ML19261E328

Requests Info Re Evacuation & Emergency Planning

ML19261E328
Person / Time
Site:	San Onofre
Issue date:	12/31/1975
From:	Hicks L CALIFORNIA, STATE OF
To:	Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
Shared Package
ML19261E325	List: ML19261E324 ML19261E328
References
NUDOCS 7907050554
Download: ML19261E328 (2)

Text

4, ,

A I.

\

//~

47 e m> X

. - . .I cu-c.,

/ o

r. ' n " o" n" .,

P"L .- 3. 'T.'.

< :373 p Nuclear de;Julntorv Cor.".1rc2c ana

=\m .'em a s .

4:D e m % w c f 5

• b. U pC Atocic Saf e ty an d licenu t r.r~- neccal Board s '

'>D

1. ashington D.C.

Docket Nos. 50-361 50-36a Q @ A.D B f f % I,3 tm P

Dear Sirs:

This is a requect for information nececcary to the function of hk f (h the recponsibilities of the Evacuation and Energency Planning Coamittee or the San Onorre State Park Citizens r.dvisory Cor -

ission.

As the Citizens Adviccry Cormission is appointed bv the Director of the California State Parks and Recreation Departaen , our reconcendations for evseuation and emergency planning are to be made to Direc cr Herbert Rhoades, and One information we gather has thus-far been obtained f rom our local and area parks officials and froc tne tublic records. This data is ir.adecuate to the exten; ~

that it is impossible for us to carry out our assi Gn=ent. We as.:

your clarification cr essentials.

First, I have cade a detailed review cr the documen; titled, "Zvacuation Plan for Area Surrounding San Onofre s; clear C-enera: Ing Station" nhich is the be.rinnitz of evacuation rianninc for the area. 2 -

.ie find no tire paraceters, and both the staic par &s departa.n:

say thereresc.onsible officials are none in for writinc our local evacua:1on inc.ut to the"c.lan" that thev have onl~

f - J scant verbal esticates from the utility officials.

Second, the verbal esticates on ..hich the " plan" was based are tremen-duely at variance witt estiaates given in tecticony before One AEC in contruction permit hearings, by bo:n Edicon Co 's witness , avacuerlon

- expert Shep;ard, anc by AIC Lead Saf ety ingineer Jonn Sea:s:

1. :dr. Ronald Mcnshev. , executive orficer of our local state parks a .w a_ s , s a d d . ".c.

officials

- . - i_e ..

e--o . -- ed"c^ a4

nat Intersta.e o nor n aould be available for evacuation of

- o .. . ". e u r. d- e ae . ' a- d.' ..e .". o n . .". c. u

's-t.. e ' n.. c a l O r. a. ( .n .a.-. .h b a '_ c .a. ,l

.. o ~' ' 1 '. *. _" . u _* , *ha.

.. ".4*. wou'd- ..o.^-

"e necessary to evacuate San Clen Ote".

.o. . e .s. o..s _ , . a . ., . ..r.  : o . . o. _ _4-.

. . e . o. o . . .y , . . 3 o- .g

. . .. h. e c o . . . . _,._ y .- . . . ' ' -

Interstate 5 nould be full of San Clecante evacuees, thus could not be used by the north teacn a rea populations.

1 w

.S_4. .-. . " l o _ '.s- .7"'c_ -~ _' e '- - - _- a_ o'. _ ' _ -'. . ' .c . . a.e. e_ d o.n '.s" _ _" c m' _' ,. .' .. d v e .' as c " ~ .v o.,.., a ...s.. . , , . ... o snd a .., c u. 4 .,. 3 u. u. . o. ._, .. u, c,h

. o, o o- ,J .. .

. n. e-

. , ., . . a . , -

~..+.a. %, - _ C o. . . .

.."4r c h. c ' u .= c a _" C_ _ a_ _' _c a_ '

a '-. c a c ". ~. " .s- _.o.' '

_ . _._ '."-^__a.'.

