ML18051A771

From kanterella
Revision as of 12:29, 14 December 2018 by StriderTol (talk | contribs) (Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Discusses Util Understanding of 10CFR50.48 & App R to 10CFR50.NRC Requested to Review Encl Logic Diagrams & Provide Comments on Completeness & Accuracy
ML18051A771
Person / Time
Site: Palisades Entergy icon.png
Issue date: 01/18/1984
From: VANDEWALLE D J
CONSUMERS ENERGY CO. (FORMERLY CONSUMERS POWER CO.)
To: CRUTCHFIELD D
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
NUDOCS 8401250249
Download: ML18051A771 (11)
v • d • e


Text

.. consumers . Power company General Offices: 1945 West Parnall Road, Jackson, Ml 49201 * {517) 768-0550 January 18, 1984 Dennis M Crutchfield, Chief Operating Reactor Branch No 5 Nuclear Reactor Regulation US Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 DOCKET 50-255 -LICENSE DPR-20 -* PALISADES PLANT -FIRE PROTECTION

-UNDERSTANDING 10 CFR 50.48 AND APPENDIX R TO 10 CFR 50 10 CFR 50.48 provides the schedular requirements for implementing the technical requirements of Appendix R to 10 CFR 50. Consumers Power Company was advised by an NRC letter dated November 24, 1980 that Sections III.G, III.J, III.L and III.O of Appendix R were requirements for the Palisades Plant and that the remaining Sections of Appendix R were adequately fulfilled by the closure of open items resulting from the "Pre-Appendix R" review of the Palisades Plant against the guidelines of Standard Review Plan 9.5.1 "Fire Protection" dated May 1, 1976. (The "Pre-Appendix R" review is summarized by References 1 through 6.) Historically, Consumers Power Company has worked to provide, in a timely manner, the Palisades Plant with fire protection features which met or ed the guidelines provided in Standard Review Plan 9.5.1 as well as our understanding of Appendix R requirements.

Given the recent NRC findings of non-compliance with Appendix R at several nuclear power plants, Consumers Power Company initiated a self-audit program to evaluate and resolve, as necessary, differences from Appendix R ments. The charter of this self-audit program is to accomplish the following:

0 0 0 0 Organize a review committee consisting of Plant and General Office personnel Develop a common and comprehensive understanding of the Appendix R requirements Review existing commitments against Appendix R requirements Evaluate whether existing commitments are comprehensive (given new understanding of Appendix R)

--.-PDR ADOCK 05000255 ! F PDR DMCrutchfield, Chief Palisades Plant FIRE PROTECTION January 18, 1984 2 0 Organize documentation packages to substantiate compliance with Appendix R 0 0 Recommend corrective action(s), as necessary Report the results of the self-audit to the NRC. The report shall summarize the review process and describe any differences from Appendix R requirements and the subsequent resolution The results of the self-audit will be submitted by April 2, 1984. The results will fully address the guidance (definitions) provided in Generic Letter 83-33, October 19, 1983. Consumers Power Company has made a concentrated effort to organize the requirements of Appendix R and subsequent NRC Staff guidance into the logic diagrams attached.

The logic diagrams reflect our current understanding of 10 ' CFR 50.48 and Appendix R requirements.

It is requested that the NRC Staff provide a formal review of the logic diagrams and provide comments as to the completeness and accuracy. (Comments were informally solicited from various NRC Staff members and considered prior to this submittal.)

Director, Nuclear Licensing CC Administrator, Region III, USNRC NRC Resident Inspector

-Palisades Attachments OC0184-0004A-NL02 DMCrutchf ield, Chief Palisades Plant FIRE PROTECTION January 18, 1984 REFERENCES 3 1. NRC, Docket 50-255, May 11, 1976, Request to Initiate review of Palisades Plant Against Standard Review Plan 9.5.1 dated May 1, 1976 2. Consumers Power Company, Docket 50-255, March 31, 1977 "Fire Protection Program Evaluation" 3. Consumers Power Company, Docket 50-255, September 29, 1977, "Fire Protection

-Containment" 4. NRC, Docket 50-255, September 1, 1978, "Fire Protection Safety Evaluation Report" 5. NRC, Docket 50-255, March 19, 1980, "Supplement 1 to September 1, 1978 Fire Protection Safety Evaluation Report" 6. NRC, Docket 50-255, February 10, 1981, "Supplement 2 to September 1, 1978 Fire Protection Safety Evaluation Report" OC0184-0004A-NL02

    • OC0184-0004B-NL01 ATTACHMENT Consumers Power Company Palisades Plant -Docket 50-255 LOGIC DIAGRAMS DEPICTING CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY'S UNDERSTANDING OF 10 CFR 50.48 AND APPENDIX R TO 10 CFR 50 January 18, 1984 7 Pages SYMBOL MEANING EXAMPLE TEXT ONL-OIFFERENCE NOTIFICATION LEVEL 5-NOTIFY NRC OF SIGNIFICANT DIFFERENCES g HEADER 1-NOTIFY NRC. NRC APPROVAL REQUIRED PRIOR TO IMPLEMENTATION 2-LATER 3-LATER 4-LATER 0¥6 AT I ON. NA-NOT APPLICABLE

OUTPUT 0 INPUT OUTPUT IW'UT INPUT OUTPUT INPUT INPUT OUTPUT CONDITIONAL}

?1 INPUT INPUT

' 1 * ' ' ' ' , ____ ... COMMON E REQUIREMENT STATEMENT OR CONOITIOO.

THE OUTPUT IS ASSUMED TO BE 'Ft!ILSE' UNTIL THE INPUT IS DETERMINED TO BE 'TRUE'. IF NO INPUT EXISTS THE STATEMENT OR CONDITION HUST BE EVALUTED AND A DETERMINATION HADE AS TO

  • TR\JE' OR 1 FALSE'. THE DIFFERENCE NOTIFICATION LEVEL MAY BE USE TO IMPLEMENT ALTERNATE MEASURES LOGIC SYMBOL -ANO GATE. THE OUTPUT IS 'TRUE' IF ANO ONl.Y IF ALL INPUTS ARE 'TRUE'. THE OUTPUT IS 'FALSE' IF ANY INPUT 15 'FALSE', LOGIC SYMBOL-OR GATE. THE OUTPUT IS ' TRUE' IF ANY INPUT IS 1 TRUE"
  • THE OUTPUT IS FALSE IF NO INPUT JS 'TRUE', LOGIC SYMBOL* INHIBIT GATE. THE OUTPUT IS 'TRUE' IF ANO ONLY IF THE INPUT IS ' TRUE' AND THE CONDITIONAL INPUT IS 'TRUE' -THE OUTPUT IS *FALSE' IF EITHER THE INPUT OR CONDITIONAL INPUT IS 'FALSE'. SHORT _HAND NOTATION FOR IIII WHERE A. B. C. D, AND E REPRESENT ANY LOG IC SYMBOL OR STATEMENT OUTPUT=FALSE OUTPUT= TRUE 00 JNPUT=UNVERIFIEO COIIDITION

'C' EOUIPMENT 15 FREE Of WATER OAHAGE FROM THE 0 ISCHARGE OF FIRE FIGHTING HOSES LESS THAN 4' IN D IAHETER INPUT=TRUE ALL FIRE FIGHTING HOSES ARE 5' IN DIAMETER EQUIPMENT IS SHIELDED FROM DIRECT OR INDIRECT SPRAY FROM THE DISCHARGE OF ALL FIRE FIGHTING HOSES HOTOR CONTROL SWITCH } SET TO 'ON' POSITION THE MOTOR HAS A FUNCTIONAL ELECTR lCAL POWER SUPPLY ANO CABLING SYSTEH MOTOR CONTROL SWITCH SET TO 'ON' } POSITION !FOR A GIVEN PIECE OF EOUIPHENTI THE MOTOR HAS A FUNCTIONAL ELECTRICAL POWER SUPPLY ANO CABLING SYSTEM NOTE1 THERE EXISTS A COHHON REQUIREMENT TO START ANY GIVEN MOTOR. STARTING EQUIPMENT A DOES NOT IMPLY THAT EQUIPMENT B, C, OR 0 lS STARTED, FURTHER. A DISFUNCT IONAL CABLING SYSTEM FOR EQUIPMENT A DOES NOT IMPLY A DISFUNCTIONAL CABLING SYSTEM FOR EQUIPMENT B, C, DR D. ----

I REFERENCE DRAWINGS DFI 122883 J I I H G DESCRIPTION D'!. J, L. STERRETT 10-10-83 c*. L. 'II, BAUER 12-12-83 APP, N. L. HASKELL 12*28*83 ORIGINAL ISSUE DLF LWB APP.0.J.VANDEVALLE 12-28-BJ 0£SCRIPTION BY APP. F E D PRC APER .. JURE CARD Also Available Un Aperture Card CONSUMERS POWER CO NUCLEAR P')WER PLANT LICENSING RC:QU IREMENTS AND DESIGN CRITERIA LEGEND JACKSON, MICHIGAN [40, 100lSK12Hl83.

