ML20086G384

Intervenor Exhibit I-MOSBA-75,consisting of Re Addl Info Concerning Amended 10CFR2.206 Petition Filed by M Hobby & a Mosbaugh

ML20086G384
Person / Time
Site:	Vogtle
Issue date:	05/17/1995
From:	Mcckoy C GEORGIA POWER CO.
To:
References
2.206, OLA-3-I-MOSBA75, NUDOCS 9507140286
Download: ML20086G384 (5)

Text

- . _ __ ___ - .

d pf-03-1?u es 42 1 - g 3 g f) - 7 5 a Exhibit].i.paae 00 1.a[f Georga Power Co7aar

• 401nwness Center Parkway g

Post 0"ce Sox 1295 Bemingrwn. Alatau 35201 NUCLEAR REGULATORYCOMMISSION mME

• C)$ M ,,g p3 $$

2 g g y , ,u . 3 Docket No.

92 W AJ Ottcal Exh. No. 1*+ U

(, in the matter of GN 'd 'I bRE C.K.M:Co Stan IDENTIRED M SE -

v.:e prece~r ., Pt.cear Applicant RECEIVED ' DOC g v:ev %ee: Intervenor 7 REJECTED Georgia ver Conto Offr tr e soonem everre sfriem Ccatractar DATE ON7dY Otner witness 5 eMb/ December 10, 1991 Reporter C Ens e ELV-03293 Docket Nos. 50-424 50-425 U.S. NucisarD.C.

Washington, Regulatory Commission 20555 Attn:

Thomas E. Murley, Director Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation

Subject:

Additional Information Regarding Mr. Marvin HobbyAmended 10 CTR S 2.206 Petition Filed by and Mr. Allen Mosbauch Gentlemen:

O By letter dated October 3, information.("GPC") responded to your August 22,1991, Georgia Power Company

\

information in The request for additional information sought.1991 req associated petitioners petition.

a July 8, with several allegati 1991 supplement to their originalons submitted by the Subsequent to GPC's October 3, 1991 response identified information which is relevant to wepr, the have epa Director's Decision in this mattel'. ration of a of the information provided in this letter.The NRC may be aware of most all material deliberations. and relevant facts and circumstance your of I.

Reconended D Pover comoanv_.ecision and Order in MarvinGeorcia Hobbv v.

By Order dated November 8, Labor Case No Williams recom. 90-ERA-30, (the " Order")1991 in the U.S. Department of the Honorable Joel R.

of Mr. Marvin Hobby be dismissed with ereiudigg. mended to t had called the NRC's attention to this proceeding GPC previously in the Company's response, dated September 28 , as explained 1991, in this matter. ,

1990 and April 1,

_v.- e 9507140286 950517 PDR  :

G ADOCK 05000424 'w h

• PDR dpa

_ _ _ _ _ _ . _ . _ . . - __ __ _ , _ . _ _ . . - . _ _ , . _ . - - - . _ . . . ~ _ , _ _ _ . - . _ . _ _ . - - -

j f' At +-03-iMa s a?

ExNbit 7f' N e AP,06 of T i' '

]t I

L GeorgiaPower A l

i ( ~

l

}

petition Mr. Mosbaugh knew: 1) Operations Department annagement j

i identified the noncompliance of Technical Specifications on a

! morning status conference call, and 2) the reason for the l 4 noncompliance of Technical specifications was that information  !

]

concerning equipment out-of-service had been placed on the back j of a Limiting Condition of Operation status sheet. Thus, it j appears Mr. Mosbaugh possessed information prior to September i

1990 which was contrary to the statements made in his l September 11, 1990 petition. l l

Particinants in an Anril is. 1990 conference call Recardina 1

.k IV.

i l, LER 1-90-006. '

j GPC's October 3, 1991 scpplemental response sets forth the basis of GPC's April 1, 1991 statement regarding the Senior Vice President's lack of participation in a telephone conference call late on April 19, 1990 which finalized LER 1-90-006. In late October, 1991 in conjunction with discovery in Mr. Mosbaugh's l Department of Labor proceeding, GPC obtained cassette audio tapes

! which were surreptitiously made by Mr. Mosbaugh during, j approximately, the February-September, 1990 time frame. One of a those tapes of April 22., 1990 discussions (identified as Tape No.

71) indicates that Mr. Hairston was nga a participant during the

I April 11, 1990 telephone conference call when language concerning i emergency diesel generator start counts was finalized in the LER.

j The following is a transcript of a portion of this tape which l

contains a discussion between Mr. Mosh ugh (" ALM") and another j participant ("P") on the April 19th conference call.

