld. -.
-
4 4+
-
o Ld x3 2 W. D
, .
- -
i
-
g si
-
-: ,
, . - --
- e co .... + .
':
' s - a .
.
uJ
~
O [(
$'
'
.,
,
-
0-. cD / . ,
'
.
,
k y' 9 %. N l s
.,
s m t i b _Ld ~
I ' pgs BR$1Mt
~ -
p ..
-
! .
-
.
. ,
..
A,
!
.
. O. '
. ... : ; ,- x, ! . -
. .:.
' - . . . -
.
. . . . . . . . . _ , _ -. .- . ... . . , , , ,
&
. . . - - - . . . s
.
. p
'
. '
\'
.
;k 4 y
,
-
.
-
-
. , -
.
.
-
.
-
2 m m 0 m
-
a L. -
-
-
0 I,1 >
.l
.
t0
.~. o l O m01 -,-rn- . 7
\n)
*
-- _
.
.. .-
7; o
-
55
.
.
.., ..
-
.
..
-
. . .
,. .
to '
.. .
I.
.-- .
i i q of, .
*
'
f.'.,.
-
. . ,
'$ . . '
,
IO - 1
- k. '
', f}
-
-:
,
-
.
O.
.
- -
4
- ,
..
~r O . u ; --~ - -
v
- -
1 1 .
% t.-
.
g.'k -
. w.
..--
- -
..
4- , -r 1~ o
-j 4-s. ..
- - -
.
.- q, -
,
d I' ' - ~$ .
,
'
.
.
4 i :
.
.
-
..
.
.
.
,
*** ,
.,-.-.
...,,
.
.- . . . ,,
0 *e W
. .l. . -* .
*'
- . . , ,
. q
. . ,_, #', * ' . -
. $
*
. "
.,,- 6 : , .. J. . . '~
-
' -
,
- . .- }; -
.
-
.
*
. '
. ,
's ..
.
' '
'
'
,. , (9 * '*
.- ,'l
..
' : .-
.
,
. . . .
'
,,.~ ,
. (%,
,
, :s
-
..- *.
'I,
,
.
~~ ; -
. ,
-a w.
v) ',- .
* .
3p }__ '
,
a' u) E
-
. ,.. ,
I __.
,
'
i- L: L.! t M U ,. u .: Q o O
. . . .
r .-' 'T ~' - '.
.
'
(0 EO _a
.
-
N
.
A
. .
.
- ;> .
<(
.
. t l / p g ,
.. ..
, --
,
i...i ,
, ,
<
=4_
"f 2 g
, -
,
,
'
--
t .d .
. . ,
g~ s s
,
.
> -
- , . . . <
,
7~ ] __
'
'
,a.
'
.,
0
.
*
;
- l D -.
- -
O O b
'
W $ dg u ;- PL i..ir.
.
y
,
- . J..
*
.
.
.
.
.
.
_ . . _ - _
l l l
- - - -
- - . . . .
. . . -
. ....-.. . - . - . _ .
. ...
- .
-
.
. m ... . ....' .O. -
. . . . . . .
l . :c7. $ . I . . .. ... -
. . .
,.
.. . . . . .. ... . . . .
c;
.
9 . .
.
-
.y 1
.
CO,
's
-
'
-
b g .
' '
,
>x g o
.
O . <_ .
-
o i
.
S () b8 1 - Z i y 1 .. to
-
. -
---
h
.
, N .
-
R R 9 -
, .- .. co -
l
~ . -
- n. ,s
,
. 'O . -
g -
'
.
-
, N, .
.
. .- .
.
.
. e, .
.
'. k .' ;
~
ly
.
(J
. k ( 01 '
.
k
.
k ', D
.
..
' - G -
.
% y N .
. .
.-
,
[ Q Q . .
-
.
l
. .Qg 3s
.
g .A . _ . _ . _
.. . .
49 m 4
,
.
A : -
-
..' (. -
n w n
.. .
..
% y% n ,:
.. .. ..
X
'
' -
.;
..
( -
. ,j 8 .
-
-
.
y <c4 . . h
.
.
. .i ,
q
-
. -
.
-:
. ' . . . .
-
. to '.T : cq '
. .
*
- ! b . .~ ' ,
~
' C 'C i 01 k
-
cnN
. -
N. s
- - . .- -
.&
.
- -
.
%
N.) w
.
'
.o y .
W 'Q 24k = x . - k N - c&p ,c,w
.
..
'3.m m m. m 3 T N N'Nm
.
l .
'
%% 'I:M (
o X
-
~ '
c ,
. 3** . . 4. .g ,
.
R.
.
'
.
-
.
-
.~
"
.
.
.
.
'
y
. . , . .
~
Q -
,. :
24 4. .
.
-
.
~~
...... - .
.
.- .
.
4
. '
'
!'.'
Ob 'q '.
.
. .
.. .
y n
, -
y- n :.
- v
.
)8 7
.
- - --
-
.
.
.
~
'
.
.
.
r, g6 -
. - -
l . .
.
.
_
Y'}.- ir l
,+,,gst y F
_ / J[f. y
~
- CN
, ~"~-~--E--_-.,-_.------_.___.d --.
s f m f --- --- ~-- a l }l oj ey s y
.Q e s\ts -- % i I
!
Q
-
u -
< .
E! 5 63 l- I
.
.
~
I w; f v ,
.
.
1
...
x 9
}
.
I
.
. ,
- - .
. .. ; t70 2
- g
- '..
. '
. , * * *
. * ,
, -
. .
..
.
-
.i. .
..
*. *- g[ , .
.
.s .
.
- * ,
~
.& *
, t,
,'
'
,.t. . .
,., t_ -
*a.-.. .... . . .
.
- ~
,
.
T'
.,.; ,
- .
.
.
.. . . .
. .)* . , ,
.
~
' -
r
-
..
q
'
.[
* ,
.- ..
- ..' ::r,..'
. .
-
,
% q o
, . ,
- . ..
. ., .
.
-
. .
.- .
_.
. , . : z. .;.
-
.. .
.. ..: - we .
.
-
.
.
...
,
,
.-: :- -
..
,o, 9>f)
. .
..
. . . .
%. ..b g
,. .
.
.
...e g ,
.... . .. .
. ..
.
.. . . . . .
-
.
.: .. ..
.
, ...
.
,
.. ,.
.
.
.! .
- '
O[ -
,
~E
-
.
't
.
*
-
1 1
' ,
. .
fs
' . .
l l .
,
,
.
s
~~~ k. N l,
s
.-
,
- t~.- -
. ,
Q(a b ('s. Q Q
.
.. - ..
..
~ ! .
.
' .
.
.
. g e .
. .
.
. .
.y * -
g
'
.
.
.
>
.
! - . '. .
-
.: ,. -
.
4w
* .
_ \ - .
.
.
.
. .
'
. -
,
.
. *g- 4M -
EI k] h)
%btg\%h\.
.-
Uc. $ 'a;. % x c oq.x b o 2 ? -
-
W ' '
.. Wkx s oy< y- , s.
.
.
.
..
1 -> s * .
.
g 8 i 0 I g 4 H g '
, - ,i
-
2 3 C T
.
O f* E
.
-
= 8 8 $
7 3
. / /
l
, / -.
8 /5 S_ _ _ _ o g
,
,
f'
# O T *
.
A G ! E
,,
,O " H R l
.
_
,
.
.
0 l ~ i 1 l 1 1 'g 1l u
, @0/ T S
_ 6 E K _
/ K C
_ - C )E O 3 A S/ L 9 R O _ _ _ L _ _ _ E 2 B O L E _ R 2 L A 3 G D S o N l _ _ _
" .
E T 2 / P / 2 N P/ WT N H U E U (S L _ C L O l E O (
<
~
/
P M ' .
.
;
illi l l l j l
,,
m' N _
" o0
- .
. ~A 3 l
y '
.
.- - - - - .
.
. . . .
.
# RE. MOVE t- lTl4EL
-= - c, \ o e
.
_ _ 4 . .
-
_ .- ~ g . . _. _
%
-
.
2 \ # \. i : g
#j W EAT" 7 52-GZ-313 R o.* ot s as:5 P\ECE bJo, 3 22 9 9- 4
\ .
.
~ CLEVIS (TEST CLAMP)
ALL UN ITS ALL LOCK.Q_ SKETCH 4
.
.
-_.,... ..... ... . .... -
.aoe.~ . - * . = . . . . * = = = . . .
-
. - --
-
e
. . . .
. 1
-
- c'd)n
-
.. -
. . . . .
*
*' ~ ~ ~ ~
* .* * *,. . . . . . . .-- ' !.; * - : - -.*-- . ~ .' . . - . ~ - " *= * *-
....1h * * .
- N', ' ' ,* em
, . x
~. ]
.
A . . . i9s_. _i._ i n
~
/ <.x
's.A~;>
D
.
M
- , e:,: t>
g M .
.
~ ~~
.\D - -
. y - 'C
, .. .
_ _
..
.
.
.
. .
y ,g.. '
.
-
l
-- a c_a o-
-
-
o s
-
.
,.
.
..
.
.
~g. g _
.
-
.
_ _ o
. , .
3 _
- -
%s -
_ __
..
.
. . . .
.
. ::- . . . . ..
.
.
..
. . .... .. . ..... . . .
..
\ ;
.. .
..
.
. C% . . .
.
.> .-
x,
.
< t D
.-
-
l ... .
**:- *
.. p .
-
. : .. - -
. -
.. ,,
..
.
