PY-CEI-NRR-0397, Forwards Suppl to 840406 Response to Generic Ltr 83-28,Item 1.2,addressing Concerns Re Acceptability of Performance Capability of Time History Recorders,Per NRC 851025 Draft Technical Evaluation

Forwards Suppl to 840406 Response to Generic Ltr 83-28,Item 1.2,addressing Concerns Re Acceptability of Performance Capability of Time History Recorders,Per NRC 851025 Draft Technical Evaluation

ML20136E087
Person / Time
Site:	Perry
Issue date:	11/15/1985
From:	Edelman M CLEVELAND ELECTRIC ILLUMINATING CO.
To:	Youngblood B Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
GL-83-28, PY-CEI-NRR-0397, PY-CEI-NRR-397, NUDOCS 8511210420
Download: ML20136E087 (4)

Text

THE CLEkELAND ELECTRIC ILLllMIN ATING COMPANY P.o. BOX 5000 - CLEVELAND, OHIO 44101 - TELEPHONE (216) 622-9800 - ILLUMINATING BtDG. - 55 PUBLICSQUARE Serving The Best Location in the Nation

% 1.

MURRAY R. EDELMAN

' " November 15, 1985 Ec'uA PY-CEI/NRR-0397 L Mr. B. J. Youngblood, Chief Licensing Branch No. 1 Division of Licensing U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington,,D.C. 20555 Perry Nuclear Power Plant Docket Nos. 50-440; 50-441 Supplemental Information Response to Generic Letter 83-28

Dear Mr. Youngblood:

In a letter dated October 25, 1985, you provided a Draft Technical Evaluation of Perry's compliance with NRC Generic Letter 83-28, Item 1.2. In that evaluation, it was stated that there was insufficient information to determine the acceptability of the performance capability of the time history recorders.

The reviewer also stated the recorded data may not be output in a readable and meaningful format. The information provided in Attachment 1 addresses these concerns and supplements our response to Generic Letter 83-28 provided by our letter dated April 6, 1984 (PY-CEI/NRR-0100L).

Should you have any further questions regarding this equipment, please let me know.

oprs <

Very 8 truly /

LK u ,

Murray R. Ede', man Vice President Nuclear Group MRE:nj e Attachments cc: Jay Silberg, Esq.

John Stefano (2)

J. Grobe

. .y i

agh12gggiggo A

Attachment 1 PY-CEI/NRR-0397 L RESPONSE TO TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT COHMENTS The analog time history recorders are described in Section 1.2.2.2 of our response to Generic Letter 83-28. All of the parameters (listed in Attachment C to our response) monitored by these instruments are normally recorded constantly during plant operations and therefore information at least 5 minutes prior to, and 10 minutes after, a plant trip will be retained.

As stated in our response, the majority of these analog parameters are recorded on single or dedicated multi pen strip chart recorders. These type of recorders are continuous plot recorders, therefore there is no interval between data points. Ce-tain parameters that change relatively slowly (such as temperatures and turbine supervisory instruments) are monitored by multipoint recorders. The sampling rate on these recorders generally depends on the number of parameters monitored and may exceed 10 seconds between data points for a given parameter. Attachment 2 to this letter is a revised listing of the recorders available for' post trip review at PNPP. This list updates and supplements Attachment C of our June 24, 1984 response and includes indication of those parameters that are recorded on strip chart recorders. The listing has been updated as required to indicate the as built plant instrumentation.

Attachment 3 is a summary list of these recorders which demonstrates that all parameters required to be monitored by time history recorders (GL 83-28 Table 1.2-2) are sampled continuously. This meets the requirements of GL 83-28 for time history recorders.

dithrespecttothereadabilityoftheoutputformat, recording devices were reviewed as part of the Control Room Design Review required by NUREG 0737 Supplement 1 and were found to be acceptable (NRC letter dated 8/28/85). This program included a human factors review of recording devices in the control room and demonstrates compliance with the intent of Generic Letter 83-28 for formatting of recorded data.

