ML20206H501

Denies 881007 Appeal of Dh Grimsley 880908 Denial in Whole or in Part Records Subj to FOIA Request Re Plant

ML20206H501
Person / Time
Site:	South Texas
Issue date:	11/16/1988
From:	Stello V NRC OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR FOR OPERATIONS (EDO)
To:	Bauman L GARDE, B.P.
References
FOIA-88-224, FOIA-88-A-45 NUDOCS 8811230212
Download: ML20206H501 (5)

Text

- _ _ _ - _ .

. oq r

I(f Escf,,g UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION 5- l WASHINGTON, D. C 20555

\...../ NOV 161988 Ms. Linda Bauman TOIA Coordinator IN RESPONSE REFER Law Offices of Billie Pirner Garde TO FOIA-88-A-45 104 E. Wisconsin Avenue (F01A-88-224)

Appleton, WI 54911-4897

Dear Ms. Bauman:

This is in response to your letter dated October 7,1988, in which you appealed Mr. Donnie H. Grimsley's response dated September 8, 1988.

Mr. Grimsley's response denied in whole or in part twenty records subject to your Freedom of Information Act (F0!A) request concerning inspections and investigations into H and G Inspection Company with regard to the South Texas Plant.

This resporse will address the records identified on the enclosed copies of Appendix D, numbers 1 through 6, and Appendix E, numbers 1 through 13 of Mr. Grimsley's response. Mr. Chilk's letter dated October 31, 1988, responded to the record identified at number 14 of Appendix E.

Acting on your appeal, I have carefully reviewed the records in this case and have determined that the previously withheld information will continue to be withheld from public disclosure pursuant to Exemotions (5), (6) and (7)(C) of the FOIA (5 U.S.C. 552(b)(5), (6) and (7)(C)) and 10 CFR 9.17(a)(5), (6) and (7)(111) of the Comission's regulations. Therefore, your appeal is denied.

The exemptiens for the denied information are identified with the description of each record listed on the appendices. The information that continues to be withheld pursuant to Exemption (5) of the FOIA is predecisional information consisting of advice, opinions, and recomendations of the staff. Release of the information would tend to inhibit the open and frank exchange of ideas essential to the deliberative process. There are no reasonably segregable factual portions of the records. Information continued to be withheld pursuant to Exemptions (6) and (7)(C) consists of names and other identifying information, the disclosure of which would cause a clearly unwarranted invasion of personal privacy. I am unable to identify any legitimate public interest in the release 1

of this information which outweighs the privacy interests of the individuals.

G811230212 001116 MA A-45 PDR

3- .

Ms. Linda Bauman' As set forth in This is a final agency (decision on the nineteen documents.the F0IA (5 U.S.C. 552 a) available in a district court of the United States in the district in which you reside or have your principal place of business or in the District of Columbia.

Sincerely,

/

/

or Stel' E cutive D' re or for Operations

Enclosures:

1. Appendix D

2. Appendix E l

l 1

l i

l l

l

\

l'

,. c Re: F01A.88-224 APPENDIX D RECOR05 PARTIALLY WITHHELD NUMBER DATE DESCRIPTION & EXEMPTION

1. 11/3/86 Texas Dspartment of Health Radiographer Withheld in part Radiation Safety Training Certification pursuant to FOIA sheet. H&G Inspection Company Exemotions 6 (1 page) and 7(C)

2. 11/3/86 Texas Department of Health Occupational Same as above External Radiation Exposure History sheet. H6C Inspection Company (1 page)

3. 2/17/87 Atomic Energy Industrial Laboratories Same as above Dosimetry Report sheet. H&G Inspection Company (1 page) l l

i 4. 3/23/87 Atomic Energy Industrial Laboratories Same as a' ove l Dosimetry Report sheet. H6G Inspection Company l

i (1 page)

5. 4/20/87 Atomic Energy Industrial Laboratories same as above Dosimetry Report sheet. H&G Inspection Company (1 page)

