ML20234A996
Text
F
,.. n,,
...a
.u:.. -.
- . a
.2 :., ; '
'i.euk
%. M Ls a,.
?.a.
,<u
-1 1
?
COUNTY-OF SONOMA RIC44AO M. HANSEY OTTICE OT oseuw..
ec une, counss' COUNTY COUNSEL
- v. v. witcHeoca 103 COUNTY ADMDTISTRATION CENTER ROBERT A. REHBERG
~
RfCH ARO E. DAFLER JOHN C. G AFFNEY M MENDWHO AVENUE
- ss v. cov=re covess' SANTA ROSA. CAUTORNIA March 22, 1963 j
s Mr.' Sidney Kingsley, Esq.,
Assistant General Counsel (Soliciter)
Atomic Energy Commission Washington 25, D.C.
1 Re:
Petition for Writ of Mandamus to compel County Board of Supervisors to revoke a j
zoning use permit granted to Pacific Gas and Electric Company for its Bodega Bay Nuclear Power Plant
Dear Mr. Kingsley:
l On March 22nd we contacted, by phone, Mr. Howard l
Shapar of your Division of Licensing and Regulation to determine I
whether the Atomic Energy Commission would be willing to become.
involved in the captioned matter.
He asked that we send the' Pleadings to you and indicated that you would try to call us on
)
Monday, March 25th, to let us know what the A.E.C. position will l
be.
l I
We have determined that our approach will be (1) a l
Demurrer on the ground of laches, (2) a Motion to -Strike Paragraph XVII (Radiation Safety Consideration) as irrelevent and redundant, (3) an answer as to the remaining allegations.
The A.E.C. will probably not be concerned with the Demurrer or Answers but will be directly concerned with the Motion to Strike.
Our argument in favor of that Motion will be:
i
- 1. Radiation Safety considerations in this case are irrelevent because the Federal Government has occtipied the field.
- 2. Radiation Safety considerations in this case are irrelevent because the Stat'e of California has occupied the field.
- 3. By conditioning the Use Permit upon Pacific Gas and Electric's obtaining all necessary permits from State and Federal Agencies the Board of Supervisors has completely. fulfilled its obligation to consider the health, safety and general welfare of the public as required by the Ioning Ordinance. (The theory here is that the Board of Supervisors is obligated to consider radiation safety but may pass the obligation on to State and Federal Agencies.)
mrM1*7"Y "" ~
~
~ me '
0 0 9J DW8f
- j SPpp 8 x
r'74
~
e
, 4 e
Mr. Stdney Kingsley, Esq.,
Assistant General Counsel (Soliciter)
Atomic Energy Commission
'iashington 23, D. C.
Page 2 3-22-63
- 4. That Paragraph XVII is merely a speculation as to what will develop at a hearing. (The theory here, by implication, is that the Board must hear and decide radiation safety questions).
In our pleadings we intend to raise the issue of Federal and State occupancy of the field so that intervention or an Amicus Brief by the A.E.C. or State will be possible.
We also feel that this point may establish a definite precedent in the conduct of hearings by local boards and either facilitate or make unduly burdensome those local hearings.
l We plan to file our Demurrer, Motion to Strike and Answer on April 1,1963 and forsee that on that day the Court will set a date for argument.
Should the A.E.C. wish to intervene or file its Amicus Brief we suggest that the Court be apprised as soon as possible.
Should we be able to help youany further in your decision please feel free to call us.
/
d
.g rs truly,
/
Q y/
.Du.~.
Robert A. Rehberg Deputy County Counsel RAR: fl Encl.
cc: Coordinator, Atomic Energy Development and Radiation Protection, State of California.
TELEPHONE:
Libert 2-4312 r
n 4
e g
. p I
,b p
- - 6 6
8
.,s n
,_d t
A ff
f p :ry g ;p " y M fq q q 'I. w S:f',,
, 1&'~ l
'*"R & V44
. $.E.' 43 SP""*%q.4 PA.JIFIC M ARINE W %
1..
^
d'.)
'4k N
W:o.E 3 4E N
w n 2hp af A.N.6 3 '
- y M.r%gggQ }.f.f.y.
r y
v e u,. v % :,., q.'m y &<, ; w.2 h
.ggy, i w v.
y wa =
,,,w
.;a 4,.y.mfu.& 9.
..g:. s V.~jf.Ti
- u. MAWMlg...
