ML20077N587

From kanterella
Revision as of 11:20, 25 April 2020 by StriderTol (talk | contribs) (StriderTol Bot insert)
(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Forwards Ltr Agreement Between Licensee & Hartsville Group Settling Remaining Discovery Disputes Re Hartsville 830711 Motion to Compel Applicant Responses to Interrogatories & Requests to Produce Documents
ML20077N587
Person / Time
Site: Robinson Duke Energy icon.png
Issue date: 09/08/1983
From: Trowbridge G
CAROLINA POWER & LIGHT CO., SHAW, PITTMAN, POTTS & TROWBRIDGE
To: Margulies M
Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
References
ISSUANCES-OL, NUDOCS 8309130172
Download: ML20077N587 (7)


Text

__ -_ - . - - -

} .

SHAW, PITTMAN, PoTTs & TROWBRIDGffshU

. pA-sete.M,p Or enO,ESS,0se AL CO.*Om&T,0NS isOO M sTattT. N. W.

. ..s , OTo~.o.c.2003. '83 SEP 12 Pi2:33 mA=SAv 0. pOTts. pA SeeELOON J. wteSEL. p C. (zoal sta sooo ,g,,g ,,,,,,ggo , g,,,,,,,,,,,,,,

STEuam?6pf7?osAN.94 JOMM A. osecubLouGM. p C. - JACn MeoWlet ar a -. .. .e ANOmEw 0. ELUS e Omot r. t=Owen.Ost, oc J. DATm.Cn McCmEv. pc TMOMAS pr. recomekn M DIt, meCaAm0 A. SAMa eTEpeeEN O. pOTTS. p C. J. Twow&S LENMAmt. ac TELECOpita STEVEN 6 MELT 3En. pA doMN 6. Cneyt PMeup J. Ma evEfom.i.l% &.$ .=8wtNDEuN mMOMAS oA.CpocmEn.sm.

WestTE OEm&LO pas.uip O. CM.ansecrr.

OSTwiCa. pc* C. ' OEAN O. AvuC=. oc . caOa) saa. ions s saa "** mO.Em7 M. oOmOou R A N Jt STANLET ..Amo

. O. TeesOTMY MasutOse, et JoseN EesoEL pc _ samaanaJ.esomOEN ggggg g, gnegy, (EORGE as mOGEmS.Ja et CMamLES e. TEssarN. PA BONNit S. 60TTut e rmE*) A. EfTTLE pA STEpoetas a. MyTTLE m. pA maperAs 300 MOwamo M. SMArrEmesAN venGesesA,S. muTLEOGE ggy,,g g, g p,gaggg JOs.N Q. mMcNELAseOR A. 94 wsNTeemOp M. SmOwm. pA DEsonAMt.SAUSEm ga,,,.E LEme*En STEIN SouCE W. CasueCM866 pt Janett 3. uAesues, pt WOa! SEE soft SCOTT A. ANENetmG LESUE A. selCMOLSOpe,Jm PA se&NOAL s. mELL pt CAMpeELL x86LE rEn Tmaves T. amOwN.se.

es; mTtN O. am&LL pc most m? g. 2AMLE R, p.C. _ m'CMamO M.mmONTs.AL DAUL es. TMOMAS meCMAmO J. MENOALL 84 "" E " 8 *E'"'"

moet NT E. mOSSIMS. 94 ygggy SETM M. MOOGAS4AN ANOmA E. S"

  • MUSCA,"

JAY CL SILDERS. pt STEVEN es. LvCAS. #A SMENA secC. MaevE?

sameAmA m.20 8077i pc EE E" ' spo*"E" OAviO es. pueENSTEiN. oc Se.aees (SMAwbAw wSee) DEuSSA A. RiOGw&T pAMELA M. ANDERSON mom 6E V. ALLEN.Jm p& mtCMenO L GALEN REsemeETM J. MayTMAN reE7 DelASNEm. et LYeeN WMf77LESET WILSOes CASLE 'SeeAwoAw OAvs0 LAwmENCE MILLgm ALEmAesOEm D. TOneASEC2um SL mEseLY WESSTE m. 94 MATIAS r.TmAviESO DIA3 ~

WMeum O.PO m a NAfosAsesEL p. SRESO.Jm pA vsCTOmeA J. PteemeNS rmEOSmeCm L mLE.IN STEVEN p. ofTLgg osaCMAEL A. SweGEm esamet AUSEseSUCal, pA JOet N M. O'NEILL Ja, meCMAmo J. pannesso ELLEN SMEmirr EsseEST L SLARE.Jm. pC JAY A. EPSTIEN