- .
.. .
.. .
.
sj
.,'
.
-
,
- .. ... - -
.
.. - .
...,r .. . . .
y
.. .
-
.
.
-.
.
.. .
. .. . . .
. . . . .
.
m
-
t y. . .
-
. : .
.
.
. : ... . . .. ._-
.
~
-.-
.- .
. . - .
. . . . . , .
. . ... ...
.
-
;, . . . .;...
--
. . . .
. .. .
- -
-
qs .
.
.
. :::. .
..
.-. o-
. . .
. . . . .
..
a ..; . .,
-
.
'..,
..
-
~*, .M . . :
. . . ..
-
-
,
(s.,(
.
. . '
'..
' '
1:. , ; :' ..l...; - {W
. . .
.
.. .- .~ .
,(
i
.
.
..
.
. . ., . .
-
.. . . :. . . . . - .
v
..
. . .
, , ..
.
.. . . . .
.. i
...
, .
- .. .
- c ... ..
.
. .
..
pi -
-m y,
. . .
. .
- .-
* *
.
-
;: .
-
-
.Y. -
.
.
.s-
. .. . ti . -
.
L.
..
-. {' ..-.
. ,-- :. .-
..
. . .
,u, .{ . G <<~
.;
.
,
. .
......
. .
.. .
.
. . .
...
.
... .
.....
.
..
.
.
. ..
..
. .
..
.
.
. o. .
,w
, . . .
.
- 7
. . .. .. . . . . . ..
..
. . . . . . . - . . .
<.,
-
. L--
.
.. -
.
- . - .
'
,
'. '
- . .
... .: . = .
.- : .' 0-- , f.
'
... '
. . ..
.. g ;
.
.
-
. .
.
. t. .
.
e n.. . . . .- l .
.
..
, .
.
.
... .
.. .
.
. ..
/
_
.
.
- -
.
q -
.
1.. . - -
.
'. .'
. . .
- 1. , - Se <$[ Ld
- , . ~. . ...%
. +
.. . . :.
- - -
g -
'
M't
'
4
.C s . ci 1.n in 0 0 g P 2 c) m 6N,3
' 4 - -
- -
.- .
C O .& - en ca N rn.
-
c.
!
w% ex O <'-& - 'h' Q
-.
,$ eJ N N N c O ~ G o 7 ,u s u_.
s s' -
<, - @. \D Q , w oC 1
s4A .i
, to rn co m
~
i o n m / Cn wm o cg W G i o,
'3 bsN g 4 -J i e-4
-
'N ss esj u .2[ O 6 V Ga 0 ci m
b l N Q,' O g Q OJ 8Q h i O $s' ~2a d 'b_, . O
'
b 5 h Yb N h'ti' o k .. c b '" a r H S. E. 4 3 af
. '
- i_ . l
LABORATORY REPORT Dat- seaTucry 22, 1980 Lab ns. K- 2 31-1 DURKEE . TESTING LABORATORIES our a.c. te, no. u ccoa 1520 West 178th St. e Cardena. Caldornia 90247 Rep h: IAmco Industries, Inc, Phone (213) 3219800 Your P.O. No.: 021351-55451 i 1532 North Johnson Avenue *A= ended Report (3-2 4-50 ) El Cajon, California 92020 CERTI7IED TEST ?2 PORT r ! Identification: One (1) Test Specimen ! P.aterial: A315 Crade 70 l 1/2" x 3-1/2" x 12" Det. P/N33411- 9 ' Heat #96352 -- Slab #1-2 Specification: ASE Ssetion III Subsection NE Para NE-2300 , 1974 edition, Su:xner 1974 addenda
'
l l ' Process: Charpy "V" Notch I= pact Test at Test Temperature listed below,
.
I
Results: Iontitudinal: !
- Retest; Test l Temperature Impact Values Iateral Expansion 7. Shear Fracture l
l 0 F. -1 42,0 Ft, Ibs. ,039" 30.0 l -2 30,O Pc. Iha. .031" 30.O
~3 39.0 Fe, Ibs, ,038" 34.0
.
-25 F. -1 44,0 Ft. Ibs, .040" 30.0 _
-2 23.0 Ft. Ib s. ,073" 25.0
-3 29.0 Ft. Ib s, ,026" 25.0
.
l my,c,,, g {{{}y{h RenutEUy SMned DURKEE T ESTING L A BOR ATORIES MAR 2 3 1980 b$D W. J. WOOLLEY CO.Br Roy narayceneral uanasee
,
.
, _ . . . - . _ . ,
- , , - - - - - .
-- - e -,s ,
. .. :.
t t'W-n%.% i 22 y 1930kM;2~ ,.. w w@.-.-'Cgi7g
.
a,e. -- m - w -.22.,. -..eg
, une
':5*Q:.c.X*Jrtarf .Fe GO.T'(: =:ew A:h-6wt
~-- Wnum n
- . .~.a: .ifGGKr on r ?.=ru.m - xQS
.
c -M;N c o.- w .. ..::- M; m...:,. ; n. . ....:z... . =.-;,,' -: i ~,.. .. . ,c. . . :..w w_ . . .. : . w . . . .- ;.. . . ..
~ %.6. ...-: ., ,
.
- :
.c
-
.
... p. ..- 3:
.
. s D U R K EE ' TESTI N G L A B D R AT O RI E S . 6 ue: U-'co3 "
.*I
"'
. I..','... ;*#., # ) ..c
-
.
- . .t. ".. * ,.ef < !.!. 1520 Wm 178th St. . . e.' .. Gardena. CoMorn'a. 90247 - .~~R. . ' . - # 9--41--i.
. - -,
.
-
.. . ~ . . . . - - . . . , ...
Ycur P.O. flo.: g.,33 ' 0,~*.a - #
. ' J. . T. ,^ ' '! , . 1,, : ' Phone (213) 32199CO
~
p~ or*. To - . .
' ~ - ' ~~ '
, .7 4' < '
-
. -
- - -
. .- . .". -. .1532 7 %. .North 'Ia=co Iod us Avenue tr les , Inc f . e:.
.,'.... -
- .-
. ,.
-
.. . ..
. .7 % .e<- .
.?o Johnson . ...
.
; . R E CII VE D -(
.
.
~ ' -~
.b. .El Cajon,' Californu 92020 -- . . c ... , .
. -.~.,, - . . .~ , --::u.
, -
. .
- .-
-
'
..
.. ..
r. r
..
- ..:.
.2. .
, x. ~-
- .
x ;,. . . .-.. . -
... .
-
.
'.
.
- . . c. . - m,
- .'r..... -
u.. .. 7.. a .
....;...
..
. .. . .
. ,..: ,
,
;...,...y.2
.-
s. 6 .e
..
.) )2 . .e s
.-. ..
. . ....
.. . . ~ .
= . . , .' .a =j .QQ -'.)
**'.}*,.*:.
* , .= L
* -.
* , . . .. :.,y. .
- 9 ,
.,
. ,, -
,
.*.
.
'..~ ., . ,. .. .: .. ./.,
. ,. w .., . ...: ~<-~.,1.c :.
- ~
. . . .;- .~w,.. . .
.s. :. . . - CERTI?TED _u:ST y ,0RT
.
- .. .
.m , . * . . .
.
. .. ..
- . : .
--. ,,r, .}. h,,.1,1.
.
.
. b., - . ;" a ,.
.t
.:,......
. . .. ,
. . -
....
. . ;. .. :. ;M . ..t .
.
u.:
. ..
v ;.n ;. -.. . . v-. , ,..,:,:. . . ..,%. .,- ..: ,...:. v. c. . . y.,:, y ., . .u.a
..y , q z.r-
.e.:..... . .. .;,;.:1,;
. .
. , , _ .. ..-. . .' ;.L.".,,.:,.;.
,; ; ;_.: r s.
. _. 5.., .. we~,. : . . .. . _ . .: .,;,
x
. : w-. ... v. . . . . . . w ,se .; ..> > :~ . . ..
. .
.
.c
. :. 3.: -
.. .
.
. ;.... ....; . .
-
-.
.
. . _ ,
- i. j.;; .,.,. u . ., ;. ,_ g;-:{. ;.@j -
-
" .
'.I..' <! ..Tt/;,/ Ideeti.!ica ion:y0ca -(1) Test Specinen . .,!.. 2g..q;.;. ,
,.
- '~ o " -:.:W.;; ::;' ,:*n ';-
.". . "2. ..-
,
, .-
.e -
( .; o. . ..::::.:z : .,.y. e. e. ' . : g.,,:S. . ,M.at.eri,a' >. . ASIS Grade 70g.g.3jgn.>g
... v ...
...
..
> - q ,. . '
..
n.. . . . . .
.
...a.,.:r . .
. r
,
. . .r
,,.:.,,.m .
- ....1J2n
.-- ..
%. i'::. .; ;
. . ..
.
.e -~. 9n
.:.
- .l...;;i.;
- . 5., . . . ~.z=y.,.
~ _ .
.E.
.+
3
'. : ' _ . .
- ...;:..
i,,:C:
- .;- ,
L g.. . ;,.a.
-
W ;-
- - .,-
y
;;a .
;i
.
. .L.:'; . ;3. r :m. :~ eM_. . - . 5;. :.h:: ' Detl.'2/M 33408-25 Y. . .
. - Eeae 99 635 2 .". W.S 2s b 1. .4 VE-.. ..."j<
.
- , . .: .. .. . .
,...e.,, , .; M.#59. . . 7". :.::.J ..
