ML19208C758: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
 
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
 
(One intermediate revision by the same user not shown)
Line 17: Line 17:


=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:*/CC D i.i UU.l.13 G
{{#Wiki_filter:*     /                                                                                                                                       _,/
_,/noo. r, muu uc. So -983 S H AW, PITTM AN PoTTs & TROW B RIDG E 18 0 0 M STACCT,N.W.
CC D i.i UU.l.13 G noo. r, muu uc. So -983 S H AW, PITTM AN PoTTs & TROW B RIDG E 18 0 0 M STACCT,N.W.
W A S HI N GTO N. O. C. 2 O O 36 m a u s a t o. Poet s stevcN L.=cLt2cm aoas ami. ioo sic v ant 6. settM *N CsaN o.AvuCR
W A S HI N GTO N. O. C. 2 O O 36 m a u s a t o. Poet s         stevcN L.=cLt2cm                                                                                     aoas ami. ioo sic v ant 6. settM *N         CsaN o.AvuCR                                                                                             -
-3ccmoc F. toowenscGc so*=N cNGck stspucN o. ports ST c 8m c m e. w w'tbCe TCb8'K semaLo cuanworr ev' M f ai m ",, P M. emoWN
3ccmoc       F. toowenscGc     so*=N cNGck stspucN o. ports               ST c 8m c m e. w w'tbCe                                                                               TCb8     'K semaLo cuanworr               ev' M f ai m ",, P M. emoWN
==ew e o.ecsta.cn.aw c s e. =awuN.reas se-oesa a ase-i7eo
    ==ew e o.ecsta.cn             .aw c s e. =awuN                             ,                                            .reas se-oesa a ase-i7eo a fianctw v .ahtoN             ac ec at c. 2ase 6c m                       M aconG c w. moo c a s, s a.
, a fianctw v .ahtoN ac ec at c. 2ase 6c m M aconG c w. moo c a s, s a.
    .cas o. maiNc L ANcc a nicaam o C. Gakc N sc o c at e. mo e s N s 0/            *'
nicaam o C. Gakc N 0/\-*'.cas o. maiNc L ANcc a sc o c at e. mo e s N s (DCg tcbcx emucc w.cwwmem L5 Lawma n rammaNo ac su r 4. htCMoks oN.s m.
                                                                                                            \                              -
M atia s F. T a avl C s o
tcbcx emucc w.cwwmem L5 ac su r 4. htCMoks oN.s m.
* Cial g g, g g g g e g,g,, Lg, , g ,g Oeg, em a n t e N o.maakL victomias.premihs 6 a caste s-antaa-s.chcan so-N.c'Nciu.sm.
Lawma n rammaNo M atia s F. T a avl C s o
m.ic, .n oL e c e s 17%.c. s sat a. castic M n sansana mossotti ream a uw c. c-u
* Cial victomias.premihs (DCg                                    g g, g g g g e g,g,, Lg, , g ,g em a n t e N o.maakL
'$o fl 6~o.cono c v. auc h.
: s. chcan         so-N     .c'Nciu.sm.                 6                Oeg,                  a                  caste s-antaa-m.ic,
m.ac.c noc o. cac*6cv. sa.
          .n soL e c e s
U$4 somn se. sMAmeN
: c.                       sat a. castic M                                                     n   17  %
%w anaeroso acehotos u acto.-ats-Qt .gcit---re co .. uvsc t ,. o as.-.com-ic.
sansana         mossotti     ream a uw c. c-u                     ~                              '$
.g- g g 3 ,, o ,, , ,o , ,, N o susan o. rasa son
: m.        o                                                       fl               6                   somn se. sMAmeN o.cono raco c v. aucacehotos anaeroso re co .. uvsc s.masmce at-aa.cw    a.ese
'3 b ,g@q]raco s.masmce at-aa.cw a.ese sicvcN w.twcas 5=ama avocheuc.cc sm.
: h.       ac.c noc u
afs..g (c r covNsc6 m a o 6. a u e n.
t ,. o as
cm%csv.s.anc.sm.
: o. cac*6cv. sa.
awaN s. weissaac
acto.-ats
'g gg6N taowas 4. santen as*N m.vwsaca , ,'s 3yt'ca s a to N s. s o N c s
                                                .-.com-ic.
*isu a= e. s ae m 7 sauce 4.symGcm som N 6. Cam m. J a.
susan o. rasa son sicvcN w.twcas
sacwcom s. acsscu
                                                                        '3
==iu m s.manvcv somNa.wcc6LLCuGn nat L. m eC MadaN.N h-@sauts t=ouas schwant July 2, 1979 The Honorable Joseph Hendrie Chairman U.S.Nuclear Regulatorn Commission Washington, D.C.20555  
                                                                                    %w Qt .gcitU$4 5
g c
                                                                                                          -g ]
g 3 ,, o ,, , ,o , ,, N o covNsc6
    =ama avocheuc.cc sm.           m a o 6. a u e n.                                 afs..g (    b ,g@q      r cm%csv .s.anc.sm.
ca s a to N s. s o N c s awaN s. weissaac
                                  *isu a= e. s ae m
                                                                          'g           gg6N taowas 4. santen               as*N m.vwsaca                             , ,'s             3yt' sauce 4.symGcm                 som N 6. Cam m. J a.                                                     7 sacwcom s. acsscu             ==iu m s.manvcv somNa.wcc6LLCuGn sauts t=ouas schwant nat L. m eC MadaN                               .N h-         @
July 2, 1979 The Honorable Joseph Hendrie Chairman U.S. Nuclear Regulatorn Commission Washington, D.C.                     20555


