ML051030297

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
04/11/2005 - Letter to Jay Silberg Request for Proprietary Documents in Vermont Yankee EPU Proceeding
ML051030297
Person / Time
Site: Vermont Yankee Entergy icon.png
Issue date: 04/11/2005
From: Poole B
NRC/OGC
To: Silberg J
Pillsbury, Winthrop, Shaw, Pittman, LLP
Brooke Poole, OGC, 415-1556
References
50-271-OLA
Download: ML051030297 (18)


Text

April 11, 2005 Jay E. Silberg, Esq.

Pillsbury Winthrop Shaw Pittman, LLP 2300 N St., NW Washington, DC 20037-1128 In the Matter of ENTERGY NUCLEAR VERMONT YANKEE LLC and ENTERGY NUCLEAR OPERATIONS, INC.

(Vermont Yankee Nuclear Power Station)

Docket No. 50-271-OLA

Dear Mr. Silberg:

In the Protective Order Governing Non-Disclosure of Proprietary Information issued on March 1, 2005, in the captioned proceeding, the Licensing Board stated (at 4 n.7):

This order, and the good faith representation and designation of documents as Proprietary Documents by counsel for Entergy, serves in lieu of the requirement for marking and for an affidavit under 10 C.F.R. § 2.390(b) and allows the Staff to receive Proprietary Documents and to protect their confidentiality under [the Freedom of Information Act]. However, the Staff is not obligated to participate in this order or to obtain Proprietary Documents hereunder. The Staff may instead access the documents under the compromise position approach specified in the Staff Answer at 5,[1] or in any other way that Entergy and the Staff agree is appropriate.

We have reviewed Entergys Proprietary Privileged Document Log2 and have identified several documents relating to DPS Contentions 1 and 2 that we would like to access pursuant to the compromise position set forth in the Staff Answer, at 5. Specifically, the Staff requests 1

See NRC Staff Answer to Entergys Motion for Protective Order Governing Access to and Disclosure of Trade Secrets and Confidential Commercial or Financial Information dated January 19, 2005 (Staff Answer).

2 See Entergys Proprietary Privileged Document Log, dated March 31, 2005.

Jay E. Silberg, Esq. that the documents listed in the attachment to this letter be provided to Staff counsel pursuant to the procedures of 10 C.F.R. § 2.390.

Please contact me if you have any questions regarding this request.

Sincerely,

/RA/

Brooke D. Poole Counsel for NRC Staff

Attachment Proprietary Documents Identified in Entergys Privileged Document Log and Requested for Production by the NRC Staff - April 11, 2005 Document Bates Date Document Title To From Company ID Number EPU003319 EPU 062992- 8/29/03 Transmittal Letter: Nichols GE EPU 062994 PUSAR Section 4.2.6 input ECCS Net Positive Suction Head for T0406 from Bruce Slifer; File No. PUPVY 312 EPU003320 EPU 062995- 8/29/03 Transmittal Letter: Nichols GE EPU 062998 PUSAR Section 6.7 and Table 6-5 input Appendix R/Fire Protection for T0611 from Bruce Slifer; File No. PUPVY 313 EPU003321 EPU 062999- 9/2/03 Transmittal Letter: Nichols GE EPU 063006 Rev to PUSAR Section 6/7 Table 6-5 and Table 1-1 input Appendix R/Fire Protection EPU003322 EPU 063007- 8/29/03 Transmittal Letter: Nichols GE EPU 063008 PUSAR Section 9.3.2 Input St6ation Blackout for T0903 from Bruce Slifer; File No. PUPVY 314 EPU003323 EPU 063009- 9/4/03 Transmittal Letter: Nichols GE EPU 063023 PORC Technical Changes to PUSAR Revision B and Comments; File No.

