|
---|
Category:CORRESPONDENCE-LETTERS
MONTHYEARML20149G1941993-09-13013 September 1993 Partial Response to FOIA Request for Listed OI Repts.Record Listed in App D Being Withheld from Public Disclosure Because It Consists of Records Compiled for Law Enforcement Purposes.Nrc Continuing to Review Records Re FOIA Request IA-93-355, Partial Response to FOIA Request for Listed OI Repts.Record Listed in App D Being Withheld from Public Disclosure Because It Consists of Records Compiled for Law Enforcement Purposes.Nrc Continuing to Review Records Re FOIA Request1993-09-13013 September 1993 Partial Response to FOIA Request for Listed OI Repts.Record Listed in App D Being Withheld from Public Disclosure Because It Consists of Records Compiled for Law Enforcement Purposes.Nrc Continuing to Review Records Re FOIA Request ML20072C9611993-06-18018 June 1993 FOIA Request for Listed OI Repts ML20079D3191991-06-10010 June 1991 Forwards B Tatalovich Correspondence Re Plant ML20235A1251987-12-16016 December 1987 Forwards Info Re Resource Technical Svcs,Inc,Including Summary of NRC Contract Work,Nrc Form 26 for Three Existing Contracts,Audit Info,Work History & Lists of Expertise Available for Special Insps & of Current Resource Svcs ML20235W0981987-10-13013 October 1987 Final Response to FOIA Request for Records.No Records Subj to Request located.FOIA-87-40 in Name of Thomas Available in PDR IA-87-676, Final Response to FOIA Request for Records.No Records Subj to Request located.FOIA-87-40 in Name of Thomas Available in PDR1987-10-13013 October 1987 Final Response to FOIA Request for Records.No Records Subj to Request located.FOIA-87-40 in Name of Thomas Available in PDR ML20235W0951987-10-0808 October 1987 FOIA Request for All FOIA Requests Made for Zimmer Plant or GE Mark I or II Containment by Cincinnati Gas & Electric, Dayton Power & Light or Columbus & Southern Ohio Electric & FOIA 87-40 ML20235B3081987-09-21021 September 1987 Responds to FOIA Request for Documents,Including AEC to ACRS Forwarding Safety Evaluation Re Zimmer.App a Documents Cannot Be Located.App B Documents in Pdr.App C & D Documents Withheld (Ref 10CFR2.790) ML20235M4251987-07-13013 July 1987 Partial Response to FOIA Request for Documents Re Acrs. Forwards Documents for Categories One & Three of FOIA Request.Review of 21 Addl ACRS Documents Continuing ML20234E4571987-06-23023 June 1987 Partial Response to FOIA Request for 771026 Minutes of ACRS Subcommittee on Fluid/Hydraulic Dynamic Effects Meeting in Portland,Or & Addl ACRS Documentation.Documents Identified on App H & Addl ACRS Documents Encl ML20209G6751987-03-27027 March 1987 FOIA Request for All Matls Made Available in Accordance W/ FOIA 87-40 & All Matls Produced to Either Plaintiffs in Zimmer Litigation &/Or GE ML20212H6601987-01-20020 January 1987 Final Response to FOIA Request.App F Documents Re Marviken II Project Encl & Available in PDR ML20210S4131986-09-26026 September 1986 Further Response to FOIA Request for 16 Categories of Records Re Facilities.Forwards App D & E Documents.Documents Also Available in PDR ML20210L2601986-03-20020 March 1986 Forwards Endorsement 31 to Nelia Policy NF-206 ML20141N2771986-01-14014 January 1986 Partial Response to FOIA Request for Seven Classes of Documents.Forwards App a Documents.App B Documents Available in Pdr.App C Documents Outside Scope of Request,Per 860114 Telcon W/Ca Reed ML20140F3691986-01-14014 January 1986 Further Response to FOIA Request for Several Categories of Documents Re Pressure Suppression Containment.Fsar & SER for Limerick Only Documentation Re 4x4 Tests.Encl Apps D-G Documents Responsive to Item 4 Also Available in PDR ML20138Q8301985-12-0303 December 1985 Further Response to FOIA Request for Records Re Voluntary or Required Redress of Sites Where Const Was Terminated, Including Crbr & Legal Analysis.Forwards App E Documents.App D & E Documents Available in Pdr.Photographs Also Available ML20136D8751985-11-0606 November 1985 Further Response to FOIA Request for Documents Re H Hoyt & Aloot Oct 1983 Rept on NRC Investigations at Facility. Listed Documents Encl & Available in Pdr.Certain Documents Totally Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemptions 5 & 7) ML20136J3371985-08-0101 August 1985 Final Response to FOIA Request for Documents Re Facility.Documents Listed on Encl Printout Located in Ofc of Investigations.Documents Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemptions 5 & 7) ML20134D7991985-08-0101 August 1985 Responds to FOIA Request for Documents Re Ofc of Investigation Repts on Facility.Documents Listed on Encl Printout Located in Ofc of Investigations as of 850227. Documents Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemptions 5 & 7) IA-84-604, Responds to FOIA Request for Documents Re Ofc of Investigation Repts on Facility.Documents Listed on Encl Printout Located in Ofc of Investigations as of 850227. Documents Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemptions 5 & 7)1985-08-0101 August 1985 Responds to FOIA Request for Documents Re Ofc of Investigation Repts on Facility.Documents Listed on Encl Printout Located in Ofc of Investigations as of 850227. Documents Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemptions 5 & 7) IA-83-684, Final Response to FOIA Request for Documents Re Facility.Documents Listed on Encl Printout Located in Ofc of Investigations.Documents Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemptions 5 & 7)1985-08-0101 August 1985 Final Response to FOIA Request for Documents Re Facility.Documents Listed on Encl Printout Located in Ofc of Investigations.Documents Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemptions 5 & 7) ML20134D5821985-07-31031 July 1985 Final Response to FOIA Request for Documents Re Wh Zimmer Nuclear Power Station.Forwards Computer Printout of Document.W/O Encl.Documents Contained in Ofc of Investigation Files Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemptions 5 & 7) ML20133Q2231985-07-31031 July 1985 Responds to FOIA Request for Documents Which Resulted in Issuance of Notice of Violation to Util in Nov 1981. Documents Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemptions 5 & 7) IA-83-787, Responds to FOIA Request for Documents Which Resulted in Issuance of Notice of Violation to Util in Nov 1981. Documents Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemptions 5 & 7)1985-07-31031 July 1985 Responds to FOIA Request for Documents Which Resulted in Issuance of Notice of Violation to Util in Nov 1981. Documents Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemptions 5 & 7) IA-83-655, Final Response to FOIA Request for Documents Re Wh Zimmer Nuclear Power Station.Forwards Computer Printout