- p. . W-. .,.g .ege.: .
.* ,y: :a . - . ;.,,,..~-..,.,,..5.. . .:; ... .. ..:..:..~~...,.
.. ,. .. . -.. .
,
.,:,,, . . . *:. .,..
...m. ...f . ,
. _
. , .:e .. .y . z. 1::m.w .- _. . .
.. . . _ . , . . . . . .
. .
.
- .2...-
. .. ~. .3.:.:.
. . . .
- n . a; . - . ..
.,----a.. ...
- n. .-
. . . . .
. /, +.:: . . .c . - , ..
;,:: . Q;.: .:
s.
- .
., :.. . , c r .
.@, ..e
.
.
, y:,-4 p:i~.;: '. '?.': .
-:..:w-g>=W.p:g.Q&;ij;: .17.. ..;.:; >N~.
.
. ..
.
*
.
. .n.:
;; 3 .';;.?:-s . -
i:b: ?...-
".i.W. ; . ; E ..,' Specificatioh: ASE Section III Subsection 33 Pa.ra 5Z-2300-,.- ' F. '
. .
.
':.L';t ~ G. N. ..
.
ed ition,. S tz: .er 1974 . add eala: y. .... G ., ..g:3.:.,;4....>.;. :.R...,jp,2
.
.
; s. ,.
.~."}.'.7.*:q Q. .
'.!' '. 5. :- :.i> ;:..a.1974
-V'. . c, c. . e. ;.., .o:. ,....-
-
. ; . ...;_
..
. , g ..,.,.:_ ~.
. ~
-
r u ,, ( -::c. a. :. ..
.. -....
. . a . :.. . .-. . L.
.
. ~ ,: :. --. n.,. .
,. .
..+-. ;.~. .,.. ... :
. :- . r::
.
. c.
.
.
.. ..
..
- ,, . ';, . .s....c.....
.
, .. . .:
.: w. . . . . . T, ....y. . .. ..
- '~..
. m,,. . .
........,.,:..'- n
....
..
. . . . . . . ..,:,,.1
.:; ~+: y . . .a ;. q t, ..v ~ .-n. .~ r. .
...
.w.
. . . .
..
. . . , . , . . . . . . e
. .
.,... . .
. ....e. .
...- . ... .. -
m<:.n.. ~ . . . -:.
.
.c :
.
<. ~ : .. .. :.#.... . . . ; . ...g,
.
. :.e - .
. . . . . s ,. ,
Charpy "V" Notch Impact Test at test temperatt:re -
;. y .:
_
.
.-
#
.. :. Process:
.~~ .
.
.. . .': as listed below t.:.g. f
.~ .. .- ' ' '/:7
.
9:. . . . }d.s,.;,. . : T g .. , .z:
'".e . . .
*
. .' * . *
-
.- ..
-
. .-. .
. . :.,- .. Q:.s:,.; c
. . _. . ,
f:.,u
..
s :.
.
~ .
..
m;.. . . . .
.- .
,
;,
. . t.u ..
- . : , .....
.
.
- : .-. . . v,q.:.5 .
; ,
.
. - .
.., . ; . ,;, ;;.
..- -
.
.
,
,:
. ;w g. . -g ,. : . -:.-=..:. ..-.
..
...r
,
. .
a.
-
.
..*
.. .: .
.
.,
,y,... - . . Y
. ..
- s. ,. , s .: . . . m. 3 ,~.y ,.v;-
. , .
-.,
, ,. . . .
... .
**:
-
. .
-
..
z: - . -La Resu.,ts: . <;
. - .
Y. .ra- . . . ~* ? : :a -
.
-
,. -
- y. ; ..,. . .' .
.-
...
r . -:...
. . . . , .
a.. . . . . .. .
.w
. .-.
-
.
-
. .. t.
.
_: -
'-
..-
'..
. .Lomittx!ical: . -. .., < G, ,
s.
. ..
-
. .
.g, -.. . . .
--. .
, , .,. . %
,
. :-aj;..
- .
- .- . .+-
.
.
.. .
. ....a f.' ' *:* L., .;
.
.: , .,..,. , ,
..:,..
. .
' y._.: ,_^ &. E. *.
. . ... .
. . ?..
.
. -
- f. . .. .,. A.
..: . Test' ' ~: .) -. . ' -- " . ~ ?. .
. .
;.. -
Temoarature . Teoact valces. .; .. Lateral Expansion . .
',- 7J Shear Fractere .g.,
'
% S '. 7, .!'T) - 59,[0 . Et,$ Ibs,7
*
' . ?.054"
~
- "' -
.lb:- T- ' ' . 42,0 "*E-0
.
~
- ~
~
j;. '-- 7,: . , . , . . . . _D . 35,0 Ft. Lbs, / -77.035" E. F i: ..
' :/.* 24. '. u.,.. d - N 3 0,0. ,.?. z
.. . .,
42,0 ,Fe, Lbs,..[ ,039" "...p.. .... .- p e , , .i . . ~ . . 3 6,0 : c,y
,
. .$. ' , . . . .
. . . .,
~ . . . . .; .
*
. . c ....
\.
,.
..,.,.
.
.
-
. ..- . y . --. . :..
. . .. .
. .. '
. . .$./ 20.8
' '
"
l . 2 '
-
. -250 F," C_3 31,'O Ft!," Ibs,' / : '
.030" "
!
"-
..
-
27,'.O .' Fe, Ls , / . .
, C2 8" . .. .-. J ? ?.;25 ^.0 ".E. .
'- .' 43,0 Ft. Lbs,v' 040" - 36.0
.. . .
. .>* . .
..:4% g. :.;...
.
. . . . .
.
.
- *
. .... b....;y . .
' .',; .;. .
,
~
.
*Y~ .
. . VO. f8Q.S*[ . .D. U.
. . ...
^ .. *
*
- -
-
_- . lAf &.0$~$. ..$~...~ .. p j'
.
. .
. .
. -
g.. .
...+
g,,,, - Respectfully Submitted
-'
; , g
,,
pA 2 , 2 * *
;.\Q.-d;ii.
.
-
.y,,\. *
.g . 'DURXEE 7E T%.G LASOR ATORIES .
,
.n" % g
,
L ilM .
**-
.
.
.-
. . .
.
..
. . . ..
..a.
;.
.
, . .,i .
,
. .
. . , . ,; - '
By.
-
D! , s Roy E, P[ gram, GeneralMacager . , , _ ,
;7J .
.
g? .
-
. . .
..
. . .
b
_ . . _. LABORATORY REPORT Dab Fsbrucry 22, 1980 La b Ns. _ K- 22 9- 1 DURKEE TESTING LABORATORIES our Rw. tos no. u-cwa 1520 West 178t- D. e Gardena. California 90247 , Report To: Phon. [213) 3219800 Your P.O. No.: 021361-5345R Iacco Industries, Inc, */cended Report (3-24-80) 1532 North Johnson Avenue El Cajon, California 92020 CERTIFIED TESr REPORT
'
Identification: One (1) Test Specimen Material: A516 Grade 70 1/2" x 2" x 23" Det, P/N 33408-3 Heat #96352 -- S2ab 02-1 Specification: AS)E Section III Subsection NE Para NE-2300 1974 edition, Su=mer 1974 addenda l Process: Charpy "V" Notch Impact Test at Test Temperature listed below Results:
- Retest: . Longitudinal:
Test Temperature Impact values Lateral Expansion 7. Shear Fracture l 0 F, - 1 46,0 Pt. Ibs, , 044" 40,0
-2 38,0 Ft. Ibs, . 038" 40,0
-3 40,0 Ft. Lbs, , ,,
, 03 9" 40,0
-25 F, -1 29,0 Ft, lbs, , 028" 25,0
-2 27,0 7t, Lbs, , 027" 25,0
-0 30,0 it , Ib s, , 029" 25,0 t
! I l Respectfully Submined ' ow RFCElVED
-
DURKEE . T ESTING LABOR ATORIES MAR 281980 g Roy C1% gram, Aeneral Manager W.1 WOOLLEY CO. '.
*
.
, - - w ,< , - - , , - - . , , , - , , . , - - ,g - , .---,, n- . - ,n,e , ,, w - - ~ ,
LABORATORY REPORT Data Fobrucry 22, 1980 tab tio. '2 DURKEE TESTING LABORATORIES cura.c. tor no.:- c 3 1:10 West 178th St.
- Gardeno, California 90247 Report To:
Phone (213) 3219800 Your P.O. No.: 0213 P_-! U52 Iar:co Industries, Inc. "* *E ( 3532 North Johnson Avenue El Cajon, California 92020 CERTIFIED TESI REPCRT
.
Identification: One (1) Test Speci:nen Material: A516 Crade 70 1/2" x 2" x 8" x 6-3/4" x 9" Det. P/N 33408-25 Heat No. 96352 S2st #2-2 Specification: ASE Section III Subsection NE Para NE-2300 2374 edition, Su=rner 1974 addenda . Process: Charpy "V" Notch Impact Test at Temperature listed be3aw Results: Iongitudinal; (* Ret e st );
,
.
Test Temoerature _I:soact Values.. Interal Expansion
- Shear Fractu a
.
0 F.-l 54,0 Ft. Es. .049" 45 . 0
-2 35.0 Fe, us. ,035" 40.0
-3 37.0 Ft, E s. ,036" t.0. 0
-25 F -1 36.0 Ft. Lbs. 033" 25.0
-2 33.0 Ft. ns. .032" 25 .0
-3 22.0 Ft. na, .022" 25.0 1
! l Respectfully Submitted RECE!VED OuRxEE TEsTmc ua0 RAT 0a:es
,
MAR 201980 ,, % f n g , cyg RoyI Pegra/:-Ge=eralManageE
.