. c _' .

' d. a.

. _'m'...,(4a_- c s'bo.'e-a_

-_ .m _ o c ' , a a. . m" s m a>_ =_ , o _- .3 *. a a t.- ) " . ' . " -e -.. u ' a u -a

a. n. a_

_~.s" .. .

_ c u s _ s"

& g. c&e.- aou, '..".o. i O d_' "a-a "o

- - . .'. o ". P. ' - s"a ' - ..'. ^_ ,

o' . ..a" " s" a 7. 3 o^ . u" ' ' . .h. o. . a. '.'.D 'd be .4.-) . 4 .n. ,u, +, ,. os

-a

.....C.. .O- o_ m.a

. c ,,, -.

0 3

. .s. o C..._-u

. , 1 a m.o_n o a

Lso rn. o 24 ---

.. q- r.gg- '

g o.o.

e

.w. o g .

.7-., 3 . , .c.e.. .. ,. +^ -

a. 1, ~

. _. _4 _' s_ o- __ e__. m . . - . .4.'a= ~ ~. n o. p a_sg- - ' o_ m u .c. . 'e.

a_vacu' c.d .".o_ o o _" r. -

. _ . _d _' a_ .". 4- 4. ". s-'...m. ._'.u---a c' .au'a _'on. --= 4 '"

sssessment" eallows h..u n - - a d o- o-, c. '. "

15 minutes fo- the firs: mile...not for :he few

.m. . s" -a mo " d - _' n 7. .".'- ~^ .x.- " a_o c.h c o e- o- na u .. d- -

o "m .~ . ' c' . _e - -o " .

he evacuated.

.r ' -

4 Paul Muspratt r a, .. e y,, u. c _,n restonsit.

le for evacuation. .-lanciar - for tha / d' J<

o - w...o- o c u, . n o_ _. n m m, ,. ;. c , . n .4 ,

. .. - a..oa,

.v__

__ .s. o. .s. u o communicated to his cuperiorc har anceaament that "there is no way I can -10 the 7eople off tnoce boucnec and out of the ocean and

_.. . _ _ _7.9 0 ~< 05Of -t

9 F

6 . . ,,,,..

Out Of . ne lan y area r

• v-first cuadrant." He uc , "I

.nute %ey gave :e f or the the ep:. .;ent to perform t.na* u ,.ni<Of  ; don't evacua have t10n. the "canpower nor

%. . . . .i) ,. 4- . ..". . u.e e a. s . '. "..a 't e w+~ .

~. . ." b a .l ,

W. .s u - :. ' *. . .

?Iere She.t.tard and Sears in error?.u^4..

^ O .*m r%' '.O .

additional d -

echanictl cat eguarcs ahien Or ha're have the dminisned u tilities* .arO he O:ed

.b.a. .,s a a *.. .a. -

a. x . e n. . ". .a *s

.39 . O n2 .-a. " o ' 4 '.

.h. . a . . . ' <s.. u"he-- a "d a- '

a s **. ...a . a. a- a .~.

T

. .# ao,

nat additional tice? Exae:ly wna: uOuld be .m..a . c r~m .o~. s.".a v a.1., .

%. e .r. j u %

d ~. d '. O .

a.,.a .4 .,. , - 1 o. .eO.

...ac..a. 4w . O n .n :..:w - . w o.

the :inimo: ::.m.u-e- ". ". d a . ~

1 ... . . . .. ... c. ., u a 4. C .,. a o.a ,,a

.a.... ...r. . .

. O W :* O :' " .' .". '. .' O r. ~.^ ..*.. * *. .~

. . . o.