of Document.W/O Encl.Documents Contained in Ofc of Investigation Files Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemptions 5 & 7)1985-07-31031 July 1985 Final Response to FOIA Request for Documents Re Wh Zimmer Nuclear Power Station.Forwards Computer Printout of Document.W/O Encl.Documents Contained in Ofc of Investigation Files Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemptions 5 & 7) ML20133Q3771985-07-29029 July 1985 Responds to FOIA Request for Ofc of Investigations Documents Re Wh Zimmer Nuclear Power Station.Forwards List of Documents as of 840227.All Documents Withheld (FOIA Exemptions 5 & 7) ML20129J4671985-07-15015 July 1985 Informs That Util 821124 Application for Extension of Const Completion Date Fee Exempt.Refund Being Processed ML20133C7371985-06-14014 June 1985 Further Response to FOIA Request for Documents Re Site Redress Where Plant Const Begun,Including Clinch River Facility & NRC Legal Analysis Re Redress.Forwards App B Documents.App C Document Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemption 5) ML20133B5651985-05-10010 May 1985 Partial Response to FOIA Request for Four Categories of Documents Re Facility.Forwards App a Documents.Documents Also Available in Pdr.App B Documents Already Available in Pdr.Search Continuing ML20129E9971985-05-0909 May 1985 Responds to FOIA Request for Compilations of Results of Operator Licensing & Requalification Exams.App a Documents Placed in Pdr.App B Documents Already in PDR ML20127F5341985-04-18018 April 1985 Partial Response to FOIA Request for Records Re BNL Investigation of Ee Kent Allegations.Forwards App a Documents.Documents Also Available in Pdr.Remaining Documents Will Be Forwarded Upon Completion of NRC Review ML20099M2911985-03-15015 March 1985 Forwards Endorsement 27 to Nelia Policy NF-249 ML20129B9301985-02-19019 February 1985 FOIA Request for Documents Re DOJ Inquiry Into Potential Wrongdoing by NRC Employees in Dealing W/Tmi & Zimmer Plants & Dh Gamble Testimony from TMI Restart Proceeding ML20100B6181985-01-30030 January 1985 Forwards Payment of Bill D-0089.Fee Paid.W/O Encl ML20125B8661985-01-17017 January 1985 Further Response to FOIA Request for Documents Re Oct 1983 Rept by H Hoyt & Aloot on NRC Investigations.Forwards App a Documents.Documents Also Available in Pdr.Info Partially Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemptions 2,6 & 7) ML20128E4161984-12-27027 December 1984 Interim Response to FOIA Request for All Agency Documents Re Oct 1983 Rept by Judge H Hoyt & Aloot on NRC Investigations at Facility.Forwards Documents.Documents Partially & Completely Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemptions 5-7) ML20101F7621984-12-20020 December 1984 Forwards Endorsement 26 to Nelia Policy NF-249 ML20129J2141984-12-0707 December 1984 Responds to FOIA Request for Interim or Final Repts Generated by Ofc of Investigation Re Facility.Documents Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemption 5) ML20093M2541984-10-18018 October 1984 Requests Written Verification of Implementation of Site Restoration Plan So CPPR-88 May Be Terminated ML20129J2031984-10-11011 October 1984 FOIA Request for Interim or Final Repts Generated by Ofc of Investigation Re Facility ML20107L6521984-07-19019 July 1984 FOIA Request for All Documents Re Insp Rept 50-358/84-04 ML20105C9801984-07-19019 July 1984 FOIA Request for Documents Re Ofc of Investigation Rept on Facility.If Requested Matls Still Protected,Copies of Matls W/Protected Sections Redacted Requested ML20151J1601984-06-0505 June 1984 Forwards IE Insp Rept 50-358/84-04 on 840220-0426.Insp Covered Status of Welding Procedure & Welder Performance Qualifications ML20091L5991984-06-0404 June 1984 Forwards Util 840601 Response to NRC 840503 Request for Addl Info Re Environ Review of Request to Withdraw Application for Ol.Five Oversize Drawings Encl.Aperture Cards Are Available in Pdr.Related Correspondence ML20091J1321984-06-0101 June 1984 Forwards Environ Review of Zimmer Site Status for Cincinnati Gas & Electric Co, in Response to NRC 840503 Request for Addl Info Re Withdrawal of OL Application.W/ Three Oversize Figures.Apertures Cards Are Available in PDR ML20128E3861984-05-22022 May 1984 FOIA Request for All Agency Records or Info Re Oct 1983 Rept by Judge H Hoyt & Aloot Re NRC Investigations at Facility ML20091A2141984-05-22022 May 1984 Forwards Ohio Edison Annual Rept,1983, Toledo Edison Co 1983 Annual Rept, Duquesne Light Co Annual Rept,1983 & Cleveland Electric Illuminating Co 1983 Annual Rept ML20084P2401984-05-11011 May 1984 Advises That Addl Info for Environ Review of Request to Withdraw OL Application Will Be Provided by 840601,per 1993-09-13
[Table view] Category:INCOMING CORRESPONDENCE
MONTHYEARML20072C9611993-06-18018 June 1993 FOIA Request for Listed OI Repts ML20079D3191991-06-10010 June 1991 Forwards B Tatalovich Correspondence Re Plant ML20235A1251987-12-16016 December 1987 Forwards Info Re Resource Technical Svcs,Inc,Including Summary of NRC Contract Work,Nrc Form 26 for Three Existing Contracts,Audit Info,Work History & Lists of Expertise Available for Special Insps & of Current Resource Svcs ML20235W0951987-10-0808 October 1987 FOIA Request for All FOIA Requests Made for Zimmer Plant or GE Mark I or II Containment by Cincinnati Gas & Electric, Dayton Power & Light or Columbus & Southern Ohio Electric & FOIA 87-40 ML20209G6751987-03-27027 March 1987 FOIA Request for All Matls Made Available in Accordance W/ FOIA 87-40 & All Matls Produced to Either Plaintiffs in Zimmer Litigation &/Or GE ML20210L2601986-03-20020 March 1986 Forwards Endorsement 31 to Nelia Policy NF-206 ML20099M2911985-03-15015 March 1985 Forwards Endorsement 27 to Nelia Policy NF-249 ML20129B9301985-02-19019 February 1985 FOIA Request for Documents Re DOJ Inquiry Into Potential Wrongdoing by NRC Employees in Dealing W/Tmi & Zimmer Plants & Dh Gamble Testimony from TMI Restart Proceeding ML20100B6181985-01-30030 January 1985 Forwards Payment of Bill D-0089.Fee Paid.W/O Encl ML20101F7621984-12-20020 December 1984 Forwards Endorsement 26 to Nelia Policy NF-249 ML20093M2541984-10-18018 October 1984 Requests Written Verification of Implementation of Site Restoration Plan So CPPR-88 May Be Terminated ML20129J2031984-10-11011 October 1984 FOIA Request for Interim or Final Repts Generated by Ofc of Investigation Re Facility ML20105C9801984-07-19019 July 1984 FOIA Request for Documents Re Ofc of Investigation Rept on Facility.If Requested Matls Still Protected,Copies of Matls W/Protected Sections Redacted Requested ML20107L6521984-07-19019 July 1984 FOIA Request for All Documents Re Insp Rept 50-358/84-04 ML20091L5991984-06-0404 June 1984 Forwards Util 