ML19261E328
| ML19261E328 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | San Onofre  |
| Issue date: | 12/31/1975 |
| From: | Hicks L CALIFORNIA, STATE OF |
| To: | Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| Shared Package | |
| ML19261E325 | List: |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 7907050554 | |
| Download: ML19261E328 (2) | |
Text
4,,
A I.
\\
//~
47 e m>
X
-..I cu-
/
o n " o" n".,
c.,
- r. '
P"L.-
3.
'T.'.
- 373 p
=\\m
.'em a s.
Nuclear de;Julntorv Cor.".1rc2c ana 4:D e m % w c f 5
- b. U pC Atocic Saf e ty an d licenu t r.r~- neccal Board
'>D s
- ashington D.C.
Docket Nos. 50-361 50-36a Q @ A.D B f f % I,3 tm P hk f
(h
Dear Sirs:
This is a requect for information nececcary to the function of the recponsibilities of the Evacuation and Energency Planning Coamittee or the San Onorre State Park Citizens r.dvisory Cor -
ission.
As the Citizens Adviccry Cormission is appointed bv the Director of the California State Parks and Recreation Departaen,
our reconcendations for evseuation and emergency planning are to be made to Direc cr Herbert Rhoades, and One information we gather has thus-far been obtained f rom our local and area parks officials and froc tne tublic records.
This data is ir.adecuate to the exten; that it is impossible for us to carry out our assi n=ent.
We as.:
~
G your clarification cr essentials.
First, I have cade a detailed review cr the documen; titled, "Zvacuation Plan for Area Surrounding San Onofre s; clear C-enera: Ing Station" nhich is the be.rinnitz of evacuation rianninc for the area.
2
.ie find no tire paraceters, and both the staic par &s departa.n:
officials resc.onsible for our local evacua:1on inc.ut to the"c.lan" say there are none in writinc that thev have onl~ scant verbal f
J esticates from the utility officials.
Second, the verbal esticates on..hich the " plan" was based are tremen-duely at variance witt estiaates given in tecticony before One AEC in contruction permit hearings, by bo:n Edicon Co 's witness, avacuerlon
- expert Shep;ard, anc by AIC Lead Saf ety ingineer Jonn Sea:s:
1.
- dr. Ronald Mcnshev., executive orficer of our local state parks a.w a_ s, s a d d. ".c.
- i_e
. ed"c^ a4 o... ". e u r. d e a. ' a-d.'..e.". o n..". c.
u 's-e e--o officials :nat Intersta.e o nor n aould be available for evacuation of t.. e ' n.. c a l O r. a.
(.n.a.-..h b a '_ c.a.,l
.. o ~' ' 1 '. *. _". u _*,
- ha.
".4*. wou'd "e
..o.
^-
necessary to evacuate San Clen Ote".
.o..
e.s. o. _,. a.,....r. o
_4-.
.. o. _
.. e. o. o..
.y,.. 3 o-
.g
. h. e c o.... _,._ y.-... ' ' -
.s Interstate 5 nould be full of San Clecante evacuees, thus could not be used by the north teacn a rea populations.
1
.S 4... " l o _ '.s-.7"'c_
_' e - - _-
a_
'. ' _ -. '.c.
w o _ '.
. a.e. e_ d o.n
'.s" _ _" c m' _',..'.. d v e.' a c " ~.v
-~
s s n d a.., c u 4.,. 3
- u. u.. o.,. u, c,h o.,..,
a..,,.. o o, o o-,J...
- n. e-
.,.. a.
~..+.a.
%, - _ C o....
..s..
"4
.. r c h. c ' u.= c a _" C_ _ a_ _' _c a_
c _'
a '-. c a c ". ~. ".s-
_.o.'
' d. a.
_'m'...,(4a_- '."-^__a.'.
c
-_.m _ o c ', a a.. m" s m a> =_, s'bo.'e-a_
o _-
- a. n. a_ _~.s"
.3
- . a a t.- ) ". '. "
- -.. u ' a u _ c u s _ s" e
-a
- a i O _' " a d
c&e. ou,
'..".o.
- -..'. o ". P. '
& g.
"o a s"
- 7. 3 o^
. u" ' '..h. o.. a.
o'.. " " s"
'.'.D
' d
- a
^
a-
r.gg-
.a be
.4.-
. 4.n.,u, +,,. s
-a
.....C..
.O o_ m.a c,,, 0 3
..s. o C.., 1 a m.o_n o
Lso o 24
)
o a
q-rn.
.._-u g
o.o.
_. _4 ' s_ o-e e__.
.w.
g.7, 3.,
.c e.., +^
- a. 1,
.4.'a=
~. n o.
p a_ - ' o_
m u.c.. 'e o
~
m
~
sg-a_vacu' c.d.".o_
o o _" r.