002 c NONE LRflC-001-GEN 8 I A REV. 0 6 5 4 3 2 8401250249-0\

I I I I , CWC.NO. I .. l l. PRIOR TO IMPLEMENTATION OF APPENDIX R THE NRC STAFF IDENTIFIED THE APPENDIX R TO RESOLVE OPEN NRC T THE FACILITY SATISFIES THE PROVISIONS OF BRANCH TECHNICAL POSTION BTP APCSB Cl.5-1 OR NRC STAFF O
n ACCEPTANCE BEFORE AUUUST Jq76. '.Also Available Hll CFR 5!11.46 THE STAFF IDENTIFIED NO 'BACKFIT' REQUIREMENT FOR EITHER PALISADES 10 CFR 51!J.4B, FIRE PROTECTION TECHNICAL OR BIG ROCK POINT WITH REGARDS Card REDUIREMENTS ARE SATISFIED

<SCHEOULAR TO APPENDIX R SECTIONS III.A. '.Aperture REDUIREMENTS ADDRESSED, SHEET 6l 111.S.IlLC,lll.0,III.E, 111.F,JU.H,Ill.l,Jll.K, AUTHOR. CPCO N "'" 40 LETTERS! REF1 INTl=RPR 6 BRP, 11/24/80, ENCLOSURE 2 PAL, 11/24/80, ENCLOSURE 2 I FIRE PROTECTION PLAN 10 CFR 50, APPENDIX A GENERAL DESIGN CRITERION 3 EACH OPERATING PLANT SHALL HAVE A FIRE PROTECTION PLAN THAT SATISFIES 10 CFR CRITERION 3-FIRE PROTECTION.

50 APPENDIX A. CRITERION

3. THIS PLAN STRUCTURES, SYSTEMS, ANO COMPONENTS SHALL DESCRIBE THE FOUOWING1 IMPORTANT TO SAFETY SHALL BE OESIGNEO 1. THE OVERALL FIRE PROTECTION PROGRAM FOR AND LOCATED TO MINIMIZE, CONSISTENT THE FACILJTY WITH OTHER SAFETY REOUIAEMENTS, THE PROBABILITY AND EFFECT OF FIRES AND 2. IDENTIFY THE VARIOUS POSITIONS WITHIN EXPLOSIONS.

NONCOMBUSTIBLE AND HEAT THE LICENCEES ORGANIZATION THAT ARE RESISTANT MATERIALS SHALL BE USED RESPONSIBLE FOR THE PROGRAM WHEREVER PRACTICAL THROUGHOUT THE UNIT, 3. STATE THE AUTHORITIES THAT ARE PARTICULAR1.

Y IN LOCATIONS SUCH AS THE DELEGATED TO EACH OF THESE POSITIONS TO CONTAINMENT ANO CONTROL ROOM. FIRE IMPLEMENT THOSE RESPONSIBILITIES DETECTION ANO FIGHTING SYSTEMS OF 5 4. OUTLINE THE PLANS FOR FIRE PROTECTION, APPROPRIATE CAPACITY ANO CAPABILITY FIRE DETECTION AND SUPPRESSION SHALL BE PROVIDED AND DESIGNED TO CAPABILJTY, ANO LIMITATION OF FIRE MINIMIZE THE ADVERSE EFFECTS OF FIRES DAMAGE ON STRUCTURES, SYSTEMS. ANO COMPONENTS

5. DESCRIBE SPECIFIC FEATURES NECESSARY TO IM?ORTANT TO SAFETY. FIREFIGHTING SYSTEMS SHALL BE DESIGNED TO ASSURE THAT IMPLEMENT t1H4J SUCH AS1 THEIR RUPTURE OR INADVERTENT OPERATION A. ADMINISTRATIVE CONTROLS DOES NOT SIGNIFICANTLY IMPAIR THE SAFETY .. PERSONNEL REQUIREMENTS FOR FIRE CAPABlLITY Of THESE STRUCTURES, SYSTEMS, PREVENTION AND COMPONENTS.
c. MANUAL FIRE SUPPRESSION ACTIVITIES
o. AUTOMATIC ANO MANUAL Y OPERATED FIRE A TO rn CFR 50. 10 CFR DETECTION AND SUPPRESSION SYSTEMS E. THE MEANS TO LIMIT FIRE DAMAGE TO STRUCTURES.

SYSTEMS. OR COMPONENTS SO THAT THE CAPABILITY TO SAFELY SHUT DOWN THE PLANT IS ENSURED. AUTHOR1 NRC REF: 121 CFR 513.48 IAJ

} OPERATE PRIOR TO LICENSED TO OPERATE JANUARY I. 1q7q AFTER JANUARY 1. 1q7q 4 ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA p R c DETAILS OF ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA FOR PLANTS LICENSED TO OPERATE AFTER JANUARY I, 197q ARE PROV{OEO ELSEWHERE ANO CLflRENTL Y ARE NOT REFLECTED IN THIS DRAWING E AUTHOR1 CPCO I DNI ,r ATER A p E R T u R REF: INTERPRETATION 113 CFR 50.48 c A R D NRC "STAFF ACCEPTANCE' MAY BE USEC IN } STOP PLACE OF A PARTICULAR SECTION OF APPENDIX R EXCEPT FOR THE FOLLOWING SECTIONS1 Jll.G. 111.J, III.L. ANO 111.0 . SEE NOTE 1 3 OR I I I APPENDIX R SECTION IU.G. APPENDIX R SECTION 111.J, APPENDIX R SECTION 111.0, NRC STAFF ACCEPTANCE, NRC STAFF ACCEPTANCE BEFORE MEET 10 CFR 513, APPENDIX R FlRE PROTECTION OF EMERGENCY LIGHTING OIL COLLECTION SYSTEM FOR FACILITY SATISFIES PROVISIONS AUGUST 1976 THE FOLLOWING APPENDIX R REQUIREMENTS MUST BE MET SC.FE SHUTDOWN CAPABILITY REACTOR COOLANT PUMP OF BRANCH TECHNICAL POSITION ANO EMERGENCY LIGHTING UNITS WJTH AT LEAST BTP APCSB <J.5-1 FIRE PROTECTION FEATURES WERE ACCEPTED SECTION llJ -SPECIFIC REOUTREMENTS APPENDIX R SECTION 111.L, AN 8-HOUR BATTERY POWER SUPPLY SHALL BE THE REACTOR COOLANT PUMP SHALL BE BY THE STAFF IN COMPREHENSIVE FIRE ALTERNATIVE ANO DEDICATED PROVIDED IN ALL AREAS NEEDED FOR EQUIPPED WITH AN OIL COLLECTION SYSTEM THE FIRE PROTECTION FEATURES PROPOSED PROTECTION SAFTY EVALUATION REPORTS Ill.A -WATER SUPPLIES FOR FIRE SUPPRESSION SYSTEMS SHJTDOWN CAPABILITY OPERATION OF SAFE SHUTDOWN EQUIPMENT IF THE CONTAINMENT JS NOT INERTEO DURING OR IMPLEMENTED BY THE LICENSEE HAVE ISSUED BEFORE APPENDIX IAJ TO BRANCH UI.B -SECTIONAL ISOLATION VALVES ANO IN ACCESS ANO EGRESS ROUTES THERETO. NORMAL OPERATION.

THE OIL COLLECTION BEEN ACCEPTED BY THE NRC STAFF AS TECHNICAL POSITION BTP APCSB 9.5-1 WAS THE TECHNICAL REQUIREMENTS SYSTEM SHALL BE DESIGNED.