.a.re ther- O tner mechanical Onanges which the u tili*ies c O cl .i c a.< e wnicn woulc allow more time? ihat about c

3n. d O G '.' S. . a.

w '.^ a. a C .". . ' . ' .. # ."O r. *. ^s.# '..".S..*, .v .' *. ." A .7 4

the a people A

in the barrancas

. a g e. .. g. w.e , a. g g .* e .w

...a.,.. ~* .#_W .b.' .'. .*. ." a d .# a a. ~. C.#

. "wO v . ' / *. .*. o. '<*- * .*s *. P. - a .l. 's "

'.r.a.

.".' .'. . . u ~ e a' '.

One O.' O L".- ^ 0 ... . . . e a. .".. e..'c -w e .*.< u

..4. d e A. 3 fa. ..O.7 *Cou. w 6.a -"a

n. .w .s. "

• ed ** *h a ** 4 .-- -- -

. . "w

..C o. ees. . ,

.ro. -

-e. . mJ . 4

. e ,,O r. A s..a . . . o. 5,

. . . o. .* .e u e. O .wo. a.,,, ,

4

- .4 .' .- * *' e 4-

.O

.A- m

• • 0-f . d,, - a

. s . . . . . ,

.. . .r. . .s. o. Oao.on.  %. . 4.. ,4.-

f .- . n .i. 00.1J . .,fO .r.

- a ..

. C ." ~ . . ^ . ^ . .~., u . #. _' .". y- " " ** . e, .n. .

w . ., o. a. ,a -

' e .*. C .' . - . a. 3 . .a. d. d. .' ~. ~. O *. ' '." o.

.w

. ". ", O n . ."

...s...

s .. -. n . 2 2. .a. , -w S. ". d a. g' U .' , '. 9 ". ~. ,

.. . g .u o.

.'.rg , .y g.. . ea -m ,., . W . . . cw

s. . -og y .)o. .e.s,.u . . .r. o. . .. a . . o. .y .g ...

c m.

f. .. .s.s.ea

,M .

3

. 3. 3 , .a n. c

. . . - . g.

.% m.nm4 1 4.w e. .. . .. .. . .g gn

.y .4p* b. w* g g g *>. " ' *

o. .i A o.u. . . , o,. s., ; . 2 g-

. a..;-

g-o.

. n. 6.g7 .- , 3gg *

• .'#.*^*-a . e *

• 4 'a 'W"aW ~*

. *, 7* ..e a ,.' o

.,q.A w -

+

'I4

.e. g5g. .o . *.19 w. . o .n. ...

-'*e-*.-

C O *. a" *. ." .a .d .". '. '

.v.'..'..'.". 7. .*. 4 c .". '. f a. "'l o# ' I ',"

.w. g g . .r.. o ...., o. .o . . d

." ^ ~

.4 4A .c. . g e. a. .

.s' n e'7' C U S *. .* .0 ~

." a "I -

v^ ." *. .M. *. c' .'. , ,s . - . . .' V '. '. '*.O U *.

... .J ea . .~ wo. a. "..f'.'.'..". .

.$ ^ ^ u ."' ~. e , a .'*.o " a. ' e ." a* .

. . o. .e m. .

. , *s .d ." a.

gO ,.S .

5 g .7o -..~. - e .n. . .

,L,.,.

s a e. ,s. .4 .. . , ,....o..s . -~4- .

. O ,, .

. 4. a. g 9 . .p.. o. .w

. o. ..

.., C " a '. .' .*. 3 m.

• • f' *:.* ." ..~ O a" . .. e .- o a. g,: .r. .e.a b.41. 4 *.<~

.N.+.a.. -a .4 . a b a. j" ^s *. 4.

f" .' *- o" ~. b o L' .a. d a.".' *. ~ ' ~

<C y 3.. w .w2

.. ..n. a. n .- a.

w.,.,,

w

.a.n.O.. o; 4 v.o.c.

2~  :, . w . .# . *^

.v

. .. ....a.n..

...r. o. . . w. . .

. .......a.. .

. a .4 A .a . a. O L. .,o.A.

'. Oa,.,

w e.

4. .; ... 3. 3..p.3.,... . .

