ML20095D982

Georgia Power Co Motion to Correct Record of Exhibits of Diesel Generator Reporting Issues Allegation Hearing.* W/Certificate of Svc

ML20095D982
Person / Time
Site:	Vogtle
Issue date:	12/12/1995
From:	Lamberski J GEORGIA POWER CO., TROUTMANSANDERS (FORMERLY TROUTMAN, SANDERS, LOCKERMA
To:	Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
References
CON-#495-17349 93-671-01-OLA-3, 93-671-1-OLA-3, OLA-3, NUDOCS 9512140094
Download: ML20095D982 (18)

Text

- _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ - _ _

1

( 00CKETED USNRC December 12, 1995

% DEC 13 P2 :47 0FFICE OF SECRETARY DOCKETING & 3ERVICE BRANCH UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION Before the Atomic Safety and Licensine Board In the Matter of ) f45

) Docket Nos. 50-424I OLA-3 GEORGIA POWER COMPANY, )

etal. ) Re: License Amendment

) (Transfer to Southern (Vogtle Electric Gene oting ) Nuclear)

Plant, Units I and 2) )

) ASLBP No. 93-671-01-OLA-3 GEORGIA POWER COMPANY'S MOTION TO CORRECT THE RECORD OF EXHIBITS OF THE DIESEL GENERATOR REPORTING ISSUES ALLEGATION HEARING Pursuant to 10 CFR Q 2.750(b), Georgia Power Company hereby moves the Licensing Board to order that the corrections indicated on Attachment " A" hereto be made to the tmnscript of the hearing on the Diesel Generator Reporting Issues allegation which took place April 7 through October 11,1995 with respect to exhibits listed by the court reporter.

Georgia Power has previously communicated this information to Intervenor and the NRC Staff (several of the corrections on the list were provided earlier today). With the exception of the correction concerning Intervenor Exhibit 11-247, which Georgia Power added to the attached list today, the NRC Staff is in agreement with the attached list. Intervenor has not responded.

9512140094 951212 PDR ADOCK0500g4 i

p ,3 i

Respectfully submitted, pfun>f wk ohn Lamberski James E. Joiner TROUTMAN SANDERS LLP Suite 5200 600 Peachtree Street Atlanta, GA 30308-2216 (404) 885-3360 Ernest L. Blake David R. lewis SHAW, PITTMAN, POTTS & TROWBRIDGE  !

2300 N Street, N.W.

Washington, D.C. 20037 (202) 663-8084 Counsel for Georgia Power Company Dated: December 12, 1995 T

~-

. . _ ._.. ._ _ _m. .. _._ _ ._. __ _. _ , .

Attachment "A" Date/ Party / Change From or Delete Change To or Add Attachment Exhibit Number / Exhibit Number, Exhibit Number, Transcript Page Description, Description, IDENT, or REC'D IDENT, or REC'D 05/17/95 GPC Change Exhibit Numbers Change Exhibit Numtm to:

Attachment 1 Exhs.II-27-II-42 "GPC 11-27" & "GPC 11-42 " "GPC 11-27 through 11-42" Tr.4624 05/17/95 GPC Change Decription: Change Decription to: .

Attachment 1 Exhs.II-27-II-42 " Corrections to Aufdenkampe "Aufdenkampe Exhibits A Tr.4624 Tatimony " through P" 05/17/95 Intervenor Delete Intervenor Exhibit 94 Attachment 1 Exhibit 11-94 from the Exhibit List page at Tr.4624 Tr. 4624. This was also bound h at Tr. 4844 in error. Int. II-94, II-94A & 11-94B were admitted on October 6,1995 at Tr.15492. Also the exhibit is Tape Transcript 32, not 269 06/01/95 Interrenor Change

Description:

Change Descripti<m to: "GPC Attachment 2 Exh.11-35 " Interrogatory Questions" Dew Point Data MWO List" Tr.6390 06/01/95 Intervenor Change

Description:

Change Decription to:

Attachment 2 Exh.11-36 "and responses" "Interrenor's Seventh Tr.6390 Request for interrogatories (7-25-94) & GPC's Response (8-8-94)"

