ML20138Q830

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Further Response to FOIA Request for Records Re Voluntary or Required Redress of Sites Where Const Was Terminated, Including Crbr & Legal Analysis.Forwards App E Documents.App D & E Documents Available in Pdr.Photographs Also Available
ML20138Q830
Person / Time
Site: Clinton, 05000000, Zimmer, Bailly, Cherokee, Clinch River, Marble Hill, Black Fox, Hartsville, Phipps Bend, 07002838
Issue date: 12/03/1985
From: Grimsley D
NRC OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION (ADM)
To: Bell N
NUCLEAR INFORMATION & RESOURCE SERVICE
Shared Package
ML20136E200 List:
References
FOIA-85-362 NUDOCS 8512300023
Download: ML20138Q830 (6)


Text

.

ia n.o 7

/

'o UNITED STATES

~g 8"

NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION o,

t WASHING TON, D. C. 20555

~

\\, *..../

t I

I Ms. Nina Bell

~

Nuclear Information and Resource Service

{

1616 p Street, NW, Suite 160 IN RESPONSE REFER Washington, DC' 20036 TO F0!A-85-362 i

Dear Ms. Bell:

i i

This is in further response to your letter dated May 8,1985, in which yon requested, pursuant to the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA), all records related to the desirability of voluntary or required redress of nuclear plant sites where work was undertaken but construction is no longer contemplated, including the Clinch River Breeder Reactor (CRBR), and NRC's legal analysic of

]

the need for site redress.

The documents identified on the enclosed Appendix 0 are already available in i

j the NRC Public Document Room (PDR).

Copies of the documents listed on'the enclosed Appendix'E are being placed in the NRC Public Document Room (PDR). The records will be filed in PDR folder 4

1 F01A-85-362 under your name.

Staff of the Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation have informed this office that 25 photographs of the Clinton site and 16 photographs of the Black Fox site are available for inspection in their office, or copying at a cost of

$82.00.

If you wish to make arrangements regarding these photographs, please 7

)

telephone Mr. Stephen Isaacs at 301-492-7604 by December 12, 1985.

I i

Sincerely, i

i f ),,yp f

Y tA ! SL' t

i 4

Donnie H. Grimsley, Director Division of Rules and Records I

Office of Administration

)

i i

Enclosures:

As stated t

4 i

0312300023 e5 g03 PDN FOIA i

DELL 85-362 PDR

[

i

+

f Re:

F0!A-85-362 l

l APPENDIX D 1.

Letter to James Keppler, Region III, from W. H. Dickhoner, Cincinnati Gas and Electric Company, dated January 27, 1984 - Accession No.

8402030260 2.

Motion for Withdrawal of Application In the Matter of the Cincinnati l

Gas and Electric Company, et. al., (Wm. H. Zimmer Nuclear Power' Station) submitted by Troy R. Conner, Jr., Conner A Wetterhahn, P.C. Counsel for the Applicants, dated March 20, 1984 - Accession No. 8403210178 3.

NPC Staff's Answer to Motion for Withdrawal of Application submitted i

by Stuart A. Treby, Assistant Chief Hearing Counsel, in the Matter of Cincinnati Gas and Electric Company, et. al., Wm. H. Zimmer Nuclear power Station, (fnit 1 Before the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board, dated April 9, 1984 - Accession No. 8404120418 l

4.

Letter from James R. Schott, Cincinnati Gas and Electric Company to Harold R. Denton, Director, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation, dated June 1, 1984 - Accession No. 8406050405 1

5.

Applicant's transmittal of information relating to Their Motion for Mithdrawal of Application, submitted by Mark Wetterhahn, Conner A l

Wetterhahn, P. C., Counsel for the Applicants', dated August 2, 1984, In the Matter of the Cincinnati Gas and Electric Company, et. al.,

i Wm. H. Zimmer Nuclear Power Station - Accession No. 8408070461 6.