==Dear Mr. Chairman:==
==Dear Mr. Chairman:==


On Friday evening, June 29, 1979, Commissioner Gilinsky announced in Middletown, Pa., that the Commission had decided to issue a formal order with respect to TMI-1.
On Friday evening, June 29, 1979, Commissioner Gilinsky announced in Middletown, Pa., that the Commission had decided to issue a formal order with respect to TMI-1. While GPU has had no official notice of the Commission's action, it is our under-standing based on Commissioner Gilinsky's announcement that the order will require TMI-l to remain shut down until further order of the Commission and that an opportunity for public hearing will be provided prior to final Commission action.
While GPU has had no official notice of the Commission's action, it is our under-standing based on Commissioner Gilinsky's announcement that the order will require TMI-l to remain shut down until further order of the Commission and that an opportunity for public hearing will be provided prior to final Commission action.
The purpose of this letter is to request that GPU have an opportunity to review and comment on any proposed order with respect to the scope and conduct of the hearing cnd the Commis-sion's decisional process.                                   The Commission's determinations on these matters can make-a difference of many months in the length of the proceeding.
The purpose of this letter is to request that GPU have an opportunity to review and comment on any proposed order with respect to the scope and conduct of the hearing cnd the Commis-sion's decisional process.
We would be prepared to meet with the Commission's st ff or in the alternative to furnish our comments within 48 hours ,2 receipt of a proposed order.                                       Meanwhile, we have the following suggestions:
The Commission's determinations on these matters can make-a difference of many months in the length of the proceeding.
: 1. The scope of the hearing should be limited to issues which arise out of the THI-2 accident L&O 1:    -    '
We would be prepared to meet with the Commission's st ff or in the alternative to furnish our comments within 48 hours ,2 receipt of a proposed order.
7909270                 4!
Meanwhile, we have the following suggestions:
Cr 1049 257
1.The scope of the hearing should be limited to issues which arise out of the THI-2 accident L&O 7909270 4!1: '''-Cr 1049 257  
 
