ML20209B439
Text
-
s s
a ig ue M
w)g
(*
UNITED STATES
'f
'g NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION g,
j WASHINGTON, D. C. 20$$$
/
MAY 2 71982 f
MEMORANDUM FOR: Richard H. Vollmer, Director Division of Engineering FROM:
Darrell G. Eisenhut, Director Division of Licensing
SUBJECT:
CRITERIA FOR INDEPENDENCE OF PARTICIPANTS IN DIABLO CANYON DESIGN VERIFICATION PROGRAM Commission Order CLI-81-30 of November 19, 1982 requires (paragraph 2 of Attachment I to the Order) that information be provided to demonstrate the independence of companies perfoming the independent design verification program (IDVP) for Diablo Canyon. The general criteria proposed by the staff to assure the independence are contained in a letter from Chaiman Palladino to Congressmen Ottinger and Dingell (Attachment 1). The criteria were discussed in a meeting on March 25, 1982 with PG3E and Teledyne (Attachment 2).
Region V has proposed to inspect activities related to the IDVP of Diablo Canyon
( Attachment 3), including the " independence statements".
It is necessary that the staff provide specific criteria to determine the financial independence of individuals and companies participating in the IDVP.
M. Messier recommended such criteria (Attachment 4), which, however, have not been approved (Attachment 5).
W. Cooper of Teledyne proposed criteria and procedures to detemine the independence of individuals (Attachment 6).
M. Messier reviewed the criteria and found them acceptable with the exception of previous involvement (Attachment 7).
We request that the Division of E.'gineering finalize the criteria for detemining the financial independence of individuals and companies engaged in the Diablo Canyon IDVP and provide us with an e>aluation of the Teledyne proposal by May 28, 1982.
In addition, we recomnund that the staff develop specific guidelines to be used for assessing the independert reviewer's freedom to fully explore concerns arising during the assignment (Attach ent 3).
Darrell G. Eisenhut, Director Division of Licensing
Contact:
Hans Schierling, LB#3 j
X28423 l\\
m
?266/40 3dro 'ik lp.
)
.}
x.y J.
MAY 2 7 79R2 Distribution Document Control: 50-275/323 TERA LB#3 File DMuller DEisenhut/RPurple MMessier RTedesco TSullivan FMiraglia MEfDRANDlf! FOR: Richard H. Vollmr, Director M
Division of Engineering BBuckley gg,,
FRQ4:
Darrell G. Eisenhut, Director HDenton Division of Licensing OELD JCrews, R-V S'JBJECT:
CRITERIA FOR INDEPEHDENCE OF PARTICIPAllTS IN DIABLO CANY0fl DESIGN VERIFICATION PROGRAM Connission Order CLI-81-30 of November 19, 1982 requires (paragraoh 2 of Attachment I to the Order) that information be provided to demonstrate the independence ~ of companies perfoming the independent design verification program (IDVP) for Diablo. Canyon. The general criteria proposed by the staff to assure the independence are contained in a letter from Chaiman Palladino to Congressmen Ottingrr and Dingell (Attachment 1). The criteria were discussed in a meeting on March 25, 1982 with PGSE and Teledyne (Attachment 2).
Region Y has proposed to inspect activities related to the IDVP of Diablo Canyon
( Attachment 3), including the " independence statements".
It is necessary that the staff provide specific critoria to determine the financial independence of individuals and ccnpanies participating in the IDVP.
M. Messier recommended such criteria (Attachmnt 4), which, however, have not been approv'ed (Attachr. tnt 5). II. Cooper of Teledyne proposed criteria and procedures to detemine the independence of individuals (Attach::ent 6).
M. ftessier reviewed the criteria and found them acceptable with the exception _of previous involvement (Attachment 7).
We request that the Division of Engineering f t:nlize the criteria for detemining the financial indeoendence of individuals and companies engaged in the Diab.lo Canyon IDVP and provide us with an evaluation of the Teledyne proposal by ttay 29, 1982.
In addition, we reconmend. that the staff develop specific guidelines to be used for assessing the independent reviewer's freedom to fully explore concerns arising during the assignrent (Attachment 3).
Jriginal signed by Darroll G. Eisenhut Darrell G. Eisenhut, Director
~'
Division of Licensing
Contact:
Hans Schierling, LR#3 aa wm a
.DA i/.........
.9.l.
.D.L omer >
.D.L;.LB.O....
,p,,,,,p,g,,,,
,R,
,p,
,,h,u
,g,,,
a5 r,g,,,p sun - r>
em>
........g............
nac ror.u m 00% NAOM m3 OFFICIAL RECORD COPY usm un-u
c,
%./ k, 1,
~J Na*N.,.W b.A'r;..mM<CwJ 4W Q.M:
.Mhmmp*'tW
.,b *f c2 ?.&tx,u9 M,*-Mtil
,f W,,&s
,y.(;
- cm.
w A. w ; m w e,; w M m
- 9 A f,Dat a e W ut w.;.Q%w.w C
e ROUTING lAND TRANSM.m!. SUP,MWWQ?.%o ITTA,,..u wS$/Hl82M wwwuym w wa:
,G.
WlnytMName: once symbot room aumber,2;;M:
['WT E y..., Agency / Post} %, *.g*M(% M 9R;d.y/J
' %?;*
2
. sattt n
-;dW.,comting cb*
y 3v y";Jg";
e
,,r
. A
.A SCHIERLING M f W,.
g p!4 y,a 2,0 c X, -
.M..
