ML17187A803

From kanterella
Revision as of 17:05, 18 March 2020 by StriderTol (talk | contribs) (StriderTol Bot insert)
(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Cavitation Test Rept 12x14x14-1/2 Cvds Pump.
ML17187A803
Person / Time
Site: Dresden, Quad Cities  Constellation icon.png
Issue date: 05/16/1969
From: Garrow L
AFFILIATION NOT ASSIGNED
To:
Shared Package
ML17187A798 List:
References
S.O.-280685, NUDOCS 9702240205
Download: ML17187A803 (11)


Text

1.I

  • l I

! BINGHAM PUMP COMPANY

  • -*11111* **
  • (,,,;,iutJ ,,,,,f_.'/ J,,,,,,/11c-l11uu ,*/

llOAIZONTAL 6 VERTICAL CtNTAlnlGA~

  • TURS:ll:E
  • AXIAL n.DW
  • V!E.T !Jl.N3 VACUUM PUMPS

()J/;;,, ...d'.:J.,./eot' 2800 N. W. F'RONT AVENUE ** PORTLAND. OREGON 9721

. .s* .-.. . --

~

REF: s.o. 280685 (Pumps No$. 270419/26)

C A'V IT A*T I 0 N TEST REP 0 RT 12xl4x14-l/2 CVDS Pump GENERAL ELECTRIC APED _ . .

QUAD CITIES I I II *. ;. -: . -

            • - . RESIDUAL HEAT *REMOVAJ: PUMPS::
  • p.o. 20s H0386 ~
  • ouR s.o *. 21041~/26 .

.. ATTACHED .IS THE *REPORT OF THE CAVITATION TEST RUN* ..

ON PUMP *NO *. 27~425 ON ~fAY 15 6 )69 1969.* :

  • .. '- *-**-*--* --- ~-1

. I

. Ref: . S.O. 280685 (Pumps No*. 270419/26) f< Page 2

  • i

SUBJECT:

'CAVITATION TI!ST 12xl4x14*1/2 CVDS rumps*

For this test, Pump No. 270425 was set up in a closed loop on the large suppression tank. All set ups, instrumentation and testing

.s** _.. -*.: -- procedures were in strict accordance with the standards of Hydraul Institute and AS:.m Ptc 8.2. Upon completion of witness and NPSH testing, pump was disassembled .for* inspection. This inspection re vealed the following: *

  • Shaft Sleeve: Excellent condition - only minor scratches from small particles which passed through separator.

Bearing:

  • Excellent *condition
  • only minor scratches as on sleeve.
  • impeller: Excellent condition, except wear surfaces showed some evidence of wear from larger particles..
  • in water and lqwer wear surface showed one groove.

Seal: Excellent condition.

    • Wear Rinns
  • Case:
  • shaft:

Excellent - slight wear only

  • Total runout* less than 0. 0005"~

No damage was. evident from this test.

Pictures were *taken by G.E. personnel* and pump was reassembled for .

cavitation test. This test consisted of setting the desired capac:,

and then reducing the suction pressure to various NPSH values unti:

the impeller was cavi tating~ . l'hi-s was run at capacities *of 4000, _

5350, and 6.000 'GPM *. *Data. takbn at each point was suction and* dis-

  • ., -charge pressure, capacity, power input, vibration, and' water temp~ -

erature. See curve No. :26992 and pages 1 6 2 of ~est data for re*

sults._ * * *

  • At completion of testing, impeller was removed and inspected by G.l and Bingham personnel. There was no evidence of any damage to the impeller from cavi tating~ There was an indication of slight rubbi1
  • " . on bottom impeller wear surfaces *. Nothing was evident -on case rini
  • .Pictures of impeller were taken. by G.E.
  • and pump was reassemb'led :_ft

'run*out .cavitation test at 6000 GPM. For this -test capacity was SE

  • at 6000 GPM. Suction pressure was .then reduced until an NPSH value vas*reached*that*was below the cavitating.point attained on the pre

.. _ vious test.* Howeve*r, *the discharge valve was opened ~o maintain

  • * * -'* :: . 6000 GPM capacl ty,, *rather than .let the capacity fall back 51, as tli

. ~ * .::>*;_.~:-_: : .- was a more .severe. *.tes~ of the pump. This condition was maintained

  • . *--'~*;::*{ ..*~'"'-> . for* one hour.\ See. attached data sheet, page 3, for test .results.*
.~
~, .t;it~*~*:P:-:: s~~f1:t.~i:.'_;,js~.:~.:.,_>*~:.-~.:.:~.~:;> - s-~ * > .. .*. * .* ... . .. ..

