Transcript of 850711 Closed Meeting in Oak Harbor,Oh Re Steam & Feedwater Rupture Control Sys Training.Pp 1-20ML20129B912 |
Person / Time |
---|
Site: |
Davis Besse ![Cleveland Electric icon.png](/w/images/7/78/Cleveland_Electric_icon.png) |
---|
Issue date: |
07/11/1985 |
---|
From: |
NRC COMMISSION (OCM) |
---|
To: |
|
---|
References |
---|
NUDOCS 8507290295 |
Download: ML20129B912 (22) |
|
|
---|
Category:LEGAL TRANSCRIPTS & ORDERS & PLEADINGS
MONTHYEARML20198L1911998-12-21021 December 1998 Submits Comments Re Proposed Rule to Revise 10CFR50.59, Changes,Tests & Experiments ML20198L1361998-12-15015 December 1998 Comment Opposing Proposed Rule 10CFR50.65 Re Requirements for Monitoring Effectiveness of Maint of NPP ML20217J2161998-03-27027 March 1998 Comment on Proposed Generic Communication Re Lab Testing of nuclear-grade Activated Charcoal ML20217F5361998-03-25025 March 1998 Comment Opposing Draft Regulatory Guide DG-1071, Std Format & Content for Post-Shutdown Decommissioning Activities Rept ML20199J4651998-01-22022 January 1998 Comment Opposing Draft RG-1070, Sampling Plans Used for Dedicating Simple Metallic Commercial Grade Items for Use in Npps. RG Unnecessary Based on Use of EPRI Guideline & Excellent Past History of Commercial Grade Items at DBNPS ML20148M6421997-06-17017 June 1997 Comment on Proposed NRC Bulletin 96-001,suppl 1 Re Control Rod Insertion Problems.Nrc Should Review Info Provided in Licensee 970130 Submittal & Remove Statements of Applicability to B&W Reactors from Suppl Before Final Form ML20134L3401997-01-22022 January 1997 Resolution 96-R-85, Resolution Supporting Merger of Centerior Energy Corp & Ohio Edison Under New Holding Co Called Firstenergy ML20133B6941996-12-18018 December 1996 Submits Ordinance 850-96 Re Approval of Merger of Centerior & Oh Edison Into Firstenergy ML20132A8461996-12-0202 December 1996 Resolution 20-1996 Supporting Merger of Ohio Edison & Centerior Corp Under New Holding Company Called Firstenergy ML20134M6191996-10-28028 October 1996 Proclamation of Support by City of Sandusky,Oh Re Merger of Ohio Edison and Centerior Energy Corp ML20108D9571996-05-0303 May 1996 CEI Response to City of Cleveland 2.206 Petition.Nrc Should Deny Petition ML20097G5731996-02-13013 February 1996 Comment Supporting Petition for Rulemaking PRM-50-63 Re Use of Potassium Iodide ML20097B8721996-01-23023 January 1996 Petition of City of Cleveland,Oh for Expedited Issuance of Nov,Enforcement of License Conditions & Imposition of Appropriate Fines,Per 10CFR2.201,2.202,2.205 & 2.206 ML20101B5841996-01-23023 January 1996 Motion of City of Cleveland,Oh for Partial Summary Judgement Or,In Alternative,For Severance of Issue & Expedited Hearing Procedures.W/Certificate of Svc ML20097B8911996-01-23023 January 1996 Motion of City of Cleveland,Oh for Partial Summary Judgement or in Alternative,For Severance of Issue & Expedited Hearing Procedures ML20096E9781996-01-0808 January 1996 Comment on Proposed Suppl to GL 83-11, Licensee Qualification for Performing Safety Analyses in Support of Licensing Actions ML20087J3611995-08-14014 August 1995 Comment Opposing Proposed Rule 10CFR2 Re Rev of NRC Enforcement Policy ML20086M8241995-06-29029 June 1995 Comment on Proposed Review of NRC Insp Rept Content,Format & Style ML20083M8701995-05-10010 May 1995 Comment on Proposed Rule 10CFR50 Re Primary Reactor Containment Leakage Testing for Water-Cooled Power Reactor ML20081C8841995-03-0303 March 1995 Comment Re NRC Proposed Generic Communication Suppl 5 to GL 88-20, IPEEE for Severe Accident Vulnerabilities. Util Ack NRC Efforts to Reduce Scope of GL 88-20,but Believes That Proposed Changes Still Overly Restrictive ML20077M5831995-01-0404 January 1995 Comment Opposing Proposed Rule 10CFR50 Re Shutdown & low-power Operations for Nuclear Power Reactors ML20072K3611994-08-16016 August 1994 Comment Opposing Proposed Rule 10CFR72 Re Plans for Storage of Sf at Davis Besse NPP ML20072K4411994-08-14014 August 1994 Comment Opposing Proposed Rule 10CFR72 Re Dry Storage of Nuclear Waste at Facility in Toledo,Oh ML20072K5261994-08-12012 August 1994 Comment Supporting Proposed Rule 10CFR72 Re Addition of Standardized NUHOMS Horizontal Modular Storage Sys to List of Approved Sf Storage Casks ML20072B1581994-08-0909 August 1994 Comment Opposing Proposed Rule 10CFR72 on List of Approved Spent Fuel Storage Casks:Addition ML20029D8221994-04-19019 April 1994 Comments on Proposed Rule 10CFR50 Re Codes & Stds for Nuclear Power Plants;Subsection IWE & Subsection Iwl ML20062M4011993-12-28028 December 1993 Comment Supporting Petition for Rulemaking PRM-21-2 Re Commercial Grade Item Dedication ML20046A9561993-07-19019 July 1993 Comment on Proposed Rules 10CFR170 & 171, FY91 & 92 Proposed Rule Implementing Us Court of Appeals Decision & Rev of Fee Schedules;100% Fee Recovery,FY93. ML20056C8951993-07-19019 July 1993 Order Extending Time within Which Commission May Rule on Petitions for Review of LBP-92-32.W/Certificate of Svc. Served on 930720 ML20045F8321993-06-22022 June 1993 Comment on Proposed Rule 10CFR26 Re Mods to fitness-for-duty Program Requirements.Concurs W/Proposed Rule in Reducing Random Testing Rate of Licensees to 50% & Disagrees W/ Maintaining Random Testing Rate of 100% for Vendors ML20044E2781993-05-13013 May 1993 Comment Supporting Petition for Rulemaking PRM-50-58 Re VEPCO Petition to Change Frequency of Emergency Planning Exercise from Annual to Biennial ML20044E1561993-04-29029 April 1993 Comment Supporting Petition for Rulemaking PRM-50-58 Re Frequency Change of Emergency Planning Exercises ML20127L8781993-01-19019 January 1993 Comment Supporting Comments Submitted by NUMARC Re Draft Reg Guide DG-1020 ML20127A6171993-01-0606 January 1993 Order.* Time within Which Commission May Rule on Petitions for Review of Board Order LBP-92-32,dtd 921118,extended Until 930208.W/Certificate of Svc.Served on 930106 ML20126D5801992-12-23023 December 1992 NRC Staff Answer in Response to Petitions for Review Filed by Oh Edison Co,Cleveland Electric Illuminating Co,Toledo Edison Co & City of Cleveland.* W/Certificate of Svc ML20126F6501992-12-23023 December 1992 Answer of City of Cleveland,Oh,Intervenor,In Opposition to Petitions for Review of 921118 Decision of Aslb.* Petitioners Petitions for Review Should Be Denied. Certificate of Svc Encl ML20126D5171992-12-23023 December 1992 City of Brook Park Answer to Petitions for Review.* Opposes Applicants 921208 Petitions for Review Based on Fact That ASLB Decision in proceeding,LBP-92-32,adequately Addressed Issues Raised in Petitions.W/Certificate of Svc ML20126D5461992-12-23023 December 1992 Answer of Cleveland Electric Illuminating Co & Toledo Edison Co to Limited Petition for Review of City of Cleveland,Oh of 921118 Decision of Aslb.* Commission Should Deny City of Cleveland Petition.W/Certificate of Svc ML20126D5781992-12-23023 December 1992 Answer of American Municipal Power-OH,Inc in Opposition to Petitions for Review of Oh Edison Co & Cleveland Electric Illuminating Co/Toledo Edison Co.* W/Certificate of Svc ML20126D4761992-12-22022 December 1992 Alabama Electric Cooperative Answer to Applicants Petitions for Review.* Applicants 921208 Petitions for Review Should Be Denied.W/Certificate of Svc ML20126A5461992-12-10010 December 1992 Order.* Requests That Answers to Petition for Review Be Filed No Later than 921223.W/Certificate of Svc.Served on 921210 ML20126A5751992-12-0808 December 1992 Petition for Review.