ML19350B514

LER 81-004/01T-0:on 810225,review Indicated That If Backup Scram Solenoids Failed,Actuation of ATWS Sys Would Prevent Closure of Scram Discharge Vol Vent & Drain Valves,Violating Primary Containment.Cause Due to Oversight in Design

ML19350B514
Person / Time
Site:	Pilgrim
Issue date:	03/10/1981
From:	Mcloughlin M BOSTON EDISON CO.
To:	NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION I)
Shared Package
ML19350B513	List: ML19350B512 ML19350B514
References
LER-81-004-01T, LER-81-4-1T, NUDOCS 8103200704
Download: ML19350B514 (2)

Text

r N?.C h0XM 066 U. S. NUCLE AR R EGULATORY COMMISSION (7 77)

< LICENSEE EVENT REPORT I l CONTROL SLOC4: l l l l l (PLEASE PRINT OR TYPE ALL RECUIRED INFORVATIONI (A,/ '

• lo li j j Ml Al P J P j Sl 1l@l 0l 0l -l 0l 0l 0l 0l 0l -l 01 01@l IS 4 11 l 1 1 I l 1 l@l l l@

7 s 3 LICENSEE CCOE 64 15 LaCENSE NWE E R 25 LICENSE TvPt JO 57 OAT sd CCN'T l0l1l $,"C l60L @l0 l 5 l OCCKET 01 -lNUMB 0l ER 21 91 3@l0 l21215 i 8 ! 1 @l 0 l }REFCR l 11018 l 140 '@

4 68 63 EVENT DATE 74 75 7 O ATE 1 St EVENT CESCRIPTICN ANO PRCS ASLE CCNSEQUENCES h t o 121 I In the event that the AWS System aLtuates in Lts intended c:anner analysis indi-  !

Io 6 3i i cates that a violatioa of primary containment would exist. The flow path j i j o .4 ; l would be from the scram Discharge Volume through the vent and drain valves to i 4

1o is1 l the reactor building atmosphere. Refer to attachment for additional information. I 104511 l l047l l l 10 i s t i I F S 9 8I SYSTEV CAUSE CAUSE CCM P. VALV E COCE CCOE SUSCCCE COMPCNENT " COE JU8COOE SLSCOCE FfT1 7 3

'l S! al@ W@ l Al@ l 2l Zi Zl'l ZI Zlh l Zl@ l Zl@

9 13 11 12 13 18 19 23

_ S E QU ENTI AL OCOURRENCE mE70R? REVISION gga,no EVENT VEAR RE70RT NO. C00E Wet No.

@ 4Eg 18 11 l l-l 23 l010l4l 24 26 l/l 27 l 0 l 11 29 23 lTl 20 l-l at l01

_ 21 22 22 7 N AC CN CN P T wtT HCURS SS I FCA S. S P*L E MANUFAC RER lF 22

!@l24Z l@ lZl@

a lZl@

a l0l0l010l se e W@ U@ l Zl@

4i 42 43 lu ZI 91 91 9l@ 47 CAUSE CESCRIPTION AND CCRRECTIVE ACTIONS h I i t o t I The direct cause of this situation was an oversizht in the desien. Ac tua tion of the !

Ii6il l AWS ARI solenoids, which were installed as ourlied in Pncu 79-2 5. would t,revent t i,,2! l bleed-of f of the instrument air header which must be decleted to oermit the vent andl 4

, i3; Idrain valves to close. On March 3,1981 a oicine modification was implemented to end I i

ii;2 ; l sure venting of the SDV Isola tion Valves in the event of AWS initiated scrr . I 7 5 3 $0 l A %80wER CTwtR STATUS IS O RV Of SCCVERY CESCRIPTION N.A.

D { s' l' l E l@ l 0l 7l 5l@l N.A.

l lZl@l '

l AC nvtTV CO$YENT RELEAsEo LOCATION C5 RELEASE @

l$ IsllZl@,aRELEAsEd@l AuCUNT N.A. OF ACWTY 44 l

45

@N.A. l 30 l

8 9 7 to 1 8ER$CNNEL Ex'CSURES NUM9ER TYPE DESCRIPT:CN Ii l 71 l 010 l 0 ' l@l' Z l@l CA.  !

PERSONNEt.\NJURIES NUM9ER DESCRIPT1CN (

liisll010l0l@l 7 8 9 11 '2 N.A.

60 I  !

I I

LCSS OF CA DAMACE TO FACILITY h W75 CESCRIPTICN .  %./ d N.A. l l 1 : 191 4 9 l 21@lto SO 4 7

8V8LICITY NRC USE CNLY OESCRIPTION 45 _

• g ISSUE 3 ,

.12 I c j Whl N.A. 1 l1III!IIII IIlI 1 .s a 50 6a es so ;  ;

NAME OF PREPARER

. omas M oughlin awCNE: 617-746 '7900 2  !

810ssooleg

BOSTON EDISON CodPANY ,

PILGRIM NUCLEAR POWER STATION '

DOCKEI NO. 50-293 Attach =ent to Ln 81-004/01T-0_

Descrip tion On February 25, 1981, the ORC reviawed thc operation of the ATWS system i

which was installed on May 12, 1980 during.PNPS Refuel IV Outage. The i

review indicated that, in the event that the Backup Scram Solenoids failed

~

and the ATWS System initiated to scram the reactor, closure of the Scram

. Discharge' Volume (SDV) vent and' drain valves would be inhibited because the vent path ~ for their' air solenoids would be blocked. This blockage occurs because actuation of the ATWS/ARE Solenoid Valves isolates the SDV air colenoids air supply header from the vent. Inability of SDV vent and drain valves 'to close' following a scram would result in a breach of primary con-tainment in that a scram discharge water flow path would exist through the SDV Isolation Valves to the reactor building. f Cause and Corrective Action ' ,

' The root cause of ~ this problem was inappr'opriate review of the design modi-fication.'. On March 3,1981 a SDV. air s apply line design chenge was imple-mented via. Field Revision Notice Number 79-25-44. TSis -modification revised

,tne original ~ desian to correct its deitaiencies. The modification consisted -

/ - - of relocating the half-inch copper air supply line for the SDV Isolation Valves. from the upstream to the downstream side of the ATWS/ARI Solenoid  !

' JValves so' that isolation of the SDV occurs on actuation of either RP5 or l ATWS/ARI. 9 l

f

~PNPS _is 'in the process of revising our methods of reviewing and approving

'modificatio'ns with more emphasis being placed on ' the conceptual phase and l increased operational input from the station' which .should minimize the possi- (-

-i

-ibility of a recurrence'cf similar' events.

i i

1 s

)

w --

+7- e w w