ML20206N316

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Responds to Ltr to NRC on Continued Events Re Transfer of Generation Assets Between Dl & Firstenergy.Info Will Be Considered as NRC Monitor Pending License Transfer Application of Bvps,Units 1 & 2 & PNPP
ML20206N316
Person / Time
Site: Beaver Valley, Perry
Issue date: 05/06/1999
From: Matthews D
NRC (Affiliation Not Assigned)
To: Kotecki D
UTILITY WORKERS UNION OF AMERICA
Shared Package
ML20206N320 List:
References
NUDOCS 9905170199
Download: ML20206N316 (8)


Text

_ _ _ _ _ _ _

l 1

May 6, 1999 I

Mr. David T. Kotecki President / Local 270 Utility Workers Union of America 4205 Chester Avenue Cleveland, Ohio 44103-3615

Dear Mr. Kotecki:

I have been a' ked by Mr. Collins to respond to your letter to the Nuclear Regulatory s

Commission (NRC) dated April 5,1999.

The NRC reviews those nuclear matters that deal with public health and safety, and the protection of the environment for the facilities we regulate. The NRC strives to achieve public confidence in our regulatory programs and processes by encouraging public participation.

Therefore, we appreciate your letter informing us of the continuing events concerning the pending transfer of the nuclear generating assets between Duquense Light Company and FirstEnergy.

The NRC is aware that, as of the date of your letter, there has been no negotiated settlement between FirstEnergy and Local 270 pertaining to the tentative generation asset exchange. The NRC will remain observant of your suit filed in Federal Court, and your complaint against FirstEnergy with the National Labor Relations Board.

However, you have not identified in your letter any specific issues over which the NRC has any regulatory responsibilities. We will consider the information provided in your letter as we monitor the pending license transfer applications and operations of Beaver Valley Power Station Units 1 and 2, and the Perry Nuclear Power Plant. If however, you have specific safety concems with respect to the operation of Beaver Valley or Perry, we request that you bring them to our immediate attention.

Sincerely, Original Signed By:

David B. Matthews, Director Division of Regulatory improvement Programs Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation

./

M45 DISTRIBUTION: See attached page

  • SEE PREVIOUS CONCURRENCES Document Name:g:\\nlad\\ LOC 270 e,t k RGEEfk 4 SCQGJp*- OGC*

C:RGEB D:Dhk OFFICE NAME MDukadiwskyj:sw" Bkah SHon[

CCarpentek DMatthews DATE 5/4/99 5/M99 5/4/99 5/k /99 5/(0/99 i

gj

}

OFFICIAL OFFICE COPY 9905170199 990506 PDR ADOCK 05000334 pgR-j l

(

P PM

$ N M NY q

4

?

k i

0%q\\

)

UNITED STATES p

y j

NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION 1

2 WASHINGTON, D.C. 20066-0001 g

I May 6,1999 Mr. David T. Kotecki President / Local 270 Utility Workers Union of America 4205 Chester Avenue Cleveland, Ohio 44103-3615

Dear Mr. Kotecki:

i i have been asked by Mr. Coliins to respond to your letter to the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) dated April 5,1999.

)

I The NRC reviews those nuclear matters that deal with public health and safety, and the j

protection of the environment for the facilities we regulate. The NRC strives to achieve public confidence in our regulatory programs and processes by encouraging public participation.

Therefore, we appreciate your letter informing us of the continuing events concerning the l

pending transfer of the nuclear generating assets between Duquense Light Company and FirstEnergy.

The NRC is aware that, as of the date of your letter, there has been no negotiated settlement between FirstEnergy and Local 270 pertaining to the tentative generation asset exchange. The

]

NRC will remain observant of your suit filed in Federal Court, and your complaint against j

FirstEnergy with the National Labor Relations Board.

J l

However, you have not identified in your letter any specific issJes over which the NRC has any regulatory responsibilities. We will consider the information provided in your letter as we monitor the pending license transfer applications and operaticos of Beaver Valley Power Station Units 1 and 2, and the Perry Nuclear Power Plant. If however, you have specific safety concerns with respect to the operation of Beaver Valley or Perry, we request that you bring them to our immediate attention.