* Requests That NRC Review LBP-92-32, 921118 Board Decision in Proceeding.Board Erroneously Interpreted Section 105(c) of AEA by Ignoring Fundamental Underpinning of Statute.W/Certificate of Svc ML20126A5871992-12-0808 December 1992 Petition for Review.* Requests That NRC Review ASLB 921118 decision,LBP-92-32.Board Erroneously Interpreted Section 105(c) of AEA by Ignoring Fundamental Underplanning of Statute.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20126A7651992-11-18018 November 1992 Limited Petition for Review of City of Cleveland,Oh of 921118 Decision of Aslb.* City of Cleveland Petition for Review Should Be Granted.W/Certificate of Svc ML20115E1771992-10-0808 October 1992 Comment Supporting Draft Mgt Directive 8.6,GL 92-05 ML20105C8971992-09-16016 September 1992 Comment Opposing Proposed Generic Communication Re Generic Ltr Concerning analog-to-digital Replacements Under 10CFR50.59 ML20114A8841992-08-17017 August 1992 Designation of City of Brook Park,Oh of Adopted Portions of Summary Disposition Pleadings.* Brook Park Not Advancing Any Addl Argument or Analysis in Connection W/Designation,Per 920806 Memorandum & Order.W/Certificate of Svc ML20099E1821992-07-28028 July 1992 Comment Supporting Proposed Rules 10CFR20 & 61 Re LLW Shipment Manifest Info & Reporting ML20099A4051992-07-17017 July 1992 Comment on Proposed Rules 10CFR20 & 50 Re Reducing Regulatory Burden on Nuclear Licensees.Supports Rules ML20101R4831992-07-0808 July 1992 Comment Supporting Proposed Rule 10CFR50 Re Receipt of Byproduct & Special Nuclear Matl 1998-03-27
[Table view] Category:TRANSCRIPTS
MONTHYEARML20101K2691992-06-29029 June 1992 City of Cleveland Proposed Corrections to Oral Argument Transcript of 920610.* W/Certificate of Svc & Svc List ML20214J0691986-11-21021 November 1986 Transcript of Commission 861121 Public Meeting in Washington,Dc Re Discussion/Possible Vote on Plant Restart. Pp 1-63.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20205C7691986-08-0707 August 1986 Transcript of 860807 Hearing in Sandusky,Oh.Pp 567-972. Supporting Documentation Encl ML20205C7801986-08-0606 August 1986 Transcript of 860806 Hearing in Sandusky,Oh.Pp 260-509. Supporting Documentation Encl ML20212F6431986-08-0606 August 1986 Transcript of 860806 Limited Appearances Session in Sandusky,Oh.Pp 510-566 ML20205C7931986-08-0505 August 1986 Transcript of 860805 Hearing in Sandusky,Oh.Pp 1-259. Supporting Documentation Encl ML20203K0651986-08-0101 August 1986 Prefiled Testimony of RM Bimber & D Gitlin Re Waste Disposal Permit for Facility.Related Correspondence ML20204E9961986-07-24024 July 1986 Transcript of Commission 860724 Status Briefing on Facility Restart in Washington,Dc.Pp 1-61.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20207F6381986-07-19019 July 1986 Testimony of D Briden,Gf Bennett,Js Bland,Dm Hendron, CE Herdendorf,R Hetherington,Wb Jackson & Re Linnemann Re Burial of Very Low Level Waste at Davis-Besse.Related Correspondence ML20207F3801986-07-17017 July 1986 Testimony of DE Guy,Rr Pavey,Jh Marshall & J Yoytek Supporting State of Oh Petition to Intervene in Proposed Waste Burial Plan.Related Info Encl.W/Certificate of Svc. Related Correspondence ML20206R7181986-06-27027 June 1986 Transcript of ACRS Subcommittee on Davis-Besse Restart 860627 Meeting in Washington,Dc.Pp 1-110.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20206J4891986-06-25025 June 1986 Testimony of D Gitlin to Be Presented on 860625 in Sandusky, Oh Requesting Rescission of NRC Approval of Proposed Sludge Disposal Project ML20206J4541986-06-14014 June 1986 Testimony of RM Bimber Requesting Rescission of Onsite Waste Disposal Permit &/Or Advance Approval of Release of Dumpsite for Unrestricted Use at Time of Decommissioning ML20151Y8351986-02-0606 February 1986 Transcript of ACRS Subcommittee on Davis-Besse Nuclear Station Unit 1 Restart 860206 Meeting in Washington,Dc. Pp 1-169.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20137T3141986-02-0606 February 1986 Statement Before Subcommittee on Energy & Environ, Committee on Interior & Insular Affairs,Us House of Representatives Re FY87 Budget ML20138Q0771985-12-18018 December 1985 Transcript of 851218 Briefing on Restart from 850609 Event in Washington,Dc.Pp 1-102.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20133F2361985-10-0404 October 1985 Transcript of ACRS Subcommittee on Davis-Besse 851004 Meeting in Oak Harbor,Oh Re Review of Course of Action Prior to Restart of Plant.Pp 1-117 ML20132A4241985-09-18018 September 1985 Transcript of 850918 Public Meeting in Washington,Dc Re Continuation of Briefing on Plant.Pp 1-80.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20132A4001985-09-17017 September 1985 Transcript of Commission 850917 Public Meeting in Washington,Dc to Continue 850724 Briefing on Davis-Besse 850609 Event.Pp 1-89.Viewgraphs Encl IA-86-787, Transcript of 850904 Meeting in Bethesda,Md Re Util Planned Action on 850609 Event.Pp 1-235.Supporting Documentation Encl,Incuding NRC 850828 Meeting Agenda & Viewgraphs of Util 850917 Presentation to NRC1985-09-0404 September 1985 Transcript of 850904 Meeting in Bethesda,Md Re Util Planned Action on 850609 Event.Pp 1-235.Supporting Documentation Encl,Incuding NRC 850828 Meeting Agenda & Viewgraphs of Util 850917 Presentation to NRC ML20215E1871985-09-0404 September 1985 Transcript of 850904 Meeting in Bethesda,Md Re Util Planned Action on 850609 Event.Pp 1-235.Supporting Documentation Encl,Incuding NRC 850828 Meeting Agenda & Viewgraphs of Util 850917 Presentation to NRC ML20129B8461985-07-12012 July 1985 Transcript of 850712 Closed Meeting in Oak Harbor,Oh Re Status Rept on Quarantined Equipment Resulting from 850609 Event.Pp 91-248.Related Documentation Encl ML20129B9411985-07-12012 July 1985 Transcript of 850712 Closed Meeting in Oak Harbor,Oh Re Status Rept on Quarantine Equipment Resulting from 850609 Event.Pp 1-90.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20129B6791985-07-11011 July 1985 Transcript of 850711 Closed Meeting Re Steam Feed Rupture Control Sys Equipment & Operations.Pp 1-72 ML20129B9121985-07-11011 July 1985 Transcript of 850711 Closed Meeting in Oak Harbor,Oh Re Steam & Feedwater Rupture Control Sys Training.Pp 1-20 ML20129B9071985-07-10010 July 1985 Transcript of NRC Fact-Finding Team 850710 Closed Meeting W/Util in Oak Harbor,Oh Re 850609 Sequence of Events. Pp 1-24 ML20129B0751985-07-10010 July 1985 Transcript of 850710 Closed Meeting W/Util in Oak Harbor,Oh Re Steam Feed Rupture Control Sys Actuated Equipment & Operations.Pp 1-37.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20129B8861985-07-0909 July 1985 Transcript of 850709 Closed Meeting in Oak Harbor,Oh Re Addl Info Request Concerning Serial 517 Ltr & Pump Capacities of Equipment Used to Mitigate Total Loss of Feed. Pp 1-24.Related Documentation Encl ML20129B1021985-07-0909 July 1985 Transcript of 850709 Meeting W/Util in Oak Harbor,Oh Re PORV Controls & Instrumentation.Pp 1-9.