. ;~ .:~{.:.~-~~*:*--~;_ ~.* - - ._

f . .. '.

  • Rel': !'.U. nnnnr~

(Pumps No. 270419/26)

~*

.*

  • Page 3 I

At conclusion of test*, impeller wa~ removed and inspected. by G. E.

and Bingham personnel. Again there w~s no sign of any cavitating damage to impeller. The only indication of .w~ar appeared on botto*

wear ring,. which seemed to be slightly "duller" in color, which in dicated possibly more rubbing. Bingham Inspection miked the diame of this area of impeller and it was within drawiug tolerance - 8.6 G.E. personnel photographed impeller.

Pump was Teassembled for second run-out cavitation test at 6000 GP and suction pr~ssure reduced to an NPSll value slightly below. the guaranteed value (about 40.2 ft.). The suction pressure was then further lowered until the pump capacity fell off to 5700 GPM. Thi cavitating condition was maintained for one hour. At this time, the suction pressure was lowered again until the pump capacity dro ped to 5400 GPM. The pump was run in this manner *for 30 minutes.

See _attached data sheet, page 4, for tcs.t results *.

Pump was di*sassemblcd for inspection. - Condition of impeller was not* changed

  • bottom .imp~llcr wear surface still miked 8. 6070".

Shaft *leeve and bearing* in excellent condition, exce.pt for *a few minor scratches.

Cavitation test was considered complete and pump was released for sh~pmentl!

-*. All cavitation* testing *and inspection witnessed by A;, Spivak. 0th G;E.- personnel present .included Tom Day, Norm Peterson and Eldon Bingham. _ . * .

..*"* . -.' ..-* . . . .? ~

~ .

.* (~ ;-1~,_/

  • II *

~

  • rJ;;;,c, Garrow *

. - ' t: .Chief Test Engineer

,....* ' .. ~ . Binghar; Pump Company

, . *:~ . Attached:-* Curve No*26992 '* May 22, 1969

  • Test Data Sheets l thru 4

_..::.... ~*;:-::

~- .

. ---< ..,,_~-:-}_;:'.* -_ .>~..:*:* ~ :* . . .~ :' ;*!: . ... > .. ,*  : . .*

-~:* 1 -*

'~. * : . I '. ~* *

      • ~*-*'-~***Lt*;.; .. * ,*'~

.).

. .. - -- ~ :, . ... .

~ -~- .. *.

. . '".,. .. ' ' *. . ,_...:.*. -~ '"

,:i:.* .... ., ....

p,;=',*.t*U*_t9" .. '*

... lfCI. CU~IOllU . ~~.) \"'\ \~~ I CUii .OHClt ltO llllCOll&ll Pll*P rClf

. . (;.

<?,. E ~ 6'r'e. t>. ; c~:;:;~ '1\:.~\L 'TH E. v' ~"'

'l2 ~: \c.\. ~ . \l\ 'i. C.VD~ : ' 'Z<:::>~~HO ~~b

.11 T-1..10A.1.5-t.

cc:11.;..11')11 f lll:t '

  • '..~ * ,.t

.. *11**

. J .**

1. D.MUD lff .. SP.Cl
  • , AHHILf ' .

DllCMJICI Pl . .

\1-It.

D:J I'. **

IUC1IOll *lfl

\Q.*

llC A~H

'"ll:\. io Hi ~~--\-\~

ID ~~

'"' *oto*

  • ~*=

C.UCS:.,~EQ.~

81:

    • Mi*
    • ~I JOI

~l/L~

Dall

~-~*<:-":*

~

uc:-.*

.C l&!P

\1.\l c::."~':>~' s .

II&.

.\4t- -.

HIP .. 16.11 DI&.

.l'1:.. ib."." "" ', 1.C***c1. "~~*

~.'h,

~"\,t"'

I I

C..~/\G.*v~

3-l.clt z ?.£\ .**

"'~ , "'"'. "~ ."'"'ht;.. ~",,. ' "*'-'"

C.Ut\."E. "1'>. "t..<::.:)'=) l.

'll'f lla.'t'O .. ~ T:.~ *

¥0'1\a~

lfAltfr

\O:~C> t

\~:"\,<<;

~

.i: "<*  :-_~ ~~* .'.