840601 Response to NRC 840503 Request for Addl Info Re Environ Review of Request to Withdraw Application for Ol.Five Oversize Drawings Encl.Aperture Cards Are Available in Pdr.Related Correspondence ML20091J1321984-06-0101 June 1984 Forwards Environ Review of Zimmer Site Status for Cincinnati Gas & Electric Co, in Response to NRC 840503 Request for Addl Info Re Withdrawal of OL Application.W/ Three Oversize Figures.Apertures Cards Are Available in PDR ML20091A2141984-05-22022 May 1984 Forwards Ohio Edison Annual Rept,1983, Toledo Edison Co 1983 Annual Rept, Duquesne Light Co Annual Rept,1983 & Cleveland Electric Illuminating Co 1983 Annual Rept ML20128E3861984-05-22022 May 1984 FOIA Request for All Agency Records or Info Re Oct 1983 Rept by Judge H Hoyt & Aloot Re NRC Investigations at Facility ML20084P2401984-05-11011 May 1984 Advises That Addl Info for Environ Review of Request to Withdraw OL Application Will Be Provided by 840601,per ML20084M0911984-05-0404 May 1984 Advises That Preventive Maint & QA Programs Will Be Discontinued on 840518 Due to Termination of Const & Dismissal of Application.Snm Provisions Will Remain in Effect Until Removal of Matl ML20112H8101984-04-0505 April 1984 FOIA Request for Repts Resulting from Listed Environ Qualification of Equipment Site Audits to Be Placed in Pdr. Access to Any Repts Resulting from Audits Held Since Oct 1982 Also Requested ML20084P3501984-03-14014 March 1984 Requests Response to Encl W & V Smelser 840210 Inquiry Into NRC Attitude Toward Utils.Concerns Include Marble Hill & Bailly Cancellation,Withdrawal of Util Application for Zimmer & Denial of License for Byron Facility ML20114A3121984-03-12012 March 1984 FOIA Request for Facility Nonconformance Repts ML20113D2281984-03-0808 March 1984 FOIA Request for Copies of All Nonconformance Repts on Facility from Start of Const to Present ML20087D1131984-03-0505 March 1984 Forwards Natl Board of Boiler & Pressure Vessel Inspectors to State of Oh Re Util Abandonment of Facility as Nuclear Unit & Board Willingness to Provide Support Should Plant Be Reinstated ML20083P2521984-02-29029 February 1984 FOIA Request for Correspondence Between Util,Hj Kaiser & NRC Referenced in Encl Ohio Civil Rights Commission ML20114A3081984-02-28028 February 1984 FOIA Request for All Region III Insp Repts from Nov 1983 to Present & All Communications Between Region III & Bechtel, Dayton Power & Light Cincinnati Gas & Electric Co Representatives Re Facility ML20102A0241984-02-28028 February 1984 FOIA Request for Region III & IE Repts from Nov 1983 to Present & Communications Between Region III & Util,Bechtel or Kaiser Corp Officials ML20084R6521984-02-24024 February 1984 FOIA Request for Computer Printout from Sept 1980 to Present of Civil Penalty Info on 27 Listed Nuclear Facilities.Sample Format Encl ML20086P7291984-02-17017 February 1984 Forwards Revised Organization Chart,Effective as of 840217. Organizational Changes Due to Decision to Convert Station from Nuclear to coal-fueled Generating Facility ML20083N2371984-02-17017 February 1984 FOIA Request for Four Categories of Documents Re Facility ML20083N2621984-02-16016 February 1984 FOIA Request for Interim Repts Issued by Ofc of Investigation Re Plant,Including DOJ Rept Re Harassment of QC Inspectors ML20086P6321984-02-16016 February 1984 Confirms 840202 Telcon Understanding That,Pending Final Commission Action for Withdrawal of Application,No Need Exists to Continue Previously Required Submittals to NRC ML20112E1481984-02-10010 February 1984 Appeals Denial of 831123 FOIA Request for 831115 Transcript Re Pending Plant Investigations & Documents Prepared After Discussing 830701 Staff Decision Not to Approve Util Actions for Plant ML20080A9041984-01-30030 January 1984 Forwards Comments on Reactor Controls,Inc (Rci) 830915 Response to Draft IE Info Notice Re Const Deficiencies,Per 831017 Request.Work Orders for Lateral Restraint Beams Not Issued to Rci ML20079S2451984-01-27027 January 1984 Informs of 840120 Agreement to Cease Const of Facility as Nuclear Plant & Convert Plant to coal-fired Facility. Ej Wagner Designated Responsible for Closing Out Nuclear Activities at Facility ML20079P4161984-01-24024 January 1984 Requests Completion of Pending Actions on 831216 Plan to Verify Quality of Const,To Closeout Outstanding Items in 821112 Order to Show Cause & Order Immediately Suspending Const ML20079M8961984-01-20020 January 1984 Forwards Personnel Resumes Inadvertently Omitted from Re Independent Auditor for Plan to Verify Const ML20079N2161984-01-19019 January 1984 Requests Written Concurrence for Training Activities,As Outlined.Facility Site Directives & Master Training Plan for All Site Training Will Be Provided to Region Iii,Per ML20079N1991984-01-19019 January 1984 Informs That Training Directive ZPM-TR.101 & Master Training Plan Developed for NRC Review ML20079F1291984-01-16016 January 1984 Requests NRC Approval of Teledyne Engineering Svcs as Independent Design Review (Idr) Contractor.Teledyne Proposal Forwarded.Criteria Used During Evaluation & Presentation Matl from NRC 840113 Meeting Encl ML20079G1841984-01-13013 January 1984 Forwards Resumes for Principal Positions Noted on Organization Chart in Section IV of Ebasco 831205 Proposal Re Independent Auditor for Plan to Verify Const ML20086K1081984-01-13013 January 1984 Forwards Council of City of Cincinnati Resolution R/18-1984 Which Expresses Dissatisfaction Over NRC Failure to Require third-party Independent Review of Facility ML20080F0441984-01-13013 January 1984 Notifies of Approval of Resolution R/18-1984 Expressing City of Cincinnati Council Dissatisfaction Over NRC Failure to Require third-party Independent Review of Facility. Resolution Encl ML20079H2891984-01-11011 January 1984 Submits Partial Response to Util Plan to Verify Quality of Const for Facility.Counsel for Miami Valley Power Project Decision Not to Attend 840111 Public Meeting Clarified. Related Info Encl ML20086L8371984-01-11011 January 1984 Requests Development of Proposed Facility Public Oversight Committee.Committee Establishment Would Inspire Public Confidence ML20079F3731984-01-10010 January 1984 Forwards Packet of Newspaper Articles Re Facility.Packet Acts as Chronological Summary of Major Events During 14 Months Prior to 831201 ML20079E2401984-01-10010 January 1984 Forwards Quality Confirmation Program, Monthly Rept for Dec 1983,per Rf Warnick ML20080F0291984-01-10010 January 1984 Notifies of 840105 Adoption of Motion Advising NRC That Limiting Public Participation to Time Permitting at 840111 Meeting Not in Best Interest of City of Cincinnati or Citizens ML20083J1491984-01-10010 January 1984 Advises That Cincinnati City Council Adopted Vice-Mayor M Spencer Encl Motion Before Council Opposing Limited Public Participation at 840111 Meeting Between NRC & Util 1993-06-18
