ML20085N694

Intervenor Exhibit I-MOSBA-9,consisting of 900323 Conversation During Critique Committee Meeting & Recorded on Tape 10

ML20085N694
Person / Time
Site:	Vogtle
Issue date:	05/17/1995
From:	GEORGIA POWER CO.
To:
References
OLA-3-I-MOSBA-9, NUDOCS 9506300285
Download: ML20085N694 (1)

Text

J 7 q5

__L. M D S 8 0 '

6 0 Ll23l sj'z 5-OL h 4

/

k,page l Of hhibit 4

DOCKETED NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMM!SSION USNRC n

Tape #10

= ~- i Decket No. Se -W f-cu 4 Official Exh. No.

M S

% JUN -6 P2 :34

'" *

• o' SEGMENT #1 Stat

• IDENTIFIED Tr.Pg.23 Applicant RECEIVED Date: 3-23-99FFICE OF SECRETARY interm,,

e REJECTED Location : Ergggp([h6ppfgrenegg 3rd floor SgpgpRtHding Contg Ott r Occasion: Critique Committee Meeting Contractor DATE o P /b" Otner Wi* ness ShIa d i

Reporter C. EU Briney: These are the worst temperature switches you ever seen in your me.

They're junk. I don't know if we need to advertise that or not, but if you i

ever looked at the calibration process for these temperature switches j

you'd say, *How the hell can we put this on something like a diesel.

Kochery: These CALCON switches have & lot of Part 21's on them, you know.

j j

SEGMENT #2 i

Tr.Pg.27,28

)

Date: 3-23-90 Location : Engineering Conference Room 3rd floor Service Building j

Occasion: Cntique Committee Meeting i

Holms: Typically when you go out and recalibrate them do they always

f. g require recalibration?

j i 8

Briney: Always require recalibration or replacement.

O Holms : Because they are off.

Mosbaugh: Do you always use this tapping procedure.

Briney:

Since the RER came back in "S8", I think we have, we did, we used that tapping procedure. Prior to that, no, we did not because the 4

vendor did not give us that information.

Briney:

I say the hell with them (CALCON switches) because they are such junk!

Holms:

But the next time you go back and try to calibrate these things, essentially every time, they require recalibration.

i Briney:

Especially on jacket water. Especially on Jacket water.

Holmes :

So we've just been living with it.

Holmes:

I think that based on the fact that they have failled after they

}

have been calibrated several times, after we go back to recalibrate j

them we have to recalibrate them or replace. They're never sat.

{

Then I think we have a problem.

i I

SEGMENT #3 Tr.Pg.41 Date: 3-23 90 Location : Engineering Conference Room 3rd floor Service Building Occasion: Critique Committee Meeting Coursey:

If they're CALCON, CALCON. you know its going to be off anyway.

'p Briney

• Chances are. Yea.

1 f

Coursey:

What he's saying, what he's saying again is what he's got to calibrate out there is a piece of garbage and you know there all going to blow!

4 9506300285 950517 PDR ADOCK 05000424 O

PDR

.