ML17340A779

Comments on Des Re Steam Generator Repairs.Document Fails to Approach Basic Characteristics Necessary for ASLB to Exercise Statutory Powers.Alara Criterion Does Not Address Environ Impact

ML17340A779
Person / Time
Site:	Turkey Point
Issue date:	02/20/1981
From:	Jaffer J AFFILIATION NOT ASSIGNED
To:	Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
RTR-NUREG-0743, RTR-NUREG-743 NUDOCS 8103030680
Download: ML17340A779 (10)

Text

REGULATORY If RMATION DISTRIBUTION SYST (RIDS)

'CCESSION NBR:8103030680 DOC ~ DATE: 81/02/?0 NOTARIZED; NO DOCKET FACIL:50-250 Turkey Point Planti Unit 3i Florida Power =and Light C 50 251 Turkey Point Planti Unit 4r Florida Power and Light BYNAME C 0500 251 AUTH AUTHOR AFFILIATION JAFFEREJ ~ Affiliation Unknown RECIP ~ NAME RECIPIENT AFFILIATION Division of Licensing

SUBJECT:

Comments on DES for facilities'ocument fails to approach basic characteristics necessary for ASLB to exercise statutory powers.ALARA criterion does not address environ impacts DISTRIBUTION CODE:

TITLE: Environ.

Comments'OTES:

COOZS COPIES RECEIVED:LTR l ENCL jg SIZE:

RECIPIENT COPIES RECIPIENT COPIES ID CODE/NAME LTTR ENCL ID CODE/NAfl- LTTR ENCL ACTION: YARGAES ~ 17 EGROTENHUISP 05'F INTERNAL: ACC IDNT EYAL BR TREAT SYS BR ENY E'NG BR 09 HYD/GEO BR HYDRO GEO BR ISE 07 NRC PDR 02 OEL l RAD ASSESSflT BR 01 SIT ANAL BR 10 UTI ANCE BR EXTERNAL: ACRS LPDR 03 NATL LAB NSIC 04 MAR 04 1981 0

TOTAL NUMBER OF COPIES REQUIRED: LTTR 29 ENCL

r j" k

~4m

~ S~ >E Sk.

/4(qu~s> lI=M 5 F@rraag go /'Ifl ..

.. Yvirec4a, .

I'Drvaia>> 0(- Liceaor'~

afkllth, ~

-MAR.O 2 198>

LL.S. N'aaioaa Qeau44xy Co>via)xsrag y,lo yXXSe ~ZOIC gOJHAll$$ P8 9laSi igbri, M Rei~ g,e,: Qn&ek Q ~ -as',

Y)e re era:

'toad~ or~ 4~ cow~% orl )00ae'Q~Lnvrnn~t L Sbb ~W rebkh t ~~r ge,e 4s. ~a 1 a&.T~~+ 9in4~4

%~A ~h. 9,Vtwa A~a. M L-~M-G~p~~, NuREU.- Oleic, t..

, ~ alaaVC-g~~vai'set iiurV040eeh. Viaa~.

0K' curreak 9cyr4hsns

+ apaLOgiWC. $ k A

('io cokie) t'ai% re'sped. 4 peseaiKj Jaei+

'reche.q'eall vsse<<'n'arl 4gs~ee ~eh%ed- p.q ~es sr1.% Co(4.

0A -t4e ~kwloalt's Y11%1LL&J a

.,ca% 5 Qg+crsla)1 Q aiqralk saa e4w larry rsfhcR

%. 0~Maim%

jQ Ale ljceRsc. 0 FPL

.f60 +

ftf $ 4i5 colleen&.

Qsuc4 a rlaaarcteclsl'arl Mroullk arrL $ a '5re 4fgch f6 (~st-tri

.ci) hie )0-lbQLp oM LEcease oall.~p, ltaLLrcewsia9. crg~rkJ >g.+

oa hi(oink bat %V oir &~g p~si q aiuaL'ICE, >~ .knvboir110103aL rued 4g lI k.uSC. 933) 4S~Ce 1 dXaSVC. ~e (aS ~ .

