Text

Rev 1 to Fission Product Barrier Evaluation.
	ML17263A835
Person / Time
Site:	Ginna
Issue date:	11/07/1994
From:	; ROCHESTER GAS & ELECTRIC CORP.
To:	;
Shared Package
ML17263A834	List: ML17263A833; ML17263A835; ML17309A559;
References
	OSSI-92-402A-2, OSSI-92-402A-2-REG-1, NUDOCS 9411090268
	Download: ML17263A835 (264)
	v • d • e

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation. Rev. 1 I,

Attachment D Fis ion Product Barrier E u i ggmmign 1 R. E. Ginna Nuclear Power Station 94i i090268 9%i i07 +I I PDR ADQCK 05000244 F PDR

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Evaluation of Ginna Fission Product Barrier Emer enc Action Levels The Fission Product Barrier (FPB) degradation category for a PWR plant is illustrated in the following table which is designated "Table 4" in NESP-007, Revision 2.

The Initiating Condition (IC) for each of the four emergency classifications (Unusual Event, Alert, Site Area Emergency, and General Emergency) are designated FU1, FAl, FSl, and FG1, respectively.

Each IC is defined by one or more EALs or combination of EALs which are indicative of a loss or potential loss of one or more of the three fission product barriers, The three fission product barriers are:

~ Fuel Clad (FC)

~ Reactor Coolant System (RCS)

~ Primary Containment (PC)

NESP-007, Revision 2, prescribes example EALs for each of the three Qssion product barriers. An EAL is defined by one or more plant conditions. For example, there are seven FC barrier example EALs, eight RCS barrier 'example EALs, and eleven PC example EALs. Each EAL may consist of one or more conditions representing a loss of the barrier and a potential loss of the barrier. Some EALs may, have only loss conditions, others only potential loss conditions, some have both loss and potential loss conditions. Each EAL is given a sequential number in Table 4. In the following list, NESP-007 EALs with a defined condition (i. e.. labeled as needing "site-specific" input in Table 4) are identified with a "yes", and those without a defined condition (i. e. labeled "not applicable" in Table 4) are identified with a "no":

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 NUMARC Ginna Barrier EAL ¹ Loss Pot. Loss ~Lo Pot. Loss FC la Yes Yes Yes(FC1. 1) Yes(FC1.2) lb No Yes No Yes(FC1.3) 2 Yes No Yes(FC2.1) No 3 Yes Yes Yes(FC3. 1) Yes(FC3.2) 4 No Yes No Yes(FC4. 1) 5 Yes No Yes(FC5. 1) No 6 Yes Yes Yes(FC6. 1) No 7 Yes Yes Yes(FC7. 1) Yes(FC7. 1)

RCS la No Yes No Yes(RCS1.1) lb No Yes No Yes(RCS1.2) 2 Yes Yes Yes(RCS2. 1) Yes(RCS2.2) 3a Yes Yes Yes(RCS3.1) No 3b Yes No No Yes(RCS3.2) 4 Yes No Yes(RCS4.1) No 5 Yes Yes No No 6 Yes Yes Yes(RCS6. 1) Yes(RCS6. 1)

PC 1 No Yes No Yes(PC1. 1) 2a Yes Yes Yes(PC2.1) Yes(PC2.3) 2b Yes Yes Yes(PC2.2) Yes(PC2.4) 2c No Yes No Yes(PC2.5) 3 Yes No Yes(PC3. 1) No 4 Yes No Yes(PC4. 1) No 5 No Yes No Yes(PC5. 1) 6a No Yes No Yes(PC6. 1) 6b No Yes No Yes(PC6.2) 7 Yes Yes Yes(PC7. 1) No 8 Yes Yes Yes(PC8.1) Yes(PC8.1)

Based on the classification key given at the beginning of Table 4, the number of example EALs. and the number of loss and potential loss conditions, the set of conditions that can yield a given emergency classification can be computed, The maximum, theoretically possible set of conditions that can yield an Unusual Event classification is given in column 1 of Table A. These consist of the PC loss and PC potential loss conditions.

The maximum. theoretically possible set of conditions that can yield an Alert classification is given in column 1 of Table B. These consist of FC loss and potential loss conditions, and RCS loss and potential loss conditions.

The maximum, theoretically possible. set of conditions that can yield a Site Area Emergency classification is given in column 1 of Table C.

These consist of any of the following conditio'ns:

~ Loss of FC and RCS, or

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1

~ Potential loss of FC and RCS, or

~ Potential loss of FC or RCS and Loss of another barrier The third set of conditions listed above can be represented by the following conditions to eliminate reference to "loss of another barrier":

~ Potential loss of FC and loss of RCS, or

~ Potential loss of FC and loss of PC, or

~ Potential loss of RCS and loss of FC, or

~ Potential loss of RCS and loss of PC

.While not explicitly stated within NUMARC/NESP-007, the following combinations are also appropriate for inclusion as Site Area Emergency classifications:

~ Loss of FC and loss of PC

~ Loss of RCS and loss of PC The maximum, theoretically possible set of conditions that can yield a General Emergency classification is given in column 1 of Table D.

These consist of the following conditions:

~ Loss of any two barriers. and

~ Potential loss of a third These conditions can be represented by the following conditions to correlate barrier loss and potential loss to the three specific barriers:

~ Loss of FC and loss of RCS and potential loss of PC, or

~ Loss of RCS and loss of PC and potential loss of FC, or

~ Loss of PC and loss of FC and potential loss of RCS Note that the loss of all three barriers justifies a General Emergency classification as well.

Since the EAL conditions are listed numerically in Table 4, Tables A through D utilize a similar numbering system which is modified by

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Glnna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 letter abbreviations to define each set of conditions. For example, condition "FC2-loss" corresponds to a loss of the Fuel Clad barrier due to primary coolant activity level greater than 300 pCi/gm I-131.

Similarly, "RCSlb-pot. loss" corresponds to a potential loss of the Reactor Coolant System barrier due to a Critical Safety Function Status Heat Sink-RED condition, and so on.

An evaluation of each condition or set of conditions listed in Tables A through D is made to determine if it properly defines the appropriate threshold for the classification. If a condition or set of conditions is appropriate, a comment reflecting this conclusion is recorded in the "Remarks" column. If a condition or set of conditions is determined to be inappropriate, it is lined out and the reason for this conclusion is similarly recorded in the "Remarks" column. Where additional space is required to complete comments, the comments are recorded by number in Appendix 1 of this document. The numbers of the comments are recorded in the "Remarks" column with the associated condition or set of conditions to which they apply.

A summary of the results of the fission product barrier evaluation is presented in Appendix 2.

00)

RECOGNITION CATEGORY F 0)

C)

FISSION PRODUCT BARRIER DEGRADATION O

INITIATINGCONDITION MATRIXTABLE 4 PWR UNUSUAL EVENT SITE AREA EMERGENCY GENERALEMERGENCY Any loss or any FAl Any loss or any FSl Loss ofboth fuel clad FG1 Loss of any two potential loss of potential loss of either and RCS barriers containment fuel clad or RCS. Ore AND Potential loss of both Potential loss of third Op. Modes: Op. Modes: fuel clad and RCS barrier.

Power operation Hot Power operation Hot OR Shutdown Shutdown I'otential loss of either Op. Modes:

fuel clad or RCS. and Power operation Hot loss of any additional Shutdown reI barrier.

Op. Modes: Q B'

Power operation Hot Shutdown NOTES:

0 Although the logic used for these initiating conditions appears overly complex, it Is necessary to reflect the following considerations:

O

~ The fuel clad barrier and the RCS barrier are weighted more heavily than the containment barrier (see Sections 3.4 and 3.8 for more III information on this point). Unusual Event ICs associated with RCS and Fuel Clad barriers are addressed under System Malfunction ICs.

~ At the Site Area Emergency level. there must be some ability to dynamically assess how far present conditions are for General Emergency.

For example, If Fuel Clad barrier and RCS barrier "Loss EALs existed, this would Indicate to the Emergency Director that. In additional to offsite dose assessmcnts. continual assessments of radioactive inventory and containment integrity must be focused on. If, on the other hand, both Fuel Clad barrier and RCS barrier "Potential Loss" EALs existed, thc Emergency Director would have more assurance that there was no Immediate need to escalate to a General Emergency.

~ The ability to escalate to higher emergency classes as an event gets worse must be maintained. For example, RCS leakage steadily Increasing would represent an Increasing risk to public health and safety.

O

2. Fission Product Barrier ICs must bc caoable of addressing event dynamics. Thus. thc EAL Reference Tables 3 and 4 state that IMMINENT(I. p e.. within I to 2 hours2.314815e-5 days <br />5.555556e-4 hours <br />3.306878e-6 weeks <br />7.61e-7 months <br />) loss or potenttaf loss should result In a c)assII)cation as If the affected threshold(s) are already exceeded. particularly for the higher emergency classes.

00)

RECOGNITION CATEGORY F U)

(0 INITIATINGCONDITION MATRIXTABLE 4 PWR O

Fuel Clad Barrier Ezample EALs Potent al Loss

l. C t ca t o tus Core cooling - rcd Core cooling - orange OR Heat sink - rcd

2. a oo ant ct vi Coolant activity grcatcr than (site.spcciAc) value Not applicablc W

3. Core xit e o t Q B

Greater than (site.speci Ac) 'F Greater than (site-speciAc) 'F O

Not applicablc Level less than (site-spcciAc) value 0

5. o tain ent a a o o to A

Containment rad monitor reading greater than (site-speciAc) Not applicable S R/hr

6. Ot e s te-s c to (site-spcciAc) as applicable (site-speciAc) as applicable Any condition In the Judgment of the Emergency Director that C indicates loss or potential loss of the fuel clad barrier O 2

Determine which combination of the three barriers are lost or have a potenual loss and use the following key to classify the event. Also, an event for multiple events could occur which result In the conclusion that exceeding the loss or potenual loss thresholds Is imminent (i. c.,

wtthtn I tn 2 hn>wah ln thta Imminent Inaa attttattnn nae l>)rlsrnx nt anrl elaaatfv aa tf the threahnlrla are exreeded.

RECOGNITION CATEGORY F I 0

0) t0 INITIATINGCONDITION MATRIXTABLE 4 PWR O

RCB Barrier Example EALs Potential Loss aSa t o S atus Not applicablc RCB Integrity - rcd OR lleat sink - rcd Greater than avallablc makeup capacity as Indicated by a loss Unisolable leak cxcccding thc capacity of onc charging pump in thc of RCB subcoollng normal charging mode u tue (site-spcclAc) indication that a SG Is ruptured AND has an non- (site-spcclAc) Indication that a SG Is ruptured isolable secondary line break AND OR the primary-to-secondary leak rate exceeds thc capacity of one (site-spccIAc) indication that a SG Is ruptured AND a prolonged charging pump In thc normal charging mode 0 release of contaminated secondary coolant ls occurring from the affected SG to the environment O

Q I

4. Co ta e t d t o o to n O OI Containment radiation monitor reading greater than (slte- Not applicable speci(lc) R/hr s

~

(site-specific) as appllcablc (site-spcclAc) as applicable fD C

O Any condition in the Judgment of the Emergency Director that p indicates loss or potential loss of the RCS barrier

0U)

RECOGNITION CATEGORY F 0)

(D INITIATINGCONDITION MATRIXTABLE 4 PWR h0 O

Containment Barrier Example EALs Potentia Loss

l. aS e to U Not appllcablc Contafnmcnt - rcd Rapid unexplained decrease following initial increase (site-spec!Ac) psig and Increasing OR OR P3 Contalnmcnt prcssure or sump Icvcl response not consistent Explosive mixture exists W with LOCA conditions OR Q Containment prcssure grcatcr than contalnmcnt depressurizatlon system sctpolnt with less than onc full train of dcpressurizatlon equipment operating I

Valve(s) not closed Not applicable AND O downstream pathway to thc environment exists W

Rclcase of secondary side to atmosphcrc with prlmaty to secondary leakage greater than tech spec allowable Not applicable pact v v o ta Not applicable i-Containment radiation monitor reading greater than (site-speclAc) t-R/hr O e

0 RECOGNITION CATEGORY F I

CO INITIATINGCONDITION MATRIXTABLE 4 PWR hD Containment Barrier Example EALs O otentisi Loss S

Not applicablc Core exit thermocouples In excess of 1200'F AND restoration procedures not cffcctivc within 15 minutes OR Core exit thermocouples In excess of 700 'F with reactor vessel level below top of active fuel AND restoration procedures not effective within l 5 minutes

7. te t (site-speci Ac) as applicable (site-spcciAc) as applicable 8.. ec ero Jt I O

Any condition in the Judgment of the Emergency Director that Indicates loss or potential loss of the containment barrier O Q

C O

DI

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 0 Table A Ginna Fission Product Barrier Unusual Events NESP-007 Remarks

'Loss or pot. loss of PC P-C4-less Condition not supported ln PEG.

P-@Ra-1ess 1 PCQe-1ess Condition not supported ln PEG.

PCS-1ess 3

>PC4'oss<:4<~",' -;: ?'-"..: ." ~:. 'i?

I QS-1ess Condition not supported in PEG.

Pea-less Condition not supported ln PEG.

Pub-less Condition not supported ln PEG.

PCS-less Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

7 Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

8 9

9 Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

10

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation. Rev; 1 Table B Ginna Fission Product Barrier Alerts NESP-007 Remarks Loss or pot. loss of FC ll FC@b-lass Condition not supported in PEG.

~"""~4~~0<Y@b<<m~M~':>%<4m"':Act +Y@~4<<~&SFAH~%4hc .~ mk~~ÃW4~~4N@4%45544<,M oss ll ass Condition not supported in PEG.

PCS-1ess 18

'" ""::: ~4.-' ':,.'"'.5:".:!:' .)

"<.';:><<~i'pFMQ ofQ<'(:<<<>Pi(p>".<:.4~j'pi'k~k~j44@z.,'"<'~'.<."':;p::".<I<,"~<i@::.:<

'.4i""<;.l:: '. " '.'..

,j4%sp<'.~<>>"'><:..'~'~-.'.i

(;-. "'Q6-'gpss<:-'>-'""'~'~"':."~

i;..q I~ass Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

12 13 Condition not supported in PEG.

14 15 Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Loss or pot. loss of RCS RCS4e-1 ass Condition not supported in PEG.

RCS44~ Condition not supported in PEG.

17 RCSQb-loss Condition not supported in PEG.

RCS5-1ess Condition not supported in PEG.

RCSQMss Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

,'R'~~~1"'-' t',,~i' ' ', '

-,""."-,'.'":."',,~,'1'~i;:!",,",,"',':"~'-':,"; ~i%; ."';:,'"....,'i::.',; :,"',"';.' .'"';,.~y,'

. Condition not supported in PEG.

20 Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table C Ginna Fission Product Barrier Site Area Emergencies NESP-007 ~Rm arka Loss of PC and RCS Condition not supported in PEG.

Conditfon not supported in PEG.

ll Condition not supported ln PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

ll ll Condition not supported In PEG.

ll Condition not supported'EG.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condftion not supported In PEG.

12

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Glnna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table C Ginna Fission Product Barrier Site Area Emergencies NESP-007 ~Rem rks ess Conditfon not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

s Condition not supported in PEG.

Condltfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Conditfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

17 ess Condition not supported fn PEG.

21 Condition not supported ln PEG.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

F~CB'-.1s'ss 17 Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

ess Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Pot. loss of FC and RCS 11, 12 11, 12 ll, 12 13

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table C Ginna Fission Product Barrier Site Area Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported in PEG.

ll, 12 ass Condition not supported ln PEG.

ass Condition not supported ln PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

13 13 Condition not supported ln PEG.

13 Condition not supported ln PEG.

Conditfon not supported in PEG.

Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condltfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condltfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

14, 25 14 14 Condition not supported in PEG.

14 Condftfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

15, 24 15 15 Condition not supported ln PEG.

15 Condition not supported ln PEG.

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Glnna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table C Ginna Fission Product Barrier Site Area Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported ln PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Conditfon not supported in PEG.

Condltfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Conditfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Pot. loss of FC and loss of RCS Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

!FCX'i"';.pot.'::',loss/,; 4 ii'll" ii"'i!i"":i.

11, 12 Condition not supported in PEG.

ll, 12 Condition not supported in PEG.

15

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Gfnna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table CGinna Fission Product Barrier Site Area Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported in PEG.

13 13 Condition not supported fn PEG.

13 Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Condltfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

14 14 Condition not supported in PEG.

14 Condition not supported fn PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

15 15 Condition not supported in PEG, 15 Conditfon not supported in PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

16

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Glnna Fission Product Barrier EAL EvafuaUon, Rcw. 1 Table CGinna Fission Product Barrier Site Area Einergencies NESP-007, Remarks Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condltfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed in Judgment" EAL.

Pot. loss of FC and loss of PC jh%'{,'((5{)' V V.((W {.4{;{+%V '%' {'((((.V ~

.gg %

Condition not supported ln PEG.

{{Q'{ WpV+W(&+V{.'(({p{"(((({V+(()'{A'{pghVQ{

{g P'P,,{ g, 'P{g(({'{APh(S {w/9@AV, {Q@P $ +w ~

'h (({l+{W'gvgp(((((({

Condition not supported in PEG.

12 Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

12 Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported in PEG.

1, 13 2, 13 Condition not supported ln PEG.

3, 13 13

$ 445-paW Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

17

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Gfnna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table CGinna Fission Product Barrier Site Area Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported fn PEG.

13 Subsumed In Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Conditfon not supported In PEG.

1, 14 2, 14 Condition not supported fn PEG.

3, 14 14 Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

14 Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

1, 15 2, 15 Condition not supported In PEG.

3, 15 15 Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

18

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Gfnna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. I Table C Ginna Fission Product Barrier Site Area Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks 15 Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condftfon not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condltfon not supported ln PEG.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

19

OSSl 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Ffssfon Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table C Ginna Fission Product Barrier Site Area Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks ll Condition not supported In PEG.

20 ll Condition not supported In PEG.

21 20 Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condltfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condftfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL; Pot. loss of RCS and loss of PC Condition not supported in PEG.

21

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fissfon Product Barrier EAL EvaluaUon, Rev. 1 Table C Ginna Fission Product Barrier Site Area Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks 2

Condition not supported ln PEG.

3 46 Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

40 Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported in PEG.

1, 19 2, 19 Condition not supported in PEG.

3, 19 19 Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

19 Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

1 2

Condition not supported fn PEG.

3 Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

40 Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported in PEG.

22

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Glnna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. I Table C Ginna Fission Product Barrier Site Area Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

I 2

Condition not supported in PEG.

3 20 Condltfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

40 Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Conditfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table C Ginna Fission Product Barrier Site Area Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Conditfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Conditfon not supported in PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Conditfon not supported in PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Loss of FC and PC Condition not supported in PEG.

1,11 2,11 Condition not supported fn PEG.

3,11 ll Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Conditfon not supported in PEG.

11 Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Glnna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table CGinna Fission Product Barrier Site Area Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

1 Condition not supported In PEG.

3

.'KC2: Joss'. -" -:;, !!'. ";i PC4"3oss.'"'.'-.

Condltfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

40 Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported In PEG.

1,11 2,11 Condition not supported In PEG.

3,11 ll Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

ll Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

25

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table CGinna Fission Product Barrier Site Area Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

1,21 2,21 Condition not supported ln PEG.

3,21 21 Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

21 Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

1 Condition not supported in PEG.

3 Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

40 Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

26

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Gfnna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table CGinna Fission Product Barrier Site Area Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL.

Loss of RCS and PC Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condftlon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Conditfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condltfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

1 2

Condition not supported In PEG.

3 47 Condltfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

27

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Glnna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table CGinna Fission Product Barrier Site Area Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks 40 Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Condltfon not supported fn PEG.

1, 17 2, 17 Condftfon not supported in PEG.

3, 17 17 Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

17 Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condltfon not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

1 2.

Condition not supported In PEG.

3 47 Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

40 Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

28

J' OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table C Ginna Fission Product Barrier Site Area Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condltfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Conditfon not supported ln PEG.

Condltfon not supported In PEG.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

29

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Glnna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Loss of FC + loss of RCS + pot. loss of PC ass Condition not supported ln PEG.

oss Condftfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

ess Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Conditfon not supported in PEG.

Condftfon not supported ln PEG.

ass Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condltfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

ess Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

ess Condition not supported ln PEG.

ess Condition not supported in PEG.

'.',PC1:pot;:1'oss-:;,: -',;:-.O';".Co'ritred;:,'.l~;:~!'."::: S4~>,'~.',!:::':,',-:,, -;g.::<.;-::;;

5. 26

'""'PC2b".-:pot."i loss.~'".'! 6;"jH2~k;;:"'=".NP.:~U~";:;;P>!':;~~j<~: ~+/( .j'.:-".;..: ';:<-',ci';,:i:: <<y~8$ j

'+"'~PC2c'-,'pot."'.loss'~'.",.":~27:;:.,CCr'ed'."+D'ep',:styt,"':pres~', '.":"" '.:-,-.:'-.. >-.'~p~g ess Conditfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

'PC61'.-'pot:.";los's':.~"'-:9':."C~'FBPNSQ>'".":',: .:<'",;."':;0""!:,;.-; ".":;,':i'+'":.s'."

Condition not supported ln PEG. 'ss Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

4 ess 5, 26

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks 5,26 27 Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

8 9

9 Condition not supported ln PEG.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Conditfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condftion not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

4

5. 26 6

16, 29 Condftfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

8 9

9 Condition not supported ln PEG.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

31

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. I Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007'Rmarks Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condftion not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condltfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Conditfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condftfon not supported in PEG.

Condftfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

32

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Gfnna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergenc'ies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Conditfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condftlon not supported in PEG.

Conditfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product. Barrier EAL EvaluaUon, Rev. 1 Table D Ginna Fission Product Banier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not'upported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condftfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condftfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condftion not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condftfon not supported fn PEG.

Conditfon not supported in PEG.

Condftfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Conditfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condftfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

5,26 Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

8 9

9 Condition not supported In PEG.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

4 5,26 35

1 OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Gfnna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

8 9

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condftfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

5,26 6

35. Addressed fnAct5'k+Dep stpt pres, above.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

8 9

9 Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condltfon not supported fn PEG.

ess Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Glnna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 =

Remarks Condition not supported ln PEG.

Conditfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condltfon not supported fn PEG.

Conditfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condltfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condftfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condftfon not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condftion not supported fn PEG.

Condftfon not supported In not supported in PEG.

PEG.'ondition Condition not supported fn PEG.

37

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG RE. Ginna Ffsslon Product Barrier EAL Evaluation. Rev. 1 Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

5,26 6

10 Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

8 9

Condition not supported In PEG.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

5,26 6

10 Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

8 9

9 Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG'.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condftfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

~ OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Glnna Ffssfon Product Barrier EAL Evaluaoon, Rey. I Table D Ghana Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 ~Remark Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL.

5,26 6

)0 Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

8 9

9 Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Conditfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed in "Judgment": EAL.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed In'Judgment" EAL Subsumed.fn "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Glnna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 ~Rmarks Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condftlon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

ass Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condltfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condltfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condltfon not supported in PEG.

Condltfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condftion not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condltfon not supported In PEG.

Condttlon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

. Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condltfon not supported ln PEG.

I Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Glnna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 I

Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported In PEG.

Conditfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condftfon not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condftlon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condltfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Conditfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condltfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condftion not supported ln PEG.

'ondition not supported ln PEG.

Condftlon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Glnna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 ~Rmarks Condltfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition nat supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condftlon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condftlon not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condltfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG:

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation. Rev. 1 Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies MES P-007 ~Rm~rk.z Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condltfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

4 5,26 6

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

8 9

Condition not supported In PEG.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

4 5,26 Condftlon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

9 Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condltfon not supported In PEG.

Condftlon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 ~Rem rk Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

4 5,26 6

34, Addressed in Rad5%+Dep stpt pres. above.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Conditfon not supported fn PEG.

8 9

9 Condition not supported In PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condftfon not supported in PEG.

Conditfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condftfon not supported In PEG.

Condftfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks 5,26 Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

8 9

Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

oss Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL.

4 5,26 6

35, Addressed in FFM + Dep stpt pres, P.40 Condition not supported in PEG.

Condftion not supported in PEG.

ass 8 9

ess Condition not supported In PEG.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Condftion not supported in PEG.

Condftfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Gfnna Fission Product Barrfer EAL Evaluation, Rev. I Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Subsumed'in "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Conditfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Conditfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condltfon not supported ln PEG.

Condftfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condftfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

47

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed in "Judgment" Subsumed in EAL.

EAL.'Judgment" Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL, Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.-

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG RE. Ginna FIssion Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. I Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL Subsumed tn "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

"Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

49

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Glnna Fissfon Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Loss of RCS + loss of PC + pot. loss of FC Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Conditfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Conditfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condftfon not supported ln PEG.

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condftfon not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condltfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condftfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Conditfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

51

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Glnna Flssfon Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table 0 Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condftion not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEQ.

Conditfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condftfon not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEQ.

Conditfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condltfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEQ.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condftlon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condftlon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

52

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Glnna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. I Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condftion not supported In PEG.

Condltfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Conditfon not supported In PEG.

Condltfon not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Conditfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Conditfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Conditfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Conditfon not supported in PEG.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Gfnna Ffssfon Product Barrier EAL Evaluation. Rev. I Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Conditfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condftfon not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condftfon not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Conditfon not supported In PEG.

Condftfon not supported in PEG.

Condftfon not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condftion not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condftfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condftfon not supported ln PEG.

Condftion not supported In PEG.

OSSl 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks ess Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condftion not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condltfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condftion not supported ln PEG.

r,g v>r girpvAw:.g A~>.wi)!w v.'.w+.y; Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.w. xwev,,'

Vga i: v ")('"jwdoM+w(')'('I >pvPw,'Nv)'),'i@,gag )wNN dvjv>r .e /rppgeg (s)e~.. >Ni >):i(N(Nvhwwkspeg;<9+6+sw'its>s $

Conditfon not supported In PEG.

'"'"*'-'-"-'""'-i!i",',,ll"-i'-i ii'I'iiii, ii Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

ass Condition not supported ln PEG.

Conditfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

55

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

irr~* ess Condition not supported ln PEG.

9+YC*N vt ssaggvgr pug)yPg .@Aye> ....gQ., ( V wN vHv<pr~pyh'~v) p~pw OxvAw~s, '))sg~ v vpv,: )v@YwgM<$dAQ(ghph P~wp v ~(r{rgrrC@(Nfl,, yrrw spgy p a. yqgr~

ess Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

48 48 Conditfon not supported ln PEG.

48 48 oss Condftion not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

RGB' ess Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Gas Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Conditfon not supported in PEG.

Condltfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Conditfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

RGB-l Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

ess Condition not supported in PEG.

RGB-1 Condition not supported ln PEG.

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Glnna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table D Gizpxa Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condftion not supported ln PEG.

40 Condltfon not supported in PEG.

40 40 Condition not supported in PEG.

Condftion not supported In PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported in PEG.

oss Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

ess Conditfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Conditfon not supported in PEG.

57

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Glnna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

39 39 39 39 Condition not supported ln PEG.

ROSE-1 Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

4-ass Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

39 39 Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

39 39 Condition not supported in PEG.

39 39 Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported in PEG.

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. l Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier GeneraI Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Conditfon not supported fn PEG.

Conditfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

40 40 Condition not supported in PEG.

40 40 Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Conditfon not supported in PEG.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

59

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Glnna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. f Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Conditfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condltlon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condltfon not supported in PEG.

Conditfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condltfon not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Gtnna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. I Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 ~Remark Condition not supported tn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL Condttfon not supported in PEG.

Condftlon not supported tn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condltton not supported tn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condltfon not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Conditton not supported'in PEG.

Condition not supported tn PEG.

Conditfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported tn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Conditfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported tn PEG.

Condltfon not supported tn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

61

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Glnna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. I, Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Conditfon not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

39 39 Condition not supported in PEG.

39 39 62

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Gfnna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. I Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported In PEG.

Conditfon not supported fn PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

39 39 Condition not supported in PEG.

39 39 Condition not supported fn PEG.

Conditfon not supported fn PEG.

Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

39 39 Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

39 39 Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condftfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

40 40 Condition not supported fn PEG.

40 40 Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

.Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL Condition not supported fn PEG.

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL EvaluaUon, Rev. I Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG; Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Glnna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation. Rev. I Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Conditfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condltfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Conditfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Conditfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG RE. Glnna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rnr. l Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condltfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condftlon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL S'ubsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condltfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

OSS Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL 67

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 ~Rem rks Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condftfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed In "Judgment." EAL Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL Condition not supported ln PEG.

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. I Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Conditfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condltfon not supported in PEG.

Condltfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Conditfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condftlon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

. Condition not supported fn PEG.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

69

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Glnna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies MES P-007 Remarks Condition not supported ln PEG.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

70

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG . R.E. Gfnna Fission Product Barrier EAI Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Loss of PC + loss of FC + pot. loss of RCS Condltfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG..

Condition not supported In PEG.

Conditfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Conditfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condftion not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

71

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Glnna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluaffon, Rev. I Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 ~Remark Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condftlon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Conditfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Conditfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Conditfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Conditfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Conditfon not supported In PEG.

16 16 16 Condition not supported ln PEG.

16 72

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported in PEG.

Condltfon not supported in PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condltfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

p Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

41 41 Conditfon not supported in PEG.

41 Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

41 41 ass 41 Condition not supported ln PEG.

41 Condftlon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condltfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condftion not supported in PEG.

Condltfon not supported ln PEG.

not supported ln PEG. 'ondition Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

73

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. I Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks 41 41 Condition not supported In PEG.

41 Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Subsumed In "Judgment" 3'Alg~lPguyl+VA'.Ph VAA (((h'VY, )PgPh',PSV~g(','PgggPP EAL.

'rPrr$

(VIVgh))gg QPP@W)PhgPPI(PH 'gh,.V *lgg~)PV~5/h, .%((:,, . V SVghgVg~AVp %.'((PQ('5K~PVgggggA@P( AyP~Vgrghyg$

41 Condition not supported ln PEG.

Conditfon not supported in PEG.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

39 39 39 Condition not supported ln PEG.

39 Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condltfon not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Glnna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rnr. 1 Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

4-less Condition not supported fn PEG.

42 42 Condftfon not supported in PEG.

42 Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL.

39 39 39 Condition not supported In PEG.

39 Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

p Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

ess Condltfon not supported in PEG.

y<<<<<<)<<<<<<gy)<<g<, y, << .. <<

-. <<<,; <<<<<<<g<, v<<<p <5 i<<<<'<))<<<< <<)<<<)<<<

Condition not supported ln PEG.

<)<)A5h4row<<".v<<'<v<<<!<<<<<<Qv<PP<<<<'<<<<<g<<<<<) <<<<<<<<<'<c<<<v<<(rP'<<<<<r<<)) 8 '+<<P'~g'I 42 42 Condition not supported in PEG.

ess 42 Condition not supported fn PEG.

75

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported In PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

42 42 Condltfon not supported In PEG.

42 Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Conditfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Conditfon not supported in PEG.

Conditfon not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

76

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Glnna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Conditfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condftion not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Conditfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condltfon not supported ln PEG.

77

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. I Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Conditfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

39 39 39 Condition not supported in PEG.

39 Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported in PEG.

ess Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

i!i:,'i'fi '"!ll'i"ii 43 43 Condition not supported ln PEG.

43 Condition not supported in PEG.

'ondition not supported ln PEG.

78

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Glnna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation. Rev. I Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

39 39 39 Condition not supported In PEG.

39 Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Condftion not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condltfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

i ca'i,:,,::ii"::i 'i,:,. i.,:,.ii i~iii ""

Condition not supported ln PEG.

i!i::...i(i,...,

43

"::,:i'i,:...,.'.'ll! )ii'll'ill" Condition not supported ln PEG.

43 Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

~a~>'C:.'r"gm'.m>em Wgp~~5".":v> '<'>>ni:.")~>> ".q~4~<Y~)."gSA".:

' e')<M"'>'<~kg<< .))'@AS%"~)x$4~~v PA~y" ~)W'<W ~~NP"i@<<% F$>4~.'

" " ~. ~>

PC3"-;josg'".':FP+',:.

wmv wi'

'FC6'-;loss' '-'".":

.~ s

'~'-":43""FaSi'ol'i+ FFMS~Ai 4:-:-:-"'.'i'.~':-"

rr),@4nv4,.$ >,r r) ~, ),l))r~vrvvw,~ >>rw.t..s;rr cu non r.(RvkvvvP5nvnw.w w w'eN )aves@*vmvw3kvFvPwwN'w))wg +"' .s 'v44ic@s45'PiveT 43 Condition not supported ln PEG.

43 Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

79

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Ffssion Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies 4

NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported ln PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

46 48 48 Condition not supported fn PEG.

20, 48 Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condftlon not supported ln PEG.

Condltfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

48 48 48 Condition not supported in PEG.

48 Condftlon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

46 48 48 Condition not supported in PEG.

20. 48

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Glnna Ffssfon Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condltfon not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

48 48 Condition not supported in PEG.

48 Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

48 48 48 Condition not supported In PEG.

48 Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

81

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condltfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condltfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

82

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG RE. Glnna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 ~Rm~rk.q Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condltfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condltfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condltfon not supported in PEG.

Conditfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condftlon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condltfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

/

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rer. I.

Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condltfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condltfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condftfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Conditfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Conditfon not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Conditfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condltfon not supported ln PEG.

Conditfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fissfon Product Barrier EAL Evaluation. Rev. 1 Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condftfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condltfon not supported in PEG.

Condftion not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Conditfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Conditfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condftfon not supported in PEG.

Condltfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condftfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condftion not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation. Rev. I Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condftfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Conditfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condftfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condltfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Conditfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condftfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Glnna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation. Rev. I Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Conditfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Conditfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condltfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condftlon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condftlon not supported ln PEG.

Conditfon not supported in PEG.

40 40 40 Condition not supported in PEG.

40 Conditfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Conditfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condltfon not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

~

Condition not supported ln PEG.

40 40 87

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Glnna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. I Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks 40 Condition not supported ln PEG.

40 Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condftfon not supported ln PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

40 40 40 Condition not supported fn PEG.

40 Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

40 40 40 Condition not supported in PEG.

40 Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

40 40 40 Condition not supported In PEG.

40

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Gfnna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation. Rev. 1 Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL Condftlon not supported In PEG.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL Condition not supported In PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Conditfon not supported In PEG.

Condltfon not supported In PEG.

Condftfon not supported In PEG.

Conditfon not supported In PEG.

Condftion not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL Condltfon not supported in PEG.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL 89

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG RE. Glnna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condftlon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL Condition not supported In PEG.

Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Glnna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported In PEG.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Loss of FC + loss of RCS + loss of PC Condition not supported in PEG.

Conditfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condltfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condltfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

16, 41 16, 42 Condition not supported in PEG.

16. 43 91

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EALEvaluation, Rev. 1 Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies N ESP-007 Remarks 48 Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

40 Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

17. 41 17, 42 Condition not supported in PEG.

17, 43 48 Conditfon not supported In PEG.

Condftfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

40 Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condltfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condftfon not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

16, 41 16, 42 Condition not supported in PEG.

16, 43 48 Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condltfon not supported ln PEG.

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Gfnna Ffssion Product Barrier EAL Evaluation. Rev. I Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported in PEG.

40 Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition riot supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condftlon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL Condition not supported ln PEG.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG; Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condftfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rex. L Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Conditfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condftfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Conditfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Glnna Ffssfon Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condftion not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condftfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condftlon not supported In PEG.

Condftlon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Glnna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table D Ghana Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Conditfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Conditfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condftion not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

41 42 Condition not supported in PEG.

43 48

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Glnna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1.

Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condltfon not supported ln PEG.

40 Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

17, 41 17, 42 Condition not supported in PEG.

17, 43 46 Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

40 Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condltlon not supported ln PEG.

Condltfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condftlon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Conditfon not supported ln PEG.

16, 41

16. 42 Condftion not supported In PEG.

'6,43 48 Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

97

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rer. I Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 ~Rmarks Condition not supported in PEG.

40 Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Conditfon not supported in PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Condltlon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condftfon not supported in PEG.

Condition riot supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

98

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Glnna I fssion Product Barrfer EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condftfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

41 42 Condition not supported fn PEG.

43 48 Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

40 Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

17, 41 17, 42 Condition not supported fn PEG.

17, 43 48

'Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

40 Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Glnna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation. Rev. I Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 ~Rmarka Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Conditfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL Condition not supported In PEG.

41 42 Condition not supported ln PEG.

43 48 Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condftlon not supported In PEG.

40 Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL Condition not supported In PEG.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condftlon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condltfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

101

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. I Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Conditfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Conditfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condftion not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Conditfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

~

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

102

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Glnna Fission Product Barrier EAL EvaluaUon, Rev. I Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies MES P-007 Remarks Condltfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condftfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition pot supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condftfon not supported in PEG.

Condftfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Conditfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condltfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

103

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Glnna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condltfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condftlon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

41 42 Condition not supported in PEG.

43 48 Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

40 Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported in PEG.

41 42 Condition not supported in PEG.

43 48 Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

40 Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Condltfon not supported ln PEG.

104

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Glnna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rex.. 1 Tab1e D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condftfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Conditfon not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condfl.ion not supported ln PEG.

Condftlon not supported in PEG.

41 42 Condition not supported in PEG.

43 48 Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

40 Subsumed In Judgment" EAL Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Conditfon not supported ln PEG.

Condftfon not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condftlon not supported ln PEG.

Condltfon not supported in PEG.

Condltfon not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Condltfon not supported fn PEG.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

105

I

~

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Gfnna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported In PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condltfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Conditfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

41 42 Condition not supported In PEG.

43

0 OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Glnna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks 48 Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

40 Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported in PEG.

17, 41 17, 42 Condition not supported in PEG.

17, 43 48 Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG, Condition not supported in PEG.

40 Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Condltfon not supported in PEG.

Conditfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condltfon not supported In PEG.

Condltfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condftfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

41 42 Condition not supported in PEG.

43 48 Condition not supported ln PEG.

107

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL EvaluaUon, Rev. 1 Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condition not supported In PEG.

Condltfon not supported in PEG.

40 Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Conditfon not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condltfon not supported ln PEG.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condltfon not supported In PEG; Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

108

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation. Rev. I Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Condltfon not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Condftfon not supported in PEG.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condftion not supported In PEG.

Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

109

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluatfon. Rey. 1 Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Conditfon not supported In PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL Condition not supported ln PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported In PEG.

Subsumed fn "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL Condition not supported ln PEG.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Condition not supported ln PEG.

Condition not supported fn PEG.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed ln "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL Condition not supported in PEG.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Condftion not supported In PEG.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL.

Subsumed In "Judgment" EAL Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL 110

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. I Table D Ginna Fission Product Barrier General Emergencies NESP-007 Remarks Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

Condition not supported in PEG.

Subsumed in "Judgment" EAL.

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. l AppencUx 1 Fission Product Barrier Remarks The only source of significant containment pressure increase other than a faulted steam generator is an RCS boundary breach. By definition, loss of the RCS boundary and the loss of the primary containment boundary require a Site Area Emergency classification.

Therefore, this EAL is unnecessary and can be deleted.

2. If an inconsistent loca response is observed, a loss of the RCS has occurred. By definition, loss of the RCS boundary and the loss of the primary containment boundary require a Site Area Emergency classification. Therefore, this EAL is unnecessary and can be deleted.

3. The initiation signal for containment isolations defined for this EAL have been specified as those resulting from of an RCS breach. By definition, loss of the RCS boundary and the loss of the primary containment boundary require a Site Area Emergency classification.

Therefore, this EAL is unnecessary and can be deleted. To address failure to isolate conditions which are not a result of an RCS breach, this condition has been incorporated into PC7.1 - Other Conditions.

4 In order to reach containment-red on the CSFST, containment design pressure has been reached or exceeded. This is indicative of a loss of both RCS and fuel clad boundaries. The source of energy must be the result of severe degradation of core cooling or loss of heat sink. Since the EAL is a potential loss of containment by deQnition, this combination of conditions requires the declaration of a General Emergency. Therefore, this EAL is unnecessary and can be deleted.

5. Containment pressure > 60 psig (containment design pressure) requires entry into RED path - Containment and is indicative of a severe loca event with actual or imminent loss of fuel clad. Therefore, this EAL is adequately addressed in PCl.l and can be deleted.

6. Generation of this level of hydrogen concentration in the containment indicates that a loss of fuel clad barrier and loss of RCS barrier has occurred with a potential loss of the primary containment barrier. By definition. this combination of conditions requires the declaration of a General Emergency. Therefore. this EAL is unnecessary and can be deleted.

7. The conditions listed in this EAL represent a loss of the RCS barrier with a potential loss of containment. By deQnition, the loss of the RCS barrier requires the declaration of an Alert. Therefore, this EAL is unnecessary and can be deleted.

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Appendix 1 Fission Product Harrier Remarks

8. These containment radiation levels can only be reached as a result of a severe core damage. This represents a loss of the fuel clad barrier and the loss of the RCS barrier with a potential loss of the primary containment. By definition, this combination of conditions requires the declaration of a General Emergency. Therefore, this EAL is unnecessary and can be deleted.

9, Core Exit Thermocouple readings >1200 'F or > 700 'F with RVLIS (

TAF with a failure of restoration procedures represent a potential loss of the primary containment, a loss of fuel cl'ad barrier, and a loss of subcooling which is a fundamental indication of a loss of the RCS barrier. By definition, this combination of conditions requires the declaration of a General Emergency. Therefore, this EAL is unnecessary and can be deleted.

10, FC3.1 - Core exit thermocouples reading > 1200 'F is an entry condition for Core Cooling RED path. Therefore, any combination of FC3.1 with PC 2.5 - containment isolation failure, is redundant to FCl.l in combination with PC2.5 and can be deleted.

Core Cooling-Red on the CSFST is indicative of a Core Exit Thermocouple reading of >1200 'F, or reactor vessel water level below the top of active fuel with a Core Exit Thermocouple reading of 2700

'F. EAL¹ FC3.1 and EAL¹ FC3.2 represent a loss and potential loss of the fuel clad based on Core Exit Thermocouple readings of 1200 'F and 700 'F, respectively. EAL¹ RCS2.1 represents a loss of subcooling, therefore, entry into Core Cooling-Red or Orange also represents a loss of the RCS barrier. Thus, entry into Core Cooling-Red or Orange by itself requires declaration of a Site Area Emergency. Therefore, this EAL is unnecessary and can be deleted for consideration of Site Area Emergencies.

12. Core Cooling-Orange on the CSFST represents a potential loss of the fuel clad barrier and a loss of RCS resulting in a loss of subcooling. By definition, this combination of conditions requires the declaration of a Site Area Emergency. Therefore, this EAL is unnecessary and can be deleted.

13. Heat Sink-Red on the CSFST represents an extreme challenge to the heat sink function and. by EAL¹ SS4.1, .requires the declaration of a Site Area Emergency. Heat Sink-Red is also a potential loss of both fuel clad and RCS thus requiring declaration of a Site Area Emergency by itself. Therefore, this EAL is unnecessary and can be deleted.

1-2

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Appendix 1 Fission Product Barrier Remarks

14. A Core Exit Thermocouple reading >700 'F represents a potential loss of the fuel clad and a loss of RCS resulting in a loss of subcooling. Core Exit Thermocouple reading >700 'F also requires entry into Core Cooling - Orange path (see explanation in 12 above). By definition, this combination of conditions requires the declaration of a Site Area Emergency. Therefore, this EAL is unnecessary and can be deleted.

15, RVLIS less than or equal to the top of active fuel requires, by EAL¹ SS5.1, the declaration of a Site Area Emergency. RVLIS 5 TAF also requires entry into Core Cooling - Orange path (see explanation 12 above). Therefore, this EAL is unnecessary and can be deleted.

16. Core Cooling Red on CSFST or Core exit thermocouples > 1200 'F represent both a loss of fuel clad and RCS. Therefore, any combination of FC1.1 or FC3.1 with PC2.1, PC2.2 or PC3.1 requires declaration of a General Emergency.

17. A SGTR with a resultant path to the environment represents breach of both the RCS and the primary containment barriers. This combination of conditions requires, by definition, a Site Area Emergency declaration. Therefore. this EAL is unnecessary and can be deleted for consideration of Site Area Emergencies. Any combination of RCS3.1 with one or more fuel clad loss or potential loss indicators results in a General Emergency.

