ML19327B249: Difference between revisions
StriderTol (talk | contribs) (Created page by program invented by StriderTol) |
StriderTol (talk | contribs) (StriderTol Bot change) |
||
(One intermediate revision by the same user not shown) | |||
Line 17: | Line 17: | ||
=Text= | =Text= | ||
{{#Wiki_filter:m pm - , , | {{#Wiki_filter:m pm - , , | ||
a 4 ~ | a 4 ~ | ||
q'; 1' . - - .. . | q'; 1' . - - .. . | ||
Babcock & Wiwox u i , ro r oivi.i.n | Babcock & Wiwox u i , ro r oivi.i.n | ||
* ' a McDermott company 3315 Old Forest Road j s | * ' a McDermott company 3315 Old Forest Road j s | ||
~ | ~ | ||
P.O. Oox 10935 | P.O. Oox 10935 Lynchburg. VA 24506 0935 (804) 3'j5-2000 JHT/89-204 A | ||
fI . | |||
Lynchburg. VA 24506 0935 (804) 3'j5-2000 JHT/89-204 | |||
October 6, 1989 jf 3 .. | October 6, 1989 jf 3 .. | ||
' Mr. J::mes A. Norberg, Special Assistan.: I Division of Engineering and 5Lystem Technology | ' Mr. J::mes A. Norberg, Special Assistan.: I Division of Engineering and 5Lystem Technology | ||
' Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation W .U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission | ' Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation W .U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission | ||
!: Washington, D.C. 20555-L | !: Washington, D.C. 20555-L | ||
, Subj ect: Rod Exchange Methodology Topical Report, BAW 10175 | , Subj ect: Rod Exchange Methodology Topical Report, BAW 10175 | ||
==References:== | ==References:== | ||
: 1. .J. H. Taylor to J. A. ' Norberg, JHT/89-98, May 22,1989. | : 1. .J. H. Taylor to J. A. ' Norberg, JHT/89-98, May 22,1989. | ||
: 2. A. C. Thadani to J. H. Taylor, Acceptance for Referencing | : 2. A. C. Thadani to J. H. Taylor, Acceptance for Referencing of . Topical Report BAW-10175, " Rod Exchange Methodology", | ||
of . Topical Report BAW-10175, " Rod Exchange Methodology", | |||
August 7, 1989. | August 7, 1989. | ||
Line 62: | Line 42: | ||
; . Catawba Units 1 and 2. B&W requests that the SER be revised to include applicability to all other Westinghouse PWEs. Justification for this extended applicability is included with the attachment to this letter. | ; . Catawba Units 1 and 2. B&W requests that the SER be revised to include applicability to all other Westinghouse PWEs. Justification for this extended applicability is included with the attachment to this letter. | ||
y trul. yours | y trul. yours | ||
.1 . 'ay1 | .1 . 'ay1 Manager, Licensing Services | ||
Manager, Licensing Services | |||
~ , | ~ , | ||
cc: w/ attach R.B. Borsum , | cc: w/ attach R.B. Borsum , | ||
T.I.. Baldwin ' | T.I.. Baldwin ' | ||
D.B. Fieno, NRC [D[g | D.B. Fieno, NRC [D[g R.C. Jones, NRC | ||
R.C. Jones, NRC | |||
/fI , | /fI , | ||
1 | 1 | ||
.: 8910270260 DR 392006 7 | .: 8910270260 DR 392006 7 | ||
/. | /. | ||
.p ADOCK 05000367 ij - | .p ADOCK 05000367 ij - | ||
s PNU ,b, | s PNU ,b, | ||
m | m | ||
'J.- | 'J.- | ||
{ | { | ||
+ | + | ||
Application of the Rod Exchange Methodology e | Application of the Rod Exchange Methodology e | ||
to Other Westinghouse PWRs e The ability to calculate the necessary information to support control rod worth measurements by rod enchange centers on accurately determining calculated individual bank worths and integral bank worth shapes. This calculational process basically consists of three inter-cormected analytical techniques: 1) the development of specific fuel nuclear cross sections; 2) the development of specific control rod cross-sections; and 3) the development of a core model for calculations of individual control rod bank worths and integral rod worth shapes. BWFC has successfully demonstrated the ability to calculate the information required to support control rod worth measurementu using the rod exchange method for Westinghouse-designed plants o in BAW-10175. | to Other Westinghouse PWRs e The ability to calculate the necessary information to support control rod worth measurements by rod enchange centers on accurately determining calculated individual bank worths and integral bank worth shapes. This calculational process basically consists of three inter-cormected analytical techniques: 1) the development of specific fuel nuclear cross sections; 2) the development of specific control rod cross-sections; and 3) the development of a core model for calculations of individual control rod bank worths and integral rod worth shapes. BWFC has successfully demonstrated the ability to calculate the information required to support control rod worth measurementu using the rod exchange method for Westinghouse-designed plants o in BAW-10175. | ||
Presented on the following page are calculated and measured rod worthe for three cycles each of two different Westinghouse-designed plants and for the three most recent E&W 177 F.A. plant reloads. Also attached are representative examples of measured integral rod worth versus predicted integral worth for three different types of plants. Measured rod worths were determined by the standard boron exchange method. This data demonstrates that BWFC has the' ability to accurately calculate control rod worths and integral worth shapes for a variety of fuel types, control rod types, and core designs. | Presented on the following page are calculated and measured rod worthe for three cycles each of two different Westinghouse-designed plants and for the three most recent E&W 177 F.A. plant reloads. Also attached are representative examples of measured integral rod worth versus predicted integral worth for three different types of plants. Measured rod worths were determined by the standard boron exchange method. This data demonstrates that BWFC has the' ability to accurately calculate control rod worths and integral worth shapes for a variety of fuel types, control rod types, and core designs. | ||
The techniques approved in BAW-10175 are insensitive to global parameters that may differ in Uestinghouse-designed pressurized water reactors (PWRs) other than the McGuire and Catawba units, such as the number of reactor l coolant system loops, the fuel assembly design (eg,, 15x15 vs. 17x17), and the number of fuel assemblies in the core (eg., Westinghouse 157 vs. | The techniques approved in BAW-10175 are insensitive to global parameters that may differ in Uestinghouse-designed pressurized water reactors (PWRs) other than the McGuire and Catawba units, such as the number of reactor l coolant system loops, the fuel assembly design (eg,, 15x15 vs. 17x17), and the number of fuel assemblies in the core (eg., Westinghouse 157 vs. | ||