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20129B8221985-07-0909 July 1985 Transcript of 850709 Closed Meeting in Oak Harbor,Oh Re Steam & Feedwater Rupture Control Sys Operations & Action Plan to Troubleshoot 850609 Anomalies.Pp 1-69 ML20129B0801985-07-0909 July 1985 Transcript of 850709 Closed Meeting W/Util in Oak Harbor,Oh Re Procedures Concerning Startup Feed Pump & Main Feed Pump Following Steam Feed Rupture Control Sys Actuation.Pp 1-43. Supporting Documentation Encl ML20129C1051985-06-27027 June 1985 Transcript of Fact-Finding Task Force 850627 Closed Meeting in Bethesda,Md Re 850609 Event.Pp 1-33.Related Documentation Encl ML20129B5981985-06-21021 June 1985 Transcript of 850621 Interview of R Osburn in Oak Harbor,Oh Re 850609 Event.Pp 1-11 ML20129B6181985-06-21021 June 1985 Transcript of 850621 Meeting in Oak Harbor,Oh Re Results of Troubleshooting & Identification of Root Cause of 850609 Event.Pp 1-140 ML20129B1811985-06-21021 June 1985 Transcript of 850621 Joint Interview of Quennoz & W O'Connor in Oak Harbor,Oh Re 850609 Event.Pp 1-53 ML20129B5681985-06-21021 June 1985 Transcript of 850621 Interview of W Rogers in Oak Harbor,Oh Re 850609 Event.Pp 1-17 ML20129B7751985-06-20020 June 1985 Transcript of 850620 Meeting in Oak Harbor,Oh Re Troubleshooting Action Plans for Auxiliary Feedwater Pumps Following 850609 Event.Pp 1-79 ML20129B4241985-06-20020 June 1985 Transcript of 850620 Interview of W Rogers in Oak Harbor,Oh Re 850609 Event.Pp 1-163 ML20129B4601985-06-19019 June 1985 Transcript of 850619 Meeting in Oak Harbor,Oh Re Action Plans for NI-1 Source Range Channel Following 850609 Event ML20129B5611985-06-19019 June 1985 Transcript of 850619 Joint Interview of T Lehman & Feasel in Oak Harbor,Oh Re 850609 Event.Pp 1-50 ML20129B7061985-06-19019 June 1985 Transcript of 850619 Meeting in Oak Harbor,Oh Re Action Plan on Turbine Bypass Valve Following 850609 Event.Pp 1-29 ML20129B5501985-06-18018 June 1985 Transcript of 850618 Meeting in Oak Harbor,Oh Re Action Plan for Main Feedwater Pump Control Sys Following 850609 Event. Pp 1-24 ML20129B0511985-06-18018 June 1985 Transcript of 850618 Interview of T Lang in Oak Harbor,Oh Re 850609 Event.Pp 1-49 ML20129B0461985-06-18018 June 1985 Transcript of 850618 Meeting in Oak Harbor,Oh Re Sequence of Events Discussion for 850609 Event.Pp 1-34.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20129D3761985-06-17017 June 1985 Transcript of 850617 Meeting W/Util in Bethesda,Md Re Auxiliary Feedwater Sys.Pp 1-50.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20129B0491985-06-17017 June 1985 Transcript of Interviews in Oak Harbor,Oh of Equipment Operators C Burns,J Meleg,M Klein & B Morrison Re 850609 Event.Pp 1-145.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20129B1271985-06-15015 June 1985 Transcript of 850615 Joint Interview of L Simon & SM Quennoz in Oak Harbor,Oh Re 850609 Event.Pp 1-78 ML20129C0591985-06-15015 June 1985 Transcript of Afternoon Session of 850615 Proceedings in Oak Harbor,Oh Re Guidelines for Troubleshooting or Performing Investigative Actions Into Root Causes Surrounding 850609 Event.Pp 1-15 ML20129B0661985-06-14014 June 1985 Transcript of 850614 Interview of R Walleman in Oak Harbor,Oh Re 850609 Event.Pp 1-114 ML20129B0841985-06-14014 June 1985 Transcript of 850614 Equipment Meeting in Oak Harbor,Oh Re 850609 Event.Pp 1-100.Supporting Documentation Encl 1992-06-29
[Table view] Category:DEPOSITIONS
MONTHYEARML20101K2691992-06-29029 June 1992 City of Cleveland Proposed Corrections to Oral Argument Transcript of 920610.* W/Certificate of Svc & Svc List ML20214J0691986-11-21021 November 1986 Transcript of Commission 861121 Public Meeting in Washington,Dc Re Discussion/Possible Vote on Plant Restart. Pp 1-63.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20205C7691986-08-0707 August 1986 Transcript of 860807 Hearing in Sandusky,Oh.Pp 567-972. Supporting Documentation Encl ML20205C7801986-08-0606 August 1986 Transcript of 860806 Hearing in Sandusky,Oh.Pp 260-509. Supporting Documentation Encl ML20212F6431986-08-0606 August 1986 Transcript of 860806 Limited Appearances Session in Sandusky,Oh.Pp 510-566 ML20205C7931986-08-0505 August 1986 Transcript of 860805 Hearing in Sandusky,Oh.Pp 1-259. Supporting Documentation Encl ML20203K0651986-08-0101 August 1986 Prefiled Testimony of RM Bimber & D Gitlin Re Waste Disposal Permit for Facility.Related Correspondence ML20204E9961986-07-24024 July 1986 Transcript of Commission 860724 Status Briefing on Facility Restart in Washington,Dc.Pp 1-61.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20207F6381986-07-19019 July 1986 Testimony of D Briden,Gf Bennett,Js Bland,Dm Hendron, CE Herdendorf,R Hetherington,Wb Jackson & Re Linnemann Re Burial of Very Low Level Waste at Davis-Besse.Related Correspondence ML20207F3801986-07-17017 July 1986 Testimony of DE Guy,Rr Pavey,Jh Marshall & J Yoytek Supporting State of Oh Petition to Intervene in Proposed Waste Burial Plan.Related Info Encl.W/Certificate of Svc. Related Correspondence ML20206R7181986-06-27027 June 1986 Transcript of ACRS Subcommittee on Davis-Besse Restart 860627 Meeting in Washington,Dc.Pp 1-110.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20206J4891986-06-25025 June 1986 Testimony of D Gitlin to Be Presented on 860625 in Sandusky, Oh Requesting Rescission of NRC Approval of Proposed Sludge Disposal Project ML20206J4541986-06-14014 June 1986 Testimony of RM Bimber Requesting Rescission of Onsite Waste Disposal Permit &/Or Advance Approval of Release of Dumpsite for Unrestricted Use at Time of Decommissioning ML20151Y8351986-02-0606 February 1986 Transcript of ACRS Subcommittee on Davis-Besse Nuclear Station Unit 1 Restart 860206 Meeting in Washington,Dc. Pp 1-169.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20137T3141986-02-0606 February 1986 Statement Before Subcommittee on Energy & Environ, Committee on Interior & Insular Affairs,Us House of Representatives Re FY87 Budget ML20138Q0771985-12-18018 December 1985 Transcript of 851218 Briefing on Restart from 850609 Event in Washington,Dc.Pp 1-102.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20133F2361985-10-0404 October 1985 Transcript of ACRS Subcommittee on Davis-Besse 851004 Meeting in Oak Harbor,Oh Re Review of Course of Action Prior to Restart of Plant.Pp 1-117 ML20132A4241985-09-18018 September 1985 Transcript of 850918 Public Meeting in Washington,Dc Re Continuation of Briefing on Plant.Pp 1-80.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20132A4001985-09-17017 September 1985 Transcript of Commission 850917 Public Meeting in Washington,Dc to Continue 850724 Briefing on Davis-Besse 850609 Event.Pp 1-89.Viewgraphs Encl IA-86-787, Transcript of 850904 Meeting in Bethesda,Md Re Util Planned Action on 850609 Event.Pp 1-235.Supporting Documentation Encl,Incuding NRC 850828 Meeting Agenda & Viewgraphs of Util 850917 Presentation to NRC1985-09-0404 September 1985 Transcript of 850904 Meeting in Bethesda,Md Re Util Planned Action on 850609 Event.Pp 1-235.Supporting Documentation Encl,Incuding NRC 850828 Meeting Agenda & Viewgraphs of Util 850917 Presentation to NRC ML20215E1871985-09-0404 September 1985 Transcript of 850904 Meeting in Bethesda,Md Re Util Planned Action on 850609 Event.Pp 1-235.Supporting Documentation Encl,Incuding NRC 850828 Meeting Agenda & Viewgraphs of Util 850917 Presentation to NRC ML20129B8461985-07-12012 July 1985 Transcript of 850712 Closed Meeting in Oak Harbor,Oh Re Status Rept on Quarantined Equipment Resulting from 850609 Event.Pp 91-248.Related Documentation Encl ML20129B9411985-07-12012 July 1985 Transcript of 850712 Closed Meeting in Oak Harbor,Oh Re Status Rept on Quarantine Equipment Resulting from 850609 Event.Pp 1-90.