SUCTION. . :, DISCHARGE

. " CIHl;:b IOfAL

...... CA PACI I f

_*{:\;1'~

PoWH S\Olll ' ~

' *, ..... ~. .,

Dt*~MIC

. .: E c 1*i:l:1  ;

~'

H~co~

  • ~

\b * 'JE.N'T\J~\ * * @

~

O'-'iT 9. to *u llUA :I.:

... ' ~l6C:*mut

,- CAGI * ,;.:: ~*

      • ;* 1$

~s

II CLIV. I~ Ill 111.\L~
  • ~ *.. ::*: *-*r HllP ..... 110-~.
  • ~

ni:ror ~~ nnor

~~ "" ...

    • 11* ~*~ ***

WAftl

.. ll&IU *~

. . IUD LI ~ ~

L\b . ' / / ~

I

' \~~) 1~ \"'\ \ l () \~C..~ t q:si. C.cw:o. -z..;~s ~I  ?~{:.

~,

~ sc\C>

~

~;*, *. -

- . t-S/

2 * **1 .J *~:.

a ,:"2.

,.,  !:.t) ,-:_(,' '

l~

';..,*~ (\('\". ~.-:, "t -* *;{,eeo ~-~)a sa1 2c4 ~'-t' *""' 0.4f. / !1S 40.

,3

' ... /:.l.

r,*-=.:*

.. ',' ,\

'?.~ i\ ')'

\\i \ l. (: \ \i.. .t.. lSt, .cea . --. ':-,' ~ \1l 'l~.4 ~ 0 %*.o n.~

~~-"

4 **l C>.~.. ~-

' \(.)1 .!\ 10 \c.;~ 1. .. ~""L l'-Poa -::.~1 a -*

QA ,~,

~1-<:.  % / o~S '!1 ~ 3!>.1

>./

I/ s

  • - -to 5 ~ '=)- \

~\ ."!, q-:.....1. ~ '::-1:. ~  ?.1~ ~,

"'. I\

', -01;. - 't ~00 'if&

-  ?.4.\ ./*O G '

si.tt.' , .~* ?~~ 4ct.\

4*

i \ 1. .tt.: *' .,_~ 3o'tta \ L 1'll t.= .1~=--

- llB ~<:)~ .~":a.,

-l  % ,

. -~, ,,,_ 5~'" .,C) e:,, % \ ~ e; ?e.'L 3\:3 8 1<:4 .t~

-I

-s.4. ,,

'ZR.~

\b.~

\.~

\.b

,, \*. '

1.~'S.

1.$6 ---!sta*~*e,_ 5~~

~ ~~b SS'\ 1..\\ A\' ~/ ~  !._.c

!o.~

0

.~

II

- " . -~ --- - - . l 2 ~ '

3 .

4 .. *

\I I

11,

. **-*'~

. ~ , .

  • t-.: .... .

... C'*l.

  • .-** ~.-
  • ,*_ /:. '.L ...
"
N:.,; . *:e ... *~

. .. ,.* ....\ ._'

    • o *** *****"'* ~
  • £-::::~? !.".t.1 r-u:.t***- co. pea;-:-1.:mo. ORCCON I'Z.OC::,. HO
  • &-*11 1 .*... *t.,*H*&..*.

12*:~* \~ .... \41. C\/D"=>

' .. r..1 ~&.lfOh*

G.E. l'.l\f'E~.

. . * . * ~Ul~\.)-C, CC\\t."-=N\'l~.J\LlH ~\)\~'~

\9\ \':.°5 Clllf 0111111 *O

"!>~~

,,.,,..... *u** ".

T-"l..1aA~5-l.

..<~..... 1:::-. f.: ,**. *~"'"' GP*.

          • .",**". I. , "'1 *~1. I ........ Hll *OtOll I08

.. I .... . ..

u*;

I I ,;_ '

om:llJUIPI~

\"'l. ****

u~

lllC1IO*

\~-

10 llli Plfl .....

~l~ \a\~

ID ~~ Ci ***

* e ****

C.U~"t~EQ.~

  • 811 G11A11
  • GIY11 ""*

~\../L~\

IATI

~

.t,... (,:')

      • *** 4****\. .,,.,,
  • . ~ttt"i\~*~"n~+:;:~ . \ 1.

lflP .Hif DIA;

l. !\__-

H ...... "'"~*

\\*"ht * ~t.~

~~":" ~ '~"' *.

'i.l'"*.C.*I : l.".\

C.UQMI. We.>* ..(;; ;c)l,. .

...""'!I ~ 1"*

  • llll*--01~ .... . *

""'". *"*"'~ *\.\,,. ' "*~ ~*.