. z.
p.
y
, Yvge
.W{;q$ r,. [ *g*
'd.b,pagg 4y
,.Q, 2 G wk 's-
.t. c ;,..f. A g 4. n.
g."i..!Y' f
D
..#.g BopresentNk.N,.c,.
'dg'@f$gg, -
4.,
w
/f M
iG W t pr.
.y
,N,.2 fl6.
2[f:
vs LClement 11111er M
. > ty ' i
..s:, n; b/ %e.
,:lo.s.,US HoiseNof(Representatives f
DO
~ r%,,
us.htn M,aq. w..
1 4.f,,h.c. q;-
..n..
7
?
- ,yg '
- 2..gm. x.c.+; h. y[hd.'s.
.h 3 4 f... I Mb
.hrDoinr 3
!$[,;.Vp,. IVenoMa;ing{a copy. o ' a letter addressed.?.
ke' A'
- yc v.
N
.ke: 2$
I $l ts WTRb,f.,of the>Pdeific iGaa and Iloct rio Co.7pany, and;eo.
$:)N[M4 iroquirinhaininimum of. u thrw 'yeur study' of fie's" -
' 3 pa..
E Joa11:y'ouWattientioni toLthe : e.:nciuding statamen
$,.', I. remarkvthat Ilfeeliwelshould have*protectiVsi e
i; d
gf Y.
ht?1.nandibiologi' cal' aspects of pondible radiat'ionipd1 i
gj
".Q j hs.. f Mjhfs pomihaanJbe!.~5 ranted by. the EG "J,
hb yplantrin;iiteinoutsN 6,
t'
~
/:' d thehregion concerned.s..I.also. reminey tX
%.i M itr40entilst ooncerninc"the comparative.
ii yh;Mg%g[,dto' ?yodWison.3,.6falloution.theimorth
=@." "9 e
g.. '
h'h-ii QQhjg,Nplantalmayp,stittients;jand t hasimplyiby lunpre inst'llatlon 25 W mater.ially; g
4,l a
.ap
,jQg.p irsaseuredfab(irforease7our alredy gra
,4 On
/some officials ::ith snch statiani)
p, w.i ;
O.
c.j that ' thief,
'onlyZo'ause.100 eesosiof thisi ' ' $hh.
'f
$&jZ,",
9__
y; 1 "f".populinti
~
$jtpat n..ola y;t.
dh fourth @awph he.;. fallout s o c cu r sthenoa' es\\is..no W
L h,
where' ys s,may ode kFof.)those? cases"rinyibe' you; er ::o(if gM t
v
, and if wela'rE j.'N.
y> f.Y. jouution; M y able',on th@doofdingly I a.*boonstr we shoul' eertainl
';pt~de
%. i h h M.;g,g gsarionsf@roonRidecation,. as it 4
M d to. cive this.'problesf * '
- o,G is my impreasion'.t k
- t.
M
' ; [ is:%ndiELuottle; Company 12 : ss.ure of: sts "o'bLi
' ?!
i 1
C
)).1
?.matterb It/s'eemsT tc me that ;the
~
~~'
' get' Star'ked. in nucleah power /g' "
todEoglystoisatisfyithedrat d[
x cinia+EnergyScots.lssion#
Werisj Fdif,p ah oul dfbe ' t hei r"M Be" finas,o i
' Jeug.. '
ens)~ud:,esn and un'.pormit< t'o Lo
/
"i.Vo f
' d{lbd$ontingentMpon the.)'ghn resjil ito Wregram.lifiI:ndt in6u el ACsi if6pildPhnidtford.$
e m.s,
g eep 5
b704F#
~u Y.
o>
,.e t=
4 E y$'&WCYh?
W f,
R Wdk e
[.f h. h h h k hk k
4 y,.i d
. c.
. mm,. 7 ;
g y. v.; - n.e
- ymeew?
- yr -_
(
Q97$4?s:ss~
xtT
~ #?*WTIPi,4
.i Aq s.q ' '
. g..dg;.4p, k
,j yys y;p
,s
'k.3,; yj:. e
? m.* n j
q
.c y
I, f *. f
??j$......,.f,;0m,,j.@L{&
g.g /# :dfj,..
j'['{"jf;
$g
,f ov., $.
s
. v n.,
f;9e'E % -.
j gy S
%VW f
g>
_?
,g eg: 9 ynt y
ot(Ytht 9
WI 5
i ur..ia.nsw i
e n n ;,:.--
h 'N b 1
7;;flG'~;f.y.).$,y y
?
w;:
u
~.
