ML17354A242: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
 
(One intermediate revision by the same user not shown)
Line 17: Line 17:


=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:REGULATORY FORMATION,DI'STRIBUTION
{{#Wiki_filter:REGULATORY         FORMATION,DI'STRIBUTION 'SY       M ('RIDS)
'SY M ('RIDS)DOCKET¹05000250 05000251 NOTES;AOCBSSXeN NBR:83021804S3 DOC.DATE>83/02/11 NOTARIZED>
AOCBSSXeN NBR:83021804S3                   DOC.DATE> 83/02/11       NOTARIZED> NO                        DOCKET  ¹
NO.FAGIL 50 250<<Tur key Point<<Planti'Unit 3i Florida lpower-and Light C.",50 251"Tur key Point~Pl anti ,'Unit 4i Flor ida lPower and Light C'AUTH'AME AUTHOR Al'-F IL I ATION'UHRIGiR~Ee Flor,ida Power 8'Light Co,<<REC IP~NAME REC IP IENT AFF IL'I ATION VARGApS~AD Operating Reactors Branch 1 SUBJEOTs.Forwards addi info on Guideline 4i,"Special Lifting Devices." Guide)ine 7g,"Crane Designi." per;draft Itechnical evaluation rept" on control of heavy loads at facili.tiese.DI'STRIBUTION i'CODE!A033S<<COPIES''RECEIVED jLTiR~.ENCL, SIZE t.TITLE: OR Submittalj USI A 36,Control of,Heavy:Load Near Spent Fuel'ECIPIENT IO CODE/NAME, NRR ORB1>BC INTERNAL!NRR REQUAgG 09 NRR/DS I/AEB RGN2~COPIES I'T<<TR ENCL 7<<7 1 1 1 1~1 RECIPIENT ID CODE/NAME NRR'CLEMENSON01 NRR J./DRAB 1'2 G 04:COPIES LTTR ENCL 1 1 1 1 ,EXTiERNAL
    .FAGIL 50 250 <<Tur key Point           <<Planti 'Unit 3i Florida lpower -and Light                       C 05000250
~ACRS NRC iPDR NTI'S 13<<,02 6 6 1 1 L'PDR NSIC 03 06 1 1 1)TOTAL NUMBER OF'COPIES REQUIRED: L<<TTR 26 ENCL 26 T3PlQAQ 9(4;<TJKLAATQV Lf'~'j9'ig8;3TA:".'
            .",50   251 "Tur key Point ~Pl anti ,'Unit 4i Flor ida lPower and Light                         C 05000251
3<)'.T..R<'.A(ll'-:
      'AUTH'AME                                   I AUTHOR Al'- F IL ATION
<@.",>250092v 0 fnFt I'J HnG 1~lHQR 64 f1O f'9 ih 0 fn 4.>f~a f'~;tnre'il y'.l~s<<'t"c,'~--''.jE3~~l2SQGGVG 0 fnpf J bns lC)HO I 59k'l9 f'llew 4 l"AV pan,b f'0;f6 f 9'ii g5~1<T Fc~~~"~G VIdlTAIJIRIA H<>><gU~>4A.<,~)Td-'e 0',)fgpjJI 8 1gMo I sbfqofl L1'.)X1'AI JIQRA 1 tT,~l<<I:l3HI dl4A V.~~ltd>" Hon5'lO ltqetfoaoA L'In[tawoqgl
    'UHRIGiR ~ Ee             Flor,ida   Power 8 'Light Co,