06/0195 Interrenor Delete: IDENT - Tr. 6572 -

Attachment 2 Exh.11-35 & Exhibits 35 and 36 were not 11-3 6 identified at Tr. 6572 Tr.6390 07/20/95 Staff Change date in the description: Change date in description to

- Attachment 3 Exh.11-5 "06-20-90" cn %e u "06-20-94"

.- Tr.10119 ""*""'r"*'*'""

07/14/95 GPC Change Description from: "OI Change Description to:

Attachment 4 Exh.11114 Interview of Moshaugh Pages " DOL Trial Testimony, Tr.9395 158 162" Moshaugh v. GPC, March 10,1992, Pages I, 158-162" 04/19/95 All Exhibits No Party Identification for any Add GPC to Exhibits 1120 &

Attachment 5 Tr.3299 exhibits appear 11-2 1; Add Intervenor to all other exhibits on the exhibit list.

4/19/95 GPC Exhibits Change "Bockhold Testimony" Bockhold A and B Attachment 5 II 20 & 11-21 4/19/95 Interrenor Change " Fax" Change to " Transcript Tape j Attachment 5 Exhibit II-76A 246"

Datel Party / Change From or Delete Change To or Add ,

i Attachment Exhibit Number / Exhibit Nanber, Exhibit Number,  !

Transcript Page Description, Description, l

IDENT, or REC'D IDENT, or REC'D l

' i 04/19/95 Interrenor Change Description from: Cha.we Description to:

Attachment 5 Exhibit 11-19 " Tape Transcript" " Transcript Tape 25" l

Tr.3299 04/19/95 Intervenor Change Dacription from: "(")" Change Description to: " l Attach-ant 5 Exhibit II 110A Transcript Tape 34" l Tr.3299 i

Intervenor Change Decription from: "04- Change Description to:

( 04/19/95 "04-09-90 COA Response Attachment 5 Exhibit 11-24 90 Letter" Tr.3299 Letter, Final" l 04/19/95 Interrenor Change Description from: Change Description to:

Attachment 5 Exhibit 11-95 " Project Paper" " August 1990 White Paper" l Tr.3299 l l 04/19/95 Intervenor Add to Description l Attachment 5 Exh.11-18 " Handwritten List of As l l should be added Found Set Points on Calcon 1 Tr.3299 JWTS Senson; IDENT at l '

Tr. 3472, It was not REC'D.

l

! 04/19/95 Intervenor Add to

Description:

" Outage 1 Attachment 5 Exh.11-123 Log,92 Project 30467 30538" l

Tr.3299 04/19/95 Intervenor Change from " Letter: August Change to "GPC Letter:

Auachment 5 Exh. II-67 30 August 30,1990" and add 1 exhibit as IDENT at Tr. l 3478.

08/22/95 Intervenor Add to

Description:

"I&C l Attachment G Exh.11-217 Log, Project Nos. 010821 27" l should he added and IDENT at 12170 i

~

Tr.12042 l l

j 08/15/95 Intervenor Add to

Description:

j Attachment 7 Exh.1179 " Deficiency Cards, Project Tr.11249 Nos. 65000-04, 65936-37,and l

! 65953"and also add IDENT at 11521 and REC'D at l 11522 l

l 07/12/95 GPC Change from IDENT - 9125 Change to IDENT - 9073, I l

I Attachment 8 Exhibit 11-106 also Add to Description to Tr.9004 read: " Draft LER I 90-6

- 4/17/90 (8 pages)"

i

2,=

Date/ Party / Change From or Delete Change To or Add Attachment Exhibit Nunber/ Exhibit Nwnber, Exhibit Nwnher, Transcript Page Description, Description, IDENT, or REC'D IDENT, or REC'D 07/12/95 GPC Change from IDENT - 9127 Ca.'unge to IDENT - 9125 Attachment 8 Exhibit 11107 Tr.9004 06-02-95 Interrenor Change description from: Change description to:

.'ftachment 9 Exhibit 11-145 "GPC II-51" " Modified Notice of Tr.6714 Violation,2/15/95 (Stali II-(Exhibit Index) 51)"

09-15-95 Intervenor Delete from REC'D Colwnn.