i e

b

- - . _ , _ _ --- ., _ _~ - .. - - - - - - --

Attachment 2 PY-CEI/NRR-0397 L RECORDERS FOR POST TRIP REVIEW TAG NO. PARAMETER POINTS POWER DATA SOURCE RATE 1,2B21R614 REACTOR STEAM TEMP 24 NON 1E NONCONTINUOUS 1,2B21R615 REACTOR LEVEL 2 1E CONTINUOUS 1,2B21R623A,B REACTOR PRESS AND 2 1E CONTINUOUS LEVEL 1,2B21R643 REACTOR METAL TEMP 4 NON 1E NONCONTINUOUS 1,2C34R608 REACTOR LEVEL 2 NON 1E CONTINUOUS 1,2C34R609 REACTOR /TURB 2 NON 1E CONTINUOUS 1,2C51R603A,B, REACTOR POWER RANGE 2 NON 1E CONTINUOUS C,D NEUTRON FLUX 1,2C51R614 REACTOR RECIRC FLOW 2 NON 1E CONTINUOUS 1,2C34R607 FEEDWATER & MAIN STEAM FLOW 2 NON 1E CONTINUOUS 1,2D17R601 OFF GAS POST TREAT 2 NON 1E CONTINUOUS 1,2D17R604 OFF GAS PRE TREAT 1 NON 1E CONTINUOUS 1,2D23R090A,B SUPPRESSION POOL TEMP 8 1E NONCONTINUOUS 1,2D23R170A,B DRYWELL & CONTMNT TEMP 7 1E NONCONTINUOUS 1,2D23R180A,B DRYWELL PRESSURE 2 1E CONTINUOUS 1,2D23R250A,B CNTMNT PRESSURE 2 1E CONTINUOUS 1,2E12R601 RESIDUAL HEAT REMOVAL TEMP 16 NON 1E NONCONTINUOUS 1,2G33R603 REACTOR WATER CLEANUP 3 NON 1E CONTINUOUS CONDUCTIVITY 1,2G43R093A,B SUPPRESSION POOL LEVEL 2 1E CONTINUOUS NARROW / WIDE RANGE 1,2M15R016A,B ANNULUS SPACE DIFF PRESS 2 NON 1E CONTINUOUS 1,2N11R050 MAIN STEAM LINE PRESS 2 NON 1E CONTINUOUS 1,2N11R055 MAIN STEAM LINE PRESS 2 NON 1E CONTINUOUS 1,2N11R060 MAIN STEAM LINE TEMP 2 NON 1E CONTINUOUS 1,2N11R065 MAIN STEAM LINE TEMP 2 NON 1E CONTINUOUS 1,2N21R183 MAIN CONDENSER PRESS 3 NON 1E CONTINUOUS 1,2N21R203 CST LEVEL 2 NON 1E CONTINUOUS 1,2N27R401 FEEDWATER PUMP 18 NON 1E NONCONTINUOUS TURB VIB & ECCEN 1,2N31R001 MAIN TURB EXPANSION & TEMP 24 NON 1E NONCONTINUOUS 1,2N31R002 MAIN TURB VIB & ECCEN 12 NON 1E NONCONTINUOUS 1,2N31R003 MAIN TURB ECCEN SPEED & 1 NON 1E CONTINUOUS VALVE POSITION 1,2N31R005 MAIP{ TURB BEARING METAL 24 NON 1E NONCONTINUOUS TEMPERATURE 1,2N64R605 OFF GAS HYDROGEN 2 NON 1E CONTINUOUS L

9 Attachment 3 PY-CEI/NRR-0397 L Time History Recorders Required by GL 83-28 Power Source Number of Data Parameter Safety Class Tag # Points Rate Neutron Flux Non IE 1,2C51R603A,B, 2 CONTINUOUS C,D Drywell Pressure 1E 1,2D23R180A,B 2 CONTINUOUS Containment Press 1E 1,2D23R250A,B 2 CONTINUOUS Primary System Press 1E 1,2B21R623A,B 2 CONTINUOUS (Reactor Press)

Primary System Level 1E 1,2B21R623A,B 2 CONTINUOUS (Reactor Level) 1E 1,2B21R615 2 CONTINUOUS Feedwater & Main Steam Non 1E 1,2C34R607 2 CONTINUOUS Flow I

&