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20129B6791985-07-11011 July 1985 Transcript of 850711 Closed Meeting Re Steam Feed Rupture Control Sys Equipment & Operations.Pp 1-72 ML20129B9121985-07-11011 July 1985 Transcript of 850711 Closed Meeting in Oak Harbor,Oh Re Steam & Feedwater Rupture Control Sys Training.Pp 1-20 ML20129B9071985-07-10010 July 1985 Transcript of NRC Fact-Finding Team 850710 Closed Meeting W/Util in Oak Harbor,Oh Re 850609 Sequence of Events. Pp 1-24 ML20129B0751985-07-10010 July 1985 Transcript of 850710 Closed Meeting W/Util in Oak Harbor,Oh Re Steam Feed Rupture Control Sys Actuated Equipment & Operations.Pp 1-37.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20129B8861985-07-0909 July 1985 Transcript of 850709 Closed Meeting in Oak Harbor,Oh Re Addl Info Request Concerning Serial 517 Ltr & Pump Capacities of Equipment Used to Mitigate Total Loss of Feed. Pp 1-24.Related Documentation Encl ML20129B1021985-07-0909 July 1985 Transcript of 850709 Meeting W/Util in Oak Harbor,Oh Re PORV Controls & Instrumentation.Pp 1-9.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20129B8221985-07-0909 July 1985 Transcript of 850709 Closed Meeting in Oak Harbor,Oh Re Steam & Feedwater Rupture Control Sys Operations & Action Plan to Troubleshoot 850609 Anomalies.Pp 1-69 ML20129B0801985-07-0909 July 1985 Transcript of 850709 Closed Meeting W/Util in Oak Harbor,Oh Re Procedures Concerning Startup Feed Pump & Main Feed Pump Following Steam Feed Rupture Control Sys Actuation.Pp 1-43. Supporting Documentation Encl ML20129C1051985-06-27027 June 1985 Transcript of Fact-Finding Task Force 850627 Closed Meeting in Bethesda,Md Re 850609 Event.Pp 1-33.Related Documentation Encl ML20129B5981985-06-21021 June 1985 Transcript of 850621 Interview of R Osburn in Oak Harbor,Oh Re 850609 Event.Pp 1-11 ML20129B6181985-06-21021 June 1985 Transcript of 850621 Meeting in Oak Harbor,Oh Re Results of Troubleshooting & Identification of Root Cause of 850609 Event.Pp 1-140 ML20129B1811985-06-21021 June 1985 Transcript of 850621 Joint Interview of Quennoz & W O'Connor in Oak Harbor,Oh Re 850609 Event.Pp 1-53 ML20129B5681985-06-21021 June 1985 Transcript of 850621 Interview of W Rogers in Oak Harbor,Oh Re 850609 Event.Pp 1-17 ML20129B7751985-06-20020 June 1985 Transcript of 850620 Meeting in Oak Harbor,Oh Re Troubleshooting Action Plans for Auxiliary Feedwater Pumps Following 850609 Event.Pp 1-79 ML20129B4241985-06-20020 June 1985 Transcript of 850620 Interview of W Rogers in Oak Harbor,Oh Re 850609 Event.Pp 1-163 ML20129B4601985-06-19019 June 1985 Transcript of 850619 Meeting in Oak Harbor,Oh Re Action Plans for NI-1 Source Range Channel Following 850609 Event ML20129B5611985-06-19019 June 1985 Transcript of 850619 Joint Interview of T Lehman & Feasel in Oak Harbor,Oh Re 850609 Event.Pp 1-50 ML20129B7061985-06-19019 June 1985 Transcript of 850619 Meeting in Oak Harbor,Oh Re Action Plan on Turbine Bypass Valve Following 850609 Event.Pp 1-29 ML20129B5501985-06-18018 June 1985 Transcript of 850618 Meeting in Oak Harbor,Oh Re Action Plan for Main Feedwater Pump Control Sys Following 850609 Event. Pp 1-24 ML20129B0511985-06-18018 June 1985 Transcript of 850618 Interview of T Lang in Oak Harbor,Oh Re 850609 Event.Pp 1-49 ML20129B0461985-06-18018 June 1985 Transcript of 850618 Meeting in Oak Harbor,Oh Re Sequence of Events Discussion for 850609 Event.Pp 1-34.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20129D3761985-06-17017 June 1985 Transcript of 850617 Meeting W/Util in Bethesda,Md Re Auxiliary Feedwater Sys.Pp 1-50.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20129B0491985-06-17017 June 1985 Transcript of Interviews in Oak Harbor,Oh of Equipment Operators C Burns,J Meleg,M Klein & B Morrison Re 850609 Event.Pp 1-145.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20129B1271985-06-15015 June 1985 Transcript of 850615 Joint Interview of L Simon & SM Quennoz in Oak Harbor,Oh Re 850609 Event.Pp 1-78 ML20129C0591985-06-15015 June 1985 Transcript of Afternoon Session of 850615 Proceedings in Oak Harbor,Oh Re Guidelines for Troubleshooting or Performing Investigative Actions Into Root Causes Surrounding 850609 Event.Pp 1-15 ML20129B0661985-06-14014 June 1985 Transcript of 850614 Interview of R Walleman in Oak Harbor,Oh Re 850609 Event.Pp 1-114 ML20129B0841985-06-14014 June 1985 Transcript of 850614 Equipment Meeting in Oak Harbor,Oh Re 850609 Event.Pp 1-100.Supporting Documentation Encl 1992-06-29
[Table view] Category:NARRATIVE TESTIMONY
MONTHYEARML20101K2691992-06-29029 June 1992 City of Cleveland Proposed Corrections to Oral Argument Transcript of 920610.* W/Certificate of Svc & Svc List ML20214J0691986-11-21021 November 1986 Transcript of Commission 861121 Public Meeting in Washington,Dc Re Discussion/Possible Vote on Plant Restart. Pp 1-63.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20205C7691986-08-0707 August 1986 Transcript of 860807 Hearing in Sandusky,Oh.Pp 567-972. Supporting Documentation Encl ML20205C7801986-08-0606 August 1986 Transcript of 860806 Hearing in Sandusky,Oh.Pp 260-509. Supporting Documentation Encl ML20212F6431986-08-0606 August 1986 Transcript of 860806 Limited Appearances Session in Sandusky,Oh.Pp 510-566 ML20205C7931986-08-0505 August 1986 Transcript of 860805 Hearing in Sandusky,Oh.Pp 1-259. Supporting Documentation Encl ML20203K0651986-08-0101 August 1986 Prefiled Testimony of RM Bimber & D Gitlin Re Waste Disposal Permit for Facility.Related Correspondence ML20204E9961986-07-24024 July 1986 Transcript of Commission 860724 Status Briefing on Facility Restart in Washington,Dc.Pp 1-61.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20207F6381986-07-19019 July 1986 Testimony of D Briden,Gf Bennett,Js Bland,Dm Hendron, CE Herdendorf,R Hetherington,Wb Jackson & Re Linnemann Re Burial of Very Low Level Waste at Davis-Besse.Related Correspondence ML20207F3801986-07-17017 July 1986 Testimony of DE Guy,Rr Pavey,Jh Marshall & J Yoytek Supporting State of Oh Petition to Intervene in Proposed Waste Burial Plan.Related Info Encl.W/Certificate of Svc. Related Correspondence ML20206R7181986-06-27027 June 1986 Transcript of ACRS Subcommittee on Davis-Besse Restart 860627 Meeting in Washington,Dc.Pp 1-110.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20206J4891986-06-25025 June 1986 Testimony of D Gitlin to Be Presented on 860625 in Sandusky, Oh Requesting Rescission of NRC Approval of Proposed Sludge Disposal Project ML20206J4541986-06-14014 June 1986 Testimony of RM Bimber Requesting Rescission of Onsite Waste Disposal Permit &/Or Advance Approval of Release of Dumpsite for Unrestricted Use at Time of Decommissioning ML20151Y8351986-02-0606 February 1986 Transcript of ACRS Subcommittee on Davis-Besse Nuclear Station Unit 1 Restart 860206 Meeting in Washington,Dc. Pp 1-169.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20137T3141986-02-0606 February 1986 Statement Before Subcommittee on Energy & Environ, Committee on Interior & Insular Affairs,Us House of Representatives Re FY87 Budget ML20138Q0771985-12-18018 December 1985 Transcript of 851218 Briefing on Restart from 850609 Event in Washington,Dc.Pp 1-102.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20133F2361985-10-0404 October 1985 Transcript of ACRS Subcommittee on Davis-Besse 851004 Meeting in Oak Harbor,Oh Re Review of Course of Action Prior to Restart of Plant.Pp 1-117 ML20132A4241985-09-18018 September 1985 Transcript of 850918 Public Meeting in Washington,Dc Re Continuation of Briefing on Plant.Pp 1-80.