W. J. WOOLLEY CO.
,
LABORATORY REPORT 7.79 4 ' cate Fcbrutry 22, 1980 Lab No. "-~__ r- C 3 DURKEE TESTING LABORATORIES cur R.c. tos no. 1520 Weo 178th St. . Gardene, California 90247 R: port To: Phone (213) 3219800 Your P.O. No.: C213 C- 5 %.* Iamco Industries, Inc,
- Amended Report (3-2L 50) 1532 North Johnson Avenue El Cajon, California 92020 CERTIFIED TE Sr REPCRT l Identificat ion: One (1) Test Specimen ~
l P.aterial: W 16 Grade 70 1/2" x 5" x 5-1/2" ' Det, P/N 33413-9 P. eat No. 94352 -- Slab #2-3
.
Specification: ASME Section III Subsection E Para NE-2300 1974 edition, Sc=mer 1974 addenda Process: Charpy "V" Notch Impact Test at test temperature as listed below,
.
! Results: Ionaitudinal:
- Retest; Test Temperature Impact Values Interal Expans ion *7. Shear Fracture 0 F,-1 44,0 Fe, Ibs, ,042" 40.0
-2 t,4 Ft. Se, ,043U 45,0
-3 55,0 Ft. Lbs, ,05 1" 55.0 l
-25 F, -1 27,0 Fe, Lbs, , 02 6" 30,0
! ! -2 ~29,0 Fe, Ibs, ,030" 30,0
*
-3 30,0 Ft,,Lbs, ,030" 20,0
.
Respectfully Submitted bb DURKEE T ESTlHG LABORATORIES W MAR 201930
,y g4d +
,
*7 E "*8' ' **""*1 "'"'5**
W. J. WOOLLEY CO. ,
. ,
LABOR.A TORY REPORT y . Data FebWruyr 22, 1980 L*5 No-DURKEE TESTING LABORATORIES car nee. t::s uo. T t- 3 1520 West 178th St.
- Gardeno, Cadornia 90247 Report To: Your P.O. No.: 5 *3 5 Phone (213) 3219800 Iamco Industries, Inc. *A:-ended Report (3- 2 !.- 30 )
1532 North Johnson Avenue El Cajon, California 92020 CERTIFIED TEST REPORT Identification: One (1) rest Speci=en Material: A516 Grade 70 1/2" x 6-1/2" x 8-1/2" Dec. P/N 33408-9 Her.c #96301 -- Slab #1-1 Specification: AS}E Section III Subsection NE Para NE-2300 1974 edition, Sumer 1974 addenda , Process: Charpy "V" Notch Impact Test at Test Tenperature l listed be2aw: 1 Results: l Ionaitudina1: Test i Temperature Impact value,a, Iateral Expansion ?. 9. ear Trac:t= e 0 F. =1 27.0 FC, Ds. . 030" 36,0
-2 35.0 Ft. Ibs. , ~039" 42.0 l -3 32.0 Fe, Lbs. . 035" 33.0 l
l
- Retest;
,
-25 F. -1 17.0 Ft, Ibs. . 02 1" 30.0
-2 63.0 Ft. Ib s. , 0 63" Greater thas 90.0
-3 62,0 7t, Ib s. . 062" Greater thas 90.0
-25 F, . -1 21.0 Ft. lbs. , 024" 34.0
-2 64.0 Ft. lbs. , 060" Greater thas 90.0
-3 41.0 Ft. Ibs. . 041" 66.0
.
Oy n ,- y=" p j p Respectfully Submitteci
-sas, >
DURKEE TESTING LABORATORIES MAR 231980
'
By M W. J. WOOLLEY CO. Ro7 % P=s:4 c*=*ral M*=ssar
.
-y- - ,,,y . . - - - , * - . -,-
__
,
* '
hM./3 bbb$b )bbb Ybb5Nb (OMPANY ^ y "g -,
,,_
* '
ff g. . M ATEn!ALS TssT!Nc ENf.!NEEP.s ,
*), .::' '.
- So!!. AND FocNDATION INVESTIGAT!oNs ^'
57 . 6'/ *~ 7 . -
- Y 306 Plasters Ave.. N.E. P.O. Box 13250, sta. K
'
DDDO
, ATLANTA. GEORGIA 33324 H -NOTCH WAG TESU ,. - .
REPORT OF _ ,
."
W.J. Woolley Company Atlanta, Georgia Clien!-
- Offic.. ~~
7425 West Lake Street River Forest, IL 60305 October 7, 1980 Date:
- oject: tawb Units 1 & 2 Job No. G-7914 Lab ilo. 234"5 Charpy V-Notch Ic. pact Tests were conducted on materials delivered to our laboratory by Law Engineering Testing Company, Charlotte, NC on 9/26/80 These tests were conducted using a Riehle Impact Testing Machine Pl-2, ., ., ~.2 ,
S/t!1-74104 with a total impact energy of 120 ft.-lbs. The velocitW" - ' of the striker at impact was 11.3 fps and energy loss due to friction d,$g i is 0 ft.-lbs, ! i
!.
TEST RESULTS . Material: 1/2" plate, AStG SA-516 Grade 70
,
.,
!
-
- W /Od~i Heat tio.: 91808 Slab 044 -
.
.
. .
" - . .nc- :/C-m.:p
.
_ . - Specicen Test Impact Mils Lateral Percent Nu:-ber Size Temo. Value Exoansion Shear C-1 10m x 10mm +150F 27 30 34 C-2 10en x 10m '+150F '26 '30 - 34
-
- C-3 10mm x 10m +15 F 28.5 30 34
, . . .. . .
Averace 2'7 .2 - We certify that the statements in this record are correct and,,,jhat the_ test specimtns were prepared and tested in accordance with SA370 h ] CT_ jij,{ s]
.
L.;i 1-)'930 W. J. WOOLLEY CO.
'
Respectjhlly submi:ted,
. LAWjENGINE,E,Ril:G TESTING CO.
. //.f f () l b'i O 5 L -
.
. -. ,. . ' :. *
.
. - .1. .
. . LAW ENGINEERING TESTING COMPANY i / ~~- : .: .
-
-
,
n.C -- \ 501 Minu.t !.ano . P. O. Som 11297 j f tp yj p.1
, - : -
,/ <.
D
\ Charlotte. ilorth C.rolina 23220 ,J REPORT OF CHARPY IMPACT T:ST W. J. WOOLEY COMPANY Client: River Forest, Illinois Office: Charlotte Metais Date: September 15, 1930 Project: Catawba 1047 Units 1 & 2 Lab. No. CHS 80-191
_.___._._ __ _ Client P. O. No.: 1047 940 Material: Reported as W" Plate, ASME SA 516, Grade 70 Heat No.: 81782 Yab 408 Data Tested: 9/10/80 Specim,n Size: 10 mm x 10 mm Test Temperature: 0 F Pr:xedure: in accordance with ASME SA-370 TEST RESULTS Impact lateral ' LETCo. Strength Expansion Percent Piece No. (Ft. Lbs.) (In.) _ Shear C:mments 8 29 80 CJl 39.0 0.045 95.0 NA 8-29-80 CJ2 39.0 0.043 95.0 NA 8 29 80-CJ3 39.0 0.042 95.0 NA
.
Inspector (s): E. Coble La rryd H. Norris Richar Reviewed by: lies >ectfully submitted,
,
LAW ENGINEERING TEST NG CO'.:? ANY
. ._ /" ? sf M Edward IA. Beck. P.E. Larry E.p61e
,
LAW ENGINEERING TESTING COIAPAN'(/, f., _
. - , i
< - ,
/ 501 Minuet Lane e p. O. Box 11297 {7 ' g .
t. Charlotte, North Carolina 28220
*
*
.
I y
// ,
;
'
. M%~.
i REPORT OF CHARPY IMPACT TEST f I W. J. WOOLEY COMPANY Charlotte Metals Office: Client: River Forest, Illinois Date: September 15, 1980 Project: Catawba 1047, Units 1 & 2 l Lab. No. CHS 80 191
-
- - . -
Client P. O. No.: 1047 940 Material: Reported as W" Plate, ASME SA 516, Grade 70 Heat No.: 77175 Slab '001 Oate Tested: 9/10/80 Specim:n Size: 10 mm x 10 mm 1
!
Test Temperature: 00 F , I
'
' Pracedure: In accordance with ASME SA-370
.- .
TEST RESULTS Im pac'. Lateral
- LETCo. Strength Expansion Percent Piece N o. (Ft. Lbs.) (In.) Shear Comments
, 8 20 80 Cl1 21.5 0.020 37.0 NA l 8 29 80-Cl2 22.0 0.022 36.0 NA ! 8-29 80 Cl3 22.5 0.022 39.0 NA
Inspector (s): E. Coble Larry Richar d H- Norris
- Revi2wed by: Respectfully submitted,
'
LAW ENGINEERING TESTING COMPANY
-
Edward M. A A' Beck, P.E. n Larry E f. oble
< m Nsnver Metals Laboratory Su pervisor '
-.
LAW ENGINEERING TESTING COMPANY,rr' _. ..: _
#' * , ; P. O. Box 11297
., x x ,
>
- u N'
#- l 501 Minuet I an. .
