ML20234E533

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Forwards News Clips Re Petition to California Supreme Court Requesting Reopening of Plant Site Issue Before State of CA Puc.Rw Smith Memo Will Include Justices Views at Hearing
ML20234E533
Person / Time
Site: 05000000, Bodega Bay
Issue date: 02/05/1964
From: Southwick R
US ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION (AEC)
To: Fouchard J
US ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION (AEC)
Shared Package
ML20234A767 List: ... further results
References
FOIA-85-665 NUDOCS 8709220425
Download: ML20234E533 (3)
v • d • e


Text

- - _ _ _ _ -

r C-1

~

Joe L " rd, Wees Seevise Reseek pahemmary 3,' iM4 Divisies of Feb11s '=" - ^1 % 4 Aedmay L. Sometensk, Ameisteet to the Manager fee Publis Infommetten, SAR f Hung annona . cag3pagggA guyama CeWRT ft:RL5 $ O- )0[

Atteshed are Clipe en the petition as the Califeenata supreme Court regnesties respesieg of the todage Eey seems bedess the State tehtas 1seesseema Commissimas and 1stsar to Editor.

a. v. aesth, Complianos Besiae V. is w =,a @ te 1ms Eurablith ta Ceglienee en seen of the vasens of the Jeettaes ,_

-

  • at the hearing. He espeet later to have a % and =111 ameused a sammary, in detait, if the court deals with time subject of fadseal ,E: .-*- in the field of easleer safety.

Arteshmente: -

As stated ces Emmeld Prise, RSS, 4 , w/ attache.

(Rabert Legenotgie SLEE . 4,_._w/ attache.

F. E. Pitteen, BGB, Elt, w/etteshe.

J. B. Lymes, 991, 4, w/ettaehe.

R. W. Smith, Comp 1. V., 845, w/attaehe.

& h eQ? To ,

'NWxf?;

FI

\ SOWERWICKint, Q92pg;g5e52227 I'DPU 3 pf:2, FIRESTOB5-665 PDR j

I

.noissin. bus red

\ .nu nekat saw esac ehT . yen

.rotta ELGP .f eihc ,yessirroM

.C nhoJ dna CU? eht rof les

.nuoc feihc ,elttuT .E drahciR  !

erew s .t i y e r D gnisoppO

.stnalp [

- {

raelcun .ci rotcaf ytefas eht no ;. ..:. ..r f o dleif eht l

detpme erp d:h CEA eht taht .

gnorw saw CUP gnimialc eht dias ehni,y!dnoce S .ylpp a '

.draeah rojam a i ton did gniraeher a gnitseuq etutitsnoc ot sa tluaf ekauq .noisiced C:IP a tn airhh l

.er rof snoitatimh, fo etutats .htrac saerdnA naS eht ot .cr eht rof dcdi eb thgim l s no miret raen os tliub eb dluow tnalp noititep a hci:tu nihtiw emit f

.n'noissimmoc i na saw redro CUP ehtlani,

.e

.giro eht ecnis taht dias eH eht smialc noitaicessa sill etinifed a tes dah erutn! sine.l

,truoc hgih eht erofeb CUP .delif si redro lan!! eht .etatS disnoc eht dias ciI ot noitcidsiruj .esac eht re deke.h eht yb stniop owt degnel litnu noitcidsigj sniater nois truoc eht dias yessirroM

.lahc noitaicossa eht rof yen .simmoc eht taht dna redro

. rot.. a ,sufyerD nimajneB miretni na ylno saw tcejorp .etal oul delif saw 1 4 deined .agedoB eht fo noitazirohtua noititep eht esuaecb detnsrg saw gnirach.er rof noititep neeb a y a b t o n d Iuoc gni CUP taht detsisni sufyerD .raeher a ,eussi ytefas eht no ehT .ekauqhtrae morf regnad , emit fo ecnedive wen dah ti gniyas ttoitcidsiruj dah noissimmoc taht dnetxe ot ytirohtua on eht fi neve taht deugra , CUP

.remmus tsal gniraeh rehto dah truoC emerpuS. eht dna eht rof lesnuoc feihc ,elttuT l

.na rof CUP eht deksa ,tluaf i

saerdnA naS eht raen oot eb .E drahci,R dim .E&GP cof dluow tnalp eht taht segrahc yen ro;ta yessirrolh nhol.

,ytclas rec!cun fo snoit hcihw rebraH dna daeH aged o .seuq ni noitcicsiutj detpme

.oB evreserP ot noitaicossA 3 .erp sah noissimmcC ygrenE ainrofilaC nrehtroN ehT i cimotA eht sdnuorg no tsu

.ytef as sti ot sa nois

.simmoC ygrenE cimot A eht

. .guA tsal gnir.teher a noitaz fo lavorppa eht no tnegnit .jnagro sdI deined yllufgnor u noc ,2691.rebmevoN ni tnalp CUP eht- taht dedneinuc

,robrail dna dac!l a,"edoD eht dezirohtua noissimmoc ehT .tnalp eht dliub ot noitac evrescrP ot n.maicossA ain

.ilppa s ynapmoc eht no sgnI .rofilaC nrehtroN eht rof yen l

i -raeh n'epc.er ot noissimmoC .rotta ,suf3 crD nimajne l

.ytefas fo cassi eht no ';mi .

seithitU cilbuP e t a t S eht .raeh rehtona meht tnarg 01 l redro ot truoc eht denoititep dah tnalp eht fo stnenoppO noissimmoC scitilitU cilbuP .

l

.daeH agedoF no dliub ainrofilaC eht redro ot iruoc eht deksa tnalp noilHm 1M ot stnaw .oC cirtcelE dna

. sag cificaP taht tnalp rewop desoporp s'.oC cirtcelE d.c:

sag cilicaP fo smenopp0 raelcun laisrevortnoc eht no stnemu,pr c yadretsey stnemugra draeh truoC emerpuS etatS ehT laro gno!.gnincom retf a truoC cmerpuS ainrofilaC eht yb y a d r e ts e y noia l

suelP sraeH ' ' -simbus rednu nekat saw 7

ysrevortnoc tnalp ecuop lTMOC CMCPfH$ ' raelcun yaB agedoB ehT D

UDM8eh - - -

euSSi2O" CdO3 tna}yh- STO,C:SD O .l...