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20132A4001985-09-17017 September 1985 Transcript of Commission 850917 Public Meeting in Washington,Dc to Continue 850724 Briefing on Davis-Besse 850609 Event.Pp 1-89.Viewgraphs Encl IA-86-787, Transcript of 850904 Meeting in Bethesda,Md Re Util Planned Action on 850609 Event.Pp 1-235.Supporting Documentation Encl,Incuding NRC 850828 Meeting Agenda & Viewgraphs of Util 850917 Presentation to NRC1985-09-0404 September 1985 Transcript of 850904 Meeting in Bethesda,Md Re Util Planned Action on 850609 Event.Pp 1-235.Supporting Documentation Encl,Incuding NRC 850828 Meeting Agenda & Viewgraphs of Util 850917 Presentation to NRC ML20215E1871985-09-0404 September 1985 Transcript of 850904 Meeting in Bethesda,Md Re Util Planned Action on 850609 Event.Pp 1-235.Supporting Documentation Encl,Incuding NRC 850828 Meeting Agenda & Viewgraphs of Util 850917 Presentation to NRC ML20129B8461985-07-12012 July 1985 Transcript of 850712 Closed Meeting in Oak Harbor,Oh Re Status Rept on Quarantined Equipment Resulting from 850609 Event.Pp 91-248.Related Documentation Encl ML20129B9411985-07-12012 July 1985 Transcript of 850712 Closed Meeting in Oak Harbor,Oh Re Status Rept on Quarantine Equipment Resulting from 850609 Event.Pp 1-90.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20129B6791985-07-11011 July 1985 Transcript of 850711 Closed Meeting Re Steam Feed Rupture Control Sys Equipment & Operations.Pp 1-72 ML20129B9121985-07-11011 July 1985 Transcript of 850711 Closed Meeting in Oak Harbor,Oh Re Steam & Feedwater Rupture Control Sys Training.Pp 1-20 ML20129B9071985-07-10010 July 1985 Transcript of NRC Fact-Finding Team 850710 Closed Meeting W/Util in Oak Harbor,Oh Re 850609 Sequence of Events. Pp 1-24 ML20129B0751985-07-10010 July 1985 Transcript of 850710 Closed Meeting W/Util in Oak Harbor,Oh Re Steam Feed Rupture Control Sys Actuated Equipment & Operations.Pp 1-37.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20129B8861985-07-0909 July 1985 Transcript of 850709 Closed Meeting in Oak Harbor,Oh Re Addl Info Request Concerning Serial 517 Ltr & Pump Capacities of Equipment Used to Mitigate Total Loss of Feed. Pp 1-24.Related Documentation Encl ML20129B1021985-07-0909 July 1985 Transcript of 850709 Meeting W/Util in Oak Harbor,Oh Re PORV Controls & Instrumentation.Pp 1-9.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20129B8221985-07-0909 July 1985 Transcript of 850709 Closed Meeting in Oak Harbor,Oh Re Steam & Feedwater Rupture Control Sys Operations & Action Plan to Troubleshoot 850609 Anomalies.Pp 1-69 ML20129B0801985-07-0909 July 1985 Transcript of 850709 Closed Meeting W/Util in Oak Harbor,Oh Re Procedures Concerning Startup Feed Pump & Main Feed Pump Following Steam Feed Rupture Control Sys Actuation.Pp 1-43. Supporting Documentation Encl ML20129C1051985-06-27027 June 1985 Transcript of Fact-Finding Task Force 850627 Closed Meeting in Bethesda,Md Re 850609 Event.Pp 1-33.Related Documentation Encl ML20129B5981985-06-21021 June 1985 Transcript of 850621 Interview of R Osburn in Oak Harbor,Oh Re 850609 Event.Pp 1-11 ML20129B6181985-06-21021 June 1985 Transcript of 850621 Meeting in Oak Harbor,Oh Re Results of Troubleshooting & Identification of Root Cause of 850609 Event.Pp 1-140 ML20129B1811985-06-21021 June 1985 Transcript of 850621 Joint Interview of Quennoz & W O'Connor in Oak Harbor,Oh Re 850609 Event.Pp 1-53 ML20129B5681985-06-21021 June 1985 Transcript of 850621 Interview of W Rogers in Oak Harbor,Oh Re 850609 Event.Pp 1-17 ML20129B7751985-06-20020 June 1985 Transcript of 850620 Meeting in Oak Harbor,Oh Re Troubleshooting Action Plans for Auxiliary Feedwater Pumps Following 850609 Event.Pp 1-79 ML20129B4241985-06-20020 June 1985 Transcript of 850620 Interview of W Rogers in Oak Harbor,Oh Re 850609 Event.Pp 1-163 ML20129B4601985-06-19019 June 1985 Transcript of 850619 Meeting in Oak Harbor,Oh Re Action Plans for NI-1 Source Range Channel Following 850609 Event ML20129B5611985-06-19019 June 1985 Transcript of 850619 Joint Interview of T Lehman & Feasel in Oak Harbor,Oh Re 850609 Event.Pp 1-50 ML20129B7061985-06-19019 June 1985 Transcript of 850619 Meeting in Oak Harbor,Oh Re Action Plan on Turbine Bypass Valve Following 850609 Event.Pp 1-29 ML20129B5501985-06-18018 June 1985 Transcript of 850618 Meeting in Oak Harbor,Oh Re Action Plan for Main Feedwater Pump Control Sys Following 850609 Event. Pp 1-24 ML20129B0511985-06-18018 June 1985 Transcript of 850618 Interview of T Lang in Oak Harbor,Oh Re 850609 Event.Pp 1-49 ML20129B0461985-06-18018 June 1985 Transcript of 850618 Meeting in Oak Harbor,Oh Re Sequence of Events Discussion for 850609 Event.Pp 1-34.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20129D3761985-06-17017 June 1985 Transcript of 850617 Meeting W/Util in Bethesda,Md Re Auxiliary Feedwater Sys.Pp 1-50.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20129B0491985-06-17017 June 1985 Transcript of Interviews in Oak Harbor,Oh of Equipment Operators C Burns,J Meleg,M Klein & B Morrison Re 850609 Event.Pp 1-145.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20129B1271985-06-15015 June 1985 Transcript of 850615 Joint Interview of L Simon & SM Quennoz in Oak Harbor,Oh Re 850609 Event.Pp 1-78 ML20129C0591985-06-15015 June 1985 Transcript of Afternoon Session of 850615 Proceedings in Oak Harbor,Oh Re Guidelines for Troubleshooting or Performing Investigative Actions Into Root Causes Surrounding 850609 Event.Pp 1-15 ML20129B0661985-06-14014 June 1985 Transcript of 850614 Interview of R Walleman in Oak Harbor,Oh Re 850609 Event.Pp 1-114 ML20129B0841985-06-14014 June 1985 Transcript of 850614 Equipment Meeting in Oak Harbor,Oh Re 850609 Event.Pp 1-100.Supporting Documentation Encl 1992-06-29
[Table view] |
Text
_
.l ,
d
- UNITED STATES L. 9 ?.
NUCLEAR REGULA'IORY COMMISSION -
\ '
IN THE MATTER OF.
f DAVIS-BESSE INCIDENT . .
L k
L f (INTERVIEW AND MEETING) .
=
(CLOSED) a
_ SFRCS TRAINING B
r 5
LOCATION: OAK HARBOR, OHIO Pages 1 - 20 h
= DATE: July 11, 1985 a _
g 7 l ..
ACE FEDERAL REPORTERS Official Reporters 444 North Capitol Street 3"M"n;";A -
8507290295 850711 PDR ADOCK 05000346 .i j,
g T PDR -
-5
-Joe Wal 1
1 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 2 NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION 3
~
-3 ------
~4 , THURSDAY, JULY 11, 1985 5 ------
6 7 MEETING BETWEEN THE NRC FACT-FINDING TEAM AND TOLEDO ~ EDISON 8 ON 9 SFRCS TRAINING 10 II ~NRC FACT-FINDING !1 EMBERS PRESENT:
.I .
12 DR. ROSSI 13 J. T. BEARD 14 L. BELL 15 16 TOLEDO EDISON MEMBERS PRESENT:'
17 J. LINGENFELTER l 18 R. SIMPKINS 19 W. ROGERS N
21 22 23 24
' Ace Federal Reporters, Inc.
25
s' i
5 47'-1-SueWalsh I PRO-CEEDINCS
'2 , (12 : 00 p.m. ) *
.3 MR. ROSSI: This is going to be a short discus-4 sion -- I hope a short discussion -- on operator training 5 related tci the SFRCS ' manual actuation. And we had a call i
0 from Wa'yne Lanning, who is a member of our Team, yesterday, 7 ~and he referred to a January 31st, 1985 letter to John' Stoles
'8 on the subject of, I guess, inadvertent actuations of SPRCS.
9 And he indicated that1that letter stated that the
- 10 fact that inadvertent low pressure actuation of the SFRCS
'II could ~1ock all other actuations, and that the main point wo 12 want to talk about-is that the letter indicated that the 13
-operators had been-trained on that potential and that fixes I4 ,w ere being; considered.