PUPVY-03-321

EPU003327 EPU 063647- 6/1/03 Project Task Report Rhow; GE EPU 063755 for T0400: Mintz; Containment Dick System Response Revision 0 EPU003328 EPU 063756- 8/29/03 Equipment Yasi S&W EPU 063818 Qualifications Engineering Report Final EQ; Duplicate is #6654 EPU003331 EPU 064038- 8/28/03 Task 0400 Decay Dick GE EPU 064050 Heat Profile EPU003333 EPU 064051- 5/19/03 T0402 - Slifer; GE EPU 064053 Containment Devin-Isolation -- redacted centis last 2 pages (GE Proprietary)

EPU003387 EPU 069471- 9/15/03 Submittal of Draft Salter S&W EPU 069484 BOP Engineering Report ECCS Pump NPSH Evaluation Draft A EPU003396 EPU 070836- 1/1/203 VERMONT GE EPU 070841 YANKEE FEASIBILITY STUDY 3.12 Residual Heat Removal System EPU003397 EPU 070842- 1/1/204 VERMONT GE EPU 070846 YANKEE FEASIBILITY STUDY 3.19 Emergency Core Cooling Systems 3

While it appears to be incorrect, this is the date provided in the privilege log.

4 See note 3

EPU003398 EPU 070847- 1/1/205 VERMONT GE EPU 070850 YANKEE FEASIBILITY STUDY 3.20 Containment Capability EPU003408 EPU 071763- 9/15/03 Draft BOP Salter S&W EPU 071776 Engineering Report ECCS Pump NPSH Evaluation Draft A EPU003410 EPU 071984- 11/5/98 Torus Temperature DE&S EPU 072115 Response to Appendix R and Station Blackout Scenarios EPU003417 EPU 072557- 1/1/03 Task Scoping GE EPU 072567 Document DRF No.

0000-0007-5271 Revision ) Task T0310: Residual Heat Removal System EPU003418 EPU 072568- 3/1/03 DRAFT Project Jen GE EPU 072587 Task Report GE-NE-0000-0010-9610-01 Revision 0 Class III Task T0310: Residual Heat Removal System EPU003421 EPU 072690- 3/7/03 Correspondence Dick GE EPU 072702 letter on T0400 (EPU) Decay Heat for Containment Analysis EPU003422 EPU 072703- 4/5/03 EPU T0400 Dick GE EPU 072715 Suppression Pool Temperature/Pres-sure Response to DBA-LOCA 5

See note 3.

EPU003423 EPU 072716- 5/2/03 EPU T0400 Dick GE EPU 072726 Containment System Response -

IBA EPU003424 EPU 072727- 5/7/03 EPU T0400 - DBA Dick GE EPU 072743 LOCA with Suppression Pool Cooling Event Results EPU003425 EPU 072744- 11/1/02 Task Scoping GE EPU 072752 Document Task T0400: Containment System Response EPU003427 EPU 072794- 2/26/03 ERC contains Slifer GE EPU 072843 information in support of Revision to OPL4A Rev 1; OPL-4A (Containment Analysis Input Values)

EPU003429 EPU 072898- 6/1/03 DRAFT Project Rhow GE EPU 073007 Task Report Task 0400: Containment System Response EPU003441 EPU 073751- 11/5/98 Yankee Atomic Fago DE&S EPU 073882 Electric Company Calculation/Analysis for Torus Temperature Response to Appendix R and Station Blackout Scenarios EPU003442 EPU 073883- 11/5/98 Torus Temperature DE&S EPU 074014 Response to Appendix R and Station Blackout Scenarios

EPU003443 EPU 074015- 11/3/98 Yankee Nuclear Fago DE&S EPU 074219 Services Division Calculation/Analysis for Torus Temperature and Pressure Response to Small Break LOCA Scenarios-Model Development EPU003444 EPU 074220- 11/5/98 Analysis of DE&S EPU 074532 Suppression Pool Temperature for Relief Valva Discharge Transients EPU003445 EPU 074533- 11/5/98 Yankee Nuclear Ganth- DE&S EPU 074845 Services Division ner Calculation/Analysis of Suppression Pool Temperature for Relief Valve Discharge Transients EPU003453 EPU 075633- 3/1/03 Project Task Report Jen GE EPU 075652 T0310: Residual Heat Removal System EPU003454 EPU 075653- 6/1/03 Task Scoping Jen GE EPU 075672 Document Task:

T0310 Residual Heat Removal System EPU003466 EPU 076413- 9/2/03 Letter attaching Nichols GE EPU 076418 Revision to PUSAR Section 4.2.6 Table 4-2 and Figure 4-6 Input ECCS Net Positive Suction Head EPU003467 EPU 076419- 8/29/03 Letter transmitting Nichols GE EPU 076421 PUSAR Section 4.2.6 Input ECCS Net Positive Suction Head T0406

EPU003479 EPU 077168- 7/6/04 VYNPS LOCA-DBA GE EPU 077199 Long-Term NPSH Information Transmittal 1/5%

per day Leakage and 100%

Containment Spray Thermal Mixing Efficiency DRF Number: 0000-0025-1645/Sec.