U[qqd t
v$:hY_,$tb5y._. IIA;rW W :Ni$$MM6.M$Nh.
. ~p.
h$bb5.h 2.b
,h.
h[hk'hbbbMTMd5DI5?@$WhNM h
e#+
y' ;,%n.,, <.,.,
,a n
.....: 4,
..,A. w+ ?w.. v. u -., * -
7,. m,. m..; w
- s. a, g w,
~ g,+
. p.,
- m. z.y.m. c p.
. p m a,,o
- 4.,. ;. 5n +.:4c:c -2*
,y.;.,9 y %. f.1,g, A,,s ~p: w": ~.b,.4::: 9,y p* y.-m n,,m.,, w%.j.7j.
w s < : :.m,y x_q.m*;- p v,y W
<.e
- g. s 5
-p;
+-?,.A;A,.,_g
. y
-v,
.., g,L :..
,,c. >,, ;
I
%.-w
'A**
g 1
.v.
+
--:5..- Actsorr
'm r;,11 rue ;.(
- M.*
., e ~ ~; p.
Per Conversation "4 N.
Note and Return
.D, No w.wt ' w;- W ror cearinese : -
)
fh As Requested kir"
' ror Correction *
- o Prepara Repry ~--W Nl/.'. b 4
g.x cirmiac w ta ror your inforrnation x s ue~: smp$ '
rM cc.sne W M tav stints' e/w.:-
Yy.+ Coordlnstson 4l W sa nature
. c re w.C N Just19 F: + . **:14
+.4.*-
g *: 9 5
f
' s "': '
- SN. '.$*
W,M:y,'c,th. v,'Q, g.:(1[.
l2 R n
Jj c.y Q *.*:} r,'*
.h,W%j.- f;6,j.fej W
n % ;?
- v.
O..? i%. b N rw*%wv ;,w}# z ' *['
6
- ?
-*\\ %,
- r..%> w.W..h..Q., yc, c
. ; c, cm.
. 4.
x
+,:/. m.. &.
~..
,.,..,,e..,, u...,, %. 2.., m.. @ %, 2 W; W-Q..m MW C l
v m,.m... t, m.s
,s,-
r.
.>.,...n..v.,,, -,+ m, e,s.
.s
.m W';?i-CRITER AJFOR lNDEPENDENCE 0F' PARTICIPA
~....
r~
n..,..
i Mp W
M.e,COIABL CANYOT DESIGN.VERIFICAT OT PROGRAM.l,:
M.= f.. W.T.\\,.:i;8.. ;o#W:0,4Q.3 4.}~w?. WQWCW.
61 5
W>WQ' n, )f. l::r.Q>;g;:. '.
- e m.
. m. a. w'.
. u y.
}&.,
"pM*r jy i.,lof n.:
c
. <;;;..; *4s..%,;., q;q..
-: w* ~., s'
?,a -
y..,
s y:s,z.]v,*i*y s t*. % c6.,
i,,. q.;.
m.,.
+c,.
. m;e.
.e r
r
. :..t... s. O... n.
-.-n..
,. 's
.,s, r... qtQ o4 h.. ~;.. nh.. e,r,. >, ', ', ' N g,gfM.. yy.'
'h',. ' ['l
~
.,g
- s.
- a c..
., q z
rvc... w ;...,. ; ~,J,.
r. q'.., n, k.t g.t
$,, f**l*M.+j-
-,D M
,M,. x,.O e
. f.
s
-n
. s.
] (t..g p
a.g..,. g.,,..; f...
c.
..y, m. p.. c. u.u
- r. g. -..,
..y, g
.. u.., ;,
y: ~. j. s. w. ;.
, : s.....,. -. ;
s., y
.... ~ q... n,,.
p. 1 c., a,s -,. s.,.,
..,.> l.
' 3,...
u y^.=
- ..,;b p,;.
<r,
(.:.
,y
< s y;
y gf C 3.C'(
Q)y g
.-. 3 ',. J,..~s.,ff.s :.
6.(;,. ',
,; n :.. -
p.,.,,,.
s,...y
?! l J.
vp.f.. W: n;DO NOT uns this~ form as a ' RECORD of ' approvals,' coni:urrences.,..,,7d j:;
- e r
n
. ' v.(
clearances, and similar actions' - m a
- w n
W '"
M;.
F,%,7ROLt:(Name, org symbol., Agency / Post)? *,yn Room No.--8 tdt /,..G.A 1 a; y W.l. w&."'.!;&. a.*d y~y';Ml. O :.,.n..u<q.a Nlt * '. "y%.
Om wn.
~.
~ ~ i % *~ :cW%:M
'. y~s c :sv
..... * - l Pa t}y'.,..,/i.......s.. ' '.
. g.7.. ; :.:c', :.y,~n:?c..:,.',a,*n n.- ;
. Phone No. p..., ;.n.,.'s,. I n
'q
~.
w.
. 8: a
- w..,.w.
- f. 'j* ; sosa-act,.;mg g,
.'6.
g,
,(
O,PTI,ONAl. FOR'd 41 (Rev. 7-76),e;iv ;
1., j
.,,, y
..j ;
- ,..;p m m.e w cza 1,. C#g *
- .i.
-,.m,
$ ( Q M,.IMI$ f!) h,f "
e*
..ar-4(*
- [e,[.JMA *. N am.A M d,*d. ]*
,-s 1
> A i..E -f \\$. LL d keh a * <. ' s 's.M R.de < ' L *.%,e. 4 4.1..:,,. me [,.
- t d
^
-