ML071570118: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
 
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
 
(One intermediate revision by the same user not shown)
Line 3: Line 3:
| issue date = 05/24/2007
| issue date = 05/24/2007
| title = E-MAIL: (NPA-PD) Cost Benefit Equation Terms
| title = E-MAIL: (NPA-PD) Cost Benefit Equation Terms
| author name = Palla R L
| author name = Palla R
| author affiliation = NRC/NRR/ADES
| author affiliation = NRC/NRR/ADES
| addressee name = Jones J
| addressee name = Jones J
Line 18: Line 18:


=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:iRort Palla -Cost Benefit Equation Terms .....Page 1 From: Robert Palla To: jojones@sandia.gov Date: 05/24/2007 7:10:00 AM  
{{#Wiki_filter:iRort Palla - Cost Benefit Equation Terms                                                             .....         Page 1 From:               Robert Palla To:               jojones@sandia.gov Date:               05/24/2007 7:10:00 AM


==Subject:==
==Subject:==
Cost Benefit Equation Terms Joe -I am not sure whether I had provided you with this table previously.
Cost Benefit Equation Terms Joe - I am not sure whether I had provided you with this table previously. Itshows how each of the terms in the cost benefit equation are derived, and their relative significance for Pilgrim. Bob CC:                 nbixler@sandia.gov
It shows how each of the terms in the cost benefit equation are derived, and their relative significance for Pilgrim. Bob CC: nbixler@sandia.gov  
 
: 1. C':\t6&#xfd;ip\GW)00001.&#xfd;&#xfd;T&#xfd;&#xfd;&#xfd;'M''P&#xfd;-'-P-aiWi 11 I c:\te1~n p\GW}OOQOl .TMP Page 1<Mail Envelope Properties (46557288.5A6  
1.C':\t6&#xfd;ip\GW)00001.&#xfd;&#xfd;T&#xfd;&#xfd;&#xfd;'M''P&#xfd;-'                                                                         -P-aiWi11 1<
:18 :10412)
Page Ic:\te1~n p\GW}OOQOl .TMP Mail Envelope Properties     (46557288.5A6 :18 :10412)


==Subject:==
==Subject:==
Creation Date From: Created By: Cost Benefit Equation Terms 05/24/2007 7:10:00 AM Robert Palla RLP3 (@l)nrc.gov Recipients sandia.gov AM jojones (ioiones(asandia.gov) nbixler CC (nbixler(asandia.gov)
Cost Benefit Equation Terms Creation Date          05/24/2007 7:10:00 AM From:                  Robert Palla Created By:            RLP3 (@l)nrc.gov Recipients                                       Action              Date & Time sandia.gov                                       Transferred          05/24/2007 7:10:30 AM jojones (ioiones(asandia.gov) nbixler CC (nbixler(asandia.gov)
Action Transferred Date & Time 05/24/2007 7:10:30 Post Office Delivered Route sandia.gov Files Size MESSAGE 505 Cost benefit equation and description of terms.wpd AM Date & Time 05/24/2007 7:10:00 AM 9603 02/21/2007 11:13:12 Options Auto Delete: Expiration Date: Notify Recipients:
Post Office                                         Delivered         Route sandia.gov Files                           Size               Date & Time MESSAGE                          505                05/24/2007 7:10:00 AM Cost benefit equation and description of terms.wpd 9603               02/21/2007 11:13:12 AM Options Auto Delete:                     No Expiration Date:                 None Notify Recipients:               Yes Priority:                       Standard ReplyRequested:                 No Return Notification:             None Concealed  
Priority: ReplyRequested:
Return Notification:
Concealed  


==Subject:==
==Subject:==
Security: To Be Delivered:
No Security:                       Standard To Be Delivered:                 Immediate Status Tracking:                 Delivered & Opened
Status Tracking: No None Yes Standard No None No Standard Immediate Delivered  
 
