ML063490027

12/13/2006 NRC Slides from Public Meeting to Discuss Results of NRC Confirmatory Action Letter Follow-Up Inspections

ML063490027
Person / Time
Site:	Perry
Issue date:	12/13/2006
From:	NRC/RGN-III
To:
References
Download: ML063490027 (22)

Text

1 1 Perry Nuclear Power Plant Perry CAL Inspections Perry CAL Inspections

--Human Human Performance, CAP Effectiveness, and Performance, CAP Effectiveness, and Maintenance Procedure Adequacy Maintenance Procedure AdequacyNuclear Regulatory Commission Nuclear Regulatory Commission

--Region IIIRegion IIILisle, IllinoisLisle, IllinoisDecember 13

, 2006December 13, 2006 2 2www.nrc.gov Meeting Agenda

• • Introductions and Meeting PurposeIntroductions and Meeting Purpose

• • Overview of Confirmato ry Action Letter (CAL)Overview of Confirmato ry Action Letter (CAL)

• • Overview of CAL Inspection ActivitiesOverview of CAL Inspection Activities

• • Human Performance Action Item Effectiveness Review Human Performance Action Item Effectiveness Review

--Inspection Scope and Results Inspection Scope and Results

• • Supplemental Maintenance Procedure Adequacy Supplemental Maintenance Procedure Adequacy Effectiveness Review Effectiveness Review

--Inspection Scope and ResultsInspection Scope and Results

• • Corrective Action Program Action Item Effectiveness Corrective Action Program Action Item Effectiveness Review Review --Inspection Scope and Results Inspection Scope and Results

• • Licensee Response and RemarksLicensee Response and Remarks

• • Upcoming NRC ActivitiesUpcoming NRC Activities

• • Public Comments and Questions of the NRC Public Comments and Questions of the NRC 3 3www.nrc.gov Purpose of Today's MeetingProvide a public forum for the discussion of recent Provide a public forum for the discussion of recent Perry Nuclear Power Plant performancePerry Nuclear Power Plant performance NRC to discuss the results of our review of NRC to discuss the results of our review of FENOC's FENOC's actions to address issues in the Human Performance actions to address issues in the Human Performance and Corrective Action Program areas of the Perry and Corrective Action Program areas of the Perry CAL CAL NRC to discuss the result of our review of NRC to discuss the result of our review of FENOC's FENOC'sactions to address th e Maintenance Procedure actions to address th e Maintenance Procedure Adequacy aspect of the IP 95002 Issues area of the Adequacy aspect of the IP 95002 Issues area of the Perry CAL Perry CAL 4 4www.nrc.gov Review of Perry Performance

• • August 2004 August 2004

--Perry Enters Multiple/Repetitive Perry Enters Multiple/Repetitive Degraded Cornerstone Colu mn of NRC Action Matrix Degraded Cornerstone Colu mn of NRC Action Matrix

• • January January--May 2005 May 2005 --IP 95003 Inspection ConductedIP 95003 Inspection Conducted

• • May 2005 May 2005 --Public Exit Meeting for IP 95003 Inspection Public Exit Meeting for IP 95003 Inspection

• • July 2005 July 2005

--IP 95003 Inspection Report IssuedIP 95003 Inspection Report Issued

• • August 2005 August 2005

--FENOC Response to IP 95003 IssuesFENOC Response to IP 95003 Issues

• • September 2005 September 2005

--NRC Issues CAL NRC Issues CAL 5 5www.nrc.gov Confirmatory Action Letter (CAL)FENOC Committed to Sustained ImprovementFENOC Committed to Sustained ImprovementCorrective Action Program EffectivenessCorrective Action Program EffectivenessHuman PerformanceHuman PerformanceEmergency Preparedness Emergency PreparednessInspection Procedure 95002 Issues Inspection Procedure 95002 Issues 6 6www.nrc.gov Perry CAL Inspection Activities Planned NRC Planned NRC FollowupFollowup Inspection Activities Inspection Activities

• • Review Licensee's Asse ssment Activities and Review Licensee's Asse ssment Activities and Corrective Action Development Corrective Action Development

• • Review Corrective Action ImplementationReview Corrective Action Implementation

• • Review Corrective Action EffectivenessReview Corrective Action Effectiveness 7 7www.nrc.gov Perry Nuclear Power Plant Completed NRC CAL Inspections Completed CAL Completed CAL Followup FollowupInspectionsInspectionsPII Phase 2 Review PII Phase 2 ReviewIP 95002 Issues IP 95002 Issues