NRC Staff's Further Answer to Motion for Withdrawal of Application submitted by Stuart A. Treby, Assistant Chief. Hearing Counsel, dated August 17, 1984, Before the ASLB in the Matter of Cincinnati Gas and Electric Company, et. al. - Accession No. 8408?10366 I

7.

Memorandum and Order (Ruling on Applicant's Motion to Withdraw Application) issued by Atomic Safety and Licensing Board, dated i

August 29, 1984 - 4ccession No. 8408310104 8

Letter to Harold R. Denton, Director, NRR from Troy R. Conner, Jr.,

Counsel for the Applicant,

Subject:

in the Matter of the Cincinnati Gas and Electric Company, et. al. (Vm H. Zimmer Nuclear Power Station) dated October 18, In84 - Accession No. 8410270018 9.

Letter to J. R. Schott, Cincinnati Gas and Electric Company from C. J. Paperiello, Chief. Emorgency Preparedness and Radiological Branch dated January ll, 1985 - Accession No. 850?01066

10. Letter from J. R. Schott, Cincinnati Gas and Electric Company to H. J. Youngblood, Chief. Licensino Hranch No.1, dated May ll,1985 -

Accession 60. 8405180047 l

t

Re:

F0!A-85-362 APPEND 1X D

11. Letter to W. H. Dickhoner, Cincinnati Gas and Electric from Hugh L.

Thompson, Director, Division of Licensing.

Subject:

Revocation of Construction Pernit No. CPPR Wm. H. Zimmer Nuclear Power Station, Unit 1, dated May 16, 1985 - Accession No. 8506040561 12..

Letter to NRC from PSE8G,

Subject:

Withdrawal of Hope Creek Unit 2 Construction Permit, dated December ?9, 1981 - Accession No. 8112310271.

13. Letter tn NRC fron GSU,

Subject:

Forwards Amendment 1 to application for Operation license and report on termination of construction activities for River Bend Station Unit 2, dated June 29, 1984 - Accession No.

8401100330 14 Letter to NRC from GSU,

Subject:

Informs NRC of GSU's Board of Directers decision not to build River Bend Station Unit ?, dated.lanuary 10, 1984 -

Accession No. 8401100146

15. Letter to H. Denton from Booker, subject: Assessment of impacts on structures adjacent to River Bend Unit 2 Excavation dated February 7, 1984 - Accession No. 8403010321
16. Letter to NRC from Schiff Hardin and Waite,

Subject:

Motion to terminate proceedin9s with a notice of filing and certificate of service for Clinton Nuclear Station Unit 2, dated May 17, 1985 - Accession No.

8505200679

17. Letter to NRC,

Subject:

Clinton Power Station Unit ? Construction Pernit No. CPPR-138 Withdrawal, dateo April 9,1985 - Accession No. 8504120744

Re:

F0it,-05-36?

I APPENDIX E t

1.

04/09/84 Meno to B. J. Youngblood from R. L. Ballard, Subject

  • i Comments on Termination of the Zimer pro,iect.

(3 pagesl 2.

05/03/84 Letter to Jim Schott, Cincinnati Gas and Electric Company from R. J. Youngblood, Chief. Licensing. Branch No. 1, Division of Licensing,

Subject:

' Request for Additional-l Infomation for Environmental Review of Applicant's Request to Withdraw the Zimer OL Application.

(4 pages) 3.

06/20/84 Memorandum for B. J. Youngblood, Chief, Licensing Branch No.1, DL from Ronald L. Ballard, Chief. Environmental and Hydrologic Engineering Branch, DE, Sub,iect:

Environmental Review of Applicant's Request to Withdraw the Zimer OL Application.

(2pages) 4.

07/05/84 Memorandum for S. Treby, Assistant Chief Hearing Counsel, DELD from B. J. Youngbicod Chief, Licensing Branch No.1, DL, i

Subject:

Environtrental Aspects of Cincinnati Gas and Electric c

Company's (CGAE) Request to Withdraw the Zimer OL Application.

1 (3 pages)

[

l 5.

