ML19319B752

RO NP-33-77-44:on 770729,indication Variation on Level transmitters,LT-SP9A6 & LT-SP9A7,found Greater than Allowed. Caused by Leaking Vent Valves in Transmitter.Valves Tightened & Level Indication Returned to Normal

ML19319B752
Person / Time
Site:	Davis Besse
Issue date:	08/23/1977
From:	George T, Lingenfelter J TOLEDO EDISON CO.
To:
Shared Package
ML19319B643	List: ML19319B642 ML19319B752
References
NUDOCS 8001270213
Download: ML19319B752 (2)

Text

_- ___ ._. _ - - - _ - - _ _ . _-_- _ .

O -

.; ..

I 4

i

~

LICEfC.c r P. E.'IT R E PO RT CoNinoi r,toCc l_ L j i l_,1 s c

' '!.'.*:.' ' ' t .C C .,s . ,o e. . ' 'H ,T ' 5,"#1' l0 ; Oj - J 0101 :'; ? ;T !-10! 31 0

@i].] O ltt i DI3 I s il. J. x{481J1il li- f- o $r13 '-d

^

is u

.. o ....o.,

Ca s a ceae svet se eu a C P raoCutt.euunea t we st riais stpost o.st

[oi con',L srI J w hLJ (d (.01 5 ; O i --1 L 0341 !1 6 L0e7 t2 19 17 1 7 2.1 (018; 2i3!7 pd a . 6.1 6. ,, .

t vtNi of 5Cnse tto**

@DI Indication variati.pn on two Steam Generator level transmitters (LT-SP9A6I 7 89 , .c

@i]l s e> and LT-SP9A7) uas greater than the alleved differential toldrance of 10 w;

[E) r ea

{ inches. (NP-33-77-44) al I

E,I53., l -

m b

l- ._

I I 7M'<- c'.&Y "

< Cn n~, ~, e on. d.3.'Iti ; _ I4';".oi c ',,, v.c, ,,,,

.i @_._'.

7 jiji 89 no C 1 H .I [Fj ae i V 1 A IL f V ; Ej_Zj 12 N LZ,t 43 iZ !2 ;Z jZ J 44 as

@ sa

CauST titSCnistioN l Leaking vent valves on the transmitter body caused a loss of level [

E-9 M

' indication. They were not properly tightened during calibration.

LoJ2} l I 1 E9 d)

EEL J G3

- I erJ g"s a $ s pows e otset a se a vus oiNoNn

• Discovt av DOC a8Ptio*

EDL 7

13.J 9

l 00 I 0I62 10 L_.EA 13

! (BJ [ 6 NA __ ,,l ,

44 44 20 e iss.si ne A t; f 6 V t 9 T ogggp y at it AltQ ger n.gg g g a,gg ag,0uN1 or .C T ive t w LOCateONC# att t att

~3 7 C 9 (Zj .lZj t0 i NA II .4 1 l 45 NA e0 l

Pt psONNEI t,urC5unt s a.vu e., e i,cc or.g C e....o NA

, ,k,M 10 ! 01 (Z] .. ,2 I,2 m

i Ptn53NNtt troust:ts mu**ct e et sC o.st ,CN O_.! 0 !s,O I ( NA l

1, e a a 07 F $lTE CQse$(Qgg %Cg3 LO55 0H oauaut to # ActLily

• )uc a se s eca.

@ ee vPC Z l NA l 1 is . y -

o Pi18 Lect ? Y 31s, u

NA ~~ -

u l

anoiioNat,aC,ons (3 =9[

NA *lm a ,

i t.- - - - . . . . . .. . . . . - _ . . . . . _ . , _-

... 3

,,,,, Jacque Lingenfi:lter/ Tom George ,

(419) 250-5000, Ext. 31 g o o1270 Tl3

[], "

V ,

TOLEDO EDISON COMPANY DAVIS-BESSE UNIT ONE NUCLEAR POWER STATION SUPPLEMENTAL INFORMATION FOR LER NP-33-77-44 DATE OF EVENT: July 29, 1977 FACILITY: Davis-Besse Unit 1 IDENTIFICATION OF OCCURRENCE: Indication variation on two Stean Generator level transmitters (LT-SP9A6 and LT-SP9A7) was greater than the allowed differential tolerance of 10 inches Conditions Prior to Occurrence: The plant was in Mode 3, with Power (MWT) = 0 and Load (MRE) = 0.

Description of Occurrence: At 0930 hours0.0108 days <br />0.258 hours <br />0.00154 weeks <br />3.53865e-4 months <br /> on July 29, 1977, Instru=ent and Control personnel were calibrating and repairing tubing leaks on one Steam Generator level transmitter at a ti=e (LT-SP9A6, 9A7 and 9B9). Each transmitter was restored to service uithin 1 hour1.157407e-5 days <br />2.777778e-4 hours <br />1.653439e-6 weeks <br />3.805e-7 months <br />. At 1045 hours0.0121 days <br />0.29 hours <br />0.00173 weeks <br />3.976225e-4 months <br /> while performing ST 5099.01, Miscellanecus Instrument Shift Checks, 2 Steam Generator level transmitter india.ations on s LT-SP9A6 and LT-SP9A7 were greater than the allowed differential colerance of 10

) inches. This placed the unit in the Action Statement of Technical Specification d 3.3.2.2.(b).

Designation of Aeoarent Cause of Occurrence: After a Maintenance Work Order was issued, it was discovered that the "ent valves on the transmitter body were leaking causing a loss of level indication in the Contrrl Room. The vent valves were never properly tightened during the calibration.

l Analysis of Occurrence: Since (he indications never went out of the tolerance that would require a manual trip of the Steam and Feedwater Rupture Control Systa:

Channel, the Channel re=ained operable and there was no threat to the health and safety of the public or Station personnel.

Corrective Action: SFRCS level indicators were monitored closely to determine if any of the channels must be tripped as per Action Statement #13 of Table 3.3-11.

The vent valves were tightened to stop the leaks and Steam Generator level indica-tion was returned to normal. Investigation of this problem is continuing with the vendor (Rosemont).

Failure Data: Stes: Generator level was inoperable on one prior event (NF-33-7 7-21) ,

} but the cause of the event was a deficient design in the power supplies.

y

- , - , , - - , - , - -.----w , , - , , _ _ , . , - _