[Table view] Category:PUBLIC ENTITY/CITIZEN/ORGANIZATION/MEDIA TO NRC
MONTHYEARML20129B9301985-02-19019 February 1985 FOIA Request for Documents Re DOJ Inquiry Into Potential Wrongdoing by NRC Employees in Dealing W/Tmi & Zimmer Plants & Dh Gamble Testimony from TMI Restart Proceeding ML20129J2031984-10-11011 October 1984 FOIA Request for Interim or Final Repts Generated by Ofc of Investigation Re Facility ML20114A3121984-03-12012 March 1984 FOIA Request for Facility Nonconformance Repts ML20083P2521984-02-29029 February 1984 FOIA Request for Correspondence Between Util,Hj Kaiser & NRC Referenced in Encl Ohio Civil Rights Commission ML20102A0241984-02-28028 February 1984 FOIA Request for Region III & IE Repts from Nov 1983 to Present & Communications Between Region III & Util,Bechtel or Kaiser Corp Officials ML20114A3081984-02-28028 February 1984 FOIA Request for All Region III Insp Repts from Nov 1983 to Present & All Communications Between Region III & Bechtel, Dayton Power & Light Cincinnati Gas & Electric Co Representatives Re Facility ML20083N2621984-02-16016 February 1984 FOIA Request for Interim Repts Issued by Ofc of Investigation Re Plant,Including DOJ Rept Re Harassment of QC Inspectors ML20079H2891984-01-11011 January 1984 Submits Partial Response to Util Plan to Verify Quality of Const for Facility.Counsel for Miami Valley Power Project Decision Not to Attend 840111 Public Meeting Clarified. Related Info Encl ML20079H6801983-12-16016 December 1983 Informs of Release of Info Highly Relevant to Miami Valley Power Project 831214 2.206 Petition for Reconsideration of ASLB Ruling Re Idvp.Review of 831215 Transcript Requested Prior to Decision ML20083F8901983-12-0606 December 1983 Requests Info on Implications of Layoffs of 300 Document Review Staff W/O Conducting Exit Interviews ML20082K2361983-12-0101 December 1983 Forwards Corrected Certificate of Svc for Memorandum in Support of Motion to Further Defer Rulings Until Completion of Investigation Into Matl False Statements by Util & NRC ML20084R5191983-11-16016 November 1983 FOIA Request for Records Relevant to &/Or Generated in Connection W/Nrc Order to Show Cause & Order Immediately Suspending Const (CLI-82-33) ML20083J5931983-10-12012 October 1983 FOIA Request for Draft or Final Hoyt Investigation Rept Re Facility ML20133Q3511983-09-19019 September 1983 FOIA Request for Ofc of Investigations Documents Re Wh Zimmer Nuclear Power Station ML20080D2451983-08-26026 August 1983 Lists Concerns Resulting from Review of Torrey Pines Mgt Audit Recommendations ML20077J0731983-08-0808 August 1983 Urges Public Meeting in Cincinnati,Oh Re Torrey Pines Mgt Review.Rept Should Be Made Public & Advance Meeting Notice Provided.Related Correspondence ML20076D9131983-07-25025 July 1983 Requests WASH-1400, Reactor Safety Study, Citing Concerns Re Facility & Ionizing Radiation ML20072N4431983-07-12012 July 1983 Forwards Motions Re Reopening Record to Admit Contentions on QA & Corporate Character & Competence ML20072N4111983-07-12012 July 1983 Forwards Miami Valley Power Project 830602 Original Motion to Reopen Record for Admission of Eight Contentions on QA & Corporate Character & Competence,To Complete Commission Record ML20090F6641983-06-29029 June 1983 Requests Info from 830607 Interview Re Ofc of Inspector & Auditor 1981 Investigation Be Immediately Reported to Commission & Aslb.Transcript Requested for Personal Records ML20081B7201983-06-16016 June 1983 Appeals Denial of FOIA Request for Ofc of Investigation Repts Re Allegations Concerning Presence of Bechtel Representative at Facility Prior to Nov 1982 ML20076J1521983-06-15015 June 1983 Forwards Appalachia-Science in the Public Interest Request to File Amicus Curiae Brief.Amicus Curiae Brief Not Sent to NRC Internal Mail or Docketing Sections ML20076J1831983-06-15015 June 1983 Forwards Cumberland Chapter of Sierra Club Request to File Amicus Curiae Brief.Amicus Curiae Brief Not Sent to NRC Internal Mail or Docketing Sections ML20072B4701983-06-0707 June 1983 Affirms Nuclear Study Committee,Southern Ohio District Church of Brethren 830603 Amicus Curiae Brief.Health,Safety & well-being of Southern Ohio & Northern Kentucky Communities Must Be Assured.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20073T3681983-04-28028 April 1983 Clarifies Contention 5 Re Ion Exchange Resin Reactor Coolant Polishing Sys,Per 10CFR2.206 ML20073E5901983-04-0808 April 1983 Recants Encl 830319 Addendum to Procedural Reasons for Acceptance of Gillman Five Proffered Contentions ML20071Q1241983-04-0101 April 1983 FOIA Request for Info Re Safety & Const Violations at Facility ML20069G4561983-03-19019 March 1983 Forwards Addendum to 830228 Contentions ML20028G6781983-02-11011 February 1983 Discusses Concerns Re NRC Oversight of third-party Nomination & Util Nomination of Bechtel to Audit & Propose Solutions for QA Breakdown at Facility ML20077J1821983-02-0808 February 1983 FOIA Request for Documents Mentioning or Referring to Contacts Between NRC & Util or Bechtel Re third-party Audit or Review of Util Mgt ML20028G2091983-01-31031 January 1983 Protests Manner in Which Region III Is Reviewing Util Proposal of Bechtel Proposal to Conduct Third Party Program. Commission,Not NRC Staff,Should Decide If Proposals Satisfy Commission 821112 Order ML20077J2681983-01-24024 January 1983 Forwards Fully Deleted Copy of Affidavit Submitted w/830120 Ltr.Substitution Requested.Witness Concerned W/Industry Blacklisting ML20077J1881983-01-20020 January 1983 Responds to Region III Challenge at 830105 Public Meeting Re Util Proposal for Bechtel to Administer third-party Program at Facility.Bechtel Nomination Should Be Rejected Due to Deficient Audit Plan ML20064M2161983-01-10010 January 1983 Opposes Reopening of Hearings & Involvement of Bechtel in third-party Audit ML20064F1421982-12-21021 December 1982 Requests Clarification of Sh Lewis 821124 Memorandum Summarizing NRC 821117 Meeting W/Util & Bechtel.Public Access to Enforcement Meetings Should Be Allowed ML20028D9641982-11-27027 November 1982 FOIA Request for Documents Pertaining to NRC Statement in 821113 Inquirer Re Zimmer Nuclear Reactor & Bechtel Corp ML20066A8871982-10-22022 October 1982 Requests Public Hearing Be Held Before OL Issued ML20066A8351982-10-18018 October 1982 Requests Public Hearings Be Held Before OL Issued ML20065M7361982-10-18018 October 1982 Forwards Suppl to Miami Valley Power Project 820820 Petition to Suspend Facility Const ML20071M8861982-09-24024 September 1982 Comments on Alleged NRC Attempt to Cover Up Seriousness of Problems