,,A,,Qq,*, dg>>~+aOOFVO<f pnf'ft I)J fat'ae~<G+
      <<REC IP ~ NAME           REC IP IENT AFF IL'IATION VARGApS ~ AD                 Operating Reactors Branch           1 SUBJEOTs       .Forwards addi     info on Guideline 4i,"Special Lifting Devices."
>IN Onl'Ob)VG nO Otnl'tiibS
Guide)ine 7g,"Crane Designi." per;draft Itechnical evaluation rept" on control of heavy loads at facili.tiese
~b1OX'>9'1
    .DI'STRIBUTION i'CODE! A033S           <<COPIES ''RECEIVED jLTiR ~
<lT<I>4 a"<fooh~loe4'tvab aoq"~int'tteoG ohio'>0" i'd%onlfoe'FuQ 8 ,cotfl ff,os'F h>s abaef yvoon 5'o fastness oa fqozi neieevfsve
                                                                      . ENCL,     SIZE t
.:BRING..JQ~f3, RTJSq3V)(d."i3AI a31<<9>g<,K&A:3Qa3
    .TITLE: OR Submittalj USI             A   36,Control of,Heavy:Load Near Spent NOTES;                                                                                  Fuel'ECIPIENT
<1uiTl>d>;,ll'-.-'l,l fovR fnoqG Zoo<i 6aiJ vvsoH'tg frl0$na0 eK~A Lc,".9;fs9tjiduV No ,"i III I I 88I IOQ JQl)d NTTJ 5'AAQX JAXA~4;~AQ@JI~83?89,>Jglf13 AfTJ V T<$3llX 93~I'.-'[<>A>$
                                          ~COPIES            RECIPIENT              :COPIES IO CODE/NAME,         I'T<<TR ENCL     ID CODE/NAME          LTTR ENCL NRR ORB1>BC                  7   <<7   NRR 'CLEMENSON01 INTERNAL!        NRR REQUAgG      09          1          NRR    J./DRAB     1'2     1                  1 NRR/DS I/AEB                1    1      G               04       1                 1 RGN2                        1   ~ 1
%3493 v T QI9 f QA0 HAH Ht3 IJ Ql@>fl;GHQA;JA S::~dr JR~'I G l'F~1
,EXTiERNAL~ ACRS                   13<<         6     6   L'PDR               03       1                  1 NRC iPDR        ,02          1     1   NSIC                06                          1 NTI'S
.BOX 14000, JUNO BEACH, F L 3340B FLORIDA POWER&LIGHT COMPANY February ll, 1983 L-83-71 Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation Attention:
  )TOTAL NUMBER OF 'COPIES           REQUIRED: L<<TTR       26   ENCL       26
Mr.Steven A.Varga, Chief Operating Reactors Branch gl Division of Licensing U.S.Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C.20555