6. 4/20/87 H & G Inspection Company. Houston. TX. Same as above Letter to named individual (1 page)

l Re: F01 A.88. ppa APPENDIX E RECORDS TOTALLY WITHHELD l

NUM8ER DA1E_ DESCRIPTION & EXEMPTION

1. Undated NRC RIV Documentation Of Violations Exemption 5 question and answer sheet (1 page)

2. Undated SRC RIV Enforcement Panel Recorvtendations Exenotion 5 sheet (1 page) 3, Undated Documentation QC Checklist Exernotion 5 (6 pages) 4* 2/12/86 Memorandum. Mark Ernerson for File. subject: Exemotion 7(C)

Possible Exposure At H6C Inspection Company (2 pages) 5, 6/9/86 Memorandum. Dale Powers to Jane Axelrad Exenotion 5 (2 pages) attachment Undated Letter. Rooert D. Martin to H6C inspection Exemption 5 6.

Company, and Notice of Violation (NOV)

(4 pages) 7* g/23/37 Memorandum. Dale Powers to James Lieberman. Exemotion 5 OE. subject: Proposed Enforcement Action On H6C Inspection Company. Inc.

() pages)

Memorandum. Robert D. Martin to James Exenotion 5

8. 2/18/88 Lieber3an. OE, subject: Proposed Enforcement Action On H&C Inspection (2 pages) a t t achme nt_

9, Undated Letter. James Taylor to H & C Inspection Co.. Exemotion 5 (3 pages) attachment 8)SNRC Order imposing Civil Monetary Penalty and Appendix. Evaluations and Conclusions (7 pages)

10. 6/9/86 Memorandum for Jane A. Axelrad from uale A. Powers, re: Proposed Enforctment Action for H&G Inspection Co. with attached (2 pages) Exemptions 5 1

a. DraftNoticeofViolation(2pages)

b. Notice of Violation (2 pages)

c. 2/12/86 Merno for file from Mark Dnerson, re:

Possible Exposure (2 Dages)

4 Re: FOI A- 88-224 APPEN0!X E RECORDS TOTALLY WITHHELD NUM8tR DATE DESCRIPTION & EXEMPTION

11. 9/23/87 Memo for James Liebennan, OE, from Dale A. Powers Exemption 5 Rly, re: Proposed enforcement action on H&G Inspection Co., Inc. (3 pages) with attached Documentation Quality Control Checklist (6 pages)

Undated draft letter to H&G Inpsection Co. from James M. Taylor, re: Order Modifying License (2 pages) with attached

a. Oraf t Order Modifying License (4pages)

b. Notice of Violation and Proposed Inosition of Civil Penalty (2 pages) ,

Memo for James Liebennan, OE, from Robert D. Exenption 5

12. 2/18/88 Martin, RIV, re: Proposed Enforcement Action on H&G Inspection (2 pages) with attached ,

a. Oraf t letter to H&G Inspection from James M.

Taylor OEDRO (3 pages) with attached Order imposing Civil Monetary Penalty (4 pages) and Appendix Evaluations and Conclusions (3 pages)

13. Undated Oraf ts of proposed response letter to Congressman Exemption 5 Archer (2 pages) with attached

a. Oraf t response letter to Harry Gibson (2pages)

b. Additional draf t letter to Congressman Archer (ipa 9e)

c. Additional draf t letter to Harry Gibson (2pages)

d. 9/24/86 Memo for T. A. Rehm from Robert D.

Wirtin, re: Congressional Inquiry with annotations (1 page) with attached Undatad Note from J. McGurren, OGC, to E. flack. OE, transmittino 14.

legal advice regarding staff's orocosed action (1 page) r . e,- p % c

LAW OFFICES lBiMe Tirner Sarde 104 E. Wisconsin Ave.