3 Eny
,yj i,f.'
?5l.'}t.
j hfoalled to) 2nyi i
?
i't ted' 4'-
1
'syfonf 5
cast'i '
m'-
4 j
.Nfd*
-f s
e y'
g w $.i.' fue 9
he Na l>
L 9
i
.I
,,.""1,,',...
L l
- g. ;, -,
,,.,r.e; r -
-~.; r--.
-- - - - --- -- -,7jh
(
p
~.(
' g.i ~y.g
.y.
yra D:%
y, nr y 1. o p
- q,
,I* g
'.k,3
.i 1.
k':(I'
'A
, h
,4Y Qff$ v$'%w, M' l[. r.m?,. *
,.i n^5 tat.
F V :,..
F[
WNb,b. ' ' $., '
h,k h
[Fj; ' 4
?T,go, Q s preblaut.
Ar unmple,.anch tar the ar,iand huferu.it can be appro,
- 4 g/
g,4 ' lo'a3F yver hould k.. w whether thesleb y'
s what51 easientla11y the :'-
ht17 up'littet,4e f,
[%g*s
- i. )',
Bodega Eosit.atskds,in relat!<
,e ;'cuales I:,ay)LW g
(iapeg@4 -
the accu,1Et1Atien 'o(radiocc :.
pallution in.T J,.*,'-.tain '6cndi'tibug:of.vind and t Ce (to any nothin he t '
bornd po1%&tief
' a gas-ch:.ed.reuoter, iff n, L; overegon ' '
'eoant '.or. ) and 'thus treh4 t' F 6.;..['
~ import,an h'Mk' ;1tMarf' "
$3espostiom:1 fishing, clam (af 0;
$ foamrserof '
geenisNi; pct-t: ally Aargerouas
- ..,. 7 plantAn the."ocew...". phi'o. pr6 blomsgo,1 the;!Msti l'd i G
.cozapany w decide to expand'
,[j !
' %' 4eT gaN =lM"i__. 7
, &;pp,An dae@qua$Q%f.S$ga, tion.to ir u= t.cate then izt 81 M ' ent,, butt. *be'iob 3N q:
~
.k P -
s ':.;Y r
b QW$
,Q
,rJ F telistudyc'rletkr$bg' on ih<.so proti, ems aho E
I
{i
, G200,000:4
fo.three years.
3 11e I do not'i d'i lSt.4,3goodffin' = -
,q.taelf rs iM,undertakeH't hi s 1 :.y e e t i gut io n', ; t' y
I,#
y%
MicaQwith 465,000,000.ne h3
=
heYe.5 f *?,Q,t,i
~'., :
$r.elictie Investigst
- FIndeeth,g,.
~
A
' y \\ ( j p'r.",, 5
- J O
dn, ffnanci.g Thetork'.Q.cf Ethere seems3to
)R c
artiag 1'taCpl(.ianT 4
VtheiBia04 kin'Tactia
?,M'i,2to2 oMhist
?$6jadaliz d
}Gossais' isdM,1 feer thaticyggp%'"
byly.
d' d i :parmit.Jfrofi.~thi
'h
.~
Y'QE'Publin) h'g,gC.obgrek(
s ig g gpou this prob 1Ekisan@g5 C M P " ~Y rv
,..ppop9s fdk. 4Wourd requiref,,,'minimumf y.:Intonal e'stanted. k^1 :en to'operatg W.
e'permis
the'deasesis 11.sht ip~oint 'outg p
w oosting" 000g'.wbuld be substantiallyule'
yb gof.
PAndathef
- W Ao11ars that has bee'aune g
tie ffa?.
F ser Bodegu head., Soseffize itr(.seems to me that suchii$
MDotoron "c
~*
' MhF *"
& wou14'; " ' ).
Soref
'~ Ias 'a6ertisemerit.t
^
l yn, such at1,tha,Cd i
b1'J.d 7
3 h
y 4 3,
. n p#. e,7 l
J i
s : '.
n.' ~...
t u
I o
E' N
(w,eam.e n.,m Y^~'
h,>,
y -
~
/m T.. d 1
d.CM*'
th OA
.yNo
%$Of lh%dt.[ :
,.,l
!.'i f,.
((N1%
%.A%
h%.M.
l"~
.n
., ;.~... - -
--ng er-~eyyv ;~r.Y"r."
