ML20098D128

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Second Updated Response to Applicant 830713 First Set of Interrogatories.No Good Cause Exists to Extend CP Because Power from Project Will Never Be Needed & Too Costly, Financing Impossible & Extension Unrealistic
ML20098D128
Person / Time
Site: 05000000, Washington Public Power Supply System
Issue date: 07/14/1983
From: Bell N
NORTHWEST ENVIRONMENTAL ADVOCATES (FORMERLY COALITION
To:
WASHINGTON PUBLIC POWER SUPPLY SYSTEM
Shared Package
ML20093C821 List: ... further results
References
CON-WPPSS-117, FOIA-84-603 CPA, NUDOCS 8409270376
Download: ML20098D128 (6)
v • d • e


Text

{{#Wiki_filter:1 - 4e E35C97 \\ G E .e w~ .j " T'.,; UNITED STATES OF AMERICA .~ i NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION .s. 1.. :_ EYE 9BE IBE_6IQUIG_E8EEIY_oND_blgggsIgg_ggang -- 2.1G;';l, c. s j.g;pd.. .' 'G,M'9*,(. In the "atter of ) ) WASHINGTCN PUBLIC POWER SUPPLY SYSTEM ) Docket No. 50-460CPA7Vg;/.h Nl.7)$f, M;. et. al. ) C

  • !: ? Y:5

) p h6 "9 h..,; 7,;; (WPPSS Nuclear Project No. 1) ) hr6 5.'.'.N'?.';il FW 4.r.w -, Y. :L., c. IEIEEYs398'.E_EE99E9_ME96IE9_BEEE9EEEE_IQ_6EELIcagI'g_EIBEI EEI_9E 7...f: 4 7,idip 6' '- INIEBB996I9BIEEt_2VLY_12t_1202i r .., O. 9 ex.w + =' r'.J h*2'y$ Jeh, h h ~ . f.s ?iQpg ~ [Qy that Licensee". hee i,[.. INTERROGATORY 11: Why do you contend f o r a n e x t e n s i o n o f.th. e.W.N. P.>.. ...?rs. failed to establish good cause ,M .'.'i.)y". %ff% ,N}'~ construction permit? .5:/ @. -:W _IG$

RESPONSE

There exists no good cause to ex nd 7 construction permit for WNP-1 because the power from the:progect D { ' e '* * '.. t 'aX '4% will never be needed (in part due to its high cost), financing':$Mp BPAcannotbe[legalif'f.Y[X .%.t.j.QQ for the project will never be possible, <w v . :. W -s. y3 responsible for halting the

project, and the period..of'. tie e d.

.@:. f j :'U ' My . tu'yd requested for the extension is entirely unrealistic and who11 .c....

m.E. 14
  • .N. F.I..S'

W:bk*,Y,MTU7J iaposaib1e for WPPSS to meet. 1&[t'b ~~% G g/.yy.l pirm "$.N, % i;/ %- .g ...i. INTERROGATORY 18: What is the basis for your responsifM6 2W h Yf hfit;y.or interrogatories 16 and 177 . ~. - .. / 9.I.% Mb..y

Nb-c

" Northwest Conservation and Electric Power Plan".% f,

RESPONSE

+ ~ g. -4;. t. ...s) 1983 by the Northwest Power Planning Council',p$*T.d.'. '/ Volume I, April 27,

fdw the " Analysis of Alternatives Related to WNP-3",)Maye;Ja.n Table 6-2,

-{ :'n u.:pl**y*C 26, 1983 by the Bonn.eville Power Adminstration, and page,28 ofyg.., ~ r ;;t.i,.,.,

    • s

'. f.$ Electric Power and Conservation Plan for the Pacificyh{*!. the ""odel

,...i
o r.-.

Con servation ~ Act.g;" ' O..' Northwc r' ", November 1982 by the Northwest v. 8409270376 840824 9 d ^- PDR FOIA ,g. ::a COHEN 84-603 PDR W F m- _. _ _ _

.a 'g ,l s ,?. .4 '.- ( z, - e fn ') Coa'it.on. g.,.. l. s.1; - ~ J.'- ih.. ' .s' -:., [.y;-.,,.. 5 .;4.s. %~

  • ~

Respectfully submitted, f.%... - J nJ'n.* %i ; i .y yr .:3~y : '\\; h; *;('W24fcT:; As G.,Qi.*,5 )m.~;s .., t .3 :s. ,.n NM%u. ~ .,p < wd. 7...e ;.3 .r.. .,.9,6 ..h .; w h f,.3-2 ~ . ;.,W 7 r$.,l, $.gE Dated this day, the 13th na Be11 y of July., 1983. Coalition for Safe Power. .= . m.. q o.. w..s..:r.,. m... .w .... _.t.m %.pw.i e.. ;;di'.h:4WPSE .. >it W .h W ...... m.+nf&i.:.% J.'_r :