--Action Item ImplementationAction Item ImplementationCorrective Action Program Corrective Action Program

--Action Item Action Item ImplementationImplementationEmergency Preparedness Emergency Preparedness

--Action Item Action Item Implementation and Effectiveness Implementation and EffectivenessHuman Performance Human Performance

--Action Item ImplementationAction Item ImplementationIP 95002 Issues IP 95002 Issues

--Action Item Effectiveness Action Item Effectiveness 8 8www.nrc.govInspection Scope -Human Performance (HU) Action Item EffectivenessHU Action Item Effectiveness HU Action Item Effectiveness

--Scope Scope**Determine whether HU tools are adequately Determine whether HU tools are adequately implemented implemented

• • Determine whether supervisors actively monitor and Determine whether supervisors actively monitor and reinforce use of HU tools reinforce use of HU tools

• • Determine whether Key Performance Indicators Determine whether Key Performance Indicators

((KPIs KPIs) reflect improved human performance) reflect improved human performance

• • Determine whether appropriate corrective actions Determine whether appropriate corrective actions implemented to address HU issues in implemented to address HU issues in KPIs KPIs 9 9www.nrc.govInspection Results -Human Performance Action Item Effectiveness HU Action Item Effectiveness HU Action Item Effectiveness

--Results Results**Use of HU Tools Use of HU Tools

--AdequateAdequate**Supervisory Reinforcement of HU Tools Supervisory Reinforcement of HU Tools

--Adequate Adequate **KPI Review Results KPI Review Results

--Adequate Adequate**Corrective Actions to Address HU Issues Corrective Actions to Address HU Issues

--Adequate Adequate**One Green finding identified One Green finding identifiedNo additional inspection beyond ROP baselineNo additional inspection beyond ROP baseline 10 10www.nrc.govBackground -Maintenance Procedure Adequacy Inspection Maintenance Procedure Adequacy Maintenance Procedure Adequacy

--Background

Background

• • August 15, 2006 August 15, 2006

--IP 95002 Issues CAL IP 95002 Issues CAL Followup Followup Inspection Completed Inspection Completed

• • Maintenance Procedure Adequacy Maintenance Procedure Adequacy

--Indeterminate IndeterminateInsufficient Number of Procedures to ReviewInsufficient Number of Procedures to ReviewMaintenance Procedure Revision Process IssuesMaintenance Procedure Revision Process IssuesSupplemental Review Effort NecessarySupplemental Review Effort Necessary 11 11www.nrc.govInspection Scope -Maintenance Procedure Adequacy Maintenance Procedure Adequacy Maintenance Procedure Adequacy

--Scope Scope**Review effectiveness of actions to address Review effectiveness of actions to address Maintenance Procedure Adequacy aspect of Maintenance Procedure Adequacy aspect of IP 95002 Issues area of Perry CALIP 95002 Issues area of Perry CAL

• • Determine whether additi onal inspection beyond Determine whether additi onal inspection beyond ROP Baseline Inspection Program is requiredROP Baseline Inspection Program is required 12 12www.nrc.govInspection Results -Maintenance Procedure Adequacy Maintenance Procedure Adequacy Maintenance Procedure Adequacy

--Results ResultsNo findings of significance identifiedNo findings of significance identifiedMaintenance Procedure Adequacy Maintenance Procedure Adequacy

--Adequate AdequateResolution of Vulnerabilities Resolution of Vulnerabilities

--Adequate AdequateNo additional inspection beyond ROP baselineNo additional inspection beyond ROP baseline 13 13www.nrc.govInspection Scope -Corrective Action Program (CAP) Action Item EffectivenessCAP Action Item Effectiveness CAP Action Item Effectiveness

--Scope Scope**Determine whether actions to address CAP Determine whether actions to address CAP issues were effective issues were effective

• • Determine whether CAP Key Performance Determine whether CAP Key Performance Indicators (Indicators (KPIs KPIs) reflect improved CAP ) reflect improved CAP performanceperformance

• • Determine whether appropriate corrective Determine whether appropriate corrective actions implemented to address CAP issues in actions implemented to address CAP issues in KPIs KPIs 14 14www.nrc.govInspection Scope -Corrective Action Program (CAP) Action Item EffectivenessCAP Action Item Effectiveness CAP Action Item Effectiveness

--Scope Scope**Problem Evaluation and Resolution Problem Evaluation and Resolution