ENGINEERED, SATISFYING THE PROVISIONS OF APPENOIX PUBLISHED IN AUGUST 1Ci76 111.C -HYDRANT ISOLATION VALVES OF SECTION 111.G ANO AUTHOR; NRC ANO INSTALLED THAT* FAILURE WILL NOT (Al TO BRANCH TECHNICAL POSITION BTP A?CSB IU.O -MANUAL FIRE SUPPRESSION 111.L ARE SATISFIED REF1 APPENDIX A.SECTION llI.J LEAD TO FIRE DURING NORMAL OR DESIGN 'J.5-1 REFLECTED IN STAFF FIRE AUTHOR1 NRC 111.E -HYDROSTATIC HOSE TESTS BASIS ACCIDENT CONDITIONS ANO THAT PROTECTION SAFETY EVALUATION REPORTS REF1 113 CFR 50.48 !Bl 111.F -AUTOMATIC FIRE DETECTION AUTHOR: CPCO THERE IS REASONABLE ASSURANCE THAT THE ISSUED PRIOR TO THE EFFECTIVE OATE OF IU.G -AS SHOWN LROC-002-GEN REF: NONE SYSTEM WILL WITHSTAND THE SAFE SHUTDOWN THIS RULE <EFFECTIVE DATE1 FEBRUARY 17. JCJ811 III.H -FIRE BRIGADE EARTHQUAKE tSEE REGULATORY GUIDE 1.2'1 45 FR 766132. 11/lCi/801 III.I -FIRE BRIGADE TRAINING LROC-21132-GEN SH 2 PARAGRAPH C.21 AUTHOR:NRC 111.J -AS SHOWN LROC-2102-GEN SH 2 SUCH COLLECTION SYSTEM SHALL BE CAPABLE REF1 113 CFR 521.48 fBI 111.K -ADMINISTRATIVE CONTROLS OF COLLECTING LUBE OIL FROM ALL <E-61 POTENTIAL PRESSURIZED ANO UNPRESSURIZED III.L -AS SHOWN LROC-002-GEN LEAKAGE SITES IN THE REACTOR COOLANT Ul.M -FIRE BARRIER CABLE PENETRATION SEAL QUALIFICATION 2 PUMP LUBE OIL SYSTEMS. LEAKAGE SHALL BE Ill.N -FIRE ODORS COLLECTED AND ORAINEO TO A VENTED m.o -AS SHOWN LROC-002-GEN CLOSED CONTAINER THAT CAN HOLD THE AUTHOR: NRC ENTIRE LUBE OIL SYSTEM INVENTORY, A FLAME ARRESTER IS REQUIRED IN THE VENT REF1 113 CFR 50.48 !Bl IF THE FLASH POINT CHARACTERISTICS OF THE OIL PRESENT THE HAZARD OF FIRE FLASH BACK. LEAKAGE POINTS TO BE PROTECTED SHALL INCLUDE LIFT PUMP ANO PIPING. OVERFLOW LINES, LUBE OIL COOLER, OIL FILL ANO DRAIN LINES AND PLUGS, FLANGED CONNECT IONS ON OIL LINES, ANO LUBE OIL RESERVOIRS WHERE SUCH FEATURES EXIST ON THE REACTOR COOLANT PUMPS. THE ORAJN LINE SHALL BE LARGE ENOUGH TO THE LARGEST POTENTIAL OIL LEAK. AUTHOR: NRC REF1 APPENDIX R.SECTION 111.0 I I OAT( NUCLEAR FOWER PLANT -J.L.

LICENSING RoOU!REMENTS I I L.W.BAUER 12-12-83 CONSUMERS POWER co ANO DESIGt I CRITERIA ., t I 10 CFR 50.48 ANO APPENOIX R APP.N.L. HASKELL 12-28-63 FIRE PR.JTECTION 0 l"za...I ORIGINAL ISSUE OLF LWB Cl'1SION*"'" JACKSON, MICHIGAN SCALE ORAW!NQNO.

I REV.

12-28-83 NONE I OAAWINt;NO.

REFERENCE DRAWINGS RE1.l[lt.T( DESCRIPTION I BY 1>DP. RE1. DArEI DESCRIPTION BY APP. {40,l00lSK121083.007

"' I LRDC-002-GEN 0 ) RSZl310584 J, H G F E D c B A 8401250249--0Z.-

PRC APERTURE CARD SAFETY GOAL1 HOT SHUTDOWN/STANDBY THE CAPABILITY SHALL ALWAYS EXIST TO ACHIEVE Al'() MAINTAIN HOT SHUTDOWN/

STANDBY UNTIL SUCH TIME AS THE CAPABILITY EXISTS TO ACHIEVE ANO MAINTAIN COLD SHUTDOWN CONDITIONS NOTE1 SHUTDOWN CONDITIONS AS SPECIFIED SAFETY GOAL1 SAFE SHUTOOWN DURING THE POSTFIRE SHUTDOWN, THE REACTOR COOLANT SYSTEM PROCESS VARitlBLES SHALL BE MAINTAINED WITHIN THOSE PREDICTED FOR A LOSS OF NORMAL A. C. POWER. ANO THE FISSION PRODUCT BOUNDARY INTEGRITY SHALL NOT BE AFFECTE01 I.E., THERE SHALL BE NO FUEL CLAD OAHAGE, RUPTURE OF ANY PR I MARY COOLANT BOUNDARY OR RUPTURE OF THE CONTAINMENT BOUNDARY RESULTING FROM FIRE DAMAGE SAFETY GOAL* COLO SHUTDOWN THE CAPABILITY SHALL EXIST TO ACHIEVE COLO SHUTDOWN CONDITIONS

'illTHJN 72 HOURS ANO TO MAINTAIN COLD SHUTDOWN CONDIT IONS THEREAFTER NOTE1 SHUTOO'll'N CONDITIONS AS SPECIFIED IN THE STANDARD TECHNICAL SPECIFICATIONS Also Available On Aperture Card IN THE STANDARD TECHNICAL SPECIFICATIONS.

HOT 5HUTOOWN-BWR1 HOT STANOBY-P'ilR.

AUTHOR: NRC ONL1 I VITAL FUNCTIONi INVENTORY CONTROL MAINTAIN THE REACTOR COOLANT LEVEL ABOVE THE TOP OF THE CORE FOR BWR, ANO BE W'ITHIN THE LEVEL INDICATION IN THE PRESSURIZER FOR PWR AUTHOR1 NRC ONL1 I AP NDIX R Ifl.L. I ANO l.L.2 COMMON REQUIREMENT VITAL FUNCTIONi PROCESS MONITORING THE PROCESS MONITORING FUNCTION SHALL BE CAPABLE OF PROVJOINO DIRECT READINGS OF THE PROCESS VAR 1 ABLES NECESSARY TO PERFORM ANO CONTROL TKE REACTIVITY CONTROL. INVENTORY CONTROL ANO HEAT REMOVAL VITAL FUNCTIONS r----------

, l DEFINE FIRE AREAS DEFINE FIRE AREAS DEFINE FIRE AREAS DEFINE FIRE AREAS 1 I ONE TRAIN OF SYSTEMS NECESSARY TO ONE TRAIN OF SYSTEMS NECESSARY TO ONE TRAIN OF SYSTEMS NECESSARY TO ONE TRAIN OF SYSTEMS NECESSARY TO I I ACHIEVE ANO MAINTAIN A GIVEN VITAL ACHIEVE AND MAINTAIN A GIVEN VITAL ACHIEVE ANO MAINTAIN A GIVEN VITAL ACHIEVE ANO MAINTAIN A GIVEN VITAL ] RF APPENDIX R Tlf.Ll<Dl OPERAT INO PROCEDURES PROCEDURES SHALL BE IN EFFECT TO IMPLEMENT THIS CAPABILITY AUTHOR* NFIC REF1 APPENDIX R, 111.L.3 :

NOTE I : ACTIVITIES WHICH ORIGINATE IN f"IRE AREPi I A' ACTIVITIES WHICH ORIGINATE IN FIRE AREA I B' CT IV I TIES 'll'HICH ORIGINATE JN FIRE AREA I c* ACTIVITIES WHICH ORIGINATE JN FIRE AREA I z* : I AUTHOR1 CPCO DM...1 I AUTHOR1 CPCO DNL1 1 AUTHOR: CPCO ONL1 I AUTHOR1 CPCO ONL1 I I I RF INTERPRETATION OF APPENDI A R F IN APR TATION OF APPEND X R R F INTERPRETATION OF APPENDIX R I l __________

.

I & 2 DEFINE SAFE SHUTOO'll'N SYSTEMS-TRAINS I & 2 I & 2 I t. 2 : :

A A

A A

NOTE 2 I GIVEN VITAL FUNCTION IN THE EVENT OF FIRE GIVEN VITAL FUNCTION IN THE EVENT OF FIRE GIVEN VITAL FUNCTION IN THE EVENT OF FIRE GIVEN VITAL FUNCTION IN THE EVENT OF FIRE I I OR FIRE SUPPRESSION ACTIVITIES IN A OR FIRE SUPPRESSION ACTIVITIES IN A OR'FIRE SUPPRESSION ACTIVITIES IN A OR FIRE SUPPRESSION ACTIVITIES IN A I I GIVEN FIRE AREA. GIVEN FJRE AREA. GIVEN FIRE AREA. GIVEN FIRE AREA. I [ AUTHOR1 CPCO AUTHOR! CPCO AUTHOR: CPCO 0 ' I AUTHOR1 CPCO I [ R F INTERPRETATION F APPENDIX A R F* NTERPRETATJON OF APPENOIX R R F INTERPR TATION OF APPENOTX R REF INTERPR TATION OF APPENDIX R I L----------

1 LRDC-002* OEN SH 3 L_----(*SHEET 3 CF-61 MANPOWER HOT SHUTDOWN/

} 5 T ANOBY ONLY THE NUMBER OF OPERATING SHIFT PERSONNEL EXCLUSIVE OF FIRE BRIGADE MEMBERS, REOUIREO TO OPERATE SUCH EQUIPMENT ANO SYSTEMS SHALL BE ON SITE AT ALL TIMES AUTHOR1 NAC ONL1 I RF APPENDIX R III ** 4 COLO SHUTDOWN ONLY NOTES* 1. FIRE AREAS 1 A' Tl-IRU 1 Z' CONSTITUTE A COMPLETE SET OF FIRE AREAS THROUOHOUT THE PLANT. THE NRC STAFF HAS ESTABLISHED THE FOLLOWING DEFINITION OF A FIRE AREA tREFERENCE GENERIC LETTER 83*33. OCTOBER l<t. 1CJ83J 'A FIRE AREA IS DEFINED AS THAT PORTION OF A BUILDING OR PLANT THAT IS SEPARATED FROM OTHER AREAS BY BOUNDARY FIRE BARRIERS NALLS. FLOORS.ANO CEILINGS WITH ANY OPENINGS OR PENETRATIONS PROTECTED VITH SEALS OR CLOSURES HAVING A FIRE RESISTANCE RATING EOUAL TO THAT REQUIRED OF THE BARRIER>.