Appleton. Wisconsin 549114897 414I730 4534 SMFF (INDA SAUWAN, L(QAL A&&r$f ANT Victor Stello October 7, 1988 Executive Director for Operations U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission APPEAL OF WillinL f\h D6CiS6 Washington, D.C. 2055 99-A-ysee W n RE: Appeal of POIA 88-224

Dear Mr. Stello,

Wac'd /0-/2-#

This is an appeal pursuant co subsection a(6) of the Freedom of Information Act as amended (5 U.S.C. 552), of the actual denial to release documents, requested on April 7, 1988, by the Garde Law Office.

By letter dated September 8, 1988, Donnie H. Grimsley, Director of the Division of Rules and Records, informed us that all of Appendix D, E1 - E9, E E13 is being withheld from disclosure in their entirety or in part, pursuant to FOIA Exemption 5, 6, 7,7(C) because; the withheld information consists of intraagency records that are not available through discovery during litigation. Disclosure of predecisional information would tend to inhibit the open and frank exchange of ideas essential to the deliberative process (5); because the withheld information is exempted from public disclosure because its disclosure would result in a clearly unwarranted invasion of personal privacy (6);

because it consists of investigatory records compiled for law enforcement purposes and is being withheld for the reason (s) indicated (7); and disclosure would constitute an unwarranted invasion of personal privacy (7C).

We believe we are entitled to the release of the documents being withheld.

We expect your response to this appeal within 20 working days of your receipt so that we can determine whether to pursue this matter further in the courts.

Thank you for your consideration of this appeal.

Sincerely, p.bf/ MW)

Linda Bauman FOIA Coordinator

&V$W Y

~

• ' ==C 60 fiovest%,wetasi U S. NUCLEAR MOULATORY COMMISSION WA- R$en. n,.2 2 sl

/*~ss. #' M ""

[ l RESPSNSE TO FREE 0'IM CF

! * ^'

'S

/) INFORMATION ACT (FOIA) REQUEST SEP Doca s t anyw e t a 3, w e,, e, 81988 e60vestin Mse La%n PART l.-RICORDS RELE ASED 04 NOT LOCAT1D (fee cAecast seneel No egency records subsect to the seaweet Aeve been located.

No adduoref egency twords Abrect to te request W been located are el<eedy evadaue for pebec aspecten end ecovq e te NRC Ph.c Docm Acc, Agency records e4,ect to the regimet eat are useaWed e Apparws: -

X 1717 H Street. N W., Weehegton DC are beeg made essJate for pWic escutca e4 copyeg e te NmC Pwtes Dec r v Agency esco'de outpact to the eut that are 4*'atJed e Apcenes moom 1717 H siiset, N W , WesNngtoa. DC, e e 'cade, wruse, f e FotA ev eese end reawester name The noeptoptetary vertson of the D'c(CleNg) that you 6g'oed to eccect e e tedeohoN coeve'6419a moth a membee of my sisM e oo* beseg made aveletde for pw end cov e s at P. Nec Puu.c occurrent Acom.1717 H Ste et. N w . wakestoa. DC. e a fone+< wrev the FotA avre.er and .oovece came.

(nclosed e efcamaton on how you may ottaa eccess to sad te cha'ges for cocreg reco'de pieced in tPe NRC Pwtd< Oocument moom 1717 H $t<eet. N W.,

Agency tocords Abfect to the te4est 6'e e* Closed Amy 8FD'acable cP4'ge for cop *S of the 'eco'd4 p'ov'ded end Dav' rent p'ocedw+es are ected in the c o.d. .w. -, to ~ ,eo.e., s,.e .een ,0.s,.ed ,o e,~. ,-o,, se,c f , fo, e_ . d d.,-t .e.,o,4 ,e .