18. The containment radiation monitor reading for EAL¹ RCS4.1 bounds the reading given in EAL¹ FC5.1. Therefore, EAL¹ FC5.1 is unnecessary and can be deleted.

19. Heat Sink-Red on the CSFST represents a potential loss of the fuel clad barrier and the RCS barrier. This combination of conditions requires, by definition, the declaration of a Site Area Emergency.

Therefore, this EAL is unnecessary and can be deleted.

20. The RCS leakage for EAL¹ RCS2.2 bounds the leakage given in EAL¹ RCS3.2. Therefore, EAL¹ RCS3.2 is unnecessary and can be deleted.

21. EAL¹ FC5.1 is a containment radiation level corresponding to 5% fuel clad failure. It is also indicative of an RCS failure because EAL¹ RCS4.1 will always be a value less than EAL¹ FC5.1. Therefore, EAL¹ FC5.1 alone requires declaration of a'Site Area Emergency.

22. Deleted 1-3

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. I Appendix 1 Fission Product Barrier Remarks

23. Deleted

24. EAL¹ FC4.1 is indicative of reactor vessel water level less than the top of active fuel. This condition always requires a CSFST entry to Core Cooling-Orange or Core Cooling-Red. Core Cooling-Orange is addressed in EAL¹ FC1.2 and Core Cooling-Red is addressed in EAL¹ FC1.l. Therefore, declaration of a Site Area Emergency due to EAL¹ FC4.1 is unnecessary and can be deleted.

25. EAL¹ FC3.2 is indicative of a Core Exit Thermocouple reading at or above 700 'F. This condition always requires a CSFST entry to Core Cooling-Orange or Core Cooling-Red. Core Cooling-Orange is addressed in EAL¹ FC1.2 and Core Cooling-Red is addressed in EAL¹ FCl.l. Therefore. declaration of a Site Area Emergency due to EAL¹ FC3.1 is unnecessary and can be deleted.

26. EAL¹ PC2.3 is an entry into Containment Cooling-Red CSFST which requires a declaration of a General Emergency under EAL¹ PCl. l.

Therefore, all combinations of conditions involving EAL¹ PC2.3 are unnecessary and can be deleted.

27. EAL¹ RCS2.1 is indicative of a loss of subcooling. EAL¹ FC1.1 is based on entry to Core Cooling-Red CSFST which is indicative of a loss of subcooling. Therefore, EAL¹ RCS2.1 can be deleted from this combination of conditions.

28. EAL¹ PC6.2 is indicative of a Core Exit Thermocouple reading of 700

'F. EAL¹ FC1.1 is based on entry to Core Cooling-Red CSFST. Core Cooling-Red cannot be entered without exceeding a 700 'F Core Exit Thermocouple reading. Therefore, this combination of conditions is unnecessary and can be deleted.

29. This combination of conditions is adequately covered by EAL¹ FC1. 1 in combination with EAL¹ PC2.5.

30. [Deleted]

31. [Deleted]

32. The purpose of EAL¹ RCS2.1 is to indicate the loss of the RCS barrier.

In order to reach the condition of EAL¹ PC2.5, a breach of the RCS barrier is required. Thus, EAL¹ RCS2.1 is bounded by EAL¹ PC2.5.

Therefore, EAL¹ RCS2.1 is unnecessary and can be deleted from this combination of conditions.

1-4

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Appendix 1 Fission Product Barrier Remarks

'33. EAL¹ PC2.5 is indicative of a loss of the RCS barrier and a potential loss of the primary containment barrier. EAL¹ RCS3.1 is indicative of a loss of both RCS and primary containment barriers. A potential loss of primary containment barrier is irrelevant to this combination of conditions. Therefore, EAL¹ PC2.5 is unnecessary and can be deleted from this combination of conditions.

34. EAL¹ RCS4.1 corresponds to a containment radiation level which is always less than that in EAL¹ FC5.1. EAL¹ RCS4.1 only indicates a loss of the RCS barrier where as EAL¹ FC5.1 indicates a loss of both RCS and fuel clad barriers. Therefore, EAL¹ RCS4.1 is unnecessary in defining the General Emergency conditions. With this change, the resulting combination of conditions is identical to those given above with justification ¹32.

35. EAL¹ RCS4.1 represents containment radiation levels resulting from a loss of the RCS barrier. However, EAL¹ PC2.5 is indicative of a potential loss of the primary containment barrier and a loss of the RCS barrier. Therefore, EAL¹ RCS4.1 is bounded by EAL¹ PC2.5 and can be deleted from this combination of conditions.

36. EAL¹ FC1.2 is an entry to Core Cooling-Orange on the CSFST. EAL¹ RCS2.1 is an indication of a loss of subcooling and is also an entry to Core Cooling-Orange on the CSFST. Thus, EAL¹ FC1,2 bounds EAL¹ RCS2.1. Therefore, EAL¹ RCS2.1 is unnecessary and can be deleted from this combination of conditions.

37. RCS3.1 represents both a loss of RCS and loss of primary containment barrier. Therefore, PC2.1 can be deleted from any combination of RCS3.1 loss and fuel clad potential loss.

38. EAL¹ PC2.1, EAL¹ PC2.2 and EAL¹ PC3.1 represent a loss of the RCS and primary containment barriers. Therefore, EAL¹ RCS2.1 which represents a loss of RCS barrier is unnecessary and can be deleted from this combination of conditions.

39. By justification ¹38 above, any combination of EAL¹ PC2.1, EAL¹ PC2.2 or EAL¹ PC3.1 and any of the following: EAL¹ FC1.2, EAL¹ FC3.1, EAL¹ FC4.1, FC5.1 or EAL¹ FC6.1, results in the declaration of a General Emergency. Therefore, this combin'ation of conditions is redundant and can be deleted.

1-5

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation. Rev. 1 Appendix 1 Fission Product Barrier Remarks

40. EAL¹ PC7.1 is used only as loss of primary containment barrier for the Unusual Event declaration. For the Site Area Emergency and the General Emergency declaration, EAL¹ PC7.1 is subsumed into the "Judgment" EAL. It is the only NUMARC primary containment barrier loss which is not associated with a loss of the RCS barrier. Loss of containment airlock doors is event dependent. The airlock doors may be open for reasons other than an emergency situation (e. g.,

maintenance activities, etc.). Shift personnel will rapidly respond to faQure of other barriers by reclosing the doors. If the doors are not reclosed. any loss of the RCS barrier that occurs with the doors open will appear as an inconsistent loca response. Therefore, this event need not be used to indicate a loss of the primary containment barrier unless the Emergency Director determines such a declaration is needed.

41. EAL¹ PC2.1 is indicative of a loss of the primary containment barrier and a loss of the RCS barrier. Any combination of EAL¹ PC2.1 with a loss of the fuel clad barrier alone requires declaration of a General Emergency. Therefore, the third EAL condition is unnecessary and can be deleted. Any other combinations of conditions using EAL¹ PC2.1 and fuel clad barrier losses are redundant and can be deleted.

42. EAL¹ PC2.2 is indicative of a loss of the primary containment barrier and a loss of the RCS barrier. Any combination of EAL¹ PC2.2 with a loss of the fuel clad barrier alone requires declaration of a General Emergency. Therefore. the third EAL condition is unnecessary and can be deleted. Any other combinations of conditions using EAL¹ PC2.2 and fuel clad barrier losses are redundant and can be deleted.

43. EAL¹ PC3.1 is indicative of a loss of the primary containment barrier and a loss of the RCS barrier. Any combination of EAL¹ PC3.1 with a loss of the fuel clad barrier alone requires declaration of a General Emergency. Therefore, the third EAL condition is unnecessary and can be deleted. Any other combinations of conditions using EAL¹ PC3.1 and fuel clad barrier losses are redundant and can be deleted.

44. [Deleted]

45. [Deleted]

46. While RCS 1.1 is a potential loss of RCS, the concern for RCS loss is reactor vessel integrity. PC4.1 is a loss of containment in that a secondary side release with primary to secondary leakage ) Tech.

Spec. provides a pathway from the RCS to outside containment. While 1-6

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Appendix 1 Fission Product Barrier Remarks it is feasible for both of these conditions to exist simultaneously, they are not related such that the failure associated with red path integrity (reactor vessel structural failure) interfaces with the containment loss mechanism (steam generator tube leakage). Therefore this combination is not appropriate.

47. While RCS 2.1 and RCS4.1 are losses of RCS, the concern for RCS loss is reactor vessel integrity. PC4.1 is a loss of containment in that a secondary side release with primary to secondary leakage > Tech.

Spec. provides a pathway from the RCS to outside containment. WMe it is feasible for both of these conditions to exist simultaneously, they are not related such that the failure associated with a loss of coolant (reactor vessel structural failure) interfaces with the containment loss mechanism (steam generator tube leakage). If primary to secondary leakage was of the magnitude to have caused the loss of inventory, then declaration would be made per RCS 3.1. Therefore this combination is not appropriate.

48. While RCS 1.1, RCS1.2, RCS 2.1, RCS 2.2 and RCS4,1 are losses or potential losses of RCS. the concern for RCS loss is reactor vessel integrity. PC4.1 is a loss of containment in that a secondary side release with primary to secondary leakage > Tech, Spec. provides a pathway from the RCS to outside containment. While it is feasible for both of these conditions to exist simultaneously in conjunction with one or more of the fuel clad loss indicators (FC1.2, FC1.3, FC2.1, FC3.2. FC4.1, FC5.1, FC6.1), they are not related such that the failure associated with a loss of coolant (reactor vessel structural failure) interfaces with the containment loss mechanism (steam generator tube leakage). If SG leakage was of the magnitude to have caused the loss of inventory, then declaration would be made per RCS 3.1 + one of the fuel clad loss indicators. Therefore this combination is not appropriate.

1-7

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Appendix 2 Suxxxxxxary of Fission Product Barrier Evaluation The following summarizes the EALs which resulted from the analysis performed of the fission product barrier methodology of NUMARC-007 for R.E. Ginna:

Unusual Event

~ PC4. 1-loss

~ PC7. 1-loss

~ Emergency Director Judgement Alert:

~ FC2. 1-loss

~ FC6.1 loss

~ RCS1.1-pot loss

~ RCS2. 1-loss

~ RCS4. 1-loss

~ RCS2.2-pot loss

~ Emergency Director Judgement Site Area Exner enc:

~ FC1.1-loss

~ FC1.2-pot loss

~ FC1.3-pot loss/RCS 1.2-pot loss

~ RCS3. 1-loss

~ FC5.1-loss

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation. Rev. I Appendix 2 Suxrmxary of Fission Product Barrier Evaluation Site Area Emer enc cont:

~ FC2.1 loss + ANY:

-RCS l. 1-pot. loss

-RCS2.2-pot. loss

-RCS2. 1-loss

-RCS4. 1-loss

~ FC6.1 loss + ANY:

-RCS l. 1-pot. loss

-RCS2.2-pot. loss

-RCS2. 1-loss

-RCS4. 1-loss

~ PC2. 1-loss

~ PC2.2-loss

~ PC3. 1-loss

~ RCS2.2-pot loss + PC4. 1-loss

~ Emergency Director Judgement General Emer enc:

~ PC1.1-pot. loss

~ PC2.4-pot. loss

~ PC5.1-pot. loss

~ PC2.5-pot loss + ANY:

-FC l. 1-loss

-FC2. 1-loss

-FC5. 1-loss

-FC6. 1-loss

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Appendix 2 Sununary of Fission Product Barrier Evaluation

'eneral Emer enc cont:

~ RCS3.1-loss + ANY:

-FC1.2-pot loss

-FC1.3-pot loss

-FC2. 1-loss

-FC3.2-pot loss

-FC4. 1-pot loss

-FC5. 1-loss

-FC6.1 loss

~ PC2.1-loss + ANY:

-FC1.2-pot loss

-FC1.3-pot loss

-FC2. 1-loss

-FC3.2-pot loss

-FC4. 1-pot loss

-FC5. 1-loss

-FC6.1 loss

~ PC2.2-loss + ANY:

-FC1.2-pot loss

-FC1.3-pot loss

-FC2. 1-loss

-FC3.2-pot loss

-FC4. 1-pot loss

-FC5. 1-loss

-FC6. 1 loss

~ PC3.1-loss + ANY:

-FC1.2-pot loss

-FC1.3-pot loss

-FC2. 1-loss

-FC3.2-pot loss

-FC4. 1-pot loss

-FC5. 1-loss

-FC6;1 loss 10

OSSI 92-402A-2-REG R.E. Ginna Fission Product Barrier EAL Evaluation, Rev. 1 Appendix 2 Suxnxnary of Fission Product Barrier Evaluation General Emer enc cont:

~ PC6.1-pot. loss

~ PC6.2-pot loss

~ Emergency Director Judgement

1 e

s

Attachment E IL U<<lode Plfaojee plqnt $ pecific EAI Guideline (PEG)

R,.F. Ginna Revision 1

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S)

R.E. Glnna IC¹: AU1 Any unplanned release of gaseous or llquld radloactlvlty to the environment that exceeds tvyo times the radiological Technical Speclflcatlons for 60 minutes or longer.

Op. Mode Applicability Q (PwrOps) Q2(HSB) Q3(HSD) Q4(CSD) Q5(Refuel) Q6(Defuel) QAII 1

AU1.1 AU1.2 (site-specific monitors) ~

A valid reading on one or more of the following monitors that exceeds the "value shown indicates that the release may have exceeded the above criterion and indicates the need to assess the release with~~pecit~ocedure):

Confirmed sample analyses for gaseous or liquid releases indicates concenlrations or release technical-specifications)

Ligule MZBZQ.Sauftrtdix LIuhh lL Qaluma 2. gr Balsams'nufimm

~4 M uQBal fttr tfmghtttf ftr artlraittftd rtghftt gant'1 R552Et B9IQKEi' 1KQ mrauhubgh brtdx arttf < KKmrttmhz alua rfg2t futm attbtt gam Zaha Rmn". < Z99 mrtta5r am ttrgaa fatm Lt2. LQ3. tritium atttf p'stir.ufafaauiih ~ 8 day. half fitaa 1K~ZZum lKKsam in 22Khmn Note: Il the monitor readingsm artt sustained for longer than 60 minutes and the required assessments cannot be completed within this period, then the declaralion must be made based on the valid reading.

Plant Specific EAL Guideline {A,H,S)

R.E. Ginna Bases The term "Unplanned; as used in this context, includes any release for which a radioactive discharge permit was not prepared, or a release that exceeds the conditions (e. g., minimum dilution flow, maximum discharge flow, alarm setpoints, etc.) on the applicable permit.

Valid means that a radiation monitor reading has been confirmed by the operators to be correct.

Unplanned releases in excess of two times the site technical specifications that continue for 60 minutes or longer represent an uncontrolled situation and hence, a potential degradation in the level of safety. The final integrated dose (which is very low in the Unusual Event emergency class) is not the primary concern here; it is the degradation in pfant control implied by the fact that this initiating condition. Further, the ~ ~t~rtr ~frftnglr the release was not isolated within 60 minutes. Therefore, it is not intended that the release be averaged over 60 minutes. For example, a release of 4 times T/S for 30 minutes does not exceed that the release duration has or will likely exceed 60 minutes.

Qg~ri .i~}Girector should not wait until 60 minutes has elapsed, but should declare the event as soon as it is determined Monitor indications ara shouf4bo calculated on the basis ol the methodology of the site Offsite Dose Cafculation Manual (ODCM to demonstrate compliance with 10CFR20. Annual average meteorohgy shoufdbo la used wfa~ltovvod.

Ibaalarm aataginfa1gr tba Ihtad mnnitgraarft maaft tratttrabr att tn an2fra Iaf'bniml Gamfiaatlrtn radlnaafiYhy ralaaaa ftmita arft nrtt zxmWd. Iba tba a~~it tftd Iat;bniml SmziEalhn fttfta2t rattly aa anfmifhd h E2 ~~

~ ~ hz~ munitrtr labe tlmfta Iba ibm n2ztnad Qiana deign 1'. ~

duff nuiuliTiza talamaf~

ara burnt rtn br'imfta tba Iftt:bniialGambmtlrtn Ifaltraa rwan ln; hmmftndfrtftnt kh.2L hdiJm Ntritnfttftrmunitrtra.

XLU.tbrgifgb 2222 QhM ~f dna'est /11Tlzft 2!f19matE rftaL1!ma dna 222ta2IIKL

0 Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S)

R.E. Glnna IC¹: AU2 Unexpected Increase In plant radlatlon or aIrborne concentration.

Op. Mode Applicability Q1(pvrrOps) Q2(HSB) Q3(HSD) Q4(CSD) Q5(Refuel) Q6(Defuel) ~ All AU2.1 AU2.2 vnsontr assemblies remaining.coverert-by~en AU2.4 Vatid ~ ~lttitttttf direct area radiation monitor readings g QIIKQIR tllgb f92lllIIQQfoal

~ IltttLt 2Q tlEZalz!IQ grgg~ increase by a factor-of-1000over~rmat'-

levels.

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S)

R.E. Gtnna Bases Valid means that a radiation monitor reading has been confirmed by the operators to be correct.

~

All of the above events tend to have long lead times relative to potential for radiofogical release outside the site boundary, thus impact to public health and safety is very low.

In light of Reactor Cavity Seal failure, incidents at two different PWRs and loss of water in the Spent Fuel Pit/Fuel Transfer Canal at a BWR all occurring since 1984, explicit coverage of these

¹t and ¹2 is appropriate given their potential for increased doses to plant staff. Classification as an Unusual Event is warranted as a precursor to a more serious types of events via EALs event.

i I nuuh~all hmdiabtd hutl asmnblim utmainina QQIfftutd he mataCmm diftlftdm huuftQfv~m. hh22 11 EAL ¹3 ~ applies to plants with licensed dry storage of older irradiated spent fuel to address degradation of this spent fuel.

I EAL ¹4~ addresses unplanned increases in in-plant radiation levels that represent a degradation in lhe control of radioactive material, and represent a potential degradation safety of the Plant. JftdIQgiigl Qf ~r f~ititQu IKEh !KDQRQQ 1Q 2 1K Qm ihft ~i Qfhaith hi lm tarn Mhsiftd baalim ihLdt Yallm am mQCR Kadilr in the level of idftoiiTiaithisa a

~

adQQIII1 Qr mll!LIQhQimunnL ~ii SQm hEd %1QQiQhsm uQI!liDallym escalates to an Alert per IC AA3, if the increases imPair utQutftitim ~iftuuzrau radtaitQu !ah ihat buftHIt

~

mme QQRdamd25EKaQlmal ifttutiQi safe oPeration.

KQ 1iam ilm shun

~

mIQQinL

~igingf ~

lQYf!L'41Kfimmihkslturm utZ ftu~ ~ adQQifliac QffKnhhi QQimdftiftd Iu ~ Qg. 1Q armis an Mli&1901 ihfmllQld. This lluuft&2~201IILQIIIIgtdfI~RliQu 1Q EAL

~

Plant Specific EAL. Guideline (A,H,S)

R.E. Glnna IC¹'A1 Any unplanned refease of gaseous or lfquld radloactfvfty to the envfronment that exceeds 200 times radlologlcal Technical Speclflcatlons for 15 mlnules or longer.

Op. Mode Appllcablllty Q1(PvvrOps) Q2(HSB) Q3(HSD) Q4(CSD) Q5(Refuel) Q6(Defuel) QAII AA1.1 AA1.2 (sit~fiemonitore) ~

A valid reading on one or more of the following monitors that exceeds the "value shown indicates that the refease may have exceeded the above criterion and indicates the need to assess the release wilh Confirmed sample analyses for gaseous or liquid releases indicates concentrations or release rates in excess of LttttiIiBttlttaata;

~

2991imfta3KEB29. hamtndix Q.Mh lL Qdtfmn2 k2 uQhnl fz dimdxafl gr anfrairmd nrthh aaafta Gmmu Bahaavz

< 199 amer mhtth hulIr and < K9 amLkr ahn dgaa fuan afthh gam hhotm Zah@3zmC < 2E rfta5r zx rtrgan fram 821. L123. lrilitfmand ltartit;tthha tffitlts RrhtrhaKlhtfta 1

19KZmm 1JMtimn 2.21EZmm dim-~~i

= ~ mar.

EL31925!tHNn Lht hhniftza 25ah1x = ~ 1'19 mEhr. 25ahlx = AU. rnBlhr. 5 Sahlx =228 mB Lbr mB'5ah1x Note: If the monitor readingsuara sustained for longer than 15 minutes and the required assessments cannot be completed within this period, then the declaration must be made based on the valid reading.

AA1.3 AA1.4 Va4d-reading-on~~adiation-monitoring-syst~reater-I t5-minuteeor4uupv (for~es-having4efemeter~imeter-monitors)

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S)

R.E. Ginna Bases Valid means that a radiation monitor reading has been confirmed by the operators to be correct.

This event escalates from the Unusual Event by escalating the magnitude ol!he release by a factor of 100. Prorating the 500 mR/yr criterion for both time (8766 hr/yr and the 200 multiplier, th-=-

associated site boundary dose rate would be t0 mR/hr. The required release duration was reduced to 15 minutes in recognition of the increased severity.

Monitor indications cttould4e ara calculated on the basis of the methodology of 44o c4oOffsite Dose Calculation Manual (ODCM~er- -.

Annual average meteorology 4toutdke i; used wallowed.

aaLL QEYRfKH1 ~~

Znm fhara ia nn high ranga arft flM11ht tt1tfrft rti ~1 Qaa ~n zrrf mnnilnr aaattniaiad tfrifh littttidai(tuan1 mtnni1ttr ln I

~ fhQnfr 1hft ~// 1/K KnitLrrt . Qgrmai Qrtftra(inn'.

Eiland 299x LS.1faitfa ia htmtnd Ka ttnnar allah. anindiaafinn n(3dfanaia hi ia nnnatnfa1'Mtth ffaftrL QQp ~i dltaa nft1 Ygiit~m~rd nftrlmafar Qlttnifkrr HQE ~i dttaa ntt1 ~ attfgma+ rftaL1ima dftaft aactftaamttn f,

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S)

R.E. Glnna ICff: AA2 MaJor damage to Irradiated fuel or loss of water level that has or will result In the uncovering of lrradfated fuel outside the reactor vessel.