Line 104: | Line 67: | ||
~". | ~". | ||
-y | -y | ||
,G | ,G l ' ;3 (. | ||
l ' ;3 (. | |||
* McGuiro-1 Cy 2' McGuire-1 Cy 3 McGuire-1 Cy 4 L BAnh ERAA EIid %Diff lank 11 EAR EIgd %Diff EADh lira 1 EIld %Diff f' | * McGuiro-1 Cy 2' McGuire-1 Cy 3 McGuire-1 Cy 4 L BAnh ERAA EIid %Diff lank 11 EAR EIgd %Diff EADh lira 1 EIld %Diff f' | ||
[ .CC 788 801 -1.6 SB 779 844 -7.7 CC 778 819 -5.0 CD 586' 656 -10.7 CD 483 509 5.1 CD 580 573 +1.2 | [ .CC 788 801 -1.6 SB 779 844 -7.7 CC 778 819 -5.0 CD 586' 656 -10.7 CD 483 509 5.1 CD 580 573 +1.2 | ||
% Diff Mean - 4.8% " | % Diff Mean - 4.8% " | ||
[ Std. Dev. - 4.2% | [ Std. Dev. - 4.2% | ||
Line 118: | Line 76: | ||
% Diff Mean - 1.0% | % Diff Mean - 1.0% | ||
1 Std. Dev. - 4.7% | 1 Std. Dev. - 4.7% | ||
TMI-1 Cy 7 D B Cy 6 ANO-1 Cy 9 EADh linAs Ermd %Diff EADE liEAR Ergd %Diff EADh !!1A1 EIRd %Diff 5 1220 1208 +1.0 5 1445 1326 +9.0 5 1380 1294 +6.6 6- 934 971 -3.8 6 1083 1111 -2.5 6 1012 1057 -4.3 2 | TMI-1 Cy 7 D B Cy 6 ANO-1 Cy 9 EADh linAs Ermd %Diff EADE liEAR Ergd %Diff EADh !!1A1 EIRd %Diff 5 1220 1208 +1.0 5 1445 1326 +9.0 5 1380 1294 +6.6 6- 934 971 -3.8 6 1083 1111 -2.5 6 1012 1057 -4.3 2 | ||
7 926 978 5.3 7 954 943 +1.2 7 825 867 -4.8 | 7 926 978 5.3 7 954 943 +1.2 7 825 867 -4.8 | ||
Line 126: | Line 83: | ||
2).All rod worths presented above are in units of PCM. | 2).All rod worths presented above are in units of PCM. | ||
: 3) % Diff - (M-P)/P x 100% | : 3) % Diff - (M-P)/P x 100% | ||
I J | I J | ||
7m-,s- - - ,~ e ,yys. m , | 7m-,s- - - ,~ e ,yys. m , | ||
* _. 4- | * _. 4- | ||
.p. | .p. | ||
^ | ^ | ||
!ntegral Rod Worth f or: Bank B . | !ntegral Rod Worth f or: Bank B . | ||
Conn Yankee Cycle 14 - | Conn Yankee Cycle 14 - | ||
O - | |||
"I | "I | ||
/ ~ | / ~ | ||
Line 150: | Line 97: | ||
- 0. 2 - | - 0. 2 - | ||
1 t | 1 t | ||
2 - 0. 3 - d o a U- i | 2 - 0. 3 - d o a U- i 5g - 0. 4 - | ||
5g - 0. 4 - | |||
ou 3: 8 , | ou 3: 8 , | ||
yg o | yg o | ||
- 0. 5 - | - 0. 5 - | ||
1 .oc | 1 .oc | ||
_ F-o v - 0. 6 - | _ F-o v - 0. 6 - | ||
Line 167: | Line 110: | ||
- 0. 9 - | - 0. 9 - | ||
[. | [. | ||
~l ' | ~l ' | ||
I i i i i i I i i i i i I i | I i i i i i I i i i i i I i | ||
~ | ~ | ||
0 40 80 120 160 200 240 280 320 Rod Position Steps O Measured IRW + Predicted IRW . | 0 40 80 120 160 200 240 280 320 Rod Position Steps O Measured IRW + Predicted IRW . | ||
i | i | ||
.i | .i | ||
:mn u.-# | :mn u.-# | ||
gm 5.% y., , s , - m.g r ,,. | gm 5.% y., , s , - m.g r ,,. | ||
m | m | ||
, . . . a , M,. ,. . A | , . . . a , M,. ,. . A Y I,%%m[% $j~M,i@ M Q~W M h- % M. .yq M[n,gy', N .t % m, 7.[m n.[ M M J.6''/ >,8..slhE n a "m[# 3Yl 4 e%6?[y@yj | ||
Y I,%%m[% $j~M,i@ M Q~W M h- % M. .yq M[n,gy', N .t % m, 7.[m n.[ M M J.6''/ >,8..slhE n a "m[# 3Yl 4 e%6?[y@yj | |||
. M y u M u & p y:m;u & | . M y u M u & p y:m;u & | ||
; pp M WQ+pX.My g xqamn sw dw c' ww aeWW~ % | ; pp M WQ+pX.My g xqamn sw dw c' ww aeWW~ % | ||
, ~ | , ~ | ||
~ e 0.' a: m; n, %' | ~ e 0.' a: m; n, %' | ||
eW; 4 w | eW; 4 w | ||
e %' M %w;# | e %' M %w;# | ||
Line 205: | Line 138: | ||
YY.+p , ??N a, W :+ . D t $......% Y +w, ?m. NYk;sthh:Eh,.lA. r,c< W ., 4.,s k; p o N :. | YY.+p , ??N a, W :+ . D t $......% Y +w, ?m. NYk;sthh:Eh,.lA. r,c< W ., 4.,s k; p o N :. | ||
e , p e. | e , p e. | ||
_4.:y-t- | _4.:y-t- | ||
aw | aw s | ||
7g e,yM %- g ,p. | |||
a *o..,.. | a *o..,.. | ||
s, ^s p - ^x * ' " "' Up' 1y~ 4, s. ,4, . . . , | s, ^s p - ^x * ' " "' Up' 1y~ 4, s. ,4, . . . , | ||
Line 222: | Line 153: | ||
>i j. = w , d['!M. n . '' TM.v- # | >i j. = w , d['!M. n . '' TM.v- # | ||
a ,c +k,.,-,e i | a ,c +k,.,-,e i | ||
, .- ty,, a | , .- ty,, a | ||
<u>,. 1Ewb;/ ' <IN ;y r | <u>,. 1Ewb;/ ' <IN ;y r | ||
[4 "be +n\ v u !s*, .N J | [4 "be +n\ v u !s*, .N J | ||
%n..b' 6' j,- :p:&':.&f.f%:y,.:p !hA | %n..b' 6' j,- :p:&':.&f.f%:y,.:p !hA s a | ||
s a | |||
~ n y-" y. .su uv '.u ! | ~ n y-" y. .su uv '.u ! | ||
p!%:.QM' m , | p!%:.QM' m , | ||
s f:c s | |||
s f:c | t.g, a80,4y .3' p | ||
. Qs A .r. '' | . Qs A .r. '' | ||
3%n' n.s, . ,K. | 3%n' n.s, . ,K. | ||
Line 243: | Line 167: | ||
,; ' Q MfM.p&.2' eg t e | ,; ' Q MfM.p&.2' eg t e | ||
, e . | , e . | ||
p | p w , | ||
w , | |||
a he ;w;' | a he ;w;' | ||
g U m e M, P 1 y>, b y@w n.x xr p : nf'g,* n,% 2 4,s M.@@? | |||
g U m e M, P 1 y>, b y@w | |||
n.x xr p : nf'g,* n,% 2 4,s M.@@? | |||
W | W | ||
: ey.'-n, , . W , ' y | : ey.'-n, , . W , ' y wa w -@W.n,;;pM n ~, . Mw W 4 < | ||
n W h@~pgW ' -:t.%o d _'. | |||
wa w -@W.n,;;pM n ~, . Mw W 4 < | |||
n | |||
W h@~pgW ' -:t.%o d _'. | |||
.c :. - | .c :. - | ||
.nw 1 | .nw 1 w~ m%c | ||
w~ m%c | |||
..+ v: | ..+ v: | ||
QWu&sh Q@.W.. | QWu&sh Q@.W.. | ||
t ,, fl ;&. 4.d~lC.] L | t ,, fl ;&. 4.d~lC.] L | ||
&4 -\m ., .m .g {9Q * ,E-f c# , | &4 -\m ., .m .g {9Q * ,E-f c# , | ||
u Ma , Dy l ' ,b $. | u Ma , Dy l ' ,b $. | ||
. ? A s * ' ;" | . ? A s * ' ;" | ||
s-L.l,9 ' n ':w | s-L.l,9 ' n ':w Mf %aj - x q'Ll" ' l . | ||
Mf %aj - x q'Ll" ' l . | |||
frwn Ml ,'mQ.? 0, %sayp | frwn Ml ,'mQ.? 0, %sayp | ||
,l' | ,l' | ||
+ | + | ||
1 .. | 1 .. | ||
y0/ ' , | y0/ ' , | ||
* a 4 4. | * a 4 4. | ||
M. M,t C' 4[''Q U~ | M. M,t C' 4[''Q U~ | ||
QmA %iM .. | QmA %iM .. | ||
1 '< | 1 '< | ||
. , /7.> :f . J. 4, ?(c; Mn i s | . , /7.> :f . J. 4, ?(c; Mn i s | ||
'i | 'i | ||
,'e' | ,'e' | ||
_ e - ' / . 'y. ,, i1 . . 1' uv.g 4/es; 5'7Mg- m ,m,l. % . .b %e,; . i.N.o i . | _ e - ' / . 'y. ,, i1 . . 1' uv.g 4/es; 5'7Mg- m ,m,l. % . .b %e,; . i.N.o i . | ||
Line 303: | Line 198: | ||
~,- N # $ ' | ~,- N # $ ' | ||
ng 3 .1 .93 | ng 3 .1 .93 | ||
.t | .t | ||
,y ' N.6 - t. .- | ,y ' N.6 - t. .- | ||
w ., | w ., | ||
,d > ' ,,x ~.. f-v f.0.M.r% s,i> Whf +4 u. , . m e > w- v, , % | ,d > ' ,,x ~.. f-v f.0.M.r% s,i> Whf +4 u. , . m e > w- v, , % | ||
M7~ - . . q, --' i. +, r F. w'. ~M 3 w's n ' m'~M, M U [,I | M7~ - . . q, --' i. +, r F. w'. ~M 3 w's n ' m'~M, M U [,I | ||