Sincerely, d

'f j

David B. Matthews, Director Division of Regulatory improvement Programs Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation

4 e

y y

g l

l dt y

ed A n 1, l

E k n r

r e n r

s n

e o d

n e

et a

e o (a is 1, t t get al t

e o

.w0 r

ri t

r s

2. '" s e u n uk acp a o r

d i

e n e

euog o a r a t

i

,o1 s

u6 n

h e age s s i

.t q 4. ' A l io2 mvt a ks qnens d

w0 u e oh e luu a gs a r l

t t t e

n it nar d4 s

i s it 1

r 4.

bi o

e s t nncr p - e u

r p

f o ndt s

pt y

s o hP cws s

e e saol i

ipe d e

n a

epUt r

s s s p ph l s

a

'e l

o s n s ek g edM cit oh oo w

uP ra msb e

r c n s

ie s ii asse ct d

id neh r

t d e

l dl l i o

eh s4 xy ga oi ioO n

f e ud pees v

h el n sl r v

a optrd ri r u c

vr a

.sc vp e

t e c e o ol O ot s vted o

h e

ol t v ol i l u

c t aI n et auo ei s

pef ch lauevl u eri w r gt r

o t ri f

vi i

aig pni f l i

vSeP i h "-

vqs

.s l c s

u s

cgt n

s a r L

la e

edn c

ei i a f a s

vp Vl g

'd o gi vue f

ceLic er e t

v oinw i

ne a n id c s s o n t

l r

uo' eisb h n o.

iieS P

o at cnisceie a

n e eef t

t t

c iri e no ahh r p n g a

).

i i r t t st t it t n 2dl g

ngs u c

).

aenht r n od nc r

a n

m potp a t, co re t r

l t

et e m n (c a

pMepe

a. a T e ek o i c"w"u p)i e a tac e(

n n

m so u r

a 8' U

i t s s

msnAl n has o2 4Tecva4 n 2 n"o l ad s si u

ul e

f i

a e

se c

_ae s:

ee h i cee h

i svo2 svvCh v r

c 9" l c1 s s -

r at s

r e

e c

r cs ei c a eI p o

e' l g

e eOie hx 2

s i

hxlol c3 il ac ar t

r Tei4 v u ee r o

t t

FeT'f 4

v pL w p n

EJ

_ b d pi bSo t

i i

sev rl d

dea e

e eP v4 es s

vi. s d

lvi e4 c

c lar neR a r s

Ved g

ve l

xwhVeac' l

r o

x n

o 2 e i

2 eo t,

c t

r eesg inani eg e

it s

ed l t

r pen nr e

T Uaubadl u Usr vi r e

sh e a eu e

d e sTs vd d vd s

nvd eo2d nl n

adl ct e a ad olvl r

i s ve e

I vcadno eo I

s t

e gV e U c.

it sl lA it l

s n e c s.

n s

s n ei i icedn h

n d

Uh ui rh e w U

t, nw d

r t

e t, d n et i o esao s

s e

o h

s x

enUelecd h le nd p

t r t t

t c

r e

i eu rb e u l

eeh i

eba ph r

xh e a ph P

Pt ot awes PTos d

s eo nMd e

g.

l 0 r o s n a

ht l

l n

f n

t e u o

o i2 o

m g

e t

t t

g d

a iw0 ac a

n e r o

d s6 s e uw n

e nt e h

0 d e g

s,

a i

a usll i l t s as n

n t

t nus o iue nS e

e et 4. i h o s2s yl rh t

a a aa sl r is t

I s e4 s t l s

e r

b e u t

s eh yie r f o nl c ef e

p e

ig e

cIl ooh o er e

c k nv e

i m T s f, io omob rpla qd aP ecant s e c

a st c t n o. v s e i, e h t srf eh s

r s

c eieih cHvok oeoi l

n e

. et x

l nr s e nrl gr a

o e

g r

t r l

s ar aNa emtah eeosFo 0

n o e r t o m

eo e ep u

-das ea E

noiu xi ob aPl r

r ad w i

s c mn a

ick e val ri a f. e i ex r s ei qeut t

t ish

. on a c uk ek eef ef e

t s e r

e ys4 la t inlvmr i

2-e v

x or h q as c r t t

r i dichi a4 e

s epeos ewt cl a

la epnu c et u s r t

cpa( ar p s. d mr ir l

pd ut oht g pl t 1 r

n ohl v el en A

V o r o pd uet si n f s c a h a c o o

os c eS noit s

e n3 n u ph ot s t r t aet i a

g c o n

t n e ei a gs t

aV ceyt h unf i

r t c

n h ta c t n

nndlaa eio) o e r r

l e wl nt r t ue1 icpnc.

io e in ai pd r

t r s t 1

e h

unc Feun i -

iwtuia w5t isi e

n a

d nqen leok ee u

n i

r s a r

dl s1isf ml t t sjWit iml e r r e

h a, h p h e u s. f gp e

b f

f l

a i ch i f f

s on c v( gh ue uv h ht t

r s e i m y?

