ML20209B236
Text
_
. T'=.; Ot va A
y f
3 NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION E
WASHING TON, D. C. 20555
' +,...../
)
UAN 12 982 1
MEMORANDUM FOR:
Pat Sullivan, Chief, Administration Branch, Office of the Secretary FROM:
Hans Schierling, Project Manager, Reverification Program, Licensing Branch No. 3, DL SUBJf.CT:
REQUEST TRANSCRIPT OF MEETING TO BE HELD JANUARY 19, 1982 --
DIABLO CANYON This is to request that a reporter prepare a transcript of a meeting to be held on Tuesday, January 19, 1982.
(S<e the enclosed meeting notice for details of the meeting.) We need the transcript two or three days following the meeting so that we can make copies for our internal use as well as for the parties to this proceeding. We anticipate attendance of approximately 100 people. Please contact me (X28423) or Jean Lee (x28413) if you need additional information.
Hans Schierling, Project Manager Reverification Program Licensing Branch No. 3 Division of Licensing
Enclosure:
Meeting Notice dtd. 01/08/82 h(
r
\\
(v o
y 4
l N
1 ff i
fU 00 0 J
I i
A-m.-
- gsy s to,,
-,I
[0, ;
~ NITED STATES U
-E**
f
. g-
' NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
- j
~
y.*g
-E_
WASHING TON, D. C. 20555
!~
5, 4....
JAN 08 1982 Docket No.: 50-275 MEMORANDUM FOR:
F. J. Miraglia, Chief, Licensing Branch No. 3, DL FROM:
H. E. Schierling, Project Manager, Reverification-Program,-
Licensing Branch No. 3, DL
SUBJECT:
NOTICE OF MEETING WITH PACIFIC GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY DIABLO CANYON, UNIT 1, REGARDING PG&E SUBMITTAL DATED DECEMBER 4, 1981 i
DATE & TIME:
Tuesday, January 19, 1982 9:00 a.m. - 4:00 p.m.
LOCATION:
Room P-ll8 Phillips Building Bethesda, Md.
PURPOSE:
To discuss issues based on staff review of PG&E submittal
'of. December 4,1981 as listed in attachment.
PARTICIPANTS:
NRC PG&E D..Eisenhut-J. Crews G. Maneatis i'
R. Vollmer R. Bosnak D. Brand, et.al.
l R. Engelken R. Faulkenberry E. Jordan W. Haass PG&E Consultants
~
J. Knight F. Miraglia R. Tedesco F. Schauer S. Skjei P. Kuo H. Schierling E. Sullivan 1
r)
.f I
l IN i -
I Hans E. Schierling, Project Manager, Reverification Program Licensing Branch No. 3 i
Division of Licensing cc: See next page.
i 8 76 Vo/04 W
L-
~ N f '., ~
.re c.-
- DIABLO CANYON t
r/ Mri Malcolm H. Furbush' 1i f cVice-President:
General Counsel
-^ ' Paci fic Gas & El ectric -Conpany<
_ LP.02 Box 7442
- 15an francisco, California. 94120 2'cc:.. Philip A. Crane, Jr., Esq.
~
~
Pacific Gas & Electric Company P.O. Box 7442 San Francisco, California 94120
_Janice E. Kerr,-Esq.
~
- California RJblic Utilities Commissio'n -
4-350 McAllister Street.
San Francisco,' California 94102' Mr.. Frederick Eissler, President Scenic Shoreline' Preservation Conference, Inc.
4623 More Mesa Drive
~
Santa Ba'rbara, California 9310S Ms. Elizabeth Apfelberg
[1415 Cozadero
~
San Luis Obispo, California 93401 Mr. Gordon A. Silver Ms. Sandra A. Silver 1760. Alisal Street San Luis Obispo, California 93401 Harry M. Willis, Esq.
'Seymour.& Willis
+
601 Califo'rnia Street, Suite 2100 San = Franci sco,- Cali fornia 94108 Mr. Richard Hubbard MHB Technical Associates Suite K 1723 Hamil ton Avenue San Jose, California - 95125
- Mr. John Marrs, Managing Editor
~
San Luis Obispo County Telegram-Tribune
- 1321 Johnson Avenue P. O. Box 112 7'
San Luis Obispo, California 93406 e
G N
e
% )
o N
Je
.g"=-.