In een of Nmc e ,e cern to the r,qweet. no fw,ter uten e toeg taken on ecce.4 6sce, daied PART lt A-lNfonMATION wtTHHttD pmoM Pustic DISCLO$umt en Certeia clo<ma:ca e the requeewd recceds e to.ng mthreid near.Af<om pw< d us esw e ow s. eat to t*e FotA eie+ree desceted e sad tw ee ,eenoes stated e Pan 4 e e e

tone S. C. sad D Aey refused poeices of the docwwts 8 08 caly pai of te 'Mord 4 toeg withr 44e a<a teeg made evadats for twtdic escwien and coev g e f a the NmC Pw< Occw eat Room 1717 M Street. N W . WasArgtoa. OC.

• 6 odde w de< the FOIA f e s

mte' *N Wste eam

\\$ ON D b  %& {,a (I nit au. ekc6ebs Apu c.wurds.

8

%.hsd %h vuuc ek og v' ecd sped  % '

noc& W \S%yn 1H .

2h 1.6V1,\e w N e&  % h ,ew% cuasa m S% %

usu ,4 y. % r c9 4 he accu m

- t sac '4Tyng, o atCf Ce cry oe amig4%o 4CCact NLU

• L' _

b) ,

./

N +e- m ah' ny NaC FORM 464 ers a er

' PREEOOM OF INFZMATION ACT RESPONSE

1. 0iA Nvustaist hM 2 i e47 g $ $60 PALT Is 8- APPUCAtti PotA (XIMPTIOees are be.ng withheld in tholf entkety or in pa

• undef FOIA Recoeds evbject to the request thet ere deserted in the e6 closed AccendEces Esorrpens end for the resoone set fntth below purswent to 5 U.S.C. 562(b) and 10 CFR 9 5(a) of NRC RagtAatbne,

l. The wt>4d eforrreten a proc *+, ctes*#ed pvrowaat to taecwtue or 12356 (DEMPTCN 13

2. The niihNad eformanon reie*.se sonofy so the beerraf personrief twies a- poce$wree of NRC. fDIMPfsCW 2)

3. The aspeed inferrreton is esec/caer enorreted from put$c sec'cevre Dy etervte bcScared. IDIMPisCW 3)

Secten 141 166 of the Ator*ue Energy Act mNh prohbets te dectcev e of Reetncted Osta or Pormer4y Reetncied Dets IA2 U $ C. 214121g5).

r Sutoa ia7 of to Atcmc tregv AC1 mACM prohbts the GWtoewte of Vactass43 $4r e gwards laforweten 142 U $ C. 2187).

4. The thka da eformaton e a trMe secret or commerce or fesac.e# eformeten that e te.ag ethree for the reancrusi ed.cated itxtMPTcN di The eformaten e cone.de ed to to coaident sl bvensa foropreta vi eformation.

The eformatea e coasde'ed to be propretary eformatoa pw esweat to to CF A 2 ?)0tdNti.

r The informaten ese e tevited sad twove$ e conf 4exo from e fo.eSa sow ce ow sweat to to Cpm 2 750dH2 Coctoew r e of pewusonal eformetoa e agency or iMreagency recoros eat see not a.edabn e throug% duovery dw q tet$aion r

S The er4hbeId e' ors'atea cotersts of ' ie< r wov ed toad to eA&t tPe ocen and fraat sichange of ideas esseat# to t*e 6etterswe process More recores a o arthbed in thew eate,ev. the fMts are ceiv<ste X sneertawed eth tse usoec ser48 eformica TN<e sino we e.o reasseatdv seregette futwei poncas toca se the esease of the futs wowW perm 4 en snorect cow.rv eso tFe prweceemet process of the egeacy f DEWP t CN li losw e *owid resv81 e a cswPvr w **arramed evason of persoca e

e pra,xy (DEUPTCN &l 6 The wreeld eformten e eierreted from putd4 6 sdosw e becawse ris a e

7. The ethheld eformten cornes of evest$,atoer exores comc8ed for tan eatorce+ eat ow poses sad e toeg a t*ted for the reasontsi e6 cares (DEW o .e_.e .a -or_ -e.,r, -..se e co.ev eeme noce. d.ec,. .. .- fx .s of -.c e-e- e

