ML17334B128

Forwards Proprietary Version of Rev 1 to ANF-87-91(P), DC Cook 2 Debris-Resistant Lower Tie Plate Pressure Drop Test Rept, Supporting Operation of Facility.Rept Withheld (Ref 10CFR2.790(b))

ML17334B128
Person / Time
Site:	Cook
Issue date:	08/25/1987
From:	ADKISSON D A SIEMENS POWER CORP. (FORMERLY SIEMENS NUCLEAR POWER
To:	NRC OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION & RESOURCES MANAGEMENT (ARM)
Shared Package
ML17334B129	List: ML17334B128
References
DAA:014:87, DAA:14:87, NUDOCS 8708310058
Download: ML17334B128 (13)

Text

lREGULATORY

)FORMATION DISTRIBUTION SYM(RIDS)~aACCESSIQN NBR:87083i0058DOC.DATE:87/08/25NOTARIZED:

YESDOCKETFACIL:50-3i6DonaldC.CookNuclearPowerPlant.Unit2.Indiana5050003i6AUTH.NAMEAUTHORAFFILIATION ADKISSQNp D.*.AdvancedNuclearFuelsCorp.(formerly ExxonNuclearCo.pIRECIP.NAMERECIPIENT AFFILIATION DocumentControlBranch(Document ControlDesk)

SUBJECT:

Forwardsadvancednuclearfuelscorptechnical reptANF-87-9i(P)

IRevip"DCCook2Debris-Resistant LowerTiePlatePressureDropTestReptp"whichsupportsoperation of.facility.

gW.C~sDIBTRIBUT IONCODE:PAOIDCOPIOUSRECEIVED:

LTRlENCL~0BIZE:(0+TITLE:Psspsistasg ReviseDitacit'uti snOpzeta'ingRsastpnfNOTEB:RECIPIENTIDCODE/NAME PD3-3LAMIC('INGTON, D0k+,3INTERNAL:

AEOD/DOAOQC/HDSiEXTERNAL:

LPDRCOPIESLTTRENCLi33iii00AEOD/DSP/TPAB k~ii044.>NRCPDR0RECIPIENT

'OPIESIDCODE/NAME LTTRENCLPD3-3PDTOTALNUMBEROFCOPIESREQUIRED:

LTIR'iENCL8 Wp-htll'$w,rWt<<)I,l<<<<h'f"IQHWrIW<<)"'1~JrI1'1hW,H,"l(

'HIVj.HPIw'I~wll)r1Pwhm,hfjvH4'H"','<<jj>>jjt)",,"'I~)<<jjmP<<HmhgWVIIHIHPI<<V AQVANCEDNUCLEAHFUELSCORPORATION 2101HORNRAPIDSROAD,POBOX130,RICHLAND, WA993524130 (509)375-8100TELEX:15-2878FUELENGINEERING aTECHNICAL SERVICESAugust25,1987DAA:014:8787083i0058 870825'DR ADOCH050003%6PPDRDonaldC.CookNuclearPlantNo.2DocketNo.50-316LicenseNo.DPR-74TRANSMITTAL OFANF-87-91(P),

REV.1,DCCOOK2DEBRIS-RESISTANT LOWERTIEPLATEPRESSUREDROPTESTREPORTU.S.NuclearRegulatory Commission DocumentControlDeskWashington, D.C.20555

Subject:

Transmittal ofDonaldC.CookUnit2Debris-Resistant LowerTiePlatePressureDropTestReportEnclosedaretencopieseachoftheAdvancedNuclearFuelsCorporation (ANF)technical reportANF-87-91(P),

Rev.1,entitled"DCCook2Debris-Resistant LowerTiePlatePressureDropTestReport,"whichsupportsoperation oftheD.C.CookUnit2NuclearPlant,AttherequestofAmericanElectricPowerServiceCompany(AEPSC),thisreportisbeingtransmitted directlybyANF.Thedocumenttransmitted viathisletterreflectschangesandanalysisofthelowertieplateusedinthemanufacture ofthereloadfueldesignated XN-4whichwillbeloadedinthereactorinApril1988.Thedocumentshowsanalysesandtestsperformed onthedebris-resistant tieplatedesign.ResultsoftheanalysesshowthattheCycle7reloadfueliscompatible withtheexistingANFfuelintheplant.ANFconsiders information contained intheenclosedtechnical reporttobeproprietary.

TheAffidavit enclosedprovidesthenecessary information toallowthewithholding oftheproprietary versionfrompublicdisclosure asrequiredby10CFR2.790(b)~fI4'*'ANAFFILIATE OFKRAFTWERKUNIONQ~KSVU(QQ)d

U.S.NuclearRegulatory Commission DAA:014:87 August25,1987Ifyouhaveanyquestions regarding thistransmittal, pleasecontactHr.JamesG.Feinstein ofAEPSCat(614)233-2040.

Yoursverytruly,DAA:llhEnclosures D.A.Adkisson, ActingHanagerReloadLicensing cc:Hr.H.P.Alexich(AEPSC)Hr.T.Georgantis (AEPSC)Hr.D.L.Wiggington (NRC)(w/Enclosures) tQCp@@Cap+1')Sw%+>al0>ocr AFFIDAVIT STATEOFWASHINGTON

))ss.COUNTYOFBENTON)I,H.E.Williamson beingdulysworn,herebysayanddepose:l.IamManager,Licensing andSafetyEngineering, forAdvancedNuclearFuelsCorporation,

("ANF"),andassuchIamauthorized toexecutethisAffidavit.

2.IamfamiliarwithANF'sdetaileddocumentcontrolsystemandpolicieswhichgoverntheprotection andcontrolofinformation.