  • :. U, B, 4.s d

+ w p n 6.T. % jPt.y 9 ,N s,.%s.A. . 3 ,y.ha%p:7, g'k.qt) 4 it.:.%h. gy s.& ~.f.WsAPsi ..;w. :k.:4.Mn.w q -;;.: Q G E. ... :y ye n 1:n. $ '.t.~; y,.9.;.Q.g, u

?.' 9- ):.9$$hit

-.' c..g rgM........rg. s. t ~'W,.- t V . Ti %4 7,; h W

-~ -V ~,. 'i

>m/R ,.. w... cd x.1,...k,s. f. - N.- M..f -T >?M'G':.d hhh%%y n4.i c1 r.Q. viWMMHT,!.6 69.4JQ w --?p ~tik ^ a..... . M. sp .....,e: ..-'; y.. N.yl: ..-: ' ?a..-. jH,i &q@;0 f.* ?. .p-M; ;,.:. ,;, r. .. ~ co s n,cr? *. -. e. o,. W ' J.3*g e. !I s h,*vm e, 6 a 9. . d.4.1.3.i.xikelik, '. +. g gg,f.M... t

.I h%,3*. Irf,
  • g'.'l

'f 3= t w;e,. M 1 SiW, :n r,, 1 w: w. ..,.. r%, ; ;r s. ,.,., ?, .,s,. ; b 't' - ? .h,,. h

  • $ a?..",1@+ ' U p q

= #3 - s l *

  • p'f,t i> '.L
t :,Qs ;'b. sh W.. e.. ; *.. g,.S..

.$,.. :-t+p g r*, l. .#.,2L b e -41 , f.u,.4 c.. -F Id -r v,+ s .\\

  • g.*.

j.

    • ),'.1**..V...

t .*w . s 7 ! = ? * '.';. - ..u... 0 . S* d D ..h ' g. g ' b.' h A .6 a w.

r: 1 ..-) O ^# ,:n 1/ ,g .1 . 4 o- ...n,..- ),.~< g,: ' ' s. '

t *y M ' '-.

$ :.j.p' . :. 3.7.,L R 3 m,.. x X..ilf.;p;..u. k un.r;...J; = .t 0 f,,1chQ:. sn' q S~ ATE OF OREGON ) ) as.

N F., 4.1

.s County of Mu;tnomah )

q, g- <.
s....;.,.,,.?;

s. W,. a,, a ..,,2..- & =.4 *,r 3 . ' f".[M(* * #.' . j MJ,fk ; Nana Swll, being duly sworn, deposes and says: That she is the Staff Intervenor of the Coalition for Safe ,4 ;- y -Power, and that the contents of "INTERVENOR'S UPDATED .J,I?".'.'is'?fl RESPONS~~.S TO NRC STAFF'S FIRST SET OF INTERROGATORIES, JULY' i.*,4T' % 13, 190,3" and "INTERVENOR'S UPDATED RESPONSES TO APPLICANT'S 'NI.hif *'t! FIRST SET OF INTERROGATORIES, JULY 13, 1983" are true and 5.,.;f,@.Yi correct to the best of her information, knowledge and . ) j.1},0.'.' belief. All responses therein were prepared by herself and t Ck.. 'M Eugerie Rosolie .4.('re.f.,' d y -s 3 s.., = % .. w* .4-.:, %... \\+4 4 S1gned: . ; ;.;g % *.,,, g y s e .y,)4.o.:v.7,,,, ..4 > c.~. L;/ > ,g

  • . 1 6 w,;,,

,19 bh;;. 7., .. y..g,e,,. g .s.- s .. g r -1rM% _ Nina Bell - -WM..-M. gh 4 i,9, Coalition for Safe Power sp; .g. v. thia / __ __ day of k "- SU " R T B 'I D AND SWORN to before me 4 ..N. ' W C >b 1983. [ 2; y ' :.,. ..1. Y! N ;,7, f i,[$ '.yth a ~ b t.s<n t. e -w .o J.,..... Jr-MyCommissionExpires:$-/[-((i-}{e' t;' Notary P lic for Oregon {.$ j

y. j,e.

r '?..; y. yjy

f.,

r; , s 4 )~<h [ .d 'i N 4. 's 's i 'l f g. 'g t .i I ,,j'.