08/29/84 Memorandum and Order (Ruling on Applicant's Motion to Withdraw l

Application issued by the ASLB on August 29, 1984, In the Matter of The Cincinnatt Gas and Electric Company, et. al.,

(Wm. H. Zimer Nuclear Power Station, Unit 1).

(8 pages) 6.

09/11/84 Note to Harold R. Denton from James p. Murray, Sub.iect:

Zimer OL Application.

(1 page) 7.

10/03/84 Pemorandum for D. G. Eisenhut, Director, NRR from L. L. Kinter, Project Manager, Licensing Branch No. 1. DL

Subject:

Plan for Action for Withdrawal of Zimer OL Application and Cancellation of Construction Permit.

(7 pages) 8.

10/09/84 letter to L.Kintner from G. C. Ficke,

Subject:

Idantification of Reining NRC Licenses.

Il naqo) 9.

10/31/84 tstter to James P. Schott, Cincinnatt Gas and Electric Company

.lgned by Frank J. Miraglia,

Subject:

SAL 9 Ordor Authorizing Pithdrawal of Application for Operating License - W'n, H. linner Nuclear Power Station Unit 1

Enclosure:

Federal Reqister Notice.

(6 pagesl 10.

11/0?/84 Meno to NRR P9t. from L. L. Kintnert Subje.ct:

Daily Highliqht.

(1page) 11.

11/0?/84 Porno to Docketiny and Service Dranch from MP,

Subject:

Notice of Withdrawal of Application for Operating License and femination of Proceedino.

(? pages) l l

Re:

F0!A-85-362 APPENDIX E

12. 01/11/85 Letter to NMSS from J. D. Flynn,

Subject:

Request that Zimmer Special Nuclear Material License SNM-1823 be terminated.

(15 pages) l l

13. 01/25/85 Memo to E. Adensam from R. L. Ballard,

Subject:

Environmental l

Inspection of Zinmer NPP Site.

(1 page)

14. 02/25/85 Memo to W. Crow from C. J. Paperiello,

Subject:

Confirmatory Survey and License Terminator 2/25/85, SNP-1823.

(20 pages)

15. 03/14/85 Letter to J. D. Flynn from W. T. Crow,

Subject:

Tennina tion of Materials License No. SNM-1823.

(2 pages)

16. 05/07/85 Region !!! Outgoing Transmission Service Request to les Kintner from Barbara Schnulle,

Subject:

Amendment No. 11 - Lic. No.

34-07251-04 (Termination).

(2 pages)

17. 05/07/85 Note to Harold R. Denton, Director,(NRR fron Hugh L.

Thompson, Jr.

Director. DL, NRR.

1 page)

CLINCil RIVER _

10. 03/23/84 Note for T. King, CRGR Progran Office, fron R. L. Ballard, DE.

Subject:

Contact Point for Clinch River Breeder Reactor Site Red rest..

(1 pge)

19. 04/30/84 Heno for T. King, CRBR Program Office, fron R. L. Hallard, DE.

Subject:

Review of Proposed Clinch River Dreeder Peactor (CRBR)

Site Redress Plan.

(2 pages)

20. 02/21/85 Note for 1. King. DST /NRP, and G. LaRoche. DE/NPR, from S. Turk, OELD, Sub.iect:

Onard questions on Citnch River Site Redress.

(1 pano)

21. Undated Drawinq - Location of Rare 4 linusual Plant Species, Clinch River fireeder Reactor Plant.

(1 page)

MAPHI.E HILI.

22. 04/01/85 Meno for B. J. Youngblood, DI., from R. Dallard, DE,

Subject:

Marble IIIII Site Stabilization Plan and Surrender of Construction Pemit.

(2 pages)

CllEROKEE 23.

11/03/83 Pern for H. Rood, DI., from R. Dallard, DE,

Subject:

Paturn of CP's for Cherokee.

(3 pages)

t l

Re:

F01A-85-362 i

APPENDIX E CPEROKEF _(CONTINUED) i

24. 05/24/81 Memo 'or G. Knighton, DL, from R. Ballard, DE,

Subject:

(

Cherokee Cancellation - Site Stabilization Plan (TAC #54651).

