ML19347A955

Amended Exceptions to Initial Decision Re License Conditions & to ASLB Order Re State of or Motion for Reconsideration. Accelerated Reporting of Design Changes & Completion of Seismic Evaluation Must Be Imposed.Certificate of Svc Encl

ML19347A955
Person / Time
Site:	Trojan File:Portland General Electric icon.png
Issue date:	09/23/1980
From:	Ostrander F OREGON, STATE OF
To:	NRC ATOMIC SAFETY & LICENSING APPEAL PANEL (ASLAP)
References
ISSUANCES-SP, TAC-13152, NUDOCS 8009300566
Download: ML19347A955 (5)

Text

-

,:t !. 0 3 ' 1 3 [ f.$

) Cf

/.

.(

co y

\\%

D**

DOC' Tt usH%-

3u

~

o E

SEP 261980

• oc w

1 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA OtSc8 $ smootp NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION p

BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING APPEAL BOARD 4

g In the Matter of

)

)

Docket No. 50-344 SP PC.RTLAND GENERAL ELECTRIC

)

3 CCMPANY, et al.

)

(Control Building Proceeding)

)

^

0 (Trojan Nuclear Plant)

)

7 AMENDED EXCEPTIONS OF THE STATE OF OREGON TO THE INITIAL CECISION AND ORDER REGARDING MOTION BY STATE OF OREGON FOR 8

RECONSIDERATION OF INITIAL DECISION 9

I.

10 EXCEPTIONS TO THE INITIAL DECISION EXCEPTION 1:

The ASLB errored 1., not imposing the license conditions 10 ir. Cregon's Proposed Findings and Facts and Conclusions of requiring accelerated reporting of design changes and

., a w ccmpistion of seismic evaluations relating to piping suppcrts. (Initial decision page 54, Conclusions of Law, first paragraph.)

19 tXCEPTIONS TO THE ORDER REGARDING MOTION BY STATE OF i

2V OREGON FOR RECONSIDERTION OF INITIAL DECISION 55*:

3 EXCEPTION 2:

i3:,.

i ! ! --

The ASL3 was incorrect when it found that there is no

, ! ! 2e.

evidence of record which demonstrates accelerated reporting i

7*'

is necessary.

(Oi ler pages 2-3. )

n EXCEPTION 3:

The ASLB was incorrect when it found that the evidence O

Page h

1-AMENDED EXCEPTIONS 8009aoo.- _ g,q Q

oll

fr 1

in the record indicates that accelerated reporting is not 2

necessary.

(Order page 3.)

3 EXCEPTION 4:

4 The ASLB was incorrect when it found that accelerated 5

reporting would be unduly burdensome on the licensee.

l 6

(Order page 3.)

7 EXCEPTION 5:

8

(

The ASLB was incorrect when it found that there is 9

nothing unique in the present situation which requires other 10 than annual NRC review.

(Order page 3.)

11 EXCEPTION 6:

12 The ASLB was incorrect when it found that Oregon had 13 never presented an issue or suggestion of a cotitention as to 14 accelerated reporting.

(Order pages 3 and 4.)

15 EXCEPTION 7:

16 The ALSB was incorrect when it found tha t there was no 17 e fidence offered as to the necessity or reasonableness of IS accelerated reporting.

(Order page 4.)

19 EXCEPTION 8:

The ASLB was incorrect when it found that there had been 20

5.

' f l 21 no showing by Oregon of any reason to submit evaluations of i

,2 l lEj changes in piping supports to the NRC staf f.

(Order page Il 23 5.)

.u.

24

////

23

////

26

////

Page 2-AMENDED EXCEPTIONS

'm 1

EXCEPTION 9:

2 The ASLB erred when it adhered to its rejection of 3

Oregon's proposed license conditions.

(Order pages 4 and 4

5.)

5 '

Respectfully Submitted de L

7 FRANK W.

OSTRANDER, JR.

8 Assistant Attorney General of Attorneys for State of Oregon.

9 Department of Justice 500 Pacific Building 10 520 S.W.

Yamhill Street Portland, OR 97204 11 Area Code (503) 229-5725 12 13 14 15 16 i

17

\\

18 19 R

i; 20 5?

\\

? 3 E,1 5;..

a:

e24*

!f43 Efi

!!! 23 eu.

2a

, 26 Page 3-EXCEPTIONS

tos

(

sh 3

U $ s C C.

Y CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE ust"-

C I Frank W.

Ostrander, Jr. hereby certify that on th 69 0%:t' # s *' ' /j 5

23 th day of September, 1980 I served the within pdWQ[f i

" Amended Exceptions of the State of Oregon to the Initial 4

g Decision and Order Regarding Motion by State of Oregon for Reconsideration of Initial Decision" upon the following par-ties of record by then deposition in the United States Post Office at Portlanc, Oregon, full, true and correct copies thereof, addressed to the said parties of record at the following addresses listed below, and prepaying the postage thereon:

Marshall E. Miller, Esq., Chair.

Mr. David B.

McCoy Atomic Safety and Licensing Board 348 Hussey Lane U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Comm'n Grants Pass, OR 97256 Washington, DC 20555 Ms.

C. Gail Parson Dr. Kenneth A. McCollom, Dean 800 S.W. Green #6 Division of Engineering, Portland, OR 97205 Architecture & Technology Oklahoma State University Ronald W.

Johnson, Esq.

Stillwater, OK 74074 Corporate Attorney Portland General Electric Dr. Hugh Paxton 121 S.W.

Salmon Street 1229-41st Street Portland, OR 97204 Los Alamos, New Mexico 97544 William W.

Kinsey Mr. John A. Kullberg 1002 N.E.

Holladay 15523 S.E.

River Forest Dr.

Portland, OR 97232 Portland, OR 97222 Ms. Nina Bell Columbia Environmental Council 632 S.E. 18th 203 S.

First Street Portland, OR 97214 St. Helens, OR 97051 Mr. Stephen M.

Willingham Maurice Axelrad, Esq.

555 N. Tomahawk Drive Lowenstein, Newman, Reis, Portland, OR 97217 Axelrad & Toll Suite 1214 Mr. Eugene Rosolie 1025 Connecticut Avenue N.W.

Coalition for Safe ~ower Washington, DC 20036 215 S.E.

9th Avenue Portland, OR 97214

~e*

or. geed Johnson Office of the Executive Legal Atomic Safety and Licensing Director Appeal Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Comm'n U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Comm'n Washington, DC 20555 Washington, DC, 20555 Docketing and Services Section p-Joseph R. Gray Of fice of the Secretary Counsel for NRC Staff U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Comm'n U.S. Nuclear Rgulatory Comm'n Washington, DC 20555 Washington, DC 20555 Atomic Safety and Licensing Alan S.

Rosenthal, Esq.

Appeal Board Atomic Safety and Licensing U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Comm'n Appeal Board Washington, DC 20555 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Comm'n Washington, DC 20555 Dr. John Buck Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Comm'n Washington, DC 20555

%dM. OL} ~

FRANK W.

OSTRANDER, JR...

Assistant Attorney Gene 5al l

.--