at Facility.Subj Will Be Brought to Attention of Congress & Administration ML20063H0641982-08-23023 August 1982 Demands third-party Investigation,Independent Mgt Audit & Halt to Const ML20063A5491982-08-20020 August 1982 Forwards Petition on Behalf of Miami Valley Power Project to Suspend Const Pending Completion of Comprehensive Reinsp & Corrective Actions for All safety-related Work by Independent Organization ML20105C4711982-07-16016 July 1982 Expresses Disappointment W/Lack of Investigation of Problems at Plant ML20063D5791982-07-0909 July 1982 Appeals Denial of FOIA Request for Document Re IE Insp Rept 50-358/81-13 ML20054M2221982-07-0909 July 1982 Explains Differences in Nonconformance Rept & in-process Insp Deficiency Rept.Investigation Into Possible Matl False Statements Requested ML20054J1441982-05-20020 May 1982 Requests NRC Investigate Facility Further Before Granting License.Assurance Requested Re Safety,Evacuation & Info Dissemination to Public ML20058E5431982-04-20020 April 1982 FOIA Request for Documents Re IE Insp Rept 50-358/81-13 ML20054C7291982-03-18018 March 1982 FOIA Request for Ofc of Inspector & Auditor Repts on Issues Investigated During 1981 at Facility,Other than Applegate Original Charges & All spin-off Repts.Excerpt from R Deyoung Unofficial Transcript Encl ML20040G7541982-02-0303 February 1982 Urges Cessation of Const Activities Until Plant Has Undergone Audit by Independent QA Firm ML20040G7581982-02-0202 February 1982 Suggests NRC Require Insp from Independent QA Firm 1985-02-19
[Table view] |
Text
m
- n _ . . .I -
c p * %
GOVERNMENT ACCOUNTABILITY PROJECT 00gJc G Institute for Policy' Studies u (202)234-9382 1901 Que Street, N.W., Washington, D.C. 20009
\ ' '83 FEB -2 h10 :53 1' ,
January 31, 1983 i ru:w: rr .
E <T ri ';R. .C ' ;
- r. 5?.RM a
- E?M .
r The Honorable Nunzio J. Palladino - !
Chairman I occtTrNUMBER U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission PROD.& UTIL1.:wo- FAC. ..g, """' j[ f[='&
Washington, D. C. 20555
Dear Chairman Palladino:
On behalf of the Miami Valley Power Project ("MVPP"), the Government Accountability Project (" GAP") submits this protest to ,
the manner in which Region III is reviewing Cincinnati Gas and s Electric's ("CG&E") proposal of the Bechtel Corporation's proposal to conduct the third-party program at Zimmer. The NRC Staff has repeatedly failed to incorporate mechanisms for effective public participation in its review process. Of greater importance, how-ever, is Region III's intention at this time to make a decision on Bechtel's proposal,without adequately investigating a number of serious matters. GAP believes it is essential that the Commission itself assume a guiding role in determining whether or not CG&E's proposals satisfy the requirements laid out in the Commission's Order of November 12, 1982, since the NRC Staff has demonstrated g it lacks either the will or the competence to do the job.
GAP's concerns lie in four areas. The order in which these concerns are presented does not indicate any hierarchy of im-portance. _
' First, in a January 27, 1983 conversation with GAP, Region III Counsel Stephen Lewis stated that the Staff is not concerned with
' the contractual arrangement between CG&E and Bechtel that existed prior to the November 12 Order Suspending Construction. In ad-dition, Mr. Lewis,has stated he does not know and is not concerned with whatever contractual relationship exists today between CG&E and Bechtel. m-.
I F 'i r -
On January 27, 1983, I telephoned Mr. Lewis to request a ' copy of any contract or arrangement currently in effect between CG&E and Bechtel, or.in e'ffect between the two companies prior to Novem-ber 12, 1983. It is obvious from the correspondence between CG&E and Bechtel that some type of agreement, either. oral or written, exists. On November 8, 1982, Bechtel Power Corporation's Presi-dent H. O. Reinsch wrote to Mr. Dickhonerlthat it was prepared to help CG&E " complete the project." Mr. Reinsch attached copies of two contracts to his letter, one of which_was a technical services agreement (Exhibit 1). Apparently this technical services agree-ment was for Phas'e 1 of Bechtel's work, which is intended to identify the organizational, procedural and other actions needed 8302070522 030131 DRADOCK05000g l }
y ,
, l t
The Honorable Nunzio J. Palladino
-January 31, 1983 ;
Page Two $
dj td complete the Zimmer project., In a November 23, 1982 letter to Mr. Dickhoner, Bechtel laid out its proposal to conduct a management 'j review required by the Commission in its November 12 Order. In the .
letter Mr. Reinsch states, " Appendix A describes the objectives and J approach to the Independent Review of the project which is proposed y
for accomplishment under the Technical Services Agreement submitted {
on November 8, 1982. This review which we have designated as Phase. t 1 is currently in progress." (Emphasis added.) h GAP and other commenters on the Bechtel proposal questioned whether '
Bechtel could be independent if it already had established a working relationship with,CG&E and had already worked on the project. In
- response to Region III Administrator James Koppler's letter, CG&E, l on January 3, 1983, wrote the following about the contractual agree-ment between CG&E and Bechtel: "The only document we have related '
to our plans to utilize Bechtel as outlined in my letter of Novem-ber 10, 1982, to the NRC Commissioners, is a proposal submitted by Bechtel with a transmittal letter dated November 8, 1982. A copy of this original submittal, less contract terms and conditions which we and Bechtel deem proprietary...is enclosed." (Emphasis added.) Mr. Dickhoner proceeded to state that Bechte'l is currently completing a management review at its own risk, and that CG&E in-tends for this assessment to. satisfy the Commission's November 12 -
Order. If approved by the NRC "a final _ agreement will be signed concerning these services...." .
It appears from both Bechtel and CG&E's responses to the NRC that some agreement already exists between the two, and that it is likely that this agreement conforms more or less to the Technical Services Agreement attached to Bechtel's November 8, 1982 letter. Moreover, it seems that if Bechtel is approved, the contractual relationship between CG&E and Bechtel whereby Bechtel is hired to do an indepen-dent management review will conform in general terms to this '
Technical Services Agreement.
Mr. Lewis sta*ad that he believes such contractual relationships are not relevant to the NRC's analysis of Bechtel's independence.
What was clear from the January 5, 1983 public meeting in Cincinnati was that the' Cincinnati community does not agree. Mayor Thomas B.
