ML17244A868

Piping & Piping Analysis Drawing List. Attachment 1 to 60-day Response to IE Bulletin 79-14

ML17244A868
Person / Time
Site:	Ginna
Issue date:	08/31/1979
From:	ROCHESTER GAS & ELECTRIC CORP.
To:
Shared Package
ML17244A865	List: ML17244A864 ML17244A867 ML17244A868
References
EWR-2512, NUDOCS 7910030910
Download: ML17244A868 (52)

Text

Attachment 1 60 Day Response to IE Bulletin No. 79-14 Seismic Analysis for As-Built. Safety Related Piping Systems R.E. Ginna Nuclear Power Plant, Unit No. 1 Docket No. 50-244 Ginna Station Piping and Piping Analysis Drawing List Rochester Gas and Electric Corporation 89 East Avenue Rochester, N.Y. 14649 EWR 2512 Revision 1 August 31, 1979

~qfO Page i ~go<~

'E<;,

4',

CONTENTS Section Pacae 1.0 Pi in ualified b Ori inal Plant Desi Reactor Coolant System 1.2 Main Steam 1.3 Main Feedwater 1.4 Safety Injection 1.5 Residual Heat; Removal 1.6 Containment Spray 1.7 Chemical and Volume Control 1.8 Component Cooling 1.9 Service Water 1.10 Steam Generator Blowdown 10 1.11 Auxiliary Feedwater 1.12 Boric Acid 12 2.0 Pi in uglified b D amic Anal sis 2.1 Standby Auxiliary Feedwater 13 2.2 Chemical and Volume Control 2.3 Service Water 2.4 Steam Generator Blowdown 16 2.5 Auxiliary Feedwater 2.6 Boric Acid 18 2.7 RCS Overpressure Protection 19 2.8 Demineralized Water 20 2.9 Charcoal Filter Dousing 21 Page ii

REACTOR COOLANT SYSTEM Pi in 8 Instrumentation Drawin RGE 33013-424 Rev. D Pi in Drawin s GAI-D-304-601 Rev. VIII Plans & Sects.

GAI-D-304-602 Rev. VIII Press Relief S Spray Piping Plans GAI-D-304-603 Rev. IX Press Relief S Spray Piping Sections

MAIN STEAM SYSTEM Pi in & Instrumentation Drawin RGE 33013-534 Rev. 1 Pi in Drawin s-GAI-D-304-014 Rev. V Plan GAI-D-304-015 Rev. VII Plan & Sections GAI-D-304-016 Rev. VII Sections GAI-D-304-023 Rev. III Relief Valves

MAIN FEEDWATER Pi in & Instrumentation Drawin RGE 33013-544 Rev. 4 Pi in Drawin s GAI-D-304-083 Rev. Vill F.W. Pump Suet. & Disch. Plan GAI-D-304-084 Rev. V F.W. Pump Suet. & Disch. Sections

SAFETY INJECTION Pi in 8 Instrumentation Drawin RGE 33013-424 Rev. D RGE 33013-425 Rev. C RGE 33013-432 Rev. B Pi in Drawin s GAI-D-304-642 Rev VIII Plans Inside Cont.

GAI-D-304-643 Rev VII Sections Inside Cont.

GAI-D-304-644 Rev. XII Plans & Sects. (Aux Bldg)

RESIDUAL HEAT REMOVAL Pi in E Instrumentation Drawin RGE 33013-425 Rev. C RGE 33013-432 Rev. B RGE 33013-436 Rev. D Pi in Drawin s GAI-D-304-611 Rev. VI Plan (Inside Cont)

GAI-D-304-612 Rev. IV Sections (Inside Cont)

GA1-D-304-615 Rev. VIII Plan (Aux Bldg)

GAI-D-304-616 Rev. IZ Sections (Aux Bldg)

CONTAINMENT SPRAY Pi in 8 Instrumentation Drawin RGE 33013-425 Rev. C RGE 33013-432 Rev. B Pi in Drawin s GAI-D-304-641 Rev. VIII Plans S Sections in Containment GAI-D-304-642 Rev. VIII Plan In Containment GAI-D-304-643 Rev. VII Sections In Containment GAI-D-304-644 Rev. XII Plans and Sections, Aux. Bldg.

CHEMICAL AND VOLUME CONTROL Pi in 8 Instrumentation Drawin RGE 33013-426 Rev. 2 RGE 33013-427 Rev." B RGE 33013-428 Rev. 1 RGE 33013-433 Rev. D RGE 33013-434 Rev. 1 Pi in Drawin s GAI-D-304-630 Rev. V Plan S Sect. (Misc."in Cont.)