e.,

11 - ,d! r. ',.\\. t ,l i i i [,' I 0. e.> g .g l [ fi ) e,. s , t. Y. g I l- .n g,j i 'l

    • \\

$.,.1

  • 4 h*

,t.i +. ).. .6 ,.g i . ; - [.: s.- .r; 4.q ... - -...l. J ',. M :- .9-.- -.-2

Ib .s. J

3. -
  • e v..,

i. s...<. / j, g-.,:, 4.;*. n c ' 5 m-4. J; *'.. g

e

! ^ t{'. V, -f. - -.,.w t,: v.c, ?w .s ..' * % %..-) 1 s.u ...a e,, i. <..s c.. .y..h.*W4i.- M ....... ] } ; Q ~J 7-;f:r - l1 4 p>+.6- ,, t 5 TATE OF OREGON ) .,. 0. '. G V... -n...: ) aa. County of Multnomah ) 4/ 4 l 1,%. q ',,! .. Y ' 3.*i4(??h . ;f! 4 h.Pis.yE: iW4F ' ' y 4.ON;iCQ7v Bell, being duly sworn, deposes and says:

4. 'N,.p.'e 4-CO4 N2na the Staff Intervenor of the Coalition for Safe" i J i?4Gi..'1 Thst she is

' N $. 5.A..;I['[ Power, and that the contents of "INTERVENOR'S UPDATED 4 RESPONSES TO NRC STAFF'S FIRST SET OF INTERROGATORIES, JULY E.,-./.'-ev f,/ ; 4 gj. c and "INTERVENOR'S UPDATED RESPONSES TO APPLICANT'S }.y Q Q 13, 19 * '3 " INTERROGATORIES, JULY 13, 1983" are true and '4 e d. j FIRST SET OF best of her information, knowledge and $4 responses therein were. prepared by herself and..i.d.y.h,14.ij w correct to the j. belief. All - i. p h '@...k. 'f... '.f..A.,. Eugene Rosolie t -~m,7 .el1,.'O.yE.n?! g- - r -y.. .F 4 /. h' ' ' = e. Si9ned: p.;;;-:tM.,.,e%'. ' ,..s ... m . s m a., e.1

s.,6$.',e,,-t[

- g ~ c., ..s o 3 ~ .%c'@ m, M_ __ ____ - } $ T.P,Q j'!', ' < ' { 4 E ' "r,.M Nina Be11 .t ' +..,., c Coalition for Safe Power -i.,.,

i.-l.-hi
..Q f Idhik EUPR! BED AND SWORN to before me this /,,,_.,_ day of
4.. :h.b..... . t.*v.

__ _, 1983. v.;c@ -.a 2~ . ;i :~.'y 't../*l

  • W

.~,.- f:.' '.*h Notary P olic for Oregon My Commiasion Expires: 4 -/f-(( '.' "* M '-

9. #-,

, L 's ,...a...., x w.. 3 gjy-r \\. r.. p :. y -

f. *.'.y.'
s. -

. 7.> g. *. ' ._..-.--,,'s ~ .t.. '. - t

1 -4 .c L y 3-1-. / . v. ~ without velidity. Furthermore, continued construction of UNP.'V - c. y.lh i-NI night bankrupt the region. c:. 4 %. Yiw ) g - S

  • k for --: yourf';:.-.a,i ry INTERROGATORY 13:

What la the factual baala p o w e r f r cu n ~l. C :? ~ statement that " Petitioner...does not believe the y.' S' 75".4 YOF J WNP-1 will ever be needed"? n. .s ...... -T.x. :,;.s.r. y c and Electric' Powe.@;;.a. >, [~ j

RESPONSE

The " Northwest Conservation t .!a-

s

-a: Plan", Volume .I, April 27, 1983 by the Northwest Power Planning),gC.'.l'. s m .a.. if A;..;. i P o w e r a n d '. W. .S - ~<

Council, Table 6-1, and the "Model Electric A

Conservation Plan for the Pacific Northwest", Nove mber.'1982, #.' bpf.91Y ~ e f .. Yh.'O '.t,-2 ~.5 s. the Northwest Conservation Act Coalition (page 28). < i.c . w p$.. a v. W. ..., $, s.~y INTERROGATORY 14: la it Your contention that if and when,}the,. W'"E .>s '2 WNP-1 la completed and ready to operate, it will not be oper,ated,rcI,.75; because there would be no need for the power? ...;g j.g%~.@- g.