OPEN STAIRWELLS ANO HATCHWAYS IN CEILINGS ANO FLOORS ARE NOT FIRE AREA BOUNOAR IES. FOR BOUNDARY FIRE BARRIERS, USING \/ALLS. FLOORS, CEILUJOS, DAMPERS, DOORS, ETC. EXISTING PRIOR TO APPENDIX R, THE RATING REQUIRED OF A BOUNDARY FIRE BARRIER IS BASED ON THE GUIDANCE IN APPENDIX A TO BTP ASB CJ. 5-h I.E., THE RATING OF THE BARRIER OR BOUNDARY MUST EXCEED WITH MARGIN THE FIRE LOADING IN THE AREA ANO NEED NOT NECESSARILY BE A 3-HOUR RATED BOUNDARY UNLESS THE FIRE LOADING WARRANTS SUCH A BOUNDARY.

FOR INSTALLATION OF NEV BOUNDARY FIRE BARRIERS PURSUANT TO SECTION 111.G.2.A.

THE FIRE RATING OF SUCH BOUNOARlES MUST BE THREE HOURS. OR AN EXEMPTION HUST BE JUSTIFIED AND REQUESTED.

THE EVALUATIONS BY SOME LICENSEES MADE PRIOR TO APPENDIX R \/ERE BASED ON FIRE ZONES WHICH 00 NOT MEET THE STRICT DEFINITION OF FIRE AREAS CLARIFIED ABOVE. IN SOME CASES, THE SEPARATION OF REDUNDANT TRAINS UNDER CONSIDERATION WITHIN THE 'FIRE ZONE BOUNDARIES' ANO THE SEPARATION BETWEEN FIRE ZONES DOES NOT COMPLY 'll'ITH THE SEPARATION, I.E ** BARRIER OR DISTANCE, REQUIREMENTS OF APPENDIX R. SUCH CONFIGURATIONS NEEO TO BE EVALUATED UNDER THE EXEMPTION PROCESS.'

2. SYSTEMS 1 A' THRU ' Z* CONST ITU TE A COMPLETE SET OF SYSTEMS NECESSARY TO PERFORM A GIVEN VITAL FUNCTION ONE TRAIN IF WHICH IS NOT DAMAGED BY FIRE WHICH ORIGINATES IN A GIVEN FIRE AREA. THERE IS NO CORRELATION BETWEEN SYSTEM 'A' ANO FIRE AREA 'A', *THE SHUTDOWN CAPABILITY FOR A SPECIFIC FIRE AREA HAY BE UNIQUE FOR EACH SUCH AREA, OR IT MAY BE ONE UNIQUE COMBINATION OF SYSTEMS FOR ALL SUCH AREAS. 1 <REFERENCE APPEND IX R TO 10 CFR 50, SECTION 111.L.31 EXAMPLE CHYPDTHET ICALl VITAL FUNCTION1 REACTICITY CONTROL COMPLETE SET OF SYSTEMS1 -CONTROL ROD INSERTION
  • 8' -BORAT ION SYSTEH 6 5 4 3 2 ... CONSUMERS POWER co NUCLEAR POWER PLANT LICENSING REOU IREMENTS AND DESIGN CRITERIA 10 CFR 50. 49 & APPENDIX R AEV. DATE DESCRIPTJON BY DATE DESCRJPTION REFERENCE DRAWINGS BY APP, OF2122883 I I L E G J H F D JACKSON, MICHIGAN [40, i00JSK121093.003 c

LrOC-002-GEN 2 B A

.*

[)RAWlllCNO.

DF3122883 EXAMPLE (HYPOTHETICAL>

SYSTEM A TRAIN I PLUS SUPPORT DIESEL JACKET COOLING PUMP

  • 1 SYSTEM A TRAIN 2 PLUS SUPPORT REPEAT FIGURE, CHANGE EQUIPMENT LABLE TO *2 Also Available On Aperture Card PRC APERTURB_

CARD REFERENCE DRAWINGS J I I BORATION PUMP *1 .llifil!!!.

ELECTRICAL CABLE OF CONCERN --PIPING

  • EQUIPMENT SUBJECT TO HALOPERATION DUE TO ASSOCIATED CIRCUITS, HOT SHORTS, OPEN CIRCUITS, OR SHORTS TO GAOUNO, LRDC-002-GEN SH 2 m-u {ALL EOUIPHENT FOR TRAIN 1 2', INCLUOING ALL NECESSARY SUPPORT SYSTEMS ANO ELECTRIC POWER SUPPLIES, SHALL BE IOENTIFIED AND CABLE ROUTING DETAILS SEE EXAMPLE. THIS SHEET. (OFF SITE POWER IS UNAVAILABLE FOR FOR 72 HOURS IREF1 APP R, 11 J. LI DEFINE EQUIPMENT

-TRAIN I All EOUJPHENT FOR TRAIN

  • 1' SHALL BE IDENTIFIED ANO CABLE ROUTING DETAILS KNOWN AUTHDR1 CPCO REF1 NONE COMMON REOUIREHENT A GIVEN PIECE OF EQUIPMENT lTRAIN 'I' AND ALL IT'S SUPPORT SYSTEMS) SHALL HAVE A FUNCTIONAL ELECTRICAL POWER SOURCE. THE POWER SYSTEM'S SUPPORT SYSTEMS SHALL ALSO BE FUNCTIONAL.

AUTHORi NRC REF t APPEND IX R, DEFINE SUPPORT SYSTEM'S EQUIPMENT DEFINE SUPPORT SYSTEM'S EOUIPHENT FREE OF SUPPRESSION OAHAGE ONE TRAIN OF ALL SYSTEHSFEOUIP RE<OUIREO FOR HOT/COLO SHUTDOWN IS FREE OF DAMAGE FROM FIRE SUPPRESSION ACTIVITIES OR FROM THE RUPTURE OR INADVERTENT OPERATION OF FIRE SUPPRESSION SYSTEMS AUTHOR1 NRC REF1 APP A, 111. G. 3 THE SUPPORTINO FUNCTIONS SHALL BE CAPABLE OF PROVIDING THE PROCESS COOLING, LUBRICATION, ETC. NECESSARY TO PERMIT THE OPERATION OF TRAIN 'I' EQUIPMENT TRAIN 'I' IS DEPENDENT ON NO SUPPORT FUNCTIONS AUTHOR1 CPCO REF1 NONE AUTHOR. NRC DNL1 I REF1 APP NO X R tr .. 2 l THE ELECTRICAL CABLE FOR A G !VEN PIECE OF EQUIPMENT CTRAIN 'I' ANO ALL IT'S SUPPORT SYSTEMS! SHALL BE AOEOUATEL Y SEPARATED FROM ALL TRAIN

  • 2' EQUIPMENT CABLES ANO All CABLES OF TRAIN '2' ' S SUPPORT SYSTEMS <CONSIDER ALL ESSENTIAL POWER, CONTROL. AND INSTRUMENT CABLES! ONL1 I IG-61 *ASSOCIATED CIRCUITS'

!SEE NOTE 1) A GIVEN PIECE OF EQUIPMENT FOR TRAIN 'I' ANO ALL OF IT' S SUPPORT SYSTEMS SHALL BE ADEQUATELY PROTECTED FROM THE EFFECTS OF 'ASSOCIATED CIRCUITS' AUTHOR1 NRC ON 1 I REF1 APP A JI[. 0. 2.A { COLO SHUTDOWN ONLY I STOP LROC-002-GEN SH 5 H AUTHOR: CPCO REF1NONE REDUNDANT TRAINS OF SYSTEMS/EQUIPMENT ARE LOCATED IN THE SAME FIRE AREA AND ARE SUSCEPTIBLE TO SUPPRESSION DAMAGE AUTHOR* CPCO REF1 NONE G ONL1 I DESCRIPTION LRDC-002-0EN SH 5 (J-6) B* DATE F ORIGINAL ISSUE DLF LWB DESCRIPTION BY APP. E "' R, M. SATTERELLI 10-7-B LW. BAUER 12-12-83 N. L. HASKELL 28-83 J, VANDEWALLE 12-28-83 0 CONSUMERS POWER JACKSON. MICHIGAN [40, 100JSK1210B3.004 c co NOTES 1. LETTER, NRC TO CPCO, 4-7-82, ENCLOSURE 2 DEFINES ASSOCIATED CIRCUITS AS FOLLOWS: THE DEFINITION FOR ASSOCIATED CIRCUITS IS NOT EXACTLY THE SAME* AS THE DEFINITION PRESENTED IN JEEE-384-1q77.

