ML19327C212

Proposed Tech Spec 4.0.2,removing 3.25 Limit for Surveillances

ML19327C212
Person / Time
Site:	Callaway
Issue date:	11/14/1989
From:	UNION ELECTRIC CO.
To:
Shared Package
ML19327C210	List: ML19327C209 ML19327C212
References
ULNRC-2107, NUDOCS 8911210170
Download: ML19327C212 (4)

Text

7. ,f .yf W y y* m -v

-

a -

., <

s 3 . . , . , . ,

7.. Y

,

'

'$QQ *

'OY *

• L DK , ' M Vr N' ,,,f ^

NG %

X T;@,$'

s

• f.

• i i  ?

?. ~ ?> '

h %d % Y'hlk'YNI&g7m erM'*. M ss M MN Q@~4:S.. "

.

• i ^4 jpf f V M ' AAtachment} t F toi Mllc.M hQm~masese M 0 M .J h h.: MM@SM.

h,hD,~u.t + 4 50c!+ e '

, , N.hM .w -  ;'6)T <

w N

J rNM. w. ~ .  ! M. .b N,Nyg m.4 q'<

..

Y,

.

J ULNRC O

m tM210 W L , ' , 9 4

,

AA.n,m,o,m-e t. %,'

P w M.J b4 W J,1.Fv u wo ,a w w~ m~ ., ,~ d . c

.m s v

.

~. ,, , , ' w .,J .,

e

,,

,a . .,, : . ,J. ,?

,

% , m , -

,

, , , m .

,

.- ',p ( a .

d . . L , 7l  ! i y ,'g - ' ..,* 'N # l' i

% gw: , w.:

', .yhp g. ,"u[..Ng 0'<sy W. %,m n ,.. , ,Idy s \* ' '

?., ' ; '. ['O $ -.;y, N < . ( ; i yl

'

,< .'fd.. llt n c.

+

-

,

e@r.ba%w.i+[g?k.[' '19, i

. s m ,

e,' m . ,

r- , . . , , A c w M, u'm

,

a, ,

,

. , .

epuwi $~t?o 'x , .' +

-

-

.

o,f' 'w* . n s! u' 4 t' y N g M +N,. w @< s,

,.,.{L v s 9 )v u. m n. ,p ' 'M sv 3. t . t vm S ..(' ' " - 'ti  ?

,'

- " ,. ): r ': , 2 '. - i '"

',

. .

J

, 96 mP , EO a s ~9f 'h M i T a

.

,N.. q s - , W> ,

,

n

'

@'t'*1 , "n 7 , s 4.a - -

' *-4 vv h,ghnehw$.~h,5,d .h 'y@k, hk.oM N[ Mf.wu [, [h, a c(,@L d. ' ' '

s

,

,, . , e.

'

-

c q ,

'

-g [~ g ). .o#' - ,.

.

h -

p,, f FM LW>tH % 4/z,s

,

o i .q. vi n 1- L..<

$ s

,

O +S .W e , /

i t u >':

s

' .' w,, . 1- 3 ,  % ,, ' ;a - -

e 'a S ,

,

>,j ,' :g q ml ,

,

4g: Qjo%g j .4W,.

M.P)L,ri . %of .i '..< ..:J.4.' ,.' j j 7 .s . ' ^ t .j4 3 ", d ' *

,'A; i t 4 i ,

, t o x

-

,

,

/

s s .

t, y

, - irg<. ,

. .i.7 ,..s

..V,Wa 4 3

-

.

W @. m

'

j 6l4 * ,,c A< > 3 G, # -

t r g~r .) ct: W <

m" .

,  ;

w

.

. ..

we

'

g am

%p.-l L u C.a T h , %,~y " q' :; n. ,*

f , r . -. . , .as . s,3' 7 7 .g + e w , 3. ..

+ v V,

, a n :,s. ,,n'

,

q

,. 3.s>..

c.

-. i 9V syy.y x em t

.

