ML20085A709
| ML20085A709 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Crane, Crystal River |
| Issue date: | 08/08/1968 |
| From: | Thomas C BABCOCK & WILCOX CO. |
| To: | Rodgers J FLORIDA POWER CORP. |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20085A715 | List: |
| References | |
| TASK-*, TASK-GB FPC-151, GPU-0519, GPU-519, NUDOCS 8307070074 | |
| Download: ML20085A709 (6) | |
Text
r-v-
n.
~ _ -
.c.
--~
+
}
. Af 31 d
(
v.<..:
0 u..:..,....:.n. ns.
p: w cer.e.s,a o; e p w
- ~.
s-P O. [t s IMO.lynct+t *- V2. 2 '!.5 T(t:.%nes(703) G3 73G1
/
.~
Aucu:t 3, 19C3
\\
g-
~
T N-131
\\ y r.
(,s.'/
/ /,,..-
G/-
t* :
s
..r.
. T. 5:i_trs, Dirc: tor.
Pover I:.ci utrirg & C:.-.ruction. Dept.
Florics ?:ver.**.:r,cratics P. O. 2c c IL*12 St.. ?ccr:1-= c, 71:rida 33733 p /T y W
- Sub, ject:
0:7:tsi ?.iver Plant, Unit E:. 3
,e Ess: : c creter Trainiac Frc:-rs=
,0<
, _\\
,c,erec e.. -,
.,.. r-.,. TEI onom..-....,.., n.:<. -.. a-
.m...
,w.-...
3":L:c?. Pia:T sr/fr, Florih 7c :.- ::r;.:re.-ion, A;ril, 1967 F. R. T, (2) Letter, ??c-18, "creretor crchus 7;:.- a:",
my 5..wST.
- iUG 261969
~
G) Intsce, de-36, "c;erater Trair.1:g Pre rs=,
July 25, 1967 (1) letter, ??c-93, "cryistal ?.1 rer :.s.=t, nit so. 3 Craisir.c 3 ochure",1:ar:h 12,.*265.*
(5) Letter ***. C. hy to Fred J. ~~cr:ss
.u 2 27, 1968.
i Dcar :*r. 3:!.gers:
On Mrrch CS, ;?GS, Yessrs. R. R. Scach, J. C. Debens, L:t F. Cor:au of EaV presented t: 71:ridt ??.tr Corporation ;cr::::21 the rtatus of AEC reactor operr.ter li:t13e rer.: ire ents and* the sct.t.ar cf 1*,*J's ;2 ass to procure a t.
trainir.g zi: :In:r. 7:e 3,urpose of the traisi g zi=:.~ ttcr is to replace the y
c;ers-ic t*. es,srie: e a.t a ec parable res:ts: rar:irei 17 the AE0 for
\\
Q licom. ting. " se sh:1 ster has now been criered 17 17.* f:: '.clivery in lace 1969 asi v'*~ % *-sta.11cd in a new traini:g center ;rtzer.tly bein con-k structei h 17: hicrg, Virginis. The fa:ility 's -ez,s:ted to be ready for h
trair.ir.g etr!7 i: 1970.
9 In accords :e vhh our previous discussic s vith 7::, vc ;;;;ose, for your d
cencid.::t:i::, -ilizatier. of the B&V ?"J. Si=
~.s---
' '-a T&~4 *ynchburg E
? col ?.*::.:::: **JI) ir. the trsining of ycur c;sruhr ;ers:r.rel who vill' i
, e5 cycrate 0 7: *. 7.iver t.*ait Co. 3.
The FP " "* st::.rthing presra= as k
- resost".y ;*. r.
i prev 2 ?' r a ten-ve:?. ect-3e c :t hhs :lt:srcos traini==Tac asi op1rt-ht 31 trahin-using hands-en c;erttic. cf -h*
?'O. fi ulater.
4
.cf *g. e 8.
propcze'. use :f the ~7:chturg Pool Reacter Ir:riie: sterste:/ and cperatic. al 1
y[{$
trr.ishg h :--:rr.ti:c a:tual reactor c;er. h: h r:~.*-hg.3 q p go s.
>4.d, s.v;j ;
1.
.~
~ ~
v e.:
- ~
f 1
c: -:
.]
q...,* y ~*
Tr.: cc:ce r.vacca ex: :: / / t. r--w :r 7
- s, *a"t s t.
J 8307070074 680808
'~
PDR ADOCK 05000289 A
HOL O 1 3 2 f. ~_ (5. N ~
~
?.
, D 9J,; /. '. i.!.6.g.
l
Ecbcoch M*.'ibcx Fr. J. T. EoJ,ers August 8, loc 8
' reacter sisrtu;, 7ais trainir.c in c:r.Jur.:ti:n with the propoced tr:.inir.c 8
on the 21*** F.7. Si= ulster can fulfill r.ll cf the ree:ter startupc' r: quired by the AI"; f:r licensing of reacter c;crr.tcr:.