Brush summarized the concerns of many when he stated at that meeting:
"I think what you are asking is, do we feel that because CG&E retained Bechtel prior to the order that that per.
se is enough to disqualify Bechtel, and I think we are reluctant at this point to come out and say yes, be-cause we want these questions answered first.... Maybe they are in fact absolutely independent. Maybe these questions will ' reveal it. But at least at the outset it doesn't look as though they would be . "
I Transcript, at 19.
\
a.
.l4:
The Honorable Nunzio J. Palladino
,1 January 31, 1983 Page Three ,
di
^
City Councilman Guy C. Guckenberger concurred:
.(
'TW] hen you have prior communications between CGGE j[
and Bechtel prior--an apparent prior arrangement, it s ,
d-makes a number of us very concerned about whether lj!
there will be public confidence in a management re- 7.!!
view of the process, or will ihis be a joint venture 4-
{i to get the plaht completed."
}t. $;
Transcript, at 15. .;
Si 8;
Obviously Mr. Keppler originally thought that the question of any existing contractual relationship between CGEE and Bechtel important ~.
enough to ask.1/ M
^
' Mr. Lewis should make sure that Mr. Keppler's questions are answered.
The Staff cannot accept CG&E's position that any contractual rela- "j tionship is proprietary information. In our opinion, such an ac-captance of CG&E's position makes the public safety a proprietary !
matter since the CGEE-Bechtel contract establishes the basic ground- f rules for quality verification of the plant. ,
Second, Region III may recommend the approval of Bechtel prior to ,
l a comprehensive investigation of alleged material false statements '1 I made by Bechtel and CG&E to the NRC about Bechtel's prior activities at the Zimmer site.
In January 27 and 28, 1983 conversations, Mr. Lewis stated that i although the NRC was investigating the alleged material false state- [
ments, its investigators did not intend to question CG&E directly l about the statements unless it was absolutely necessary. Further, l
Mr. Lewis stated that he believed this "in,vestigation" could be l completed within a week or even less time. GAP believes allegations j of material false statements by Bechtel and CG&E should be of seri-ous concern to the N RC . In fact, Mr. Keppler explicitly acknowledged ,
this at the January 5, 1983 public meeting: "[I] f Bechtel responded l falsely, it will be treated as a serious matter, yes." Transcript, j i
l at 60. ,
Certainly the NRC considered Bechtel site vt' sits in connection with l the CG&E letter of November 10, 1982 significant enough to ask about.
Mr. Keppler requested specifically "a chronology of meetings between :
CG&E and Bechtel, and site visits by Bechtel employees in connection I with this effort." Once again, Region III should be serious about l
.getting full and accurate answers to its questions. Any investi- !
i gation cannot be deemed complete until the NRC has spoken to those l allegedly responsible for making the statements -- CGEE and Bechtel
-- and returning with its findings to those who made the initial allegations -- GAP and the five witnesses with critical evidence about the alleged misrepresentations. We have learned that the
-1/Mr. Keppler specifically asked: "Please provide all documents and a discussion of any oral understanding related to CG&E's plans to utilize Bechtel as described in your November 10, 1982 letter to the NRC Commissioners and activities contemplated in response to the November 12, 1982 Commission order."
- a
' (
The Honorable Nunzio J. Palladino '
January 31, 1983 Page Four '
'l nl five witnesses have confirmed with federal investigators the specifics
- of GAP's January 20, 1983 letter'to Mr. Keppler. S u r e l~y , under those
, circumstances it is " absolutely necessary" to demand that CGEE foi - l' mally respond to the charges. j yl Third, Region III has received additional information from CG&E about allegations that Bechtel has a financial involvement in the three ,
j j
utilities which own Zimmer. Prior to GAP 's telephone calls to
- Mr. Lewis on January 27 and 28, 1983, none of this information was shared with the public. After conducting further research on the subject, GAP believes that Bechtel's past financial involvement in the three companies which own Zimmer necessitates a full investiga-tion of Bechtel's prior, and perhaps continuing, tole in underwriting CGGE, Dayton Power f4 Light, and Columbus and Southern Ohio Electric debt and equity. ,
According to Mr. Lewis, on January 10, 1983 CG&E forwarded a letter from Bechtel to the NRC in which Bechtel's chief counsel John F.
McGuinn states the followingt i
1)/ Dillon, Read has no present investment interest in'any of the three utilities owning Zimmer.
- 2) Dillon, Read formerly participated in underwriting
~
< syndicates formed to raise debt or equity for theithree utilities.
. 3)' Sequoia Ventures, a privately-owned company whose share-holders include members of the Bechtel family, owns a "significant interest" in Dillon, Read.
- 4) Three of Dillon, Read's 22 directors were nominated by Sequoia.
G AP ' s subsequent research demonstrates the following:
- 1) According to Dillon, Read Vice-President Carl DeLucia, Sequoia Ventures purchased Dillon, Read in June, 1981.
- 2) Sequoia Ventures, Mr. DeLucia stated,'is owned by the '
Bechtel family and serves as an umbrella for the Bechtel family's business interests.
- 3) The Board of Directors of Dillon, Read consists of sub-stantially the same people today as before its purchase by Sequoia.
However, three new directors have been nominated by Sequoia. In e f fe ct , Bechtel's letter provided information irrelevant to the allegations made by GAP.
i See Cohen Affidavit, attached as Exhibit 2.
Mr. Lewis informed me thac he had asked CG&E to clarify a few statements in the Bechtel letter described above. ,
o'
! i l
.1 The' Honorable Nunzio J. Palladino _,
January 31, 1983 g -
Page Five .
.Considering'the past subst'antial involvement of Bechtel in Dillon, ]
i Road, and through Dillon, Read in underwriting debt and equity for the three utilities which own Zimmar, GAP believes it is imperative #
that the NF.C conduct a full investigation. Moreover, the NRC must ;
condition any approval of Bechtel on its and,Dillon, Read's commit- '
ment not to underwrite or to participate \in any underwriting syndi- ,
cates which raise ei,ther debt or equity .for any utility which owns any portion of Zimmer over the operating life of the plant. j i
Fourth, Bechtel's overall attitude towar'd its proposed independent review of Zimmer's management is not conducive to assuring that Zimmer is constructed in accordance with NRC regulations, and so as to protect the public health and safety. In Bechtel's letter of j November 8, 1982,. Mr. Reinsch reveals the company's perspectives t, 'j -
i
- "The completion of your project is vital to your company as well as the future of the U. S. nuclear ;
utility industry." i v
In viewing Zimmer as the last stand for the nuclear industry in some imagined war game between pro-nuclear and anti-nuclear forces, Bechtel seems to miss'the point of the Commission-ordered independent audit. The overriding objective of both the management audi't and the independent verification of the quality of construction at Zimmer must be to ensure that Zimmer has been built and can be operated safely. Bechtel already has revealed its bias by' eliminating the possibility that it may not be feasible to finish the plant safely.
Bechtel's announced goal is speedy completion, which may conflict ,
with the findings of a truly objective review.