3.IamfamiliarwiththedocumentANF-87-91(P),

Revision1,entitled"DonaldC.CookUnit2Debris-Resistant LowerTiePlatePressureDropTestReport,"referredtoas"Document."

Information contained inthisDocumenthasbeenclassified byANFasproprietary inaccordance withthecontrolsystemandpoliciesestablished byANFforthecontrolandprotection ofinformation.

4.TheDocumentcontainsinformation ofaproprietary andconfidential natureandisofthetypecustomarily heldinconfidence byANFandnotmadeavailable tothepublic.Basedonmyexperience, Iamawarethatothercompanies-regardinformation ofthekindcontained intheDocumentas.pr'opriejyry

.andconfidential.

5.-TheDocumenthasbeenmadeavailable totheU.S.NuclearRegulatory Commission inconfidence, withtherequestthattheinformation 4tcontained intheDocumentwillnotbedisclosed ordivulged.

T 6.TheDocumentcontainsinformation whichisvitaltoacompetitive advantage ofANFandwouldbehelpfultocompetitors ofANFwhencompeting withANF.7.Theinformation contained intheDocumentisconsidered tobeproprietary byANFbecauseitrevealscertaindistinguishing aspectsofdebris-resistant lowertieplatewhichsecurecompetitive advantage toANFforfueldesignoptimization andmarketability, andincludesinformation utilizedbyANFinitsbusinesswhichaffordsANFanopportunity toobtainacompetitive advantage overitscompetitors whodonotormaynotknoworusetheinformation contained intheDocument, 8.Thedisclosure oftheproprietary information contained intheDocumenttoacompetitor wouldpermitthecompetitor toreduceitsexpenditure ofmoneyandmanpowerandto,improveitscompetitive positionbygivingitextremely valuableinsightsintodebris-resistant lowertieplateandwouldresultinsubstantial harmtothecompetitive positionofANF.9.TheDocumentcontainsproprietary information whichisheldinconfidence byANFandisnotavailable inpublicsources.10.Inaccordance withANF'spoliciesgoverning theprotection andcontrolofinformation, proprietary information contained intheDocumenthasbeenmadeavailable, onalimitedbasis,toothersoutsideANFonlyasrequiredandundersuitableagreement providing fornondisclosure andlimiteduseoftheinformation.

ll.ANFpolicyrequiresthatproprietary information bekeptinasecuredfileorareaanddistributed onaneed-to-know basis. 12.ThisDocumentprovidesinformation whichrevealsthedebris-resistant lowertieplatedeveloped byANFoverthepastseveralyears.ANFhasinvestedmanythousands ofdollarsandmanyman-months ofeffortindeveloping thedebris-resistant lowertieplaterevealedintheDocument.

Assumingacompetitor hadavailable thesamebackground dataandincentives asANF,thecompetitor might,ataminimum,developtheinformation forthesameexpenditure ofmanpowerandmoneyasANF.THATthestatements madehereinabove are,tothebestofmyknowledge, information, andbelief,truthfulandcomplete.

FURTHERAFFIANTSAYETHNOT.SWORNTOANDSUBSCRIBED beforemethis8~~dayof1987.,noTARy,,PujLIC l~4!14/g6*/

ADVANCEDNUCLEARFUELSCORPORATION 2101HORNRAPIDSROAD,POBOX130,RICHlAND.

WA993524130 I509I3758100TELEX:15.2878FUELENGINEERING 8TECHNICAL SERVICESAugust25,1987DAA:014:87DonaldC.CookNuclearPlantNo.2DocketNo.50-316LicenseNo.DPR-74TRANSMITTAL OFANF-87-91(P),,REV.

1,DCCOOK2DEBRIS-RESISTANT LOWERTIEPLATEPRESSUREDROPTESTREPORTU.S.NuclearRegulatory Commission DocumentControlDeskWashington, D.C.20555

Subject:

Transmittal ofDonaldC.CookUnit2Debris-Resistant LowerTiePlatePressureDropTestReportEnclosedaretencopieseachoftheAdvancedNuclearFuelsCorporation (ANF)technical reportANF-87-91(P),

Rev.1,entitled"DCCook2Debris-Resistant LowerTiePlatePressureDropTestReport,"whichsupportsoperation oftheD.C.CookUnit2NuclearPlant.AttherequestofAmericanElectricPowerServiceCompany(AEPSC),thisreportisbeingtransmitted directlybyANF.Thedocumenttransmitted viathisletterreflectschangesandanalysisofthelowertieplateusedinthemanufacture ofthereloadfueldesignated XN-4whichwillbeloadedinthereactorinApril1988.Thedocumentshowsanalysesandtestsperformed onthedebris-resistant tieplatedesign.ResultsoftheanalysesshowthattheCycle7reloadfueliscompatible withtheexistingANFfuelintheplant.ANFconsiders information contained intheenclosedtechnical reporttobeproprietary.

TheAffidavit enclosedprovidesthenecessary information toallowthewithholding oftheproprietary versionfrompublicdisclosure asrequiredby10CFR2.790(b).

ANAfflLIAIE OfKRAf11VERK VNIOhlQwKitU U.S.NuclearRegulatory Commission DAA:014:87 August25,1987Ifyouhaveanyquestions regarding thistransmittal, pleasecontactMr.JamesG.Feinstein ofAEPSCat(614)233-2040.

Yoursverytruly,DAA:llhEnclosures D.A.Adkisson, ActingManagerReloadLicensing cc:Mr.M.P.Alexich(AEPSC)Mr.T.Georgantis (AEPSC)Mr.D.L.Wiggington (NRC)(w/Enclosures)