Attachment 10 Exhibit 11-247 h ~ " m i= Tr " a * = w **

Tr.14061 7 97Y """

08-17-95 Tr. Page 11884 Change Date from August 9, Change Date to August 17, (In-Camera 1995 1995 Session Attachment 11 T

4624

• 1 INDEX (cont.)

2 WITNESS DIRECT CROSS REDIRECT RECROSS BOARD 3 4820 4 4829 5 4835 6 4841 1

7 4843 8 4851 9 4853 -

10 4855 11 EXHIBITS 12 Fvhibit No. Descriotion IDENT REC'D f Ezh; bHs A - P  !

13 GPCII 44 t-rratie... i.v Aufdenkampe4 4656 4657 14 C"CII-42 T= tiacr.y 4656- ano s -

l 15 Intervenor 69 Excerpt from Transcript of) 4844 4845 16 pe 269 4844 4845 fntarvannr 17 / Intervenor stipulations 4738

18 19 0 f

20 21 22 23 ,

l 24 25 Attachment 1 l

6390 1 INDEX 2 WITNESSES: DIRECT CROSS REDIRECT RECROSS 3 George Bockhold 4 By Mr. Blake 6393 -- -- --

5 By Mr. Michael Kohn --

6434 -- --

6 By Mr. Barth --

6641 -- --

7 By Mr. Michael Kohn --

6693 -- --

8 By Mr. Barth -- 6705 -- --

9 By Mr. Michael Kohn -- 6709 -- --

10 EXHIBITS i

11 LXHIBIT NO. DESCRIPTION IDENT REC'D f l

12 GPC II-49/ Bockhold Exhibits 6402 6402 I 13 GPC II-57 C through K 14 GPC II-61 Ward Exhibit C 6602 --

15 GPC II-76/ Bockhold Exhibits 16 GPC II-80 L through P 6412 6413 ,

1 17 GPC II-81/ Bockhold Exhibits

~

18 GPC II-85 A through E to Affidavit 6418 6419

& p t 3 us feinb b k M hle LIKl~ 6572 .

19 Int. II-35/ jIniertogarDry-q"estiene n,*5

(

't-s f Or ._,Omq

~

ywor',s $nde n k R L 20 Int. II-36 and-sce c.: c ((g*, 6572 1

21 Int. II-141 Deficiency Card 1-89-1317 6442 6454 22 Int. II-142 Deficiency Card 1-90-004 6442 6454 23 Int. II-143 MWO 19001651 6523 --

24 Board II-1 Calcon Sensor Brochure 6489 --

Attachment 2

10119 1- EXHIBITS

.2 EXHIBIT NO. DESCRIPTION IDENT REC'D 3 GPC II-120 Transcript of Tape 72 9693 10192 4 GPC II-121 Transcript Cover Page 9726 10192 5 GPC II-122 " Agreed" Transcript 9739' 10192 6 GPC II-123 Travel Record. 9744 10192 7 GPC II-125 Intervenor Exhibit 95 8 White Papers 9830 10192 9 GPC II-126 Excerpt from Mosbaugh OI 10' Interview: July 17th and 11 18th, 1990; p 226 9867 10192 12 GPC II-128 Mosbaugh OI Interview Exhibits 9888 10192 13 GPC II-130 3/11/92, Trans. Mosbaugh 9909 10192 14 GPC II-131 5/14/93, Pleading 9912 10192 15 GPC II-132 NRC Meeting Notes 9915 10192 16 GPC II-133 Transcript, Tape 69 9939 10192 17 GPC II-134 Excerpt of Exhibit 3 10004 10192 3B GPC II-135 Vol 3, Mosbaugh Deposition 10017 10192 19 Staff II-2 Excerpt from 1.9 of FSAR 20 Page 65 and 66 10201 10209 21 Staff II-3 Regulatory Guide 1.68.3 10202 10209 22 Staff II-4 Georgia Power Procedure #

23 11882-1 Rev. 15 10213 10310 Y

24 Staff II-5 06-20-9p Memo from Charles 25 Casto 10267 i

Attachment 3

9395 1 EXHIBITS 2 EXHIBIT NO. DESCRIPTION IDENT $ REC'D j 3 GPC II-113 Mosbaugh Training Record 9397 l