Op. Mode Applicability Q 1 (Pwr Ops) Q 2 (HSB) Q 3 (HSD) Q 4 (CSD) Q 5 (Refuel) Q 6 (Defuel) ~ AII AA2.1 AA2.2 monitors ~li i~ ~') ggttftUttttg ~>tttttf alarm on one or more of the following radiation gg Itic;gttlt~l Jtttt) ~nr fjttg ~g~: ~e-epeefiasnonitore)

~

K5.5mlQaJ B; 25~

~ijiinn g}gg ~

AA2.3 AA2.4

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S)

R.E. Glnna Bases This IC applies to spent fuel requiring water coverage and is not intended to address spent fuel which is licensed for dry storage, which is discussed in NUMARC IC AU2. "Unexpected Increase 4 Plant Radiation or Airborne Concentration."

NUREG-0818, "Emergency Action Levels for Light Water Reactors," forms the basis for these EALs. ItUtuhrnla EALs arfUfftfjnftd by the specific area where irradiated fuel is located such as reactor cavity,woac~ossof, or spent fuel pool.

I!1Q radta QQ QEQIIQf alarm RKkclafrtd Yrjfh 1bh EK rnuaf ba QH!1HQEd In aYrtiif uQQQQk5~ dfKIara1hn Qf aQ amftrgftQK dutt iQ a s?uljrtua ~l RQQaL hn anatn1rnltad fuftf handljna rtrmm hftfjjftdas amr a~rftnf rtr arJiutx ftlaiftdfrt iha mrntarrrftnirtf irradjafftd fual mlrjgh ramfth inunftlfmmfftd rrr unuudrnltftd amdifjnna. Ihjaiftrminrthlnr ha:

hen amitjmlltr addftd furst;lurh anijrJrrafad jnt:mui in arfta radjaLIrrn IILrfrhaa a rftmrtf rtf churn nftrfnrrrrftd in auzrdaam mjfb anurrufrd nzmhuaa durjnrr raffia@ nnftrafigna.

There is time available to take corrective actions, and there is little potential for substantial fuel damage. In addition, NUREG/CR-4982, "Severe Accident in Spent Fuel Pools in Support of Generic Safety Issue 82, July t 987, indicates that even if corrective actions are not taken, no prompt fatalities are predicted, and that risk ol injury is low. In addition, NRC Information Notice No. 90-08, "KR 85 Ilazards from Decayed Fuel presents the following in its discussion:

In the event of a serious accident involving decayed spent fuel, protective actions would be needed for personnel on site, while offsite doses (assuming an exclusion area radius of one mile from the plant site) would be well below the Environmental Protection Agency's Protective Action Guides. Accordingly, it is important to be able to properly survey and monitor for Kr-85 in the event ol an accident with decayed spent fuel.

Ihara fuftt urEQYftry. EK hh22h unnftrzmrE.

unnftriaaaar Y am Lhha h nr? IELftl~im~~ mal in Lhhr fuftl frillmls Rhumb! rth29QZLIIQ Qf haa Qf E919E IQYQl Emu'hn ht rftrrujrftrLuu. ~

Ia nn indtnarhn fhat ttraittr Intra! in 1ha anftnr fual rtant far Dtfutttina aavirtr haa drrtrtltftd in 1ha htrttf nf iha fual rtlhtr ihan by. rhuat rtttaftnraljrtn. Knca hhL2 addraaata Idsual ahaftnrartnn-h Thus, an Alert Classification for this event is appropriate. Escalation, if appropriate, would occur via Abnormal Rad level/Radiological Effluent or C4coctor judgement.

~ Qgnftnrj~ ~gangy Qgrtrdjnatnrl fMfuanr.az

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S)

R.E. Ginna Ictf: AA3 Release of radioactive material or Increases In radlatlon levels wlthln the faclllty that Impedea operation of Iyitinte required to malntaln safe operations or to establish or mafntaln cold shutdown.

Op. Mode Appllcablllty 0 1 (Pwr Ops) Q 2 (MSB) 0 3 (HSD) Q 4 (CSD) Q 5 (Refuel) Q 6 (Defuel) ~ All AA3.1 AA3.2 Void ~~~ht radiation monitor reading greater than 15 mR/hr in areas-rsquiring-(sit~pecific) Q ~ radiation monitor readings greater than

!ha; functions.AND access is required to establish or maintain cold shutdown Qutral Bxttn = E1. Quotud Elm hhohur QB -)Site-specific)-list, Qh5.=hx ~~ mm zd 22=hx m mm

-(Sitewpecitic)-list

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S) 0 R.E. Ginna Bases Valid means that a radiation monitor reading has been confirmed by the operators to be correct.

fjm;hratha fjtffth auzmoiau md hmuzuu radialho lmh ihat hrhHX m:ftfuh jj Ehr.

~ ~jgttgftg ~ ffbmjj0~ ~ ~tmfj~g jg fjth Qg. ig gyp'attftgft~ ~MK safe This IC addresses increased radiation levels that impede necessary access to operating stations, or other areas containing equipment that must be operated manually, in order to maintain The cause operation or perform a safe shutdown. ft is this impaired ability to operate the plant that results in the actual or potential substantial degradation of the level of safety of the plant.

and/or magnitude of the increase in radiation levels is not a concern of this IC. The QhjffQl~zyizz gmgrgftagy, QggrdjttaigQC4cecM must consider the source or cause of the increased radiation levels and determine if any other IC may be involved. For example, a dose rate of 15 mR/hr in the control room may be a problem in itself. However, the increase may also be indicative of high dose rates in the containment due to a LOCA. In this latter case, an SAE or GE may be indicated by the fission product barrier matrix ICs.

This IC is not meant to apply to increases in the containment dome radiation monitors as these are events which are addressed in the fission product barrier matrix ICs. Nor is it intended to appl to anticipated temporary increases due to planned events (e. g., incore detector movement, radwaste container movement, deplete resin transfers, etc.)

~off-normal operating procedures, emergency operating procedures, the 10CFR50 Appendix R analysis, identifying areas containing safe shutdown equipment.

roe~~ ~ ~ g~gII. ~ ~ ~ Q~ ffflj~>gg.

Areas requiring continuous occupancy g~g include the control room jf an The value of 15 mR/hr is derived from the GDC 19 value of 5 rem in 30 days with adjustment for expected occupancy times. Although Section III.D.3 of NUREG-0737, Clarification of TMI Action Plan Requirements", provides that the 15 mR/hr value can be averaged over the 30 days, the value is used here without averaging, as a 30 day duration implies an event potentially more signiiicant than an Alert.

ased on gjiggii~ radiation levels which result in exposure control measures intended to maintain doses within normal occupational exposure guidelines and limits (i. e., 10CFR20), and in doing so, will impede necessary access.

r i i I wn

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S}

R.E. Glnna IC¹: AS1 Boundary dose resulting from an actual or imminent release of gaseous radloactlvlty exceeds 100 IHfttrt~

or 500 mR ChNOQQE Thyroid for the actual or proJected duration of the release.

Op. Mode Appllcablllty 0 1 (Pwr Ops) 0 2 (HSB) 0 3 (HSD) 0 4 (CSD) 0 5 (Refuel) 0 6 (Defuel) 5 All AS1.1 AS).2 A valid reading on one or more of the following monitors thatu the-value shown indicates that the release may have exceeded the above criterion and EEE ~ Zarttrttl Bttam lhsa hsaasaraattl Batt.? affactitta data 19l2EQ:

Zabe2puf.

MK9uB'x I Mls' 115B ttGBz M1922aamliaa hhrtihta 15ubdr = L51 mEbr. 2 Gahfx = ~ 1BBV=XmBhr mEbr. 22ah1v. = X1Z mEbr. 5 Gah1x = R29 mB dz Note: If the monitor reading(s) is sustained for longer than 15 minutes and the required assessments cannot be completed within this period, then the declaration must be made based on the valid reading.

AS1.3 Valid dose assessment capability indicates dose consequences greater than 100 mR Jfgp whole body or 500 mR child QQP thyroid.

AS1.4 Field survey results indicate site boundary dose rates exceeding 100 mR/hr ~ expected to continue for more than one hour; or analyses of field sunrey samples indicate child QQf. thyroid dose commitment of 500 mR for one hour of inhalation.

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S)

R.E. Glnna Bases Valid means that a radiation monitor reading has been confirmed by the operators to be correct.

The 100 mR ~ integrated dose in this initiating condition is based on the proposed 10CFR20 annual average population exposure. This value also provides a desirable gradient (one order of description. The 500 mR integratedcbiM44yroid QQf. fhfrmtf dose was established in consideration of the 1:5 ratio ol the EPA Protective Action Guidelines for thyroid.

~

magnitude) between the Alert, Site Area Emergency, and General Emergency classes. It is deemed that exposures less than this limit are not consistent with the Site Area Emergency dass whotakody and QQE based on a site boundary dose of 100 mR/hour rr/hoto4ody TEDE or 500 mR/hour

' ', whichever is more limiting (depends on source term assumptions).

Iha mhm abnttm tttara daittrmInatf 1iliziaa EEE ~ Xan1rttl Eh'hm huasmaai: haauf urtan tttbttfa hudx attftamua. Iha aafculaiiana mada iba aaaumnlittn af naufral aiabiTtitr anti an 8 rnuh miffataaff. Ibad ggnffiligna raftra:dtni II

~

annuaf airaiaga maIaazhm. EZE~ attmfiaaihat tfrhafahttfy.thea h limilina mhh mmi ia amarganm daz8iaalhn antf nruiaaibra M 'l&t Muvgb EZZ kM arayidaa fttr fMQ2 rafaaaa tfaiarminalhna. iba yatfabtriltr rtf ramdh haaatf.urtgn 1ha nuadmr af MKa anrhtr RCa aurdutfaa iha ma gf amr mngfa auuutur ffafauff tratua fttr 1'tunilara.

The ESAB ggJQpQ ~

monitors on that pathway.

source terms applicable to each monitored pathway shoutcLbo hatra htan used in conjunction with annual average meteorology in determining indications for the Q ~PI ~ ~t ~

3. ~A Iabttt 22 Qggm +~~mn 4 K E. Qiana lhxfaar Ham Haa1 Iat:hniml SnaaifIaatittna. hmattdmanl hh. M hdirJm XKhi1bru ARRAN

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S) fCff: AG1 Op. Mode R.E. Ginna Boundary dose resulting from an actual or lmmlnent release of gaseous radioactivity exceeds 1000 Bevy or 5000 ntR-Chud Qgf. Thyroid for the actual or proJected duration of the release using actual meteorology.

~g ~ eA~ele Applfcablllty Q1(PwrOps) Q2(HSB) Q3(HSD) Q4(CSD) Q5(Refuel) Q6(Defuel) ~ All AG1.1 AG1.2 A valid reading on one or more of the following monitors that~

the~tueehown indicates that Ihe release may have exceeded the above criterion and ERE ~

indicates the need to assess the release with Santrttl Ehum lhasa MasaaanL";

hhahm Zake2mf M%1~

ti 52X9uRm Mh322am lioa hhoitgc'BBV=MmBh 12ahiv. =95J.mBlhr.22nhlx=~mEhr. 25ah1x = 2hZ mEhr 1JKQESz 8 Gahlx =2XB mB de Note: tf the monitor reading(s) is sustained for longer than 15 minutes and the required assessments cannot be completed within this period, then the declaration must be made based on the valid reading.

AG1.3

~

Valid dose assessment capability indicates dose consequences whole-txxfy or 5000 mR Q}f thyroid.

greater than f000 mR ~ AG1.4 Field survey results indicate site boundary dose rates exceeding 1000 mR/hr ~ expected to continue for more than one hour; or analyses of field survey samples indicate child QP thyroid dose commitment of 5000 mR for one hour of inhalation.

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S)

R.E. Glnna Bases Valid means that a radiation monitor reading has been confirmed by the operators to be correct.

The 1000 mR IEDEwhofabody and the 5000 mR Q}fcQ4 thyroid integrated dose are based on the EPA protective action guidance which indicates that public protective actions are indicated if the dose exceeds t rem 7QP ~hAabody or 5 rem QPcM4 thyroid. This is consistent with the emergency class description for a General Emergency. This level constitutes the upper level of the desirable gradient for the Site Area Emergency. Actual meteorofogy is specifically identified in the initiating condition since it gives the most accurate dose assessment. Actual meteorology (including forecasts) should be used whenever possible.

d based on site boundary doses for either whefohody TEOE or~kkbyroid QQf~rrtid, whichever is more limiting (depends on source term assumptions(s).

Iha ~ratuaa hhtttlrt nam dafartmrtad uhlmau ER)R ~ Xrtrtfrrt(HarmIbsen Maaamattihaaadrfgtn ttthrtlahrtdx rttgrtaurL Iha aahuiaitum mada iha azafmuitrtrt rtl nauiral aiahtltitr artdarr 0 muh mhd auaarL Iha2r azdjijrtita raitraaarfi aortual afraiaga maIartrrtiagtt. ERlR &iRartaaiTiLr ihai @huh hrtdh daaa la limifiarrnifb raataui Q amargartm aiamiHuaijrtrr arid rtruiauibra @dim bh M BMtrtugh ERIE BR rtrmidaa hr EBK32ralaa2r daiarmjrtaiittita. (ha m~iahiLily.rtfiaaulia ha2tdurtrtrt iha rtumhairtf hELQ artdtrtr SQ rtradudaa (ha u2r rt(afMr 2rtgiarziulrtr dafaulf)rajuahi iha2r mrtrtitara.

The ESAR QQQEla on that pathway.

~ source terms appficabfe to each monitored pathway 4~kLba hatra haart used in conjunction with annual average meteorofogy in determining indications for the monitors

? EEff 2399zhal Emm Qm buaa2~n

3. ESTAB Mia 22 6 B.E. Qiana Szittar Rrt~Mar Rlaoi Iauhniml Gmmfiaaiiurta. hmartdatarti

5. Mhuiariarta irtr HUJdhBG EBLIS hy ES. Rail(air Eifa KhL2KS hh.Q. Brfidm ~ 1hru KL22

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S)

R.E. Glnna IC¹: HU1 Natural and destructive phenomena affecting the protected area.

Op. Mode Applicability Q1 (Pwr Ops) 2 (HSB) Q3 (HSD) 4 (CSD) Q5 (Refuel) Q 6 (Defuel) 5 All

~

Q Q HU1.1 HU1.2 (Site-specif Report by plant personnel of tornado within atttnt protected area ttgygdgty..

~ig~tta ~ tna11nJ tty, anft at ~r ~l ~rtj~n ~r PHD grrng ~ggllry~b ~ Lnntat aftt ~ ~~h)ttt f Qanfittnatianat mtbauatttt at m intttnahxaamhc tbnn 221a aaidt'aatftd hx Lftd LED an

~i ttttttaftnatt pJgg" HU1.3 Assessment by the control room that-an. event has-occurred-.

HU1.4 Vehicle crash into boundary.

~ aLafftat'ttft ~ tfnaftah plant structures or systems within protected area HU1.5 HU1.6 Report by plant personnel ot an unanticipated explosion within protected area boundary Report of turbine failure resulting in casing penetration or damage to turbine or generator seals.

resulting in visible damage to permanent structure or equipment.

~(Sit~pecifie)-occurrence-Deer Creek lhoding over entrance road bridge OR Lake level > 252 IL OR Screen House Suction Bay water level < 15 feet (hw-hw level atarm)

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S)

R.E. Glnna Bases The protected area boundary is+picatty Ihat part within Ihe security isolation zone and is defined in Ihe site security plan.

Damage may be caused to some portions of the site, but should not affect validated a reliable sourc . As defined in the EPRl.sponsored ability of safety functions to operate. Method of detection combo g based on instrumentation, by Guidelines for Nuclear Plant Response to an Earthquake, dated October 1989, a "felt earthquake is:

"An earthquake of sufficient intensity such that: (a) the inventory ground motion is felt at the nuclear plant site and recognized as an earthquake based on a consensus of control room activated. For most plants with seismic instrumentation, the seismic operators on duty at the time, and (b) for plants with operable seismic instrumentation, the seismic switches of the plant are switches are set at an acceleration of about 0.01 g."

EAL ¹~ is based on the assumption that a tornado striking (touching down) within the protected boundary may have potentially required for safe shutdown of the plant. If such damage is confirmed visually or by other in. plant indications, the event may be escalated damaged plant structures containing functions or systems to Alert.

EAL ¹~ ).tm htfta tffettftd aiauff 11m EhL urumha au amiTh midanm hr daJafatjun hftyuad shah thft Eurmidaa. Itmmfufftihh EAL ¹~4 is intended to address such items as plane or helicopter crash, barge crash uf imuauhui glar uLujftufj~that may potentially damage plant the event may be escalated to Alert.

structures containing functions and systems required lor safe shutdown of the plant. If the crash is confirmed to affect a plant vital area, For EAL ¹~5, only those explosions of sufficient force to damage permanent structures or equipment within the protected area should failure of pressurized equipment, that potentially imparts significant energy to near by be considered. As used here, an explosion is a rapid, structures and materials. No attempt is made in this violent, unconfined combustion, or a catastrophic of the damage. The occurrence of the explosion with reports of evidence of damage (e. g., deformation, scorching) is sufficient for declaration. The mlitt EAL to assess the actual magnitude

~~iuf {Emftf~n @@~in ~Qiroctoc also needs to consider any security aspects ol the explosion, if applicable.

EAI. ¹~6 is intended to address main turbine rotating component failures of sufficient magnitude to cause observable damage to the turbine casing or to the seals of the turbine generator. 0 leakage ol combustible fluids (lubricating oils) and gases (hydrogen cooling) to the plant environs. Actual fires and flammable gas build up are appropriately major concern is Ihe potential lor the risk to non-safety related classified via HU2 and HU3. This EAL is consistent with the definition of an Unusual Event while maintaining the anticipatory nature desired and recognizing of the emergency classification is based on potential damage done by missiles generated by the failure or by the radiological releases equipment. Escalation

. These latter events would be classilied by the radiological ICs or fission product barrier ICs.

I in hrm r in i h h rin nr r r' f h I EAL ¹~7 covers ~i~I~Laab r I n i I e precursors of more serious events.

~r luke mauu tfatftf ~ 2R fL mmuufuh tu ~ Ibad ufftftkffuudiau mar ftaffaauft ruad hrjduft may. urftulida ftmftraaauy. rmuumauamnnal ammed ffaffth. 5mmn tfuflaf Gudhnihy. huff s 1RQ. uurramad~ tu Qmhtulfaultahrm uujnt mf mhiuh Lftulflmafuadmtffutiunhfthm 5E'fer~n 1

2. ~

MUiibLm5ahr GaftftattumEa!Qr ~

{Hzd) Emftiumtt'. Lz

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S)

R.E. Glnna IC¹: HU2 Fire within protected area boundary not extlngulshed wlthln 15 minutes of detection.

Op. Mode Appflcablllty 01(PwrOps) Q2(HSB) Q3(HSD) 04(CSD) Q5(Refuel) Q6(Defuel) QAII HU2.1 Qd areas not extinguished within 15 minutes of control room notification er-verNeat alarm:

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S)

R.E. Glnna Bases The purpose of this IC is to address the magnitude and extent of fires that may be potentially significant precursors to damage to safety systems. This excludes such items as fires within administration buildings, waste. basket fires, and other small fires of no safety consequence. This lC applies to buildings and areas that are not contiguous or immediately adjacent to plant vital areas.

Escalation to a higher emergency class is by IC HA2, "Fire Affecting the Operability of Plant Safety Systems Required for the Current Operating Mode".

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S)

R.E. Ginna IC¹: HU3 Release of toxic or flammable gases deemed detrimental to safe operation of the plant.

Op. Mode Appllcablllty Qt (PwrOps) Q2(HSB) Q3(HSD) Q4(CSD) Q5(Refvet) Q6(Defuel) QAlt HU3.1 HU3.2 gg~i area boundary in amounts that can allect gf tht ghttt nerm4operation~hey4nt,

~ g[~

Report or detection of toxic or flammable gases that could enter

~ gL g)ftftt gft~ggJ gj ~

fttttfttftttwithin the

'fg~tttt Report by heal, county or state ofticials for potential evacuation ot site personnel based on otfsite event.

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S)

R.E. Gonna Bases This IG is based on releases in concentrations within the ~ tmt~~tbt boundary that will affect the health of plant personnel or affecting the safe operation of the plant with the plant being within the evacuation area of an offsite event (i. e., tanker truck accident releasing toxic gases, etc.). The evacuation area ls as determined from the DOT Evacuation Tables for Selected Hazardous Materials, in the DOT Emergency Response Guide for Hazardous Materials.

Plant Specific EAL. Guideline (A,H,S}

R.E. Glnna iC¹: HU4 Confirmed security event which Indicates a potential degradatlon ln the level of safety of the plant.

Op. Mode Appllcablllly Q 1 (Pwr Ops) Q 2 (HSB) Q 3 (HSD) 0 4 (CSD) Q 5 (Refuel) Q 6 (Deluel) 5 All HU4.1 HU4.2 Bomb device discovered within plant protected area lout and outside the Qirtilttrplant vital area@

loimnediaitt Quildirta

~r fhMrtr Qgjffigg

~~Ii ~t'r Qmbm~mant lhLdimr BEtrRLnsY D!LiQIMd!QQ Raadhx hmEian Qtttdtkahr Buildirtlt Guaan Sum Qmlral Barm Ra&+

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S}

R.E. Ginns Bases This EAL is based on . Security events which do not represent at least a potential degradation in the level of safety of the plant, are reported under 10CFR73.71 or in some cases under 10CFR50.72. The pfant protected area boundary iWypfcaffy that part within the security isolation zone and is defined in the-ERQ1 YflQtZf@R KO. QfK ttQfhRf KthfQ i'ialla Qguldfg Qgllfjmfftrtgy.Bag, Bomb devices discovered within the plant vital area would result in EAL escalation..

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S)

R.E. Glnna ICff: HU5 Other condltlons existing which In the Judgement of the Ibid ctggyZ~ ~gitm;y 4@oese warrant decl ttrtttion of an Unusual Event.

