ML20024D898

LER 83-073/01T-0:on 830714,discovered That Certain Core Protection Calculator Addressable Constants in Channels B & D Did Not Comply W/Most Recent Values in Log.Caused by Default Constants Being Left in channels.W/830729 Ltr

ML20024D898
Person / Time
Site:	San Onofre
Issue date:	07/29/1983
From:	Ray H SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON CO.
To:	Martin J NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION V)
References
LER-83-073-01T, LER-83-73-1T, NUDOCS 8308080386
Download: ML20024D898 (4)

Text

.* .

• s

• Mic FSKM 344 U.S. NUCL3 Aft RMULAT@RY CSMMGBEN APP 7s@VED CY CM3 LICENSEE EVENT REPORT siso ssu O*/r4so (PLEASE PRINT OR TYPE ALL REQUIRED INFORMATION)

CONTROL B LOCK: l l l l l l l@

I o Ii .l .lC l LIC 7

A EN.E I SE IC 0oD lE S I 2l@l0 l 01 - l LIC le ..

0l EN.E 01NU01 010 l -l 01 Ol@[4_Ll_l MB E R .S ..

11 1l ll@l57 C.Tl l@

LIC E N.E T Y PE .. S.

CON'T Lo l' ]

p

"::""' L..LJ@l0 l5

.t DOCK l0ET NUMBER l 0 l 0 l 3l 6l 1l@l.. .. 0 l 7 l1 l4 ]8 l 3W EPoRT EVENTO.TE 74 75 l@l017 D.TE I2 l 9 l 8 l3 l@

EVENT DESCRIPTION AND PROBABLE CONSEQUENCES io l o !2 l lWith the Unit in Mode 1 and followin completion of a channel functional test on l la la l l Core Protection Calculator (CPC) Channel A, a routine channel comparison was l o 4 l conducted. During this comparison it was discovered that certain CPC addressablq lo is liconstants in Channels B_ and D did not comply with the most recent values contained lo ls l Lin the CPC Addressable Constant Loa. The incorrect values were assumed to be l lo l7 lInonconservative and CPC Channels B and D were declared inoperable ir) accordance l lo ls l lwith Technical Specification 2.2.2 at 1630. Public health and safety were not l 1

.*attected by ,t,his event. ..

a.E "

c '.",': .mL e....NEN,e..E .1":.E .: m :E lol91 l Il Al@ lA l@ l X l@ l ZlZ lZ lZ lZl Zl@ lZ l@ lZ l@

• " " " " " " " "'; "' " ' !.'J.' "

E, E N, , u .

@ 'dd.""E,, l813I 10 17 I 3 I I/I 1-1

... .. L..] .. M ., L. 91_1.J. L.T._1 ,, L..OJ n*" '";"""  :::1', '"1;*  ;" N.... @ *:M",'3"' , ";"*;:.. '".' .Lc

V .

, *

," : ",%.8 IX l@l XI@ L.5Z_j@ L.LJ O I o f olo l o I L,y_J @ 'dLJ @ L.ZJ@ I z 19 I 9191

9. 94 3 .7 4. 4 4. 4 44 47 CAUSE DESCRIPTION AND CORRECTIVE ACTIONS h lilo llInoperability of CPC Channels B and D was due to addressable constants from the__j lili llchannel functional test data base (i.e., " default" constants) being left in the l li l 2 i lchannels following comoletion of the 18-month channel calibration and function,al_]

l i l a l l test. The correct constant values were entered into CPC Channels B and D within I lil 4 l lone hour and the channels were declared operable. (See attachment). l

'.",*M'l "".'e"#," ; o,.co. u v

,...E, o,N o . .ro. .E.c.,,,,o-liIsILB_]@lOlSl0l@l NA @I (A_j@l CPC Channel Comparison ]

.'Ehi['lE#k"El.E

.-o Mr , .crivir. Loc....N o,,, ELE..E l iI eI [Zj @ l Zl@l

, .. i. i.

NA @l 4.

l 4.

NA l

NuumER 7V85 D E.C R.PfloN Nr i I il 71. .l0 l 0l 0 l@L..Zjgt PE R .oNN EL INJURIE.

Iil81l0 l0 l 0 l@l NA l

..,Eo to vv r o.oE.c

. .','.i . . E ,v io No .c'u@

8308080386 830729 PDR ADOCK 05000361 11 l 9. .l W@l NA s PDR l

...uRI"*'ii ll..., .N @

NRC USE ONLY 12l o l l N l@l NA [ lllllllllllll 7 . . i. .. .. ..

H. B. RAY N N / M l W k Psone (714) 492-7700 NAME OF PPEPARER 7 _

4 .

ATTACHMENT TO LER 83-073 SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON COMPANY SAN ONOFRE NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNIT NO. 2, DOCKET NO. 50-361 SUPPLEMENTAL INFORMATION FOR CAUSE DESCRIPTION AND CORRECTIVE ACTION A preliminary evaluation by Combustion Engineering, Inc. (CE) concluded that the use of default values for the addressable constants did not violate safety margins for 50% power operation.

A final evaluation will be performed and if results to the contrary are obtained, a revision to this LER will be submitted.

As corrective action to prevent recurrence of this event, Computer Engineering is developing a program requiring a second verification of CPC constants on a periodic basis.

4 l

1318u

O.

e .

.=

0t Southern California Edison Company S AN ONOFRE NUCLE AR GENER A TING ST A TION l'83 gr3 f

$5 ,-

P .O. B O X 12 8 S AN C LEMENTE C ALIFORNI A 92672 /

H. B. R AY d vetspHONE S v A,10 N . A N A. . . July 29, 1983 i,.l..,.,,.

t U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Office of Inspection and Enforcement Region V 1450 Maria Lane, Suite 210 Walnut Creek, California 94596-5368

?

Attention: Mr. J.B. Martin, Regional Administrator

Subject:

Docket No. 50-361 14-Day Follow-Up Report Licensee Event Report No.83-073 San Onofre Nuclear Gen'erating Station, Unit 2

Reference:

Letter, H B. Ray, (SCE) to J. B. Martin (NRC),

dated July 15, 1982 The referenced letter provided you with confirmation of our prompt notification of a reportable occurrence involving the Core Protection Calculators (CPC).

3 Pursuant to Section 6.9.1.12.b of Appendix A, Technical Specifications to Facility Operating License NPP-10 for San Onofre Unit 2, this submittal provides the required 14-day follow-up report and a copy of Licensee Event Report (LER)

No.83-073 to address this event.

If there are any guestions regarding the above, please contact me.

Sincerely, i H6 lncurris

Enclosure:

LER No.83-073 l

l

e ,

. Mr. J.B. M2rtin cc: A.E. Chaffee (USNRC Resident Inspector, Units 2 and 3)

J.P. Stewart (USNRC Resident Inspector, Units 2 and 3)

U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Office of Inspection and Enforcement U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Division of Technical Information and Document Control ,

Institute of Nuclear Power Operations (INPO)

v. =-

I 1318u

. , . . . - , . _ - - - . _- . .. . . .- . . - , . . = - . , :. : :.