'a pages)

25. Undated Figare l'- Areas Disturbed During Construction, Duke Power Company Cherokee Nuclear Station.

(1 page)

26. Undated Fioure 2 - Existing Plant Structures and Construction l

Facilities, Duke Power Company, Cherokee Nuclear Station.

(1page)

IIARTSVILLFANDPHIPPSBFJD 27.

12/08/82 Memo for A. Schwencer, DL, fron R. Ballard, DE Subicct:

Procedure for Cancelling CP's for Hartsville B, I and 2, and Phipps Bend I and 2 NPP.

(2 Pages)

BLACK FOX l

i 28.

10/28/83 Letter to J. D. West, Public Service Company of Oaklahoma, fron G. LaRoche, DE

Subject:

Proposed Site Visit (Black Fox) - to observe implementation of soil stabilization t.

l crosion control plan.

(1page)

29. 02/01/84 Memo for E. Adensam DL, fron P. Dallard, DE.

Subject:

Inspection of Black Fox Erosion Control Plan's Execution.

(4 pages) nA 1 L L,Y,,

(

30. 02/03/82 Meno for D. Lynch, DL, from R. Ballard, DE,

Subject:

l Environmental Engineering Branch Review of Pedress of Railly Site.

(4 pages)

,CLINTON l

31. 04/19/85 Description (list) of General Plan View of site (Photos of Clinton Unit 2 excavation).

(3 pages)

32. 05/31/82 Memo for W. Butler, DL, from R. Dallard, DE,

Subject:

Fnvironmental Review of Applicant's Request to Withdraw the Clinton Unit 2 OL Aprilcotton and the Withdrawil of Construction Permit No. CPPP-130.

(2 pages)

33. 06/06/H5 NRC Staff's Response to Applicant's Motion to Termirate Proceeding (Clinton Power Station, Unit 2).

(15pages)

l w,,., : '5~

9.n=

Nuclear n"ormation anc lesource Service 1346 Connecticut Avenue NW 4th floor. Washington. O C 20036 (202) 296 7552 May 8, 1985 FREEBOtt OF ffWORMADON James M. Felton, Director Division of Rules and Records Fora-BS- % 2.

Office of Adminstration U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission N'd S//D/@

Washington, D.C.

20555 PREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT REOUEST

Dear Mr. Felton:

Pursuant to the Freedom of Information Act, 5 U.S.C.

522, an amended, the Nuclear Information and Resource Service requesta the following documents regarding the redrecc of siten where nuclear plant construction has begun.

Please consider

" documents" to include reports, studies, test resulta, correspondence,' memoranda, meeting notes, meeting minutes, l

working papern, graphs, charts, diagrams, notes and summaries of l

conversations and interviews, computer records, and any other forms of written communication, including internal NRC Staff memoranda.

The documents are specifically requested from, but not limited to, the Office of the Executive Legal Director (OELD) and Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation (NRR).

Purnuant to thin request, please provide all documents prepared or utilized by, in the possession of, or routed through the NRC related to:

l 1.

The decirablity of voluntary or required redress of nuclear power plant citen where exploratory, excavation or construction j

work han taken place and construction is no longer contemplated, including the Clinch River Breeder Reactor, except those documentn already part of HRC proceedings; 2.

NRC's legal analynic of the need for cite redrean of such alten both with and without a current construction permit and with and without a Limited Work Authorization having been incued.

l In our opinion, it in appropriate in thin cane for you to waive nearch chargen, purnuant to 5 U.S.C. 552 (a) (4) ( A) "becauno furninhing the information can be concidered an primarily benefiting the general public."

The Nuclear Information and Renource Service in a non-profit organization nerving local organizationn concerned about nuclear power and providing infor-mation to the general public.

Infornation required by 10 CFR 9.14a wao provided by letter dated Auguat 3, 1984.

i

_ +..m.- e l

r l

l 2 --

i Sincerely, t

e Nina Bell Assistant Director cc: File P

o l

l I

.-