,  : ;. , , s L, -

4. 6 ,

i ,* , , < r

,x;,

, .

hw vs' ..* st h

,,s .x. u: .

-

ns s r ewm.e. e,. vm .w' a.

, .

. u  : ,

W; a ,sgm&p&y

%q 1 .

-

mp f g 2. F.uP-

.

a >

..

s

.

- 4'

m. ' , ,

..S,. J*

i,

...;_

<

s*s

,

4,

.e.. H m

t q

• h /. n,e sM ..'c

.,e,w,

,

-) , g ,, 9 .

s.

%

W, & s g w ;A w .9,ra ..>uW < m;Tr , .m.ej. .,

• u.y~.

v 4 ' t s

,

.

'

w< 2, J U+-

, s-Fhyb ,J Q.

, , '

4 my t4 ,yt . * ,

p.'

.,

ns1 ,n -:jL,,

'

$w ;-7. wf e j,-V ., *e.

o d. qa: P ,v..v, '.. ;.oQ r.f.,x ^ ,!,1 ,"g,g.;, 4..f.5,'r8 ,,. m ;-

t

,a

.

e

, -

Q ,M,,

.

i, y

,

<

.g. -

, , --

t

. ,

5

,' "( . 4 ,

. r

-1

- :

.

y J' O j;"

4nA,]g u;,p j cM  ;' f a' A

• n(n,.n d- 9

<W-

. 1,. " s g n,. M .~ .

sm ,m.g. 4A, . .

- , ,

my e e < fi 2 y -

.- - . 4y

!' .t s t

'

-

s

' I

,

f 4

. , '

, , , e# i< i .'

• s

'm #

.. ' i  ;

• [,V[,

g

\y y em .pr. meg fC^I f, Cz p

• k '. I'h' } L 3

'*

u.\ ,;

• "

-9 >[F

'

g

. ..

,

. : . ,y, ,,

..,.,

• " *

. i

.,./

"

. w, , ,

.

...

MQ d,,n by y.,E .:. : .3 . m.,[.. [. 4 9 q- , ,4

.~.y ,s.', $ ,6 M ".t.. ).. V f 4 ,, . .

4 p@.cw%Y%$j.,, ' . g-f M,

, W,. ,. s .a. ' . . :

e ,t

'

-

i

,

n .<! s

>

+

' '

,

n ': v , . ,'W .

M.~ ..1r.

. y

/,

.W

.

,

' '

[...t6 ' [. i ii% ,s.. t '  ;'%

. 69g %

, i

" " q>

,

's t c7pm, - ' 'i.no.,

m ,

-"s ' .i.,iV; 3'

w

>

, ,

,-J-7 o-  : +.4 t" ,*-*

< r

1. sMm L%;w r r; gC,f# s , s-r

,' r .. , " , " " ?y.,

.-

s -

i e ,- . y'

,

-

e p a.1,1

-

Mi'ib; ,  %~! '

, - ' b n 'O ? 1,

'c f *s:f O rf Er , 8 t s t

v,-. 3 4 M, ,,,

w : w' c +

'. +

. n.

MMM. p. .. ;;.w

. c .

- '

>

m e a ,7 ) y &, . -K y- w p , .. ,. - '

e3 . ., ' ' ' ,

.x < m&, . ,

),ny. 3 b '. . '. . M Y

'

,k .., ', *'~

s y@

ff be $.,g ' . , s ' to, ..?

E

.9,'. .p ' ' 4, f. ' ,i i +

,

i g

'

' :,f . .

,

vw<m ' L. :'

-

g we . m.-i7 .,)

e He w ,w6-y  ; ; & i

,

~ u t n,<

, wwwa ,

%.. e L

<

&v s , s ' m3 r

,

. c. ,. - -

.c .