. Q iaoiv cowi51[sslar15 'Khan>Nshl tr es 9>14 YK(cd 'f%ereIrag> Aurt. j4.

.csvaKala4, oaths 0II +ukase. Q 'ttai's area Ioas,...lg.goall prlSarl t4.........

igypcssi0rl >

iaissskmarir~ peace., f f )go evvieor Qht, F.E.S..ts

~6, eovcpagfson.peg

~ gncop44.

qvqoses o(

c4r p.m~d,~ n Ag'crise icvor~..E pL 6:opeabnw(4/2Q

.(q.i.i.S) eg e> <~~.tq.~.~-l),.Sofia.iS0&.. b.i.a,.a),

boAvase. 03l %(AQ oviqk6'5 ( -&os-+ 4)SPSRQ> g4 aas 'g()1L-Cawing 5 ilukl4).~coasts.

Q ~

.ylaiaorals <aia( oLrre &$

llreirc Nk k1%<<A oc coiaa[4@tk .!gook aiv5t (RAcs assaciaikr[ +reavow~

foqoioSN SSgPh- 0PACS .Pe(oml. 4Cekrvrk .+ W p

, .4C4ise iS

'xososlis6so (4~ ~ AM 0( tfp&X GO,.rr<4. W~'baSg. Coissiteelh

0

~~;

f~~ ~A 58~3&i-v

%i:OVALS," . 3 ~XP-'kaCsQ M>J 4 a~~

h r

~t l

v P

1

~

I C

\

h V t 11 t

v' k

ll,

~ ~

,l~, f ~ 'l )t

'N i

O'L

\.

K I

l

'y 'I I

C yf l

, Qc (nt>> finn~ad; ovt L(cetnse..;)otf I+us'b'on. 2fk~ g4en Tj<r+ f'ern{-

0"+ ~4(re)or A4 4casr Df,vt a q tate'to co sfc4(e co)fkntnqL ryACRs.

.'Qs voath 4at)f)on I ouugw(tjj ) ttnle(~. 14 JlejK4(ll c)os/of ref)facetlneo(4

.@site(e>wi34 ar efoje6fve eon)pahiEon ots r(Nfoas4j esc)finite'd, ca)not Isea b~asiw buffa ~ooze 0 4gsls 0 (e;ega to tf Any)>mL kq~

An@ 4cotnoe> IA(e coos'projected 4ioe lolf tf CI'rootstg ~v)')tg K (Iaehrc 'werg4(ng at)a()tsf Rtn Isn-IR)nek& L)coos)0f) v)og C9(trMt Cub~(n a)krvva,'nves ln~sbea ~ ~ntkoa %pal)e545.'d ~

Gest)4s v(ecok Pvefoftntovib fn Akrnho)t resoo)fok. Isof Atcco~Nktf

))) Vjot(of SRONnM+l~ YOOI Ras)c . 4 'On( t.s 'og s)1(cfeaf IIiss lots QJ Qls 6)ofog kKervesoue mvrevf. palft(oadfvt'HAJJ f5 I4e p'foeess grefsettffog Vain'en 4 ~ entvtron)nt(t. 4(f (fscatf of QYsiosvAIILO )nna&<SIL.

@gfoacgll@ gas+ of tfen eJva+ins Io cooL Q t4A politi g ((c+/%4/8 Loaf Lewh cfcoi(kin)04<oo +ts nq goes 4 t)~<<+4 e)(ces5 en~g )vite

.

VAI4a'h'on 4oioe a4%ag 'p.s~ek "ro W e))v)ron)non+ t4(olu) lt LCcAAI

'.mbs )so cikIseretnec io4L&a IIr 4 5 es~e)II t'nIo 0 InoMrq 4 k cc

! Va)croak caffl 0 Co04~ ~L or.e (I(i art)tiabfnIS o. deep ns)in. )n

.,904, Letnuna.  % aa 4d-~ iss) =snekoned caw  % rc4asc!Io M .

gf)tneraL QAgosIf)Nece ontli eoivtrontnon) . MIn(tn IIOII op@I fkc ccoosf> fs oj)Ho&'.