4. .~ , .e so

_s pcssony aiow tre to take Mten to seesd poteates *toegio.eg or a ecd 4t<c of NitC req ve-eats from e,erga* ors it.ALMPTCN 7t Ait Dwicese *oved ccretstote an waarsates evesca of personal pr.vacy sixtWPTCN fiCil r e fre eformten scrssis of rems of cav4ws are otrer c'ormten t*e dulcev e of **<m aov d re.W 4eatw of coefdeated sowace P Amt il C-OtNVING Of flCIALS acen a tN*d e eerst frora producten or exico.

l Pi re. g , o to Cf R 9 9 eed or 9 t$ of te U $ Nweiser 8eavterovv Corwsca regviatere. 4 has r teen orerweed tot to etorthe F ce'soes resce I

and in;.. As prodwtea or dwicese e cretrarv to to escac ete est

' Orwe cc of Rwtes sad Recores O#<a of A&W1'atee. son sev dea.eis teet q, be sc< eased to tre teocweve Dextor for Oce<et.oes .tooi

~

atC0 h 5 OtNit0 APPtLLAf t Of fiCIAL OtNviNG Of 0CIAL fif LirOf fiCE LC 0 D& WQ l 0A1% C6er N

?t?terD>n DUsh big Nw<.nyh M d .y. N X He 9 06 a)1 % e) '

Gam LA bh ee %4pA X t

l l P ART tt 0- APPEAL RIGMTS The denal by each dermng otroef Mentafed in Psit fl C may be appea'ed to the Apgerate Officalidentif.ed in that Section, Any such acce l wert ng and must tg made einhe E dayt of rece pt of th s f ewonse. Ag9ee'sv must be addre t>st it is an "Appeal from en Instef F0(A Deson.

U S. NUCLE AR REOULATORY t.;OMMi$

siac sonne ess .een 31 em FOfA RESPONSE CONTINUATION i

m.

.- \

, Re: F01A 88-224 APPEN011 8 RICORDS MAINTAINED AMONG POR Fitt$

Nupq(R EATJ. OCSCRIPfl0N

1. 3/11/86 Letter, (1 page)R. E. Hall to H & C Inspection Company NRC Inspection Report 15000042/83-01 App A (6 pages)

NRC Inspection Report 15000042/85-02 App 3 (2 pages)

Accession No. 8603200320

2. 5/22/86 Letter, Richard L. gangart to H & C Inspection Company (2 pages)

NRC Inspection Report 15000042/86-01 (4 pages)

Accession No. 8605290286

3. 7/21/86 Letter, Robert D. Martin, RIV, to H&C Company, Houston, Texas, su'uject: Notice of Violation And proposed Imposition of Civil Penalty (NRC Inspection Report Numbers 15000042/85-01 and 15000042/85-02)

(2 pages) attachment Notice of Violation and Proposed leposition of Civil penalty. H&C Company - Martin to H & C (4 pages)

Accession No. 8607250120

4. 7/29/86 Letter Steve M. Steen to Director. I&E, subject:

Docket No. 15000042. EA 86-104 (5 pages)

Accession No. 6608080021

5. 8/11/86 Nterials License. US NRC, H & C Inspection Company (5 pages)

Accession No. 861125003

6. 10/29/86 Letter, Robert D. Nrtin to Harr/ W. Cibson, H&C, (2 pagais) Accession No. 8611040154 attachment

7. 10/29/86 Letter, Robert D. Nrtin to Honorable Bill Archer, Congressman (1 page) Same as above

i

. Re: F0IA. 68 224 APF(N011 B RECORDS MAINTAINED AMONG POR FIL(5 NUMBER DATE. 0($CRIPfl0N

8. 7/21/87 Letter and inspection report. Docket 30 29319/87-03, H6C Inspection Company

($ pages)

Accession No. A7n?290345

9. 8/25/87 Letter, enforcement conf erence Villiam L. Fisher to H&C Inspection Company (6 pages)