. ~*

'~ .~: *. - ' .. ~.- ., .

.. *,,ra* - ... .

D*~CliAt:CI:

~:. Sl.l:tl:>M *

. .i"* tOtaL

  • CAPACITY POWll

~

~;\'l\~

a*' 10 r**H .*u*

  • lfll 0

.. **~ .ra.1;. MHalC

~I* !.: I~ 1tl&c:11m,"

C'N"T \fo *'1£.N't\JQ..\. @

\-\~CO~

IAGI

..... *-=~ ** "'lL . . .

.. * ' l

":i:._:51 ri:t -OF

.>or--. I WAU.:

~-*

P-:.:-~ unot WAll8 new.~

i*

,. ~!**51~ *****

wan1 llAll

~~

!\'

~

4': ~* ~*

~*~~

1.,\ ':a . f;,~. ~*.. c ~1!.

I l ...

1.C.;,- .... *- 4~., ~ , ... '

.. .\ *::, C:.-\ \ 4crr  % ~S.\

.. iO'.J ~:l."1 l\r_'(.$) ~l.~ . 0 ,, 4'Z.1

,-\_ --: -i::;-

'- .~

l"-'""'.. . I' A., ....

., -f ..,, 'l........ . ,, C.1'- ~ . -

,_.o~~ l-ei>. Ir. .,

~,, J ll'J' ~ ~~  ?.lb 1.b~

=-i-- .

1**,*'* ~*

I

. -. \1..~. \ ": <<... .'., 0.:. i.' .': ':: .') ~b<::.:1 ii 11.

l\ ~'-' *'

I

  • r..

...:.*~*w

. <:~4 .\-,(, 11$  % / '!.l.~ 1.1..5

~

..r I .. ,.. , - \~;L' '1~ 1~l.l\* .::~ ~,,*~ I.

\.\ ...-;1. ~ .,.......

(J * \. i:.9l * -* ~\.)c ~1.l 11.S % %?. .. \ ~lli 'l\:"\

    • . p... ") ~~f I , --* . / / :.l:'\ 1.\- .4-

..I

).

I ~~ -*

.\ ,1;"',:j -: C:) ?'~

~.

,t)

, .. .I

' I

  • I I ,I.

I' I

'~

      • ~ . ' .* ' ., i '

I

,*,; .J ' , ........ \ '-.:,,; .I

... ,',": \ *

. ~-- .... ~ ....

*.~** ::* 1:1rJGH~M Pt.iuP co~

II.CH* Pll*P lllf c.:.~.;lltc .. ,. * *' IP* I. O. MCAO 0 P ** IH. ..... I u~ o~~ :: 1- 111 aaca . rut *o*o*

T-'?.1041.5- ~

IOI

&SllHLT

. .* , 1 ,_i!t:\. 10 111 ~<::l:l \.-\~ . C.U~"'t<..~£Q.~.

'.. r ',:

111c1111u "" *. - 1ucrio* "" * ** *. lfP. * %1 HllHH

. \"l,. . II \~ * . *:.*. t * ~~ OY.1. ~\.ILl\c...

    • ~*

I "

.. * -c.\

2 '

.. *C,\

_......_..........___--ii---~*-------~. . . .-t*--+---~-----~-----'-----*l---...;.*~*-----1----1------f...--~f----+---~*1-----+------+-----tr--

_.,___.....,_____,.....__._.-,---1----***---1._--1~-.- .J.---1----+*------1 ...;...-+---+-~-1----1----1--1----t-----t"---i--

-J.~---1----1---~l--*~l,__.._____l--~1----11--~--.J.-----1------1--**-----1-----i1-----+-----t----il----+----t-------t~---.---r----<

_.__ _....._____.Lo-_,__..__..........- A . _ - - " - - - - *- - --*-**-*

  • . a.::1**'-.* .,.
  • r. o. *HD * * ** '"* ***GI u11111LY I .,".I *~
-iL_o.....:....*"'--~... ;;.._a.;;.;..;.;..._;..;...;....__-+--+---:____....,__1~-*....-n._.~ n. ** ~<=--~---==~

I 11c ..ca ~*n *otH ..

.*. .~P_.......~...u-....;;~:::.:'t.;..;~~;;.:£::;.;:~==~:.:*:.-__,-..,*~~-----

  • .....-*.;.**;...--..**&...;.;....._...&.__..._.,_.- t - - - - t 1 - - - - t DllCllllOI "fC 1un*.o* " . * * ** . arr. e "' 8 ... , e 1u, ' nar11 n oat' en_***.. ** * * . :* Xl..
  • ID * \~  : ID ~~ Clt\i .;; eat\, ~"\./L"C', ~-q. <:,.')
  • -r. ~ ........ :.