    • ""'**^e ELLkN A. rmEDEL 8 ANITA J. rINNELSTEles cam 6ETON S. JONES.pr m&NO L. Au.EN MANNAset.M.uteEm=AN EsLEEN =.oLEmEm T - A..Am m.oc EuSA.Etes .. pEseOLETOe. COuse.EL SaeeOmAE.rOLSO. OAv,0m.SAMA jam 3 es, symGER. e4 mammy M. OLAS5ptEGEL JuOtTM A. SANDLEm C. SOwCOfN TRA8se

- . .se .4 September 8, 1983 ww?E. S 0. meet .AL NvM.Em

. 822-1026 Morton B. Margulies, Chairman Atomic Safety and Licensing Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Re: H. B. Robinson Nuclear Generating Station, Unit 2, Docket No. 50-261 OL

Dear Judge Margulies:

(- With reference to your letter to me dated August 23,  ;

1983, I enclose further letter agreement between the Harts-l ville Group and Applicant's counsel settling all remaining discovery disputes in connection with ths Hartsville Group Motion to Compel Applicant- Responses to Interrogatories and Requests to Produce Documents, dated July 11, 1983.

Res ctfully submitted, l

mg l

! or F. Tr V5r'idge ounsel for Applicant Enclosure cc w/ encl: Service List f*.309130172 830908 PDR ADOCK 05000261 0

l PDR

f' UNITED. STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION k"[hE0 BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING'@OA%B 12 Pi2 :33 0FF!:E OF SEcst p, CCCKEiir4G & SEP. ,:.,

BRANCH In the Matter of )

)

CAROLINA POWER & LIGHT COMPANY ) Docket No. 50-261-OLA

)

(H. B. Robinson SteamjElectric )

ASLBP No. 83-484-03LA Plant,. Unit 2) )

SERVICE LIST .

Administrative Judge Morton B. Margulies Chairman, Atomic Safety and Licensing Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Administrative Judge Jerry R. Kline Atomic Sarety and Licensing Board U.S. . Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Administrative Judge David L. Hetrick Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Professor of Nuclear Engineering University of Arizona l Tucson, Arizona 85721 Docketing & Service Section (3)

Office of the Secretary U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. - 20555 Myron Karman, Esquire Office of Executive Legal Director U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 B. A. Matthews Hartsville Group P. O. Box 1089 Hartsville, South Carolina 29550

a e

Dr. John C. Ruoff P. O. Box 96

- Jenkinsville, South Carolina 29065 Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Board Panel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Samantha Francis Flynn, Esq. .'

Carolina Power & Light Company P. O. Box 1551 Raleigh, North Carolina 27602 e

)

l -

~

l I

f e

I I . , .. . - _ . _ . _ . -__ . . _ . . _ . _ . . _ _ _ . ._.._ - , . ._ ._. _ _ .. ,,_ ___ __ _ ,.

SHAW, PITTMAN, PoTTs & TROWBRIDGE A paarTesteseMe or poortsseoMAL ComeomarsoMs a 1800 M STatET. N. W.

WASM6NGTON. D. C. 20036 maansAT c. po?Ts. e4 sMcLeoes J. wassat. or 04 2 000 ggggg,, g ,,,go,, g,,,,,,,,,y,,,,,

rTruam? 6 pvTTesAes. et JOMN A. McCuLLouow.

  • C. - JACM escMAT ANOscwo.ELus c cesIr.Toowenicos.oc J. PAtmCm MacRET. mA e TMoMas M.Mc.o*Mecn m,CMAmoA.SAMp ETrpMIN O. poTTs. PA J. TMoMAs LEMMAnv. pA TELacoperm JoMN 6CAmm.Jm.

( t MAL 3 CMAmmorr. er STEVEN 6 esELTEEn. ot TwoM As E. CacCut a. J m.

eMeLu> o, mostwsCm.

  • C. OcAss o. AuuCa. PA M2) s22-8096 & C224sse PMeur J. MAnv.tT moogn?M,go goM WC,N DE UN,A.,*M,,ITE g7 ,Lgy , ,
c. TiesoTMT seAgtoes, et Joness tNog6 e4 mameAma J. Deomoe m

_ La Cromos M. mossles.sm PA CMambas s. Treensm. PA sonnet s. SOTTuta y,,s,u,,t,,n.g,pyyggoog surTM ret 1 A.LlTTLE.p A sTapMEN e. MUTTLam, ma mAmeram soo Mowamo M. seeArre pasass mATMamMt p. Coetta JoseN e. mMessat.AseOsm. et wsNTMaop N. smowns. pA e OsmonAMs.aAusan seuCE w. CMuesw P4 Janets a. seAesues. pA Woalestaote scott A. ANENGEmo JANsCE LEMete-sTErm Lasus A. so"p*2 M Ja, PA ma NoAL a. msw PA CatepetLLasLLaram TmAvis T. SnowN.Jm-esamfise 3. neALL. pA messm?t.3AMLam.p4 ~

paub M. TMcMAS CMARO M. RONAL IteCMAsBO ed. MENOAw pA sTEpMEse B. ME8MANN ftoGEfBT 5. 8BOSSems. 94 ygLg3 stTM M. MoceAsnape JAT E. seLSEGIs. PA STEVEN M. Lucas. 94 SMEILA enCC. MA85VEY sANOAA E. SnusCA nameseA M. moseoTTi. or oAviO De. musaNsTries. er no.aeos (sMAwbA= wsM) Ocussa 4. mioowaT E8'EE" 'eno=Neu.