==Dear Mr.Varga:==
T3PlQAQ            9(4;<TJKLAATQV        Lf'~'j9'ig8;3TA:".' 3<)'.T          .. R<'.A(ll'-: <@.",>
Re: Turkey Point Units 3 8 4 Docket Nos.50-250&50-251 Draft Technical Evaluation Re ort In our letter (L-82-346) dated August 10, 1982, we provided additional information on the items in the Draft Technical.
250092v    0 fnFt I'J HnG 1~lHQR      64 f1O f'9 ih 0 fn 4 f~a f'~;tnre'il y'.l ~s<<'t "c,'~--' '. jE3~~
Evaluation Report on Control of Heavy Loads at Turkey Point Units 3 8 4.The purpose of this letter is to provide additional information on Guideline 4 (Special Lifting Devices)and Guideline 7 (Crane Design).Our evaluation of FPL designed lifting devices is attached.The Westinghouse designed lifting devices have been evaluated by Westinghouse and we have received a preliminary copy of their report.We are still in the process of reviewing the detailed recommendations contained in the report.We expect to ccmplete our review and provide the evaluations by March 15, 1983.For Guideline 7 we have received schedules from the crane manufacturers for evaluations of the crane designs.We expect to be able to submit these evaluations by August 15, 1983.Should you or your staff have any questions on this information, please contact us;Rober E.Uhrig Vice President Advanced Systems 8 Technology REU/PKG/js Attachment 8302i80483 8302ii PDR ADOCK 05000250 P PDR cc: J.P.O'Reil ly, Regi on I I Harold F.Reis, Esquire.PNS-'LI-83-099-1 PEOPLE...SERVING PEOPLE l' REACT(K EVALU TURKEY POINT UNITS 3 Kc 4 ELD SLINGS INES A special lifting-rig consisting of six (6)wire rope slings is used at Turkey Points 3 and 4 for handling of the reactor and pressurizer missile shields and the reactor coolant pump hatch covers i.n the con~tainment.The lifting rig consists of two parts, each composed of three (3)slings and a 2 1/8" diameter choker.Although these slings are dedicated to handling these loads, the slings are standard"off-.the-.shelf" i.tems with no special design.Therefore NUREG 0612 General Guideline (5)"Lifting Devices that are not Specially Designed" is considered the applicable evaluation criteria.The following is a summary of pertinent sling, load and crane proper~ties: CONSTRUCTION 1 I/4" DIAMETER 6 X 36 IWRC WIRE ROPE I ULTIMATE STRENGTH (MIN)REACTOR MISSILE SHIELD WT PRESSURIZER MISSILE SHIELD WT CRANE MAIN HOOK (MIN SPEED AT RATED LOAD)120',000//
l2SQGGVG    0 fnpf J bns lC)HO I        59k'l9 f 'llew 4 l"AV pan,b f'0;f6 f 9'ii g5~1< T Fc~~~ "~G VIdlTAIJIRIA H<>><gU~                          > 4A.<, ~)Td-'
97,'000//51,300//5 fpm sume er Table 3-Per Sling In order to account for the NUREG 0612 Section 5.1.1(5)dynamic load factor, it will be conservati.vely assumed that the maximum lifting speed during missile shield handling is 20 fpm.Using the factors in CMAA//70 for dynamic contribution, this constitutes a 10/increase in load (i.e., 1/2 X per 1 fpm.Thus, the following safety factors are calculated:
e 0',)  fgpjJI    8 1gMo I    sbfqofl L1'.)X1'AIJIQRA    1 tT,~l<<I:l3HI                dl4A V. ~ ~ltd>"
:F.S.(Reactor Mi.ssile Shield)=5.2 F.S.(Pressuri.zer.
Hon5'lO ltqetfoaoA L'In[tawoqgl                                ,,A,,Qq,*, dg>> ~
Missile Shield=7.7 (40'ngle from vertical, 6 sli.'ngs)(25 Angle from vertical, 4 slings)Note that NUREG 0612 Guideline 5 requires a minimum factor of safety of 5.0.The above factors of safety are calculated by dividing the sling ulti~mate strength by the adjusted actual load weight.The load i.s adjus>ted to account for the sling angle from the verti.cal and the prevt.ous-ly mentioned dynamic contribution.
        +aOOFVO<f pnf      'ft J fat'ae~<G+
The slings are assumed to be constructed of Improved Plow Steel and the working load values are obtained from ANSI B30.9.There is, how>ever, no documentation available to verify what the actual sling mate>ri.al is or that it conforms to this ANSI standard.
I)                >IN  Onl' Ob)VG nO        Otnl'tiibS          ~b1OX'>9'1      <lT<I>4 a "<
IQ'I~4>>e}}
fooh~loe4'tvab          aoq "~int'tteoG ohio'>0" i'd% onl foe'FuQ 8
              ,cotfl ff,os'F      h>s abaef    yvoon 5'o fastness oa fqozi neieevfsve
:BRING      .. JQ~f3 fovR fnoqG Zoo<i 6aiJ
                                        ,vvsoH RTJSq3V)(d."i3AI a31<<9>
                                                      'tg frl0$ na0 eK~A g<,K&A:3Qa3 <1uiTl>d>;,ll'-.-'l,l Lc,".9;fs9tjiduV                  ,"i III I I No 88I  IOQ                                            83? 89,>              T<$  3llX93~I JQl)d NTTJ                                        Jglf13  AfTJ          '.-'[<>A>$ %3493 v T V                          QI9  f QA0  HAH 5'AAQXJAXA~4;~
AQ      @JI~
Ht3  IJ                                                GHQA; JA        S::~dr Ql@>                                                      JR~'I f      l;                            G l'F~1
 