GAI-D-304-631 Rev. VIII Plan (Mics. in Cont.)

GAI-D-304-632 Rev. VI Sect. (Misc. in Cont.)

GAI-D-304-633 Rev. XI Seal Water 8 Charging Line Plan S Sect. (In Cont..)

\

COMPONENT COOLING Pi in 5 Instrumentation Drawin RGE 33013-435 Rev. B RGE 33013-436 Rev. D Pi in Drawin s GAI-D-304-618 Rev. X Clg. to RV Supports/RCP's GAI-D-304-619 Rev. IX Clg. to RV Supports/RCP's GAI-D-304-621 Rev. VIII Plans, Auz. Bldg. 235-8 GAI-D-304-622 Rev. VII Plans, Aux. Bldg. 253-0 GAI-D-304-623 Rev. III Plans, Auz. Bldg. 271-0 GAI-D-304-625 Rev. II To Sample Coolers

/.

('

I SERVICE WATER Pi in 8 Instrumentation Drawin RGE 33013-529 Rev. F Pi in Drawin s GAI-D-304-691 Rev VI Cooling to Cont Recirc Cooling Units Plan GAI-D-304-692 Rev III Cooling to Cont Recirc Cooling Units Sect.

GAI-D-304-693 Rev IX Plans (Int. Bldg.)

GAI-D-304-694 Rey IX Sections (Int. Bldg. )

GAI-D-304-695 Rev VIII Plans (Aux Bldg.)

GAI-D-304-696 Rev VII Sections (Aux. Bldg.)

GAI-D-304-697 Rev II Plan Above El. 253-8 S Sections Misc. (Aux Bldg.)

GAI-D-304-698 Rev IV Cooling Water to Air Recirc.

Motors Plan 6 Sect. (Cont.)

I

(

STEAM GENERATOR BLOWDOWN Pi in & Instrumentation Drawin GAI D-302-121 Rev. IX Pi in Drawin s GAI-D-302-121 Rev. XVI Plans, Containment GAI-D-381-050 Rev. 3 Piping Reroute, Int. Bldg.

10

AUXILIARY FEEDNATER Pi in 6 Instrumentation Drawin RGE 33013-544 Rev. 4 Pi in Drawin s GAI-D-304-085 Rev. Cond. To Pump Suctions GAI-D-304-086 Rev. Plans and Sections, Int. Bldg.

GAI-D-381-046 Rev. 4 New crossover, Int. Bldg.

11

BORIC ACID Pi in 8 Instrumentation Drawin RGE 33013-425 Rev. C RGE 33013-426 Rev. 2 Pi in Drawin s RGE-33013-627 Rev. 5 Plans and Sections, Aux. Bldg.

GAI-D-304-644 Rev. Plans and Sections, Aux. Bldg.

12

STANDBY AUZIZIARY FEEDWATER Pi in & Instrumentation Drawin GAI D-302-071 Rev. E Pi in Drawin s GAI-D-381-023 Rev. 1 Cond. Suction to Pump GAI-D-381-033 Rev. 4 Plans in Containment GAI-D-381-034 Rev. 2 Plans in Aux. Bldg. (253-0)

GAI-D-381-035 Rev. 3 Plans in Aux. Bldg. (271-0)

GAI-D-381-036 Rev. 4 Plans in Auz. Bldg. Add.

GAI-D-381-038 Rev. 0 Misc. Sections, Auz. Bldg. Add.

GAI-D-381-039 Rev. 2 Details, Auxl. Bldg. Add.

Anal sis Isometric Drawin s GAI-C-381-026 Rev. 1 Cond. Tk to Pump Suctions GAI-C-381-040 Rev. D Pen. 119 to SGA GAI-C-381-041 Rev. A Pen. 123 to SGB GAI-C-381-042-1 Rev. A Pen. 119 to Pump GAI-C-381-042-2 ,Rev. A Pen. 119 to Pump GAI-C-381-042-3 Rev. A Pen..119 to Pump GAI-C-381-042-4 Rev. A Pen. 119 to Pump GAI-C-381-042-5 Rev. A Pen. 119 to Pump GAI-C-381-043-1 Rev. A Pen. 123 to Pump GAI-C-381-043-2 Rev. A Pen. 123 to Pump GAI-C-381-043-3 Rev. A Pen. 123 to Pump GAI-C-381-043-4 Rev. A Pen. 123 to Pump GAI-C-381-043-5 Rev. A Pen. 123 to Pump 13

2.2 CHEMICAL AND VOLUME CONTROL Pi in & Instrumentation Drawin RGE 33013-426 Rev. 2 RGE 33013-427 Rev.. B RGE 33013-428 Rev. 1 RGE 33013-433 Rev. D RGE 33013-434 Rev. 1 Pi in Drawin s GAI-D-304-630 Rev. V Plan & Sect. (Misc. in Cont.)