D &L Tn'nl h s fi n o nsj, ojos basgh t klC, MA!'b Us 4 GPC II-114 4 CI Ir.te. view vi husuo-3a _

5 ages /158-162 9440 6 GPC II-115 Mr. Tate's Notes 9446 7 GPC II-116 Trascript: Tape 172 p7-8 9537 8 9560 9 GPC II-117 Transcript: Tape 79 p14-16 9548 10 9560 11 GPC II-118 Technical Specifications 3812 9563 12 13 14 15 16 17 T 18

.o 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Attachment 4

3299 1 INDEX (CONT.)

2 WITNESS DIRECT CROSS REDIRECT BOARD 3 George Bockhold 3461 3517 i

4 3465 3522 5 3467 6 3474 7 3480 8 3497 ,

1 9 3505 10 EXHIBITS 11 Fvhibit No. Descriotion Ident Rec'd Erh;hll5 A*)

12 II-20 and II-21 Bockhold Testi;=y 3311 3311 13 II-76A Eax b ye U. 2 M 3315 3318 l

14 II-19 Tape [TranscriptA6 3326 5 II-110A "

J/ 3327 den despaase 16 II-24 04-094 Letter, Floa f 3352 I

0 4m.5 f I99b Lahlh 3370 17 3 95 f rscj w t Paper 18 % 89 Safety System Data 3383 195-90 Tape 27 Transcript 3384 20 II-57 Interogatory Response 3425 3427

[Y 21 II-25 t _

3444 3446  !

SIV Tape 40 Transcrgp$ NY G"'5f!*"

hfYo'.n$2 e 94l'$1u .

22 II-123 ggq c (, r,,je er 3472 36 44 y Jo&27 23 II-81 Outage Turn Over Log 3476 24 II-67 et er: August 30,/990 U 2 II-13 Bockhold OI Testimony 3495 Attachment 5

12042 1 INDEX 2 WITNESSES: DIRECT CROSS REDIRECT RECROSS 3 Mark Briney 4 By Mr. Blake 12074 -- -- --

5 By Mr. M. Kohn -- 12098 -- --

6 7 I 8 EXHIBITS 9 EXHIBIT NO. DESCRIPTION IDENT REC'D 10 GPC:

11 II-153 Briney Exhibit A 12077 12077 l l

12 II-154 Briney Exhibit B 12077 12077 i

13 II-155 Briney Exhibit C 12077 12077 )

l l l '

l 14 II-156 Briney Exhibit D 12077 12077 l 15 II-157 Briney Exhibit E 12077 12077 l

l 16 II-158 Briney Exhibit F 12077 12077 17 II-159 Briney Exhibit G 12077 12077 18 Intervenor:

4

, 7 19 II-213A Corrected Demonstrative Aid 14 12043 --

20 II-215 Certificate of Traceability of )

21 Alnor VP-2466 12046 --

1 22 II-216 5/11/90 R. Johnston memo 12100 --

5atf r*C 63 , A* jut 14s. f or 2/-2 <7 ,7 ,

i Attachment 6 l

. I 11249 1 INDEX 2 WITNESSES: DIRECT CROSS REDIRECT RECROSS 3 William Shipman (resumed) i 4 By Mr. Barth --