_. _d _' a_.". 4 4 ".
'...m.
._'.u---a c'.au'a
_'on.
--=
4 s-sssessment allows 15 minutes fo-the firs: mile...not for :he few h..u n - - a d o-o-,
" e c. '.
s" a " d - _' n
- 7..".'- ~^ x.
" a_o c.h c o e-o-
u.. d-o "m.~ ' c'. _e - ".
.m.
na
-o
- mo he evacuated.
.r 4
Paul Muspratt restonsit le for evacuation -lanciar for tha / d' r
J<
o a,. e y,,
- u. c
_,n w...o c u,. n o_ _. n m m,,. ;. c,. n.4,
.s. o..s. u o a..oa,
- o
.v__
communicated to his cuperiorc har anceaament that "there is no way I can -10 the 7eople off tnoce boucnec and out of the ocean and
_... _ _ _7.9 0 ~< 05Of
-t
9 F
6 Out Of ne lan y area r
- v-
.nute first cuadrant."
He uc,
"I,. < ; don't have the canpower nor
%ey gave :e f or the the ep:..;ent to perform t.na* u ni Of evacua t10n. "
.i),. 4.". u. e
?Iere She.t.tard and Sears in error?. 4..
e
- a. s. '. "..a 't e w+~
~..." b a.l,
u^ ^ O.*m r%'
'.O W.
.s u - :. ' *...
additional :echanictl Or ha're the u tilities.arO O:ed cat eguarcs ahien have dminisned
- he
.b.a .,s d -
a a *.a.
- a. x. e n.. "..a *s
.h.. a... '
<s..
u"he--
.m..a. c r~m.o~. s.".a v a.1.,a d a- '
.39. O n -a. " o ' 4 '.
T.#
ao, a s **...a. a. a-a.~.
2.
%. e.r. j u d ~. d '. O.
- nat additional tice?
Exae:ly wna: uOuld be the :inimo: ::.m e
.u- - ". ". d a
~
a.,.a.4.,., - 1 o.
.eO.
...ac..a. 4w. O n.n :.:w -. w o.
... c, u a 4. C.,. a o.a
,,a
.a... r.
... o.
1
. O W :* O ' " '.". '..' O r. ~ ^.*. * *.
.~
.a.re ther-O tner mechanical Onanges which the u tili*ies c wnicn woulc allow more time?
O cl.i c a.< e ihat about the people in the barrancas 3n. d O G '.' S.. a.
'.^ a. a C.".. '. '. #."O r. *. ^s #
'..".S..*,
.v ' *.." A.7 c
4 a
.#_W
.b.'.'..*.." a d
.# a a. ~.
C.
' r.a.
. a g e.. g w.e, a g g.* e
...a.,..
"wO w
.w A
~*
v. ' / *..*.
- o. '<* *.*s
- P. a
.l. 's
.".'.'... u ~ e a' '.
One O.'
O L".- ^ 0...... e a.
.".. e..'c e *.<
u 6.a "
- ed ** *h a ** 4.--
- w
-"a "w
.4.'.- * *' e 4-
. 4. d e A. 3 fa. O.7 *Cou.
5,.s.o..*
w n.
. e,,O r. A
.w
- 0-
... o.
.e u e.
s..a
. C o.
e.,
.ro.
-e.. mJ.
4.r.
..s. o. Oao.on.
%.. 4..
... e,.n..., o.
a.
O.w. a,,,,
.O
.A m. d,, -
o.
4 es.
s f
a
,4.-
f.-. n.i. 00.1J,f
. C." ~.. ^. ^..~., u. #. _'.". y-
' e.*. C.'.
a
,a
.. O.r.
w.
-. a. 3.
.a. d. d..' ~. ~. O *. ' ' " o. ". ", O n.."
S. ". d
- a. g' U.', '. 9 ". ~.,
.w
- s.. n
. 2 2...,...s...
. g.u o.
-w a
.'.rg
.y g. ea -
W cw
-og
)o.
.e,.u...r. o.
m,.,.
... a.. o..y
.g g.
s.
y
.s
,M 3
f.
.s.s.ea
. 3. 3,
.a n. c
- o..i A o.u..., o,. s. ;. 2 g-a..
.%.n 4 1 4.w e....
m.
..g gn
.4p* b.
c m m w
- e a,.' o * *^*- e
.'#. a . *
- 4
.y
- g g g *>.
g. n. 6. 7., 3gg
.,q.A
-o.
w
'a
+
'W"aW ~*." ^ ~
'I4 g
.e. g..o. *.19 w..
o.n.., 7
-'*e-*.-
5g
.w. g g..r. o.,
o.
C O *. a" *..".a.d.". '. '
.v.'..'..'.".
- 7..*. 4 c.". '. f a.