,~ f '. ' *'

.~'

J. *- ... ..

ir

,....' . ~ .. \~ ',-~. b *.~ C:.

I . I * *

'\t. ;_ \r.il ~ '\: "1. .\

  • "\7 -* * *

-~* ..aJ...;...1--'--+-----1r------t-~-**-\--\~~-:,_.~'-'-~-..-""-*~-*~-'~-t'--N__P~*~'~-(__~-t-**c_,_'_'_'_i+~---~-~-~+~-u_u_*_~-t-u-*_~_,-1--___c+--'~-~-~-c1-'1'--1_...*~~*~~-~-P~'~~~-*~--~--o1-~-4_,..._~_Ei_~_~-1~

.~ -6.J.:: c\~tL. ,~S . \.(:. )~9J 11 ~!\C(.~ ~'2S * ~t.() \l.b '?ft.\  % % !1.\ 'Sl.~ r.

    • ..... ,.S 4ot ,3.S \~C.. , , ~ 1.1 sh.ca ~1.c, S\S *le.. 'Zb.4 [% i~ iio ltS ,,
  • .. I\.~ t\a l 1! S ,.~ '7:>.4 1.1 t:Aeo ~l~ ~\S *l~ 2"*"-' % :% ~E. 9 !l .C. 1

. .. " '\~ ~\ \;..S *~ .. t"~"e: i ~' w Q, *\:>.::,, .~~ >i> *' i--.n- e .>~ ..'-" I q_ i~c.C)

---a.-.---i.----4-----1~---"----1-~+-----

A. ~. \_JY.A .£.:>:*:..*.._.~-..._,:;~~<1-=C:==-~~:l-.._..fl\.~Qr:"*~...='.b~-~.---1---t


.-_-:.... '..~--

.. -.~--~* ~ ~ ,.,,J

____________. . . ,__.i-..A.--------.._--_,,____ . . . '

I.

~

~-

... :* ;~~/ :~\_:.;  ;*.

~ .....

I

~ *,~ .

. .; ~

.: ~,.........

... '* . *.* f .;* *..* ; . * *

  • l ...*

l . . ... ""'!

c~{ -1

. .. .  ; f

. . *. I *

. *~

I.*

.. ~-*1.i .. .......

1***~

~~-

4

  • _!:
/' _,.-
.. :~:* ~--*t i .. ... . **.
I ....
i. : *
  • ~ j' ' *:*~ 'j~J )* ""  ; ....~ ..

. I:::..!

  • . j .. *:: *

-~

.'*** . ~ *. :  ;

,!tii::1, :u 'f "' ' ":'

.. **. .. . .~ ... ' ',

J ~ **

{ __

-:'- ~

, ... ** 1. * * ** .....*.

I

. ~

.'*,')

... .'(

\ ... ...... . .

  • i:. ' . '* ** I;
  • .. ,r

. -.1J* __.:.;'"':;:t.~~...:.~-CP-~---~-P_"""-/9_.._ _...._*0~:~ .~~~

Ef--<:T .!,. Wl"t!!I.....'!:. C.t>..'ilCT...."T\C.-W "tE'ii{ ... ;. : ~

~£.E ~ \ - 1. S:o-C. * \>A.,A.. . .... ,

A4 t

. ~** ,

~

.....** *'~\. .. . ~

\'t. \i\

{?.£'-'ERA\. E\.~lRlC..* 'ca ~l:C.D c."~~ PUMP cbl.a*J.Of\I Wt.N..-i H E.bt°.-A.>W <U.

.CHuACllRISllC CURVE SHEET Blt.fGHAM PUMP Co

DIA. IMPSLUll

..l.. ,, * ......

lJu~\> c.,-, \t:..~. ~. M'l. ~tc\I"' ~800 N. W. FRONT AVS.

D*A CY* *o. \ . ' --

N .......... OUlltCD

\'t \ 1. C"{J~ * \

ll*Rll*NC*

3Slb R.P.M*

CUltftNO.

'\r.t-~ .~'l. r

~""~  :. *

\.le). *

-rro6z.c;; *..oRTu'ND

'., . 9AEGON . _Tl.l.. . .. 'Lb qq'7_

"l"-. ** ~

    • .,, ~. .

o'

  • =* *:,-  ;.. *"'.