11251 --

11332 ,

5 By Mr. M. Kohn --

11315 --

11335 6 By Mr. Blake -- --

11328 --

7 Harvey Handfinger 8 By Mr. Blake 11344 -- -- --

9 By Mr. M. Kohn --

11350 -- --

10 By Ms. Young --

11446 -- --

11 By Mr. M. Kohn --

11482 -- --

l 12 By Ms. Young --

11499 -- --

13 By Mr. M. Kohn --

11501 -- --

14 i

15 EXHI BITS 16 EXHIBIT NO. DESCRIPTION IDENT REC'D 17 GPC:

18 II-149 Handfinger Exhibit A 11347 11347 19 II-150(a)-(e) Handfinger B (MWOs) 11349 11349 l l

20 Intervenor:

21 II ___ j)g&timuj bds, bvejf t f dos. 65e60 ofi l 51 % -37 % 515s ti n t it sn.

22 II-213 Demonstrative Aid 11378 --

23 II-214 7/31/90 Letter ESG to Bockhold 11388 11389 Attachment 7 l

9004 1 EXHIBITS 2 EXHIBIT NO. DESCRIPTION IDENT REC'D 3 Intervenor II-167 Hairston notes 9013 4 INTERVENOR II-67 WITHDRAWN ON PAGE 9017 5 GPC II-105 GPC working schedple 9019 y ( t. 4-ll'Iflo 9 c '/3 6 GPC II-106 JLER 1-90-6" (8 pages) Sa@1F 9/ A S 7 GPC II-107 4/30 memo from Bockhold 3129' 9127 8 GPC II-108 4/11/90 pgs from tape 42 9129 9 GPC II-109 5/2/90 pgs from tape 90 9139 10 GPC II-110 '92 proj. 057506-057511 9144 11 GPC II-111 Handwritten memo 5/9/90 9147 12 GPC II-112A 7/23 Motion to Compel 9174 13 GPC II-112B 7/30 Letter, Mosbaugh 9174 I

I

=

Attachment 8

6714 1 INDEX 2 WITNESSES: DIRECT CROSS REDIRECT RECFQS1 3 Thomas Victor Greene, Jr.

4 By Mr. Blake 6715 -- -- --

5 By Mr. Stephen Kohn -- 6732 -- --

6 By Ms. Young --

6857 -- --

7 EXHIBITS 8 EXHIBIT NO. DESCRIPTION IDENT REC'D 9 GPC II-43 Greene Ex. A (Qualifications) 6717 6717 10 GPC II-44 Greene Ex. B (Tape 187 Trscpt) 6717 6717

'c e of V.'e Ir$'d A 11 Int. II-145 yo j;(\ed AO"O flef,Sk@

II 51 ( I~ 6h ,2-llS/9S 6832 6838 12 Staff II-18 Staff Version of Greene B 6884 6949 13 T

'. i I

Attachment 9

. . _ . _ _ m _ _ _ . _ . . _ ._ . _ . . . _ . _ _.. _ _ _ _ _ . - . . __ _ . . _ _ . -- _ . _ _ _ _ _ . -

14061 EXHIBITS t

! EXHIBIT NO. DESCRIPTION IDENT REC'D

^

Int-II-230 GPC's 3rd response to 3rd

• 14062 I interrogatories 4

Int-II-242 Mr. Domby's notes

• 14062

Int-II-243 GPC's 4th response to 3rd interrogatories * '14062 Int-II-244 One page from NWO 19502428

• 14062 Int-II-231 Summary Report, 02-15-90

• 14190 Int-II-245 1-pg ltr 3-16-90 from GPC 14081 14190 Int-II-246 Tape 101 Side A 14171 14190 05-08-90 Int-II-247 Excerpt of Tape 99 Side B 14180 141;G 3"

05-08-90 Int-II-248 Memo to Mr. Lyons 05-08-90 14184 14190 Int-II-249 Interview of George Frederick 06-27-90 14184 14190 Int-II-250 Interview of Mike Horton 06-26-90 14185 14190 Int-II-251 Interview of J. Aufdenkampe 07-13-90 14185 14190 Int-II-252 Audit Finding Report 14186 14190 Int-II-253 Interview notes with Skip 1 Kitchens 06-26-90 14190 14190  !

Int-II-254 Procedure 00002-C 14192 14190 GPC-II-191 Review of Mr. Mosbaugh by Mr. Bockhold 14206 14207 GPC-II-192 Memo: LeGrand to Bockhold 06-21-90 14207 14211  ;

GPC-II-193 90V0015 by W.C. Lyon 08-21-90 14208 14211 GPC-II-194 Chilling Effects / Intimidation t of PRB Members 14209 14211 Int-II-89 (Previously Identified) 14211 Int-II-255 One page by Mr. Lyons 14217 14228 Int-II-256 Quality Concerns File 14218 14228 l'

• Previously marked for identification.

l l

l i

Attachment 10

.. . . - . . - _.- _ . - . . . . - . . - . _ - . . - ~ . . - . . - ~ . - . . . ~ . . . - _ . . . . - . , - ~ . . . - _ -

IN-CAMERA SESSION 11884 1 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 2 NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION l 3 +++++

4 ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD 5 HEARING l 6 -------------------------------X <

l l

50-424-OLA-3  !