ASSOCIATED CIRCUITS OF CONCERN ARE DEFINED AS THOSE CABLES <SAFETY RELATED, NON-SAFETY RELA TEO, CLASS lE, AND CLASS IEJ THAT: 1. HAVE A PHYSICAL SEPARATION LESS THAN THAT REQUIRED BY SECTION Jll.0.2 OF APPENDIX R, ANO: 2. HAVE ONE OF THE FOLLOWING A. A COMMON POWER SOURCE WITH SHUTDOWN EQUIPMENT

!REDUNDANT OR AL TERNATIVEI ANO THE POWER SOURCE IS NOT ELECTRICALLY PROTECTED FROM THE CIRCUIT OF CONCERN BY COORDINATED BREAKERS, FUSES, OR SIMILAR DEVICES, OR EXAMPLE: FIRE AREA ---es.s.O.t:lAJflLCJllC!Jll.

_ TRAIN B 8. A CONNECTION TO CIRCUITS OF 6 Y AFFECT 5 THE SHUTDOWN CAPABILITY

!E.O., AHR/RCS ISOLATION VALVES, ADS VALVES, PORV, STEAM OENEMTOR ATMOSPHERIC DUMP VALVES, INSTAUMENTATION, STEAM BYPASS, ETC.>, OR SECTION llJ.0.2.A OF APPENDIX R TO 10 CFR 50 REQUIRES THAT CONS IOERATION BE 0 IVEN TO 'HALOPERAT ION DUE TO HOT SHORTS, OPEN CIRCUITS, OR SHORTS TO GROUND.' FIRE AREA f2zzzz===

TRAIN B C. A COMMON ENCLOSURE

<E.G .. RACEWAY, PANEL, JUNCTIONJ WITH THE SHUTDOWN CABLES <REDUNDANT AND AL TERNATIVEl AND, (I) ARE NOT ELECTRICALLY PROTECTED BY CIRCUIT BREAKERS, FUSES, OR SIMILAR DEVICES, OR 121 VILL ALLOW PROPAGATION OF' THE FIRE INTO THE COMMON ENCLOSURE FIRE AREA COMM-_o_N, ,AS,'

_CJF!CJ.JlT

__ ENCLOSURE zz222222222222zzJ T---"' *---TRAIN B NUCLEAR F 'JWER PLANT LICENSING FEOUIREMENTS AND DESIGN CRITERIA 10 CRF 50. 48 & APPENDIX R LRDC-002-GEN 3 0 4 3 2 B I A 8401250249-t>f SUPPORT SYSTEM TRAIN

  • 1 POWER '* .

SYSTEM A TRAIN I PLLJS SUPPORT DIESEL JACKET COOLING PUHP *1 DIESEL SUPPORT SYSTEM TRAIN

  • I De SEAL COOLING PUMP *1 SYSTEM A, TRAIN 2 PLUS SUPPORT REPEAT FIGURE. CHANGE EOUIPHENT LASLE TO *2 Mao-'.Available Oii "*'Aperture Card BORATION PUMP *1 -----ELECTRICAL CABLE OF CONCERN --PIPING
  • EOUIPHENT SUBJECT TO HALOPERATION OVE TO ASSOCIATED CIRCUITS.

HOT SHORTS, OPEN CIRCUITS, OR SHORTS TO GROUND. COMMON POWER SOURCE} !SEE NOTE 1.2.AI ADEQUATE CABLE SEPARATION COMMON POliER SOURCE ISOLATE EQUIPMENT ADEQUATE CABLE SEPARATION .SHALL BE PROVIDED TD ENSURE PHYSICAL ISOLATION BETVEEN TRAIN 'l S EQUIPMENT CABLING ANO THE 'ASSOCIATED CIRCUIT' THE EQUIPMENT PDVER SOURCE IS ELECTRICALLY PROTECTED FRDH THE CIRCUIT OF CONCERN BY COORDINATED BREAKERS.

FUSES. OR SIMILAR DEV ICES PROVIDE A MEANS TO ISOLATE THE EQUIPMENT ANO/OR COMPONENTS FROM THE F IRE AREA PRIOR TO THE FIRE ti. E., REHOVE PO\IER CABLES. OPEN CIRCUIT BREAKERSJ tG-61 AUTHOR1 NRC REF1 SAH AS NOTE I C2J THE SOURCE SHALL SuPPLY THE NECESSARY FAULT CURRENT FOR SUFFICIENT TIME TO ENSURE THE PROPER COORDINATION VITHOUT LOSS OF FUNCTION OF THE SHUTDOVN LOADS. AUTHOR1 NRC ONL15 REF1 SAME AS NOTE I PRC 1l\PERTURE CARD ON 15 AUTHOR1 NRC REF1 SAME AS NOT 1 ACCEPTABLE INTERUPTTNG DEVICE THE ACCEPTABILITY OF A PARTICULAR INTERRUPTING DEVICE IS CONSIDERED DEMONSTRATED IF THE FOLLOWING CRITERIA.

ARE HET1 tll THE INTERRUPTING DEVICE OESION BE FACTORY TESTEO TO VERIFY OVERCURRENT PROTECT ION AS DES IGNEO IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE APPLICABLE UL. ANSI. OR NEMA STANDARDS.

Ill! FDR LOii ANO MEDIUM VOLTAGE SVITCHGEAR (4B0 V ANO A60VE> CIRCUIT BREAKER/ PROTECTIVE RELAY PERIOOIC TESTING SHALL DEMONSTRATE THAT THE OVERALL COOROINATIDN SCHEME REMAINS WITHIN THE LIMITS SPECIFIED IN THE DESIGN CRITERIA.

THIS TESTING MAY BE PERFORMED AS A SERIES OF OVERLAPPING TESTS. <Illl MOLDED CASE CIRCUIT BREAKERS SHALL PERIODICALLY BE MANUALLY EXERCISED AND INSPECTED TO INSURE EASE OF OPERATION.

ON A ROTATING REFUELING OUTAGE BASIS A SAMPLE OF THESE BREAKERS SHALL BE TESTED TO DETERMINE THAT BREAKER DRIFT JS WITHIN THAT ALLOWED BY THE DESIGN CRITERIA.

BREAKERS SHOULD BE TES TEO IN ACCORDANCE

'11 ITH AN ACCEPTED QC TEST ING METHODOLOOY SUCH AS MIL STD 10 5 O. UV> FUSES \IHEN USED AS INTERRUPTING OEVICES 00 NOT REOUJRE PERIODIC TEST!NO. DUE TO THEIR STABILITY, LACK OF DRIFT. AND HIGH RELIABILITY.

AOHINISTRATIVE CONT'AOLS HUST INSURE THAT REPLACEMENT FUSES VITH RATINGS OTHER THAN THOSE SLECTED FOR PROPER COOROINATINO ARE NOT ACCIOENTALLY USED. AUTHOR1 NAC ONL15 REF1 SAME AS NOT I DNL15 LRDC-002-GEN SH. 3 SH. 3 CD-31 SPURIOUS OPERATION}

csee NOTE 1.2.Bl PROVIDE ELECTRICAL ISOLATION THAT PREVENTS SPURIOUS OPERATION.

POTENTIAL ISOLATION OEV ICES INCLUDE BFIEAl<ERS.

FUSES. AMPLIFIERS, CONTROL SVITCHES.

CURRENT XFRS. FIBER OPTIC COUPLERS, RELAYS AND TRANSDUCERS AUTHOR; NRC DNL15 REF1 SAME AS NOTE I DETECT ION ANO PROCEDURES PROVIDE A MEANS TO DETECT SPURIOUS OPERATIONS ANO THEN PROCEDURES TD DEFEAT THE HALOPERATION OF EQUIPMENT II. E ** CLOSURE OF THE BLOCK VAi.VE IF PORV SPURIOUSLY OPERATES.

OPENING OF THE BREAKERS TO REMOVE SPURIOUS OPERATION OF SAFETY INJECTION!

AUTHOR1 NRC ONL1 5 REF1 SAME AS NOTE I PREVENT FIRE PROPAGATION PROVIDE APPROPRIATE MEASURES TD PREVENT PROPAGATION OF THE FIRE AUTHOR1 NRC ONL1 5 REF* SAME AS NOTE 1 DR. R. M. SATTERELLI 10-7-B COMMON ENCLOSURE

} !SEE NOTE I. 2. CJ ELECTRICAL PROTECTION PROVIDE ELECTRICAL PROTECTION Cl. E., BREAKERS.