" Y WCWWKW " ~
?!!
i'
~
.T D
R
/ N
.R
.eF~R
.S O
e E
.Wo
,.C h/ I s
.R RrCmn W
j.vA T
t
.C
.J.
b.
,nCH e
ah LE
,RkN mo
. m
,h o.
a
,F c
I D
U s
y,i,us.,n L u l gJ R G
G
, y, d,ekrslvFeo al n nrrsnieola s
,b e i ;,
o u a a a l d l a t 'e,l E
en ssrnee n
R sewrlreuCs eh rsrnng a
- Dp nld aeorocuet o eueuaa g
J.
Ni hFEKD BFDMGLSJ gNFCLP r
o o
Al o
R M
~
S J
G Ng f
1 n cf ut i
(
IR
- E u Co L.
F O
-..N s
O y
R.F y
t I
r l,N a
e S
M
.GDd~,thR.' W e
I RcR T
,J R.
V L
.leno
. L r
,D
,M,R M, x, R K
I y
H.S t
.ECiabd s
D J,,n A
,f mhnl
,e; s
e, e, b r
,skt orewl iyolr
, 'n,.,, i rscal sl nhot
,R rh C,
es eeessl e e f.
at cs v
a k
r l
r o,e l
a kauaroreiorNiuWH ckcoa M,H s,
e m
cCLWGGINBCB i
iRM i
a t
e ri e
P K n-B S
R
=
',2
/
y
~*
- F
.;11lf3(yifqU -
. ~
. (,- ?Jj -n
- J; 7.,
7 311d!jl ji a m n1't y 3,
( il 63 5, Q
1 4
e l
7f
.s
.s+
6
-d*
N i,.
/ '
.E R-
. E.
- C OE N C N TH N H
E E A T O T OA V
E C S C
E R N A L E
DG S O G F L N E.
_ EA F
t O
A 0 S7 N
I S
N C M@r si 1
5 a
HE E O T
E, uG N 2
I A L T C OCT E I
O T.
DA I
I TI M A A
WF F S S D, EM 9
F S F EA R M R 6
)
L I
C L F T
a LP E /
X E
O E
@O Wt A
P N A A 8
I e V
O E
R N A
D
.I NH E
D E A H HY Y ROC s
8 C /
N W O AP Os I N R WT N L OI tMM E
7 E
y I
R 5 S T FH F S A K
S N
E S
N u
O' S R N.E W C
0 E
S A L OG 6 i oD.bIr R
E T
O A
UI s
n C
s A
R E R EO A O D
A F
e a
(
VR S
N G
O N
G c
r Er e
m.
D C
B R I
E N
E I
O NE 3
E T HR e
A A
e.
g Y
n n
E R ILC3 DF CTE Ei R
yf J
5 LE E H
A U
UR P DT P 4
E n.
p D
T R
O S E E L F T. -
2 I
e eX H S E T R A 0
B A
E r r S T R UI P N B
O N
G F
t u d.k1 7
G A
mt e...
I R O O NS D
S O N
Y2SM a
Ninh ILF I R. D I
O 2 E
A-SI R
R R
r S
NL e g
.EO U S I
O R
- HE R
E t i c E
A O Rek G
G n si _
T A
gEF E
s S
T MS BS O AS P -
C O
R A
I MI I
A L
P A
I A
L r
E R
N 9 Y
I D. II H
R R E
RI F
N A
f o O
N G
E 5 L A L A S A E R
Y A
R C
A f
D P t L N P T P
M /
A
- S M
F L
M D
N N
E u E OE P P
N N
N C a I
R oL CI CR A E-I U s O
OG E
A L
N O
O U
P H B
A HA F F C
O /
a S NI LE NF O G L T
M E
N T
R O-gS R
A R
E L
E R
E D 5 E
S K L. OO a_
D F
g I Mt f
C d.f 1 /
T H
R t
N D
E R A RI EN A U
M I
N F
A A
O R
R R
H E
Y I
A O
S H CI O
E C
G
.E E
N WNT S C I
N U I
P H
E T
O C
G L
D EL gH P
E C
G T E I
F R N
/
S F
T E
0 ER HF EA A
L O )7 1
R N
M T
c C( T LGWOCM P
R I
Mg g g
7 E
$gg i<>
2 A
e M'i 1
1 M,-
gI M
M s
e N
l
'u l
6 0
i n
(
P r
g r
O t
t I
L i
C
)
i E
. D i
I t
^
r a
D O
l u
c D
N
~.,
h a
a R
.II
$E g
5 c
O b
5.