Op. Mode Applicability Qt (Pwrops) Q2(HSB) Q3(HSD) Q4(CSD) Q5(Refuel) QS(Defuel) QAII HU5.1 Other conditions exist which in the judgement of the Qgtt~iggr

~ QgggrZigZ ggltLgftffZV Director indicate a potential degradation of the level of safety of the plant.

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S)

R.E. Gonna eaaeS

~

This EAL is intended to address unanticipated conditions not addressed explicitly elsewhere but that warrant declaration of an emergency because conditions exist which are believed by the pygmy~~ ~tftfgftfgyQftfIL~~Dicectoc to fall under the Unusual Event emergency class.

From a broad perspective, one area lhat may warrant 2tjff ~tftfyj~~gt,ggy Qgftfijjmfgglhroctoc judgement is related to likely or actual breakdown of site specific event mitigating actions. Examples to consider include inadequate emergency response procedures, transient response either unexpected or not understood, failure or unavailability of emergency systems during an accident in excess of thai assumed in accident analysis, or insuflicient availability of equipment and/or support personnel.

Specilic example of actual events that may require mtjjf Qgg!~ftf.g~~gggffjjfht~QicocM judgement for Unusual Event declaration are listed here for consideration. However, this list is by no means all inclusive and is not intended to limit the discretion of the site to provide further examples:

f I in xl in in

~ Uncontrolled RCS cooldown due lo secondary depressurization It is also intended that the mljjfQggtIZj~ggtftrlmlfggftfgag~C4cectac judgement not be limited by any list of events as defined here or as augmented by the site. This list is provided solely as examples for consideration and il is recognized that actual events may not always follow a pre-conceived description.

Piant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S)

R.E. Glnna fc¹: HA1 Natural and destructive phenomena affecting the plant vital area.

Op. Mode Appffcabllfty Q 1 (Pwr Ops) Q 2 (HSB) Q 3 (HSD) Q 4 (CSD) Q 5 (Refuel) Q 6 (Defuel) 5 All HA1.1 HA1.2 (Sit~le)-method.

~Lhhj.~>~k ~t ~in hn Q ftaft fear mftLtt gfggf ggg@~i ~rtfmftj (site-specific)-mph-strik~hin4 sod Qzjjtmaijaa ttjmtihauakft aj aa intttasi1x amiar than QJiaa aa dftiermitnttj ha IEG Kiaftr

%~~%I GM~bauakft Eamrgftfit'X EbuC.

n i HA1.3 HA1.4 h

Reactor-building fntake-building

~

Report of any visible structural damage fbi ~ft.'2llftfii QZ1LQl BQHl QQQQQLEl Qj Ki!Hl

~tt@~ ig ftftttiftmftOitttjfttjjttL fthttt ~@ijttft on any of the following plant structures:

VNimat

~ Diesel generator.buikfing -

.-Turbine building Condensate storage tank - Controf room~

~her-]sit~pecifie~ructures HA1.5 Vehicle crash %feeling gt: fttgjthijjttjmgggt

~~ii~n ~i plant vital areas.

~ rli fiats~ gars?ruZj f itl ra

~ i'i fjamagu HA1.6 of-the.folfowingpant.areas-: ghtti ~

Turbine failure generated missiles result in any visible structural damage to or-penetratieaef-any Eufjfttntttli Sit~pecifio)-occurrences, Flood water accumalating on screenhouse operating floor OR Lake level > 253 ft. OR Screen House Suction Bay water level < 13 feet

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S)

R.E. Glnna Bases Each of these EALs is jntended to address events that may have resulted in a pfant vital area being subjected to forces beyond design limits, and thus damage may be assumed to have occurred to plant safety systems. The initial "reporl" should not be interpreted as mandating a lengthy damage assessment prior to claasliication. No attempt II made ln thla EAL to assIli the actual magnitude of the damage. Escalation to a higher emergency class, if appropriate, will be based on System Malfunction, Fission Product Barrier Degradatlon, Abnormal Rad Releases/Radiological Effluent, or 2!jji ~rtd2tr fEI!Ift!QftrlgyQQQ!rjjgrrg~r C4roctor Judgement ICs.

EAL ¹~1 cboutMe is based on~~poci~ FSAR design basis ol ggg g.. Seismic events of this magnitude can cause damage to safety functions.

EAL ~should's based on~~pec~ FSARdeefgokaciaaaatfmaff ~~jrQgmfU!fajjgarjjftg rtggdjfjg!I of sustained+ mph ~Qg~. Wind loads of this magnitude can cause damage to safety functions.

EAL ¹~3 should specify'-specifics structures containing systems and functions required for rafa Qjarti Qrtft!~i EAL ~g IharMihQfjahxmbjgh taitfraj aorf rfftairl!Qiitta Qhftt&MRara jftffjgalf@jflIhft QHII!Ql!Qgm arft afjftQttalftlYQhffta hx lb'ftarta !Q YtbEh EK k$ 1J. 12attff 12 ark!jafft!miQarj IhfKQfg!ftfbft!a ja DQ rtftftfffgr fhja EBL EAL ¹~5 is intended to address such items as plane or helicopter crash, , train crash, or barge crash into a plant vital area.

EAL ~reJatoadocL4aaddressaa the threat to safety related equipment imposed by missiles generated by main turbine rotating component failures. Thrt air!Igi!Irftaa!It safety-related equipment, their controls, and their power suppfies. This EAL is, therefore, consistent with the definition of an ALERT in that if

'mfgjttft!j missiles have damaged 'afety related equipment the potential exists for substantial degradation of the level of safety of the plant.

EAL ¹~7 covers bjg~gttt jajrft raatjiin jgu Qf ~ rtjani aattjgmaaL Ejggtf IMaittr aggttmajaljnQ Qniha agraaa bg!!2r QQ!I!afj!IQfjggrQr jalm lttmh2:253 fLQQ!!ItaQQ!tthiQ jtmhib!ItaijtlajnQxiial!IQIijgf!tftgLGmum HQI!2r Rxijga Qax ffttfaj~i2fi. QQrrftaQQQffaiQ fbft!Ijft!!aijgnnhahrft2!jffh jfr lb% mg~~~ 881 fjrftttraIKQttmQ a!KfjElbktda bftggmmQ QQKYa!a!L Q~fer

~

gaga.'.

High Eahr EhzU Emttrgartgtr Baa

2. Lgyr Smear!bm.z Eahr Lml

3. 5k% Ea!1bguajm Efmatann;r ~t~

2.~

6 BQE ESTAB R@Jiu

5. if!ift!Qjjimhhmu angra!tnbgt!aft Banu Bar Sa1m LmL Iaaf ~

5. EZE 22 Qjtia!QlQQ 51QIQQ!QlRLHj QR!ik iKrfEQKi51a age ibtar U2t. IQ Emtt!Qft!KKR52 BKtta2rtftrti IQ lmx Shia frgm William Bagin arttf Adhere Szdactf

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S)

R.E. Glnna IC¹: IIA2 Fire or explosion affecting the operability of plant safety systems required to establish or malntaln safe shutdown.

Op. Mode Applicability Q1(PwrOps) Q2(HSB) Q3(HSD) Q4(CSD) Q5(Refuel) Q6(Defuel) QAII HA2.1 The following conditions exist".

a. Fire or exphsion in any of the folhwing-(site-specific) areas:

AND

b. Affected system parameter indications show degraded performance or plant personnel report visible damage to permanent structures or equipment within the structures or equipment within the specified area.

e Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S)

illa'""'"'"""" '"'""'"'""'"'" ""~A R.E. Glnna Bases

lMBE consulted for equipment and plant areas required for the applicable mode. This will make it easier to determine if the fire or exphsion is potentially affecting one or more redundant trains ot safety systems. Escalation to a higher emergency class, if appropriate, will be based on System Malfunction, Fission Product Barrier Degradation, Abnormal Rad Releases/Radiohgical Effluent, or Emergency Director Judgement ICs.

I mini ~

With regard lo expiosions, only those expfosions of sufficient force to damage permanent structures or equipment required for safe operation within the identified plant areas should be considered. As used here, an explosion is a rapid, violent, unconfined combustion, or a catastrophic failure of pressurized equipment, that potentially imparts significant energy to nearby structuies and materials. The inclusion of a report of visible damage" should not be interpreted as mandating a lengthy damage assessment prior to classification. No attempt is made in this the~

any security glitftfggggy QggLI~~Ouoc!or with the resources needed to perform these damage assessments. The aspects ol the exphsions, if applicable.

~

EAL to assess lhe actual magnitude ol the damage. The occurrence of the explosion with reports of evidence of declaration of an Alert and the activation of the TSC will provide

~~gL 5gg~hgL gmgrgfIIIgy Qg~aggQQicector also needs to consider

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S)

R.E. Glnna fc¹: HA3 Release of toxic or flammable gases wlthln a faclllty structure which Jeopardizes operation of systems required to maintain safe operations or to establish or malntaln cold shutdown.

Op. Mode Appllcablllty Q {PwrOps) Q2(HSB) Q3(HSD) Q4(CSD) Q5(Refuel) Q6(Defuel) QAII 1

~

HA3.1 HA3.2 Report or detection ot toxic gases within a~gg~lt facility structure~ in concentrations Report or detection ot flammable gases within a ~lttmttmt structure in concentrations that that will be life threatening to plant personnel: will tittle ttt ttttttlgtttftfttttft~gry fgL~ the sate operation of the plant: I

Plant Specific EAL Guideline {A,H,S) R.E. Glnna Bases This IC is based on gases that have entered a plant structure grgghfittlt ~ Q itttttltttZZftZ~gZy. fgr&fectfag the safe operation of the plant. This IC applies to buildings and areas contiguous to plant vital areas or other significant buildings or areas {i. e., Service Water Pump house). The intent of this IC is not to include buildings (i. ewarehouses) or other areas that are not contiguous or immediately adjacent to plant vital areas. It is appropriate that increased monitoring be done to ascertain whether consequential damage has occurred. Escalation to a higher emergency class, if appropriate, will be based on System Maifunction, Fission Product Barrier Degradation, Abnormal Rad Releases/Radfobgical Effluent, or Qhjff cttigft~hgZggtftfgftm 929Ll8thtlltL}director Judgement ICs.

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S) R.E. Glnna IC¹'A4 Security event ln a plant protected area. Op. Mode Applicability Q1 (Pwr Ops) 9 2(HSB) Q3(HSD) 0 4 (CSD) P 5 (Refuel) Q 6 (Defuel) g All HA4.1 HA4.2 Intrusion into plant protected area byltftg~ggpWreetAe4aree

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S) R.E. Qlnna Bases fhft f~i~n protected area boundary can be considered g mgftjfff;~ wilt escalate this event to a Site Area Emergency.

                                                                                                              ~    ~ostiloJorco. Intrusion into a vital area by~~tilaforco    ~fhtffZgf
                                                                                                                                                                                          ~

This class of security events represents an escalated threat to plant safety above that contained in the Unusual Event. For the purposes of this IC, fttfLLt~hr. ftftftfffbQ~ftftfftftftftftf

                                                                                                      ~itLh

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S) R.E. Glnna IC¹: HA5 Control room evacuation has been Inltfated. Op. Mode Applicability p 1 (Pwr Ops) p 2 (HSB) p 3 (HSD) p 4 (CSD) Q5 (Refuel) Q 6 (Defuel) g All HA5.4 fntry into gait evacuation. vre ~~ Qzggg Qgglg Jgggggg~gi+ for control room

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S) R.E. Glnna Bases With the control room evacuated, additional support, monitoring and direction through the Technical Support Center andlor other Emergency Qg~~ EttgjTjljLt necessary. Inability to establish plant control from outside the control room will escalate this event to a Site Area Emergency.

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S) R.E. Glnna IC¹'A6 Other condltlons existing which In the Judgement of the QQg c'@gal~ g~gggy, DIre@et warrant declaration of an Alert. Op. Mode Applicability Qt(PwrOps) Q2(HSB) Q3(HSD) Q4(CSD) Q5(Refuel) Q6(Defuel) QAII HA6.t lOther conditions existing which in the Judgement of the ~ +@~~ ~ttgftft~ gg fjiftftI+r Director indicate that plant safety systems may be degraded and that increased monitoring of plant functions is warranted.

plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S) R.E. Glnna Bases This EAL is intended to address unanticipated conditions not addresse dd I'tlj d exp icitij e lsewhere sew ere but a warrant declaration of an emergency because conditions exist which are believed by the u that 5lijfi~ff~gLLEmergency Coordinator) to fall under the Alert emergency class.

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S) R.E. Glnna IC¹: HS1 Security event In a plant vital area. Op. Mode Applicability Q1(PwrOps) Q2(HSB) Q3(HSD) Q4(CSD) 05(Refuel) 06(Defuel) %All HS1.1 HS1.2

                                                              ~@~ a-trsettts4srse ~
                     /ah ~

Intrusion into IttILtttttgttdgg plant ~gyjgy, vital arear'y gg ~~~'n Q /1k QSBQhQC: t sntingsnsy-Plan, hoxamftb meat uhiah ceammh aakual u HhCh failure 4 aha axabuaa amtttd ltt mM tha attbtit. i n

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S) R.E. Gonna Bases This class of security events represents an escalated threat to plant safety above that contained in the Alert IC in that gg to the vital area. ft~~ ~ progressed from the protected area

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S) R.E. Glnna ICA'S2 Control room evacuatfon has been Inltlated and pfaeAcontrof gf ~ fgg]ggg cannot be established. Op. Mode Applfcablfity Q 1 (Pwr Ops) Q 2 (HSB) Q 3 (HSD) Q 4 (CSD) Q 5 (Refuel) Q 6 (Defuel) 5 All HS2.1 The following conditions exist:

a. Control room evacuation has been initiated.

AND within+ite-specific) + minutes.

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S) R.E. Glnnn Bases

                                                                                                                                           ~
                                             ~ ~

Expeditious transfer of safety systems has not occurred but fission product barrier damage may not yel be Indicated.+Sitaspocif+ time for transfer g based on analysis or assessments

                        ~    auQrgl gf gigot        2ghgu           gguK ftftthf, ~ ~ gZfi~

as to how quickly control must be reestablished without core uncovering and/or core damage. fht alKQItttllttfjalR hf Qiana huftftftditt8mtttnIftatiadiratm 1hat 29 miff Itive h In cold shutdown and refueling modes, operator concern is directed toward maintaining core cooling such as is discussed in Generic Letter 88-17, Loss of Decay Heat Removal. In power operation, hot standby, and hot shutdown modes, operator concern is primarily directed toward maintaining critical safety functions and thereby assuring fission product barrier integrity. Escalation of this event, if appropriate, woukf be by Fission Product Barrier Degradation, Abnormal Rad Releases/Radiological Effluent, or Shift 5ggmyhftf )Etttftfgtnlgy, Qgftfdittgfgr]4irector Judgement ICs. VNth respect to protection of the public and safe plant operations, plant control must focus primarily on the ability to maintain the reactor in a cooled condition. Therefore, it is appropriate to change the IC and EAL so that it emphasizes the need for core cooling when controlling the plant from outside the Control Room. anahunii vie. Q~r~n

4 Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S) R.E. Gjnna IC¹: HS3 Other conditions which In the Judgement of the Area Emergency. Qgf Qggyryggg ~gyp'ggZgggi~ ~~a warrant declaration of Site Op. Mode Appllcablllty HS3.4 Q f (pwr Ops) Q 2 (HS8) Q 3 (HSD) 0 4 (CSD) Q 5 (Refuel) Q 6 (Defuel) r All Other conditions which in the judgement of the Qhj55ggglYj2tf {EH19lgftlf.9?QLdHH1QQ Director warrant declaration of Site Area Emergency.

Plant Specific EAL uideline (A,H,S) R.E. Ginna Bases This EAL is intended to address unanticipated conditions not addressed explicitly elsewhere but that warrant decfaralion of an emergency because conditions exist which are believed by the gaff Qg~~ {fggtgttftgyggfttffjthttgQC4cocM to fall under the emergency class descriplion for Site Area Emergency.

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S) R.E. Glnna IC¹: HG1 Security event resuItlng In loss of ablllty to reach and malntaln cold shutdown. Op. Mode Appllcabfllty Q1 (Pwr Ops) Q 2 (HSB) Q3 (HSD) Q4 (CSD) Q5 (Refuel) Q 6 (Defuel) g All HG1.1 Loss of QB

       ~  physical control of ~r  the control room due to security event.

HG1.2 lum af ahnhal mdrul af Ihr rmrrtfh ~dana aaaabildx thrt h mtrrilx tirftrtL

Plant Specific EAL uideline (A,H,S) R.E. Glnna Bases ~un Mammer This IC encompasses conditions under which a hostile force has taken physical control of vital area required to reach and maintain sale shutdown. mf aminfain um t;ztfiag. Ihttrrtfrtrtt1hh E6L lm httta azdiM fa +hfdf a hm rtf allot mafral fount htfh fhtt azfud re ~ ggaggra httrtt Q fhtr ~ rtalf tluntftt ahufthttta rtaattLt. gf ftiilftrfrt

0 Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S) R.E. Glnna ICP'G2 Other condftfons exfstlng which In the Judgement of the General Emergency.

                                                                                           ~    ggggyJg~ ggprgggy 4Qroohe warrant decfaratfon of Op. Mode Appllcablllty             Q1(PwrOps) Q2(HSB) Q3(HSD) Q4(CSD) 95(Refuel) 96(Defuel) AAII HG2.1 Other conditions existing which in the judgement of the Q~rtjggttt) Director indicate: (t)
                                                        ~ ~~~tttttttftgtt actual or imminent substantial core degradation with potentialforlossofcontainment,or (2) potentialforuncontrolledradionuclide releases.

These releases can reasonably be expected to exceed EPA PAG plume exposure levels outside the site boundary.

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S) R.E. Gonna Bases This EAL is intended to address unanticipated conditions not addressed explicitly elsewhere but that warrant declaration of an emergency because conditions exist which are befleved by the cliffGlGEf~ {ErttftrgftfigyggttUfitg~ Qirectac to fall under the General Emergency.class.

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S) R.E. Glnna IC¹: SU1 Loss of all offsfte power to essential busses for greater than 15 ntfnutes. Op. Mode Appffcablflty 01(PwrOps) Q2(HSB) Q3(HSD) Q4(CSD) Q5(Refuel) Q6(Defuel) 5AII SU1.1 The folhwing conditions exist: ~i~~if r ~n

a. Loss of power to-(sit~pecfffc) 2a1ha huziliarx tumftrrmatr for grealer than 15 minutes.

b..AI least (site-specific) ~ ht rtmftrgrmf;y riittmtirrftrtttrftlgg JCIBIKQJEMJIIIIIKGIE

                                                                  ~ driftit(mfltlthfiogglar fry are-sv ppfyfng-poweW~rgency-buses

0 Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S)

                                                                                                                                                                                      'lant R.E. G)nna Bases Prolonged loss of ~      AC power  ~~      reduces required redundancy and potentially degrades the level of safety of the plant by rendering the plant more vulnerable to a complete toss of AC power (station bfackout). Fifteen minutes was selected as a threshold to exclude transient or momentary power fosses.

Plant Specific EAL Guideiine (A,H,S) R.E. Ginna fCttf: SU2 lnablllty to reach required shutdown within Technical Speclllcatlon ltmlts. Op. Mode Appllcablllty g1{Pwrops) g2{HSB) 3{HSD) Q4(CSD) Q5(Refuel) Q6(Deluel) QAll SU2.1 Plant is not brought to required operating mode within-{site-specific) Technical Specifications LCO Action Statement Time.

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S) R.E. Ginna L't'onditions ol Operation (LCOs) require the plant to be brought to a required shutdown mode when the Technical Specification required contiguration cannot be restored. Depending on the circumstances, this may or may not be an emergency or precursor to a more sever condition. ln any case, the initiation of plant shutdown required by the site Technical Specif'ication requires a one hour report under 10CFR50.72 (b) non.emergency events. The plant is within its safety envelope when being shut down within the allowable action statement time in the Technical Specifications. An immediate Notification of an Unusual Event is required when the plant is not brought to the required operating mode within the alhwable action statement time in the Technical Specifications. Declaration of an Unusual Event is based on the time at which the LCO-specified action statement time period elapses under the site Technical Specifications and s not re at to how tong a condition may have existed. Other required Technical Specification shutdowns that involve precursors to more serious events are addressed by other System malfunction Hazards, or Fission Product Barrier Degradation ICs.

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S) R.E. Glnna IC¹: SU3 Unplanned loss of most or all safety system annunciation or Indlcatlon In the control room for greater than 15 minutes. Op. Mode Appllcablllty 5 3 (PwrOps) g2(HSB) 53(HSD) 04(CSD) 05(Refuel) Q6(Deluel) QAII SU3.1 The following conditions exist:

a. Loss of for greater than 15 minutes.

AND

b. Compensation-aLurnfng~fons

c. ln the opinen of the Shift Supervisor, the loss of the annunciators or indicators requires increased surveillance to safely operate the unit(s).

AND

d. Annunciator or indicator loss does not result from planned action.

Plant Specific EAL uideline (A,H,S) R.E. Gjnna Bases This IC and its associated EAL are intended to recognize the difficulty associated wilh monitoring changing plant conditions without the use of a major portion of the annunciation or Indication equipment. Recognition of the availability of computer based indication equipment is considered (SPDS, plant computer, etc.) "Unplanned" loss of annunciators or indicator excludes scheduled maintenance and testing activities. specific plant design and subsequent retrofits. dadaraihn fIfaa hlmihaadfla ihhr lm.