FUSES OR SIMILAR DEVICESl AUTHORi NRC REF1 SAME AS NOT I L. II. BAUER 12-12-83 CONSUMERS POWER co SO:(:fl0:.*00 I. LETTER, NRC TO CPCO, 4-7-82, ENCLOSURE 2 DEFINES ASSOCIATED CIRCUITS AS FOLLOWS1 THE DEFINITION FOR ASSOCIATED CIRCUITS 15 NOT EXACTLY THE SAME AS THE DEFINITION PRESENTED IN IEEE-3B4-1CJ77.

ASSOCIA.TEO CIRCUITS OF CONCERN ARE DEFINED AS THOSE CABLES tSAFETY RELATED. NON-SAFETY RELATED, CLASS IE. ANO CLASS lEI THAT1 I. HAVE A PHYSICAL SEPARATION LESS THAN THAT AEOUIREO BY SECTION Ul.G.2 OF APPENDIX R, AN01 2. HAVE ONE OF THE FOLLOWING A. A COMMON POWER SOURCE WITH SHUTDOWN EQUIPMENT CREOUNOANT OR AL TERNATIVEl ANO THE POWER SOURCE JS NOT ELECTRICALLY PROTECTED FROM THE CIRCUIT OF CONCERN BY COORDINATED BREAKERS, FUSES, OR SIMILAR DEVICES. OR EXAMPLE* FIRE AREA : _ _ _ f!S.S.O"lftTfQ

_tjilCJJH

.. -TRAIN B B .. A CONNECTION TO CIRCUITS OF EOUIPM91T WHOSE SPURIOUS OPERATION WOULD AOVERSEL Y AFFECT THE SHUTDOWN CAPABILITY CE .. G ** AHR/RCS ISOLATION VALVES, ADS VALVES. PORV, STEAM GENERATOR ATMOSPHERIC DUMP VALVES, INSTRUMENTATION.

STEAM BYPASS. ETC.I. OR SECTION III.G.2.A OF APPENDIX R TO 10 CFR 50 REOUIRES THAT CONSIDERATION BE GIVEN TO 'HALOPERAT ION DUE TO HOT SHORTS. OPEN CIRCUITS.

OR SHORTS TO GROUND.' TRAIN A FIRE AREA IVALvE.l_

_ _ _ flSS_OJ:lf!JfQ

_C,Jll<;_UJT

__ TRAIN B C. A COMMON ENCLOSURE CE.G., RACEWAY, PANEL. JUNCTION>

WITH THE SHUTDOWN CABLES !REDUNDANT AND ALTERNATIVE!

ANO, m ARE NOT ELECTRICALLY PROTECTED BY CIRCUIT BREAKERS, FUSES, OR SIMILAR DEVICES, OR (2l WILL ALLOW PROPAGATION OF THE FIRE INTO THE COMMON ENCLOSURE FIRE AREA COM_M_O_N, ,AS,'

__ ENCLOSURE ZZ2ZZZ2ZZ2ZZ2ZZ2d I T ___ _, TRAIN B NUCLEAR POWER PLANT LICENSING REOU IAEMENTS *AND DESIGN CRITERIA JACKSON, MICHIGAN C40, !00JSK121083.008 10 CRF 50. 48 & APPENDIX R LROC-002-GEN 0 rlEFERENC!::

ORti;.*JNGS DESCRIPTION DATE DESCRIPTION BY APP. G F E D c B I A s4o 1250249-oS DF1122783 I I H J .* 6 5 4 3 2 Y' Also Available On Aperture Card ... --..

SH 3 ) ' ' CONTROL STATION1 ALTERKATE OR DEDICATED SHUTOOVN ALTERNATIVE OR OEOICATEO ISEE NOTE 31 SHUTDOVN CAPABILITY ANO ITS ASSOCIATED CIRCUITS, INOEPENOENT OF CABLE SYSTEMS OR COMPONENTS JN THE AREA. ROOM OR ZONE UNOER CONSIDERATION SHALL BE PROVIDED IN EACH CASE WHERE IT CAN NOT BE DEMONSTRATED THAT ONE TRAIN OF SYSTEMS/EQUIPMENT NECESSARY TO ACHIEVE ANO MAINTAIN HOT SHUTOOWN CONDITIONS, FROM EITHER THE CONTROL. ROOH OR EMERGENCY CONTROL STATIONS, IS FREE OF DAMAGE AUTHOlb NRC ONL1 I R F1APP R 111.G.3 FIRE DETECTION INSTALL FIRE DETECTION IN tSEE NOTE 1J THE AREA, ROOM, OR ZONE UNDER CONSICERAT ION AUTHOR1 NRC Fr APP R 111.0.3 FIXED FIRE SUPPRESSION INSTALL A FIXED <SEE NOTE 2l FIRE SLIPPRESSION SYSTEM IN (SEE NOTE II THE AREA. ROOM, OR ZONE UNDER CONSIDERATION AUTHOR1 NRC REF1APP R 111.G.3 ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' '.. ,/ C0"°40N REQUIREMENT

!ALTERNATE SHUTDOWN CABUS ANO/OR EQUIPEHENT HUST BE INDEPENDENT OF BOTH TRAIN

  • 2' THE AREA. ROOM OR ZONE UNDER CONSIDERATION DF4122B83 RADIANT ENERGY SHIELD CABLES, EQUIPMENT ANO ASSOCIATED NON-SAFETY CIRCUITS OF REDUNDANT TRAINS SHALL BE SEPARATED BY A NONCOMBUSTIBLE RAD ANT NERGY SHIELD AUTHOR1 NRC ONL1 I REF1APP R 11.G.2 <Fl FIRE DETECTORS FIRE DETECTORS SHALL BE INSTALLED IN (SEE NOTE I! THE FIRE AREA AUTHOR1 NRC REF1APP R 111.G IE! AUTHOR: NRC REF1APP R III ** PRC APERTURE CARD REFERENCE ORAWIMGS J I I SH 3 rLROC;::;*:N SH* <E-6J ... -....

SH 3 <H-21 ..... -.... ' ' ' ' ' ' ,' .... ,,,./ COl<><DN REQUIREMENT ' ' ' ' ' ' ' .............

REOUIREHENT COLO SHUTDOWN } ONLY CONTROL STATION! LOCAL ISEE NOTE '41 CONTROL CAN BE ESTABLISHED FOR EITHER TRAIN OF A GIVEN SYSTEH/EOUIPHENT FROM AN EMERGENCY CONTROL STATION !EXCLUDING ALTERNATIVE OR DEDICATED SHUTOOlilN SYSTEMS, ANO THE SYSTEM' S/EOUIPMENT' S REOulRED ANO ASSOCIATED CIRCUITRY IS FREE OF FIRE DAMAG

E. PROCEDURE

S SHALL BE IN EFFECT TO IMPLEMENT THIS CAPABILITY

  • CONTROL STATIOtu CONTROL ROOM CONTROL CAN BE ESTABLISHED FOR EITHER TRAIN OF A GIVEN SYSTEH/EQUIPHENT FROH THE CONTROL ROOH AND THE SYSTEM' St EQUIPMENT'S REQUIRED ANO ASSOCIATED CIRCUITRY IS FREE OF FIRE DAMAGE NRC R F1APP R ur G COH><ON REQUIREMENT ONL1 I LIMITED DAMAGE REPAIR PROCEDURES tSEE NOTE 51 DAMAGE TO COLO SHUTDOWN SYSTEMS/ EGUIPHENT SHALL BE LIHITEO SO THAT THE SYSTEMS CAN BE HADE OPERABLE ANO COLD SHUTDOWN CAN BE ACHI VEO 'IHTHIN 72 HOU MATERIALS FOR REPAIR OF COLO SHUTOOWN SYSTEMS/EOUIPHENT SHALL BE READILY AVAILASt.E ON SITE REPAIR PROCEDURES SHALL BE IN EFFECT TO IMPLEMENT REPAIR TO COLD SHUTDOWN EDUIPEHENT AUTHOR1 NRC ONL1 1 AUTHOR: NRC AUTHOR1 NRC DNL1 I RF1APPR Ill.LS REF1APPR III.LS REF1APP R 11 ** 5 DR MEASURED HORIZONTAL SEPAAATION

!SEE NOTE 6) ALL CABLES, EQUIPMENT AND ASSOCIATED NON-SAFETY CIRCUITS OF REDUNDANT TRAIN '2' SHALL SE SEPARATED BY A HORIZONTAL OISTANCE OF HORE THAN 20 FEET FROM THE EQUIPMENT

/CABLE OF CONCERN FOR TRAIN 'I' WITH THE FOLLOWING CONDITIONS BEING MET1 A. NO INTERVENING COMBUSTIBLES B. NO INTERVENING FIRE HAZARDS AUTHDR1 NRC DNL= 1 REF1 APP R. 111.0.2 !OJ ' , , COMMON ....