0000-0029-7076-R1 EPU003485 EPU 077204- 6/10/04 Correspondence re: Dick GE EPU 077228 VYNPS EPU T0400:

DBA-LOCA for Long Term NPSH Evaluation /GE-VYNPS-AEP-346/DRF 0000-0007-5271 EPU003486 EPU 077229- 7/6/04 Correspondence re: Dick GE EPU 077262 VYNPS EPU T0400:

DBA-LOCA for Long Term NPSH Evaluation/GE-VYNPS-AEP-346 Revision 1/DRF 0000-0007-5271 EPU003487 EPU 077263- 7/6/04 Correspondence re: Dick GE EPU 077296 VYNPS EPU T0400:

DBA-LOCA for Long Term NPSH Evaluation/GE-VYNPS-AEP-346 Revision 1/DRF 0000-0007-5271 EPU003488 EPU 077297- 8/7/04 Correspondence re: Dick GE EPU 077331 VYNPS EPU T0400:

DBA-LOCA for Long Term NPSH Evaluation/GE-VYNPS-AEP-346 Revision 2/DRF 0000-0007-5271

EPU003521 EPU 079574- 6/1/03 TASK T0400: Dick GE EPU 079682 CONTAINMENT SYSTEM RESPONSE REV. 0 EPU003522 EPU 079683- 6/1/03 TASK T0400: GE EPU 079791 CONTAINMENT SYSTEM RESPONSE REV. 0 EPU003523 EPU 079792- 6/1/03 TASK T0400: GE EPU 079900 CONTAINMENT SYSTEM RESPONSE REV. 0 EPU003524 EPU 079901- 6/1/03 TASK T0400: GE EPU 080009 CONTAINMENT SYSTEM RESPONSE REV. 0 EPU003577 EPU 085452- 7/6/04 VYNPS LOCA_DBA GE EPU 085483 Long-Term NPSH Information Transmittal 1/5%

per day Leakage and 100%

Containment Spray Thermal Mixing Efficiency EPU003578 EPU 085484- 7/6/04 VYNPS LOCA_DBA GE EPU 085515 Long-Term NPSH Information Transmittal 1/5%

per day Leakage and 100%

Containment Spray Thermal Mixing Eff[iciency]

EPU003579 EPU 085516- 6/10/04 VYNPS LOCA-DBA Mintz GE EPU 085538 Long-Term NPSH Information Transmittal 1.5%

per day Leakage EPU003583 EPU 085710- 8/28/03 Task T0400: Decay Dick GE EPU 085722 Heat for Containment Analysis

EPU003586 EPU 085723- 1/1/206 OPL-4A GE EPU 085763 (Containment Analysis Input Values) for Vermont Yankee Nuclear Power Station EPU/MELLLA+

Draft EPU003600 EPU 086640- 4/29/04 Submittal of ECCS Salter S&W EPU 086653 NPSH Engineering Report Section 3.7.1 Rev. 0 T0406 EPU003608 EPU 087458- 1/1/207 ECCS Net Positive GE EPU 087464 Suction Head PUSAR Section 4.2.6 PUSAR Pages: 4-10 and 4-11 T0406 EPU003609 EPU 087465- 1/1/208 ECCS Net Positive GE EPU 087469 Suction Head PUSAR Section 4.2.6 PUSAR Pages: 4-10 and 4-11 T0406 EPU003610 EPU 087470- 1/1/209 ECCS Net Positive GE EPU 087474 Suction Head PUSAR Section 4.2.6 PUSAR Pages: 4-10 and 4-11 T0406 EPU003611 EPU 087475- 7/17/03 ECCS Net Positive GE EPU 087479 Suction Head PUSAR Section 4.2.6 PUSAR Pages: 4-10 and 4-11 T0406 6

See note 3.