) J r f -'- ; | ) J r f -'- ; | ||
Y - ..uL -. | Y - ..uL -. | ||
',- %Q .b | ',- %Q .b | ||
. - ;p< ,%*' , ~ gmN. " | . - ;p< ,%*' , ~ gmN. " | ||
Line 322: | Line 211: | ||
, 4 i | , 4 i | ||
'l | 'l | ||
-N 4 | -N 4 | ||
'% 'h | '% 'h | ||
-g5 'e | -g5 'e | ||
: h. h..y, '3 f | : h. h..y, '3 f | ||
siz, , . . .,_ g | siz, , . . .,_ g | ||
Line 334: | Line 219: | ||
, yme,m y | , yme,m y | ||
.s , , - . | .s , , - . | ||
. 0 ,' ,. 3 %y ,f* %yl.Q n p,l | . 0 ,' ,. 3 %y ,f* %yl.Q n p,l 4 | ||
4 | |||
g~g- a yn 4m :. nA 3 | g~g- a yn 4m :. nA 3 | ||
p&pga.v. M, ; s , .; ' .3 7 w | p&pga.v. M, ; s , .; ' .3 7 w | ||
. o,. ,m s % | . o,. ,m s % | ||
a 4ss .4./m, - | a 4ss .4./m, - | ||
. g. - -rN u .s. a na n.m e -wde of. . 3 W ,, ,r wi''' ,1 , ";w +- ,4f ~,a. es c;g' se ;,rr w n; ;m.; | . g. - -rN u .s. a na n.m e -wde of. . 3 W ,, ,r wi''' ,1 , ";w +- ,4f ~,a. es c;g' se ;,rr w n; ;m.; | ||
,, r( | ,, r( | ||
uOwl mt d;1 ap+fq ,O ut+ < 1 | uOwl mt d;1 ap+fq ,O ut+ < 1 | ||
* a , ,y e q.; . .e . a , s .s t 5 s | * a , ,y e q.; . .e . a , s .s t 5 s | ||
& . .w. aMw., ; t s ,.f- | & . .w. aMw., ; t s ,.f- | ||
? | ? | ||
! tY % | ! tY % | ||
w" 'N' - M s' :~ | w" 'N' - M s' :~ | ||
a | a | ||
,g .n . | ,g .n . | ||
3 Pe W ; 7' Ni Ci t '.,, D;G . V.: | 3 Pe W ; 7' Ni Ci t '.,, D;G . V.: | ||
Q. M.f'M G Q: . , wn di,- M, O M; 3% | Q. M.f'M G Q: . , wn di,- M, O M; 3% | ||
Line 367: | Line 241: | ||
+4 | +4 | ||
... c.''a+Gpf .n | ... c.''a+Gpf .n | ||
, " ' y% ~ m a. | , " ' y% ~ m a. | ||
g | g | ||
+ | + | ||
m;% U vy;p :..e., , o y+pe; y. yY .y? .m , ' tpa' 3 s;h-,; n n , , | m;% U vy;p :..e., , o y+pe; y. yY .y? .m , ' tpa' 3 s;h-,; n n , , | ||
~ | ~ | ||
mtm' ./,y | mtm' ./,y | ||
* i ,< | * i ,< | ||
f | f | ||
Line 390: | Line 258: | ||
* W mm y | * W mm y | ||
.f ap.lS s Q w;ca..+ L a- b 4. v, w._e wo M.y ,f ep ,4 4- >- | .f ap.lS s Q w;ca..+ L a- b 4. v, w._e wo M.y ,f ep ,4 4- >- | ||
4 s . | 4 s . | ||
1 | 1 | ||
.'~. | .'~. | ||
4 | 4 | ||
,'..s. | ,'..s. | ||
w m' R %.f e 1 +%5.. | w m' R %.f e 1 +%5.. | ||
' ; . s ,.O6y t Vi, | ' ; . s ,.O6y t Vi, | ||
'} '1 'O' g#frQO , .. A' S M.9 n '. ' t fi sg $3 C U.,A>. | |||
'} '1 'O' g#frQO , .. A' S M.9 n '. ' t | |||
1 s D1 Wa%y'- < <. s '4.,#.s | 1 s D1 Wa%y'- < <. s '4.,#.s | ||
. -y [ ' ..V'6' | . -y [ ' ..V'6' | ||
', .d. :o? r , c n e# .s e W W.. | ', .d. :o? r , c n e# .s e W W.. | ||
f' ' | f' ' | ||
f9 e m%a s | |||
f9 e m%a | |||
s | |||
, , s y n l! | , , s y n l! | ||
M@.$y.Mirj kg E Cs ip1 "q n W. | M@.$y.Mirj kg E Cs ip1 "q n W. | ||
1 | 1 h j + i 3 | ||
h j + i 3 | |||
i 'r 3 | i 'r 3 | ||
.g b.',. @ ,%+ 9 ane 7 9W ,> wwi j | .g b.',. @ ,%+ 9 ane 7 9W ,> wwi j | ||
-, 3 | -, 3 | ||
.., .@3~y a>m% y o e | .., .@3~y a>m% y o e | ||
~y a - | ~y a - | ||
. .< E ~ | . .< E ~ | ||
-1 n opm[m 4 | -1 n opm[m 4 | ||
. -. ; w ; | . -. ; w ; | ||
7G J' .T z: 'O C " | 7G J' .T z: 'O C " | ||
e As(f?kwp g 'd %f ' k P' | e As(f?kwp g 'd %f ' k P' | ||
'er[ & .. i | 'er[ & .. i | ||
^ | ^ | ||
.f 4 | .f 4 | ||
: t. , T** | : t. , T** | ||
: b. I , | : b. I , | ||
tt,y-w; JN:. " v m(c"_ m,, J.,M' n Y''M m* - | tt,y-w; JN:. " v m(c"_ m,, J.,M' n Y''M m* - | ||
Line 450: | Line 296: | ||
v,m,,s n x.,n ;g, 1, | v,m,,s n x.,n ;g, 1, | ||
4a, | 4a, | ||
' 1 * | ' 1 * | ||
%' s .- Pc &gM,r m a | %' s .- Pc &gM,r m a | ||
, ,% . . ,9" , ' ya 9.w hg$ 8' . . ,kN qs ? '1,k | , ,% . . ,9" , ' ya 9.w hg$ 8' . . ,kN qs ? '1,k | ||
~ | ~ | ||
t | t | ||
~ | ~ | ||
-),_ | -),_ | ||
n | n | ||
@ .i U | @ .i U I 'M5 s 'd i grM W.,,o %w,f lm* ' o., u;m,' e' , ' , | ||
I 'M5 s 'd i grM W.,,o %w,f lm* ' o., u;m,' e' , ' , | |||
47, | 47, | ||
,s ',;q s uh | ,s ',;q s uh | ||
;W e Ec. W/ | ;W e Ec. W/ | ||
-' y' e .. _. . | -' y' e .. _. . | ||
LM w/+b, .J.g .~:xM-= us W).e ; e- s3,ys J'% s u s. < > | LM w/+b, .J.g .~:xM-= us W).e ; e- s3,ys J'% s u s. < > | ||
f e OV p , | f e OV p , | ||
# g.ww% s .+, | # g.ww% s .+, | ||
w . ,4 A e' 4 | w . ,4 A e' 4 4 - | ||
i b, 9 1 s | |||
4 - | |||
i b, | |||
9 1 s | |||
: y> e g- e s. 6. | : y> e g- e s. 6. | ||
.~% | .~% | ||
pAr.;d. | pAr.;d. | ||
Line 497: | Line 320: | ||
;r.-y | ;r.-y | ||
- 4 i | - 4 i | ||
,$fd %#.0 ; y. WD i . , > | ,$fd %#.0 ; y. WD i . , > | ||
s:<*,, .. ht | s:<*,, .. ht | ||
,C;:;N' 'Q . aQ1' n c.m t | ,C;:;N' 'Q . aQ1' n c.m t a - , .e; a ,s v v t" J ,:. | ||
y%ph,y *f.W":l, C*-G...l' .q *q% p f qvct ODY Lh&-W 3r N 4 , ! e/ .aQ:\ neq | |||
y%ph,y *f.W":l, C*-G...l' .q *q% p | |||
f qvct ODY Lh&-W 3r N 4 , ! e/ .aQ:\ neq | |||
+U r. | +U r. | ||
dn s , | dn s , | ||
e a | |||
' ' n j&;> | ' ' n j&;> | ||
m., ,, ? | m., ,, ? | ||
Line 516: | Line 332: | ||
pan;1.Oo | pan;1.Oo | ||
,p nw n g.. | ,p nw n g.. | ||
m g~ - | |||
m | |||
g~ - | |||
;<v~. | ;<v~. | ||
;3' r- g m y1 - dw<._.e , , ,4 | ;3' r- g m y1 - dw<._.e , , ,4 m>. | ||
b.;.Ny wwo ?% ;L.H G-ug);; W Gj yJ i W .' | |||
m>. | |||
b.;.Ny wwo ?% ;L.H G-ug);; W Gj yJ i | |||
W .' | |||
m/ | m/ | ||
9 i , , | 9 i , , | ||
;, ,; , '* <. O ; W b , .',- | ;, ,; , '* <. O ; W b , .',- | ||
d w?% | d w?% | ||
et 3$s .A t a | et 3$s .A t a | ||
Line 547: | Line 349: | ||
A&.pe,.mc:tfme & s o s: | A&.pe,.mc:tfme & s o s: | ||
- a s, s,. | - a s, s,. | ||
7 ' n a,a f. 'L' yi i | 7 ' n a,a f. 'L' yi i | ||
; t 4 x. ..t | ; t 4 x. ..t | ||
,. 4.t . | ,. 4.t . | ||
%.,+t | %.,+t | ||
. of 0 - | . of 0 - | ||
-<Om w'.%. .'.%; . q. 4O.*4 .' ' U , n up w x3a', , _ | -<Om w'.%. .'.%; . q. 4O.*4 .' ' U , n up w x3a', , _ | ||
l .Lf :*-* A' xMg: ' ?'Q + 0:-yd "vA > | l .Lf :*-* A' xMg: ' ?'Q + 0:-yd "vA > | ||
jv.' ,, | jv.' ,, | ||
'' ~, | '' ~, | ||
/; 'r i ' | /; 'r i ' | ||
? gj g! | ? gj g! | ||
Line 571: | Line 364: | ||
1 | 1 | ||
,a> | ,a> | ||
;q- , | ;q- , | ||
uy n f %;r rR ,q g4. t | uy n f %;r rR ,q g4. t | ||
-v.. | -v.. | ||
< m. , > - | < m. , > - | ||
t x .#n .. ,.w, . | t x .#n .. ,.w, . | ||
4 | 4 | ||
. p 4 W w %: ". '. ,. h.e | . p 4 W w %: ". '. ,. h.e | ||
; . :D e | ; . :D e | ||
Line 588: | Line 375: | ||
. y, W> ' | . y, W> ' | ||
t/ | t/ | ||
T . ,, | T . ,, | ||
oj 4 | |||
oj | |||
4 | |||
J, : | J, : | ||
h5)v o . | h5)v o . | ||
.w l ' ' ' | .w l ' ' ' | ||
h | h | ||
~ $ e$ & f, fu | ~ $ e$ & f, fu F W , + .it-o yf j | ||