7 In the matter of:  !

8- GEORGIA POWER COMPANY,.31 A.l.a.  : 50-425-OLA-3  ;

i 9  : Re: License Amendment i

i 10 (Vogtle Electric Generating  : (transfer to ,

11 Plant, Unit 1 and Unit 2)  : Southern Nuclear) ,

12  : ASLBP No.  ;

i 13 -------------------------------X 93-671-01-OLA-3 If ,

14 Wednesday, August ff, 1995  !

15 Plantation Room West l

16 Telfair Inn  !

17 326 Greene Street 18 Augusta, Georgia l 19 The above-entitled matter came on for in-camera 0

20 sessi'1n at approximately 1:17 p.m.

?

21 BEFORE:

22 PETER B. BLOCH Chairman 23 JAMES H. CARPENTER Administrative Judge 24 THOMAS D. MURPHY Administrative Judge 25 At*=cht 11

DOCKETED i USNRC UNITED STATES OF AMERICA

% DEC 13 P2 :47 NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION OFFICE OF SECRETARY Before the Atomic Safety and Licensine Board DOCKETING 1 SERVICE  :

BRANCH ,

i In the Matter of )

) Docket Nos. 50-424-OLA-3 GEORGIA POWER COMPANY, )

etal. ) Re: License Amendment

) (Transfer to Southern (Vogtle Electric Generating ) Nuclear)

Plant, Units 1 and 2) )

) ASLBP No. 93-671-01-OLA-3 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE This is to certify that copies of the within and foregoing " Georgia Power Company's Motion to Correct the Record of the Exhibits of the Diesel Generator Reporting Issues Allegation Hearing" were served on all those listed on the attached service list by express mail delivery. This the 12th day of December,1995.

T

.o l

John Lamberski TROUTMAN SANDERS LLP Suite 5200 600 Peachtree Street l

Atlanta, GA 30308-2216 (404) 885-3360 l

l

- _ . - - - . .- ._ - . . . - - - - . .- .. .- _ ~ . - - - --.-.- ~

i f

t

! UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION

! BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD 2

In the Matter of GEORGIA POWER COMPANY,

• Docket Nos. 50-424-OLA-3 -

21 A1 50-425-OLA-3 (Vogtle Electric

• Re: License Amendment Generating Plant, * (Transfer to Southern l Units 1 and 2)-

• Nuclear) l'

• ASLBP No. 93-671-01-OLA-3 i

SERVICE LIST Administrative Judge Stewart D. Ebneter Peter B. Bloch, Chairman Regional Administrator Atomic Safety and Licensing USNRC, Region II i Board 101 Marietta Street, NW l U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Suite 2900 Commission Atlanta, Georgia 30303 Two White Flint North I 11545 Rockville Pike Office of the Secretary Rockville, MD 20852 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Administrative Judge Washington, D. C. 20555 1 James H. Carpenter ATTN: Docketing and Atomic Safety and Licensing Services Branch Board 933 Green Point Drive Charles Barth, Esq.

5 Oyster Point Mitzi Young, Esq.

1 Sunset Beach, NC 28468 Office of General Counsel One White Flint North Administrative Judge Stop 15B18 j 1

Thomas D. Murphy U.S. Nuclear Regulatory

,' Atomic Safety and Licensing Commission

,. T Board Washington, D. C. 20555 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Director, Two White Flint North Environmental Protection 11545 Rockville Pike Division

! Rockville, MD 20852 Department of Natural Resources  !

Michael D. Kohn, Esq. 205 Butler Street, S.E.

. Kohn, Kohn & Colapinto, P.C. Suite 1252 i 517 Florida Avenue, N.W. Atlanta, Georgia 30334 Washington, D.C. 20001 Office of Commission Appellate Adjudication One White Flint North

, 11555 Rockville Pike

Rockville, MD 20852

_ _ _