C
-
!1
'
O Charlotte. tierth Carolina 28220 f(;' i j f.T// REPORT OF CHARPY IMPACT TEST Yl. J. VIOOLEY COMPAf4'y Cliens' River Forest, Illinois Office: Charlotte Metals Date: September 15, 1980 Project: Catawba 1047. Units 1 & 2 Lab. No. CHS 80 191
. . _ . - .-
Client P. O. fio.: 1047 940 Material: Reported as W" Plate, ASME SA-516, Grade 70 Heat No.: 77175 Slab 002 Dato Tested: 9/10/80 Specimen Size: 10 mm x 10 mm i Test Temperature: 00 F Pr:cedure: In accordance with ASME SA-370 _ <
- TEST RESULTS l
l Impact Lateral
- LETCo. Strength Expansion Percent Comments Piece ti (Ft. Lbs.) (In.) Shear 8 29-80.CA1 24.0 0.026 29.0 NA 8 29 80.CA2 25.0 0.029 31.0 NA 8-29 80-CA3 24.0 0.026 27.0 NA l
. - - - . ,
. . . , . . _
'...'.,9.,,. '_.;-
...- .. ....
. J. - i : ;;.
' Insp:ctor(s): E. Coble Larry'r'd H. Norris
. . 5 ' \ ' ^? . .;
"
1 .i.). Richa s .
. R: viewed by: Respectfully submitted, Edward 6 4/[" /
M. Beck. P.E. LAW ENGINEERING. TESTING COT.:P A .' Y
- -s Larry E. Co' e g w
.
Metsis Department. Manager Metals Laaoratory Supstviser
.
1.AW ENGINEERING TESTING COtAPANYf_ , _-_ g'.;p *
.
-
,
/- p
/ J 501 Minuet I.ane . P. O. Box 11297 4:. , 9 , 3,.
-
g
# 0 Charlotte. North Carolina 28220 Sd.. i i d/5.
' %;.;; ~
REPORT OF CHARPY IMPACT TEST W. J. WOOLEY COMPANY Charlotte Metals Client: River Forest, Illinois Office:
'
Date: September 15, 1980 Project: Catawba 1047, Units 1 & 2 I 1.ab. No. CHS S0 191
- . - -
Client P. O. No.: 1047 940 Material: Reported as W" Plate, ASME SA 516, Grade 70 Heat No.: 77175 Slab 005 Date Tested: 9/10/80 Specimen Size: 10 mm x 10 mm Test Temperature: 00 F
- ,
Pr:cedure: In accordance with ASME SA-370 _
- TEST RESULTS Impact Lateral
- LETCo. Strength Expansion Percent Piece No. (Ft. Lb s.) ' (In.) Shear Comments 8 29 80 CG1 21.0 0.016 25.0 NA f NA l 8 29 80 CG2 42.0 0.045 95.0
' 8 29 80-CG3 22.0 0.022 29.0 NA Insp;ctor(s): 1.a r ry' ' E. Coble Richard H. Norris , ' Reviewed by: Respectfully submitted.
'
*[ML _ . ._
LAW ENGINEERING TESTING CC .".? A.'Y n
.
. . . .o mi.
< w -
UAW UNG]M23R!NG 7537 SNG CCPDANY
' '
/ ,,; , M ATE?.!\LE TEST!/4G ENGINEERS JE F-~~h
/ U:l' - So!L A'iD FoL*ND AT!oN I ;VESTIC ATIONS I '
- t u. a ..
39: Ptasms An.. f f.E. P.O. Box 13250, St:. K M ((g m.pQ D ' ATLANTA, GEORGIA 3o324 gg ff REPORT OF
" -
""
H.J. Woolley Company Client: 7425 West Lake Street office: Atlanta, Georgia River Forest, IL 60305
*
'o,fect: Catawba 1047, Units 1 & 2 P.O. ilo. 1047-950 G-7914 Lab No. 23445 Job No.
.
Charpy V-Motch Impact Tests were conducted on materials delivered to cur laboratory by Law Engineering Testing Company, Charlotte, ilC, on 9/26/80 T.,, These tests with S/il1-74104 wereaconducted total in.cactusing energya Riehle of 120Impact ft.-lbs.TestingTheMachine veloci Plt'/ OF/IO: ! of the striker at impact was 11.3 fps and energy loss due to frictiong . is 0 ft.-lbs.
-
-
_. TEST RESULTS Material: 1/2" Plate, ASI'E SA-516 Grade 70 .
$' / 0 4 7 :
Heat ilo.: H-77175 Slab 005 D4..
;:.
_: /g .g .g i Specimen Test Impact Mils Lateral Pe cent flucher Size Temo. Value Exoansion Shear B-1 10mm x 10mm +150F 33 38 59 B-2 37' 60
-
10mm x 10mm +150F ~32 B-3 10mm x 10:= +150F 31 34 61
. .. .
Average ' 32'
.
We certify that the statements in this record are correct and that the test specimens were prepared and tested in accordance with SA370
- m. ,C cp prg g-a
-
ccilu.:: 0 C' Resp tjully ui su:nr.i
.) :ey/OOLLE
.
LAW/ I .ENGINEE(RING
... 7 }lj, // TESTING CO
.a : _
- .-
,. LAW ENGINEERING TESTING COMPANYps __ _
_ s [ g 501 Minuet f.ane
- P. O. Box 11297 n.c/I -).
[fb5$'-
' # Charlotte, North Carolina 28220 <k. .
*
%x.l '~
REPORTOF CHARPY If.1 PACT TEST W. J. WOOLEY COMPANY Charlotte Metals Office: Client: River Forest, Illinois Date: September 15, 1930 Prrject: Cat 1wba 1047, Units 1 & 2 Lab. No. CHS 80191 _ . _ . . . . Client P. O. No.: 1047 940 Material: Reported as W" Plate, ASME SA 516, Grade 70 Heat No.: 77175 Slab 007
-
Date Tested: 9/10/80 Specimen Size: 10 mm x 10 mm Test Temperature: 00 F
.
Pr:cedure: In accordance with ASME SA-370
.
TEST RESULTS Impact lateral ' Strength Expansio, Percent LETCo. Comments Piece No. (In.) Shea- _ Ft. ( Lbs.) 0.020 36.0 NA 8 29 80 CHI 19.0 0.030 23.0 NA 8 29 80 CH2 30.0 0.030 47.0 NA 8-29 80-CH3 31.0 inspector (s): Larry'* E. Coble Richard H. Norris Revi wad by: Respectfully submitted, 7 LAW ENGINEERINGW- TESTING fr&jk/ f -<;~ CO:. ?A? Y
'
.
-
f,_&
, , , .
.
__. ._. - - . _ .. -- . = - - . ~- - ___.
. .
r.:.:.- . . G:,..r.-. , .W s.; h, - W : W- 7/e.d, _
.
te:- - .
.A s/ U. . <- . -
EG(.T %;., d Eir;yd 22l'i930 . . .d, .g.Ch:.v.t..Py'MP
.
. .. . . . . 4 ".1 L.A 30RATORY Mi.9.WW.I:.J.". R EP QRT. . '*Mic. . ,4'EE.'.C
,
.. ,- .:.;mmw:.. -;*:. ::,,.9.e.
-
. :-' :-:o 1-~
'
'. - p n --:.,.: ~.:.
.. . .x ? m
.~:,r%.. ..:6.U.U: w r . :w~ -t .DURKEE: TESTING LABORATORIES u o. c-m3" + 'cua M
>
. .
.
Y ~. . - 9. /i N.4..; 6. lle.ASf
"~
.1520 Wed 17M St.-; +.*,'.- . Cardena, Californ*a . 90247
-
- .
. . ;. - i. - - -
- .2% *
. . . s
!..*_ ....- . . . .
.
Ycur P.O. tio.: 0 2 ' 3' ' O *C' * - - - R:;; ort To: !.. .f .
.: . . . .
. Phone (213) 321900 .4 *' . C:t M
- ~ s- . :lacco Icdustries, Inc,-
* - - - -
'
- .,,.[;,,?/h 's ;1532 Nort!t Johnson Avenue .. - g
*
- c. .;
'
- Shipper No, 2852'I h.
.'f
'"
. ' f,"., g c- "J'.,'- l
.'i' El Cajon /. California 92020 _- . ... .c-
.
- e. ; y : 3.. '-
- -
,
.-
-..,.-
,- .
., - w- '
..:
- -
. _. ,~..,...t. . . ; . .: .. ....r. .s . .
. . ..'. a. ..
.
.. ..
. . . . . . . . ,. .-~. . . . . ... .< . , . .. . , . . - .n
..
.
,..- .. ,. . :. . .i
. . -~
, . . 1
. . . . . . ; .. , ... ..
': :s . . , r.
- n : . :...%
- a. *: ..s. . .. .%.. 4.-
. . . . . . .
. . -- .; q. . . . . - - .
.
.
.
. n'~
- c
. . '. , .- s > .1.~.wy .-n-2 -
...(...
e.
-
..
. :. :;. ~.; m .4.s W . - : :y .
.
. .p... .:: -. CERTIFIED TEST REPCRT
.
f * -' ...
-,
.. . .- ... . . , . . -
- 5. .$. l,Y.*ih.. F .' N>M.' j. itCUII.I'.-$.$i l
r . ... . i h.:.,. N.. .N. .. . w .x'M. : g.N W'k....' ... h, N . .N :
. MY. ' ~~b$.Y) . ,s. . u
,
.;. . ,. ;_ . .-
.