                                                                      . BOX 14000, JUNO BEACH, F L 3340B FLORIDA POWER & LIGHT COMPANY February L-83-71 ll, 1983 Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation Attention: Mr. Steven A. Varga, Chief Operating Reactors Branch gl Division of Licensing U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D. C. 20555
 
==Dear Mr. Varga:==
 
Re: Turkey   Point Units   3 8 4 Docket Nos. 50-250 & 50-251 Draft Technical Evaluation Re     ort In our letter   (L-82-346) dated August 10, 1982, we provided additional information on the items in the Draft Technical. Evaluation Report on Control of Heavy Loads at Turkey Point Units 3 8 4.
The purpose   of this letter is to provide additional information on Guideline                 4 (Special   Lifting Devices) and   Guideline 7 (Crane Design).
Our evaluation of   FPL designed lifting devices is attached.             The Westinghouse designed lifting devices have     been evaluated   by Westinghouse     and   we have received a preliminary copy of their report.           We are   still   in the   process of reviewing the detailed recommendations contained           in the report.     We   expect to ccmplete our review and provide the evaluations by March 15, 1983.
For Guideline   7 we have received schedules     from the crane manufacturers for evaluations of the crane designs. We expect to be able to submit these evaluations by August 15, 1983.
Should you or your     staff have any questions   on   this information,       please contact us; Rober E. Uhrig Vice President Advanced Systems   8 Technology REU/PKG/js             8302i80483 8302ii Attachment PDR ADOCK   05000250 P                   PDR cc: J. P. O'Reil ly, Regi on I I Harold F. Reis, Esquire
    .PNS-'LI-83-099-1 PEOPLE... SERVING PEOPLE l'
 
TURKEY POINT UNITS 3 Kc 4 REACT(K                                ELD SLINGS EVALU                                                        INES A special lifting -rig consisting of six (6) wire rope slings is used at Turkey Points 3 and 4 for handling of the reactor and pressurizer missile shields and the reactor coolant pump hatch covers i.n the con~
tainment. The lifting rig consists of two parts, each composed of three (3) slings and a 2 1/8" diameter choker. Although these slings are dedicated to handling these loads, the slings are standard "off-.
the-.shelf" i.tems with no special design. Therefore NUREG 0612 General Guideline (5) "Lifting Devices that are not Specially Designed" is considered the applicable evaluation criteria.
The following is a summary of pertinent sling, load and crane proper~
ties:
CONSTRUCTION                 1 I/4" DIAMETER     6 X 36 IWRC WIRE ROPE I                                         sume er ULTIMATE STRENGTH (MIN)             120',000//  Table    3    Per Sling REACTOR MISSILE SHIELD WT             97,'000//
PRESSURIZER MISSILE SHIELD WT         51,300//
CRANE MAIN HOOK (MIN SPEED AT RATED LOAD)           5 fpm In order to account for the NUREG 0612 Section 5.1.1(5) dynamic load factor, it will be conservati.vely assumed that the maximum lifting speed during missile shield handling is 20 fpm. Using the factors in CMAA //70 for dynamic contribution, this constitutes a 10/ increase in load (i.e., 1/2 X per 1 fpm. Thus, the following safety factors are calculated:
:F.S. (Reactor Mi.ssile Shield)     = 5.2         (40'ngle from vertical, 6 sli.'ngs)
F.S. (Pressuri.zer. Missile Shield = 7.7           (25 Angle from vertical, 4 slings)
Note that NUREG 0612 Guideline 5 requires a minimum factor of safety of 5.0.
The above factors of safety are calculated by dividing the sling ulti~
mate strength by the adjusted actual load weight. The load i.s adjus>
ted to account for the sling angle from the verti.cal and the prevt.ous-ly mentioned dynamic contribution.
The slings are assumed to be constructed of Improved Plow Steel and the working load values are obtained from ANSI B30.9. There is, how>
ever, no documentation available to verify what the actual sling mate>
ri.al is or that it conforms to this ANSI standard.
 