We propc:e to provide the tes-veck cou-:a: in T"."' Sir.ulstor traini c.(ped of
~
Phsse I*.*) cer.erally a,s decerited in atte.:ha.1 ':r.tle 3. starting in. July,1970.
The detc.i* s cf the course *=:terini are sutJ t:t' to clicht modification durir.g.
- e are pleased to quote far the final ;r.:pration of instructic: :sterisl.
a this pr:grsr.~s price of t iligi,h: 2,ar.d.,d:11srs ($200,000) for train,1,gg a 12-::: gr:up._, We furth@cr quote,a pri:e Of cae h : dred thousand^f.ollars s
($100,CO*u f:r an additional group cf sJx (C) =cn.
This quotati'en is sutJcet
,to the esst 'ter=s and cenditions s's~ cur L'utlear Stecs Cupply Cor.trict A12-10S' dated Csycster 10, 1967 The above pricos et.tr caly the additienal R&W cei:t for cc:d : ting the fR Si=ulstor trainisc, fr.:le31sc the use of SW facilities, perso.r.ci, and trainin; r.sterials duri:g the.er.-vech progran. This quotation enlu.ies ths.t pcrtion of the classroc. tre.!:Ir.c ;resently in Phases III and I7 and in:1udei in the present USS Contrs=t. The salaries a.d expenses of FPC persor.nel shall be by Florida Pover. A quetati.pn cn the two-veut program utilizing the Lfnchburg Pool Eeactor as ;rcrc '.ei in Tr.bic 2, " Tentative Course Outlir.e,.Ir.treduction to Reactor 0;sratter.: and Practical Reacter Physics",
i vill te ser.*. to you in the near future.
- e 34'J has fatricated's mockup of the console of the powcr.pinr.t si=ulator.
invite you and your personnel to visit lyt:hturg to inspect this concole =ech-up and to discuss the sir:ulator training yrrgran further as you mey desir'c.
We ree : er.f that you discuss your overal* c;ers.tcr training proces:, including trainia;; cs the B&W PV3 Sisulator, with the C;erator Licensing Branch, USAF.C, (Mr. Tra:1 relly, Branch Chief).
I. request thst 3W participate with you'in a.v discussiens that, may take place with this trasch of the AIC.
Please advice if any 'further infor. stion is required to enable yoe to make an early decision on this quotation.
I RT.SPOSEE '"O yPC I.rl"fFR DATED JU':t 2't,1943:
i i
Refere:ce (5) requested that ve add.-ess oc.rselves to certain question's when sute.itting thic proposal., Cur res;cr.se to iir. F.ay's questi.ons follovs:
l l
1.
As the ;rescr.t time, the AEC reccc:Ir.es the d'iffievity that' vill te ex-I perier.:ed in providing. nuclear pover ststics.experiu.ce for the. great nu ter of resetor operators which eill te rcquired by the ele.ctrical utilitics. In addition, the ve.lue of tics s; cat in an operating pis=t
- could be limited, since durinC a:7 four to six-=on'.h period of tice, a ple.t could be base loaded and so site.ificant operating experienee vould he ottained. In discussicas with the AT.0, vertal a;;roval has been diven.
for the use of a simulstor as a substitute for power reactor operating ex ericace.. This approval is contir. gest en L&*J pr-viding an adequate si ule.*.!.r. of the pirnt and on the Utility agrcc=: a to send the trainee s
~
to a ;;vcr recctor for a short perici cf ot:crvation. This cbservatic.n vil.1 :st require " hands-on" contr:1 of the cperatinc plant. Although
~
o132 p.* G A 6 D.s}fi,1.iiE.E.
~
s**
.m
___,.rm
+,
1 Cab:cchCV.Teox Mr. J. T. Roigers August 8,1963 no written cd:rante: esn he ottsir.<d'fr:: th:..!>.',
I'eW vill ethe ary ressenctic =adIficatter.s required to..he the":10 simulater precrt-g a:ccptabic to the. AEt.
i 2.
The schedule for Ei9's siculater is thst.it te c;erstier.?1 and debucccd, in early January,1970.. The.six- :r.th ;sried ;rcecedin; the first clas; vill be utill:cd by B57 perscnnel fir their own training in addition.to acquaintinC the AEO vith its functicas. Also, any modifications required in hardstre or ;rocrs= ming that =sy toccc.c a;part:t during this period vill also be exac. We feel that hacquate "cushler." has teen provided in the chcedule t. rcure that the ??O procram cr.n te.;rovided duri~ng the tir. period scheiuled.