e somos v. Au.am. Jm, mA mCManOE.oALrN meMNrTMJ.MAuTMAN **"*'AM ^ ****o rges 3 Ostagesta. pA LyNee weerTTLgggT witsoM EAObE ,E****b#* OAVID LAwfBEPeCE sesLLg, ALEXANDER o". Toneas"2CZun

' 52. f CMLT wEasTE4. PC MATlas F.71taveEso OeA2 _ ratOgntCM L ALE *MtLip O. postfga feeTeeAssetLp.SDEEo.Jm,P A VtCTosteA J. PEmmeNs STEVEN p. pv7LER.les DesCMAEL A. swfoEn

%AmaAuGatosuCutPA JoMM M.O' Mas w sm. fDeCMAseO J. *Ammesso CLLEN eMEnter 1885e897 6 GLARE.Jm. pA JAT A. EpsTIEN ELLEN A. F5BEDEL' A8 elta J. FIteKELsTEIN gggg p, g gy, CAIBLEToes s.Josess. PA MAseO 6 ALLaN MaNesAM E. M. ugstseesAN EsLEEN es.SLaseetm TMoneas A SW". *A

  • EuSAGETH M. PEteOLEToes CouNesk saasosta L roLaoes DAvec m. SAMm JAmeEJ es. SW8tGER. PA MAmst? M. oLAssestoEL Juesrw A.SaseOLEm C. Sowootes Tmasm

. - - -.a September 1l 1983 wn.Teus Osm.CT ..AL Mu .in 822-1026 4

Mr. B. A..Matthews The Hartsville Group P. O..Dox 1089 Hartsville, South Carolina 29550 _

i I

Dear Mr. Matthews:

This will confirst our further agreements with respect l to additional Hartsville Group interrogatories to which Licensee i objected and with respect to which'Hartsville Group has filed a motion to compel, with the result that agreement has now been reached between us on all discovery disputes covered by Harts-ville Group's motion to compel.

Interrogatories 1-34,1-36 and 1-38. (Disciplinary Actions and Allegations of Harassment)

Licensee will respond further to these intierrogatories by September 30, 1983, subject to the following limitations:

(1) Response to cover only CP&L employees involved l

in non-compliances covered by an NRC notice of violation since January 1, 1978.

, (2) Names and other personal identifying information will not be disclosed in Licensee's response.

l

.c. .

T P' '

.~SHAw, PITTMAN. POTTs & TROWBRIDGE

  • -m.ca .., - ce wio.

Mr. B. A. Matthews September 1, 1983 Page Two-Hartsville Group reserves the right to move the Board for ah order requiring'such disclosure with respect to specifically identified disci-plinary actions or allegations of harassment.

Licensee reserves the right to object and/or seek a protective order with respect to any such motion.

(3) L'icensee's' response will be based on (a) a file search of documents related to the non-compliance and (b) review of the personnel records of the individual (s) involved .

On the basis of these commitments, the motion to compel is withdrawn.

Interrogatory 1-39 (Disagreements)

! Licensee will make further inquiries of management per-sonnel at'the Brunswick, Harris and Robinson facilities who have been present at such facilities in a managerial capacity in the

. period January 1, 1978, to date to provide additional coverage of possible disagreements covered- by this interrogatory during such period.- -

! Licensee will also respond further to this interrogatory by September 30, 1983, based on a file search subject to the fol-lowing limitations: ,

. (1) Response to cover only disagreements associated

., with non-compliances covered by an NRC Notice of violation since January 1, 1978.

(2) Names.an d-ot her personal identifying information will not necessarily be disclosed in Licensee's -

. response. If not, Hartsville Group reserves the .

right to move the Board for an order compelling such disclosure with respect to specifically identified disagreements. Licensee reserves the right to object and/or ceek a protective order with respect to any such motion.

e v vw- - - -e - -.-r, y+ ,,e , ,.--,,.,,7-,4g&-, r.,-,., , , , ,n-, , ,.m,----%c...m,.r-g-e-., . - , -w---,-w

.a. . ., .

f,

SHAW, PITTMAN, PoTTs & TROWBRIDGE aosm e . e o.e m ea m Mr. B. A. biatthews September 1, 1983 Page Three (3) Licensee's response will be based on a file. search of documents related to the non-compliance.