. o. a e .. 3 u 3 c . ,.

-aw g o. e. ".O".'.* o,.. r.eg .,.. . 4 .". '. .". e

'e" c". ."." ' 7 v^ a ,

no vs . 1 , ,.

u s '."., O .' O u ,#. .e. * *. * .>.a of* = ~. A..". S .

f.-a .m. . g- .a A.o.fm..o. . g

, w .,. e.o .-n. . .y.r.g .

4. . .

a 4 .. . o, A.4.0 . g .t . . 3 f p. mo.

e . .w o. .-. -,.1 ,

... a. y. ,3 , y.u , o. . . 3 e .a.

s v o. . .,.o. ...g . 4..e . .g o c o.

e...,, . g ...a.., g w.a. ..... . . ..

. ..e . .. p. o. . g C c. ." O * * * ~ O ". S 4

..f r .w g i .,. v e 'r,o--s.w  : a.. e

.# .a ..".o., . o .o....

f..a .

h4"TanCa3 Oeach. -- * . o. . . - . . . o.

.Tn f. mu s . . .o S.e.n.o. w w.a ao. C , a. .s,,n..

ade gu o c/- C.# .*^a +.v a. , .. o -~. o .' a O ..' :-

w . ..n.- n ..

s.... o. e-e. sJ 3 .c .e., ..a , o. A .a 0 .,w.- . .

. a. .#^" s.".'-".o...*O.,

o.

n .-

s.

.. .o.

". e ' .' .' .7 5' '. e .e '. .' .'. 0 .. ,'I . .

. "e o- .r a. ,

.#"a.a..."...'.

. ',,', .O .n. ~...a. 1. 7 "w p a. ~

o. ge

. ,> -C ~. ~ . "... * ~ . J' O u '.v .# '.--. ~ , ." O j O 's- '

d --

.V .' .1 .' ."*.g's.'."*.

^ y"s % a. .' .'.' ' . a. s. #. a. w d ".

s o. ."

. g S.aa.e o .e a. o. a. o g a 3 o ~.~.a.

' ' ' . ' . . ' . ' ~ . ' ' . . ' '. O

. ., s . . . + . . .o.. .~ g.w ..o n . . ,o. ..,.. ^ 'l . . 4g .g. ,.

.~'na*o.~.^

- a .

'.'s'.m~.,"*..".

a

,. C.,, 4 o. ,, a. .

.i . . . . .u.. . o . ,

j sgf-,..o.

S . . a. . ' ..g .ua

. A.

.em s .= .

e. .

.e O.. . -a e

- . o. g.

. . . -c. ,; g .4.- o. . .

3. .r. e, , a C " ." ^. *. .". O **

j"a ***....'*..'y'w.^. .O f".*.~..". ~ . . " . * . " ,

y o. 7.,,. . .i - '.'.*.s" W'.'..' *vs-. ***".'

afy.

. . , . .. e, , 3.-. . s ,, ,;

a. c .a a.... . . p ., e. m. . -

d . . s S ~. a. C . .' .* s* a* s"-...*.*..* ~* " .

3.. y.., g u a * .n. w

. ' " . "..."..a. #*"

.. '. .~.2.a.*.*.*.s~^.' . . 3 */ *. * .s. ~.<' .' .' 3 u C

" "j " O .

...a . s . .m.. o-- + L" a.. o g o. .- c. -

.. ,. o .. c. . ~., ,

,c ir i  ! ,t_ , . , . , .

.7 f- _i"",~N ;

^

/Y. L L .)

. e . . .. a . . , "..,..r.,..=.

. .. 2. 3 . ..a . .. e .c. a , - .".

.. ..3. . a. a.,., ,"s..,.

e..... - . a. . , m -

.m.a......,.~..-..,.

, , .. ... ,.o.r. c. __

.. ... ..= 0 _4 m f g e r o ,..

~. . O ..

qq m n r q q w-* . _