. , I e .

e 0., ..6sO

,f . . o ..c a aned03- s ./ /

+H2cs + 4691 5.s,r ..a,w . .

' reniumxGI.S-C ejtcP - t. s a A. t v... ...

- 3 y

k jL ,

.. Q -

^ ,y 3 Page C-S.F.iExaminer

.'8,5 ! b . u<..lj wed.. Fed. 5.1964 ^

  • SC2H*

3/cf. o n

- s s o C 0 u , ?,

%c. t -

D00cG3 b Considers M} ant' , ,

SOGCC5, issue a r

N.aCRTlBg

_The EMega Bay nuclear ,~

powce plant controversy -jnpreme Cogyf was taken under submis.

sion y e s t e r d a y by the "

.IIerirs Pleur California Supreme Court The State Supreme Court hfter morning long oral heard arguments yesterday ar;;uments.

on the controversial nuclear Opponents of Paci!ic Gas power plant that Pacific Gas <.

had Elcetric Co 's proposed

.%3.mi! Hon phmt asked the and . Electric Co. wants to build on Bodega Head.

court to ordcr the California Oppone.nts of the plant had Public Utilitics Commission petitioned the court to order

, to gr:mt them ar.other hear. ~

. he on the issue of safety. the S t a t e Public Utilities Denjamin Drey fus, attor. Commission to re open hear.

my for the Northern Califor., ings on the company's appli.

.ia Anociatit.n to Preserve cation to build the plant. The Dodega l! cad and 11 arbor, commission' authorized ' the plcnt in November;1962, con-contended that the PUC tingent on the approval of u rongtully denicd Ids organi.

zation a rehe;. ring last Aug- I the Atomic Energy Commis-ust on ;; rounds the Atomic i sion as to its safety.

Energy Commission has pre. The Northern California empted jurisdiction in ques- o Association to Preserve Eo.

tions of nuc! car safety. dega Head and Harbor which

,lohn Morrissey, attorney charges that the plant would foc PG&E. and Richard E. be too near the San Andreas Tettic, chief counsel for the smd the Supreme Court had fault, asked the PUC,for an-PUC. argued that cren if the no authority to extend that other hearing last summer, commission had jurisdiction saying it had new evidence of time. danger from earthquake. The on the safety issue, a rehear.

ing co u 1 d n o t h a y e been Dreyius insisted that PUC petition for re-hearing was granted bceause the petition authorization of the Bodega denied 41.

w as iiled too late. project was only an interim. Denjamin Dreyfus, attor-  !

order and that the commis. ney for the association' chal-Mornssey said the court sion retams jurisdiction until lenged two points by the bcked jurisd:etion to consid- PUC before the high court..

the final order as filed.

er the case. lic said the State ' He said that since the orig-l.egishiture had set a definite Ilis anociation claims the inal PUC order -was an in- i time within v.hich a petition plant would be built no near = terim' one, the co;nmission's  !

might be hied for the tc. to .the San Andreas carth- l statute of limitations for re-hearm:: of a Pl'C decision. (luake fault as to constitute questing a rehearing did not a ma. lor hatard.

apply. Second!y, he said the PUC was wrong in claiming that the AEC h.d prc<mpted

. the field of :di;.; on the

- ' safety ' factor it.c nuclear plants.

Opposing Dr e y I u s were .

. Richard E. Tuttle, chief coun. 'l sel for the PUC, and John C. 'i Morrissey, chief PG!.:E attor.

ney. The case was taken= un. .

der submissions gl

.) . )

s 1

i j

l

  • W'li.-.1x, ?).c/Lq Plant at Bodega Editor-l read the statements about the P. G. & E. nuclear power plant at . Bodega by David E.

Pesonen of the Northern Califor.

nia Association to preserve Bodega Head and Harbor in The Chronicle January 30.

As an electrical engineer, licensed in the State of California, as a lover and preserver of the beauty and history of our State, I would like to make the following comments:

The nuclear plant at Bodega will be absolutely safe, if built, be-cause it can be built only with the ,

consent of the Atomic Energy  !

Commission. I think it is self.

evident that they have available the finest geological as well as other eng;neering talent . .

Anyone -vho . . . d r i v e s to Bodega Bay nd Head will see that ,

the plant and environment as -

planned by P. G. & E. will add  ;

physical beauty to Bodega Head.

  • We must also remember that the products of the minds that God has given to certain members of mankind are also His works.and have a great beauty in themselves.

I think Mr. Pesonen could do a tremendous service in preserving the beauty of Bodega Bay and Head if he could get the area cleaned . . . so that it would not look like a badly kept garbage dump, as it now does.

LOUIS ETS.HOKIN.

San Francisco.

l I

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20234E533&oldid=3193800"