GAI-D-304-631 Rev. VIII Plan (Mics. in Cont.)

GAI-D-304-632 Rev. VI Sect. (Misc. in Cont.)

GAI-D-304-633 Rev. XI Seal Water & Charging Line Plan & Sect. (In Cont.)

RGE 33013-708 Rev. 2 A RCP 51 Seal Bypass RGE 33013-709 Rev. 2 B RCP 51 Seal Bypass Anal sis Isometric Drawin s GAI-C-381-076 Rev. 0 From 10" AC to Pen 112 GAI-C-381-077 Rev. 0 Valves 200 A, B and 202 GAI-C-381-078 Rev. 0 Regen. Hx. to Isolation GAI-C-381-079 Rev. 0 8" R.C. Line to Isolation RGE SK447-201 Rev. 0 A RCP Seal Bypass RGE SK447-202 Rev. 0 B RCP Seal Bypass

2.3 SERVICE WATER Pi in 8 Instrumentation Drawin RGE 33013-529 Rev. F Pi in Drawin s GAI-D-304-691 Rev VI Cooling to Cont, Recirc Cooling Units Plan GAI-D-304-692 Rev III Cooling to Cont Recirc Cooling Units Sect.

GAI-D-304-693 Rev IX Plans (Int. Bldg.)

GAI-D-304-694 Rev IX Sections (Int. Bldg.)

GAI-D-304-695 Rev VIII Plans (Aux Bldg.)

GAI-D-304-696 ,Rev VII Sections (Aux. Bldg.)

GAI-D-304-697 Rev II Plan Above El. 253-8 6 Sections Nisc. (Aux Bldg.)

GAI-D-304-698 Rev IV Cooling Water to Air Recirc.

Notors Plan Sc Sect. (Cont.)

Anal sis Isometric Drawin s GAI-C-381-024-1 Rev. B SW suction to SAFW Pump A GAI-C-381-024-2 Rev. B SW suction to SAFW Pump A GAI-C-381-024-3 Rev. B SW suction to SAFW Pump A GAI-C-381-025-1 Rev. A SW suction to SAFw Pump B GAI-C-381-025-2 Rev. B SW suction to SAFW Pump B GAI-C-381-025-3 Rev. B SW suction to SAFW Pump B GAI-C-381-025-4 Rev. B SW suction to SAFW Pump B 15

2.4 - STEAM GENERATOR BLOWDOWN'i in S Instrumentation Drawin GAI D-302-121 Rev. IX Pi in Drawin s GAI-D-302-121 Rev. XVI Plans, Containment GAI-D-381-050 Rev. 3 Piping Reroute, Int. Bldg.

Anal sis Isometric Drawin s GAI-C-381-086 Rev. 1 Pen. 322 to Iso. Valve 16

2.5 AUXIjIARYFEEDWATER Pi. in S Instrumentation Drawin RGE 33013-544 Rev. 4 Pi in Drawin s GAI-D-304-085 Rev. Cond. To Pump Suctions GAI-D-304-086 Rev. Plans and Sections, Int. Bldg.

GAI-D-381-046 Rev. 4 New crossover, Int. Bldg.

Anal sis Isometric Drawin s GAI-D-381-044 Rev. D New crossover, Int. Bldg.

17

'i 2.6 BORIC ACID Pi in & Instrumentation Drawin RGE 33013-425 Rev. C RGE 33013-426 Rev. 2 Pi in Drawin s RGE-33013-627 Rev. 5 Plans and Sections, Aux. Bldg.

GAI-D-304-644 Rev. Plans and Sections, Aux. Bldg.

Anal sis Isometric Drawin RGE-33013-625 Rev. 0 B.A. Tanks to M.O.V's 18

2.7 RCS OVERPRESSURE PROTECTION Pi in S Instrumentation Drawin s Catalytic A-202 Rev. 0 RGE 21489-253 Rev. 1 Pi in Drawin s Catalytic A-13501 Rev. 3 Plan Catalytic A-13502 Rev. 3 Details Anal sis Isometric Drawin s Catalytic SK 725-501-00 Rev. 0 Catalytic SK 725-502-01 Rev. 1 Catalytic SK 725-502A-00 Rev. 0 Catalytic SK 725-506-01 Rev. 1 Catalytic SK 725-507-01 Rev. 2 Catalytic SK 725-505-02 Rev. 2