~~

"Compensatory non.alarming indications: in this context incfudes computer based information such as SPDS . This should include all computer systems available for this use depending on h Shhd b II Bkll It is not intended that plant personnel perform a detailed count of instrumentation bst but iht use gf tfuucal~ judgement J~ ~ Qjff Qg~~ ~ i(tft threshold for determining the severity of the plant conditions. This judgement is supported by the specific opinion of the Shift Supervisor lhat additional operating personnel will be required to provide increased monitoring of system operation to safely operate the unit{s}. It is further recognized that most plant designs provide redundant safety system indication powered from separate uninterruptabfe power supplies. While failure of a large portion of annunciators is more likely than a failure of a large portion of indicalions, the concern is included in this EAL due to difficulty associated with assessment of plant conditions. The loss of specific, or several, safety system indicators should remain a function ol that specific system or component operability status. This will be addressed by their specific Technical Specification. The initiation of a Technical Specification imposed plant shutdown related to the instrument loss will be reported via tOCFR50.72. If the shutdown is not in compfiance with the Technical Specification action, the Unusual Event is based on SU2, Inability to Reach Required Shuldown Within Technical Specification Limits." (Sl~pocitic) Annunciators ~adicatoc for this EAL must include those identified in the Abnormal Operating procedures, in the Emergency Operating Procedures, and in other EALs (e. g., aret process, nnd/or effluent rad monitors, etc.). Fifteen minutes was selected as a threshold to exclude transient or momentary power losses. Oue to the limited number of safety systems in operation during cold shutdown, relueling, and defueled modes, no IC is indicated during these modes of operation. This Unusual Event will be escalated to an Alert if a transient is in progress during the loss ol annunciation or indication.

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S) R.E. Glnna fC¹: SU4- Fuel clad degradatfon. Op. Mode Appllcablflty Ql(PwrOps) Q2(HSB) Q3(HSD) Q4(CSD) Q5(Refuel) Q6(Defuel) QAII SU4.1 ~e-spesifis) lgltjgMtttLjlg ~ readings > 2 R/hr 4ndisatirt94trel-SU4.2 (Sit~pacific)-coofant sample activity TeshnisatSpesifisation-affevrabte-tirnits ~ gf jLflE~/

                                                                                   ~    uQilam dura tttumalttnt Li21 and 1ha matfjfiuna af Xaah. Buaa. X1&ham maaadmi

Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S)

                                                                                                                                                                                         'lant R.E. Glnna Bases This lC is included as an Unusual Event because it is considered to be a potential degradation in the level ol safety ol the plant and a potential precursor of more serious problems EAL   ¹~1 lttidmm  ~if attzitzrmiha i? EbQmbhhmrmuttttth itt1/ btttl hEz~mltzihtt Rxh.5m.azlaa1 zfhuir limihL EAL ¹5lL4,2 addresses coolant samples exceeding ittial ~tttdrtg ggglaaf ggfjyjiggzf coofant technical speciffcat fons                       Escalation of this lC to the Alert level fs via the <fssfon product barrier. degradation monitoring ICs.

BMttttm; 3. ?

   ~5am~~

E9 ZROQihtt SKifQIiQQBX%19QL

3. EEE 2355at;titan KK1h

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S) R.E. Glnn8 ICO: SU5 RCS leakage. Op. Mode Applicability 8 5 (PwrOps) g2(HSB) 83(MSD) Q4(CSD) Q5(Refuel) Q6(Defuel) QAII SU5.1 Either of the following conditions exist:

a. Unidentified or pressure boundary leakage greater than 10 gpm on

b. Identified Ieakage greater than 25 gpm.

Plant Specific EAL Guideline {A,H,S)

R.E. Glnna Th'C luded s an Unusual Event because it may be a precursor of more serious conditions and, as a result, is considered to be a potential degradation of the level of safety of the plant. The 10 gpm value for the unidentilied and pressure boundary'leakage was selected as it is observable with normal control room indications. Lesser values must generally be deter e mined throu g h time~nsuming surveillance test {e. g., mass balances). The EAL for identified leakage is set at a higher value due to the lesser significance of identified leakage ln comparison to unkfentified or pressure boundary leakage. fn either case, escalation of this IC to lhe Alert level is via Fission Product Barrier Degradation ICs or IC SA3, Inability to Maintain Plant In Cold Shutdown. Only operating modes in which there is fuel in the reactor coolant system and the system is pressurized are specified.

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S) R.E. Glnna fcff: SU6 Unplanned loss of all onslte or offslte communlcatlons capabllltles. Op. Mode Appllcablllty Q1(PwrOps) Q2(HSB) Q3(HSD) Q4(CSD) Q5(Refuel) Q6(Defuel) QAfl SU6.1 Either of the following conditions exist:

a. Loss of alf-(eft~mcifie-tiet) gg~rtilftyjng onsite communications capability affecting the ability to perform routine operations:

Ehnt Jttittnltttnfr mrttm; 1tuiddlurtt dial mtttrn. ilt1ttrfam nilh Bh mhm 2uutd rettrttrftd piruaa rtt trttlinummmuii miry rtuun 1@ uriah rtuun.a@la~in nt tltmaL attttiliatr huldintr andirtrttrtnttdiartrhdlditttr am1ud uzm ftt 1Mrhntt huildin

                    ~M matral rrtum 1lt EGA Enttrgx Qlutratittna     .

intel rlttun 1tt Enrttrrtttnt;y.kzmx Qmhr LBadia1hn Elan tutfd h Ha' OR Mi'a SHE

b. Loss of atlgeite~peeifie-tiet)

ElmimHaimh Ehnl 1ttla~rrtr 2511Lrn'tut~h gfghLl~lvyji~oflsite communications capability:

                                      ~i 2x@QE l8KRI Emttraarzx HaliTha1ian Guam LEttr camtnuaicalintt m1h HBGl Ehlhuad ala1hnr.

matud rtuun 1ttdrtun BRkE Lim Qtutlatttr IGG. Emttrtrttnt;tr Suuuur. Gmhr attd Smrh QEm mitb malkh ratkhta

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S) R.E. Gfnna Bases The purpose of this IC and its associated EALs is to recognize a loss of communications capability that either defeats the plant operations staff ability to perform routine tasks nece ssa ry for plant operations or the ability to communicate problems with offsite authorities. The loss of offsite communications ability is expected to be significantly more comprehensive than the condition addressed by 10CFR50.72. Ih "' radios/walkie talkies). B ""i'nd dedicated EPP phone systems. This EAL is intended to be used only when extraordinary means are being utilized to make communications possible (refaying of information from radio transmissions, individuals being sent to offsite locations, etc.).

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S) R.E. Gonna IC¹: SU7 Unplanned toss of required DC power during cold shutdown or refueling mode for greater than 15 minutes. r Op. Mode Applicability Q1(pwrOps) Q2(HSB) Q3(HSD) 54(CSD) g5(Refuel) Q6(Defuel) QAII SU7.1 Either ~ of lhe following conditions exist:

a. Unplanned loss of vital DC power to required DC busses based on-~e-specific) ~(,'~g bus voltage rndications AND

b. Failure to restore power to at least one required DC bus within 15 minutes from the time of loss.

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S) R.E. Glnna The purpose of this IC and its associated EALs is to recognizee a loss of pC powe ss o power co compromising the ability to monitor and control the removal of decay heat during cold shuldown or refueling operations. This EAL is intended to be anticipatory in as much as the operating crew may not have necessafy indication and contro o equipmen nee e o Unplanned is included in lhis IC and EAL to preclude l e declaration lude the of an emergency ec aration o erne e ass a result of planned maintenance activities. Routinely plants will perform maintenance on a train related basis during shutdown periods. It is intended that the loss of the operating (operable) trainis to be considere d.. If t h'is oss resu Its in thee ina inabiiiity to maintain cold shutdown, the escalation to an will be per SA3 "Inability to Maintain Plant in Cold Shutdown." i'lert bus volta e st~hfbag based on the minimum bus voltage necessary for the operation ol safety related equipment. This voltage valve should incorporate a margin of at eas 15 minutes least mi of operation before the onset of inability to operate t h ose Ioa d s.. Th't 'ally is vo age is us near the minimum voltage selected whenbattery sizing js performed. Typically the valur for the entire battery set is approximately 105 volts per cell. For a 56 string battery set the minimum voltage is typically I.81 volts per cell. ~QQ-Q JQRLrrIEQf Qll2 KHfQg P565K QQfQIII"

0 S Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S) R.E. Glnna IC¹: SA1 Loss of all offslte power and loss of all onslte AC power to essential busses during cold shutdown or refuelfng mode. Op. Mode Applfcabfffty Q1(PwrOps) Q2(HSB) 03(HSD) 54(CSD} ~ 5(Refuel} 06(Defvef) QAff SA1.1 The following conditions exist:

a. Loss of power to-(sit~~Tie):

Gialhn huiTiian Iramhrtnar 1KB, QQjhQ~tQE ~rn Qrrf ~ AND

b. Failure of (cite~celtic)-~ ~ftttflgy ~

               ! &! l!!I!I !!!IM!!u!I!!U!!!!

K arewuppfying power-to emergency buses, AND

c. Failure to restore power to busses ~ gQQ JjQ QQ ~+QQ ~Meac&ne.

emergency-bus within 15 minutes from the time of loss of both offsite and onsite AC power.

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S) R.E. Glnna Bases Loss of all AC'power compromises all plan't safety systems requiring electric power including RHR, ECCS, containment heat removal, Spent Fuel Heat Removal and the Ultimate Heat Sfnk. Wher in cold shutdown, refueling, or defueled mode the event can be cfassified as an Alert, because of the significantfy reduced decay heat, lower temperature and pressure, increasing the time to Effluent, or ~ restore one of the emergency busses, relative to that specified for the Site Area Emergency EAL. Escalating to the Site Area Emergency, if appropriate, is by Abnormal Rad Levels/Radiofogica

                +ftf,~i{~m~rggyQftttt~ggQChcoct~ Judgement ICs. Fifteen minutes was selected as a threshold to exclude transient or momentary power fosses.

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S) R.E. Gtnna IC¹: SA2 Failure of Reactor Protection system lnstrumentatlon to complete or Inltlate an automatic reactoreemw Protection system setpolnt has been exceeded and/}Z manual~~ flfg was not successful.

                                                                                                                                          ~ once a Reactor Op. Mode Appllcablllty                       51(Pwrops) g2(HSB) Q3(HSD) Q4(CSD) Q5(Refuel) Q6{Defuel) QAII SA2.1 (SQo~ffo)-

exceeded'-automat'B85GE ur BKuatb in HU 5ubuifiaaiitr Rld Emmuuuz fhra1iun h.mauintli

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S) R.E. Glnna Bases Ibh M. addrttaaftaaatr manual ffjQ Qr autQtmtiQ trtnaigaat JQ!hnmfhy.a manual JLJQrdthhfaihiQabuidQttfa lharftaQtQL luanattlanirttftuirtalr amftrltItaQlrhQratiQa. This condition indicates failure of the automatic ggggZ gZggtf protection syslem to ffjQsccaa the reactor 1Q fba attfftal lttbiQb QrftQturffta Jhft LttaQiQL httnQ mada au~tttQat. This condition is more than a potential degradation of a safety system in that a front line automatic protection system did not function in response to a plant transient and thus the plant safety has been compromised, and design limits of the fuel may have been exceeded. An Alert is indicated because conditions exist that lead to potential hss of fuel clad or RCS. A manual laQ~ is any set of actions by the reactor operator(s) at the reactor control console which causes control rods to be rapidly fnserted into the core and brings the reactor subcritical (e. g., reactor trip button). Ihh Emt rmdfjaQ M. fmzahtftnaattQtfiQaLv mQdjthd tQmQLaaQuraIah dftIjnalbft QQLtdittQndftaQahftdhy.ihtt ftnftfjQ baal aamfhd JQ QlftmrizmfmhrLaaQtQLa. It@ failura Qf auJQLM+ tntttatiQn Qf a lftaQtQL fnQ fQttlrtrffd Jtlr auQQftaafut manual ia~iian ~i tfdttQh Qan hr LaQtdttr fatrttn al Jba LttaQtQL QQntLQJ QQflaQftt dQfta nQt Qua a QQtftatiat JQaa Qf Ltithftrfuftt Qtad Qr le hQur~i Jl ja lbft QQnlinuad uiilQatiItLuadar QQadtiiQna LttauLrrg a OtaQlQL aQram ltthkh QQm. lha QQfftattat thraat tQ LK Qr fuai Qtad Jatftgrtttr. Jt an QBBHGR uath mhh Qa EKi. QE11GhLllz aflm JtntnartIaltt ailmN JQ lrta iha LaaQ1QL hata httta lalrtta. lhartt haa hatta a faitura la abul damn iba otaQiQL. hul lmttbQui auhaiaaiIat baal rtanttralIQa. Jf a BEJ2aath mhh Qa E9J.Q3lTIQBLJDaftziatmadiataattffalQh JQiriQ Jhft LftaQJQL Jia~tft ttafta 1ahm. 1bftrft haahtana faituralQ shul dQt~tn tht rftaQ1QL. nith adtalaattaf httal QanttlattQn. Qhm Qf thftafrQQndittQna IL BQrfMnt a QQlttattat 852 Ql fbft t!Nt Qtad JtQuadaK, aad thud arrant a dftQtarattQa Qf kKBL 6 manual JLIQ h aox KlQf aQitQaa Jty.i!E LQKtQLQQftratQLJal al Jhft EaQ1QL QQntLQJ QQlliQJR 1Q itiialftan iriQ dQaa nQi tafK aQhat Ql QQ18i~ atiuQLt5 Qf Qlhttr Ratlftma nQL ia d in aad Qf ~

       ~u QQntrQJ LQdk 12 ha Laaii ta2trittd intQ JAR QQLa aad ~r llKKKiK2lttKtIQalLLQ LftaQ1QL Lrin JtutlQn). Jt Ja JmQQLlaal 1Q aQlft lhal lhk Jaitulft Qf 1ba EKtQL QLQJKliQn al51ftm auld                                                                                                     a QraQuraQL 1Q fhmQa QLQdKJ hatnftr dftaitafjatiQa. JJlft Qf'Q afgYta nQ Qlhttl aatttbr fuaQttQn hut 1Q iailiata LftaclQL itic. ItltIrttfQrtt.QaQa lha LgaQlQL haa hafta mzttmtttr lrtQQmf.aaiturfta inlba EERattalftmQaa haraaQQtaal aatftltt ifauaat. JtimmafHatamanual ufhmiQ iriu ibft LftaaiQL mitt axftuht JQllatttiatt mugailiaa Qf an auiuataitQ lrirtfailura. lhara h nQ lbraal JQ ailhar Qtaal aafaltr QL fhaian umbel Jalttltrtttr tttatttd 1Q lha autaaurttQ iuu faiturL Ibh dfallattQn h QQLiahlttal milb lba QbjtQaiaby. Qf mahaQ aQQurala lra. QQtlattntalittft QtmifiQaliQaa.

Qgfg~rn Qa;

1. BLLNhQriliQ ttiiy"

2. EER1 J3ttaQQaaft JQ EhtaQiQLEb@laalh2MF

3. EM2 ZmQQnaa 1Q bm Qf Bura miuldana"

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S) R.E. Glnna IC¹: SA3 fnablllty to maintain plant In cold shutdown. Op. Mode Appllcablllty Qt (PwrOps) p2(HSB) Q3(HSD) 54{CSD) 55(Refuel) Q6(Defuel) QAII SA3.4 The following conditions exist: a-lass-rA )site-specifio) shutdown. b.

 ~
   ~~       ~

Exceeds 200 OR temperature increase that either:

                 'F cold-shutdowMemperature-limit-Teohnica&pecification
 ~ Results in uncontrolled temperature rise approaching 200 'F cold shutdown-temperature.

limit-teohnioaLspesittoation.

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S) R.E. Gfnna Bases Abnormal Rad Levels/Radiological Effluent or ~ ~imfL This EAL addresses complete loss of functions required for core cooling during refueling and cold shutdown modes. Escalation to Site Area Emergency or General Emergency would be via gfaftfgftagy g~gaafgQ Qicoc4oc Judgement ICs. For PWRs, this IC and its associated EAL are based on concerns raised by Generic Letter 88-17, "Loss of Decay Heat Removal. A number of phenomena such as pressurization, vortexing, steam generator U-tube draining, RCS level differences when operating at a mid-loop condition, decay heat removal system design, and level instrumentation problems can lead to conditions where decay heat removal is lost and core uncovery can occur. NRC analyses show that sequences that can cause core uncovery in l5 to 20 minutes and severe core damage within an hour atter decay heat removal is lost. Under these conditions, RCS integrity is lost and fuel clad integrity is lost or potentially lost, which is consistent with a Site Area Emergency. ~~pec~ indicators for these EALs are those methods used by the plant in response to Generic Letter 88-f 7 which include core exit temperature monitoring and RCS water level moniloring. In addition, radiation monitor readings may also be appropriate as an indicator of this condition. "Uncontrolled" means that system temperature increase is not the result of planned actions by the planl staff. The EAL guidance related to uncontrolled temperature rise is necessary to preserve the anticipatory philosophy of NUREG.0654 for events starling from temperatures much lower than the cold shutdown temperature limit. Escalation to the Site Area Emergency is by IC SS5, Loss of Water Level in the Reactor Vessel that has or will Uncover Fuel in the Reactor Vessef," or by Abnormal Rad Levels/Radiological Effluent ICs. Qiana h a mugs uai1 aim. ~fr gag.

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S) R.E. Ginna IC¹: SA4 Unplanned loss of most or all safety system annunclatlon or Indlcatlon In control room with either {1) a slgnlf leant transient In progress, or {2) compensatory non-alarming Indicators are unavailable. Op. Mode Applicability 51(PwrOps) g2(HSB) 53(HSD) Q4(CSD) Q5{Refuel) Q6{Defuel) QAII SA4.1 The tollowing conditions exist:

a. Loss of most or a~~peeTiie) annunciators Baatti2aa for greater than f5 minutes.

AND

b. In the opinion of the Shifl Supervisor, the loss of the annunciators or indicators requires increased surveillance to safety operate the unit{a).

AND

c. Annunciator or indicator loss does not result from planned action.

AND

d. Either of the following;

 ~ A signilicant plant transient is in progress OR
 ~ Compensatory-non-alarming-Indicatfone        REQ5, gh5, are Is unavailable.

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S) R.E. Glnna Bases This IC and its associated EAL are intended to recognize the difficulty associated with monitoring changing plant conditions without the use of a major portion of the annunciation or Indication equipment during a transient. Recognition of the availability of computer based indication equipment is considered (SPDS, p'lant computer, etc.). Planned" loss of annunciators or indicators included scheduled maintenance and testing activities. lt is not intended that plant personnel perform a detailed count of the instrumentation lost but ~ use gj t~~ judgement jt)f)hft 555ggzhgL ga)hft threshold for determining the severity of the plant conditions. This judgement is supported by the specific opinion of the Shift Supervisor that additional operating personnel will be required to provide increased monitoring of system operation to safely operate the unit(s). lt is further recognized that most plant designs provide redundant safety system indication powered from separate uninterruptable power supplies. White failure of a large portion of annunciators is more likely lhan a failure ol a large portion of indications, the concern is included in this EAL due to difficulty associated with assessment of plant conditions. The loss of specific, or several, safety system indicators shoukl remain a function of that specific system or component operability status. This will be addressed by the specific Technical Specification. The initiation of a Technical Specification imposed plant shutdown related to the instrument loss will be reporled via 10CFR50.72. If the shutdown is not in compliance with the Technical Specification action, the Unusual Event is based on SU2 "Inability to Reach Required Shutdown Within Technical Specilicalion Limits. (Sf~c'wc) Qnnunciators ~nc4catore for this EAL must include those identified in the Abnormal Operating Procedures, in the Emergency Operating Procedures, and in other EALs (e. g., area, process, and/or effluent rad monitors, etc.). Significant Transient" includes response to automatic or manually initiated functions such as scrams, runbacks involving greater than 25'lo thermal power change, ECCS injections, or thermal power oscillations of 10% or greater. "Compensatory non-alarming indications" in this context includes computer based information such as SPDS. This should Include all computer systems available for this use depending on specific plant design and subsequenl retrofits. If both a major portion ot the annunciation system and all computer monitoring are unavailable to the extent that the additional operating personnel are required to monitor indications, the Alert is required. Due to the limited number of safety systems in operation during cold shutdown, refueling and defueled modes. No IC is indicated during these modes of operation. This Alert will be escalated to a Site Area Emergency if the operating crew cannot monitor, the transient in progress.

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S} R.E. Glnna Ic¹: SA5 AC power capablllty to essential busses reduced to a sIngle power source for greater than 15 rnlnutes such that any addltlonal single failure would result In station blackout. Op. Mode Applicability 51 (Pwr Ops) g 2 (HSB) ~ 3 (HSD) Q 4 (CSD) Q 5 (Refuel) Q 6 (Defuel) Q AII SA5.1 Ttre4ottowing-condone-sxfst for-greater lhan-t5 minutes: AND froma~teonsi~wer-sour (sitewpecific-list): KGB XDGEB Rahm hmilizxIrmhrmftt Rag~a hu~i~nhum 129

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S) R.E. Ginna BaSeS This IC and the associated EALs are intended to provide an escalation from IC SU1 "Loss of All Offsite Power to Essential Busses for Greater than 15 Minutes." The condition indicated by this IC is the degradation of the offsite power with a concurrent failure of one emergency generator to supply power to its emergency busses. Another related condition could be the bss of all offsite power and loss of onsite emergency diesels with only one train of emergency busses beingkacMed from the unit main generator, or the bss of onsite emergency diesels with only one train of emergency busses being backfed from offsite power. The subsequent bss of this single power source would escalate the event to a Site Area Emergency in accordance with IC SS1 "Loss of Al Offsite and Loss of All Onsite AC Power to Essential Busses." Example EAL ¹~tb should be expanded to identify the conlrol room indication of the status gf offsite.specific power sources and distribution busses that, if unavailable, establish a single failure vulnerability.