• • Audits and Self Audits and Self

--Assessment Effectiveness Assessment Effectiveness

• • Staff Willingness to Raise Issues Staff Willingness to Raise Issues

• • Use of Operating ExperienceUse of Operating Experience

• • Key Performance Indicat or Implementation Key Performance Indicat or Implementation and Results and Results 15 15www.nrc.govInspection Results -Corrective Action Program Action Item EffectivenessCAP Action Item Effectiveness CAP Action Item Effectiveness

--Results Results**Problem Evaluation and Resolution Problem Evaluation and Resolution

--Adequate Adequate**Audits and Self Audits and Self

--Assessment Effectiveness Assessment Effectiveness

--Adequate Adequate**Staff Willingness to Raise Issues Staff Willingness to Raise Issues

--Adequate Adequate**Use of Operating Experience Use of Operating Experience

--Adequate Adequate**Key Performance Indicators Key Performance Indicators

--Adequate Adequate**One Green Finding IdentifiedOne Green Finding IdentifiedNo additional inspection beyond ROP baseline No additional inspection beyond ROP baseline 16 16www.nrc.gov SummaryPerry is being operated safely Perry is being operated safelyAll scheduled CAL All scheduled CAL Followup Followup inspections inspections complete completeNo additional inspections planned beyond No additional inspections planned beyond ROP Baseline Inspection Program inspections ROP Baseline Inspection Program inspections 17 17www.nrc.gov Licensee Response and Remarks 18 18www.nrc.gov Perry Nuclear Power Plant Upcoming NRC ActivitiesDecember 31, 2006 December 31, 2006

--Finalize HU and CAP CAL Finalize HU and CAP CAL Followup Followup inspection results and i ssue inspection reports inspection results and i ssue inspection reportsJanuary 2, 2007 January 2, 2007

--Conduct IP 95001 Inspection; White Conduct IP 95001 Inspection; White EAC Power System PI in 2EAC Power System PI in 2 nd nd Quarter 2006 Quarter 2006January 10, 2007 January 10, 2007

--Conduct public meeting in Region III. Conduct public meeting in Region III. FENOC to discuss assessment of completion of CAL FENOC to discuss assessment of completion of CAL itemsitems 19 19www.nrc.gov Perry Nuclear Power Plant Upcoming NRC ActivitiesEarly February 2007 Early February 2007

--NRC to internally discuss Perry NRC to internally discuss Perry performance and assess the sustainability of that performance and assess the sustainability of that performance at the annual internal Endperformance at the annual internal End

--of of--Cycle meeting Cycle meetingEarly March 2007 Early March 2007

--NRC to issue End NRC to issue End

--of of--Cycle letter to Cycle letter to FENOC FENOCMid Mid--March 2007 March 2007

--NRC to conduct public meeting to NRC to conduct public meeting to discuss End discuss End

--of of--Cycle assessment resultsCycle assessment results 20 20www.nrc.gov Contacts for Additional InformationRegional Public Affairs OfficerRegional Public Affairs Officer

• • Jan Strasma or Viktoria Mitlyng Jan Strasma or Viktoria Mitlyng

• • Phone: (630) 829 Phone: (630) 829

--9663 or (630) 829 9663 or (630) 829

--9662 9662Perry Resident Inspector OfficePerry Resident Inspector Office

• • Mark Mark Franke Franke , Senior Resident Inspector , Senior Resident Inspector

• • Mark Mark Wilk Wilk , Resident Inspector , Resident Inspector

• • Phone: (440) 259 Phone: (440) 259

--3610 3610 21 21www.nrc.gov Reference SourcesReactor Oversight ProcessReactor Oversight Processhttp://www.nrc.gov/NRR/OVERSIGHT/ASSESS/index.htmlhttp://www.nrc.gov/NRR/OVERSIGHT/ASSESS/index.htmlPublic Electronic Reading RoomPublic Electronic Reading Roomhttp://www.nrc.gov/readinghttp://www.nrc.gov/reading

--rm.htmlrm.html Public Document Room Public Document Room1 1--800 800--397 397--4209 (Toll Free) 4209 (Toll Free) 22 22www.nrc.gov SummaryPerry is being operated safely Perry is being operated safelyAll scheduled CAL All scheduled CAL Followup Followup inspections inspections complete completeNo additional inspections planned beyond No additional inspections planned beyond ROP Baseline Inspection Program inspections ROP Baseline Inspection Program inspections