;.;n;., .,....:. Identification: One.(1) Test Speci=en .- 2. i . 3.j.
.
t . . , . . . ._. _ . . . ,/,4;.
' ' ';
'
. A516 crada 70 C' . " -
.. ...1;e /~'<.S~D. f..
- -
- - - . ~
'.: *
.
. . . .' .~7.' l.'. " t . gi;.C..'.,,. Ma ter. ia l::qf.' @ ..g...C..
.
.<. p 't.<
.
.
.,.3: , w g % .. g 8 - 3 ,y.1/2"..x 3 /c 3';' ' ..' -:.
c .n ....;...e... : - -.. ...
.'.. .., 13- :.
- - ._ ~
. . . . - .
- "
- a,'. - ;j :.. ;:-::. 3,e =. P/N 334.10 03t .- s- :' >,
-
- - e
- w. .:1.:o; .
- . .. . . .
. . ' . ' .. -.:..s.:x.-.
~ *:v.-
. * :w
.
.
'.
<... :-.
'
yent 077.175. ~. .). ..- Slab.0008: .--
.
an .:. . .s
.. . ; . . .:. .._v. ..' n. .. .. u
. . . . , .
. . . > s: . ,u.,. .. . , . a.-
. .
-
,.. 2
- t. ,.. : . .: :.: .a.p-
..
..;...., .....:
. . ...: . v -
,'.,.>..f.,.-.. .. .
.. : ..
.....
... ..
.,,:....e.,.....s 3 .. .. . w . 3 ,, .
.
.. .. .
.. .. .
.- . .v.r,-
.
. -'.M*i..? Q. c,.
,
-
.. ......... . . ~. -
. ...
. _ .- ,h..,
.
'
.6 ~t.1- l $ .-; & - G $7 N.. . - s r f. -
* " ' -
.*
*
-M-Wr' "J. . ;"? :..'-':.191%&- .1 Specification: ug",;-:;-L " ASME i.&;inction S III Subsection EB TNE-2300...
Para _
.'.
-
-
.U
.-[.y, ,.R.
' '
'
> b
. . .. -8, - "'i.
. ,.h.
. 7. JJ.9 Q .f.y .D ":.,s .:~ 7 1974 Iditicn,'.'.1974 Si=:mer'.addarx!A. . . ; i. ;.. .. ..;, '.-
r-- .+
. .
>: . c ..... -
, .cq .
..,y: >.. rv . ., y .; .y: :
. .:..r...r ,.,;4 : 2:. , . K.n ;. .
, ,. . ,:;
.-
, 8 " . .z
- .
.. .. .;- .:s.::. s,
.
. ..
;..
.
.
.
- ;.. .e .:....,.....
.
.v.
> ~
. u .: ... ..u...
..m. . . . . '
;..
. , .
- -
,
. . ..,.; . , ,f,, : n.. , n. ...., ;. :: s.
.
-
.~ .
<
- x. .
- -
.....
. . .. . . v- .- .<.-. :n .
. a .~ .r . _ . ..rr. . :. . . .%s W.u..
.. . . . .
" ' M <,. ; ,'.
.
-:y*:_ ; , C... :.;- .M ? . '-* ;- . ,' ' '. M. . . .: ,D. : ' . ,.,= -
- '
. * -
.
-
.
. ..
*.
'
, Process:^ * " ' Charpy "V" Not'ch Impact Test'at Test Temperature .
~; : .:.c.;;. <. ; x;;;. . , ' 11seea below ., i ~ - X - .
,- u - A ?;-
....%. .$. . . . .... > . .- ;
.
- - .
.- .
m
...w.
...
.
- . . : ~.-
.
.. .t .
, . .
. .'
< :' .;nesults:
~
-m2 . .'.;. : , -
'- .-
. . -',
- , .:
. .. -
. .- ?
.
..-
r, ;k,... .
.
. - Iongitud inal: -
- .
-
.. .-
.
.
.. -
.
..
..+ . w. . . . :. ..,: , . . . . . . ..
.m
. p. .,: 1,s c -. .
..... r. . . . . . . -.w. .. ~ s . . . . ..
. . . . .; -
- 7. Shear Fracture
- ,
..
Isteral Emansion
.
.
; ..e ../ . Temperature ' Impact values _ .
.
.,.
N: Ft[ Ibs,h ' - #'./.024" /
'
'
-
o : .- fl0,0 . J[.; c,. .c e- 37,,.qo;. y,g. .g . 243 0. g . . '28,0 ' F t. 016" / . ^.Ias s tha'n
.
lbs ,@ * ~^
.
,
-
.
Inss than 10,0 3*
; -
' -
- .; . ,02 9". - . #. . .'9. . . .. ; .d..- IS ,0-
.
.. "dR.g.@ m . 31. 0., Fe, lbs. . .W .
.- .r . '.".-I.
. , '.
' T, . ~0 -
.. . .
, *
'
* -
N ' W '37[0 Nti."I'sN.u.v b . ,
"
' "03 6" /. .- ..TO . $'O -3'
. '
z
.
.
._
.i:? '.: :: 3:< *::~. g g ,o y c , ty s , / .' 'G ,030n ? -
* , " 2. . -
,
-
'
q 43,o ,'ik
#
,
*
- X_ 25, o > yt,' Ibs ,' V ?. ' J-: ..F
..<..-'. '.:. . ....? -. _. ... '7.. . .:.. .... 3 0.w ', 0 .~. :. =.
-
.028".V
.
. ..
.
.
- .. . . . . .. a -. w
..
% .m '
-
-
= .-- :.
,
. ,. .. .e - . F. ., : e . . ', ;U
.
- ~
.
. .. -25 F ,'. . N.i 5'[0 t',' lb's',, , '
.h: ,'dO 6" . i.
,,
Iass than 10,0 f
'"
_ " J .; .
'
o 15, O Fe, Ibs,
-
.
,017"' 'Iass than 10,0
". n 007'? - * .. .Iass than ". 10, 0 ,
': T ' .f,q
*
,A
-
- d. Q.( .[~5,06l0.f Ft. Lbsl ,
. ,
Iass than - 10,0 . ,
. ,.
.
,.,- .
'
" Ft,'1bs, . .,'- .f. ,005" ...
~
"
"' ~
.N ; . 10I0' FtI'Ibs[ .
'[012" - 'Iass than iO,'O
. ;
'W 6 . 13,0
. .
.-
~
.. .
F t, lb s ,. . ' ,015" Iass than. . 10.0 .F' : 21,0 Fe, Lbs,- ,019" Iass than 10,0
- '
^! ?" c. ,' *- . % f., fd. DAIIS ; _-
; .-
.
{0W
.
- - -
yD ..:Wl:.5 : . y,m. .}.
- .
*
.- .. .i . _. . ? , . .r . . ;. }L**. -
o ,.
. . .
R.es/) y Submit.37pp.Qi . , .
,
c
~~".
. .x . ..
ectfully. .. .
. , , .
-
-
.- r m .
. g. .,...:
;,.
DURKEE,TE I - . LASQR ATORIES,
. . . ,,;, .
..
..
..
p D
' -
- Q, .m L.u gC #
'
~ -
sm
,
.
,. .
,,_%o,c.P.!,r.m.c.m.=a.txasse=
- -
. o .
c ... y.,. '
.
. a
.
.
~
.
; h ).51'Y .
.
.. .
.
..
. .
. . * .
-*h"-' -----.--e.--m--
'
- - , ,. 4.4,,,, , , _,_
_ ---- - LAW ENGINEERING TESTING COMPANY a. .. s s-f wm - s ar,mm ,wn, me, <" # m'h %
. X 2 e CHAAI.CTTE. NCATH CAACUNA 28220 - *
gg, (7046523 2022 g
.
/
REPORT OF CHARPY IMPACT TEST Client: W7 J. WOOLEY COMPANY Office: Charlotte Metals River Forest, Illinois Pr: ject: Date: March 27,1981
.
Catawba 1047, Units 1 & 2 CHS 81191 Lab. No. Client P. O. No.: 1047 1014 Material: Reported as W" Plate ASME SA 516, Grade 70 Heat No.: 75462 Slab 313 Date Tested: 3/2?/81 Sp:cimen Size: 10 mm (0.394") < 10 mm (0.394") Test Temperature: +180 F Precedure: In accordance with ASME Section 11, Subsection NE 2300 and Section lil, SA 370 TEST RESULTS . Impact - Lateral LETCo. Strength Expansion Percent Piece No. (Ft. Lbs.) (In.) Shear Comments 3 25 811C1 22 0.020 40 - 3 25 81 1 C2 29 0.026 48 - 3 25 81 IC3 26 0.024 37 -
.
.
Inspector (s) . Larry E. Coble Richard H. N ris , l l l Reviewed by: Edward M. Beck, P. E. Corporate Consultan l'Aetals Respectfully submitted, LAW ENGINEERING TESTING COMPANY i f -, f W
,,..,,-s,A.......m...-_....._.1...
I ! e.u. m .: v. .:,. :. ....:.:........:.... .
........ .... ,..
;-.*,v.g. ;:. :.,... .g. ,w
.s.... .
.
. . :.-~. n .. fm,. ~< s.o, .w
.1? ,.- p.v. u.a. ;- . l.:p.a,p.
a2
- . s,.. .. . p.1.A B O R u-. t-. ~&* *- , : * -
n,,.', .: . :. ...*-,... .. . . . .. . ;9 ,mr. '. ~.r. J A T.C R Y. . ,R E ? e..f. O._RT ' .. .. .....