... .I%6.54k@llet(I'ats ))noses ()noj NELtase 4 W etnvfton~f el(~ dli'vec't.

rAI)@et 04vavf4 alri~mW or sosL. T4.)n4rnnk&(few~ef

hit~(0(

=,'nil)&'oe A(M)esseL ~ of eob(se. fX % vuatn 04%(4uu}z. Of ont e)nvfron:

won4L (wI Inlet ea~eh; -Q cf h.~. 0IIe V $ s(N re4ax $ 4)'Jlrons.

OI- yok 045.sic) evtevg of (04(c4 wt(4e)(4')A) .or fn situiL pxckt$ can so)ac fc)ves (4 sat0&~(rrAL 4afe.nt)

'S'+~vms sn)~ .Onl)of) Ioa~sa<oh.hm, ~ soos4 er4neit. 140I&ez scafherek '(4~agH- ~eufnanke, (f W Qc)(hnagi ( segces Qs(e f4e ot(4g ennv(vtnttntt)k attic(sfek 4g, or ento)I coej))ta44f recotfni>eL ~I

=

- Q. b()retaoocs (5'4 eMV)vor)fathlp o'er If)e 0)ioc 4I(I44+.In vl64(og'Joist~

I405l atg M. Dtvfsltn 0( LI'cons)nIIS MKC W v)oti((L fAC QK ltvelL)cc

.Qklbotttt(. )0. s40kjj 54=0IAINI4nr oar ggagko)sn5 vel)4fn Ql-ni}lG 0$ g4c RrQ <o(n) k fak os 4 eSHmk 'f4e cos) oh, qe)tr(g '(4(sni all j4e .poOS'. 4

N I 1(

VN N

~  !

I I N V

e

~

'I N N~

)I

~ ~

! V

~- NA)

I 1

N.

NNNQJ'~ =".= >.='.. A

• N

)

V l

'!'d dd V N

N.--J V V I

d

! I -  !

I K I N

N N

I N

0 IIoo N ioe+

~iraq

~ olO ~

'K. IIlcaicS.

~K M vcasoioa44'. aseLmvcc o)A ~o J.q ~'oii 3.6adiaSL p4s~4on c aclahes Mb algS c4wiiiak % (04kioL IIiP. 4iic QM(lAboiiikee bi et- '4

~ II oscar Q~ coiic4ihs 'dia4 saA Qoe(46'ooi A.A4~ voou "uii4'}zL<g"-

,Oi Qiia+catoiil ox. Ik sli'll Ql'EWE qokv,iiaL.

~boa eI, t.l 5 aniipxcs a sio*+riii ~i'iiviroooeu"iaL i+acr os Mc QA lioil. 4$ t 0$ W fLroir Ivl&cAA g '149 )iiiasiilil'lac +Q..

~~

.'og it.). laC coitipaoes to/4anoq. poisoiiig cousi~ a qic~huRc.

.(4elA iNig ~4aM, ~nAge spica'M! a llIeh'iiics so mfs4a4.

Ie (iopq. coiugovisovi S4o<iil. oc ioiO'L + 4'os r pre INoikQ.

~~,

',

.bZA. ouiil Se..o&~ise.,or euihiraL ILvS> i )nnsp cf~lg hi rqoeb ieiiea(eLI cow.()aces fW4a4A e4riiiol YCpaW. 4 fk <Ia((il

,ollei~'niioa4 A.

illcwt go'r hb~ iii4 account ~ opacaboo olr'Iipe plough rial rqp.i4.