3 SiW's. sir.ulator facility will Include a rsproccststien of the control console for a siccio unit 352 nue:ctr power stetten with the contrcls J
operating a ec puter instead of the ptver statica ces;onents. ' The ccatrol
'rocas vill contain the conr. oles for c:r.t.-ol of t,he evercli 800. :m plant
)
and the required operational indicaters and clsr s.
The layout of the simulator vill te sent to you abcut the first of deptester for use in(
i laying cat the console for the Crystal Siver No. 3 tr.it.
h.
The entire apprcach in the desic of'the sinulator h:s been ti provide a piccc.of "high fidelity" equipec:t which vill o; crate in real t'ico.
We have acecr.plished this eith the equ!p cat purchssed a:d as such, there' are no discernible limitations in the accuracy of si=ulating operation.
There may be, hevcVer, differences in the scope of instrumentation as presented by the simulator and as provided by TPC*and also in the ar-rancement or desi n of the console. These differences will be slight C
compared with differences that a trainic vould experience by going into any plant in operatica today or in 1970 when the training vill be required.
q 5
Provision for training the operctors in absorsal c;erating situutions or "casualtics" is quite extensive. Casualties can te introduced either on a procras: sed basis or directly by the instructcrs a.-d are donc in such a manner that the atmosphere of an artifically i=;esci cendition is evcided.
At the present time, ve are progra==ihg sp;roxi stely 80 casualties which involve the control rod drive syste=, nuclear instru=entation syste=,
reactor coolant system, secondsry pitat turbine ar.d feedvster syster.s, auxiliary syste:s, cnd electrical syytems. In addition to the preceding, the instructor has the ability to i=;oco redundant casualtics concurrent vith those progra==ed.
It' is anticipated that all of these casualties vill be imposed a nu=ber of times, since i=. rove: st in response by the s
operator to a situation is the =ctns of evaluati=c the operator.
t y
gg.;).i.-C..s 0132 % M. O..
l
~
I. : ~
1.. a
=
~
F m
C6:0d. f.Y.Tc0;;
h-August 8, 1963 2.*r. J. T. Rcicers
? ??ATIC': mil? 0:* SI'"J!.ATOR ' ?AI~~* i 7", C*.*: *dALL,_"~-:A-*~*:. PR* 0E *.*!
T c MW Trainin Guide,'referen=e (1), deceribes an overall ; recess of training which does not include usc of a ;:vsr plant sir.ulator. The e.v. trial in this doeur.cnt has been discussed with Florida Power 0 prating and ilciscerinc persennel.
The revised p'rocran including sir-4 t:r training is as follows:
Phase I Tacoretical Trainin;
- R C1.scrvatica Phase II.
Phase III in' P'.lR TechnoIc;y Trsinind,
Phase IV
- P'O. 0,+raticu Training Phase V.
D:-the-Job Training 1.
Phase I Theoretier_l'T: sir.irc - Sy Florida Power l
We continue to recc=. cad thst the theoretical training te ccnducted essentia11'y
~
.as proposed in Section 3 2, ";+scription ar.: Schedule for ?/pical Training Program", pa:es 8, 9, and 10 :f reference ( A), an as ci na in = ore detati in
~
i our letter FPC-18, reference (2), with one execpt.icn. 'the fetroduction to calculus may be de-e=phasi:ei hy reducing the estiented tira, spcst.on.this subject from 60 to 10 hours1.157407e-4 days <br />0.00278 hours <br />1.653439e-5 weeks <br />3.805e-6 months <br />. This is in accordance with our discussions with the AE0 as reported is our letter, PPC-36, refereccc (3).
N 2.
Phsse Il PWR Observation - 27.lorida Power.
\\
\\
This is an observation perici at an operating.9:essurized vatcr power reactor to provide the Bractical ba:kgrou d requir:d by the L'C.
We believe this residence time of Florida ;crs:: el at an operating reactor can be reduce,d from six (6) months to about three (3) months by use of the 35*/ si=ulator in Phase IV.
Also,'the require =ent for operation of this pcVer reactor can be eliminated completely if the B&W siculstor, toccther with ten (10) rtartupt on the Lynchburg ?cci Reactor, is utilized in Phase IV.
3 f);nse III
'B&W FWR Tech =c1cgy *" raining - By B&W Th!s phase is a classroor. traising program conducted at the Lynchburg truining facility by 3LW s.:1 is included in our present **!S secyc of supply. Utilization of the training simulator in Phas !7 vould chance the curriculu:a of this phase ty transferring those items associated with reactor plant operation fre. ?hase III to 7hase IV. The:e include reactor opere. tion, fuel handling, I.s.r. of the safety analysis, a.d the startup and test progras. "The curriculu= is listed in Table.1. " Tentative Operr.tsr Training Program Outline, ?'.~.4 ':echnology Training (Phase III)".
w I
I.Do}.'FrIJ.'.W:7..
0132 t y.0..E..' F a.