15 MR.-BEARD: ,.You know, I would like to make sure we
-16
. understand th~e first part,[too, what theyLmean by that
~
'I7 ,~
. statement at some --
18 MR. ROSSI: Yeah. And'so with thatzsort of intro-I9 duction, could[you tell'us what you know of statements that s
20 were madefin the letter, and what sort of training'had-the 21 '
operators been'.provided?: 1 22 MR. LINGENFELTER: Okay. 1Let me-lead into that, 23
. because I was the author of the letter.
2
- AhFEbd Rga%n,lm.
And the' statement was made describing the fact I
25
, that we; knew the' operators who were aware of the misarrangement'
, ; j l-
n 1
3 1
1 t7-2-SueWalsh of the actuation switches. 4
, 2 'MR. ROSSI: Okay. Now, the misarrangement has to I
3 do with the diagonal arrangement of the two buttons that 4 they would push under certain circumstances, rather than 5 having them located right on the same horizontal line.
6 MR. LINGENFELTER: That is correit.
'7 MR. ROSSI: Okay.
8 MR. LINGENFELTER: And my basis ior making that 9 statement was.that people who have taken the licensed opera--
~
10 . tor training in.my group' knew that that training had been 11 provided. In other words, I did not go back and look at all 12 the training records- to find out exactly where it was
.13 covered, but we have people - 'we knew the operators who 14 are aware of that particular problem.
15 And that'was.what my sentence was based'upon'.
16 MR. BEARD: .Okay. Let me ask you, Jack, on this 17 statement -- this state $ent apparently was made that if low-18 pressure manual actuation occurs'it " blocks other inputs.'"
< ~
19 What does that mean?. >
20 MR.- LINGENFELTER: No, no. It doesn't block other 21 inputs.- Well, it woul'd override actual inputs,.just like 22 _in the' event that happened on the 9th.
- 23 This statement was - made that_ if you push -- in a 24 non-diagonal'-fashion,-you. push the low pressurefbutton.so
- Ace-Federal Reporters, Inc.
25 that one channel recognizes one. steam generator is bad and
1 l
4 l
.#7-3-SueWalshi the'other channel recognizes the opposite generator is bad, ~
P
, 2 then both steam generators get isolated; 599 and 608 go
,3 closed. So that cuts off:the-feedwater.
4 ~ MR. ROSSI: That was the meaning of your statement?
5 MR. LINGENFELTER: Yes.
6 MR. ROSSI: That was the meaning _ of your statement?
7 MR. LINGENFELTER: It doesn't change anything 8 ~ else. .I mean, all the' main feed isolation occurs,'everything.
9 else. ~ But the problem becomes that you don't have any-10 auxiliary feedwater.
11 -MR. BEARD: So, you are really, if I understand you
'12 right, referring to the fact that the way the. system is de-13 signed all the low pressure actuation inputs have priority over 14 all'other-inputs. And in that sense it-sort of blocks other 15 s ignals and also cuts off aux _feedwater input?
16 MR. LINGENFELTER: Right.
17 MR. ] BEARD: Okay.
18 MR. LINGENFELTER: That's fair.
, -19 ~MR."lBEARD: I think.I u'nderstand what you were-
~
l 20 referring ~to.:
- 21 MR. ROSSI: Okay. 'Now, what can you today -- what L 22 do you know about the' training of.the specific' operator'that
~
23 was on duty that: pushed the switches incorrectly on June 9th? ~
24 Do you know anything.about whether he had had l
- Aes.deral it.porten, lac 25 training related to-the switches? If you don't know --
, , . .,. , , , , ~-, - - , . , .,
5
- 7-4-SueWalsh] 'MR. SIMPKINS: I'm pretty sure that he had. I :
, 2 can't verify it positively. But I know that -- how the 3 licensed 1 group that he went-through -- I can't verify that.
4 I know how the licensed group that he went through had the 5 trainin'g on the SFRCS and also the ATOG training that was 6 conducted later, last year, the November / December time frame.
7 IIe had a f specific transient where -- in fact, it 8 was a B&W'run transient that ran on a computer printout, all 9 the stuff with the safety bit to verify when they got in 10 that section>of the emergency procedure that they would actuate 11 on low pressure.
t 12 MR. ROSSI: IIad they -- what sort of general train-13 ing do you give to the operators related to the switches? 'Do 14 you take them into the control room and show them the switches or -- 7 15 16 MR. SIMPKINS: Th'is training,-the ATOG, we physically 17 walk them through a mockup control room.
18 j MR.!ROSSI: A mockup; control room?. 4 19 MR. SIMPKINSi Yeah.
20 MR.;LINGENFELTER: You know, the control room mock-
- 21 up was' prepared for the control room design, to be used as a' 22 training -- sort of a training aid.
23 MR. ROSSI: Okay.- So you walked them through a 24 mockup control' room, and there you have the switches mocked'up.
. Ae-Federal Reporters, Inc.
~
25 And do they -- do you know if those switches on that c -
k.
6
~
- 7-5-SueWalshi mockup have the little red tape under the fourth buttons 2 down that are used for. low level?
Do you happen to know?
3 MR. SIMPKINS: I would have to,look. I don't
'4 know or don't remember what time the. pictures'were taken.
~
5 MR. LINGENFELTER: I couldn't tell you on,that.
~6 MR. ROSSI: Is the mockup here now? Is it at 7 the' site? Is it in this building?
8 MR. LINGENFELTER: It's over towards the plant.
9 It's outside the protected area.- It's a little -- not that
'10 direction. It's in a little warehouse building.
11 MR. ROSSI: Is it a full-scale mockup?
12
. MR. LINGENFELTER: Yes.
13 MR; ROSSI: Okay. If we were to go over and 14 look at it today and what'ever the status is of the red tape,:
15 would there'be any guarantee or assurance that iftthe red 16 tape is not there today that it wasn't there then, or vice-I7 versa?
18 MR. LINGENFELTER:, No, there wouldn't be any
-I9 ~
assurance,,but,myf feeling is that-the red tape was.put 20 there .for the serious contmal room fire!which came~ up in --
21 that evolution occurred.in '84.'
22 MR. SIMPKINS: Late '84-I believe.
23
. MR. LINGENFELTER: And'the mockup was based on 24
.the status of the plant as of '83. There have been some
.' Ace-Federal Reporters, IrM:.
25 changes made:to it that I doubt-that that tape addition was-
~
7
!#i-6-SueWalsh l made.-- in fact, I'm sure that the tape addition would not
, 2 have been made.
3 14R . ROSSI: So the tape would not have been there
-4 lwhen.they were' training? And really the training on the 5 manual actuation of the SFRCS is primarily based on the
..6 mockup:and not in the control room training?
7 MR. SIMPKINS: Well, for this particular training 8 lit was only because we had a mockup available. We hadn't 9 had it before.
i l
'10 MR. LINGENFELTER: The tape you'are referring to 11 is on the low' level?
12 MR. ROSSI:- The -- yes.
13 MR. LINGENFELTER: Okay. Now, the particular 14 question we are talking.' about here, - of course, is:the' cross 15 pattern-of the low'p'ressure switches. The tape --
16 MR. ROSSI: Would have no distinguishing marks 17 ..there other;than just knowing. '. >
18 MR. SIMPKINS: The operators'were. walked through-19 the control . room for differe'nti pr'o' edures J
c and shown the red -
20 tape from the low level. trip buttons in: the actual control 21 ~ room.- But I can't swear that this guy that pushed the wrong 22 buttons was'a reactor operator at'the~ time that he did that 23 - or-not.
24 I'm not sure.
keFeared Remem, lac. J l
25 'MR. BELL: In your training lecture for the' steam l
8 c
'.#7-7-SueWal and feedwater rupture control system, do you point out to
. 2 Ethe operators that ifLthe-two end line buttons are pressed 3 ,
that part of-the SPRCS design is-adversely effected?
4 MR. SIMPKINS: The last time it was given in 5 requalify the.SFRCS lecture was in '83, and the information i,
- 6 I found ~ on that, there'is nothing that specifically said,
- 7 you know,
- that'this is required. All the design basis I 8 ' 'think was gone through'as'far as how it actuates on low.
9 pressure.- But I can't guarantee.
I.
1 3 10 I: sat through.the lecture, but-I just can't 11 remember if he specifically said.two low pressure buttons 12 one on each side would enable the~ aux feed system.
4
{ .-
.13 The lecture going,on currently now,.which is 14 -after the fact, certainly/ points it out.