F W , + .it- | |||
o yf j | |||
e.pp;f q. . 3- | e.pp;f q. . 3- | ||
, .t g~. | , .t g~. | ||
* 3C r - 9. .s > | * 3C r - 9. .s > | ||
->t. ' - | ->t. ' - | ||
4 | 4 | ||
- 3 ,:' ' | - 3 ,:' ' | ||
.h=.mw -- - ' i .,,;e. Jmuse 9 -t .>, .. 4* _f/ s | .h=.mw -- - ' i .,,;e. Jmuse 9 -t .>, .. 4* _f/ s ne.. | ||
ne.. | |||
'n;'} /, | 'n;'} /, | ||
f.x%y, | f.x%y, 3 . , i -s s - | ||
3 . , i -s s - | |||
g ' j/ sM,. f5.. K * '''r'g Iy.f .W p.y f /- | g ' j/ sM,. f5.. K * '''r'g Iy.f .W p.y f /- | ||
i l, | i l, | ||
em | em | ||
.t | .t | ||
' c.r_ ,- mq | ' c.r_ ,- mq | ||
+4 DMk W ', | |||
+4 DMk | |||
W ', | |||
n .t | n .t | ||
_ 6 g t? | _ 6 g t? | ||
e , "h W a. e, y | e , "h W a. e, y | ||
,, ilhf '! ' 4,m | ,, ilhf '! ' 4,m | ||
(" | (" | ||
:;qq.$y g # | :;qq.$y g # | ||
Line 653: | Line 409: | ||
, y. .. . | , y. .. . | ||
. ..+-. | . ..+-. | ||
e m, \ | e m, \ | ||
- , ( | - , ( | ||
d 's 9 , (di j | d 's 9 , (di j | ||
. %. Iy( g.-w,, i 1 -- - - - ' | . %. Iy( g.-w,, i 1 -- - - - ' | ||
v- ' | v- ' | ||
g%., -r.s v d i ,- | g%., -r.s v d i ,- | ||
a , | a , | ||
<-4F ,, c | <-4F ,, c | ||
: 4. $ ..m. >4.esAe >, , . | : 4. $ ..m. >4.esAe >, , . | ||
. o 1 +. . ~ s 0 -- O | . o 1 +. . ~ s 0 -- O n%wn p - y. o '1r i f ... f) gl ' 3\y w -}. ;%.<p jM[y-MN1j , | ||
n%wn p - y. o '1r i f ... f) gl ' 3\y w -}. ;%.<p jM[y-MN1j , | |||
3 t I 1. I I i i U I O | 3 t I 1. I I i i U I O | ||
e@gm' wy-M : | e@gm' wy-M : | ||
o> ;. co- o o- o o o o o o w .. | o> ;. co- o o- o o o o o o w .. | ||
o o o o o- o o o o | o o o o o- o o o o | ||
: m. tc 'a to .v to e n. co cn WW@x gd pb 'l ( l l l l l { l p4.v a q .d ' s ,- s . ,a s h'S J./ : b; I | : m. tc 'a to .v to e n. co cn WW@x gd pb 'l ( l l l l l { l p4.v a q .d ' s ,- s . ,a s h'S J./ : b; I | ||
[n. imlv %m ~;a ' f,,j l | [n. imlv %m ~;a ' f,,j l 2M WW ., m o e r ' ' | ||
2M WW ., m o e | |||
r ' ' | |||
q 'quoM pos loJ6mul | q 'quoM pos loJ6mul | ||
@4 .f%,d ~ | @4 .f%,d ~ | ||
u | u | ||
' i , ,Q~' | ' i , ,Q~' | ||
ox:N.iv.)7 , | ox:N.iv.)7 , | ||
.Jg. s , ' , | .Jg. s , ' , | ||
, ,. i , f ' ' ' | , ,. i , f ' ' ' | ||
h.Q v) | h.Q v) | ||
Line 696: | Line 437: | ||
,),''v,*si.. I 6J ,e,,.4 * | ,),''v,*si.. I 6J ,e,,.4 * | ||
''v[' ;ty Og'{ , .'4 J ,- - | ''v[' ;ty Og'{ , .'4 J ,- - | ||
ji;$ I | ji;$ I | ||
:)o.s m ,ti"chy' | :)o.s m ,ti"chy' | ||
@p . w' %(,!n.- . L ' | @p . w' %(,!n.- . L ' | ||
i f 1 ymM | |||
i | |||
f 1 ymM | |||
; ',pt .t.6 y O ? >. ' | ; ',pt .t.6 y O ? >. ' | ||
MD M.w(yNPQn".9,2;3hhhlh;b,% | MD M.w(yNPQn".9,2;3hhhlh;b,% | ||
Line 716: | Line 447: | ||
r | r | ||
*i1 | *i1 | ||
. < ' 4 r m?.. i | . < ' 4 r m?.. i | ||
Siit I , f ,aj ji A ti ? | Siit I , f ,aj ji A ti ? | ||
I | I | ||
~ | ~ | ||
: A+ | : A+ | ||
w r | |||
w | |||
r | |||
a-0 .- | a-0 .- | ||
" 2 3 - | " 2 3 - | ||
i | i | ||
~ | ~ | ||
i 8 0 .- | i 8 0 .- | ||
2 | 2 | ||
= | = | ||
i | i | ||
.w 0 | .w 0 | ||
i 4 B 2 . | i 4 B 2 . | ||
k - | k - | ||
n e a | n e a | ||
Line 760: | Line 472: | ||
R I | R I | ||
d e | d e | ||
f e c lc + i ei t d .~ | f e c lc + i ei t d .~ | ||
h y S er t | h y S er t | ||
Line 769: | Line 477: | ||
e 0 n | e 0 n | ||
o | o | ||
,P | ,P o k e i 6 i t w W so + | ||
o k e i 6 i t w W so + | |||
1 i n - | 1 i n - | ||
y a a Y P d | y a a Y P d | ||
i | i | ||
, o n d | , o n d | ||
, n o R. o R | , n o R. o R | ||
~ | ~ | ||
o C - i 2 0 | o C - i 2 0 | ||
1 | 1 | ||
Line 788: | Line 491: | ||
t y | t y | ||
I n / 0 | I n / 0 | ||
# i 8 W | # i 8 W | ||
RI i | RI i | ||
. d e | . d e | ||
r u | r u | ||
0 s s s 4 a | 0 s s s 4 a e | ||
M | |||
,. i | ,. i | ||
,. O | ,. O E' 0 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 - | ||
g 2 o g Orlv s | |||
2OO f53 yOT _ouova5 y | |||
l | |||
E' 0 | |||
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 | |||
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 | |||
g 2 o g Orlv | |||
g Qn@ . Wn .; | g Qn@ . Wn .; | ||
= & wW.mxw W N wmww 5 m Mn fpg: e . .. | = & wW.mxw W N wmww 5 m Mn fpg: e . .. | ||
n.r mu m. | n.r mu m. | ||
%n. . | %n. . | ||
MM ge 4CNgW. | MM ge 4CNgW. | ||
aMWRC' ,wprn ye . -e | aMWRC' ,wprn ye . -e W n.TJ,%, @..._WaJa%;M | ||
W n.TJ,%, @..._WaJa%;M | |||
, m ,4-c- , . 7- . ; P %n,,:.y. w~ | , m ,4-c- , . 7- . ; P %n,,:.y. w~ | ||
m W | m W | ||
Line 833: | Line 518: | ||
-= ,h n . - # .M n: d, %:q .v ;.,. n% | -= ,h n . - # .M n: d, %:q .v ;.,. n% | ||
n m, ;j? -m ;_ g n ?m-e. . | n m, ;j? -m ;_ g n ?m-e. . | ||
n - | n - | ||
<x - | <x - | ||
-~ | -~ | ||
-wso | -wso sp, ,. | ||
sp, ,. | |||
c g. ~ ug ;+g.: w. , .mp ,; ? ~q% | c g. ~ ug ;+g.: w. , .mp ,; ? ~q% | ||
3.x,c ..ny e. %m-: gl.- w4.Q. %+% ,37: ..:wf.~3 g0w 4 u =,r~ w s y.. - y u::- w,.g m.w w., , e~e- n w. | |||
3.x,c ..ny e. %m-: gl.- w4.Q. %+% ,37: ..:wf.~3 g0w 4 | |||
u =,r~ w s y.. - y u::- w,.g | |||
m.w w., , e~e- n w. | |||
, M.~ | , M.~ | ||
, . ::n, | , . ::n, s | ||
s | |||
y; | y; | ||
,m~; y% 3 .,.~. | ,m~; y% 3 .,.~. | ||
,;m,3nA_y . ;j ; _,,. 4, ,.w; | ,;m,3nA_y . ;j ; _,,. 4, ,.w; | ||
-- - ,, < rr .- | -- - ,, < rr .- | ||
> .u . r e,. ; : s.g. | > .u . r e,. ; : s.g. | ||
.,...,77,a.,4. | .,...,77,a.,4. | ||
.wg ,- - .j p,. | .wg ,- - .j p,. | ||
,r - r -. | ,r - r -. | ||
. . _ , , e - | . . _ , , e - | ||
3 | 3 | ||
.y | .y | ||
. .,, .., - . . . p j, -. , | . .,, .., - . . . p j, -. , | ||
, ~.9.. _,, | , ~.9.. _,, | ||
agp .j | agp .j | ||
- ~ . | - ~ . | ||
e~q | e~q c - y ,p{tegM116MWe.thMNOW~--*----'-v;nGvE9.W+E.- . .n @g | ||
c - y ,p{tegM116MWe.thMNOW~--*----'-v;nGvE9.W+E.- . .n @g | |||
%+). .,gW,. d 3.: | %+). .,gW,. d 3.: | ||
+ | + | ||
x-a e _ - ,. _-_, | |||
x- | |||
a e _ - ,. _-_ | |||
z | z | ||
, ' --. - -q:, | , ' --. - -q:, | ||
.4 M.} | |||
.4 | |||
M.} | |||
-:l | -:l | ||
-ma : -p; #m e c - _ | -ma : -p; #m e c - _ | ||
,a./ m.p_n-em. , ' _'_._1,'< | ,a./ m.p_n-em. , ' _'_._1,'< | ||
: u. n <. . <v- q ,,;.w. g_ ;- | : u. n <. . <v- q ,,;.w. g_ ;- | ||
,z, - -c.,h, J | ,z, - -c.,h, J | ||
w' r . - | w' r . - | ||
2 m. ,m W,J | 2 m. ,m W,J | ||
. , ., . . , . .. s . | . , ., . . , . .. s . | ||
Overlo.p ,a_ zm.w e,+c | Overlo.p ,a_ zm.w e,+c | ||
: a. o. . p- , CrGs 5-7~n, | : a. o. . p- , CrGs 5-7~n, | ||
~ | ~ | ||
a | a | ||