A secondary purpose of the program is to re-establish public
- confidence in CG&E and in the NRC. CG&E's and Bechtel's unwilling-ness to work with the public and those workers and whistleblowers who first brought the problems of Zimmer to the NRC's attention
, has only aggravated the already-anxious Cincinnati community. More-
' over, CG&E's failure to serve the intervenors or other interested parties with relevant letters and information on the third-party proposal, and the NRC's tolerance for and encouragement of such secrecy have further eroded public confidence in the dedication of the NRC to protection of the public health and safety.2_/
GAP requests today that the Commission itself reassume the power it delegated to Mr. Keppler to ensure that the entity chosen to conduct a management audit, of, Zimmer and a verification of the soundness and safety of Zimmer's construction be truly independent and competent, and have complete integrity.
2,/MVPP has requested that the Commission prohibit any further ex parte contacts between CG&E and Region III Staff delegated the responsibility to review the third-party proposals of the utility and that MVPP be notified of all further meetings on the third party. Supplemental Brief in Support of Petition for Baconsideration, December 22, 1982. pg -
K' M
o9 .
=
, s ,
0- - ! , I
. .I
)
The Honorable Nunzio J. Palladino ;
January 31, 1983 -
a V
Page Six ' - ,
s fg It is clear that'Mr. Keppler has shut out the public at every -j critical stage of the review process, in direct contradiction to j his professed desire for effective public participation, and his '
claim that Region III's review process would parallel the third- i}
party review process established at Diablo Canyon. .
f.
k GAP.further requests that the Commission itself ensure an adequate I review and -investigation of the four points outlined above-- 1 1).~That the Commission obtain and study the oral or written contractual relationship now existing be- j tween Bechtel and CG&E and existing prior to the - j November 10, 1982 CGEE letter to the NRC; j
- 2) That the Commission ensure a thcrough investigation of all allegations that Bechtel has a financial in-volvement in the.three utilities which own Zimmer and that Bechtel and CGEE have made material false statements to the NRC about Bechtel site visits prior to November 12, 1982; and
- 3) That the Commission ensure that whatever entity is chosen to cond'ct u a third-party audit 'of Zimmer is .
-dedicated to safe construction and operation of the plant and not to the future of the three owners of Zimmer or the nuclear industry.in general.
Today, GAP is also writing to Congressman Morris Udall to request that these matters be addressed at the February 22, 1982 NRC Autho-rization Hearing. The NRC has admitted tardiness in recognizing the quality assurance breakdown at Zimmer and even today to being ill-equipped to handle the many serious problems existing at the site. The Commission 's unprecedented actLon in suspending all safety-related construction at Zimmer on November 12, 1982 highlighted the extraordinary nature of the plant's deficiencies. Given this his-tory, and the total erosion of the public's confidence in CG&E and in the NRC Sta f f , GAP believes nothing less than direct and con-
- sistent attention by the full Commission to the third-party review process will re-establ,ish public confidence in the Zimmer plant.
Sincerely yours, ,
EA. .2^ ^
Lyn e Bernabei omas Devine Counsel for Intervenor Miami Valley s
Power Project e LB/TD/my f*-
(.m
I ..'. a ,
EXHIBIT 1 %
" :.J-
~
Bechtel Power Cor,ooration
- .y . Engineers - Constructors
,00LKETE0 -
US}iRC Fifty Beale Street .- / j
. San Francisco. California A 4Mress:
P.O.Bos 3965. San Franc:s:o.CA 939 N 83 FEB -2 ~
i 7.
s;.
. i
, , ,,g.. November; 8', ' 1982
-[CCigTlgf5fliv: CE ;
i
]
BRANCH ,
%g Mr. W.H. Dickhoner, President s Cincinnati Gas and Electric Company 's ')3 139 East Fourth Street
- Cincinnati, Ohio 45202 . ~
!i 3
De'ar Mr. Dickhoner: ,
/
We appreciated the ' opportunity, the f rankness , and the cooperation of your .
3 personnel in discussing the status of your project last Friday. We agree that
.this is a critical time in the schedule for the completion of the W.H. Zi=cer plant. The completion of your projec't is vital to your company as well as the
. future of the U.S. nuclear utility industry. Bechtel is prepared to mobilize our full capability and experience to help Cincinnati Gas and Electric complete the project. ,
We believe that our management experience at Fermi, WPPSS, South- Texas , and Diablo Canyon can provide you with the assistance your project organization -
needs to resolve the current problem areas and complete the Quality Confirmation Program. . -
Appendix A describes the immediate steps we would take to identify organizational, procedursl, and' actions that are needed. This Phase 1 of the initial work is expected to take three weeks, in which time our senior people ;
would further de' sign the approach and a staffing plan for the , completion of ;
the project. Generally, those same people, upon completion of this phase, ;
vould be available to. carry out the implementation of the plan. l i
Appendix B includes the resumes' of, the Phase I team members. You'll find them i
,.very experienced in' nuclear power " plan't['and particularly BWR, projects. In j salmeting these candidatesi ve have'empliasized the need for experience in: i
- 2. .' ' ~u.'h n;Bhq,*.~l :ifigf
,.1. ' ' . Project manag . at and con'struction management
- 2. Integrated project control I
- 3. QA/QC programs '
- 4. Construction completion, systems turnover, and startup Appe ndix C includes summaries of Bechtel's nuclear experience, which, as you know, is approached by no other company.
e 0 t;. .
~~~
Mr. W.H. Dickhonor, Prasident , _O
' 2 'l
- ** g. A Pcgq-umb3r 2 8, us2
. Bechtel Power Corporation H '
(
~
Some of Bechtel's in-depth capabilities that we think are important to this f job'are: '
f
' ^,
> ;J ,
4
- 1. Construction management and direct-hire construction *
,y
. y}
'! . Quality control programs -
, J:
m A
g
- 3. Project control systems for integration of quality, , schedule and cost
- priorities .
j
- q x
4 ' Reactor containment expertise '
- 5. Welding expertise and national code relationships l- 6.
Nuclear regulatory licensing expertise i
- 7. Labor relations
. q ,
- 8. Operating power plant services .
In Appendix D, for your. convenience we have included copf es of two contract forms. The first is a technical services' agreement which is our nor=al cont ract for studies similar to the Phase I effort. The second is the form we normally use for more broad-based support of nuclear plant project completions. This Phase IL contract allows assignment of the, activities that [
we can foresee for successful completion of the project and allows Cincinnati Cas and Electric, at their discretion to utilize any of Bechtel's capabilities that may be required. -
In the event that additional support services are needed after project completion, commercial terms are included that' allow Cincinnati Cas and
' Electric to use our Operating Plant Services organizatioc af ter commercial operation for whatever help may be needed. ~
I have found it useful to personally intensively review our performance and
~
overall project progress in periodic ?
executive review meetings with your counterparts in other, utilities. I I recommend a similar program on the Zimmer
'k Bechtel is prepared to provida.
h* k Cas and Electric in..the 'succe,, ssful expertise , and resources c,ompletion
' to assist Cincinnati
. of the W.H. Zimmer Nuclear Station project. We so have' sufficient experienced personnel to accomplish it in conjunction with the project's'. existing capable personnel. We look forward to working with you towards that end. -
Sincerely, H.O. Reinsch President-HOR /lsw - .