7 See note 3.

8 See note 3.

9 See note 3.

EPU003612 EPU 087480- 1/1/2010 ECCS Net Positive GE EPU 087484 Suction Head PUSAR Section 4.2.6 PUSAR Pages: 4-10 and 4-11 T0406 EPU003613 EPU 087485- 7/6/04 VYNPS LOCA-DBA GE EPU 087517 Long-Term NPSH Information Transmittal - 1.5%

per day Leakage and 100%

Containment Spray Thermal Mixing Efficiency EPU003618 EPU 087669- 7/6/04 VYNPS LOCA-DBA GE EPU 087701 Long-Term NPSH Information Transmittal - 1.5%

per day Leakage and 100%

Containment Spray Thermal Mixing Efficiency EPU003627 EPU 088112- 1/1/2011 3.12 Residual Heat GE EPU 088117 Removal System.

Appears to be a portion of a larger doc.

EPU003674 EPU 088844- 7/17/03 ECCS Net Positive GE EPU 088848 Suction Head PUSAR Section 4.2.6 PUSAR Pages: 4-10 and 4-11 PUSAR 4.2.6 Draft A1T0406 10 See note 3.

11 See note 3.

EPU003675 EPU 088849- 7/17/03 ECCS Net Positive GE EPU 088853 Suction Head PUSAR Section 4.2.6 PUSAR Pages: 4-10 and 4-11 PUSAR 4.2.6 Draft A T0406 EPU003676 EPU 061674- 1/1/2012 ECCS Net Positive GE EPU 061675 Suction Head PUSAR Section 4.2.6 PUSAR Pages: 4-10 and 4-11 T0406 PUSAR 4.2.6 VY Input FINAL 8-29-03 EPU003677 EPU 088854- 1/1/2013 ECCS Net Positive GE EPU 088858 Suction Head PUSAR Section 4.2.6 PUSAR Pages: 4-10 and 4-11 T0406 PUSAR 4.2.6 VY Input FINAL 9-2-03 EPU003681 EPU 088868- 8/8/03 ECCS Net Positive GE EPU 088874 Suction Head PUSAR Section 4.2.6 PUSAR Pages: 4-10 and 4-11 T0406PUSAR 4.2.6 - incl VY comments EPU003712 EPU 091633- 8/13/03 ECCS Net Positive GE EPU 091637 Suction Head PUSAR Section 4.2.6 PUSAR Pages: 4-10 and 4-11 T0406 PUSAR Section 4.2.6 draft final 12 See note 3.

13 See note 3.

EPU003717 EPU 091638- 8/8/03 ECCS Net Positive S&W EPU 091644 Suction Head PUSAR Section 4.2.6 PUSAR Pages: 4-10 and 4-11 t0406 PUSAR Section 4.2.6 incorporating VY comments EPU003720 EPU 091693- 7/17/03 ECCS Net Positive S&W EPU 091697 Suction Head PUSAR Section 4.2.6 PUSAR Pages: 4-10 and 4-11 T0406 PUSAR Section 4.2.6 draft A EPU003723 EPU 091719- 1/1/02 SAMPLE/DRAFT GE EPU 091726 Task Scoping Document Utility Plant ARTS/MELLLA -

Task T0401:

Subcompartment (Annulus)

Pressurization Loads EPU003743 EPU 092930- 1/1/03 Task Scoping GE EPU 092940 Document Task T0310: Residual Heat Removal System Draft Comment Resolution EPU003745 EPU 092941- 3/1/03 Project Task Report Jen GE EPU 092960 Task T0310:

Residual Heat Removal System WIP VYNPS EPU T0310 Task Report.doc

EPU003746 EPU 092961- 6/1/03 Project Task Report Jen GE EPU 092980 Task T0310:

Residual Heat Removal System WIP VYNPS EPU T0310 FTR.doc EPU003794 EPU 093962- 1/1/2014 Conservatism in the GE EPU 093963 Containment Pressure Calculation for NPSH Evaluations NRC RAI SPSB-C 11 EPU003796 EPU 093973- 1/1/2015 ECCS NPSH GE EPU 093974 PUSAR Section 4.2.6 PUSAR Page:

4-10 4-11 T0406 EPU003797 EPU 093975- 1/1/2016 ECCS NPSH GE EPU 093979 PUSAR Section 4.2.6 PUSAR Page:

4-10 4-11 T0406 EPU003801 EPU 093990- 1/1/2017 ECCS NPSH GE EPU 093996 PUSAR Section 4.2.6 Page: 4-10 4-11 T0406 with table attached EPU003802 EPU 093997- 1/1/2018 ECCS NPSH GE EPU 094003 PUSAR Section 4.2.6 Page: 4-10 4-11 T0406 with table attached 14 See note 3.