e e

e rl nt s s sf c c n4 iwt i del r

oi is e

cy f iwt vd e ol D

lvg pi ae uo3 ct r

t it ir ah a nl aninp yt w v T s, n 3

  • n c

a t

e aio e voc o o cf e

e a c 1

d a epvge r

s aa V pd o

vner et icjt e enr i s nit ei t

.k el r ee ina lenp md ie c f

e d r o ulaeh iri c r s a d V o.

ih ci k

ws mt vgisih i

t n

c r va d

- un cr n

st t e s a uiu4 omr ent ah e r nhhjnd pd ootem 2pa mhc L. tcb2 it r r epr n nt lvp e el t o

e r a

t h ei eg i

t t

r a

c e sl f n

nna a it I e ur t r e1 t

i n

m f

icd el oya o, t o i i S

a a

pup eiooa o

ycp nP p :, deSpu3 c

r i

r oef nit v ed u

t m d V, e nrl o

Ul i

vf gfee gf ea e ei i

t s

ot i a Wf.

rl or o

,a r p

aggr t

i poa a s l

nao s

r s

oaei h p u4 o.

nn ad pr gsn n

t t

eei ois mf v cl s

r oe a e w

,d si s

ns a n gl 1 meo n1 enri laif u

ir i

ot v1 t

pmh w J

s o e ec e s ee e

o

. u

, s d

r i nwe a ;., b V

~

lve u h o ish

n a t

a o

t r

p r,

v na1 s

c r p d, w t edd gd

's e ge i e ul Am, ige i

t v. a!

3 a

f r

n s

e mp

, gmt iot o

anh x st a

e v

e nt n.Alb nniu r v e

t i t Se es g ren t r oot o

sg t

eno4d sh s ei

. ae i is d eil s s mi a im d pt f wh,d s icn. e pd teI ni l

en t

) pplt c nt r i wkowic e

e a olak vi aourd S

uvi h et h ed i c s

s et l r

c el t i r

oc yP v s o e nyo a of l ol u Trd xs n e e xo s or i

T x el t a

L

  • et f sI asI ot i p I bibd oAwvd

" p a e pi b es s

r ec 8

8 8

8 7

7 7

7 g

0A 0

4 A 0

B n

n i

41 G0 o m 4t G1 om n

- 3 yi yi t

3 3

3 t

t w

0 8

t e

e 1

1 e ct 0

8 1

1 e ct a.

7 9

f es 7

9 f es r o 7h 9h ajy 7h 9h ajny n

DN 8S - 2S SI S 8S 2S SI S s

n 2

n e 2:

S o

o v d

d C

i d

d i la n

n nR d

t n

n C9 a

lo V

a if I

,. a,

, a, wgn a

c I

o t

sl 1 1 1 I 1 k

01 1 2 o ni s 4444 ei 234 c

s8855 dit e t

av t

S ge 4466 u lol l v n t

lae in3333 Peh itn3333 h ooa d

VI UVVVV LLC UVVVV SCiVs

)

)

3 4

3 0 4

e 0 -

04 r

- I

- 5 b

I S I 1 m

S -

S -

- 2 2

IU-u I

U U

N U

- J

- J m

JS J S t

S C S C e

C(

C(

I o

L

g l

t e

r f n e

h l

e a

oawit i

k M

d e

oh oie k

o n

k t

t t

trd O

a n

o eoe s.

kt s nip r

s n h

is d.

tso t

s e s r n 1

oe uar s n i top l

a t

s n s e

h et ap lus 1

s l4l en ll io v at t h

r c

epr i

0, t h n n

li tr t

t n pm lunl w ef s iu f o nt t

di t

c ui a t

r a f s f

a e u

f eo od op s

s r a vb ul ic *o s

spc e nt p isys p epr) r s pi a i

c oc

=

g eog n r

at g e

t s

sP ah lr e a d nc(c2 x=

n e

r n n r

d x=

ien a d nn t

pt er r iopa2 e= ig vhi d. )c.

e=

ai e

iopwM v

r rl g e

v et po c

r r hd

~(

oe ir h

pet h h

ot u c

epr r

f osaSl pe on3 oe a

z a a r o oO r

ti d

t n

l bh pt is4 c

os u

t

~2 laysfo eh ut t h c qC a t

lar r

f c e Ri eh u

c a y eb n 1

x n n

vt 1

cl e v

t et h oin2 i e el h ivt hi o

cl s e

o n heoge

iow, h

os w rh r

no aeiitint at o0 ct a

it i t

t t

c ct r at t

o n gd 1 a r o ngss4 a

d.).