REQUIREMENT AND CABLE SEPARATION OUTSIDE CONTAINMENT THE CABLE SE PARAT ION CRITERIA FOR CABLES ROUTED OUTSIDE CONTAINMENT ARE SATISFIED AUTHOIU CPCO FIRE DETE TORS FIRE DETECTORS SHALL BE INSTALLED IN (SEE NOTE II THE FIRE AREA AUTHOR1 NRC REF: APP R llI.G.2 !Cl AUTOMATIC FIRE SUPPRESION DNL1 I AN AUTOMATIC FIRE SUPPRESSION SYSTEM SHALL BE INSTALLED IN tSEE NOTE 1l THE FIRE AREA AUTHOR1 NRC REF1APPR 111.G.2 ICJ \*HOUR FIR BARRIER CABLES, EOUIPMENT AND ASSOCIATED NON-SAFETY CIRCUITS OF THE TRAIN 1 I' EQUIPMENT OF CONCERN SHALL BE ENCLOSED IN A FIRE BARRIER HAVING A I-HOUR RATING AUTHOA1 NRC DNL1 I REF< APP R I l.G. 2 IC) I-HOUR FIRE BARRIER DNL1 I __ ..'coMHON ANO REOU IREHENT MEASURED H RIZONTAL SEPARATION

!SEE NOTE I CABLES, EQUIPMENT AND ASSOCIATED NON-SAFETY CIRCUITS OF REDUNDANT TRAIN

  • 2' SHALL BE SEPERATEO BY A HORIZONTAL.

DISTANCE OF MORE THAN 20 FEET FROM THE TRAIN 'I' WITH THE FOLLOWING CONDITIONS BEING HET; A. NO INTERVENING COMBUSTIBLES B. NO INTERVENING FIRE HAZARDS ' ---AND _,'COMMON REQUIREMENT 3-HOUR BARRIER CABLES, EQUIPMENT AND ASSOCIATED NON-SAFETY CIRCUITS OF REDUNDANT TRAIN '2' SHALL BE SEPARATED FROH THE EQUIPMENT/CABLE OF CONCERN FOR TRAIN 'I' BY A FIRE BARRIER HAVING A 3-HOUR RATING AUTHOR1 NRC REF1 APP R JII.0.2 (Al STRUCTURAL STEEL STRUCTURAL STEEL DOES NOT FORM A PART OF OR DOES NOT SUPPORT THE FIRE BARRIER AUTHOR1 NRC REF1APP R lII.0.2 !Al STRUCTURAL STEEL STRUCTURAL STEEL FORMING A PART OF OR SLJPPORT(NO SUCH FIRE BARRIERS SHALL BE PROTECTED TO PROVIOE FIRE RESISTANCE EQUIVALENT TO THAT REQUIRED OF THE BARRIER AUTHOR1 NRC CNL1 I REF1APP R 11r.o.2 CABLES, EQUIPMENT AND ASSOCIATED CIRCUITS OF ALL TRAIN '2' EQUIPMENT IN FIRE AREA OF CONCERN SHALL BE ENCLOSED IN A FIRE BARRIER HAVING A !*HOUR RATING { OUALIFIEO BY NOTE I ON LRDC-002-GEN.

SH. 2 AUTHOR1 NRC REF1 APP R I J. G. 2 <Cl DESCRIPTION BY H G F ONLr I ORIGINAL ISSUE DESCR!PT!ON E R. R.H. SATTERELLI 10*7-S 0<. L W, BAUER 12* 12-B3

"'"" ArP. N. L. HASKELL 12-28-B3 D APPEND IX A TO BTP ASS 9. 5* I CABLES, EQUIPMENT ANO ASSOCIATEO NON-SAFETY CIRCUITS OF REDUNDANT TRAIN '2' SHALL BE SEPARTEO FROM THE EOUIPHENT/CABLE OF CONCERN FOR TRAIN 'I' BY A FIRE BARRIER HAVING A RATING CONSISTENT WITH THE GUIDANCE PROVIDED IN APPENDIX A TO BTP ASS 'l. 5-J ANO ACCEPTED BY NRC AUTHOR1 NRC REF1 APP R 111.G.2 <Al DNL* 1 CONSUMERS POWER JACKSON, MICHIGAN [40. J00lSKl210BJ.

005 c co B NONE NOTES I. THE t*lC STAFF INTERPRETS

  • IN' TO HEAN 1 THROUGHOUT'

!REFERENCE GENERIC LETTER 83-33 OCTOBER 1q, 1qa31 2. 'A FIXED FIRE SUPPRESSION SYSTEM SHALL HAVE DISCHAROE HEADS ANO THE DlSTRJBUTION PIPING FOR SUCH HEAOS 1NSTALI.EO.

HOSE STATIONS DO NOT SATISFY THIS REQUIREMENT.*

IREFERENCE OEtERIC LETTER. 83-33 OCTOBER 1 q, 1 't831 3. ALTERNATIVE SHUTOOVN CAPABILITY IS PROVIDED BY REROUTING, RELOCATING OR HODIFICATION OF EXISTING SYST£HS1 DEDICATED SHUTOOVN CAPABILITY IS PROV IOED BY lNSTALL ING NEV STRUCTURES ANO SYSTEMS FOR THE PURPOSE OF POST-FIRE SHUTDOWN.

<REFERENCE 10 CFR 50, APPENOIX R SECTION 111.G, FOOTNOTE 21. 1 SHUTDOWN SYSTEMS INSTALLED TO ENSURE POSTFIRE SHUTDOWN CAPABILIY NEED NOT BE DESIGNED TO MEET SEISMIC CATEGORY I CRITERIA.

SINGLE FAILURE CRITERIA.

OR OTHER DESICiN BASIS ACCIDENT CRITERIA.

EXCEPT WHERE REQUIRED FOR OTHER REASONS, E. G. , BECAUSE OF INTERFACE WITH OR IMPACT ON EXISTINO SAFETY SYSTEMS, OR BECAUSE OF ADVERSE VALVE ACTIONS OUE TO FIRE DAMAGE.' !REFERENCE 10 CFR 50 APPENDIX R. SECTION I II. L. 61 '4. *OPERABILITY OF THE HOT SHUTDOWN SYSTEMS, JNCLUOING THE ABILITY TO OVERCOME A FIRE OR FIRE SUPPRESSANT INDUCED MALOPERATJON OF HOT SHUTDOVN EQUIPMENT AND THE PLANT'S PO'iER DISTRIBUTION SYSTEH, HUST EXIST WITHOUT REPAIRS. MANUAL OPERATION OF VALVES, SVJTCHES ANO CIRCUIT BREAKERS IS ALLOWED TO OPERATE EQUIPMENT AND ISOLATE SYSTEMS AND IS NOT CONSIDERED A REPAIR. HOWEVER, THE REMOVAL OF FUSES FOR ISOLATION IS NOT PERMITTED.

ALL MANUAL OPERATIONS HUST BE ACHIEVABLE PRIOR TO THE FIRE OR FIRE SUPPRESSANT INDUCED MAl..OPERATlONS REACHING AN UNRECOVERABLE PLANT CONDITION, <REFERENCE ITEM S OF ATTACHMENT C TO NRC INTERNAL CORRESPONDENCE, SECY-83-26q, JULY 5, 1q93J 5. 'OPERABILITY OF THE HOT SHUTOOWN StSTEHS. INCLUDING THE ABILITY TO OVERCOME A FIRE OR FIRE SUPPRESSANT INDUCED KALOPERATION OF HOT SHUTOOVN EQUIPMENT AND THE PLANT'S POWER DISTRIBUTION SYSTEH, HUST EXIST WITHOUT REPAIRS. MANUAL OPERATION OF VALVES. SWITCHES ANO CIRCUIT BREAKERS IS ALLOWED TO OPERATE EQUIPMENT ANO ISOLATE SYSTEMS ANO IS NOT CONSIDERED A REPAIR. HOWEVER, THE REMOVAL OF FUSES FOR ISOLATION JS NOT PERM I TTEO. ALL MANUAL OPERA T IONS HUST BE ACHIEVABLE PRIOR TO THE FIRE OR FIRE SUPPRESSANT INDUCED HALOPERATIONS REACHING AN UNRECOVERABLE PLANT CONDIT ION. HODIFlCATIONS, E.O., WIRING CHANGES, ARE ALLOWED TO SYSTEMS ANO/OR COMPONENTS NOT USED FOR HOT SHUTOOVN, WHOSE FIRE OR FIRE SUPPRESSANT INOUCEO MAL.OPERATIONS HAY INDIRECTLY AFFECT HOT SHUTOO'l'N.

THESE REPAIRS MUST BE ACHIEVABLE PRIOR TO THE MALOPERATIONS CAUSING AN UNRECOVERABLE PLANT CONDITION.

REPAIRS FOR COLO SHUTOOVN ARE ALLO'lfED BY SECTION 111.L.S OF APPENDIX R. FOR COLD SHUTDOWN CAPABILITY REPAIRS. THE REHOVAL OF FUSES FOR ISOLATION AND THE REPLACEMENT OF CABLING IS PERMITTED.

ALSO, SELECTED EQUIPMENT REPLACEMENT, E.O., SUCH AS REPLACING A VALVE. PUMP, CONTROL ROCH CONTROLS ANO INSTRUMENTS.