Accession No. 8708270300

10. 2/11/88 letter, Harry W. Cibson, H6C. to Lorenzo Wilborn, RIV, subject: H A C Inspection Company (1 page) attachments Supplemental Response to Notice of Violation (8 pages)

11. 1/15/88 Memo, Harry Gibson to All H & C Inspection Company Laployee s (2 pages)

Film Badge 6 Dosimeter Comparison sheets (2 pages) i Film badge graph sheet 1 (1 page) l Atomic Energy Indust rial 1.aboratories Dosisetry Report sheet (1 page)

12. 2/ll/sti Letter, Frank Malek to Harry W. Cibson, re Monthly Inspection Surveillances (1 page)

Inspection Cuide (6 pages)

Aggnign No. 8803140052 l 13, 6/25/88 Letter, Billie Carde to James Lieberman, re request for an Enforcement Hearing on Docket No. 30-29319, EA 87-165 (1 page)

Accession No. 8806080233 1

y* 7/16/86 Notification of Significant Enforcement Action.

H&G Inspection Co., Inc. (1 page) ANO 8607250105

15. 8/11/86 Letter to H&G Inspection Co. , Inc., from Jane A.

Axelrad, re: Acknowledging receipt of check o no..s - -- ...

. Re: 101 A.88-224 APPCN011 8 RECORD $ MAINTAINED AMONG POR Filt$,

i NUMBER DEL 0($CRIPT!04

\

16. 08/25/87 Sumary of Enforcement Conference (2 pages) ANO 8708270319 r

17. 7/22/97 Notice of Significant Meeting (2 pages) ann 8707290257

18. 10/21/87 EN 87-89, Notification of $lgnificant Enforcement Action (1 page) ANO 8710300091

19. 12/16/87 Letter to James Taylor, O!E, from Harry Gibson, H&G Inspection Co. (3 pages) with attached Response to Notice of Violation (6 pages) and RequestforMitigationofProposedCivil Penalty (3pagesi ANO 8712280014 r

tetter to H&G Inspection Co. from James M. Taylor, ANO 88041204

20. 4/7/88 DEDRO, re: Order Imposing Civil Monetary Penalty (1 page) with attached

4. Order Imposing Civil Monetary Penalty , ann 88041204 Appendix Evaluations and Conclusions (9 pages)

21. Notification of Significant Enforcement Action, ANo 88041100 4/7/88 EN 87-89A

22. 4/11/88 Memo for David L. Meyer, RPB, from James Lieberman, ANO 88041303 ,

OE, re: Order !@osing Civil Monetary Penalty 0 page)

I

Re. F01 A 68-224 APPENDIX C 0($CRIP110N IOGER DA}i M and C Inspection company. Inc.. Special Undated

1. Instructions. License No. 11-217%

(3 pages)

New License Condition for M & G Inspection Company. Inc.

Undated 2* (1 page)

Handwritten note, meeting recorded by M. Cibson Undated 3* (1 page) 7/24/86 US Mail return receipt, to M6C Intpectien Cospany 4* (1 page) 7/22/87 Notice of $tgnificant Meeting. H6C Inspection Company 5* Docket No. 30-29319 EA 87-145 (2 pages) 10/26/87 Return sail receipt, to H6C Inspection Cospany

6. (1 page) 7, 10/29/87 Region IV News Release. NRC Staf f Prosses $7.500 Fine Against Company For Alleged Violation In Vyosing Operations (1 page) 11/19/87 Letter. Harry W. Gibson to Robert D. Martin. Docket 8' No. 30-29319/87-03. EA 87-165 (1 page) 11/27/47 Letter. 'J1111am L. Fisher to M & C Inspection Company.

9. (2 pages) 12/16/A7 Letter. Harry V. Cibson to James Taylor, lat.

10. Robert D. Martin RIV, subject 1160 Inspection Company (2 pages) attachment _

12/16/87 Sworn notarized statement (1 page)

"ndated Computerized Response To Notice of Violation.