.

t4- ~$ relieofciLLJ 'INRkcs ccNpRi'so%5 +. 4Qck~aotL. rodiafloiL

,w>o i saA ii 4rni is ah 4ilg sea <<~his. fs'rba/e g q,ioi4fieaia on pa(+

M~.coAocio, oa 'AITIVIZ's mhio S(giiaLS aac4oA auLrah'o>> 4eoitiiL 4

'm a ci)n4oah.+we 4s aIiso akw, kiLI dohleiL ia 5 uli Sriila c eu Siioec M hey'o~iq. 4 Yiiis Kh6~.

p)(egin. CauSeS ~IOi) Q 4~4& fW+qrcvr.t OoIL ga+.ce w a'-i.r -os'.MS~ .itiA .%e...ervcion.t4. a.P (/~3 /)

l . ~- Quasi.oaL ac4 g coasraie4M..A0 pk cd.aiicL.olkoi 'lcNii +verse I<bkdis eyceiI> Qe. M %~~ c v.Naacp. c~hmg o iL.o%c. ~s+citso.

s'hi( R(& 4KMx4IIiowiIAioo%: GNAT'Hsegc&(EJ 6Rsvkse,g Qh( Rf tc lcs Ail,Octal"c

~eirga~isi~is cia,.iooc llm~i oa&caoa4s.Sar.vikrc ~sc ceiwbs gus'Ii.

r( o4(siic.'c coiiiiaiii aseeswuh ~ii ~+dc oii cii4,ooIcM

.'k';5, ow WQ,Qnc. oR,MU~U =8Mo<Mw.

5II'. i~acr o(..occilkAX Is ciI+ecssceL (9 il) iil ~is oa BeiiiaL O . oprzS'ops each- iaeo(v'iNl..aceib~b as ihg~ cuih i>> dei~ee 4 M q<4Lic OI6 iud W ~u.iro>>.iiuu As ho.aHcrouisoes, 4oi oaa Qeeaboii dna kcaLec4oohc c liiiiwcraece

"' 5iuh.".~itILe'".P 42

..Io <4hhq 't4 i ~As cto~ii. ~< ice bi'llroil (sppseiL 4 rye,iie)

r F

I P, A F

F

!1 II r

I g IW, Ff I'

F l>

4 C F W

F-I F'r F

I. .'JKF IF F

r 0

,II'I H

W F

F W'

I( Qha6(<4j K  % gnaw(cd(o(eI'- os ((ie esfipna4s Q< e(fkic wnm'q (IiLoa4(l. Qo.&a%4(i(. ((in wnACI4ion g/>>Le ei(tai(.'s Onto(i.3.

.

gv "taco(8h s~ oeo W II'" ca i 4< e. vk ~a(i( be coiggek (Mi(Ia o eexkL l(v,~ac(c ui( tee evW(ron iocnb.

~ ~fshis aces(~

+I(sasic

.Cco($ 4ssiofl ((g,A ~ Qkft; S&eiiiei(L cIa(ls Qa. & L!ce sinn iIo op~

i(FM 6>

, ene me p~ ~~(I 8Ve

~on "it Qs +rskkmn.

h(I oM s44&.

Yo4mioi~L

,p4jenwk (teuetop@l SH. (s one+ bg JJJ.

'hLhkhn (,nbnoia c(Qnes(C @kc4iniloIIg eIIi(-~q Lute(ot: )'4

's

~(ab'ons(imp 4% (n(v((onn(@it> ~~ (m~osed. mneiiLiuu~fs epee%

(noo (((eosicW ~a(e<P + o((i(inat (Joel'(se (nsQk og'4 Lisceices

., e~ I,cia.SSS(e(f as a~~W.

gov, cwk ka..~4 nhufs (Vo(( aIfourig li(e 6 Smack.

~g'4h)te)('c, ((4 u4k Lily. kuo(ol o(g<>@we 534i's.sn(jed;

~ ~r K

,(((t()

qn)cesS

$ '5Ãce 6 wN fccWIN G)gokkA(to(

4 e.(s (:~ce ((

I(oR wvo4cAii8AR poetic(yak..

1% "(45 Li(cons(g

'