WILL SE REVIEWED ON A CASE-BY-CASE BASIS TO VERIFY ITS PRACTICALITY WITHIN THE APPROPRIATE TIME CONSTRAINTS.

PROCEDURES FOR REPAIRING DAMAGED EQUIPMENT SHOULD BE PREPARED JN ADVANCE liITH REPLACEMENT EQUIPMENT U. E., CABLES HAOE-UP VITH TERMINAL LUGS ATTACHEOJ STORED ONSITE. ALL REPAIRS SMOULO BE OF SUFFICIENT QUALITY TO ASSURE SAFE OPERATION UNTIL THE PLANT IS RESTORED TO AN OPERATING CONDITION.

'REPAIRS NOT PERMITTED INCLUDE THE USE OF CLIP LEADS IN CONTROL PANELS Clr'HICH MEANS THAT HARO WIRED TERMINAL LUGS HUST BE USEDJ , ANO THE USE OF JUMPER CABLES OTHER THAN THOSE FASTENED VITH TERMINAL LUOS. * \IHEN REPAIRS ARE NECESSARY IN THE FIRE AREA, THE LICENSEE SHOULD DEMONSTRATE THAT SUFFICIENT TIME IS AVAILABLE TO ALLOW THE AREA TO BE RE-ENTERED ANO THAT EXPECTED FIRE ANO FIRE SUPPRESSANT DAMAGE WILL NOT PREVENT THE REPAIR FROM TAKING PLACE ANO THAT REPAIR PROCEOURE WILL NOT ENDANGER OPERATING SYSTEMS. IN ADDITION, WRITTEN PROCEOURES MUST EXIST FOR THE ORDERLY TRANSFER OF CONTROL FROM THE CONTROL ROOM AND THE REMOTE SHUTDOWN STATIONS ANO VICE VERSA. THE REPAIRS TO COLD SHUTDOWN SYSTEMS ARE CONSIDERED TO BE AN UPPER LIMIT. THE LICENSEE HAY DESIGN THE PL.ANT SO THAT COLO SHUTDOWN CAN BE ACHIEVED WITHOUT REPAIR.' <REFERENCE ITEM B OF ATTACHMENT C TO NRt INTERNAL CORRESPONDENCE.

SECY-83-26q, JlJL.Y 5, lqij31 6. 'PLASTIC JACKETS ANO INSULATION OF GROUPED ELECTRICAL CABLES. INCLUDING THOSE VHICH ARE COATED, SHOULD BE CONSIDERED AS INTERVENING COJoUlUSTTBLES.

1 <REFERENCE GENERIC LETTER B3-33 OCTOBER 1q, l'l83J NUCL[ AR POWER PLANT L!CENS ING REQUIREMENTS AND DESIGN CRITERIA 10 CFR 50. 48 &. APPENDIX R P OT CTION A SHEET 5 REV, 0 8401250249-0G, .. 6 5 4 3 2 f *; . 7 I I I I I I "'""' '

  • DIHCAm CCllRD.ATIDN iETMElll Dl'LIJBTATION S0G&LE. ACTIVITY m:SCSUPTIQll MCI SPiClr:'lC SiCTICIN OS: .......... L SCHEtu.E AS FOLLOWS. BEFORE STAATt.P AFTER THE EARLIEST f1F TIE FCl.LOVING DATES AFTER A) nE FIRST REFtELIHG OUTAGE BJ A PLAYED OUTACiE THAT LASTS AT LEAST 60 DAYS C> AN lH'LQHNED OUTAGE THAT LASTS AT LEAST 129 DAYS 2. SCHEDULE AS FOLLCIWS.

BEFORE STARTuP AF'TEA THE EARLIEST OF Tt£ Fu.LOWING OATES AFTER ll-26*B3i AJ TtE FIRST REFUELlNG DUTACE 8> A PL/HIED OUTAfiE THAT l.ASTS AT LEAST 60 DAYS Cl m UfiF'l..INED OUTAGE TtMT LASTS AT LEAST l2S DAYS 3. SOEDU.E AS FOLLOWS. 6EFORE SHRTUP AFTER THE EARLIEST OF n£ FOLLOWING DATES AFTER Ci*B-931 A> TNE FtRST REFl.ELING OUTAGE B> A PUIMED OUTACiE TKAT LASTS AT LEAST Giii DAYS 0 AN lltPLANNED OUTAGE THAT LASTS AT 10 CFR 50.48, FIRE PROTECTION LEAST WI DAYS 4. FPSER-FIRE PROTECTIOO TY SCHEDULE REQUIREMENTS EVALUATION REPOATCSI M>PENDIX CAI TO BNKH POSITltlt QTP APCSS Cl.5-1 IPU3LI IN AUGUST 1*761 1e CFR 5il.48 I PALISADES 2*17-81 3*17*81 3*17*81 3-17-81 11-17*81 SEE NOTE I 5-26-83 CSEE REF. un 11*26*83 SEE NOTE 2 SEE REFEREKCES 2.:1.4. PIG 9 SCHEDULE I 2*17-81 3*17*81 3-17-81 3*17-81 11-17-81 SEE NOTE I 3--8*83 lSEE REF. II q.a-e3 SEE NOTE 3 SEE REFERENCES Z.S.,7.0.At<<J q EFFECTlVE DATE OF COMPLET FIRE SUBMIT PL.ANS ANO EXEP.PTION REQU£STS-COMPLETE MODIFICATIONS COMPLETE HOOIFICATICl6 fflC CONCLUSION THAT THE COMPLETE 6\LL MODIFICAT10NS COMPLETE ALL MIXllFICATIOHS COMPLETE ALL MODIFICATIONS 10 CFR '50.46 AMJ PROTEC THAT SCt£DULES FOR f'E'.ETING IN EVENT THAT AN THAT DO NOT REQUIRE THAT REQUIRE Al.T£RMA TllOllN THAT DO rcn REQUIRE THAT REQUIRE ASSOCIATED VITH TfE 10 CFR 50 APPENDIX R INV Tl£ PROVISIONS OF E TION REQUEST TO PLANT SHUTDOWN PLANT SfflJTDOWN DESIGN I PLANT SHUTDOWN Pl.ANT SHUTOOWN FIRE PROTECTION PLAN s. APPEfl:llX R TS SAFE AND FPSER lSEE N'lTE 41 I MEETS T TS ACTIVITY TRAIN! OF SECTIDN 111.G.3 OF CE fll'P.R TO"' CFR 50. REQUIREMENTS SHALL BE TOLLED UNTIL. FINAL COMMISSION ACTION ON Tl£ EXEMPTION REQUEST 10 CFR 50; APP. R. III.G.2 * * * * * * !SAFE SHUTDOWN>

REFERENCES1 10 CFR 50. APP. R. III.G.3,III.L

  • * * * *
  • L. LETTER. NRC TO CPCO 3-8-Bl. DOCKET *50-155 !AL TERNA TIVE/DED.

' 2. 10 CFR 5'1.48 SECTION Id> SHUTDOWN>

<SCHEDLIL.E NOT REO'OI 3-LETTER. NRC TO CPCO 10 CFR Sil. APP. R. Q-1*78 0 DOCK£T 50*255 III.J * * * * *

  • 4. LETTER. NRC TO CPCO 3-IQ-88, DOCKET 5'!1*25S !EMERGENCY LIGHTING>
5. LETTER. NRC TD CPCO 2*10*81. DOCKET 50-255 10 CFR 50. APP. R. S.. LETTER. NRC TO CPCO 4-4-7<1, DOCKET 50-15!5 III.0 * * * * * * \ 7. L.ETTER. NRC TO CPCO 3*11*80, DOCKET 50*155 <OIL COLLECTION SYSTEM> 8. L.ETTER. NRC TO CPCO 3-27-80, DOCKET 50-155 10 CFR 50.48 Cl. LETTER. NRC TO CPCO FIRE PROTECTION PLAN, *
  • 11-14*80, DOCKET SMSS If!. LETTER. NRC TO CPCO ANO FPSER !SEE NOTE 41 5*26-BJ, DOCKET 59-255 .Als@ Available On Aperture Card p R c

' ;:' A p E R T u R B c A R D I I "" J.L. STERRETT NUCLEAR POWER PLANT CONSUMERS POWER* co LICENSING REQUIREMENTS cK. L.W. BAUER 12*12*83 ANO DESIGN CRITERIA su;ttOt<>£40 i0 CFR 50.4 8 ANO APPENDIX R APP. N. I.. HASKELL 12-28-83 FIRE PROTECTION

\ 0 ORIGINAL ISSUE DLF LWB 12-28-83 JACKSON, MICHIGAN NDNE 1 ORAil!N(;NO, I REV. ORAlllNGNO. REFERENCE DRAWINGS AEV, DATE DESCRJPTION BY APP, "'* DATE BY APP. [-111l,111ll21lSKl2l083.00S

  • JO* I LRDC-002-GEN 0 DESCRIPTION " OF'5122883 L 8 4 0 1 2 5 0 2 4 9 -f:J 7
Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML18051A771&oldid=1197734"