  'I 4>>   ~
IQ e}}

Latest revision as of 22:18, 3 February 2020

Forwards Addl Info on Guideline 4, Special Lifting Devices & Guideline 7, Crane Design, Per Draft Technical Evaluation Rept on Control of Heavy Loads at Facilities
ML17354A242
Person / Time
Site: Turkey Point  NextEra Energy icon.png
Issue date: 02/11/1983
From: Robert E. Uhrig
FLORIDA POWER & LIGHT CO.
To: Varga S
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
REF-GTECI-A-36, REF-GTECI-SF, RTR-NUREG-0612, RTR-NUREG-612, TASK-A-36, TASK-OR L-83-71, NUDOCS 8302180483
Download: ML17354A242 (5)


Text

REGULATORY FORMATION,DI'STRIBUTION 'SY M ('RIDS)

AOCBSSXeN NBR:83021804S3 DOC.DATE> 83/02/11 NOTARIZED> NO DOCKET ¹

.FAGIL 50 250 <<Tur key Point <<Planti 'Unit 3i Florida lpower -and Light C 05000250

.",50 251 "Tur key Point ~Pl anti ,'Unit 4i Flor ida lPower and Light C 05000251

'AUTH'AME I AUTHOR Al'- F IL ATION

'UHRIGiR ~ Ee Flor,ida Power 8 'Light Co,

<<REC IP ~ NAME REC IP IENT AFF IL'IATION VARGApS ~ AD Operating Reactors Branch 1 SUBJEOTs .Forwards addi info on Guideline 4i,"Special Lifting Devices."

Guide)ine 7g,"Crane Designi." per;draft Itechnical evaluation rept" on control of heavy loads at facili.tiese

.DI'STRIBUTION i'CODE! A033S <<COPIES RECEIVED jLTiR ~

. ENCL, SIZE t

.TITLE: OR Submittalj USI A 36,Control of,Heavy:Load Near Spent NOTES; Fuel'ECIPIENT

~COPIES RECIPIENT :COPIES IO CODE/NAME, I'T<BC 7 <<7 NRR 'CLEMENSON01 INTERNAL! NRR REQUAgG 09 1 NRR J./DRAB 1'2 1 1 NRR/DS I/AEB 1 1 G 04 1 1 RGN2 1 ~ 1 ,EXTiERNAL~ ACRS 13<< 6 6 L'PDR 03 1 1 NRC iPDR ,02 1 1 NSIC 06 1 NTI'S )TOTAL NUMBER OF 'COPIES REQUIRED: L<<TTR 26 ENCL 26 T3PlQAQ 9(4;<TJKLAATQV Lf'~'j9'ig8;3TA:".' 3<)'.T .. R<'.A(ll'-: <@.",> 250092v 0 fnFt I'J HnG 1~lHQR 64 f1O f'9 ih 0 fn 4 f~a f'~;tnre'il y'.l ~s<<'t "c,'~--' '. jE3~~ l2SQGGVG 0 fnpf J bns lC)HO I 59k'l9 f 'llew 4 l"AV pan,b f'0;f6 f 9'ii g5~1< T Fc~~~ "~G VIdlTAIJIRIA H<>><gU~ > 4A.<, ~)Td-' e 0',) fgpjJI 8 1gMo I sbfqofl L1'.)X1'AIJIQRA 1 tT,~l<<I:l3HI dl4A V. ~ ~ltd>" Hon5'lO ltqetfoaoA L'In[tawoqgl ,,A,,Qq,*, dg>> ~ +aOOFVO<f pnf 'ft J fat'ae~<G+ I) >IN Onl' Ob)VG nO Otnl'tiibS ~b1OX'>9'1 <lT4 a "< fooh~loe4'tvab aoq "~int'tteoG ohio'>0" i'd% onl foe'FuQ 8 ,cotfl ff,os'F h>s abaef yvoon 5'o fastness oa fqozi neieevfsve

BRING .. JQ~f3 fovR fnoqG Zoo<i 6aiJ

,vvsoH RTJSq3V)(d."i3AI a31<<9> 'tg frl0$ na0 eK~A g<,K&A:3Qa3 <1uiTl>d>;,ll'-.-'l,l Lc,".9;fs9tjiduV ,"i III I I No 88I IOQ 83? 89,> T<$ 3llX93~I JQl)d NTTJ Jglf13 AfTJ '.-'[<>A>$ %3493 v T V QI9 f QA0 HAH 5'AAQXJAXA~4;~ AQ @JI~ Ht3 IJ GHQA; JA S::~dr Ql@> JR~'I f l; G l'F~1 . BOX 14000, JUNO BEACH, F L 3340B FLORIDA POWER & LIGHT COMPANY February L-83-71 ll, 1983 Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation Attention: Mr. Steven A. Varga, Chief Operating Reactors Branch gl Division of Licensing U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D. C. 20555