. .... .... ,. ..r...... . . yg, f w
.an. .
.y . .
g- . .. .m. to n e.e. ..
~.
. -- . =-s,. . , .-
;,..g F.Fcbruary g ,. 19 8 0 .' r. . . g.; s ger. .;- ~~. n . &w, .-:. , . f.
. - .; 2- .
. y., /%.,,. . ... . e -- -
2 c., .... . . ,1,
.
- -W M.~ e > t :.:;.. . .. - w. :.: .-*: u
- Y.'.W
- 's f-n ? r .:,% . %.>: G.? ..~,:, s',y:;f;P.,:.o it..sc.M > er:.; :" - ' %;- (E DY U 4 R K E E ^ T E STI N G L A B~O~Ji;J.,4.u,:J.7- RATORIE5 &
) [.I.*-~P.. --' I */.3.* f,' ,.h. id.[.'?.S~.
R port To: ;. 1
. .. -
; ;. .-... ;
.. -
kl520 We d 178th S t. . , . . .
.c- :;~....-.r...").: Phone (213) 3219300 4
.
*. .Gardero. Cal; forma . 90247
. .
-
.
.....- .
'Ye::r P.d. Nr : - '
.-
,#9 *., ~ ' * - -
.,. .
'*-~-
, - .
- 0-~f> f?-i.FIamco Industriess : Ice; - i.
-
- -
. .
'
. -
-
'
C.47:
' ' -
.:.6bEm.'.':s.; ,p. 3532 North. Joheson Avenue
*
.
- --
- c. .g - , i.?.
x . - c Shipper No, 2 Ep2 7.j , . t .:. '.W.]' /. ,:.El Cajon, California 92020 ...,... . . ; .....; i
. :z.., e .. . >
. . .
. . . . , 1. .
. , . . . . .
. ,
; :l.+.:e .::-:.,;..e. p s.. g. r . n.- . :g g c. g g yy q,.;...-.
.,. . . . ;. .a.%,.
.
- . . .
.
, ..
.:.... s.
.,.
. ;. . . .y . . . . . .w .:. : . : p.
.. .. .. . . .. .c ., . . ;;%. .. :7+ .. .
.
.
,
v
. ..
.
-
. u., .;- -
.
.,.<.a... ..
..
.
,
. . . . .. . .. . .
m.. .,; - y . , . ..
?.
. .. . . . . . ... .
.
**
.
W :. ;;f f....s, :s s .*: *:.....lj.' ;*s , , ..,, , - ':".**r1 " * -* .- '.an
. -~;,. .. . ._1,,.,g'_ * ..* .
' .
*=J R** Q 'y*. .;.,.;
- 5. p f;. . . j. g:"' *. -
"*
*
'
e '* . ..y r- *- .
.
. . . ' . .. Q* I.:
.
o ;:, s.,; - ,
.e.. ...
.: -
. ::.. ". <r . ....0.- t. .*:. . . 1.:
..; .
,~... ~ c. .J".............',.w...
; . f.; e, .g .
. , , :.:., ;t., ,.. .. . . , ; . ,, . . . .. . ..;. ... c, _. . ~ . . . ..a.. . . . . , - .
! '3: :z. .,. ' :.:..,:.w 'y::.: w. p..*4..
.s .. ..
.x.l. -{.; . .. 9.ph. CERTIFTED TEST REPORT.
. . . . . . -A b.
.
* .
- ff . :...:::.? '....[ . ~ ..?:g*},ym.1.R.COf.y._.y.
-
.
,
.. . . . . ......
,
. .
. .. . . .,
' .s." . ~. <.):.v .f. . . .n, .?x . .z Identificaeion;. w.
. . .. Oce (1) 'tast Speci::en%.... :f .. ~;tA",'/ ../ .
,"..
-
.L'. . I. E. . .'.J-*".'. :. ~. ..;;. I. 9 -
.. .
l -.W. .,:.p%: . u~..c.1o.;r.W.. t. - Maeer.in1:........ -A516 Crade 70. . ..:l-.i.
-
. .. . o., ;;..a:%..3..
. .
. . .. . .:: . . .., .A;. -. . .:.,.:. .. -m,;.._ ..; b,2. v.
- .
.
- . . w.. 7 .-
. -
.. . t .- . 't . ..:. : g; m 1/2" x sn x 8n . . . . ..- -
.- . . .
- 4. g. g. 2,..4. ,M. M'g.g./.ey.},,,
.
~
.Z 'i,. g,. p,e,Qf g 33417 8 /% "*.'--e. . U. .- ' - ;' .'. '. *. 7 - . h.t. . i. ,~
, . .
c
.;;.'. M.. r
... . . . . . . . .
" .
, ,. .;.m.. d;. ' . j.7.,. r.r', . . . s. . ;.?.
. ..o
. .~. .,:, . .c..-
F.e a e J 754 62. ,f.S2ab ... f> ; 3 w..Q. 2A
, , . . . .
..
......
-
- .._.'". .
.....:. . . . . . . . . ,c..,, .. .. .. v
.
.
. ... . , . . .. ..
,.
... ,. .. .. .
.
. . . ... . .
,
.
4 .
.
,,.,.,. . ....<. .,...t....,._.
. .
.
.. . . . . . .w . .
..
.
.. - .
.,
....
.
..2., . .,
.
.- .. . , . . .
. ' ..
..
%.. ;:,-z: ~.. .q. ... ;.. .. t 7 2." 6 ; , ~ . . .s - .. -;.y;
..
.... p :f.y m: w e;' .:.-% m -<.;;c.
..
- .r.9.-.,m .- c; l'. :.:
. .
. .
~. .
-
.-
" . '. 3.'
_ ~
'
-
'. _.'.'.$ . M 'Specif fee tion; :- 1 SIS'eAtid III ' Subsection E c Para 2-230d7 ~
-
+y, . ,j .t,
...
zf:C . . i;;;; f g . y.g ,.,. ,. .'.1974 ed ition
, ..
.s.e.'.. . S u:=.,. er.1974 a.dd.e nda .' ....:.,..
3; i ~. . . T-
. , ..,. , :.,- ..c.f.... .. . . . .M,. ..,..
.s*. .,,.
. *. .e. . ,. . ... .m. , f :. . , . . .. ..,.. . . .
..
,
. - - . . . . , ..
. .
, . . . . . . ,.
. . .
.. ; . .. .
..
. ...:
, , . . , , .c .,- .
, . ' . , g. , . .:
..
. , . . . .g... ,.. ,.:% q.,.,c~....g
. . . . . .G . 3 , , .. . .. y. .
*
'g - .
.o
* ..
'. .g .4 ~;. s. .:.***"....f*4,
,, - . ,. -;m %,; %.
,
-
.: ..
.. ..s
.. ..s.e ' .. ;. . . . . 1 g.
- s. . .. - s ,
; -
o.
,.
,,,s.4.,'-
'*.~:_*,.....- *
. & . :,Y. ,. ; ===:..*a.
-
. f- t .
.
r .,- . s. . ,
.,..;f. . ~.t .,.,,.-l,.
*
.. ..i......?. * .*
*
*
- i. ' .
- , ~ ~ ~.. . ... < * * * :, ;
.'..,.s.,:' e:-s
.~ ,..,:;~;:,,.. C.*.. .; .s
,x,.
.
.**.. .. .. . . . . ,
..:..,..s
.
i ~,. - ' . . . .
. .
. : 'g .. -
..
.. . . ,
. ..
.
. . s. . . .: .. . .. .
.
. ..
' ' ' "-
- -
.Procers' ' Charpy "V" Notch Impact Test at Test Te=peract:re .
. . :b .:';. . '. g. < . :; :- ' ' - % . ' ' *
-
* * *
..f
. , . . ,. Listed. belou
.
. .
.v
.
.. ,. ., .
..
. n. . ....-
.-.
.
. .
.
. . , . ,...7.., , ...
.- .. ..
. . .
. '. . - . .
.
,'s....-
, s .
-
. . : 1, ~. . y. . . , -
. . ::s, . . ;- . . .
.. .G. 2.
,....-
.
. . . .
. , . . .. .. . .. . .
..2g . ,
., .. . 3
.. ,
,.<,.e.
. .
.,
. .. ., y . . . . .... ., . ,. . . . .. ...-
-
' .. .
,
Results: i .cd si . n.- ....,'f. .. . . , . . . .. .
< .
.
-
. ; ;-
-
.5
, ,9
- v. ,. s c.': a...
' .C.* ... . . -
....;,,. ,. . ,'._'.t.,..Iongitud inal: ~ ~
.
..
-..r-;.
2
- p. ,.
- 5 ..
.
. j -
.,..-
,.
..z.. . .. .u .. .. .
~. .
*
,,,..-,...m.
.. ;..
, .
- t
. .
2.',
.e. . s.r
".s .<
e .. vy;,
- e. r.<.. .
,.
..
.
. ..
.
. ..
. .
.
?. .
. ,' , Test . ..g..,. y.pi.~ .g..s.g . . 3.,. ,
.e .
. ;z m . ':- . . . , . J.. .. ;;. .. .. ,
. .
p' hpa ce va lues ~
. .
. .
.,~-
'
Tempera t ure Iateral Expansion 7. Shear Fre :t: e
-
f e, . -
.
.
-
.: .,
* ;. % , ba Ff Q.. eN .2 7,.0
.- ,.
- . .
. .
.
, , ,.m.w; < '/-
Ft(....-..... I.bs,f .' s.7 .
-
. . , ,
- .
f,. 031" . . ;;J .r.