Enclosures
- hh frd.%!f$h ., ,$ h}h s -
.k $ h ' *4l# )- Wr,& h $.
w.Qh_.. . ;fs l k *y_& hkh 'b5 e..
, . , ;g,g' ' 4,('M ."$*-
a ~
, . ' .:* -
* ."-( .+ ( W,*2W.1 " .
- t ,,
...<n .,
* .p>;. j
;i
/ + e v gl 4XHIBIT 2 ,
), a. %%L , , ,
. , , , , n .f r '
,y
; ug, ;.c
'.! x.
. : iikyM M 4 RQ'.b Q 9ci.h;Mhh
' ~
. AFFIDAVIT . , . , '@ -
,;Q i
- Jw sd tn'*.;1 ..u sa@Cl- gtpyt ea g M*.
.- b.n. W.gry : o ,
tw gggt.
g j .,o q
. . NO U*W.@ . City of Washington ) ,
~
-9 3%Q .< &wJj~J{.41s
)- ss. %, . ..
- m , . qcay Ae M District of Columbia) .
s .
m.
. ~ ; . 4,,
M+di[0,d I 4 _ - n. ,
* '. [:,y u, b elc :@gQ
. .- r . ,
3:Q -
-Mark Cohen, being duly sworn, deposes and says:
. e1
/M. [fNDM 4 .> ... ,. o .,
- 1. My name is Mark Cohen. I am a legal intern with the Government
. r a . . .. 9. ..'cY ,
...y'- -y Accountability Project of the Institute for Policy Studies. . , l 1.j g. n .
- 2. On Friday, January 28, 1983, I spoke by phone with a man who ~
- 1. . .. .
T-
.". Js. ..
identified himself as Carl DeLucia. Mr. DeLucia said that he is z.,.
- - ,. ..-a ; ,
E*v3i the Vice-President of Dillon, Read & Company. a ,
. , , .t - el '
- 3. Mr. DeLucia asked that he not be quoted. I told him 'I would [ !
w .
' I abide by his request. i
. . 4. . .
g-i ,
- 4. The following is based upon my notes and recollections of ,
1 1 N
'4- this conversation:
T n
., _ , 5. Mr. DeLucia said that Bechtel had purchased Dillon, Read & .f
,s. .m
<3 Company in June 1981. He said that Bechtel is the major shareholder - y .
. 'd in Dillon, Road.'
._.,A '
4 y 6. Upon questioning, Mr. DeLucia clarified his statement by f
;.y ' i explaining that the formal name of the purchaser is Sequoia ventures,
'}
, r J, '
Inc., which he characterized as a privately-held company that is c, . .. ..
7 owned by the Bechtel family and serves as an umbrella for family
,}
.1
..3 s
. ;, : 0'; : '
business interests. . 1, ;
y- % q
. < 7. Mr. DeLucia said that the Dillon, Read Board of Directors is ; i
. ..M ( '
l
..V
' ~ '
composed of the same people today for the most part as it was before
' , : Y [: w
.MJ/.\ its purchase by Sequoia Ventures. However, he counted three j
%, 4
;Wg "
Directors selected for the Dillon, Read Board since June 1981, 4
J
/ $ sc L.u :.;- '
[
who were nominated by Sequoia.
( ,e .. _.> , u, .:f' e y2,.h ., ;.
i
* ; t l 1 "..
M; I have read the above one-page affidavit and it is true, j j
C..,.2.
accurate and complete to the best of my knowledge and belief. i
; ... f, ,y,( ,
y<,
g &
~
l Ji. . . MXRK COHEN ,
l
'~ I c'2 Subscribed and sworn to before i M"P' me this d day of k m I
';; 1983. (/ f ,
l 6
; Y N. -
5 ' < NC7FARY FUBL.LC >
- YlOLA H. BURKE HotAny Misuc Distitlcr or columa A ?
Ng Cousinion Empires Janua,y 2.1986
. - wg g.w.yp
=---e.. n.,
l
.a 4- .-
p .,
.r.
~ < s p : -- - -
., . , r. . y, ,,
i
, . i. , ,
[ L 1"*--"'" ~ ~ - - = -n, . - - . - - . . , _ , _ _ m e ._ u _ }
GOVERNMENT ACCOUNTABILITY PROJECT cog'a institute for Policy Studies . . 1 1901 Que Street. N.W., Woshington, D.C. 2000? (
'h5 -
, /-
. $3 @ ~~ r
, . January 31,,19,3jsq , ,..y I
, c ,
-p ;
The Honorable Morris K. Udall '\. . 1l
' U.S. House of Repr'esentatives Df 235 Cannon House Office Building 1 Washington, D. C. 20515 ,
Dear Congressman Udalls,
3 hl Today the Government Accountability Project transmitted our serious 6.
concerns to the Nuclear Regulatory Commission Chairman Nunzio J. ,',
Palladino about the manner in which Region III Staff is conducting e its review of the proposed third-party independent program for the Zimmer Nuclear Power Plant near Cin,cinnati, Ohio.
GAP requests that, in the course of the February 22, 1983 Authori-zation Hearings for Fiscal Years 1984 and 1985, you and your col-leagues impress on the Nuclear Regulatory Commission the need to enhance public participation and to increase public confidence in
- the integrity of the NRC review process. j 2 .
As yon and other Committee members are aware, the Commission was very slow to recognize the quality assurance breakdown at the Zimmer plant. Moreover, the November 12, 1982 Order of the Commission sus-pending construction at Zimmer was unprecedented. As Chairman Palladino admitted at that time, the Commission does not have the ,
situation at Zimmer under control. In ordering an independent s
third-party review of management and an independent review of the quality of construction at Zimmer, the Commission took the first step necessary to restoring seriously erode'd public confidence in the safety of the plant's construction and in the NRC itself.
Unfortunately, the NRC Staff is completely neutralizing the gains in legitimacy the Commission achieved on November 12. As GAP's letter to Chairman Palladino describes, the Region III Staff appears prepared to approve the Bechtel Corporation as the entity to complete the management review without adequately investigating a number of serious matters. In light of Region III's apparent inability to handle the task, GAP requests that the Crmmission reassert its commitment to oversee directly the reso ation of the Zimmer quality assurance breakdown.
GAP further asks the Commission to ensure that a number of serious matters are investigated prior to final approval of a third party _
i to conduct a management audit or to submit a quality verification j plan for Zimmer.
l l
e i o. _._
W The Honorable Morris K. Udall - 2- January 31, 1983
.,3
'f .)
Thank you in advance for your consideration of our request. ,-]:..:I Sincerely lyours, , fhj c.,
a y
. % * 'a
.- J' L e Bernabei *E ,
Sta f Counsel *l -
.s .- , 3 4 AcY ;)
Thomas Devine
. Legal Director j
+
s b LB/TD/my ,'
/
e Enclosure i
s e T m
'I
.s 9
i I
e
e h
l s
4 l
l l -
l l
. _ - . _ , -- . . .}}