H & C Inspection Company Inc.. Docket 30-29319 License No. 42-26838-01. EA 87-145 (9 pages)

. t IfotA88224 APPINDIX C DATE DESCRIPTION NU'eER '

11' NRC from 399. Invoice, acknowledglag receipt of check from HM Inspection Co. (1 page) with attached

a. Xerox of HM check No. 5295 (1 page)

b. 8/5/86 Letter from Harry Gibson, HM Inspection Co. transmitting check for civil penalty (1page)

Surnary of HM Inspection Recent Enforcement History (1page) l i

e

Re: F0lb88-224 APPENDIK 0 RECORDS PARTI ALLY WITHHELO_

DATE 0(SCRIPT 10N 4 EXCNPTION NtM8tR_

1. 11/3/86 Texas Department of Health Radiographer Withheld in part Radiation Saf ety Training Certification pursuant to F01A cheet. H6G Inspection Compan) Exemotions 6 (1 page) and 7(C)

2. 11/3/86 Texas Department of Health Occupational $ame as above External Radiation Exposure History sheet. H6G Inspection Company (1 page)

3. 2/17/87 Atomic Energy Industrial 1.aboratories Same as above Dositetty Report sheet. H60 Inspection Company (1 page)

4. 3/23/87 Atomic Energy Industrial 1.aboratories Same as above Dosimetry Report sheet. H60 Inspection Company (1 page)

5. Atomic Energy Industrial 1,aboratories $ame as above 4/20/87 Dosimetry Report sheet. H60 Inspection Company (1 page)

6. M & C Inspection Company. Houston TX. $ase as above 4/20/87 t.etter to named individual (1 page)

Rei F01A 88an APPEN011 E RECOR05 TOTALLY WITHHELD, NUMBER DATE DESCRIPfl0N 1 EXEMPTION

g. InTated NRC RIV Documentattoa of Violations Exenption 5 question and answer sheet (I page)

Undated SRC RIV Enforcement Panel Recoeviendat ions Exenotion 5 2,

sheet (I page)

Documentation QC Checklist Exemotion 5 3, Undated ,

(6 pages) [

g, ' 2/12/86 Memorandum. Mark Emerson f or File subject: Exemotion 7(C) <

Possible Exposure At H6C Inspection Company (2 pages)

Memorandum. Dale Powers to Jane Axelrad Exenotion 5

5. 6/9/86 (2 pages) attachment Undated Letter. Robert D. Martin to H6C Inspection DeWon 5 6* Company, and Notice of Violation (NOV)

(& pages)

Exemotion 5 9/23/87 Memorandus. Dale Powers to James 1.ieberian.

7* oE. subject: Proposed Enforcesent Action on H6C Inspection Company. Inc.

(3 pages)

• '" 0"  !

g, 2/18/88 Hemorandus. Robert D. Martin to James 1.ieberman. OE. subject: Proposed Enforcement t

Action On H6C Inspection (2 pages)

I attachment Undated 1.etter. James Taylor to H & C Inspection Co.. Exemotion 5 ,

9.

' (3 pages) ,

attachment USNRC Order leposing Civil Monetary Penalty and Appendix. Evaluations and Conclusions ,

(7 pages) l i 10. 6/9/86 Memorandum for Jane A. Axelrad f rom pale A. Vowers, i

re: Proposed Enforcement Action for H&G Inspection I Co. with attached (2 pages) Exemptions 5 8

a. Draf t Notice of Violation (2 pages)

b. Notice of Violation (2 pages) f

\

c. 2/12/86 Memo for file from Mark Emerson, re:

Possible Exposure (2 pages)

Re: F01 A=_88-224

~

APPEN011 E RECORD $ TOTALLY WITHHELO MUM 8ER_ DATE DESCRIPTION & EXEMPTION

11. 9/23/87 Memo for James Liebennan, OE. from Dale A. Powers, Exemption 5 RIV, re: Proposed enforcement action on H&G Inspection Co., Inc. (3 pages) with attached Documentation Quality Control Checklist (6 pages)