& Opened  
                                                                                                                                                  .3 4
.3 4 Net Value = (APE + AOC + AOE + AOSC) -COE, where APE =AOC =AOE =AOSC =COE-averted public exposure costs averted offsite property damage costs averted occupational exposure costs averted onsite costs averted cleanup and decontamination costs (ACC) + averted replacement power costs (ARPC)cost of enhancement Cost Significance NUREG/BR-Related Parameters Value If All Internally-Initiated Core Factor 0184 Section Damage Events at Pilgrim Are Eliminated APE Offsite exposure 5.7.1 AP-Rem (from MACCS2) $314K AOC Offsite economic 5.7.5 AOffsite Economic Cost Risk -OECR (from MACCS2) $566K From 12/12/2006 Entergy letter, Attachment C, Table E. 1-15:-CAPB-12: $4.85E6/event
Net Value = (APE + AOC + AOE + AOSC) - COE, where APE     = averted public exposure costs AOC    = averted offsite property damage costs AOE    = averted occupational exposure costs AOSC    = averted onsite costs averted cleanup and decontamination costs (ACC) + averted replacement power costs (ARPC)
-CAPB-14: $4.96E9/event
COE-      cost of enhancement Cost     Significance   NUREG/BR-                           Related Parameters                       Value If All Internally-Initiated Core Factor                     0184 Section                                                                     Damage Events at Pilgrim Are Eliminated APE     Offsite exposure     5.7.1     AP-Rem (from MACCS2)                                                             $314K AOC     Offsite economic     5.7.5     AOffsite Economic Cost Risk - OECR (from MACCS2)                                 $566K From 12/12/2006 Entergy letter, Attachment C, Table E. 1-15:
-CAPB-15: $18.0E9/event
                                        - CAPB-12: $4.85E6/event
-frequency-weighted sum for all CAPBs = $8.21 E9/event From NUREG/BR-0184, Table 5.6 (1990$ costs, within 50 miles):-average for all NUREG-1 150 plants = $2.46E8/event  
                                        - CAPB-14: $4.96E9/event
--highest NUREG-1 150 plant (Peach Bottom) = $2.71 E9/event AOE Onsite exposure 5.7.3 Immediate occupational dose (3,300 P-Rem) $2K Long term occupational dose (20,000 P-Rem)ACC Onsite economic 5.7.6.1 Onsite cleanup and decontamination cost ($1.1E9.single event, PW) $76K ARPC Onsite economic 5.7.6.2 Plant power level. $51 K}}
                                        - CAPB-15: $18.0E9/event
                                        - frequency-weighted sum for all CAPBs = $8.21 E9/event From NUREG/BR-0184, Table 5.6 (1990$ costs, within 50 miles):
                                        - average for all NUREG-1 150 plants = $2.46E8/event -
                                        - highest NUREG-1 150 plant (Peach Bottom) = $2.71 E9/event AOE     Onsite exposure     5.7.3     Immediate occupational dose (3,300 P-Rem)                                           $2K Long term occupational dose (20,000 P-Rem)
ACC     Onsite economic     5.7.6.1   Onsite cleanup and decontamination cost ($1.1E9.single event, PW)                 $76K ARPC     Onsite economic     5.7.6.2   Plant power level.                                                                 $51 K}}

Latest revision as of 06:36, 23 November 2019

E-MAIL: (NPA-PD) Cost Benefit Equation Terms
ML071570118
Person / Time
Site: Pilgrim
Issue date: 05/24/2007
From: Palla R
NRC/NRR/ADES
To: Jackie Jones
Sandia
References
TAC MD3698
Download: ML071570118 (3)
v • d • e


Text

iRort Palla - Cost Benefit Equation Terms ..... Page 1 From: Robert Palla To: jojones@sandia.gov Date: 05/24/2007 7:10:00 AM

Subject:

Cost Benefit Equation Terms Joe - I am not sure whether I had provided you with this table previously. Itshows how each of the terms in the cost benefit equation are derived, and their relative significance for Pilgrim. Bob CC: nbixler@sandia.gov

1.C':\t6ýip\GW)00001.ýýTýýý'MPý-' -P-aiWi11 1<

Page Ic:\te1~n p\GW}OOQOl .TMP Mail Envelope Properties (46557288.5A6 :18 :10412)

Subject:

Cost Benefit Equation Terms Creation Date 05/24/2007 7:10:00 AM From: Robert Palla Created By: RLP3 (@l)nrc.gov Recipients Action Date & Time sandia.gov Transferred 05/24/2007 7:10:30 AM jojones (ioiones(asandia.gov) nbixler CC (nbixler(asandia.gov)

Post Office Delivered Route sandia.gov Files Size Date & Time MESSAGE 505 05/24/2007 7:10:00 AM Cost benefit equation and description of terms.wpd 9603 02/21/2007 11:13:12 AM Options Auto Delete: No Expiration Date: None Notify Recipients: Yes Priority: Standard ReplyRequested: No Return Notification: None Concealed

Subject:

No Security: Standard To Be Delivered: Immediate Status Tracking: Delivered & Opened

.3 4

Net Value = (APE + AOC + AOE + AOSC) - COE, where APE = averted public exposure costs AOC = averted offsite property damage costs AOE = averted occupational exposure costs AOSC = averted onsite costs averted cleanup and decontamination costs (ACC) + averted replacement power costs (ARPC)

COE- cost of enhancement Cost Significance NUREG/BR- Related Parameters Value If All Internally-Initiated Core Factor 0184 Section Damage Events at Pilgrim Are Eliminated APE Offsite exposure 5.7.1 AP-Rem (from MACCS2) $314K AOC Offsite economic 5.7.5 AOffsite Economic Cost Risk - OECR (from MACCS2) $566K From 12/12/2006 Entergy letter, Attachment C, Table E. 1-15:

- CAPB-12: $4.85E6/event

- CAPB-14: $4.96E9/event

- CAPB-15: $18.0E9/event

- frequency-weighted sum for all CAPBs = $8.21 E9/event From NUREG/BR-0184, Table 5.6 (1990$ costs, within 50 miles):

- average for all NUREG-1 150 plants = $2.46E8/event -

- highest NUREG-1 150 plant (Peach Bottom) = $2.71 E9/event AOE Onsite exposure 5.7.3 Immediate occupational dose (3,300 P-Rem) $2K Long term occupational dose (20,000 P-Rem)

ACC Onsite economic 5.7.6.1 Onsite cleanup and decontamination cost ($1.1E9.single event, PW) $76K ARPC Onsite economic 5.7.6.2 Plant power level. $51 K

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML071570118&oldid=2176644"