On the basis of these commitments, the motion to compel is withdrawn.

Interrogatories 3-96 through '3--103 and' 3-104 (b) '(Sleevina)

Hartsville Group withdraws its motion to compel taking -

into account the information that Licensee has already submitted.

to the NRC and to the Hartsville Group on.the. sleeving alternative and Licensee's representation that with respect to the sleeving alternative Applicant has not made additional studies or calcula-

~ .

tions necessary to respond to these~ interrogatories and does not intend to do . so ~for its own purposes. On the same basis Hartsville Group withdraws Interrogatory 3-24 of its second set of interrog-atories to Applicant.

l Interrogatories'3-121 and'3-122 (Financial Forecastg In addition to previous answers to Hartsville Group's interrogatories, Licensee has committed to supply to Hartsville Group a supplemental report on the-15; year cost projection pre -

'viously' supplied to.the NRC' Staff and to the Hartsville Group comparing- the steam ' generator replacement alternative with the alternative of retiring the Robinson 2 Unit. Licensee agrees that Hartsville Group may submit further discovery requests to Licensee based on'any new information which may be contained in the supplemental report. Based on these commitments the motion to. compel ~is. withdrawn.

~

Interrogatories 8-27 and'8-28,'and-8-41 through-8-43 i

Licensee withdraws its objections to these interroga-tories and will answer them by September' 30, 1983.

i '

L l

- . . . - . . . . , , . . , ,m-m._ _ _ _ _ . , , _ _ , . . _ _ _ . . , , :_....._,___

e4 q * +9 id I b i 9

! 4 , t, 'I l 4 b{ (J '

'!' ;1 fa '1 c' i 2

i tt

' (o,'N ,

.. L.

e 3 d

  • j g

\

  • g ,

i a*(

g. ,, N ' '

,t, t'- }*

  • 1 .d' 4 14 ('s

, 'I

, (a. 1 *

+

3

' s

(; it i , ,

,'3

,- ) f .  ! ' ,f

' I' 1

1 t t' > , g

\ *1 , (a t' P

, t - -

,, ') Q

, n s\  ; '

>-' l.,. ** .

I'

, e ,

i .

? -,

n e; ,

e, u,

'I

[ ', , '. 1 1* . t4 m '1 I' 1

g. -
  • ~

k \ r ,g b '

+

.1 -

9 ..

L,. , -(t k [ . (,

(3  ;; 3. II $j 4 y.3 i: ' ' "

(t i, 13 tg i

'.1 '1 '. I g [.6 U. ,, p .

i o

( *, 0 3J s A

c; C,

1 c g..>

> x >

I .

x s 'f 2 e. 1 ()

. PS , g o i. La

.., ,a s n .sk(.

ct L-

. ,, , ,. eo" '

l g3 +

-) j ,. . 3

< i eg >> e i*

o t 3 '

- 4

- 6 -]

., r +, :1 - . ,

t. . ,'<

1

,3 >] t= i. (, s 'I ti \' it *1

, (t

'} IA ',

n -

.r'O M *1 t, ,4 p- ) *

. tt '.* '1 .

T ,e s , i, , , '

i3 r1 ,3 i 5-

,g \\ 'd 7

[ ", il II

  • 1 6 i 'A s

\ ')

+3

,, h tt '

j , g,' *I *Ib

<t 5, .,3 ,

s' ,'

<, r. e- )

,' 1 '}

<. c . . -

't rs Il II P t '.,

X , ,

) ,

-e + e qT l' bd l.-'

)' "$ [

'il

.I

.; () (..

t*, (J >

t t 1 ( - i t 6-I

', t1 6' ('

  1. I ii l

'. t 1 N

<: 3 ,a - .

f SHAw PITTMAN. PoTTs & TROWCRIDGE a m=c .. or onsa.io==. co o..rio .

Mr. B. A. Matthews September 1, 1983 Page Four Licensee's-commitments to supply information are with-out prejudice to Licensee's right to object to the introduction of such information in evidence on the ground that such infor-mation is outside the scope of Hartsville Group's contentions.

If this letter accurately reflects our agreements, please so indicate by signing and returning the enclosed copy.

Licensee's counsel will ' submit a copy of the signed agreement to the Licensing Board.

Sincerely, SHAW, P TTMAN, POTT & TROWBRIDGE au . n swA6 G[orge[F.Trowbridge [

Eounsel for Licensee l Accepted:

17f/zA -

Representative for The Hartsville Group l

l l

l cc: Dr. John C. Ruoff c/o Palmetto Alliance 2135 Devine Street I Columbia, SC 29205

.