  • E'l.*<m M" %ju RESPONSE: Yes.

i= ~ e n .e .a You contend are releva.n.t.p< 7- 'NTIRFOGATORY 15: What'factora do 2,: 's.- j,g@.,t[;t 7 an est-ts.ng whether power from WNP-1 will ever be needed?, " Northwest Conservat. ion Q,-;.'. i 3. f, 6 RIS?ONSE: The factors listed in the .1 n &. er

.
i 1983 by. t.h.,e. ', :.?

and E;ertric Power Plan", Volume I, April 27, s ....3 ~ ~ h ' 5.NG...)*:k. Northwes Power Planning Council, the " Analysis of Alternatives}g;;., a . ~.. - 4 - -+.;,# .1,.. Re ated to WNP-3", May 26, 1983 by the Bonneville Powere,. g - k-4 '<bWtlh' Adminstratien, the "Model Electric Power and Conservation. Plan..JA.:#. y; w. ..A for th-Pacific Northwest", November 1982 by the Northwest' 4 -.. W;7'b '.ll C o n s.t r v 3 t :.,n Act Coalition, and the " Analysis of R e s o u r c e $,.>.:: ,s. .....->c. a: A ; t e : r. : *.. v o r." dated April 19, 1982 by BPA. .'.M.y :v M... c-6#.6 .I -n. ,u. l ', Respectfully

bmitted, i

6< s,-. r.- s '. ?l:! ^.w',' 5 l t l .~ l )...,. r. [. 1', C a t e.d .o d..s y, the 13th Nina Bell cf Ju;y,

  • 98?.

Coalition for Safe Power [. i l ! - 5. l..

'f X.- 6. --2 t 1 e, o s., s

f. !
9. O ympia, WA 98501) on or about June 10, 1983.

3 ...".T.. z., - i s A L A B,7 2 2,,.,.'.y,. +, The legal basis identified by the intervenor to date .a.. w ~ < %, : W(. ' onswer to Interrogatory.*.No N. v INTERROGATORY 11(b): If yourset forth and explain fully / ho.wy' y. w. 11(a) is in the affirmative, D I' .T. 4 %jr t, factual basis or legal authority for this contention. m ; t :. h. Q ~t-s N " u l t i m a t e '

  • g o'o'd ?

R* I?

RESPONSE

ALAB-722 establishes that the . S.w El I. ; i u.+ t cause" d'etermination is expected to encompass a Judgement:- about r;. 4.;,n .. 4 * + n. '.?; r M 4 ;; 34> .t. not to rest solely uport:rg.;yv ....w.:

fi why the plant should be completed and is

,.,: y .v..a n I, the' applicant's fault for delay", "whether good. y ;,,. g a judgewnt as s.t p p:.

r..
, ~ -
a cause e
u sts to egend the construi: tion completion date".and t at y / '.

continued f'w..i.wh "a u d '3 + m e n t must still be made as to whether T <.i ? A'o .t.; 2 q construe-ion should nonetheless be allowed." The Appeals Board...h r,m ? t. 2

w. -

k ?. M y also discusses the temporary lack of need for power anct lackjof4 g;&c 1 G.,M$b financina ac factors which cause delay with valid businesag,.f.f3 2

C,l....%

a distinction between a " deferral"4 ofl*f'j -!fQ purposes. Intervenor sees s ' r E.n. /f ' W-lack of need or slowing of growth rate,.with yl%:f %. need and a temporary a, 3. + . u. t. the former a more suitable description of the instant case. 4.cfpq f $ :* '.'idC& 5 'l.;&MQ !N'ERROGATORY 12: (a) Do you claim that the actual deferrel.[if ruig in the need for power in the Northwest United States does'. not G I'.jp justify deferring construction of WNP-17 j ac'dm').f (b) E:< plain fully your answer to Interrogatory No. 12(a).F 34:sr.', t is in the p.}CC' te) If your answer to Interrogatory No. 12(a) that l.p:, affirmative, state the relevance of your statement NorthwestUnited,6.'.,p[ will ever.be.i.%.,Al "Potitioner...does not belive the power from WNP-1 needed" to your claim that need for pow'er in the States 9.es not justify deferring construction of WNP-1. . j...':. ;;,

  • y... V BESPONSE:

.( a ) Yes. (b) The " deferral of need" austifies N' O.o d, W 5.. e s.. . c ) p.r'.',,- ( canceliction of the project not a deferral of construction. If there as never a need for the plant, the pla'nt should'be C - 'ep,Id rS.) plant's principle purposejis,,t.*c.:/ i cancelled, not deferred, because a 5 '.$9 W to provide needed electricity. The basis for the NRC's decisionl '. W , - e.:.% construction permit has proven to be totally,.';.), to grant WNp-1 a i y.,. s e h ,,,.}}

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20098D128&oldid=4315797"