15 See note 3.

16 See note 3.

17 See note 3.

18 See note 3.

EPU003803 EPU 094004- 1/1/2019 ECCS NPSH GE EPU 094008 PUSAR Section 4.2.6 Page: 4-10 4-11 EPU003823 EPU 095164- 6/10/04 VYNPS LOCA-DBA Mintz GE EPU 095186 Long-Term NPSH Information Transmittal - 1.5%

Per Day Leakage EPU003824 EPU 095187- 9/28/04 VYNPS LOCA-DBA GE EPU 095218 Long-Term NPSH Information Transmittal - 1.5%

Per Day Leakage and 100%

Containment Spray Thermal Mixing Efficiency Verified and Final EPU003825 EPU 095219- 9/28/04 VYNPS LOCA-DBA GE EPU 095250 Long-Term NPSH Information Transmittal - 1.5%

Per Day Leakage and 100%

Containment Spray Thermal Mixing Efficiency Verified and Final EPU003826 EPU 095251- 9/28/04 VYNPS LOCA-DBA GE EPU 095282 Long-Term NPSH Information Transmittal - 1.5%

Per Day Leakage and 100%

Containment Spray Thermal Mixing Efficiency Verified and Final 19 See note 3.

EPU003827 EPU 095283- 9/28/04 VYNPS LOCA-DBA Mintz GE EPU 095305 Long-Term NPSH Information Transmittal - 1.5%

Per Day Leakage EPU003832 EPU 095646- 4/5/03 Memo re: T0400 Dick GE EPU 095658 (Containment System Response) w/Attachment (LOCA-DBA Short and Long-Term NPSH Information Transmittal EPU003849 EPU 098156- 8/5/04 VYNPS LOCA-DBA GE EPU 098188 Long-Term NPSH Information Transmittal - 1.5%

Per Day Leakage and 100%

Containment Spray Thermal Mixing Efficiency EPU003850 EPU 098189- 6/10/04

Subject:

VYNPS Dick GE EPU 098213 EPU T0400: DBA-LOCA for Long-Term NPSH Evaluation; Attached Study EPU003860 EPU 098664- 8/7/04 T0400 DBA-LOCA Dick GE EPU 098698 for Long-Term NPSH Evaluation EPU003861 EPU 098699- 6/1/03 Project Task Report Rhow; GE EPU 098807 T0400 Containment Mintz System Response EPU003862 EPU 098808- 1/1/2020 Draft BOP Salter S&W EPU 098821 Engineering Report

- ECCS Pump NPSH Evaluation T0406 20 Id.

EPU003877 EPU 099365-

Subject:

Example GE EPU 099770 Task Report.

Attachment is Browns Ferry Nuclear (BFN) CP FTR T0400, Containment System Response EPU003879 EPU 099771- Example Task GE EPU 100176 Report - T0400 Containment System Response EPU003969 EPU 101191- FW: PUSAR 6.4.4 GE EPU 101195 TBCCW - DRAFT A T0406 ECCS NPSH

& T0607 TBCCW EPU003996 EPU 101486-

Subject:

Comments GE EPU 101490 on T0406 ECCS Pump NPSH; Two attachments on the subject and two re:

PUSAR EPU004006 EPU 101498- (Attachment is ID# GE EPU 101504 3274) FW: PUSAR for ECCS NPSH Section 4.2.6 EPU004008 EPU 101505- PUSAR for ECCS GE EPU 101511 NPSH Section 4.2.6 EPU004080 EPU 104062- E-mail (Attachments GE EPU 104075 are ID#s 8494 and 8495) Attached Stone & Webster Letter VY 2003-0090 Transmittal of Draft ECCS NPSH Engineering Report Section for Entergy Review. T0406

EPU004111 EPU 104276-

Subject:

DBA LOCA GE EPU 104300 Long-Term NPSH Case with 1.5% La; Attach. Re: This document provides the DBA-LOCA results after 600 seconds for input to long-term NPSH evaluations per Reference 2 EPU004112 EPU 104301-

Subject:

DBA LOCA GE EPU 104323 Long-Term NPSH Case with 1.5% La; Attach. Re: This document provides the DBA-LOCA results after 600 seconds for input to long-term NPSH evaluations per Reference 2