.. . .
.
"
.:
'. .
-.
.... .
- .:
-52,0
- .'..'. -
Q
'
., , ,
- 4. 40,0 Ft .Lbs,f- c. 5 6 ,0
'
- c;,. ....,032". 040". --i, 7:'..
. , ~ , -,. ' . .,'-" 3c. ,.32,0.;Ft..Lbs,/: w.y
. , . .- w. . . . - , . ,
. ,s . . . . , .. .
- . ..
.
- e. ;.: -
.,
- -
,
. : .43,0 . . .:
. -
; -
.:: .
, ... .,.. -
. . c.~. :.y-- c* <. .;
.
. . .
.
. .-. ,. .;. c. . .. ~~~:
.
+
. .
.;
.
. . ,
.
o
.. g ;,;.i.(. , p- . p '
, . . :, :.-
*
; .
..
.
. -25 F,
-
. 20,0 F t Lbs /* ",023" .
-
. I
~
40.0.
'
.
.$027" ~ 40,0 -
.-18,'O24, O','.Ft f Lbs.g[
.
'
- / *. - '
.
-
,l ..,; . . [Ft Lbs', ; .
.' ;,022" s
. .
-
?K 3 0 ,0.. ? 1 .
.l. ; <f. ,' 03 b" ' '
-
.
.
0 $I - 30[0" ht[I5s~',. A * ' 28,0 " Ft, lbs, / ,032"
' ~
' '
' 43,0 -'
4 . . . , . c.
. ' ...'-
-@ '
.-
'
. 025 '.' /'
-
.- ; Qf/ 20,0 Ft,;Lbs. ' - - 52,0 .-
-
e .- . .:. .,. f i., .. _.
.
.
f.0 02/3Sl .
.: - . . _.. :::
' '
*
. . . . -. . v o. S irt,d A
*-*
Q y 3 ] N 7 0 yy;.
.
. . ~?
'
f
## I espectfullf/5ubmi ed
.
.
.
,
. ,
at 7
'DURKEE T EST' LA 3OR ATOR!E5 -
.
*t,&pQ,v#\, .
,g'\ f-A - - - - - -
.- ~; ..
*
.\W .-
( .~ . : s-yf*,.
. . >.
. . . ,D .. .. . m .i. .
,
. .
. . .
,
. B u -
-
-
.
am, General Macapr
.
'
g .)g Roy E, Fe
' -
-
'trl y -
.
. ..
.
..
.- .
, .. .
.
.
.w.. ,.w.- -
-. , g,- --,
'
E.AW bMG3M.E 3MG 72f>IENG COSMdMY
'
'
" ~
M ATERIALE TESTING ENGINEERS M 't
*} /(0),Qg Soll AND FOUNDATION INVESTIGATIONS I ,,
33G P!nters Ave., fJ.E. P.O. Bo.x 13260, Sts. K
) . . i'
,
ATLAtJTA, GEORGIA 30324 b."h kgl N
- CHARPY V-NOTCH EP/CT TESTS REPORT OF W.J. Woolley Company Client: 7425 West Lake Street Office: Atlanta, Georgia River Forest, IL 60305 Date: October 7, 1980
'oject: Catawba 10?7, Units 1 & 2 P0 No. 1047-950 G-7914 Lab I:o. 23446 Job No. Charpy V-Notch Impact Tests were con /Jcted on materials delivered to our laboratory by Law Engineering Testinu Company, Charlotte, NC on 9/25/E0 These tests were S/N 1-74104 withconducted usingenergy'of a total impact a Riehle Impact Testing flachine Pi,l 2The veloc YE, D 120 ft.-lbs. of the striker at impact was 11.3 fps and energy loss due to fricttica d40 6 I is 0 ft.-lbs.
,
.
TEST RESULTS l Material: 1/2" Plate, ASME SA-515, Grade 70 ! rr /047
~~~
- l Heat No.: 44014 Slab 2/1 DF; /C -/C -2b Specimen Test Impact Hils Lateral Percent Number Size Temo. Value Exoansion Shear 10m x 10m +15 F 40 37 42 D' D-2 10n1 x -10m - +150F 33.5 28 35 D-3 10m x 10re t15 F 40 -40 48
.
Average 37.8
.
We certify that the statements in this record are correct and that the test ~ specimens were prepared and tested in accordance with SA370 ,
.
Respectfully submit:ed,
-
LAVb ENGINEE:tlNG TESTING CO.
/ 7 + + . W /I l d
- _ _ = _ . . . _ _ _
s . . . 0$ SkbbbU ?bb Yb$'.b$ $D$; h.$b5 p. [_ ~ MATE t! ALE TESTING ENGINEERS ,fV'%
'.
'
/ Soil AND TouSDATloN INVESTIGAT!oNS E' Y-kb%
395 Pinten An.. N.E. P.O. Box 13250. S:s. K ATI.ANTA. GEORGIA 30024 It g'# CHARPY V-f 0TCH It' PACT TESTS REPORT OF tl.J. Uoolley Company Clir.nt: 7425 Uest Lake Street ' Office: Atlanta, Georgia River Forest, IL 60305 Date: October 8, 1980 roject: Catawba 1047, Units 1 & 2 p0 d1047-950 Jcb No. G-7914 Lab flo. 23447 O5 *
.
CharpyV-flotchImoactTestswereconducte[o'nm'aterialsdeliveredtocur
'
laboratory by LETCo Charlotte, flC ..
.~ . - o n 9/25/80.
~
These tests were conducted using a Rieh'id Impact Testing !!achine ElGOPY TO: S/fl 1-74104 with a total impact energy of 120 ft.-lbs. The velod y of the striker at impact was 11.3 fps and energy loss due to fricE9a N8 is O f t.-lbs. l
- TEST RESULTS __
Material: 1/2" Plate, ASME SA-516, Grade 70 Heat flo.: 44104 Slab 3/1 DATE:/g). f.gp q
.
. .
Specimen Test Impact Mils Lateral Percer.t flumber Size Temo. Value Excansion Shear
'
E-1 10mm x 10cm +18"F 26.5 24 98 o E-2 10am x 10mm +18 F 24.5 27- SS E-3 10m x 10mm +180F 22.5- 25- 7)
'
-
. .
_
.
" ~
Averace
-
. ..
e . g He certify thet the statements in this record are correct andstjpts th_t }est.L ~ e specimens were prepared and tested in accordance with SA370
~
CCT 141920 W. J. WOOLEY CC
.
Respectfully submit:ed, i ' WAENGIMEpp{[SM CO.
~
i Tr
--
O LAW ENGINEERING TESTING501M.muet Lane
- P. O. Box 11297 (i\*C 1
C s
/ *2* Charlotte. North Carolina 23220 s f
,
. %;;p~.
REPORT OF CHARPY IMPACT TEST W. J. WOO LEY COMPANY Charlotte Metals Client: River Forest, Illinois Office: Date: September 15, 1980 Project: Catawba 1047, Units 1 & 2 Lab. No. CHS 80 191 _ ____.____... Client P. O. No.: 1047 940 Material: Reported as %" Plate, ASME SA 516, Grade 70 Heat No.: 44014 Slab 7/1 ' Data Tested: 9/10/80 Specimen Size: 10 mm x 10 mm l Test Temperature: 0 F Precedure: In accordance with ASME SA-370 .. l '
.
TEST RESULTS 1 Impact lateral " LETCo. Strength Expansion Percent h Piece N o. (Ft. Lbs.) (In.) Shear Comments 8-29 80 CF1 33.0 0.030 37.0 NA l NA 8-29 80-CF2 43.5 0.035 42.0 i 8 29-80 CF3 37.0 0.032 38.0 NA l l l l Inspector (s): 1.arry E. - Coble
- i Richard . .H. Norris Reviewed by: Respectfully submitted,
' LAW ENGINEERING TCSTING cot /.?N:Y
' & t <
.
Edward M. ' Beck. E. LitrygCoble w
LAW ENGINEERING TESTING COMPANY j- a. ..s
- g. .
- - - s - , - n - , n u a,,
g r~'7:p
,[.
g j, To "$dI2N'cx4atorucars cancus4 2s22o aw s2>2=2 M g T-D.$ y REPORT OF CHARPY IMPACT TEST I ' W. J. WOOLEY COMPANY Charlotte Metals
- Client
- River Forest, Illinois Office:
March ;!7,1981 Project: Date: . Catawba 1047, Units I & 2 CHS 81191 Lab. No. l Cli:nt P. O. No.: 1047 1014 1 Material: Reported as W" Plate, ASME SA 516, Grade 70 Heat No.' 13437, Slab 9/2 Date Tested: 3/27/81 l Sp;cimen Size: 10 mm (0.394") x 10 mm (0.394") l Test Temperature: +18 F Precedure: In accordance with ASME Section !!, Subsection NE-2300 and Section Ill, SA-370 , TEST RESULTS . ! l impact - Lateral LETCo. Strength Expansion Percent Piece No. (Ft. Lbs.) (In.) Shear Comr.ien ts 3-25-81 2C1 122 0.084 * - 3 25 812C2 122
- 0.084 -
3 25-81-2C3 122 0.087 * -
#-
Sevimen did not break. Percent shear cannot be determined. i . l Inspector (s) : Larry E. Coble Richard H. Norri 1 / L Reviewed by: y Edward M. Beck, P. E. Corporate Consultant / Metals Respectfully submitted, !
LAW ENGINEERING TESTING COMPANY y 3 f
. - /}}