'.s.SHAW, PITTMAN, POTTS & TROWBRIDGE The Honorable Joseph Hendrie July 2, 1979 Page Two and to whether the measures proposed by Metro-politan Edison Company to be accomplished prior to the start-up of TMI-l represent an adequate short-term response to that accident and a basis for restart of TMI-1.
s SHAW, PITTMAN, POTTS & TROWBRIDGE The Honorable Joseph Hendrie July 2, 1979 Page Two and to whether the measures proposed by Metro-politan Edison Company to be accomplished prior to the start-up of TMI-l represent an adequate short-term response to that accident and a basis for restart of TMI-1. These mea-sures are listed in a letter from Mr. Herbein to Mr. Denton, dated June 27, 1979 (copy at-tached).
These mea-sures are listed in a letter from Mr. Herbein to Mr. Denton, dated June 27, 1979 (copy at-tached).2.Since the Commission has decided that TMI-l should not restart until further decision and order of the Commission itself, the normal process of hearing and decision by an Atomic Safety and Licensing Board followed by appeals to the Appeal Board and then to the Commis-sion should not be followed.
: 2. Since the Commission has decided that TMI-l should not restart until further decision and order of the Commission itself, the normal process of hearing and decision by an Atomic Safety and Licensing Board followed by appeals to the Appeal Board and then to the Commis-sion should not be followed. One alternative would be to adopt instead the procedura fol-lowed in the Appendix I and ECCS rulemaking proceedings, i.e. an adjudicatory hearing before a specially appointed hearing board which would then certify the record to the Commission for decision.
One alternative would be to adopt instead the procedura fol-lowed in the Appendix I and ECCS rulemaking proceedings, i.e. an adjudicatory hearing before a specially appointed hearing board which would then certify the record to the Commission for decision.
: 3. The hearing board should be instructed, as permitted by present regulations, to consoli-date to the maximum extent possible multiple interventions by private individuals or groups.
3.The hearing board should be instructed, as permitted by present regulations, to consoli-date to the maximum extent possible multiple interventions by private individuals or groups.
: 4. The order should make clear that pending the outcome of the hearing Metropolitan Edison Company may proceed to make modifications in the TMI-l plant and plant procedures in ac-cordance with existing Commission regulations, including modifications alteady required by the Commission for other 3&W reactor plants.
4.The order should make clear that pending the outcome of the hearing Metropolitan Edison Company may proceed to make modifications in the TMI-l plant and plant procedures in ac-cordance with existing Commission regulations, including modifications alteady required by the Commission for other 3&W reactor plants.
The above suggestions are consistent both with an op-portunity for citizens living in the vicinity of the plant fully to p?rticipate in a public hearing and with the interest of the customers of Metropolitan Edison Company in the earliest practi-cable decision on the restart of TMI-1.
The above suggestions are consistent both with an op-portunity for citizens living in the vicinity of the plant fully to p?rticipate in a public hearing and with the interest of the customers of Metropolitan Edison Company in the earliest practi-cable decision on the restart of TMI-1.
1049 258 52S VE0i}}
1049 258 52S VE0i}}

Latest revision as of 06:51, 2 February 2020

Comments on V Gilinsky 790629 Announcement That NRC Will Issue Order Re Facility.Util Should Have Opportunity to Review & Comment on Proposed Order.Submits Suggestions on Scope of Issues,Conduct of Hearing & Decisional Process
ML19208C758
Person / Time
Site: Three Mile Island Constellation icon.png
Issue date: 07/02/1979
From: Trowbridge G
GENERAL PUBLIC UTILITIES CORP., SHAW, PITTMAN, POTTS & TROWBRIDGE
To: Hendrie J
NRC COMMISSION (OCM)
Shared Package
ML19208C759 List:
References
NUDOCS 7909270411
Download: ML19208C758 (3)


Text

  • / _,/

CC D i.i UU.l.13 G noo. r, muu uc. So -983 S H AW, PITTM AN PoTTs & TROW B RIDG E 18 0 0 M STACCT,N.W.

W A S HI N GTO N. O. C. 2 O O 36 m a u s a t o. Poet s stevcN L.=cLt2cm aoas ami. ioo sic v ant 6. settM *N CsaN o.AvuCR -

3ccmoc F. toowenscGc so*=N cNGck stspucN o. ports ST c 8m c m e. w w'tbCe TCb8 'K semaLo cuanworr ev' M f ai m ",, P M. emoWN

==ew e o.ecsta.cn .aw c s e. =awuN , .reas se-oesa a ase-i7eo a fianctw v .ahtoN ac ec at c. 2ase 6c m M aconG c w. moo c a s, s a.

.cas o. maiNc L ANcc a nicaam o C. Gakc N sc o c at e. mo e s N s 0/ *'

\ -

tcbcx emucc w.cwwmem L5 ac su r 4. htCMoks oN.s m.

