ML20105B989

Provides Results of Review of NSHC Package Re Amend to Licenses NPF-9 & NPF-17 to Exempt from App R,Iii.J Emergency Lighting Requirement.Oeld Concurrence Not Recommended

ML20105B989
Person / Time
Site:	Mcguire, McGuire, 05000000
Issue date:	12/22/1983
From:	Rawson R NRC
To:	Scinto J NRC
Shared Package
ML20102A920	List: ML20102A922 ML20102A925 ML20102A929 ML20102A931 ML20102A933 ML20102A934 ML20102A937 ML20102A939 ML20102A942 ML20102A944 ML20102A946 ML20102A948 ML20102A959 ML20102A961 ML20102A969 ML20102A974 ML20102A981 ML20102A984 ML20102A999 ML20102B001 ML20102B008 ML20102B010 ML20102B032 ML20102B045 ML20102B058 ML20102B060 ML20102B063 ML20102B068 ML20102B080 ML20102B085 ML20102B106 ML20102B112 ML20102B114 ML20102B120 ML20102B122 ML20102B125 ML20102B127 ML20102B139 ML20102B142 ML20102B147 ML20102B156 ML20102B159 ML20102B167 ML20102B177 ML20102B185 ML20102B194 ML20102B196 ML20102B200 ML20102B206 ML20102B211 ... further results
References
FOIA-84-166 NUDOCS 8502090284
Download: ML20105B989 (1)

Text

.

December 22, 1983 Note to:

J. Scinto From:

R. Rawson MCGUIRE AMENDMENT PACKAGE CONCERNING AMENDME

SUBJECT:

REQUIREMENT This package appears straightforward on its surface, but conc

(" Emergency Lighting") requirements the Safe Shutdown Facility and nevertheless.

The justification given for the proposed NSHCD access and egress routes.

is that " implicit in the requirement for the 8-hour battery-powered c

emergency lights... is the assumption that a fire could simultaneously disable the existing emergency lights and safe shutdown equipment.".Th justification would be valid if the SSF were intended only for the If the SSF situation of a fire disabling the normal shutdown equip

(

. \\

regulation is the assumption that a fire could disable existing emergency lights at a time when the SSF is otherwise neede If the SSF at McGuire is required for situations othe I also wonder consequences of an accident or reduce a margin of safety.This rationale wo about the precedent being set here.

.?

to every SSF in the country.

I recommend that ELD not concur in this package in its present form.

T h

f

.//_

R.R.

L

/

C,v F

j,

~

cc:

J. Gray s

i; B502090284 84051G PDR FOIA ADATOB4-166 PDR

/M

,,g emm e-

.e.

age __

6 h-QN