"'l o# ' I ',"
.o.. d
.4 A.c.. g e. a..
4
.s' n e'7' C U S *.
- 0 "..f'.'.'..".
." a
~
"I v^." *..M. *. c'.'.,,s. -...' V '. '. '*.O U *.
.$ ^ ^ u."' ~. e
- s.d." a.
, a..o " a. ' e. a*.
.J a.
wo.
e
.~
a.
.. o..e m..
gO,.S
,L,.,. 5 g.7o. - e.n..
e.
,s.4 s
.,,....o..s. - -.
- 4. a. g 9. p.. o.
~4
-..~
b a. j" ^s *. 4 a
. O,,
- o..., C " a '..'.*. 3
.w
. g.r..e.a b.41. 4 * ~
... e.- o a,:
- f'
- * ".~ O a" 2~
f".' - o" ~. b o L'.a. d a.".' *. ~ '
m.
.N.+.a. a.4
. a
- n. a.
n.- a. w.,.,,
~
- ^
w
.......a..
. a.4 A
.a.
- a. O L.., '. O,
.a.n.O..
4 v.o.c.
- ,. w o;
<C y w
.w2
.v
....a.n..
. r. o.
w.
- 4....
- 3. 3..p.3.,...
o,. r.eg.,.. 4.". '..". e
'e" c".."." ' 7 v^ a,
3..
o.A.
a.,
e.
- w. o. a e.. 3 u 3 g o. e.
c.,.
".O".'.*
'."., O.' O u,#..e. * *. *.>.a
-aw u
s of* = ~. A..". S.
no
. 1,
.m.
. g-A.o. m o.. g vs f.-a
.a f p., w.,. e...
o n
.y.r.g.
m e..w o. -.
f..
4.
4... o, A 4 0. g.t..
-,.1
- a..,3, y.u, o...
.,.o.
o.
a 3
3 e. 4..e. g o c o.
- o..
y s
a.
v
...g
..e e...,,
. p. o.. g C c.." O
g.., g a.
...a w.
..f r.w g i.,.
e
'r,o--s.w
- * * ~ O ". S 4
h4"TanCa3 Oeach.
.# a
..".o.,
. o
.o -- *. o.
.. -... o.
f..a v
e
- a..
.Tn f. mu.
S.e.n.o.
w
.o a
ao s.
w. C, a.
,,n..
..n.- n..
- o. e sJ 3.c.e.,
, o. A
.a 0., -..
.s w.
ade gu o c/-
C.
. a +.v a.,.. o. o.' a O.' a..#^"
-e.
s....
- ^
-~
..a n.-
.o.
w.
s.
". e '.'.'.7 ' '. e.e '..'.'. 0..,'I.
.#"a.a..."...'. ',, ',
'.v.# '.--. ~,." O j O 's-y"s % a.
.'.'.' ' . a. s. #. a. d ".
s o."
s.".'-".o...*O.,
"e -.r a.,
.O n.
~...a.
- 1. 7 "w o.
o 5
p a.
- o..,> C ~. ~. ". * ~. J' O u
.V.'.1.'
."*.g's.'."*.
~.~.a.
' ' '. '.. '. ' ~. ' '.. ' '. O.~'na*o.~.^
ge -
~
d --
^
w
. g S a.e o.e
- a. o. a. o g a 3 o
g.
.a
- o...o n.. o.,. ^
'l.
- a.
w
'.'s'.m~.,"*..".
,. C, 4 o.,,.
.i
.., s o
. 4g
.g.
.~
a
. '..g A.
.e S.. a.
a.
... +.....
m.=
- e..
.ua
.u..
j sgf-,..o.
e. o.
g.
-c.,; g.4.- o.
.O f".*.~..".
~.. ". *. ",
s
.e O.. 3..r. e,, a C "." ^. *..". O j"
....'*..'y'w.^.
'.'.*.s" W'.'..'
-a a
y o.
7.,,...i vs-.
afy.
e, 3.-
s,,,;
a.
c.a.. p., e. m..
a....
s 3.. y.., g u a
- n.
d S ~. a. C..'.* s* a* s"-...*.*..*
"..."..a.
w
~* "
. 3 */ *.
- s. ~.<'.'.' 3 u C
.~.2.a.*.*.*.s~^.'
" " " O...a. s. m. o +
L" a. o g o..- -
j c.
..,. o. c...,,
~
,c i r i
,t_,.,.,.
N
/Y.
L L
.)
.7 f- _i"",~
^
- 2. 3.
,"s..,.
.. e.c. a,
..a
-.. e.... a.., "..,..r.,..=.
m f g e r o,..
. O.
e.....
-. a.., m
. 3.. a.
a.,.,
.m.a......,.~..-..,.
..... 0
,,..., o r. c.
_4
..=
~.
qq m n r q q w-*
_