Wy-e,e 3.-p--
@m ae@q-h 1s e.ma g.m et wM de po
-gg
K*"
Mr. Malcolm H, Furbush.
i cc:. Resident' Inspector /Diablo Canyon NPS c/o U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission P.~0.. Box 369 Avila: Beach, California 93424
.Ms. Raye Fl eming 1920 Mattie Road Shell. Beach, California 93440 1
..-John R. Phillips,.Esq.
Simon Klevansky, Esq.
Margaret Blodgett, Esq.
Marion P. Johnston, Esq.
Joel-Reynolds, Esq.
Center for Law in the Public Interest 10203 Santa Monica Boulevard 4
Los Angeles, ~ California 90067 Paul C. Va' lent'ine, Esq.
' 321 Lytton Avenue -
Palo Alto, California 94302 4
Mr. Byron S. Georgiov-legal ' Affairs -Secretary Governor's Office State Capitol Sacramento, California 95814 Herbert H. Brown', Esq.
Hill, Christopher & Phillips,.P.C.
1900 M Street, N.W.
Washington, D.C.
20036
~
Mr. Richard E. Blankenburg, Co-Publisher Mr. Wayne A. Soroyan, News Reporter South County Publishing Canpany P. O. Box 460 Arroyo Grande, California 93420 l
Mr. James 0..Schuyler Vice President - Nuclear Generation Department Pacific Gas & Electric Company
.P.O. Box 7442 San Francisco, California 94120 t
Bruce Norton, Esq.
Suite 202 3216 North 3rd Street Phoenix, Arizona 85012 I
i c
.- 3
p..
4.
.;, t s,
n
- r.
.'f - ~ ~
?!!rj-l'alcol:a'H. Fur!r;sh 3 *.
1Ir.~ W."C. Gangloff
^
"estinyhouse Clectric Corporation.
t P. 0.' Box 355.
Pittsburgh, Penn'sylvania 15230-
[
= David F. Fleischaker, Esq.
^
P. O. Box 1178 '
Uklahoma City, Oklahoma 73101 t
j
=
' O 6
J 7..
e e
G S
0 0
4 g
I' 4
9 9
l 4
S O
1 D
l s,
s'
.=
+
i 5
f i
I l
T-
+
i: ~,
[.-
i
- i; r
?'
k.;;.:gy,
^
=..
E, Attachment Agenda Items Meeting with PG&E January 19, 1982 Seismic Reverification Program I.
Scope and Technical Aspects of Plan
-II.
Sample Criteria
- III.. Benchmarking of Results IV. QA Audit Methods V. ' Size and Technical Qualifications of Review Team VI. Contractual and Financial Qualifications of Review Team t
e 1
9 I.
Um new '-
. * * % b- ~ - -
+
,.w,...
_~%
t
~
1.
Scope and Technical Aspects of Plan 1.
Basis for selection of building (s) and structure (s) for seismic requalification 2.
Models for piping problems, including-isometric drawings based on "as built" conditions 3.
Verification of input and seismic loads for piping and support analysis 4.
Verification of design specifications, design l
reports and design documents with respect to "as built" conditions 5.
Acceptance and rejection criteria for piping and supports 6.
Supports for large components (tanks, heat exchanger, pumps, vessels) 7.
Application of Reg. Guide 1.100 (Seismic Qualification -
~
of Electric Equipment for IJuclear Power Plants)
{
to conduit and cable tray supports, and equipment 8.
Adequacy of seismic input for equipment qualification, interpretation of vertical ground motion, effects of torsion and building. response characteristics -
9.
Equipment procurement and qualification process (contractual obligations, modifications to account for Hosgri earthquake, commitments made during licensing activities)
~
- 10. Procedure and basis for determining errors in seismic qualifications.-
11.
Independent development of dynamic model for auxiliary building
- 12. Criteria for acceptance of fundamental mode frequency, mode shapes and selective floor response spectra
- 13. Seismic reverification of-buried tank and outdoor water storage tank 14.
Independent field _ verification prior to requalifica-tion; consideration of IE Bulletin 79-14 in independent field verification
.,_m
' ~ ' ~ - ' -
e,.-
-..s. :
..3
~
f 2-e
- 15. Seismic-service-contract activities within program scope
- 16. DetaiIs for analysis of PG&E internal interfaces
- ~
- 17. : ' Definitions for (a) significant ' deficiency or.
error and (b) insignificant deficiency.or error
- 18. Guidelines for determining appropriateness of design methods considering change in " state of the art" technology II. Sample Criteria
- 1.. Criteria for selection of sample calculation and for expansion of sample size if needed 1
2.