Dear Mr. Varga:

Re: Turkey Point Units 3 8 4 Docket Nos. 50-250 & 50-251 Draft Technical Evaluation Re ort In our letter (L-82-346) dated August 10, 1982, we provided additional information on the items in the Draft Technical. Evaluation Report on Control of Heavy Loads at Turkey Point Units 3 8 4.

The purpose of this letter is to provide additional information on Guideline 4 (Special Lifting Devices) and Guideline 7 (Crane Design).

Our evaluation of FPL designed lifting devices is attached. The Westinghouse designed lifting devices have been evaluated by Westinghouse and we have received a preliminary copy of their report. We are still in the process of reviewing the detailed recommendations contained in the report. We expect to ccmplete our review and provide the evaluations by March 15, 1983.

For Guideline 7 we have received schedules from the crane manufacturers for evaluations of the crane designs. We expect to be able to submit these evaluations by August 15, 1983.

Should you or your staff have any questions on this information, please contact us; Rober E. Uhrig Vice President Advanced Systems 8 Technology REU/PKG/js 8302i80483 8302ii Attachment PDR ADOCK 05000250 P PDR cc: J. P. O'Reil ly, Regi on I I Harold F. Reis, Esquire

.PNS-'LI-83-099-1 PEOPLE... SERVING PEOPLE l'

TURKEY POINT UNITS 3 Kc 4 REACT(K ELD SLINGS EVALU INES A special lifting -rig consisting of six (6) wire rope slings is used at Turkey Points 3 and 4 for handling of the reactor and pressurizer missile shields and the reactor coolant pump hatch covers i.n the con~

tainment. The lifting rig consists of two parts, each composed of three (3) slings and a 2 1/8" diameter choker. Although these slings are dedicated to handling these loads, the slings are standard "off-.

the-.shelf" i.tems with no special design. Therefore NUREG 0612 General Guideline (5) "Lifting Devices that are not Specially Designed" is considered the applicable evaluation criteria.

The following is a summary of pertinent sling, load and crane proper~

ties:

CONSTRUCTION 1 I/4" DIAMETER 6 X 36 IWRC WIRE ROPE I sume er ULTIMATE STRENGTH (MIN) 120',000// Table 3 Per Sling REACTOR MISSILE SHIELD WT 97,'000//

PRESSURIZER MISSILE SHIELD WT 51,300//

CRANE MAIN HOOK (MIN SPEED AT RATED LOAD) 5 fpm In order to account for the NUREG 0612 Section 5.1.1(5) dynamic load factor, it will be conservati.vely assumed that the maximum lifting speed during missile shield handling is 20 fpm. Using the factors in CMAA //70 for dynamic contribution, this constitutes a 10/ increase in load (i.e., 1/2 X per 1 fpm. Thus, the following safety factors are calculated:

F.S. (Reactor Mi.ssile Shield) = 5.2 (40'ngle from vertical, 6 sli.'ngs)

F.S. (Pressuri.zer. Missile Shield = 7.7 (25 Angle from vertical, 4 slings)

Note that NUREG 0612 Guideline 5 requires a minimum factor of safety of 5.0.

The above factors of safety are calculated by dividing the sling ulti~

mate strength by the adjusted actual load weight. The load i.s adjus>

ted to account for the sling angle from the verti.cal and the prevt.ous-ly mentioned dynamic contribution.

The slings are assumed to be constructed of Improved Plow Steel and the working load values are obtained from ANSI B30.9. There is, how>

ever, no documentation available to verify what the actual sling mate>

ri.al is or that it conforms to this ANSI standard.

'I 4>> ~

IQ e