I I
h A
c i
(
^
TC a
3 y
NC E
F N
g l
- !I_
it
~
m a
A s
ga E
=
d l
t I
M N
t u
O y
J I
M M
T O
S c
o P
K R
R M[gggO A
M C
j k
e M
S O
e R
O k E
E
_ F m T s D
R
,;1 g{
g' 2.
i i,d.
,'la3,a!5. j'Ih e
., *t'.I' n,. l~ 11 i
O? n, ),;;
90,
1' Jj.
'a'
, j t
g 3t Y
b T
D R
N R
.eFR
. S O
e 3
.Wo
.C~,
f I
t
. C
.J
.R RrCmn W
E
,RkN ~,nGH',
T a
e ah A
D L
,F c
mo
. m
,h o.
~.
/,
L s
y,i,us.,n LuleJR G
U
, y, d,ekrsl vFeo
.al n G
nrrsnieola,l s
,b e i,,
ldaebrocuet o eueuaa g
ouaaaldl at en ssrnee n
/
E R
sewrlreuCseeh rsrnng a
Dp FEKDI FDMGLSJ Al gNFCLP r
Ni o
o R
M S
i G
Ng I n S
.b.i
/f t
u
~
vij
~
o IR L
c i
F
~
~
O N
r r
R :F
's 0
y l
R t ;/
s
- a
,N e
r
- M
.GDd - hR..W e
T L
,J
.l
,t i
i
.R RCR T
r
~Li
,D K
D bs.
.ECiabd, M y, R M
,R eno s
H.
t,
,fmhnl
,e
,x, Jnn A
R=
rh C,
rscal sl nhot es eeessl eet at cs
,ai s
nv a
k br
,skt orewl syolr nar l
r e,-
c
- oa kauar,GINBCBBWH oreioroiu ohe l
a ir RM cCLW" e
scH e
m ri
~
B ai t
e PE l
MB S
R
,l!)',,
',4
-i;.l { 3Li i j 8I! ~
i > ;i! Ij.<
e a
x
- g
~
3Y$hjQd',6I'
- M1i]3{1W Qtf;4i IA-
,-.i f ;)
x
. j:)
7!
3i,-
- j;.
J c
I
- p i
n E
- . i L
.1 I
v.2.:..-
- c. u _.c s,o.. - _ __
1
(
(
/
FROMs' DATE OF DOCUMENT DATE RECEIVED:
mr. cum unum (cm) 5/ss/59 s/29/59 FILE CODES CROSS INDEKs TOs MR. J0ER'A. McCQEE, M A N A% AEc DE SCRIPTIO N:
CONGRESSIONAL MARC SHOULD BE ANSWERED WITHIN SEVEN MM M M 5, (7) WORKING DAYS OF ITS REFERRAL TO AN OFFICE FOR AC.
ggg g qg g
TION. ALL REPLIES. IR RESPECTIVE OF WHO IS TO SIGN THE LETTER. SHOULD BE ROUTED THROUGH THE OFFICE OF CON.
gg ggg R E S SION AL LI AISO N.
IF THERE IS ANY Q UESTIO N AS TO M M NAM M M 91 --
-m.
HicH orygCE SHOULD PREPARE A REPLY. PLEASE CALL THE 3
OFFICE OF CONGRESSIONAL LIAISON. FOR INFORMATION CON.
' NM N
p CER NIN G PR E P A R ATIO N OF CONGRESSIONAL MAIL SEE AEC MANU AL CHAPTERS 0287. 0243 AND WA CHAPTER 0287.
REMARK 8s REPLY TO BE PREPARED BYs D ATEs l
maunca raramame 5/a9 PREPARE REPLY FOR SIGN ATURE OFs CH AIR M AN GENERAL MANAGER l
l i
ASST. GENER AL M ANAGER l
A. TAletABO l
l DivlSloN DIRECTOR IN STR UCTIO N Ss l
NWMRTO N N l
INFORMATION COPIES HAVE BEEN SENT TOs CH AIR M A N GENERAL M ANAGER S
OFFICE OF GENERAL COUNSEL H
M TAMARO c
g, b,
I b.
J p... U.S. ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION CONGRESSIONAL CORRESPONDENCE' CONTROL FORM' ~
WASHINGTON. D. C.
FORM W A.122 41 50)
I i
1 l
1
+
"~ Y [**.
L-__:'_
}
- t~l t