ar pi o n gl oi rk sl p r ntut pu

eipw, pugnt t

t r at t

r n on1 r a r n o inc nmpsh ltei a

p ou og lteic

. c r

s nret acisP imqeg ltis o0 nqnt e e

. (

e sh a s

i gJ 2 ui ut d

it f

ea ac ed1 isvu m

e r

a a

el p cnw1 l i sl e ed e

rd at s vm e e o ur r s t t M

ri el s

i er l

v u luph n h xo i vd TecsP i f ot a TecO i

i l s e xu 2

aa h xl h a a

a h

t EJ t

eh t

Ted 4

i vr t d n.

d e s pn e -

l eow ih m o

s g

lvl c laed t, r v d o a lug f

g V

n Viu l d e u s t n

si 2i u 2 ch b

r it r

s ed e s ad T

it e

v it e

xd Ts nl n nel Uvp Us o eo a e c

vlc e

t d k o d ieg lad.

m a

nc n vn n

aed al i Ve s s re h e ar t

ci v u 2i n I

s I

c w l

it c.

t d

it r A

s r s

eo nie s nid nxd h

n h e Uet d

U t, ew U

t, x

e s

u s

e o es o eih s

e s o

h l k d h le l h e e

c s

p t

t t

t o

rb ou rb d rl lvd r

ea rh ea n e ao P

PTts s PTa Pvc f

n o

p ea e o w

g ir r

ed 4 lue ht p

n vl t

g 0iuyt, d mn lo n ig nl u s

t o

f a a o a

l o c n

- f ae ne a

uigef t

el v i

2 cs i e c mh l hb pe r

w s

pt o

al 0 r ic r t od eij gut t caah n r

E(l vdb ig pe pi eirf u

ns st a r

t w

e Sseodd u r

x un h s oI o t

aas E

r vw mpr t ef

.d r

e a nl Ib h u or e sdl ol yne a

t o

e na su 7

v l

et t

u i ph 1

l 3 v oa

.d cpyt V

2 s s niu aga inp l

0 n

a nms t

e h i pl a

n t

r f n e

oieut A

0er et o i glyh is lt n

topa w

ogne t

g

- h et t

vh n u p glp m

Et po n n a igi i io e id r

f e

S opa l t

s e n toh at ot l

r i

cw rh ge e

rnldpu r

r c mf t

e t

a f

e af S ad r t e auao r e r

h ai e

h hlpo o n eh d eC e lui hd t

t D

e, iegt d".

omolr d R "p.

pow ce it pt ct p

i o w e

ro nad n x

f e gi h aak gof uer g

sh e

t t vnr e

c nrl oht irnd n ut l go if a t

n eon wt n n

land i

t r

ve) nd inh uT ia s

.st la u ait a o

o s

is s p enpl dC i

dS n en aTodwp eCra ge niai h

iOo pa eV s

c ah h

iny ym lah v

lvRt mt if t

t at ep e p. l n slir ea r f

i t

a ee a %

l a

t st f e

vt r

vh vd s

r

+.

e o e a ph tah u a e a

h et u

n ut e

iset mt n ist cl o6pr t

s t

J s

s n rl h loit pwi h mI

.d

's r6 t

t s

t e s a eb oe n e

r pel z a gs wggn gf i r z r

e e or pi r a

eoi ni nn rii r in r

d r

t u ot u rb pt uis isd egg s

e t

q s ps pd otshS cs e L

Inut CT e lolud r rS o

e e L

esd aaaC l

msedl r

miRapu Co n

f r n ehh Cur nie

" wh ccR

" ppafb a

8 8

8 8

7 7

7 g

- B v.

l 0

0 l

7 l

0 a

a 0

G S,R.

icel

- A

- A a

i G0 h e ceJm G2 ic el n

8 m mrom G1 GI m

o 2

m mr i

w 0 2 mu ;e 8

- 2 2

ut e 0

8 A

ut 1

a.

7 982 el nt 7

9 1 1

C V C. t 1

el s

9 el n s

r o 7h 9726 h ooy 7h 9h h o

. y 9h h oo DN 8S 201 1 y

CVCS 8S 2S S

2S CVCS n

n 2

2 k e io o

k d

c d

n v y

it n

ue n

al t

a a

yah a

Ta l

gl a n

ic ra el V o

no t

s3 l

=C 1

mrot f

I I

1 i

ye 2 3 igI e s

eiv n i4 i

= a v ts0 ut e

2 t

rl t

t r ev x

r 5 nl i5 a

lae n2 u

pa n2 loou n2 hi Vi UV ANSV nl a d

UV VCO UV CLV

)

)

3 4

3 0 4 0 5

0 0 -

0 r

- I

- I e

l I l

I m

C-C CC b

l i

IC u

- 2

- U 2

N U U I 2 I

U-U

- J J

m J

S JS J

t S

e C

S C S

i C(

C(

C 5

?

j