~ n f1-m N m. a. | |||
0 mm: | |||
~ n | |||
f1-m N m. a. | |||
0 | |||
mm: | |||
, . . ~ , .-.3- u | , . . ~ , .-.3- u | ||
- . -c..mw :. | - . -c..mw :. | ||
.9$ | .9$ | ||
~. , | ~. , | ||
''I'_ .'~,., ' ., '].c. 0; - | ''I'_ .'~,., ' ., '].c. 0; - | ||
_f 3 | _f 3 | ||
- 0.2 ~ - "* JM' ~ ~ | - 0.2 ~ - "* JM' ~ ~ | ||
% '~~~MN | % '~~~MN e, ' * , | ||
e, ' * | |||
c S x' .. ' '<- | c S x' .. ' '<- | ||
Y ;_, | Y ;_, | ||
~ v F v a,f mn | ~ v F v a,f mn | ||
Line 959: | Line 576: | ||
.wn u ; a,n;y | .wn u ; a,n;y | ||
, ., , . u ww _ + :fa | , ., , . u ww _ + :fa | ||
~ | ~ | ||
t < s y~ | t < s y~ | ||
a p | a p c | ||
c | |||
_o 4 _ _ | _o 4 _ _ | ||
; , n, | ; , n, | ||
- - w: . | - - w: . | ||
pg n , a -w.- c te x w- | pg n , a -w.- c te x w- | ||
= | = | ||
n- -. x- .- | n- -. x- .- | ||
~ -,,am.w -= w' .na m. | ~ -,,am.w -= w' .na m. | ||
Line 992: | Line 592: | ||
. | . | ||
* _s_ _ ,,, a ; " | * _s_ _ ,,, a ; " | ||
A, N' | A, N' | ||
'm. :A > r y-J T 'j f | 'm. :A > r y-J T 'j f | ||
~ , | ~ , | ||
> s .4 .c < , - | > s .4 .c < , - | ||
7,- c.. .,c,.. ., .2 | 7,- c.. .,c,.. ., .2 | ||
.m-~ | .m-~ | ||
-O.8 .w | -O.8 .w | ||
?.. _- . | ?.. _- . | ||
.s | .s | ||
.e. w% .- | .e. w% .- | ||
n m'~;.'m' 3 ~ '- -.e. a | n m'~;.'m' 3 ~ '- -.e. a 4- - + , w ~.c w -~xaw - | ||
4- - + , w ~.c w -~xaw - | |||
_i _ | _i _ | ||
~ | ~ | ||
'.m. D. . < - | '.m. D. . < - | ||
EG{ O.c ~ % - | EG{ O.c ~ % - | ||
m._' | m._' | ||
' -'"E .- | ' -'"E .- | ||
Line 1,030: | Line 612: | ||
r | r | ||
" ' '.}', | " ' '.}', | ||
~ : f ^^ | ~ : f ^^ | ||
s'' .,1,* s /g:h . , 9' ,.N ;>f- yp. <w' f' % | |||
G , | G , | ||
~ , , | ~ , , | ||
1% M ,. 9' | 1% M ,. 9' y' }m | ||
y' }m | |||
~ | ~ | ||
b, f,gyy T; | b, f,gyy T; | ||
Line 1,044: | Line 622: | ||
: a. _; 2 - h, - | : a. _; 2 - h, - | ||
y | y | ||
[p | [p t' .s a' dc | ||
t' .s | |||
a' dc | |||
~ | ~ | ||
m ym ~ .: . | m ym ~ .: . | ||
w _: . .- w& [% | w _: . .- w& [% | ||
' - 1.4 - | ' - 1.4 - | ||
+_. , , | +_. , , | ||
On a . | On a . | ||
, ., y o, - %. . | , ., y o, - %. . | ||
yc < ,~' . . , | yc < ,~' . . , | ||
W | W | ||
~ | ~ | ||
D , . | D , . | ||
.~- | .~- | ||
+ - | + - | ||
-~-- ' . . - | -~-- ' . . - | ||
~a_ ..r& | ~a_ ..r& | ||
Q % - * , , m yi - ^y _l.i 3 , - | Q % - * , , m yi - ^y _l.i 3 , - | ||
4 - a W'J o .8 - | 4 - a W'J o .8 - | ||
,o- . . | ,o- . . | ||
- -..= . w, c _Q - | - -..= . w, c _Q - | ||
_%'r c | _%'r c | ||
F | F | ||
~ | ~ | ||
.~ ,f#'7: 4.~M,- _ | .~ ,f#'7: 4.~M,- _ | ||
Line 1,092: | Line 649: | ||
., ~ p ?- . ~''' | ., ~ p ?- . ~''' | ||
%"'," 'a%' ', _- ; f,. | %"'," 'a%' ', _- ; f,. | ||
t. | t. | ||
. q := n | . q := n | ||
, - . .,1:- | , - . .,1:- | ||
y oi e. - | y oi e. - | ||
e _9. . 2 _ _ | e _9. . 2 _ _ | ||
,. ~ | ,. ~ | ||
= m _ _ v$ | = m _ _ v$ | ||
e +t msq- >. . . | e +t msq- >. . . | ||
--1 | --1 | ||
~ - | ~ - | ||
m - | m - | ||
-c ,4 / f .d k | -c ,4 / f .d k | ||
- 2.4 - | - 2.4 - | ||
. m. y . | . m. y . | ||
e1 y - | e1 y - | ||
y 7- k f m.i.m.# '';h. '' "'4_ | y 7- k f m.i.m.# '';h. '' "'4_ | ||
~. | ~. | ||
p .Nf E jyeng t- | p .Nf E jyeng t- | ||
- 2. 6 - y :u. | - 2. 6 - y :u. | ||
w . -. . w | w . -. . w mw a | ||
mw a | |||
., a C , | ., a C , | ||
~ | ~ | ||
. .ww A ., ,., _ = . ' . , , | . .ww A ., ,., _ = . ' . , , | ||
_2.8 - | _2.8 - | ||
s, - -_ | s, - -_ | ||
~ m. ..-,.&_s- %y | ~ m. ..-,.&_s- %y | ||
.~. - | .~. - | ||
w.q | w.q | ||
, .= | , .= | ||
.E. .s r N" | .E. .s r N" | ||
,c n s s | ,c n s s | ||
.w _, , | .w _, , | ||
_a _ . | _a _ . | ||
- r | - r | ||
'n | 'n | ||
Line 1,165: | Line 687: | ||
j & | j & | ||
7 }Q, | 7 }Q, | ||
,s_. ,.r- .-.- , ..s . .g -Q m | ,s_. ,.r- .-.- , ..s . .g -Q m | ||
4_. | 4_. | ||
w | w | ||
- 3.2 1 w .- | - 3.2 1 w .- | ||
c l.s ,s if | c l.s ,s if | ||
, :~' -- | , :~' -- | ||
3 | 3 | ||
Line 1,182: | Line 700: | ||
" Wh r i .i i. . | " Wh r i .i i. . | ||
: im 4. . | : im 4. . | ||
cic -1 | cic -1 | ||
..a - .. v , .. ,i . i. | ..a - .. v , .. ,i . i. | ||
... .e c-r -_ u.- | ... .e c-r -_ u.- | ||
w 0 40~ 80 L120 m . ~160t E O2002 - $ 240 7.e. .mZ280' ? &w- _m;m O M I M; n . | |||
w | |||
0 40~ 80 L120 m . ~160t E O2002 - $ 240 7.e. .mZ280' ? &w- _m;m O M I M; | |||
n . | |||
, . n. s eas - y | , . n. s eas - y | ||
, < 4 - - - | , < 4 - - - | ||
: m. , -,,. 5 | : m. , -,,. 5 | ||
; t | ; t | ||
,_- 7 | ,_- 7 | ||
. _ . .. v. '_ . | . _ . .. v. '_ . | ||
. Rod 1IndexOWDe . ~ W- - M "- ~M nW< O w f~%<. -J | . Rod 1IndexOWDe . ~ W- - M "- ~M nW< O w f~%<. -J v , .. .. c ., , eq | ||
v , .. .. c ., , eq | |||
* - M. | * - M. | ||
. :O Measured IRW | . :O Measured IRW | ||
,.A 6 ,L, Predicted v , -, s %- "- 3 .lRW- - | ,.A 6 ,L, Predicted v , -, s %- "- 3 .lRW- - | ||
~ | ~ | ||
t, % | t, % | ||
- 7 | - 7 | ||
' QW d. | ' QW d. | ||
g o c% | g o c% | ||
; %., -...,y | ; %., -...,y | ||
,> 13 , .cc | ,> 13 , .cc | ||
_ ,- *}m | _ ,- *}m | ||
'se-"L | 'se-"L | ||
>#^ > | >#^ > | ||
~ | ~ | ||
Line 1,244: | Line 729: | ||
*-r - 8 a | *-r - 8 a | ||
*4 | *4 | ||
~ "7''''>"w , | ~ "7''''>"w , | ||
,,Am* 3 | ,,Am* 3 | ||
, - - _g g. '.y.x | , - - _g g. '.y.x | ||
_'.,s | _'.,s | ||
,'s' | ,'s' f ^ ; ' %', _--& | ||
f ^ ; ' %', _--& | |||
: f. - | : f. - | ||
'W + ' * ' ' .p ' | 'W + ' * ' ' .p ' | ||
, f - . g | , f - . g | ||
~ | ~ | ||
* r ;? '',.m,$ y- ' \ | * r ;? '',.m,$ y- ' \ | ||
, . e'- L:s ., .. * -.'%'' | , . e'- L:s ., .. * -.'%'' | ||
^ | ^ | ||
.,"*~ ~, | .,"*~ ~, | ||
Line 1,271: | Line 748: | ||
..r.. | ..r.. | ||
, , x. | , , x. | ||
, s 7; < g.. y | , s 7; < g.. y | ||
: ..s - | : ..s - | ||
3 j f ^-,f>-,- j: -s. | 3 j f ^-,f>-,- j: -s. | ||
4 | 4 | ||
...m. a.? | ...m. a.? | ||
f'-' 9 -,! | f'-' 9 -,! | ||
.,'*.m m | .,'*.m m | ||
& - ' o 2 ,f '1 Y , *'- { -. _ | & - ' o 2 ,f '1 Y , *'- { -. _ | ||
T - | T - | ||
: s. . | : s. . | ||
. ~ .' ~*o r | . ~ .' ~*o r | ||
'''T | '''T g _.; | ||
g _.; | |||
+- .*-_'a i, | +- .*-_'a i, | ||
} --'. | } --'. | ||
^. | ^. | ||
1 s 4 | 1 s 4 | ||
_ = ' ' " ~~~~- - | _ = ' ' " ~~~~- - | ||
Qy- '# | Qy- '# | ||
a-,j"'*,.. | a-,j"'*,.. | ||
y,*'- ,,,,,.'._.y__,,j x | |||
y,*'- ,,,,,.'._.y__,,j | |||
x | |||
,.,s -~.. , | ,.,s -~.. , | ||
- ,3 m-8 - , . ~ - | - ,3 m-8 - , . ~ - | ||
a ~ . | a ~ . | ||