.. .:* -~-. "_._.

t ....

Reference* 11 ......

. \ *.~ ~ ' .. __,_: ... ,.

. . ,* ~

, .. * * : .r' .~.* *

... ;'.' GENE;;.637..,042~J 193 -~-Dresden Nticlear Power Station ......

. * ' .*--ijhits:-2**and3~Co~tilinni~nt Analy.se~ ofthe:PBA;;LOCA:

\ .$. - ** * * * ** *- * ' -  : - ** * ' * **

. . ...** to ".Update. the Design 'Basis for .tjle *-LPCI/Containment

...,..* . *~ *: '-,coolmg System*Februai-y J994.' * "*'-..** :.. * '"* .. * * ~-- -*.*:. ;-.*

- .. . ' . -'.* ' . _.... ~- .~*.

/; ***'. -* ~ *...:*

)- ....

  • -~ *,, .. . .
  • ~ ,...

~:--

~: ..

.~

. ,* ~

, __*-.  ;. - .. :* ~

".i

~

. 'i"

_*_ ~ ...... -

..... :.: . -*-*-1:* .* ...

      • :. *'! *~**
~ *-

-~* .. -...~-,,;:, -.. .-..:"

.. ~ ..

...... : ~ ., -."'-* .. -'

.J"*'

_.,.* .. ' .... * .~.

  • '* *"\;

. .: ~"' "=*-'...:.: .. -**. ... ~:. *. :

  • -Ji*~~*:. ~ .

.*, : -i.""-~*: -_:)- _*. ~--. ...:*

  • 1

.1..

- :*-.r. <.- __ .....-... -

-~.

. .;.~ ... ._: .. ~-" .. ~ ..,, .

- ---** ~- .* *~ *.

. -~ , ",';'

-~. . .....

~ :...,

    • GE Nuclear Energy GGllll'fll~ ~

17S CillnlArA"a!IMI &onJ'1Ut c.t 9SUS February 28, 1994 ..

I Ms. Sharon L. Eldridge

. Commonwealth Edison Co. .

Dresden Nuclear Power Station:

Rural Route No. l

}donis, IL 60450 I I

Dear Ms. Eldridge

  • I-

. I I

Subject:

.Containment Ana!lyses to Update~ Basis for the Dresden LPCJ/Containment Cooling System-!Transmittal_of Pinal Report GENE-<).37-042-1193*.

(Budgetary .Estimate No. 295-1EDCP-EB4-93) /

I

References:

__ l) 2)

. . CECo Pllichase

_T. L.

I,

~man Letter to Order 314715 YY-68.

Update ~e B~ of the Dresden LPCI/Containment Cooling -

  • System I)resden Nuclear Power Station, Units 2 and 3, Budgetary S. L. Eldridge, *eontainment Analyses to . *
  • EstimatelN°o. 295-1EDCP-EB4-93/ October 27, 1993. : . "

'This letter provides the finAl report GENE-637-04~1193. Your comments on the draft report. .

  • given 2/9/94 were incorporated ih the final report. Per References 1 and 2, GENE-63741~1193 .:.
  • documents the results of contaim'nent analysis of the DBA-LOCA to support a CECo qpdate of the basis ofthe IJ>CJ/CoJJtaimnePt Cooling System for Dresden Units :i. and 3. * **

This report *satisfies the requirem~ of Deliverable No. 2 of the Budgetary Estimate (Reference 2). . I , ,

I .

The results of the GENE analysJ docum~ in GENE-637--042,;.1193. are verified, with

_documentation and evidence ofv~cation contained in DRF T23-o0717.

' Please contact me if you have any questions on the attached report.

, I

- .I

. ~ . J"

' *~

  • .* *,' /**:*  :- ~..... ~ . '. -

-~I* ,. . *' . *

  • :~ ' \ J
  • Sincerely,

.-44(~

S.MintZ Engineering & Licensing Consulting .Services. Projects I*

MIC 469, (408) 925-1791 . I Fax. No. (408) 925-1674 Attachment cc K. Ramsden (CECo) I ll R Willems J. E. Torbeck . '

I i

I /

I

  • 1 I

I I

I I

I

  • ..** I.

.I I .

I

. I "I .

.. . .- *::,. ~. * . ;**~-~~  :**; .'"':"- ~_:*~_,,,- . ~)

'.*I

  • .o * * * * *, * * ~- *.:..T* .*..r. -:* ~ .

- .: ... ~ < :*:. -_.

-~-  :*.

'*" " ~ '