1 I
e l
l t
C0bCO !* faYTI!COX F.r. J. T. Rodcers August 8, 1963 k.
Phs:e IV P'4R Cpcraticn Trr.ininc - P/ E3'l Phase IV is an s;chti:nst truinirc period utilizing e.:. :r:: 1ectures and BW facilitics at lynchlurc, Vircinja, including the iy: fr.lu.fc rool Rocctcr
- 12 ; ver station and the F'JR Si:.ulator for a cecrdinated traininc effe
- operation. This period cf traininC is directed to.aris the ut.derstunding and actusl perfor=snee of c;crational proceduren that =27 le en:cuntered in Crysts1 River Unit no. 3 This ph2:e of training cenris r of rix (6) vceks of instrnetion split betvse: clas:rcon and sir.ulator c;e. a-ica, two (2) vecks of training on the !?3, followed by four (h) vecks :f thift operatten on the 1"Ja Si ulator including an AEC-type vritten and prating cra :inution.
Traininc durinc 'this ph sc is centered about cetus 1 ce: r:1 of the plant'at the reactor con: ole. The su: lect power station simule. :r vill to a repre:ca-tation of the 21'l ESS utiliti=c the latest in si=uistics ts:1.niquas to re-prcduce opcratica of the p:ver station for operator trd:.!:.c. Af ter first learning the details of ;last design and constractic. ir. 7:ste III.and the
(
thcory of operation in the clasrroom portion cf Phase ~", -he operstor is schooled in the practier.1 c::Ju t of plant operatices. Our'sc the four-J vsek period of shif t operations, the trainees vill opree the control rocm as if it verc a tanit in ec::arcial o;crition. Conduct cf ::.sualty and era:rceney procedurcs are pessible to an extent i:practirs. c. ar. cycrating reactor. The instrueger vill probe the level of kncvi dfe cf each operator by interjecting various sycten and cc ;onent failures in.: ;last operaties.
Major casualtics that cann:t to eenducted in : n.oper:.tisc re?.eter vill be cou-lucted oc the simulater in detail. Acts.1 operatier.sl experience ar.d a
responsibility vill be greater than that a<ailab' s at a:3 s' :li.ar power reactor station that can te used for training.
The propoced cu/riculu= for the classrcom training assnitted with the P'#a Si=ulator operation is given in Table 3. " Tentative Cutline, Ecactor Subjects During Operational Thase of Opct-stor Training Procrr: (7"sse IV)".
Optional training at the C::;wy's Kuclear Dcvelop cat "e *.er is described in Section b.3 of the Ti-r.icia; Guide,i reference (1).
.e v:uld propose that
- ~
this porticr. of Phase I7 ts increased from k0 hours te,E, h:,urs in accordance with Table 2 " Tentative ccarse Outline Introductics t= ?.ea:ter Operatiens and Practical Reactor Physics". If this option is sele:ted, trainees vill -
I perform actusi reactor startup and physics experisetts at the LPR. Each trainee vill be expected to c =plete ten (l'0) startu;s :
-he LPR thus ful-filling all of the AEC require:ents for actual. reacter :.artups. You r.ny, elect, of course, to =cet the AEC requirement for res:::: ste.rtu;c on ancther power reactor if you do n t vish to utill:e the trainiac a. the LPR. The proposed curriculu. fcr.this ;crtien of the procr?.s is give: in Table 2,
" Tentative Course Outline Introduction te Reactor C;ers.-i :s and P:s:tical Reactor Physics".
l s'
l
.g l
j D 9 @..,i.i.d E.i 0132 d Od. d.
e
..s k
O U.,.... *d...e.O.,
.w. s. i Y
J, T. ReJ;cra.
-f-
/sucu :L S, 2.0.*i
.I
)
c.
t.%...i on. ts...,.
. i.., r... :- :. -
- .c traf:Ir.C Pro rt r. cn.f;:tti si 1: Or/tts1 F.iver site. f r..elvIr.,, t!.c tcJtirc ;.d i'.ar' tp scti*.It!c.-
.-!:*. ::: *:e aftc eted ty ute of the-7".*
o tra*nf.c sInMntor.
'i,t.s F."J ; r.!:::n1:. in this ;.1.st: I a-inclu!e! i cur s:e.re or surply in the OE3 0::
.:t.
~
Sineercly ys,urs,
~
/
/
, y 9/ o'.'A~~
C. E..Ther.as.
Projcet Ihnacar i
C....:c.3 A*.it:1 =.cr.ts - 3 CC: (W/*.ttseh.)
R. F. Erlier J. k*.* ".la: pron 300: (7/At'ach.)
J. C. Dettens R. E. Beach
- 3. Beisel J. F:Tarland s
. a. T. sed. o r n1e 121 l
-1 1-013 2 :*.> *0 7; n.
., D s},.o hw.5 y.
.