._.'p,. k v. , ,lF | ._.'p,. k v. , ,lF | ||
-f,',"'. * . . - .,;.. ^ | -f,',"'. * . . - .,;.. ^ | ||
p".., ,( | p".., ,( | ||
_. , 3 yn-.c- .ey g ! T_ , ./.%. . 3 .a r7+'., | _. , 3 yn-.c- .ey g ! T_ , ./.%. . 3 .a r7+'., | ||
'y - ,,g-r.. . . . ,. q: | 'y - ,,g-r.. . . . ,. q: | ||
. < -w_,', | . < -w_,', | ||
i,2 h O: | i,2 h O: | ||
,. ,,e _ . | ,. ,,e _ . | ||
..'-\~..- <+' | ..'-\~..- <+' | ||
4 ,,.f. | 4 ,,.f. | ||
t *q, ,,c s | t *q, ,,c s | ||
.''.4s.,;,.; | .''.4s.,;,.; | ||
g | g | ||
;f,- * , G> . 5 ur g | ;f,- * , G> . 5 ur g | ||
: r. .,.'- | : r. .,.'- | ||
; A.;w. 2 :'k: ' - A 4f,i , | ; A.;w. 2 :'k: ' - A 4f,i , | ||
Line 1,337: | Line 791: | ||
___n%_-- | ___n%_-- | ||
--%2%_ . | --%2%_ . | ||
__.u-____. - '.' ~ '. . $ _ - - ~ '' ~' | __.u-____. - '.' ~ '. . $ _ - - ~ '' ~' | ||
~ ^ - ^ ' ' ' - ' ' * * [ | ~ ^ - ^ ' ' ' - ' ' * * [ | ||
' # ~ ^ - -- ' - ' | ' # ~ ^ - -- ' - ' | ||
' "}} | ' "}} |
Latest revision as of 17:04, 18 February 2020
ML19327B249 | |
Person / Time | |
---|---|
Site: | Mcguire, Catawba, McGuire, 05000000 |
Issue date: | 10/06/1989 |
From: | Taylor J BABCOCK & WILCOX CO. |
To: | Norberg J Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
References | |
JHT-89-204, NUDOCS 8910270260 | |
Download: ML19327B249 (7) | |
Text
m pm - , ,
a 4 ~
q'; 1' . - - .. .
Babcock & Wiwox u i , ro r oivi.i.n
- ' a McDermott company 3315 Old Forest Road j s
~
P.O. Oox 10935 Lynchburg. VA 24506 0935 (804) 3'j5-2000 JHT/89-204 A
fI .
October 6, 1989 jf 3 ..
' Mr. J::mes A. Norberg, Special Assistan.: I Division of Engineering and 5Lystem Technology
' Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation W .U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission
!: Washington, D.C. 20555-L
, Subj ect: Rod Exchange Methodology Topical Report, BAW 10175
References:
- 1. .J. H. Taylor to J. A. ' Norberg, JHT/89-98, May 22,1989.
- 2. A. C. Thadani to J. H. Taylor, Acceptance for Referencing of . Topical Report BAW-10175, " Rod Exchange Methodology",
August 7, 1989.
Dear Mr. Norberg:
TReference 1 transmitted ' the subject topical report to the NRC for review.
Subsequently, l Reference 2 provided the Safety Evaluation Report (SER) and E' ' approval for that application. Thio SER concludes that the rod exchange
, nethodology is. acceptable for use by BWFC for McCuire Units 1 and 2 ' and
- . Catawba Units 1 and 2. B&W requests that the SER be revised to include applicability to all other Westinghouse PWEs. Justification for this extended applicability is included with the attachment to this letter.
y trul. yours
.1 . 'ay1 Manager, Licensing Services
~ ,
cc: w/ attach R.B. Borsum ,
T.I.. Baldwin '
D.B. Fieno, NRC [D[g R.C. Jones, NRC
/fI ,
1
.: 8910270260 DR 392006 7
/.
.p ADOCK 05000367 ij -
s PNU ,b,
m
'J.-
{
+
Application of the Rod Exchange Methodology e
to Other Westinghouse PWRs e The ability to calculate the necessary information to support control rod worth measurements by rod enchange centers on accurately determining calculated individual bank worths and integral bank worth shapes. This calculational process basically consists of three inter-cormected analytical techniques: 1) the development of specific fuel nuclear cross sections; 2) the development of specific control rod cross-sections; and 3) the development of a core model for calculations of individual control rod bank worths and integral rod worth shapes. BWFC has successfully demonstrated the ability to calculate the information required to support control rod worth measurementu using the rod exchange method for Westinghouse-designed plants o in BAW-10175.
Presented on the following page are calculated and measured rod worthe for three cycles each of two different Westinghouse-designed plants and for the three most recent E&W 177 F.A. plant reloads. Also attached are representative examples of measured integral rod worth versus predicted integral worth for three different types of plants. Measured rod worths were determined by the standard boron exchange method. This data demonstrates that BWFC has the' ability to accurately calculate control rod worths and integral worth shapes for a variety of fuel types, control rod types, and core designs.
The techniques approved in BAW-10175 are insensitive to global parameters that may differ in Uestinghouse-designed pressurized water reactors (PWRs) other than the McGuire and Catawba units, such as the number of reactor l coolant system loops, the fuel assembly design (eg,, 15x15 vs. 17x17), and the number of fuel assemblies in the core (eg., Westinghouse 157 vs.
Westinghouse 193). Since BWFC can accurately determine individual control rod bank worths (and integral shapes), and since BWFC has demonstrated technical support for control rod worth measurements by the rod exchange method, the applicability for BA9-10175 should be extended to any Westinghouse reactors which BWFC may support in the future.
y,.- -
~".
-y
,G l ' ;3 (.
- McGuiro-1 Cy 2' McGuire-1 Cy 3 McGuire-1 Cy 4 L BAnh ERAA EIid %Diff lank 11 EAR EIgd %Diff EADh lira 1 EIld %Diff f'
[ .CC 788 801 -1.6 SB 779 844 -7.7 CC 778 819 -5.0 CD 586' 656 -10.7 CD 483 509 5.1 CD 580 573 +1.2
% Diff Mean - 4.8% "
[ Std. Dev. - 4.2%
Conn Yankee Cy 12 Conn Yankee Cy 13 Conn Yankee Cy 14 ZADh licas Erid %Diff Bank ligag Ergd %Diff EADh litaa EInd %Diff CD 2068 2050 +0.9 CD 2319 2122 +9.3 CD 2114 2183 3.2 CA 1813 1818 -0.3 CA- 1872 1813 +3.3 CA 1929 2008 -3.9 ;
CB 767 776~ -1.2 CB 802 748 +7.2 CB 929 961 -3.3
% Diff Mean - 1.0%
1 Std. Dev. - 4.7%
TMI-1 Cy 7 D B Cy 6 ANO-1 Cy 9 EADh linAs Ermd %Diff EADE liEAR Ergd %Diff EADh !!1A1 EIRd %Diff 5 1220 1208 +1.0 5 1445 1326 +9.0 5 1380 1294 +6.6 6- 934 971 -3.8 6 1083 1111 -2.5 6 1012 1057 -4.3 2
7 926 978 5.3 7 954 943 +1.2 7 825 867 -4.8
% Diff Mean - 0.3% ,
Std. Dev. - 5.2%
NOTES: 1) All Predicted rod worths calculated by B&W/BWFC.
2).All rod worths presented above are in units of PCM.
- 3) % Diff - (M-P)/P x 100%
I J
7m-,s- - - ,~ e ,yys. m ,
- _. 4-
.p.
^
!ntegral Rod Worth f or: Bank B .
Conn Yankee Cycle 14 -
O -
"I
/ ~
- 0.1 -
- 0. 2 -
1 t
2 - 0. 3 - d o a U- i 5g - 0. 4 -
ou 3: 8 ,
yg o
- 0. 5 -
1 .oc
_ F-o v - 0. 6 -
u ci + '
o u
5 - 0. 7 - .,
s
- 0. 8 -
- 0. 9 -
[.