15 MR. ROSSI: So there may'not h' ave been a lot of 16 . stress.in the' training on all those problems with the
, 17 : butt'ons? ,
-18 MR..SIMPKINS: I knowfit was brought.up that i 19 you have to' cross the'bbttons. - But I' can ' t verify that it
~
120 was" brought up,lwhat happens-if you don't.
'21 LI know that'it was brought up, _the actuation-on
' 22 ~
low level if you only hit one:and only hit one actuation
'23
, channel. ..But I can't.: swear if that was_ covered.
4 24 MR.~. BELL: . Jack, had your. department. considered
= Ac F.d.mi n.p ,ws, inc.
25 the possibility of this incident; prior .to its occurrence?
L s-L
9
)7?8-SueWalsh 1 MR. LINGENFELTER: You mean in specific terms 2 of having a guy push the top two buttons?
3 MR. BELL: Or -- yes, the top two buttons.
4 MR. LINGENFELTER: Okay. The top two buttons, 5 -as opposed to if you were trying to push .it on low pressure,
. 6 diagonal. That was specifically.what we had been concerned 7 with when we -- in the human engineering discrepancy,.the HED, 8 that we had.
9 .In other words, we never -- we never contemplate'd 10 ~ that'-he would hit the top two buttons instead of the fourth 11 ones down, if that's what you are aiming at.
12 MR. BELL: That's what..I wasiasking, yes. .The 13 consequences of inadverte'nt actuation on SFRCS on a low.
14 . steam generator pressure in Number ~ l' steam generator and a 15 low steam generator pressure"in Number 2 steam generator.
16 MR. LINGENFELTER: Ye'ah . With the- HED, we 17 ' identified, we'lo"oked'at'that problem and again as opposed 18 to -- the problem we are ? actually looking at here, is he hit
- 19 the top two buttons instead of the fourth one down. We didn't 20 - think ofEthat as part of the HED I ' guess.
21 MR. BEARD: Let's see if I can summarize and'make
~
22 sure I understand. Because of the HED, the deficiency, I.get 23 .- the. impression 'that you .made sure that at your training 24 / program ~you emphasized:to the operators that.if they have a Ace-Federal Reporters, Inc.
25 steam generator they had to use the diagonal approach rather f
,. t _
__ , , _ , . _ .- e .. . -4,, ,. <-
10 Ili-9-SueWalshi than'some other approach.
' ^
. 2 MR. LINGENFELTER: Right.
3 MR. BEARD: All right. Now, that's the point 4 number one. Point number two is, I don't think I hear you 5 saying that you emphasize in the training that if he were 6 to push it straight across the impact on what that would -
7 have'on other. actuation signals such as low level.
8 MR. LINGENFELTER: That specific action and its 9 consequences and its impact on plant was probably not pointed 10 .out.
11 MR. BEARD: The point I'm trying to get at is, i
12 .I.think you were emphasizing when you got this situation, 13 here is ' the right way to do - it.
.14 MR. LINGENFELThR: Right.
15 ,
MR. BEARD: And you probably also -- or, I would 16 guess th'e instructor would have said- if hel did + 1t straight 17 across that's the wrong way to do it. You know, I.would 18 imagine that would be a typical part'of the lecture.
19 But, what I'm trying to 'get to is, you .didn' t
' 20 really point 'out that if he does it in the straight horizonta:
21 manner, he not only doesn'.t get what he wanted to get but he, 22 in effect, blocks the SFRCS from.other. inputs, which seems 23 .to be the statement which was made in the letter.
4 24 See, the statement in-the letter, as it was read
- AciFedwol llepo .cs, Inc.
25 to me yesterday,-was -- and it was-read verbatim, and
11
- 7-10-SueWalsh obviously I don 't have it-h1 frontof me, and you don't either - -
r
. 2 but it said that we recognize that when you have low pres-3 sure. actuation that this blocks all the other inputs.to 4 the.'SFRCS system. But our operators have all been trained
'S on'this, and they are'all checked out, and they know about 6 : this potential problem.
7 MR. LINGENFELTER: No, that's not the way it
'8 reads.
9 MR. BEARD: Okay. That's where --
- 10 MR. LINGENFELTER: That was certainly not the II
~
Lintent of the' thing. 'And I may have to go back and get-a
~
12 copy of tit for you.-
13
~
But, it was -- and it really hadn't to do with ,
14 the blocking ' of other . signals. It was --- we were more 15 ' concerned about the blocking of feedwater specifically with 16 that" activity.
17 And again.we were basing it on the assumption 18 that the only time the guy would even aim his fingers at 19 .those. top buttons would be if he were.trying to actuate i
20 a low-pressure.
21 MR. BEARD:' Okay.
22 MR. LINGENFELTER: 'So, what we'were concerned 23 with'is that he understood that~he had to hit the diagonal.
'24 MR. BEARD: Right.
Ace-Federal Reporters, Inc.
25 MR. LINGENFELTER: It wasn't'a. matter.of -- the
i 12
' #'7-11-SueWalsh - thing that we were trying to come across with had nothing 2 . to do'with what happened here in terms of hitting the top 3 buttons .versus the - fourth ones .down.
4 MR. ROSSI: Is part of your standard training 5 and policy at this plant that the operators should manually 16 initiate safety functions when they see that they are on the
-7 way to being automatically initiated?
8 ' I mean, is that something that is a standard 9 policy?
10 MR. SIMPKINS: No. In fact,-it's specifically 11 not to be done in the safety features.
' 12 The only system that is manually actuated is SFRCS by the proce' dure-which says if the automatic actuation
~
13 14 fails'to actuate it on low' level. And that.is-strongly 15 : emphasized throughout. training.
e END #7 16 M.Simons flws 17 ,
18 19 20 l 21 1
22 l i
l l-
'23 I~ 24
' Ace-Federal Reporters, Inc.
25 l
i e-
___L....___...m . _ E- _.m__..m._ ... _ ____._.__._____._.___._________._.__._.m.__ .__.-_-___.m_.m_m____.._.___.____m.._m.___:__._.._____-______u.______.- _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
13
.Sim 8 MR. ROSSI: Is it a policy at the plant or part
.)
. of the training that when you have a loss of main feedwater a
. 2 transient that the operators should manually initiate the 3
SFRCS low level in anticipation or prior to giving the 4
automatic- signal?
MR. SIMPKINS: It was strongly emphasized to follow the emergency procedure and that guides you into 7
. actuating on low level if SFRCS does not actuate.
MR. ROSSI: 5 Dut only if it doesn't actuate 9
automatically and there is nothing that says do it in 10 anticipation?
) 11 MR. SIMPKINS: That is not true. It does in a 12
~
- r und-about way because if you get into loss of coolant or 13 lack of heat transfer, then you actuate SFRCS and verify your j4
~
15
. raised steam generator levels i to'12'4 inchesa and trip?Ehe #
reactor coolant pump.
16 j7 MR. BEARD :- You are.the guy that trains the 18 perators, right, or one of your guys?
^
.j9 MR. SIMPKINS :=' I~was involved in some of the 20 training, yes.
21 MR.: BEARD: .Would your~ training have included 22 consideration of.that if you lose level in the generator 23 f r whatever reason. arid you are approaching the . automatic 24 actuation point that it might be a good idea to conserve
. hFederal Reporters, Inc.
25 what inventory is in there and that one way one might do .
R
.'____.___._________________.._________._____________. __.___._____._____m _____.__1_
14
$im.8-2' .1 that-is to go ahead and manually actuate the low level
- 2 actuation? i 3 'MR . SIMPKINSe No.
4 MR. BEARD: That is not part of your training? j 5 MR. SIMPKINS: It is not part of the training.
6 The dead band between low-level limits and the SFRCS trip 7 setpoint is so close that'iteis ---
8 MR..LINGENFELTER: :That:isf_ifnyou are in a< post -
9 trip situation, which we have been in a number of times. I 10 -
think I know.the direction of your question. It is not II uncommon, nor is it prohibited specifically for an operator 12 to manually actuate SFRCS in the situation he was in because 13 the levels were dropping and the speed on the turbine was 14 dropping and he knew he was going to buy it sooner or later.
15 The problem they have-with that is the way the 16 system' works. He turns right around'and fills them right 17 back up to where they already were in'a real-fast fashion.
18 They do not like' the overcoolingLtransient that results from 19 that. So they anticipate it.
20 ,~ MR. ROSSI: So it is'a policy at least at the
~
21 plant that they push the buttons _in= anticipation-of low level t
22 for the-kind of transient that occurred?
23 MR. LINGENFELTER:. It is not a firm policy. It 24 varies from shift to shift. It depends on.how they feel l Ace-Federal Reporters, Inc.