2.8 DEMINERAZIZED WATER Pi in S Instrumentation Drawin s RGE 03021-62 Rev. 2 Pi in Drawin s Catalytic A-13201 Rev. 2 Pen. 324 Anal sis Isometric Drawin s Catalytic SK 722-101-00 Rev. 0 Catalytic SK 722-102-00 Rev. 0 20

2.9 CHARCOAL FILTER DOUSING Pi in S Instrumentation Drawin s RGE 33013-432 Rev. B Pi in Drawin s Catalytic B-13210 Rev. 2 Anal sis Isometric Drawin s Catalytic SK 272-001-02 Rev. 2 Catalytic SK 272-002-02 Rev. 2 21

Attachment 2 60 Day Response to IE Bulletin No. 79-14 Seismic Analysis for As-Built Safety Related Piping Systems R.E. Ginna Nuclear Power Plant, Unit No. 1 Docket No. 50-244 Methods Used for Inspection, Evaluation, and Nonconformance Control for Seismic Category I Piping Systems Inside Containment Introduction a) The inspection of piping systems inside containment was completed prior to the August 15, 1979 issuance of the Supplement IE Bulletin 79-14. This attachment describes the inspection and evaluation methods used at Ginna Station.

b) Different inspection and evaluation methods were used for piping which was originally qualified by equivalent static analyses and for piping which has been qualified by dynamic analysis. These are presented separately.

2. Reactor Coolant S stem and Cate or I Pi in 24 Inch Nominal Pi e Size and Lar er Seismicall uglified b E uivalent Static Anal ses 2.1 Methods a) Data and dimensions were obtained by field teams to prepare as-built piping and support drawings. The information obtained by field teams included pipe size and geometry; insulation thickness; valve locations, type and orienta-tion; support locations; and penetration clearances.

Detailed as-built. pipe support sketches were prepared noting support geometry, component, sizes and lengths, and weld sizes and, lengths.

b) The dimensions, data and the as-built sketches were com-pared to the original design drawing by engineers per-forming the evaluations. Field inspection by the engineers was also performed as necessary.

c) Discrepancies were compared to established acceptance criteria and appropriate action taken for discrepancies which did not meet the criteria. Discrepancies which could not be compared to the established criteria were handled on a case-by-case basis.

d) Discrepancies requiring action were handled in three ways.

For minor deficiencies in support construction which did not affect the function of the support, e.g. loose nuts, missing lock nuts, etc. main-tenance trouble cards were issued and repairs made.

2. For significant deficiencies, e.g., missing supports, immediate evaluation or repair was made during the outage controlled by nonconformance reports.

3. For other deficiencies which were judged by the engineer not to affect, operability, but requiring additional evaluation, the deficiency was noted and further evaluated after the outage. These are documented on nonconformance reports as appropriate'.

e) As-built piping and support drawings are being prepared.

2.2 Acceptance Criteria a) Pipe geometry, valve location and support location*

Pi e Size Tolerance to 6" 2 8" 8" to 18" 2 12" 20" to 36" 18"

• For supports, this tolerance may not be projected through or around fittings.

b) Angular Tolerance I

For linear type hangers or valve orientations, the acceptable deviation is 2 4'rom the as designed "

position.

c) Pipe Support Configuration When the as-built configuration of a support differs from the design drawing, e.g. a box guide replacing a U-bolt, a nonconformance is not recorded if the as-built support performs the same function and is built of equal or better materials than those required by the design drawing.

F Support Materials Material sizes listed on the design drawings are con-sidered as design minimums. Material size increases are acceptable except in the case of engineered components, i.e. springs, constant supports and snubbers. Where information plates are illegible or missing on standard components, i.e. snubbers, springs, constants, dimensions of the component are made. lf the physical dimensions agree with the catalog dimensions of the design drawing component, it is assumed the installed component is correct. No deviation is acceptable on standard com-ponents.

e) Pipe to Support Clearance The sum of the gaps on both sides of a pipe may deviate

+ 1/16" from design. For pipes having a temperature less than 120 F, a tight fit is permissible. For pipes of temperatures greater than 120'F, the sum may deviate 1/16" from design.

Any deviations which exceed the tolerances listed above are recorded.

Pi in S stems, or Portions of S stems, Seismicall uglified B D amic Anal sos a) Recent piping modifications and additions at, Ginna Station have in general been qualified by dynamic analysis. The control and authorization of changes to the installation drawings is significantly improved from original plant construction. For this reason, a general inspection of piping and pipe supports was performed since detailed inspections were recently performed.

A comparison of the installation drawings and as-built piping and supports was made.

c) A comparison between the original analysis isometric input data and the installation drawings was made and discrepancies noted.

Discrepancies were controlled in the same manner as described in item 2.1 c) above.

e) Drawing changes wil'l be made as required.

'I

/

/ (

I