Undated draf t letter to H&G Inpsection Co. from James M. Taylor, re: Order Modifying License (2 pages) with attached

a. Oraft Order Modifying License (4pages)

b. Notice of Violation and Proposed Imposition of Civil Penalty (2 pages) ,

Memo for James Lieberman. OE, free Robert D. Exenption 5

12. 2/18/88 Martin, RIV, re: Proposed Enforcement Action on H6G Inspection (2 pages) with attached

a. Draf t letter to H&G Inspection from James M.

Taylor. OEORO (3 pages) with attached Order Imosing Civil Manetary Penalty (4 pcges) and Appendix, Evaluations and Conclusions (3 pages)

13. Undated Draf ts of proposed response letter to Congressman Exemption 5 Archer (2 pages) with attached

a. Oraft response letter to Harry Gibson (2pages)

b. Additional draft letter to Congressman Archer (1page)

c. Additional draft letter to Harry Gibson (2pages)

d. 9/24/86 Memo for T. A. Retn from Robert D.

Martin, re: Congressional Inquiry with annototions (1 page) with attached Undated Note from J. ficGurren, OGC, to E. Flack. OE, transmittino 14 legal advice regarding staf f's oroposed action (1 page)

Ene- M N e

e -

e_

' t.AW OF FICES

• 3 llll2 T irn : r S c r /2 104 E. Wisconsin Ave.

Appleton, Wisconsin 54911-4897 4141730 4534 mrF Lps04 SAW Am.LtQat A6&illasef CAA04 SCMutLat. ADWoutSTRATivt ASSilf Aarf April 7, 1988 FREEDOM OF INF,ORMATION ACT REQUEST FREEDOM Of INFORMATION MT REQUEU Director Office of Administration U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission

h. M '[ [ M cI Y Washington, D.C. 20210 g

TO WHOM IT MAY CONCERN (FOIA, 5 U.S.C. 552)

Pursuant the GardetoLaw the of Freedom of Information fice requests copies ofAct any and all agency records and information, including but not limited to notes, letters, memoranda, drafts, minutes, diaries, logs, calenders, tapes, tran-scripts, summaries, interview reports, procedures, instructions, engineering analyses, drawings, files, graphs, charts, maps, photo-studies, data graphs, agreements, handwritten notes,boods, telephone messages, co runof f s, and any other data compilations, interim and/or final reports, status reports, and any and all other records releva into H&G Inspection Company and its operations conducted under federal nuclear regulations.

9.3a(t This request includes all agency records as defined in 10 C.F.R.

and the NRC Manual, Appendix 0211, Parts 1.A.2 and A.3 (approved October 8, 1980) whether they currently exist in the NRC official, "working" investigative or other files, or at any other location, including private residences.

9.3a(b) and the NRC Manual, If any records as defined in 10 C.F.R.and covered by this request have supra _, please provide all surrounding records,

'including removed after this request, limited to a list of all records which have but not been or are destroyed and/or removed, a description of the action (s).

taken relevant to, generated in connection with and/or issued in order to impicment the action (s).

Garde Law office requests that fees be waived, because "finding the information can be considered as primarily benefitting the general public," 5 U.S.C. 552 (a) (4) (a).

&~7,2!?34Y A)*f

s"",'.

Page For any documents or portions that you deny due to a specific FOIA exemption, please provide an index itemizing and describing the documents or portions of documents withheld. The index should provide a detailed justification of your grounds for claiming each exemption, explaining why each exemption is relevant to the document or portion of the document withheld. This index is required under Vaughn v. Rosen (I), 484 F2d 820 (D.C. Cir. 1973), ce r_t .

denied, 415 U.S. 977 (1974).

We loo ( forward to your response to this request within ten (10) working days.

Sincerely,

/h Linda Baunan FOIA Coordinator LB/kt 1