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S) R.E. Ginna IC¹: SS1 Loss of all offslte power and loss of all onslte AC power to essential busses. Op. Mode Applicability 51(PwrOps) 52(HSB) g3(HSD) Q4{CSD) Q5{Retuel) Q6(Deluel) QAII SS1.1 The following conditions exist:

a. Loss of power to-(site-specific):

Bairn huxiliarx Iraaafatrmftr 12k QBfhQ AND

        ~i.rlXJEK5 fkrrr        ~

b. Failure of/site-specific)

I ~gency-generators-ar~ppfyfng-power-to emergency-buses: AND

c. Failure to restore power to at feast~e emergency bus within 15 minutes from the time of loss of both offsite and onsite AC power.

plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S) R.E. Gonna Bases Loss of all AC power compromises all plant safety systems requiring electric power Prolonged toss of all AC power wiii cause core uncovering and loss of containment integrity, thus this event can escalate to a General Emergency. momentary power losses, but should not exceed 15 minutes. 7h~~~ time duration should be seleded to exdude transient or

Plant Specific EAL GUideline (A,H,S) R.E. Glnna IC¹: SS2 Op. Mode Protection system setpolnt has been exceeded andLgE manual+mm ling was not successful, ~ Failure of Reactor Protection system lnstrumentatlon to compfete or fnftfate an automatfc reactoreerara~ once a Reactor 5 ibRKa pgyEf:E gglarailug. Appllcablllty 51(PwrOps) Q2(HSB) Q3(HSD) Q4(CSD) Q5(Refuel) Q6(Defuel) QAII SS2.1 6K C Ml~ cif~ica&u~xeW hHD rrifhtr; Emargrtncx brtrafhnh innnftrafhta QR Bmr mm nrtt sPl nhbin 15min.rti inifhthndmmrgfrntnrbzalhn

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S) R.E. Ginna box h$ 2

Bases Ihhmndjtjan add!Lmz frjn rtr automat!l; trjn agnat ttttttttxftdhx a manual 1!h Httadftr @mr ~5la

                                                                       ~    taih tlr abut dttxm ftta rftat;fttr.

Automatic and manual scram are not considered successful if action away from the reactor control console was required to scram the reactor BK r~ jnAiafjgn fn dftf;mm hthxr Pkhthnirtlr arab@ frj!t. Ibh rtffhn rtt fhr Khl addrftma anx manual frjrtar

QKSIR8zritiualitx = fafb h.mtfftutdhaad itn taitu!a rtt atxrftr aufu!natty fr@ mgnaththxrftdhxx manua! 1!junlxb taih @abut dftxrn fhftrmht fu anatffrtnf ihaf ihftrmfftrharttdmttfr mltrahtafhad tz nhhh fhfr mhhrauffnna~dammd. fit Ibh gggdjfiln jndjuafaa ~i gt ftgfb fht aufttmgfjg and manuat!t!rtfai mtafftma fear fort fhfr rftagfgr jn ~iungftgnxrifb a tahra gi at fftrnafa +rafjrtnaxafftma+ rfrduga rftagfgr 1!atrtxr dmv.htat tttxtth. Iha aunhnatjan rtt taitura ftt htfb trtt!tttjntt and huJmu urrtfttt;fjgnaxafa!na ftriundj!tn in cmartnaft ttt a a!ant fran.'fatti. ahrtrt xttfb fhtt matjnuftd uruduafhn rtt baai I!mfa a dimt Ibmat tn tuel dad and BGR jntagrjtx and Qm xrarntnh dttt:taratjttn ut a 2h intra Fmftrrttntm. fbaf ~eieengx b~ri n ~ nttf rtr yQiI nrtf Q!tttttf;~i jg!ftdu~ ~ 15mjnufmh mtgjttftd flr ahxr fjma tttr rime!lrftnn,flat!afjgn frt fta atbrt;fjxa and rtrgxtdaaadtazimjnafttr htbxftftn RKi and 552J. Iba gtauitjgaflftn abrtutd ha mada

                                                                             ~w ~1 aa atttn arith auftarftnf Although this lC may be viewed as redundant to the Fission Product Barrier Degradation IC, its inclusion is necessary to better assure timely recognition and emergency response.          Escalation of this event to a General Emergency would be via Fission Product Barrier Degradation or mjtf Qilrta!Xialtr LEE!~+       QQg!fjlg1gQOirectoc Judgement ICs.

2 HLi~critiaalitx.

2. Efhkl Shan:eh Bltat;tttr Hm1adSMF

2. EM2 J3mrtnm fi lm ttf fax Gbutdftxt!L

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S) R.E. Glnna IC¹: SS3 Loss of all vital DC power. Op. Mode Applicability S1 {PwrOps) g2{HSB) 53(HSD) 04(CSD) Q5(Refuel) Q6(Defuel) gp,il SS3.1 Loss of ail vital DC power based oafeit~peeifie)-<~~ff; bus g~gftftfi~tt~for greater than 15 minutes. vottage indications ~

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S) R.E. Glnna Bases Loss of all DC power compromises ability to monitor and control pfant safety functions. Prolonged toss of all OC power will cause core uncovering and toss ot containment integrity when there ls significant decay heat and sensible heat in the reactor system. Escalation to a General Emergency would occur by Abnormal Rad Levels/Radiological Etlluent, Fission Product Barrier Degradation, or motif ggg~ iEIDttfgfttt~gggggggigLiC4rector Judgement ICs. Fifteen minutes was selected as a threshold to exclude transient or momentary power hsses. Qiana fhfmam ha ~ un'iia.

j. BGk2 Jn~tttt Eumf 1KB'ruel'~

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S) R.E. Glnna IC¹: SS4 Complete loss of function needed to achfeve or malntaln hot shutdown. Op. Mode Applfcabfllty Q1(PwrOps) g2{HSB) W3(HSD) Q4{CSD) QS(Refuel) Q6(Deluel) QAII SS4.1 Complete loss of any~te-epeeifie) function required for hot shutdown aaihz BB.HKRK

                                                                    ~ jgjgglftffQ ~

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S) R.E. Ginna BaSeS This EAL addresses complete loss of functions, including ultimate heat sink and reactivity control, required for hot shutdown with the reactor at pressure and temperature. Under these conditions, there is an actual major failure of a system intended for protection of the public. Thus, declaration of a Site Area Emergency is warranted. Escalation to a General Emergency would occur by Abnormal Rad Levels/Radiological Effluent, Fission product Barrier Degradation, or mtift ~~ur LErnrttgftnuy gggrrjjnatrrrt t4cectce Judgement lCs. Lm rtf mbuithatjtr h umtrrtrrtr1 at thrt Rh hm Ernrtrgruuz trtutt hx Ehl 55? law rtt mhm tuncfizm rmirrtrftu roajntain hrtt @utrhm mudd rrtmrjt in a BEt2 eath mt thrt HHISHKQKR

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S} R.E. Ginna IC¹: SS5 Loss of BPV water level that has or will uncover fuel In the ~ Op. Mode Applicability Qt (Pwr Ops) Q2 (HSB) Q3 (HSD) Q4 (CSD) Q5 (Refuel) Q6 (Defuel) +All SS5.1 Loss of RPV ~~ water level as indicated by: AND

b. (Site-ep LnhQiit~i ~ '

ht IIlitiltghEQ ~~ ' tlhtilh ihtt 5jih E? QgJR ogolt!IIg

                                                                                 ~ jg1ggf, fQQJQ 5i1h It@ Bmiltr Xemd hmf rttritttymt. i1hrttrtltrfmfthat uaittr itttttd iIIit@ fhmtJrtr Zmal h rfrmILiiitritimirttmaizEmf mrzm mf um IIIIImux h lhth.

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S) 0 R.E. Gfnna Bases Under the conditions specified by this IC, severe core damage can occur and reactor coolant system pressure boundary integrity may not be assured. hertha For PWRs. this IC covers sequences such as prolonged boiling foilowing loss of decay heat removal. Unaa~rftnr af thft fufdiumaftatbrft af tha rntftnt that mam fufd urzmry iaimiifim1iuaahna farktahtimr a Shhma Rnftraffne. Snmathftr mnhaaufffhad,tafufdunaatrftuinadff Atutffayrn ar rfdufd athftr iban aRm af dmxhhtt rfunaml uuahiMit h iaaaaraariatfr ta EBL an ihh anft mnt. Ear athftr aaftnrtina mmtm. fufdunaumx ha hm af 1ht Eufd Gad md fKS hamiumhhh rftauim.rfuJzatian af @ 2'm Krmmtftnm. Thus, declaration of a Site Area Emergency is warranted under the conditions specified by the lC. Escalation to a General Emergency is via radiological effluence lC AG$ . HfLffr

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S) R.E. Ginoa IC¹: SS6 Inability to rnonltor a slgnlf leant transient In progress. Op. Mode Appllcabilfty 51(PwrOps) 2(HSB) g3(HSD) Q4(CSD) QS(Refuel) Q6(Defuel) QAII SS6.1 AII of the following conditions exist:

a. Loss of +sit~~tie) annunciators ftr, iafjgtittfa

                                                                          'n ssociate@wit  uafet~ystems-b.

AND Compensatory-non-alarming~fons AND

                                              ~       aaff ~ are-is unavailable.

c. Indications needed to monitor-(site-specific) ftaafttfrtfttagf f II 'n I n r m r safety-functions are unavailabie:

E~ KE ~ Ehactar Iniftuaadiafa raga Baurm Hara aumh. &arm Haaga ZIKBura in4zku al EKEa uutftiog. ELLLi.BGR Bmttfft.BQSBalLGaldLftg Imnmaiura. 59 ggftfa~aftf ~iign AND

~~

Harum Efanga hqL HM Ehn.GGPrmttra QmiaiMtaai Bmm. QuaiaiftmftfIILfttfftL

d. Transient in progress.

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S) R.E. Glnna

                                                                                                                                                                                            'his IC and its associate EAL are intended to recognize the inability of the control room staff to monitor the plant response to a transient. A Site Area Emergency is considered to exist if the control room staff cannot monitor safety functions needed for protection of the public.

Annunciators for this EAL should be limited to include those identified in the Abnormal Operating Procedures, in the Emergency Operating Procedures, and in other EALs (e. g., rad monitors, etc.). Compensatory non-afarming indications in this context includes computer based information such as SPDS. This should include all computer systems available for this use depending on specific plant design and subsequent retrofits. Significant Transient" includes response to automatic or manually initiated functions such as scrams, runbacks involving greater than 25% thermal power change, ECCS injections, or thermal power osciilations of 10% or greater. Pi~iffc) Indications needed to monitor safety functions necessary for protection of the public must include control room indications, computer generated indications and dedicated annunciation capability. The specific indications should be those used to determine such functions as the ability to shut down the reactor, maintain the core cooled and in a eoolable geometry, to remove heat horn the core, to maintain the reactor coolant system intact, and to maintain containment intact. "Planned actions are excluded from this EAL since the loss of instrumentation of this magnitude is of such significance during a transient that the cause of the loss is not an ameliorating factor. ~Rfer~ne,

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S} R.E. Glnna IC¹: SG1 Prolonged loss of all offslte power and prolonged loss of all onslte AC power. Op. Mode Applfcabfffty 81(PwrOps) g2(HSB) Q3(HSD) Q4(CSD) Q5(Refuel) Q6(Defuel) DAII SG1.1 Prolonged loss of afl offsite and onsite AC power as indicated by:

a. Loss of power to imfhgsit~fis):

Sativa httttiliaxItmfarmftrihh

      =   Ratho hmTiau Xramhrmftr 32B

b. Failure of-(site-spec fffe) emergency buses,

c. At teast one of the following conditions exist:

        ~ Restoration of g

tttttttL at least one ~~@ emergency bus within fsft~peeffue) g hours is not fikefy K fndfsat~ Lctualur immimtftiftftlof.hhQH~N ar BED aalb m Ea2.XQBEQRQL59

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S} R.E. Ginna Bases Loss of all AC power compromfses ait plant safety systems requlrlng electrfc power Including RHR, ECCS, Containment Heat Removal and the Ultimate Heat Sink. Probnged bss ot all AC power will lead to bss of fuel clad, RCS, and containment. The g hours to restore AC power can be based on site blackout coping analysis performed ln conformance with 10CFR50.63 and Regulatory Guide 1.155, "Station Blackout", as available, with appropriate allowance for offsite emergency response. Although this IC may be viewed as redundant to the Fissbn Product Barrier Oegradation IC, its inclusion is necessary to better assure timely recognition and emergency response. This IC is specified to assure that in the unlikely event of probnged station blackout, timely recognition of the seriousness of the event occurs and that dectaralion of a General Emergency occurs as early as is appropriate, based on a reasonable assessment of the event trajectory. The Ii7celihood ot restoring at feast one emergency bus should be based on a realistic appraisal of the situalion since a delay in an upgrade decision based on only a chance of mitigating the event coukf result in a loss ot valuable time in preparing and implementing public protective actions. In addition, under these conditions, fission product barrier monitoring capability may be degraded. Although it may be dNicult to predict when power can be restored, it is necessary to give the Emergency Director a reasonable idea of how quickly (s)he may need to declare a General Emergency based on two major considerations:

1. Are there any present indications that core cooling is afready degraded to the point that Loss or Potential Loss of tissr'on product barriers is imminent? (

hfauuatia+

2. If there are no present indications of such core cooling degradation, how likely is it that power can be restored in time to assure that a loss of two barriers with a potential loss of the third barrier can be prevented?

Thus, indication of continuing core cooling degradation must be based on fission product barrier monitoring with particular emphasis on gag Qgg~gg (EtftftrfmgyQfmfdjmlgQOirocfar judgement as it relates to imminent loss or potential loss of fission product barriers and degraded ability to monitor hssion product barriers. EIftfermx9; 1 EK2. XQBE QQQLEU

2. SK h1tm @ Dr. Mmmh fhIItfj3PM2 M Ging Rabat Bmc Plant Raihn Blast hnahm EK bKBB9l

2. HERG31KV Ehgriml DhlribtlfimGnffUIL igfL

Piant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S) R.E. Glnna 1C¹: SG2 Failure of the Reactor Protection System to complete an automatic scram and manual scram was not successful and there ls Indlcatlon of an extreme challenge to the ablllty to cool the core. Op. Mode Appllcabfffty g1(PwrOps) Q2(HS8) Q3(HSD) Q4(CSD) Q5(Refuel) Q6{Defuel) QAII SG2.1

2. Either oi the following ~ ~ lenin < ~r egg ~

BED aa1h m Ljm QKGIHh2. ~92QUHG

b. -(sit BED ml m&QKGIafHLtHEhI2tK

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (A,H,S) R.E. Gonna Bases Automatic and manual scram are not considered sucessful it action away from the reactor control console is required to scram the reactor Under the conditions of this IC and its associated EALs, the efforts to bring the reactor subcritical have been unsuccessful and, as a result, the reactor is producing more heat load for which the catha safety systems were designed. Although there are capabilities away from the reactor control console, such as emergency boration in PWRs the continuing

                                                                                                                                        ~~gritlgaiity                          antarad~

i'r temperature rise indicates that these capabilities are not effective. This situation could be the precursor for a core melt sequence. af ulnar ranga indrathnirt dar.raaaa haRm Rk hi!axing a cauda iriL Zbh uarIRtn af iha EK addrftaaaa am'anual

                                                                                                                                                                 - QQQ gathia aufrtmatia trip aignal hlhnadhlr a manual 1thmhiahfaihinahut drntiha rmchrig an affiant that tharmhr ia airtdmng mgrahaatlltadbr ntxh tha~alratftmaltrarftdaairtnad. IhlaauufhhnhuRataafaituLa gfhgth thaautrlmatig andmanual gn fggrg arutat;tea  zr:~     tn tria tharmhir inartniun@Rtn            lailurartl altarnata bzathn alfatftma h.rmhmamiur      amr    haRIn dmxhaat lfnrah.

For PWRs, the extreme challenge to the ability to cool the core is intended to mean that the core exit temperatures are at or approaching 1200 'F or that the reactor vessel water level is below th top of active fuel. For plants using CSFSTs, this EAL equates to a Core Cooling RED condition. Another consideration is the inability to initially remove heat during the early stages of this sequence. For PWRs, if emergency feedwater flow is insufficient to remove the amount of heat required by design from at least one steam geneator, an extreme challange shoul be considered to exist. For plants using CSFSTs, this equates to a HEAT Sink RED condition. FocSWQc

In the event either of these challenges exist at a time that the reactor has not been brought below the power associated with the safety system design ttypically 3 to 5% power) a core melt sequence exists. In this situation, core dedaration can occur rapidly. For this reason, the General Emergency declaration is intended to be anticipatory of the fission product barrier matrix declaration to permit maximum offsite intervention time. Eh humor. all ? HL? GQEtEQQQLIKG:

3. ER2 MhIGRK 6 EELS% Khaitgnaa h? HaaaULr Eha~2MS

        'rm2rtn~gf ~r~g~

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (FPB) R.E. Glnna PWR FPB IC¹: FC1 Barrier: Fuel Claddin Type: Pot ntial Loss

== Description:== Critical Safety Function Status FC1.2 Cccacootiag-ORANGE ~ ~ ~~ thtlb jg QQQ~Q FC1.3 Coracootiog- RED path in F-0.3, HEAT SINK Bases: Core Cooling - ORANGE indicates subcooling has been lost and that some clad damage may occur. Heat Sink - RED indicates the ultimate heat sink function is under extreme challenge and thus these two items indicate potential loss of the fuel clad barrier. Ehhmxe;

i. QKGIHh?. QmQ~t~tlLIg. Emhhn2

2. QKSI HL3. Hmt Hah Euhhn 2

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (FPB) R.E. Ginna PmfR FPB ICftt: FC2 Barrier: Fuel Ciaddin Type: Loss

== Description:== Primary Coolant Activity Level FC2.1 Coolant activity greater than Bases: This ~~cit+ value corresponds to 300 trCi/cc l-t3t equivalent. Assessment by the NUMARC EAL Task Force indicates that this amount ol coolant activity

                                                                                                                                                              'here is no equivalent "Potential Loss" EAL tor this item.

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (FPB) R.E. Gtnna PWR FPB ICg: FC3 Barrier: Fuel Cfaddin Type: Loss Descrfptlort: Core Exit Thermocoupfe Readings FC3.1 Greater tha~te-spec~ Jgggg Bases: The "Loss" EA+sfto.specie reading should correspond to significant superheating ol Ihe coolant. This value 'typically corresponds to the temperature reading that indicates core cooling-RED in fuel clad barrier EAL ¹ 1 which is usually about 1200 'F. Eh'!Jm;

1. QKSI HL2.9m Qauliffg. Bftfd.~2 P EB=Q 1 Meaftffmh lmhauutft QaCe QftfttfiLBazh!ftft Z

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (FPB) R.E. Gonna PWR FPB tC¹: FC3 Barrier: Fuel Claddin Type: Potential Los

== Description:== Core Exit Thermocouple Readings FC3.2 Greater than4si~poci~ jggg Bases: The "Potential Loss" EAL~~ecitfc) reading should correspond to loss of subcooiing. This vafue typicaiiy corresponds to the temperature reading that indicates core coofing - ORANGE i fuel cfad barrier EAL fr 1 which is usuaHy about 700 to 900 'F. 5gh; Ibh uud5gn 5 g Zlhg1 ttf QKGIHKRQQBE QQQL59

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (FPB) R.E. Glnna PWR FPB fC¹: FC4 Barrier: Fuel Claddin Type: Potentfal Loss Descrlptlon: Reactor Vessel Water Level FC4.1 RVLIS <43% wl no RCPs running (46% adverse containment) Bases: There is no Loss" EAL corresponding to this item because it is better covered by the other fuel clad barrier Loss EALs. The~~ocific) value for the Potential Loss EAL corresponds to the top of the active fuel. For sites using CSFSTs, the "Potential Loss" EAL is defined by the Core Cooling - ORANGE path. The~~pocific) value in this EAL should be consistent with Ihe CSFST value. Heal@ 8 SLvvr. Qftofuhmem ~t ~hf h23lKd.ltlhemftE szzm~~oftof amalut h QDfbtiftc ibao 5 mQ Qf Q?Qi~~irafiaiho hQERterihul 19&5. HILL ~+~ QQQd5go h 9 R8521 Qf CGER HL2 Q2BE QQQL59 Ehfemm;

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (FPB) R.E. Glnna PWR FPB IC¹: FC5 Barrier: Fuel Cfaddin Type: Loss

== Description:== Containment Radiation Monitor Reading FC5.1 Containment rad monitor reading greater thaagite-specie) ~~ Bases: The~~peciTic)-reading is a value which indicates the release of reactor coolant, with elevated activity indicative of fuel damage, into the containment. The reading should be calculated assuming the instantaneous release and dispersal of the reactor coolant noble gas and iodine'inventory associated with a concentration of 300 ItCi/gm dose equivalent 1-131 into the containment atmosphere. Reactor coolant concentrations ol this magnitude are several times larger than the maximum concentrations (including iodine spiking) alfowed withfn technical specifications and are therefore indicative ol fuel damage (approximately 2-5% clad failure depending on core inventory and RCS volume). This value is higher than that specified for RCS barrier loss EAL ¹4. Thus, this EAL indicates a loss of both the fuel clad barrier and a loss of RCS barrier. There is no "Potential Loss" EAL associated with this item. Ehfmxmz H. B95LifitHEQ~KQQ GQ19m BQYLQE KGKflQQ LLEW QQ L92

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (FPB) R.E. Gtnna PNR FPB IC¹: FC6 Barrier: Fuel Claddin Type: Loss Desert ptfon: Other (site specific) indications FC6.1 Failed Fuel Monitor (R-9) reading > 10,000 mRemihr Bases: This EAL is to cover other~~pecific) indications that may indicate hss or potential hss of the fuel clad banier 't Sam Kaid Bud thftitftrrm8m ftfMJKQ mgftmdz aumaanda tft.55 hftl failure.

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (FPB) R.E. Glnna PWR FPB IC¹: FC6 Barrier: Fuel Claddin Type: Potential Loss

== Description:== Other {site-specific) Indications FC6.2 Bases:

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (FPB) R.E. Qlnna PWR FPB ICy: FC7 Barrier: Fuel Claddin Type: Loss/Pot. Loss Descrlptlort: Emergency Director Judgement FC7.1 Any condition in the opinion of the mtjft~gggjgfKfQgy~gtt QgfttffirgfgQQhoctoc that indicates loss or potential bss of the fuel clad barrier Bases: This EAL addresses any other factors that are to be used by the ~igy~i~ {P~r~gg~ifgQQicoctac- in determining whether the fuel clad barrier is bst or potentially bst. In addition, the inability to monitor the barrier should also be incorporated in this EAL as a factor in mtjjt Qgggyj~ gglgrltftfZZggZfina~Qicoc4ac judgement that the barrier may be considered lost or potentially lost. (See also IC SGt, Probnged Loss of All Offsite Power and Probnged Loss of All Onsite AC Power, for additional information.)