Lawma n rammaNo M atia s F. T a avl C s o

  • Cial victomias.premihs (DCg g g, g g g g e g,g,, Lg, , g ,g em a n t e N o.maakL
s. chcan so-N .c'Nciu.sm. 6 Oeg, a caste s-antaa-m.ic,

.n soL e c e s

c. sat a. castic M n 17  %

sansana mossotti ream a uw c. c-u ~ '$

m. o fl 6 somn se. sMAmeN o.cono raco c v. aucacehotos anaeroso re co .. uvsc s.masmce at-aa.cw a.ese
h. ac.c noc u

t ,. o as

o. cac*6cv. sa.

acto.-ats

.-.com-ic.

susan o. rasa son sicvcN w.twcas

'3

%w Qt .gcitU$4 5

g c

-g ]

g 3 ,, o ,, , ,o , ,, N o covNsc6

=ama avocheuc.cc sm. m a o 6. a u e n. afs..g ( b ,g@q r cm%csv .s.anc.sm.

ca s a to N s. s o N c s awaN s. weissaac

  • isu a= e. s ae m

'g gg6N taowas 4. santen as*N m.vwsaca , ,'s 3yt' sauce 4.symGcm som N 6. Cam m. J a. 7 sacwcom s. acsscu ==iu m s.manvcv somNa.wcc6LLCuGn sauts t=ouas schwant nat L. m eC MadaN .N h- @

July 2, 1979 The Honorable Joseph Hendrie Chairman U.S. Nuclear Regulatorn Commission Washington, D.C. 20555

Dear Mr. Chairman:

On Friday evening, June 29, 1979, Commissioner Gilinsky announced in Middletown, Pa., that the Commission had decided to issue a formal order with respect to TMI-1. While GPU has had no official notice of the Commission's action, it is our under-standing based on Commissioner Gilinsky's announcement that the order will require TMI-l to remain shut down until further order of the Commission and that an opportunity for public hearing will be provided prior to final Commission action.

The purpose of this letter is to request that GPU have an opportunity to review and comment on any proposed order with respect to the scope and conduct of the hearing cnd the Commis-sion's decisional process. The Commission's determinations on these matters can make-a difference of many months in the length of the proceeding.

We would be prepared to meet with the Commission's st ff or in the alternative to furnish our comments within 48 hours5.555556e-4 days <br />0.0133 hours <br />7.936508e-5 weeks <br />1.8264e-5 months <br /> ,2 receipt of a proposed order. Meanwhile, we have the following suggestions:

1. The scope of the hearing should be limited to issues which arise out of the THI-2 accident L&O 1: - '

7909270 4!

Cr 1049 257

s SHAW, PITTMAN, POTTS & TROWBRIDGE The Honorable Joseph Hendrie July 2, 1979 Page Two and to whether the measures proposed by Metro-politan Edison Company to be accomplished prior to the start-up of TMI-l represent an adequate short-term response to that accident and a basis for restart of TMI-1. These mea-sures are listed in a letter from Mr. Herbein to Mr. Denton, dated June 27, 1979 (copy at-tached).

2. Since the Commission has decided that TMI-l should not restart until further decision and order of the Commission itself, the normal process of hearing and decision by an Atomic Safety and Licensing Board followed by appeals to the Appeal Board and then to the Commis-sion should not be followed. One alternative would be to adopt instead the procedura fol-lowed in the Appendix I and ECCS rulemaking proceedings, i.e. an adjudicatory hearing before a specially appointed hearing board which would then certify the record to the Commission for decision.
3. The hearing board should be instructed, as permitted by present regulations, to consoli-date to the maximum extent possible multiple interventions by private individuals or groups.
4. The order should make clear that pending the outcome of the hearing Metropolitan Edison Company may proceed to make modifications in the TMI-l plant and plant procedures in ac-cordance with existing Commission regulations, including modifications alteady required by the Commission for other 3&W reactor plants.

The above suggestions are consistent both with an op-portunity for citizens living in the vicinity of the plant fully to p?rticipate in a public hearing and with the interest of the customers of Metropolitan Edison Company in the earliest practi-cable decision on the restart of TMI-1.

1049 258 52S VE0i