Statistical basis.for sample size and proceoure in case of failure 3.
Equipment sample from safe shutdown and cooldown systems 4.
Adequacy of design process and quality assurance; reporting on basis of sample cases 5.
Criteria for sample checks and independent calculations 6.
Application of current evaluation techniques to-independent sample calculations in analysis of i
structures and components,.
l III. Benchmarking of Results i
1.
Benchmarking to NRC problems, of computer code for piping analysis IV. QA Audit Methods 1.
Reporting procedure for R.
F.' Reedy to R. L. Cloud and PG&E
~
I 2.
Scope of QA review (procurement documentation control; instructions, procedures and drawings; document control; auditing) t-3.
Review of operational QA program (post 1978) 1 with respect to implementation of corrective actions
.4.
Consideration of applicable QA criteria (10 CFR 50 App. B) l l
I
... -,_ ;___ u
.. a__ _
- ~,. _ _ - - -
r-
..- e;
+
-- --+-
~ ~ - -
-~ ---
~, -,, -,.
n 4:
.): Q ;
t Y., Size and' Technical Qualifications of Review Team u.
1l.
Identification and qualifications of. individuals t
s performing QA review 2.
Expertise of-individuals in civil-structural
,. design and-analysis Expertise in seismic analysis' of structures
- 3.
4 4.
Assignment of. individuals with appropriate expertise to specific tasks
'i
- c
.V I. Contractual and Financial Qualifications of Review Team 1.
Previous. involvement of companies and individuals in Diablo Canyon activities now under their independent review scope.
2.
Previous ~ involvement of companies or individuals in Diablo Canyon Seismic design work
- 3. = Previous employment by PG&E of individuals now 7
participating in independent review l
't -
4.
Ownership or control of PG&E stock by individuals partic'ipating in independent review
'5.
Employment by PG&E of relatives,ipating in review, or members of present household of indiv.iduals partic
' and position if appropriate.
E
's r,(
k e
i i
+
. y
..a h
i I
s 3
1 a
/ w k'
.j y 4.
-+ g -
s
w3, a.
(.
1-MEETING NOTICE DISTRIBUTION Docket File 50-I&E Negion I-NRC PDR I&E Begion II -
Local PDR I&E Region III 4-
'NSICr
- IAE Region IV i;
iTERA
.I&E Region'V
.LB!3 Files' NRC Participants E.. Case f
R. Bospak J. Knight w-D. Eisenhut F. Scha'er R. Tedesco 4
u R.-Purple S.~Skgei F.'Miraglia p-R. Tedesco
'W. Haass P. Kuo B. J. Youngblood G. Bagchi E. Sullivan 57 -
A.-Schwencer
~
.R. Engelken E. Jordan F. Miraglia J. Crews R. Faulkenberry E. Adensam D. Eisenhut H. Schierling J.~ Miller R. Vollmer G. Lainas R. Mattson T. Wambach, Acting T. Speis B. Russell M. Srinivasan D. Crutchfield O. Parr T. Novak F. Rosa S. Varga B. Sheron, Acting T. Ippolitto W. Kreger
.R. Clark R. Houston
- J. Stolz W. Gammill R. Vollmer F. Congel
-J. Knight' L. Rubenstein
'R.
Bosnak W. Butler
'F. Schauer C. Berlinger R. Jackson Gd. Lear,..,,,-
,.... F.;Schroeder
.c.
,;...,..s K,, Knidl Attorney, OELD.
D, Skovholt OIE (3) uik idi G. Knighton G. K:.:d on ACRS (16) 2':'s5 '!n!
M. Ernst A~st OSD'(7)
A. Thadani -
J. LeDoux, I&E W. Minners B.' Grimes, I&E S. Hanauer M.' Wi.11 tams, DL H. Thompson W. Johnston D. Vassallo S. Pawlicki P. Collinr, V. Benaroya
-:.r-D. Ziemani
'Z. Rosztoczy V. Moore W. Haass D. Muller
. -.. c. -
bec: Applicant' Service; List R. Ballard R Ra!!ard W. Regan Branch LB!3-
' A. Toal s ton Project Manager H.
L. bcnierling, neverification Licensing Assistant J. Lee Program
{
.W*
~4WE.M. WWe 9* 9'
- NN.-
' " ' - ~
y.
--