~l '
I i i i i i I i i i i i I i
~
0 40 80 120 160 200 240 280 320 Rod Position Steps O Measured IRW + Predicted IRW .
i
.i
- mn u.-#
gm 5.% y., , s , - m.g r ,,.
m
, . . . a , M,. ,. . A Y I,%%m[% $j~M,i@ M Q~W M h- % M. .yq M[n,gy', N .t % m, 7.[m n.[ M M J.6/ >,8..slhE n a "m[# 3Yl 4 e%6?[y@yj
. M y u M u & p y:m;u &
- pp M WQ+pX.My g xqamn sw dw c' ww aeWW~ %
, ~
~ e 0.' a: m; n, %'
eW; 4 w
e %' M %w;#
9 r m y n M..~ qDM% e (gw}Yh;gL
. c,4+ .n ap m$ $y w w p M mr h
y .g w 4,4 u % .kmo - , w; u . n, .#
- n. e n a -5
- Mk k h
,4 u%, pr .s n
A i s
- 5. k.
s a,3.
YY.+p , ??N a, W :+ . D t $......% Y +w, ?m. NYk;sthh:Eh,.lA. r,c< W ., 4.,s k; p o N :.
e , p e.
_4.:y-t-
aw s
7g e,yM %- g ,p.
a *o..,..
s, ^s p - ^x * ' " "' Up' 1y~ 4, s. ,4, . . . ,
, *W ,r gn :g;Q>i
- '"* d.E imU M# 243 ^hU,. .p N.+ 3 O Dp'p n ,m, ' ~ W. M S
$$.s[q n m . n. ,
i 6,
>v' ? w, ' 4, aw A,. y. .]
h1 'r A v hcMM u,v .: ,
Iy mel-
% .' .Gb.c 4'
>i j. = w , d['!M. n . TM.v- #
a ,c +k,.,-,e i
, .- ty,, a
,. 1Ewb;/ ' <IN ;y r
[4 "be +n\ v u !s*, .N J
%n..b' 6' j,- :p:&':.&f.f%:y,.:p !hA s a
~ n y-" y. .su uv '.u !
p!%:.QM' m ,
s f:c s
t.g, a80,4y .3' p
. Qs A .r.
3%n' n.s, . ,K.
e
,.b , 4 *,. e s q
,; ' Q MfM.p&.2' eg t e
, e .
p w ,
a he ;w;'
g U m e M, P 1 y>, b y@w n.x xr p : nf'g,* n,% 2 4,s M.@@?
W
- ey.'-n, , . W , ' y wa w -@W.n,;;pM n ~, . Mw W 4 <
n W h@~pgW ' -:t.%o d _'.
.c :. -
.nw 1 w~ m%c
..+ v:
QWu&sh Q@.W..
t ,, fl ;&. 4.d~lC.] L
&4 -\m ., .m .g {9Q * ,E-f c# ,
u Ma , Dy l ' ,b $.
. ? A s * ' ;"
s-L.l,9 ' n ':w Mf %aj - x q'Ll" ' l .
frwn Ml ,'mQ.? 0, %sayp
,l'
+
1 ..
y0/ ' ,
- a 4 4.
M. M,t C' 4[Q U~
QmA %iM ..
1 '<
. , /7.> :f . J. 4, ?(c; Mn i s
'i
,'e'
_ e - ' / . 'y. ,, i1 . . 1' uv.g 4/es; 5'7Mg- m ,m,l. % . .b %e,; . i.N.o i .
5
~,- N # $ '
ng 3 .1 .93
.t
,y ' N.6 - t. .-
w .,
,d > ' ,,x ~.. f-v f.0.M.r% s,i> Whf +4 u. , . m e > w- v, , %
M7~ - . . q, --' i. +, r F. w'. ~M 3 w's n ' m'~M, M U [,I
) J r f -'- ;
Y - ..uL -.
',- %Q .b
. - ;p< ,%*' , ~ gmN. "
. E 4
'~*
, 4 i
'l
-N 4
'% 'h
-g5 'e
- h. h..y, '3 f
siz, , . . .,_ g
'v%. s. .. W ' f'y,p.j s'.
, yme,m y
.s , , - .
. 0 ,' ,. 3 %y ,f* %yl.Q n p,l 4
g~g- a yn 4m :. nA 3
p&pga.v. M, ; s , .; ' .3 7 w
. o,. ,m s %
a 4ss .4./m, -
. g. - -rN u .s. a na n.m e -wde of. . 3 W ,, ,r wi ,1 , ";w +- ,4f ~,a. es c;g' se ;,rr w n; ;m.;
,, r(
uOwl mt d;1 ap+fq ,O ut+ < 1
- a , ,y e q.; . .e . a , s .s t 5 s
& . .w. aMw., ; t s ,.f-
?
! tY %
w" 'N' - M s' :~
a
,g .n .
3 Pe W ; 7' Ni Ci t '.,, D;G . V.:
Q. M.f'M G Q: . , wn di,- M, O M; 3%
n;g .
t <
.c
+4
... c.a+Gpf .n
, " ' y% ~ m a.
g
+
m;% U vy;p :..e., , o y+pe; y. yY .y? .m , ' tpa' 3 s;h-,; n n , ,
~
mtm' ./,y
- i ,<
f
,:%@;a fg 34 . :- 'i
- , , Q' t ., .. 2 ,r; ,i; c 3 .. y
+
t a
, , Lt. , ?<* l ,
, >t
- W. ""']. OL .y u ~a p > s 4 *
- W mm y
.f ap.lS s Q w;ca..+ L a- b 4. v, w._e wo M.y ,f ep ,4 4- >-
4 s .
1
.'~.
4
,'..s.
w m' R %.f e 1 +%5..
' ; . s ,.O6y t Vi,
'} '1 'O' g#frQO , .. A' S M.9 n '. ' t fi sg $3 C U.,A>.
1 s D1 Wa%y'- < <. s '4.,#.s
. -y [ ' ..V'6'
', .d. :o? r , c n e# .s e W W..
f' '
f9 e m%a s
, , s y n l!
M@.$y.Mirj kg E Cs ip1 "q n W.
1 h j + i 3
i 'r 3
.g b.',. @ ,%+ 9 ane 7 9W ,> wwi j
-, 3
.., .@3~y a>m% y o e
~y a -
. .< E ~
-1 n opm[m 4
. -. ; w ;
7G J' .T z: 'O C "
e As(f?kwp g 'd %f ' k P'
'er[ & .. i
^
.f 4
- t. , T**
- b. I ,
tt,y-w; JN:. " v m(c"_ m,, J.,M' n YM m* -
> m[ (m m,'.v; " '
$., NqV 'u --1" ....i ?.,, -
r J
,-w..,v 4
v,m,,s n x.,n ;g, 1,
4a,
' 1 *
%' s .- Pc &gM,r m a
, ,% . . ,9" , ' ya 9.w hg$ 8' . . ,kN qs ? '1,k
~
t
~
-),_
n
@ .i U I 'M5 s 'd i grM W.,,o %w,f lm* ' o., u;m,' e' , ' ,
47,
,s ',;q s uh
- W e Ec. W/
-' y' e .. _. .
LM w/+b, .J.g .~:xM-= us W).e ; e- s3,ys J'% s u s. < >
f e OV p ,
- g.ww% s .+,
w . ,4 A e' 4 4 -
i b, 9 1 s
- y> e g- e s. 6.
.~%
pAr.;d.
r 's
- r.-y
- 4 i
,$fd %#.0 ; y. WD i . , >
s:<*,, .. ht
,C;:;N' 'Q . aQ1' n c.m t a - , .e; a ,s v v t" J ,:.
y%ph,y *f.W":l, C*-G...l' .q *q% p f qvct ODY Lh&-W 3r N 4 , ! e/ .aQ:\ neq
+U r.
dn s ,
e a
' ' n j&;>
m., ,, ?
4.- ..N- .1q ' :m.O ;f . N, .
pan;1.Oo
,p nw n g..
m g~ -
- <v~.
- 3' r- g m y1 - dw<._.e , , ,4 m>.
b.;.Ny wwo ?% ;L.H G-ug);; W Gj yJ i W .'
m/
9 i , ,
- , ,; , '* <. O ; W b , .',-
d w?%
et 3$s .A t a
, f 3 ,:
4,-
b
- . e- .
g -. r rH .. + g ', '
s.L' 's 1 Q
A&.pe,.mc:tfme & s o s:
- a s, s,.
7 ' n a,a f. 'L' yi i
- t 4 x. ..t
,. 4.t .
%.,+t
. of 0 -
-<Om w'.%. .'.%; . q. 4O.*4 .' ' U , n up w x3a', , _
l .Lf :*-* A' xMg: ' ?'Q + 0:-yd "vA >
jv.' ,,
~,
/; 'r i '
? gj g!
kgM b QM v ,.N,: h ' o " , n) s
! :b'4 s W' ,
1
,a>
- q- ,
uy n f %;r rR ,q g4. t
-v..
< m. , > -
t x .#n .. ,.w, .
4
. p 4 W w %: ". '. ,. h.e
- .
- D e
. M( o , . 3M, m
. y, W> '
t/
T . ,,
oj 4
J, :
h5)v o .
.w l ' ' '
h
~ $ e$ & f, fu F W , + .it-o yf j
e.pp;f q. . 3-
, .t g~.
- 3C r - 9. .s >
->t. ' -
4
- 3 ,:' '
.h=.mw -- - ' i .,,;e. Jmuse 9 -t .>, .. 4* _f/ s ne..
'n;'} /,
f.x%y, 3 . , i -s s -
g ' j/ sM,. f5.. K * r'g Iy.f .W p.y f /-
i l,
em
.t
' c.r_ ,- mq
+4 DMk W ',
n .t
_ 6 g t?
e , "h W a. e, y
,, ilhf '! ' 4,m
("
- qq.$y g #
- p. mi :a . . y, ~ ,
g, .W.;W
'h ::: ; 'O.
Q O.#.. .
, y. .. .