25 comfortable with-operating in.that particular/ situation.
i t
15
'Sim 8-3 i
~
Some shifts don't do that. But we, knowing the way the
. 2 system responds to it, have never specifically precluded 3 somebody from trying to do that, especially given their 1
4 . concern or. potential concern not knowing exactly the status 5 of the SFRCS.
m 6 MR. ROSSI: So maybe a correct way of stating 7 it is that the procedures neither tell them to do it, nor 8 tell them not'to do it.
9 MR. SIMPKINSr I would have to look at the 10 ' procedure. I can't remember the specifics on if for some 11 reason both-feed pumps were tripped at power with the 12 . supplementary steps telling'them.specifically what to do.
13 MR. ROSSIF We have that. procedure anyway.
14 MR. BEARD: Are you talking about the ATOG 15 procedure?-
16 MR. SIMPKINS: I believe that does tell you to 17 manually actuate it on low level if both feed-pumps go away 18 -on a trip and SFRCS doesn't' actuate.
~
I'9 MR. ROSSI: Well, there is a difference between what 20 .you said and,what he did. What I have heard you say several 21 times is that the procedure spedifically says that if you 22 don't.get the automaticiactuation'o,flSFRCS, then you manually
~
23 initiate it. And the question is does the procedure tell 24 him:to manually initiate-it before he gets the automatic Ace-Federal Reporters, Inc.
25 initiation in anticipation ---
l i-t__. _
16
,Sim-8-4
'I MR. SIMPKINS: It does because it doesn't mention'say the words-if SFRCS does not automatically
~
. 2 3 initiate in the places I am' thinking of, and it is just 4 : recalling from memory-the action that I am referring to.
5 .One of the. supplementary action steps is that you verify 6 proper feed water response. If not, you go to the next step 7 which asks has SFRCS actuated.
8 .MR. ROSSI: Well, we can check on the procedure 9 there. We don't really need to depend'on overybody's memory
~
10 of the procedure because we can look. .; -
.11
-NR. BEARD: Well, I guess the only thing that
'12 .
. I would like to make sure that I understand is that I gather-
.13 .
that'as'farlas the general training that all operators get, 14
.you do not emphasize or bring up that one should try to 15 manually actuate on low lcvul in anticipation of some 16 situation like Jack-referredsto, but that certain shifts 17 may.be more comfortable in choose to operate in that manner.
18 Is that a fair statement?-
19 -
MR.7 LINGENFELTER: J That would be my perception.
20 '
'I won't" speak fo'r: training.
21 MR.~ROSSI:',I.also heard-the statement that 22 '
the procedure may be written to.tell' them that if they have 23 SPRCS
~
a loss of' feed,that they should manually initiate 24 hFedoroI Reporters, Inc, and it doesn't say if--'it isn't initiated automatically or 25 anything. It may just say if I have lost main feed to
_. ._ ___ m . _ . - . _. ._
17
- Sim 8-5 j manually actuate SFRCS, but we can.look.
2 MR. SIMPKINS: I believe it uses the words
. 3 verify proper SFRCS actuation. I really can't remember.
4 MR. ROSSI: Well, we can check the procedure.
5 MR. BEARD: But it would be a follow-up action, 6 as I understand the way you are describing.it, to something 7 having not happened automatically.
8 MR. ROSSI: That is the question though. It may 9 or may not be, depending on how it is worded.
J 10 10R. BEARD: But what I hear the gentleman saying i
y r. is from memory, for whatever that is worth. What he 12 remembers is that the part that tells him to actuate is the 13 follow-uP to having him check to see if it happened already -
i 14 automatically.
15 MR. SIMPKINS.* Yes,
- i. <
, 16 MR. BEARD: Okay. And we can check the procedures j7 and_look at it. -
I i
18 MR. ROGERS:. .In y'our training an operator manually
, j9 actuating SFRCS on. low level, would/it be considered a 20 Procedural violation or-~in any way an imprudent operation 21 by-the operator, given the training.they have been-given ---
22 MR. SIMPKINS: To manually actuate SFRCS, no, by
- 23 no means no.
j- 24 MR. ROGERS: That is okay,
' Ase-Federal Reporters, Inc.
25 MR. ROSSI:- So the procedure doesn't prohibit I
i
- _____________.___ _ _ _ . _ . _ .. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . . _ _ . . _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ . . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ ~
18
- S'im18-6 j it either.
2 MR. SIMPKINS: Right.
3 MR. ROSSI:t . There is no prohibition in either 4 the training policy or the procedure for doing it. It is 5
left up to the operator's discretion basically.
MR. SIMPKINS: I can't remember the exact words 7 of the procedure. I am.sorry.
8 MR. ROSSI: We will have to check it.
9 MR. SIMPKINS: I don't_know if that is a fair 10 . statement to make.
gj MR. ROGERS: I guess I am just look at it from an i
12 operating phil' sophy. o for ' people that' hav'enhad: operator. licenses 13 and the general tradition that it happened given your'feedwater y problem and the problems you have had with rapid feedwater -
15 reduction. It is not an uncommon occurrence for your operators 16 to punch out SFRCS manually.
j7 MR. SIMPKINS: .Right.
18 MR. ROSSI: That hastbe~ e n :youriobs6rvatipn -is that;
, j9 they generally do do that.
20 MR. ROGERS: They are very concerned because of the 21 way rapid feedwater reduction operates. There is a two-minute 22 timer in there and there are some questions'in that two-minute 23 time frame when you are sitting there watching the feedwater 24 and.trying to get a feel for what is really going on, and as hFederal Reporters, Inc.
i 25 levels came.down, and if they feel that rapid feedwater
)
8:
19
'Sim'8-7 :1 _ reduction isn't going to take over and do what they want it 2 to do, I think it is a safe assessment ~to say that they go 3 ahead and take the system into SFRCS by manually actuating.
4 I think there have been cases where before the 5 manual actuation takes place, which they have intentions of 6 doing, the automatic system eventually takes over. There have
~7 been cases where they have been in that transition before.
8 Correct me if I am wrong.
9 MR. ROSSI: Larry.
10 MR. BELL: Would you tell me the length of the 11' lecture on the SFRCS system in the hot license training program?
12 MR. SIMPKINS: 'I believe it is four hours.- I am 13 pretty: sure that is about ' the length of it.
14 MR. BELL: Earlier you didn't mention the fact 15 that 'it was even included in the hot license program. You only 16 addressed a requalification lecture. So I wsanted to make 17 sure that it was included in the hot license program.
18 MR. SIMPKINS: There are also specific signoffs 1 .
~
19 before th'ey even go into the hot license class that that system 20 is checked out by a reactor operator. .
21 MR. BELL: On a slightly different subject if 22 you are in the training department. Would the area that you 23 work with include training on aux feedwater systems?
24 MR.'SIMPKINS: Yes.
AseFederal Reporters, lac.
25 MR. BELL: All right. In association with the
m 20 Sim 8 j training that you give the people, and I am referring
- 2 specifically to non-licensed individuals, is that in your 3 jurisdiction?
4 MR. SIMPKINS: Yes.
5 MR. BELL: Okay. Does that training include 6 recovery type operations, such as relatching the turbine 7 trip throttle valve?
g MR. SIMPKINS: Yes.
9 MR. BELL: So that from a training perspective 10 if a guy has been through your course and his card is 11 signed off, so to speak, on aux feedwater, one would expect 12 that=the guy knows how to reset the trip throttle valves?
13 MR. SIMPKINS: Yes.
14 MR. BELL: Thank you.
15 MR. ROSSI: .Anything more?
16 MR. BELL: No.
17 MR. ROSSI: Okay, that is the end of that then.
18 (Whereupon, at_12:10 p.m., the. meeting concluded.)
j9 ******'
~
20 ,
21 22 23 24 hr.d.e. hp.<=es, ix.
25
J .,__ _
, CERTIFICATE O? P RONELJ '. 35 k 2 3
This is to certify that the attached procee:iings before the 4 ::RC COCXXKEXIEX FACT FINDING TEAM.
3 In the matter of: DAVIS-BESSE INCIDENT t
Date of Proceeding: July 11, 1985 [
a Place of Proceeding: Oak Ilarbor, Ohio 7
were held as herein appears, and that this is the original 9 transcriPt for the file of the Commission.
10 GARRETT J. WAYSil, JR. b MYRTLE II. WALS!!
Official Reporter - Typed Official Reporter - Typed 12
.Qy k, j $W *
9 Offl ial Reporter - Sigt. Officiadfeporter-Si ature 15 16 17 MARY SIMONS ;
to Official Reporter - Typed e
- t 20 g_ MA
'OfficipReporter-Signature 22 ,
~
. 23 2A e'
23 TAYLOE ASSOCIATES REGISTERED PROFESSION AL REPORTCRS NORFOLK, VIRGINIA
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . . _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ . . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . . _ _ _ . . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ . . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _