ML20195D821

Final Response to FOIA Request for Documents.Forwards App C Documents.App a Documents Partially Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemption 6).App B Documents Totally Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemption 5)

ML20195D821
Person / Time
Site:	South Texas
Issue date:	06/16/1988
From:	Grimsley D NRC OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION & RESOURCES MANAGEMENT (ARM)
To:	Laura Smith BAKER & BOTTS
Shared Package
ML20195D827	List: IA-87-675, Subpoena Directing E Stites to Appear on 870428 in Arlington,Tx to Testify Before NRC Personnel Re safety- Related Deficiencies &/Or Records Falsiifcation at Plant IA-87-745, Subpoena Directing E Stites to Appear on 871008 in Arlington,Tx to Testify Before NRC Personnel Re Allegations Made Concerning safety-related Deficiencies &/Or Records Falsifications at Plant ML20195D821 ML20195D842 ML20195D852 ML20195D856 ML20195D864
References
FOIA-87-675, FOIA-87-745 NUDOCS 8806230209
Download: ML20195D821 (7)

Text

'

NUCLEAR REGUgATORY COMMISSION I Nac soia ntovist wveta ,

,p""

.,. 3,.

e l r

$sA-e%615 &&,pe.r7-ws-O uts 3.se r

+, -

i i RESP NSE TO REEDOM OF h.I ' * ^' , l l ''

\N e e e . ,f' INFORMATION ACT (FOIA) REQUEST g i g ]ggg l

-Docsst wvera si m .m.-

KEOVESrER '

(, * .

?0 Qu%ft g y \ > b1l j\

\ PART 1.-RECORDS RELE ASED OR NOT LOCATEC' (See checked bonest No agency recoros sut' rect to the request have been located No addrtoral egency records sub;+ct to the request have been located Agency records m.beect to the request that are coatded m Appendia re sueady avassab;e for pubi.c erspecton and copiang m the NaC Puu.c Docu& art Room.

1717 H Street. N W . Washegton, OC Agency records sutr ect to the request t*st are .denti ed f m Append >= MbO a e be cg made a.adave for pubiac espect on and cca eg e the NaC Public homent X Room. m7 w s"eet N W . wn~reon. oC. in a foide u den ih FOiA numc+r and rea wester name Tre nororopretcy wson of tre propeans! t at you ag.eed to uceci in a t.ephone conwutoa urn a errbe of m, stan . m t ,ng made a,444bie fo, pubi.c especton i and cores at the NaC Pubic Document Acom 1717 H Street. N W . WasNrsg?on DC, in a folder under tb. FOIA nurrber and requester eame l X Enciosed is efematon on how you r sy oeten acceu to and t*e chyges for copyeg records piaced in the NaC evu.c occument Room.1717 H Street. N W . West. econ OC l Aa.ncy r. cords b.et io m c. quest ce encloud Any sod.cWe chyge for copes of tPe rEords provided and payment procedu es are noted m the comments sec%e j X ax-a we-o a re -t r~ t-ea re+ed to =~~r ra- o9e-cvws' f- re e* and d -' resoonse io voo

,in m. of NaC s res- io in s , vest no f-or . . ee.no ta- on appeamer oted PART 11 A-INFORMATION WITHHELD FROM PUBLIC DISCLOSURE I i

Certa n eformaton e the requested records e being ethheld from ovN.c d>sclosure pursuant to t*e FOI A esempt.ons descnbed in and for the reasoes stated in Pad F sec-K t ons 8. C. and 0 Ary r. eased port.ons of tre documeats for *Nch ora v prt of the ruo.d . being *.the eid re be<ng mase avaa the NRC Pwt+c Document Room 1717 H Street, N W . Washegton, DC. e a foider under tNs 501 A number and roovester name a ve for out+c especton and coevro e I

I Comments ~

1. DCOMcVt ' O j b IS beiMC {d CA5c lh Y{ M{ / F6 -

Mc MonL74-W (; 'C i AC C, O( s + C *i ID ojo 6 3' C 0 vA  ; e dse ben yelasd  !