. ..+-.
e m, \
- , (
d 's 9 , (di j
. %. Iy( g.-w,, i 1 -- - - - '
v- '
g%., -r.s v d i ,-
a ,
<-4F ,, c
- 4. $ ..m. >4.esAe >, , .
. o 1 +. . ~ s 0 -- O n%wn p - y. o '1r i f ... f) gl ' 3\y w -}. ;%.
;. co- o o- o o o o o o w .. o o o o o- o o o o
- m. tc 'a to .v to e n. co cn WW@x gd pb 'l ( l l l l l { l p4.v a q .d ' s ,- s . ,a s h'S J./ : b; I
[n. imlv %m ~;a ' f,,j l 2M WW ., m o e r ' ' q 'quoM pos loJ6mul @4 .f%,d ~ u ' i , ,Q~' ox:N.iv.)7 , .Jg. s , ' , , ,. i , f ' ' ' h.Q v) 'e. s LQyQ.k)y f;q k9y*m,pn.s y n.w, . . 3 5 E,,,< p 4( / *,c.N. c . .q'o" ^ *% e ,),v,*si.. I 6J ,e,,.4 * v[' ;ty Og'{ , .'4 J ,- - ji;$ I
- )o.s m ,ti"chy'
@p . w' %(,!n.- . L ' i f 1 ymM
- ',pt .t.6 y O ? >. '
MD M.w(yNPQn".9,2;3hhhlh;b,% M,+ffN'df0hd % 6 &i.t@A:? [ 1 v H, s a 1/h s * . 'p 3 r
- i1
. < ' 4 r m?.. i Siit I , f ,aj ji A ti ? I ~
- A+
w r a-0 .- " 2 3 - i ~ i 8 0 .- 2 = i .w 0 i 4 B 2 . k - n e a B r o 4 1 i 0 0 2 s p t W R I d e f e c lc + i ei t d .~ h y S er t r C e 0 n o ,P o k e i 6 i t w W so + 1 i n - y a a Y P d i , o n d , n o R. o R ~ o C - i 2 0 1 = , r g y e i t y I n / 0
- i 8 W
RI i . d e r u 0 s s s 4 a e M ,. i ,. O E' 0 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 - g 2 o g Orlv s 2OO f53 yOT _ouova5 y l g Qn@ . Wn .; = & wW.mxw W N wmww 5 m Mn fpg: e . .. n.r mu m. %n. . MM ge 4CNgW. aMWRC' ,wprn ye . -e W n.TJ,%, @..._WaJa%;M , m ,4-c- , . 7- . ; P %n,,:.y. w~ m W ,2 *;5 6 p+ .:,y ~ m.m. QM M W=fGM m y -@.Q y',:w.,n,~
- x. g.M@n@.m.g%Q,w.n%gn%ewme.y L.W D's, m--w @M .. G _W $ W,c.W M M W i M g.c .na n , .
p -= ,h n . - # .M n: d, %:q .v ;.,. n% n m, ;j? -m ;_ g n ?m-e. . n - <x - -~ -wso sp, ,. c g. ~ ug ;+g.: w. , .mp ,; ? ~q% 3.x,c ..ny e. %m-: gl.- w4.Q. %+% ,37: ..:wf.~3 g0w 4 u =,r~ w s y.. - y u::- w,.g m.w w., , e~e- n w. , M.~ , . ::n, s y; ,m~; y% 3 .,.~. ,;m,3nA_y . ;j ; _,,. 4, ,.w; -- - ,, < rr .- > .u . r e,. ; : s.g. .,...,77,a.,4. .wg ,- - .j p,. ,r - r -. . . _ , , e - 3 .y . .,, .., - . . . p j, -. , , ~.9.. _,, agp .j - ~ . e~q c - y ,p{tegM116MWe.thMNOW~--*----'-v;nGvE9.W+E.- . .n @g %+). .,gW,. d 3.: + x-a e _ - ,. _-_, z , ' --. - -q:, .4 M.} -:l -ma : -p; #m e c - _ ,a./ m.p_n-em. , ' _'_._1,'<
- u. n <. . <v- q ,,;.w. g_ ;-
,z, - -c.,h, J w' r . - 2 m. ,m W,J . , ., . . , . .. s . Overlo.p ,a_ zm.w e,+c
- a. o. . p- , CrGs 5-7~n,
~ a ~ n f1-m N m. a. 0 mm: , . . ~ , .-.3- u - . -c..mw :. .9$ ~. , I'_ .'~,., ' ., '].c. 0; - _f 3 - 0.2 ~ - "* JM' ~ ~ % '~~~MN e, ' * , c S x' .. ' '<- Y ;_, ~ v F v a,f mn _1.,y, e.. CfQ .wn u ; a,n;y , ., , . u ww _ + :fa ~ t < s y~ a p c _o 4 _ _
- , n,
- - w: . pg n , a -w.- c te x w- = n- -. x- .- ~ -,,am.w -= w' .na m. ~ n -0. 6 - ~ .u - ,- s , ~. . m *s.,.m :.l m ,?. & W 45 ) .
- _s_ _ ,,, a ; "
A, N' 'm. :A > r y-J T 'j f ~ , > s .4 .c < , - 7,- c.. .,c,.. ., .2 .m-~ -O.8 .w ?.. _- . .s .e. w% .- n m'~;.'m' 3 ~ '- -.e. a 4- - + , w ~.c w -~xaw - _i _ ~ '.m. D. . < - EG{ O.c ~ % - m._' ' -'"E .- ",. m K'.h*%+ r " ' '.}', ~ : f ^^ s .,1,* s /g:h . , 9' ,.N ;>f- yp. <w' f' % G , ~ , , 1% M ,. 9' y' }m ~ b, f,gyy T; ~
- a. _; 2 - h, -
y [p t' .s a' dc ~ m ym ~ .: . w _: . .- w& [% ' - 1.4 - +_. , , On a . , ., y o, - %. . yc < ,~' . . , W ~ D , . .~- + - -~-- ' . . - ~a_ ..r& Q % - * , , m yi - ^y _l.i 3 , - 4 - a W'J o .8 - ,o- . . - -..= . w, c _Q - _%'r c F ~ .~ ,f#'7: 4.~M,- _ oQ -2.- - 2' v ., ~ p ?- . ~ %"'," 'a%' ', _- ; f,. t. . q := n , - . .,1:- y oi e. - e _9. . 2 _ _ ,. ~ = m _ _ v$ e +t msq- >. . . --1 ~ - m - -c ,4 / f .d k - 2.4 - . m. y . e1 y - y 7- k f m.i.m.# ;h. "'4_ ~. p .Nf E jyeng t- - 2. 6 - y :u. w . -. . w mw a ., a C , ~ . .ww A ., ,., _ = . ' . , , _2.8 - s, - -_ ~ m. ..-,.&_s- %y .~. - w.q , .= .E. .s r N" ,c n s s .w _, , _a _ . - r 'n .a w. j & 7 }Q, ,s_. ,.r- .-.- , ..s . .g -Q m 4_. w - 3.2 1 w .- c l.s ,s if , :~' -- 3 ~ A . - v~+ S'. ~ _ ..::. : i . Pr r -3. 4 m ,e: t . x.- o,, " Wh r i .i i. .
- im 4. .
cic -1 ..a - .. v , .. ,i . i. ... .e c-r -_ u.- w 0 40~ 80 L120 m . ~160t E O2002 - $ 240 7.e. .mZ280' ? &w- _m;m O M I M; n . , . n. s eas - y , < 4 - - -
- m. , -,,. 5
- t
,_- 7 . _ . .. v. '_ . . Rod 1IndexOWDe . ~ W- - M "- ~M nW< O w f~%<. -J v , .. .. c ., , eq
- - M.
. :O Measured IRW ,.A 6 ,L, Predicted v , -, s %- "- 3 .lRW- - ~ t, % - 7 ' QW d. g o c%
- %., -...,y
,> 13 , .cc _ ,- *}m 'se-"L >#^ > ~ % j.._ <:5. # .n
- -r - 8 a
- 4
~ "7'>"w , ,,Am* 3 , - - _g g. '.y.x _'.,s ,'s' f ^ ; ' %', _--&
- f. -
'W + ' * ' ' .p ' , f - . g ~
- r ;? ,.m,$ y- ' \
, . e'- L:s ., .. * -.'% ^ .,"*~ ~, s _ - n. +~; ,,,._ n sv ,.,c , ~ v c.- - . .. -w. 7'; ..r.. , , x. , s 7; < g.. y
- ..s -
3 j f ^-,f>-,- j: -s. 4 ...m. a.? f'-' 9 -,! .,'*.m m & - ' o 2 ,f '1 Y , *'- { -. _ T -
- s. .
. ~ .' ~*o r T g _.; +- .*-_'a i, } --'. ^. 1 s 4 _ = ' ' " ~~~~- - Qy- '# a-,j"'*,.. y,*'- ,,,,,.'._.y__,,j x ,.,s -~.. , - ,3 m-8 - , . ~ - a ~ . ._.'p,. k v. , ,lF -f,',"'. * . . - .,;.. ^ p".., ,( _. , 3 yn-.c- .ey g ! T_ , ./.%. . 3 .a r7+'., 'y - ,,g-r.. . . . ,. q: . < -w_,', i,2 h O: ,. ,,e _ . ..'-\~..- <+' 4 ,,.f. t *q, ,,c s ..4s.,;,.; g
- f,- * , G> . 5 ur g
- r. .,.'-
- A.;w. 2
- 'k: ' - A 4f,i ,
/ s .. +4Ph .,t ,#e,*7* >*%;ppg, :-v-s ___n%_-- --%2%_ . __.u-____. - '.' ~ '. . $ _ - - ~ ~' ~ ^ - ^ ' ' ' - ' ' * * [ ' # ~ ^ - -- ' - ' ' "