! - AIM: I think there is a high probability that there is I a problem with their statement [in LER 90-06 concerning i diesel generator start information).

P: What George told me over the phone--

l - ALM George who?

1 I -

P: George Bockhold--

- ALM: When?

! - P Esfore we issued the LER. ,

AIM: Yeah.

- 7

We had a big conversation on those numbers with George (Seekho14), uh, [esorge] Emirston--

l (

_ AIM: Yeah. '

i

-s-

4

JfJi-03-1994 09:47 ExhibitT ,page. 1 of.7_.

l P.07 l

!O

' (. Georgi'aPower d 78 --or not Nairston, [ Bill) Shipman.

1 I

AIM: They were all on there.

P3 i

--and what George (Bockhold) said is they had explained to the Region that they had had--they used--

Tom got those numbers from what we presented to the NRC and then he just added the additional starts after that---

ALM: That's right.

P: But--and we questioned that with George (Rockhold) and what George [Bockhold) said is, 'Yes, we did have failures; the Region was aware we had failures, but we were in the troubleshooting mode and once we cleared the troubleshooting mode than we had that many successful starts.'

ALM: That's not true--

P: That's what I was told.

1 AIR: You can interpret--

ALM: Yeah, but that was a presumption on George's part--

Pt No. George did not presume anything. He made that as a statement of fact and all that information was presented (on April 9', 1990) and that's the way he made the to him before he made the NRC presentation presentation.

ALM: OK, well that's--

Pt George was aware of the fact that (inaudible)--

AIR: You've got to establish -you know, you have weasel words in this thing, yo,u've got to establish a criteria, OK, between X and X, how many successful starts do I think I had? What's my criteria? The words problem?

in there say ' failures and problems.* What's a O

I

-s- ,

%.. ..e.. - - - - , . . . . < - - . ~ . . . . . + - . . . , _ , , .. . ~.-- ..... ,, _ __,,,,,, . -. . ..~, ,..__ .... , , _ _.w.m.,,-.,--_ . - - - _ _ - , _ , , , , . _ _ , . _ . _ , _- - - , , _ , - - . . . - . . , - - . ,

JUN-03-1994 09:as Exhibit I, Pap 9 d5 g,og GeorgiaPowerA P:

would have been to wordappropriate it to sayWell, way I th

- havethis from had eighteen date going back.' consecutive'We, start have had -we s without a trip ALM:

p: Whatever-the words in there Well, they weren't-- weasely, areOK, -

AIR:

'since the 20th.'-they say ' failures and ey probleas' say and P:

standpoint, they weren'te intended AIX:

y. From m to bThey You e weasely.y ways.

need to decide what we missed , you know,ent er -All I'm sa we P: You'll

[Bockhold] probably want to mention that to George

.I ALM:

We need to decide what ssedwe mi not, but I have yet to be able various ways of interpreting it s true to or figurevie k

each method of interpreting, the I findwords a flaw withre out, among th i

i excerpt, Mr.

12R.

the participant indicated Bairston participated in conversati ted portion of thatthis mas can b

r. Shipman and not Thisduring participants reflected in documents sup is consistent the August with the collections which fina ve recollectio 1 l.

! Mr.plemental response. enclosed in GPC'sasOctober 3, 199

! Mosbaugh, as of April 27Moreover, the conversation indi GPC's prior responses 1990, include had not reached cates an Aoonclusion a that personal of " m 4 Mr. Dockhold from Mr. Mosbaugh pril 30, 1990ent" whi hmeno i relative to the IJDt.

Mr. Nosbaugh's conclusion regardi c to

information in the LER crystalliz ng incorrect, materialndicates to us tha

\ had been forwarded to the NRC .

ed only After the original I2R i

3

[O -

Jut 4-03-1994 09:49 gg 5 g 5-ceorsieeomer A O( -

matters I hope in anthis expeditious information will be helpful to resolve these manner.

assistance, please do not hesitate to contact me.If I can be of any further Very truly yours,

~

C. K. McCoy Enclosure cc: Georcia Power Company Mr. A. W. Dahlberg Mr. W. G. Hairston, III Mr. W. B. shipman Mr. P. D. Rushton Mr. J. T. Beckham Mr. M. Shelbani NORMS O(

U. B. Nuclear Reaulatory Commission Mr. S. D. Ebneter, Regional Administrator Kr.

D. 5. Mood, Licensing Project Manager, NRR Mr. B. R. Bonser, Senior Resident Inspector, Vogtle Document Control Desk

. l O

. . . - . - - - . . . - - . - - . - . . -._ . - . - . . . - - . . . . . _ - , -