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (FPB) R.E. Glnna PWR FPB ICg: RCS1 Barrier: RCS Type: Potential Loss

== Description:== Critical Safety Function Status RCS1.1 BCShtegrBy - Red fhtth gft ~ gpgQQ RCS1.2 ~~e- Red ftatb ittIEaa. BEZEL Bases: This EAL is for PWRs using Critical Safety Function Status Tree (CSFST) monitoring and functional recovery procedures. path indicates an extreme challenge to the safety function derived from appropriate instrument readings, and these CSFs indicate a potential toss of RCS barrier. Tliere is no "Loss" EAL-associated with this item.

References:

1. CSFST F.0.3 HEAT SINK

2. CSFST F-0.4 INTEGRITY

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (FPB) R.E. Glnna PNR FPB fC¹: RCS2 Barrfer: RCS Type: Loss Oescrfptfon: RCS Leak Rate RCS2.1 Greater than available makeup capacity as indicatedby Bases: The "Loss EAL addresses conditions where leakage from the RCS is greater than available inventory control capacity such that a loss ol subcooling has occurred. The toss of subcooling h. the tundamental indication that the inventory control systems are inadequate in maintaining RCS pressure and inventory against the mass loss through the leak.

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (FPB) R.E. Ginna PWR FPB IC¹: RCS2 Barrier: RCS Type: Potential Loss

== Description:== RCS Leak Rate RCS2.2 Bases: The "Potential Loss" EAL is based on the inability to maintain normal liquid inventory within the Reactor Coolant System (RCS} by normal operation of the Chemical and Volume Control System which is considered as one ltmttcoatNugat charging pumps discharging to the charging header. ln conjunction with the SG Tube Rupture Potential Loss" EAL'this assures that any event th~. results in significant RCS inventory shrinkage or loss (e. g., events leading to reactor scram and ECCS actuation} will result in no lower than an Alert emergency classification. ~frgggg'GLBIuhhRBJi

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (FPB) R.E. Ginna PWR FPB IC¹: RCS3 Barrfer: RCS Type: Loss

== Description:== SG Tube Rupture RCS3.t

                   ~       Qmrulur Mmnuuttitft Bases:

This EAL is intended to address the full spectrum of Steam Generator (SG) tube rupture events in conjunction with containment barrier "Loss" EAL ¹4 and fuel clad barrier EALs. The "Loss" EAL addresses ruptured SG(s) with an unisolable secondary line break corresponding to the loss of 2 o3 fission product barriers (RCS barrier and containment barrier - this EAL will always result in containment barrier "Loss" EAL ¹4). This allows the direct release ol radioactive fission and activation products to the environment. Resultant offsite dose rates are a function of many variables. Examp'lesinclude: coolant activity,actualleakrate,SGcarryover,iodinepartitioning, and meteorology. Therefore,doseassessmentinaccordancewithICAG1, Site Boundary Dose Resulting from an Actual or Imminent Release of Gaseous Radioactivity that Exceeds 1000 mR Whole Body or 5000 mR Child Thyroid for the Actual or Projected Duration of t Release Using Actual Meteorology, is required when there is indication that the fuel matrix/clad is potentially lost. specific) indication should be consistent with the diagnostic activities of the emergency operating procedures (EOPs)+Wuaifabto. This should incfude indication of reduction in prima coolant inventory, increased secondary radiation levefs, and an uncontrolled or complete depressurization of the ruptured SG. Secondary radiation increases should be observed via

             - -.: -r ~~~>>~o~ ~rr oi~nr clierharae. SG biowdown. mains steam, and/or SG sampling system. Determination of the "uncontrolled" depressurization of tlie ruptured SG
                                                                                                                 ~rslnr sr ups 7                           ~         J      Across I ~ Itstsrsn
                                                                                                                                                                                     ~

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (FPB) R.E. Glnna PWR FPB ICA: RCS3 Barrier: RCS Type: Potential Loss

== Description:== SG Tube Rupture jakes~ RCS3.2 LuutuLft midftutiTimf Gmmtgrluha BuatuuL h$ 2 Eriaum iu mtuurudaz jhthum ha Kam Bases: The Potential Loss" EAL is based on the inability to maintain normal liquid inventory wilhin the Reactor Coolant System (RCS) by normal operation of the Chemical and Volume Controf system which is considered as onecoatNugal uitutglftu pump discharging to the charging header. In conjunction with the RCS leak rate "Potential Loss EAL this assures that any event that results signiiicant RCS inventory shrinkage or loss (e. g., events leading to reactor scram and ECCS actuation) will result in no lower than an "Alerl emergency classification. Bt~<<i~ g2QQr9~ ~ Bu@llrr"

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (FPB) R.E. Glnna PWR FPB IC¹: RCS4 Barrier: RCS Type: Loss

== Description:== Containment Radiation Monitoring RCS4.1 Containment radiation monitor reading greater tha+sitacpoc~ 10 FUhr Bases:- The~~ reading is a value which indicates the release of reactor coolant to the containment. The reading should be calculated assuming the instantaneous release and dispersal of the reactor coolant noble gas and iodine inventory associated with normal operating concentrations (I e., within T/S) into the containment atmosphere. This reading will be less than that specific for fuel clad barrier EAL ¹5. Thus. this EAL would be indicative of a RCS leak only. If the radiation monitor reading increased to that specified by fuel clad barrier EAL ¹3, fuel damage would also be indicated. However, if the site-specific physical location of the containment radiation monitor is such that radiation from a cloud of released RCS gases could not be distinguished from radiation from nearby piping and components containing elevated reactor coolant activity. this EAL should be omitted and other site-specific indications of RCS leakage substituted. There is no "Potential Loss" EAL associated with this item. Qp~fr ~n GKIfgIJgQEgJ, HftyhSiiQ 2 co 7 4 o~ ~~en tv winh ran10<rlmdnt Rsrlistinn I aval Ravision 3

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (FPB} R.E. Glnna PWR FPB IC¹: RCS5 Barrier: RCS Type: Loss Desert ptlont Other (Site-specific) indications RCS5.1 Bases: This EAL is to cover other~~poc~ indications that may indicate toss or potentiai toss of the RCS barrier, including indications from containment air monitors or any other instrumentation.

t~ ~

~ ~

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (FPB) R.E. Ginna PWR FPB IC¹: RCS5 Barrier: RCS Type: Potential Loss Descrlptlon: Other (site-specific) indications RCS5.2 Bases: This EAL is to cover other (site-specific) indications that may indicate loss or potential loss of the RCS barrier, including indications from containment air monitors or any other (site-specific) instrumentation.

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (FPB) R.E. Glnna PWR FPB IC¹: RCS6 Barrier: RCS Type: Loss/Pot. Loss

== Description:== 215~~~ ~QQQQf QQQQjimtQQQIrec~ Judgement RCS6.1 Any condition in the judgment of the Emergency Director that indicates loss or potential loss of the RCS barrier. Bases: This EAL addresses any other factors that are to be used by the ghiif+ggzjiiz ~Lrr. ~ Qgggjiig~ Ckoctoc in determining whether the RCS barrier is hst or potentially lost. In addition, the inability to monitor the barrier should also be incorporated in this EAL as a factor in gggg~~ )EttlftrgZgy QgggjthtfgLlQirectoc judgement that the barrier may be considered lost or potentially lost. (See also IC SG1, "Prolonged Loss of All Offsite Power and Prolonged Loss of All Onsite AC Power, for additional information.)

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (FPB) R.E. Ginna PWR FPB IC¹: PC1 Barrier: Prima Containment Type: Potential loss Descrlptlon: Critical Safety Function Status PC1.1 Contairuuent- Red fbi}h ~ Bases: This EAL is for PWRs using Criticaf Safety Function Status Tree (CSFST} monitoring and functional recovery procedures. RE path indicates an extreme challenge to the safety function derived from appropriate instrument readings and/or sampling results, and thus represents a potential loss of containment. Emergency representing a potential loss of the third barrier. ala mtdtag bighuuhl~i ufftuurr~ It ~h tm mhd halffttux Ltmt Giaau hu au.taa!nit htta ~ Conditions leading to a containment RED path result from RCS barrier and/or fuel clad barrier loss. Thus, this EAL is primarily a discriminator between Site Area Emergency and General

                                                                        ~ttag shah~

ftfumafal auhOL)MRS addftfI 1a dhtiagtL1h IEQ1 GG fklllLiiaMfftQ?fttidaatttat Shkh QHX IQSl Ihat mntaiafaftat deign ammrftd Kah hmmhdhc amRR~ fumhmak grani iaLL There is no "Loss" EAL associated with this item. Bahmm

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (FPB) R.E. Glnna PWR FPB IC¹: PC2 Barrier: Prima Containment Type: Loss Descrlptlon: Containment Pressure PC2.< Rapid~xpfaiaedrrrt~rrtifgf decrease in Containment Pressure foffowing initial increase gagman PC2.2 azaam1ftra 1hu1 m nrt1rtttui containment pressure or sump level response not consistent with LOCA conditions. Lrt.rmftzrtftgfgd iaabh fhrt 1rt umrarttr adhru rtr auigrtztit'mshm mfiam. f;~ Bases: Rapid unexplained loss ot pressure (i. e., not attributable to containment spray ftr ~grtrtilmr ~ or condensation effects) following an initial pressure increase indicates a toss of containment integrity. Containment pressure and sump levels should increase as a result of the mass and energy release into containment from a LOCA. Thus, sump level or pressure not increasing indicates containment bypass (V-sequence) and a loss of containment integrity. ~f~rn f'. 8zm rmuavm azm~r BKk33K HftrIsirtrt5

2. 8xn mrtzz arrzadfrrft. BKQABfLriYiz4

3. K E. Gitrm ilrtr4ttftdEKL EigMrft RB ibrmrgh kH

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (FPB) R.E. Glnna PWR FPB ICg: PC2 Barrier: Prima Containment Type: Potential Loss Oescrtpt tort: Containment Pressure PC2.3 +~poc~ psig and increasing 1L'ittjjjOgfftttQ~gfDtaijZgKIRQi PC2.4 R 6 hldraattn maQttQltafjttQ IQ mnlajtttnttnt PC2,5 fhtt IQ ~ ~i ~ ~ fbQO QHBI ft mutt s26Ldg; 2 QHhK flora Em

                                                         ~ii~Q g~~inm ~ti ~fgQQtth ttgttj~mOI
                                                                              ~+n                              ~r QHhK Qmmutt         M>   ftmg; 2 QHhK Bum Zuam QB 2QRI Bum Eans aod1GHhK Sum Euae Bases:

The ~~octTQ Qg psig tor potential loss ot containment QttcQQtfQtf If'Qy ~ ~ ~ M12 II5IdR QHlfQ!QtQttQl 5hiilMX1ttmtlt lQ Itjgh MltajQHlttQI IIQtt ftQtajt gggfgjQtQttQL

is based on the containment design Pressure. fits!~ It + Q+tttf htEttYQI Existence ot an explosive mixture

                                                                                                                   ~T 111QI ttt~rlt ~1IQQ IZtQ IL'iQQf 1ftQG1K 22ltllU11" ERR RCg IQ5621IQgltLijlhtQ1 gJOQR Q Q jttt~ggg) means
                                                                                                                           ~   E? RORitlmg ~i                                               ~

lflQER Ibaj 52QIQIQQ1ttQI tfttmltQ QQtlMfQQf Q2R" a hydrogen and oxygen concentration of at least the lower deflagration limit curve exists. The indications of potential loss under this EAL corresponds to some of those leading to the RED path in EAL ¹1 above and may be declared by those sites using CSFSTs As de cribed above, this EAL is primarily a discriminator between Site Area Emergency and General Emergency representing a potential loss of the third barrier. Themcoact ~ potentiat loss EAL represents a potential hss of containment in that the containment heat removaVdepressurization system which the equipment was supposed to have actuated.

                                                                                                                                                     ~      containment sprays,    Qggjg,~ tco-Q~tr!~nc
                                                            'f  i n        I      -4 n   r r:    << llcchD    cow ann n    )9   1 I

9 8 nn R 9-pa

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (FPB) R.E. Ginna PWR FPB IC¹: PC3 Barrier: Prima Containment Type: Loss Oesortptton: Containment Isolation Valve Status After Containment Isolation PC3.1 Either: Q Qi Qg h~f~i Rl 1ftu~ uai Q Q1 QQ valve(s) not closed ~ Lftgjati Lnnf~iii AND downstream taftiglgjaat ~ tu iatiQtft ALE QQQEE RLQEB ~$ 1ittgiEl 9+$ ii2 QHliIMQIHlftal pathway to the environment exists Bases: This EAL is intended to address incomplete containment isolation that allows direct release to the environment. It represents a loss ol the containment barrier. Itm uhcam ~ imbfTity. tu hah@ @mt ufifmaf ohms!12;hataiau fIuhifhmntaiamftaL" hahIftaaiiIti Ift.aauturft uahuhtattlft,hake fnun1!um afitmaf. axahmamhiah utataiftmftat bguadam hut uhhh aithar Aft aftt hatlIt autamatia iatlatifta hludium ur amiftfta dime ar indimt rahma aath hi: amah@ malaai auhida thft mataiamttat. mtmfhafaafi thft There is no "Potential Loss" EAL associated with this item. ~f~rn It; ER21 Jhemarm ift Hiah Quatatafxfftat PrammC

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (FPB) R.E. Gonna PWR FPB IC¹: PC4 Bar fler: Prima Containment Type: Loss

== Description:== SG Secondary Side Release with Primary to Secondary Leakage PC4.1 Release of secondary side to atmosphere with primary to secondary leakage greater than tech spec allowable gf QJ gpg ggZ~ gftftftfa~ Bases: This EAL addresses SG tube ruptures. Secondary side releases to atmosphere include those from the condenser air ejector, atmospheric dump valves, and mainsteam safety valves. For smaller breaks, not exceeding the normal charging capacity threshold in RCS barrier "Potential Loss" EAL ¹2 (RCS leak rate) or EAI ¹3 (SG tube rupture), this EAL results in an Unusual Even For larger breaks, RCS barrier "Loss" or "Potential Loss" EAL ¹2 would result in an A'lert. For SG tube ruptures which may involve multiple steam generators or unisolable secondary line breaks, this EAL wou'ld exist in conjunction with RCS barrier "Loss" EAL ¹3 and would result in a Site Area Emergency. Escalation to General Emergency would be based on "Potential Loss" the fuel clad barrier.

plant Specific EAL Guideline (FPB) R.E. Glnna PWR FPB IC¹: PC5 Barrier: Prima Containment Type: Potential Loss Descrfptlon: Signicant Radioactive Inventory in Containment PC5.1 Containment radiation monitor reading greater tha+sito-spociTig~~ Bases: The~~pec~~HrILr reading is a value which indicates significant fuel damage well in excess of the EALs associated with both loss of fuel clad and loss of RCS barriers. As stated in Section 3.8, a major release of radioactivity requiring offsite protective actions from core damage is not possible unless a major failure of fuel cladding alhws radioactive material t be release 3 from the core into the reactor coolant. Regardless of whether containment is challenged, this amount of activity in containment, if released, could have such severe consequences t at it s ud t t t t th' ntial loss of containment such that a General Emergency dedaration is warranted. NUREG-1228 Source Estimations During Incident Response to evere Nuclear Power Plant Accidents," indicates that such conditions do not exist when the amount of clad damage is less than 20%. Unless there is afrite-specific analysis j ify g ig value, it is recommended that a radiation monitor reading corresponding to >20% fuel clad damage be specified here. There is no Loss" EAL associated with this item.

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (FPB) R.E. Glnna PWR FPB IC¹: PC6 Barrfer: Prima Containment Type: Potential Loss Desorlptfon: Core Exit Thermocouples PC6.1

                           . Qftaggfimf tg Qgtfratgf ~

Core exit thermocouples in excess of 1200 'F and restoration procedures p~ J, Hftaggftaa tg Jgggglgta Qggjjog, not effective within 15 minutes

                                                                                                                                  ~ gggjiftL~~              QKggrtaa tg DggrRfgg gggk gggljftm QE}

PC6.2 core exit thermocouples in excess of 700 'F with LQZIQQtfata QQE Qgjtttg. HK2. Bttauaaa tg Ihgradftft GER Qggljag ~ E~ BYLAW ~~~ /55 adttftraaggetalgtjftftftg and restoration procedures ~~ Haaggftaa tg Qgttlratftft Qrg gggfjgg, not effective within 15 minutes Bftaggrtaa tg Bases: ln this EAL, the function restoration procedures are those emergency operating procedures that address the recovery of the core cooling critical safety functions. The procedure is considered effective if the lemperature is decreasing or if the vessel water level is increasing. The conditions in this potential loss EAI represent imminent melt sequence which, if not corrected, could lead to vessel failure and an increased potential for containment failure. In conjunction with the core exit thermocouple EALs in the fuel and RCS barrier columns, this EAL would result in the declaration of a General Emergency loss of two barriers and the potentiaf loss of a third. If the function restoration procedures are ineffective, there is not "success path. Severe acckfent analyses (e. g., NUREG-1150) have concluded that lunction restoration procedures can arrest core degradation within the reactor vessel in a significant fraction of the core damage scenarios, and that the likelihood of containment failure is very small in these evenls. Given this, it is appropriate to provide a reasonable period to allow function restoration procedures to arrest the core meit sequence. Whether or not procedures will be effedive should be apparent within 15 minutes. The mijft Qgg~jggr ggoargftggy QggrfljflatgQQiroc4oa shou mike the declaration as soon as it is determined that the procedures have been, or will be effective. The reactor vessel level chosen should be consistent with the emergency response guides applicable to the facility. There is no "Loss" EAL associated with this item. hah; Ldmaa ggntaiafattrtt lfahfftaht ffmfftmhmmr ggot~it grftamrfth guftatftr thank gag gr ggataiagtagt radjatjgahrftatftr tbaa 1K'.

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (FPB) R.E. Glnna PNR FPB IC¹: PC7 Barrier: Prima Containment Type: Loss Descrtptlon: Other (site. specific) indications PC7. t fhibrfrm19rtQRQ gn umlRttimnt Rirhzh Qi lnv3Q~M IR9hmt uo19intnRQI rtr999urR rRI19f w. rturgRmhumhhh 192iiIR in R rnfighgi99l 1RttRrtRIbnRir itt ibRRrnriigrrrn9ni QB Q rK QQ valve(s) not closed sb9Q IttuirRtf5lthb 199uih In R 19tfh)ltgigRI 1919999 ltRIIHMRKIR ibR 911Yirgnrnttni Bases: in containment annulus or other contiguous buildings. Iha gtntfilhn 9Q~QRQC KLkRtftf9rf IR Rrftfr922 JQ99 gf cgnt9!llrn9lti ftgunrf9JY 22 R

                                                                      "~I'rt
                                                                         ~r 9h9R srtQIRjnrnRQI Q1999urR 191I9f gr QurgR Qf fRIIurR Ik
                                                                                                                               ~~

This EAL should cover other~~cittc) indications that may unambiguously indicate toss or polential loss of the containment barrier, including indications lrorn area or ventilation monitor

                                                                                            ~                                                199tdlk inn 1Rr(igiggiHI 19!RR9R rtRIIQY@r Ir? IbR ibR QHg91nrn9nt YRQI QRtb Igihttdng rrtuIIQR 9m119!QQ19ni YRQIIQlt~ Qlntiiihn Q re QQ valve(s) not closed Eb9a rRQuirRtf 281Kh192tl1R in RIRdhhgiGRI 191999R rQibMRK Ik 1bR RQYIrttnlnRQL" SRR RtfdRtf irt Rtftfr999 Ql Qr QS hQIRihn RllurRREhhb R1R Qrti IQIIIRIRtfRR R 199uli Qf htunthnr hRgb. Ibh M.hgnlr mn9tthr9lf fltr ibR uurrtg9Rrtf MhrRIhn gf RQUnu9uRI E~rRQL Egrrf991919ihnrtf ahhm RK gr Qm19rRI Ern91g9ngi99. IbhM.h RulmunRtf IQIREGLL=

Etn9rg9mQugrfinRIgr dudlmQI. Ilbi99gnrfiihnmarRin uzimihn nith Rh99rtf fKRkmhrRIhnmill&rnRlfRhattf gnPQ2J.22rtr2J.

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (FPB) R.E. Glnns PNR FPB IC¹: PC7 Barrier: Prima Containment Type: Potential Loss Descrfptfon: Other (site-specific) indications PC7.2 Bases: This EAL should cover other (site-specific) indications that may unambiguously indicate loss or potential loss of the containment barrier, including indicalions from area or ventilation monitors in containment annulus or other conliguous buildings.

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (FPB) R.E. Glnna PWR FPB ICif'C8 Barrier: Prima Containment Type: Loss/Pot. Loss Descrlptioft: Emergency Director Judgement PC8.t Any condition in the judgment of the ~ gift~ {Etttfttgtnt~gggfffttbtfgQQicectoc that indicates bss or potential bss of the containment barrier Bases:

                                                                    ~i   ~~i~

This EAL addresses any other factors that are to be used by the addition, the inability to monitor the barrier should also be incorporated in this EAL as a factor in ~ Qtfg~f

                                                                                     ~fttgfnt~ggggfjgg~Duector in determining whether the containment barrier is bst or potentially bst.

gJftftfgftitgy~trfjlgggQOicectoc judgement that the barrier may be considered lost or potentially lost. (See also IC SGt, Probnged Loss of All Offsite Power and Probnged Loss of All Onsite AC Power, for additional information.) 1

Plant Specific EAL Guideline (FPB) R.E. Gtnna PWR FPB IC¹: FC1 Barrier: Fuel Claddin Type: Los Descrlpilort: Critical Safely Function Status FC$ .1 Coreceorrag-Red ~ jo ~ QQQP QQQJ~ Bases: Core Cooling - RED indicates significant superheating and core uncovery and is considered to indicate loss of the Fuel Clad Barrier.

l~ 0 s}}

ML17263A835

Text

References:

Navigation menu

Search