1

\

I I

l l

l i

1 880623020Y 800616  :

PDR FDIA l SMITH 87-675 PDR i

l S' #E D-etcfoa, Dn Cs ev smEcCac$

4O * / & p> .

l I

N AC FOR M 464 *s, i 9 ar j

1

. i j

FREEDOM DF INFOR$AATION ACT RESPONSE FOIA NUMBERf SL Fo1 A - 8W 675/- 796 DaTE M } h M3 )

, , PAQV il 8- A? PLICA 8!.E FOIA EXEMPTIONS /

Records subject to the request that are descr<ted in the enclosed Appendices A+B are being withheld in their entirety or in part under FO! A Eucmptions and,for the reasons set forth below pursuant to 5 U.S.C. 552(b) and 10 CFR 9 Sla) of NRC Regulatrons.

1. The wthhe6d eformaton is p'operty ciaswfed pursuam to Enocut've Order 12356 (EXEMPTION 11

2. The wthheid mformaton relates solely to the rie'nal personnel rules and procedures of NRC. l[x(MPTlQN 2)

3. The wthhe'd informaten is specAca#v esempted from pubisc d.sclosure by statute indicated. 4 EXEMPTION 3)

Secten 14t ;45 of the Atome Energy Act #'ch D'ohibets the disclosure of Restr<ted Data or Formerfy Restrcted Data 142 U S C 216t 2166).

I lSecten 147 of the Atomic Ene gv Act whc' proNtats the declosure of UnclassAed Safeguards informaten (4/ U S C. 216h. l

a. The wthheid eformation e a trade secret or cmrcial of financias eformaten that is bemg wthheid for the reasorws) iMicated (EXEMPTION di The information e cons.dered to be corsforetal busee=s (propietary) informatun l The informaron is conside'ed to be proo e'.a y eformaton pursuant to 10 CFR 2.79CWdit11.

s The eformaton was submrtted and receed e confeence from a foreign source pursuant to 10 CFR 2 790(dK2l

5. The wthheid mformaton coroasts of eteragency or etraagency records that are not avadable through discovery dunng trtigation. Doctosure of prolaces.onal informatice wowid tend to ch@t the open and fearA ncharge of ideas essential to the deliberstrve process. Where records are wthheid in the*r erarety. the facts are meatncatdy mth,ect ine coutry eto the proseceenal process of the agency. tExtVPirON Stwith the predececnal eformaten Dere afso are no reasonabtv segregabl X 6 The wtveld Wormaton e .serroted from put*c oeciosure because its esclosure would result in a cuady unwarranted invason of oersonal prnacy. (EXEMPTION 6,

7. The withhew cformation corests of evestgatorrr ecords compied for ts* enforcement pur poses and e teng ut**eid for the reasonis) edicated. (EXEMPTION 71 o,gciosure wouw meer*ye wth an enforcement proceedeg bOcause et could revee' the scope, erecton, and focus of enforcorrent er forts. and thus covid posseory allow them to tase action to sneed potect$ wrongdomg or a viotation of NRC requirernents f rom mvestigators IDEMP"ON 7( An Deciosure would constrtute an unaenanteo escson of personal prwacy IEXEMPTION 7tCo l I

The informaten consets of names of ewcoes and other Wormat>on the declosure of wNch would rev,ar .dentrt.es of confidente8 sources (EXEMPTION h011 PART If C-DENYING OFFICIALS Dursuant to 10 CFR 9 9 and 'or 915 of tre U S NWae' equietory Commeson regulaturw. n has been determered that tN oformaton mthheid is esempt from producten or escicese. '

and that s's producton or osclosure e cormary to te ni.tec eterest The persons responses for the denial are those orfic*s wantAed below as denveg officials and the Diree'or.

Dive. son ol .%tes and Records. Offce of Adrrewstrre. tot any dents that may be appealed to the Executrvs Director for Operations 1003 l i

OENYING OFFICIAL TITL E 'OF FIC E '

RECORDS DENIED APPELLATE OFFICIAL A* h Mark hdb AHinAmA E N %.n H U hah l

l 1

PART 11 D- APPEAL RIGHTS The denial by eacn der @g o#cel Artdue Part II.C may be appealed to the ADoeHate Officialidended in that section. Any such appeal must be in writmg and must be made wthm 30 days of escript of this response. Appeals must be addressed as appropriate to the Executive Director for Operations or to the Secretary of the Commason. U S. Nuclear Regulatory Cornmission, Washington, DC 20555, and should ctearfy state on the envelope and in the letter that et is an " Appeal from an inabai FOR Deosion "

CCFonuown.rie U.S. NUCLEAR REOULATORY COMMISSION tie FOlA RESPONSE CONTINUATION

i

! l

\ \

Re: FOI A- 87-675 / F0!A-87-745 1

APPENDIX A RECOR05 PARTIALLY WITHHELO NUMBER DATE DESCRIPTION & EXEMPTION l

1. 9/16/66 Letter, Mark toereon, R17. to named individuel Allegation No. 4-86-A-096 (1 page) Exemption 6 1

2. 9/04/87 Subpoena of Eddie Stites to appear at U.S. NRC, Exemption 6 Region IV, Arlington TX (1 page) j l

3, 9/22/87 Subpoena of Eddie Seites to appear at U.S. NRC, Exemption 6 Region IV Arlington, 1X (1 page)  ;

l i

4. 4/87 Subpoena to named individual to appear at US NRC Exemption 6 office of Region IV l

(1 page) j l

l

.s.

Re: F01 A ;87-675 / F0I A-87-745 APPENDIX A RECORDS PARTIALLY WITHHELD NUMBER DATE DESCRIPTION & EXEMPTION i i

i

1. 9/16/56 Latter, Mark Enereon, RIV, to named individual Allegation No. 4-86-A-096 (1 page) Exemption 6 l

{

2. 9/04/87 l Subpoena of Eddie Stites to appear at U.S. NRc, Exemption 6 Region IV Arlington TX (1 page) 3, 9/22/87 Subpoena of Eddie Stites to appear at U.S. NRC, Exemption 6 Region IV, Arlington, TX (1 page)

4. 4/87 Subpoena to named individual to appear at US NRC Exemption 6 office of Region IV (1 page) l

.r.

.e

, , Re: FOI A- 87-675 / F01A-87-745 APPENDIX B RECOROS TOTALLY WITHHELD NUMBER ,

DATE DESCRIPTION & EXEMPTION

1. 4/20/87 Memorandum, Robert D. Martin to James M. Taylor. Exemption 5 subject: Recomended Issuance of Subpoena For j Interview of Mr. (named individual) l l

1

)

O e

S e

E

Re: F0!A-87-675 / F0!A-87-745 APPEN0lX C RECORDS MAINTAINED IN THE PDR UNDER THE AB0VE FOIA NUMBER NUMBER DATE DESCRIPTION 1, Undated Memorandum, Victor J. Stello to Regional Administrator Region IV, subject: Delegation of Subpoena Authority (1 page)

O P

e 9*

- . . , . , . . - _ , _ . - - , , , ---,,,y-. ,,,n wn_r.+-y,_,,- ,a gw,m_,.--,,,yw,n-rwy,-,-,-v.o-m..n-ww.

,, Re: FO!A.87-675 / F0!A-87-745 APPENDIX C RECORDS MAINTAINED IN T.HE PDR UNDER THE AB0VE F0IA NUMBER NUMBER DATE DESCRIPTION

1. Undated Memorandum, Victor J. Stello to Regional Administrator Region IV, subject: Delegatio!. of Subpoena Authority (1 page) r e

W 6-

- - - - . . . _ _ _ _ _ _ . - . _ . _ . _ - . _ _ . _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ . . . . . . . - _ . . . _ _ . _ _ _ _ . . . . .