'

,w < 2-v, O W , -g'y' *

,%

/; .. [b 1

'

' * - a- '4

' . , . .

kMl t' ([5, " ' ' ' ' '

' + "

.3, '

hf k,r ;iMN,d[:-OR [' ',y

... .. .. .. . , . .. . . , , . . .

a~ y?!.

b ; PROPOSED TECHNICAL SPECIFICATION ~CHANGESc' 'A J ' ,

-

'

, w

<

. Wt ,

y . w,% m)ajy'

> >

tWyn'

,

, i

9 sv ,W

.M:: <d. n'  : s -

y: v,

's'"

,

A'h W,c

d ',!,c..'(3'

_

'

.

,

>

N' '

> *4 W%}t), &fy J. ' R h.' ' ? ' . % ^ . y6

,

jj$%dfW ' ?, %M ,

,

, s , . - . ,. . . , . .

r . ,

' t l-R }

% c N. ,4. PS ecification 4:.0.2

'

"

' ' ' T ad' - w? w

'

, ,

w k . d, J. , s, ?~  : s r e.c, . .

• '

-

1 - s:l i g.s%g-w..#.

w* 7 ; 14 fd '( 'f{ *ds ar,,J 4 f

s m *

, 7

- +

'f

' ' '. i -/. I . . ' " . , ,'i I 'i'1

, wMd h f> s i- .' 1 I , .1 l kf Nh !

M 3p rW o i , ,

"

'

a t M' ' 'i ' ' '

'

..V I s ,, /

m y-St>xe m,, ~, ,

o4 %, .. 'O t.

~ ~,

6 m o 3 1v. ,

,

,.$.

l ,

u, e

.7 m'9 yjf ?

Mt:-C; . ..:. r,f. G / l n, a+.,< -y. w

,

,

e

",y,',.,, *4, f:tsm f i ,* ,n, " +, ,# s '

. i

,y y$y y m r.,.

..

, ,

,

,o. ,. _ < ,

,

. ,e. , m,

, ._ -'s

.

a

,f (r r < ) ,37 WlQ.G V . .s'. 31 i l

' '

%

p

,a g. m.s.r

,

._ ;

.~y.s ,, ,,4, c.g-e.g+," Q-/ tt e

• 33

-

. .

' ..

.

[Ig, 9

' sk$ # "

k f. /

,'

.

$f.( j $ / ,; lyTM b)n , " '

2 a

'I r

a. p m e ,>, m Q;

i "L

~

Q!;ks..Q s '

,ij,+,yn s,

,

.. -

p , ,

'

q:.

.nyth.

9:.

o p%<re

.r u p m>; -< ' .7 , - > :7

,

t

,

' n. a r,3 } } Q l,tl.

'

t '

q

1. !I, c? h). .g"i ? n s . . n.

r?, , ,

,

'

• %> ] t v ' , 4.G.;.K'h ' -

w-

> r <

-

4Aw.b. y. y.y .

< '

r 1

gp,m fw wo gnte;f.8. .,>f e , ..

,

z'.

• MQ J '? %,b} Q{

~

,

'*

$pf .L r j? , ; ,g ,,

k _ 3 g]A' ! ?

M.gu ,

y.... zg g i ._ , ,,

w/R o r n i , A . . . r, c . +. r , ,

W4 . . . 47- i v b, d., ,e -

sk' i - - s-#C t t;

-4

1. '

M ,' - s ^

y- , s

. 3 g f .j, ,s, s i;4 l

,

J , s.. 1

1. e t> t.

m$..%

mj z..c . -

s ,A.r a pM.f

.

,s ~7 p' .l ,.i. , i e >

,

>

,

> <

. ' ,

N\..

d h 's,'f5 9 ' - $ '( 6 t

ve%w m4 [", 3 > < ,  ; y ,

.s >.....e(, . t . r. ,

AN .d.-?

,.

7c- '<

t-w,g, e i eo +: %. 5 , ; ,!A. . ,,

n q'*jky)g. wa: ., p

. q

, j '

+

p Vpgy ,v,,.e, wv ,v 4 o

e r

.,

,

• f '* 4 j g'u . /W,-f, 3 g a' . ] , [.wM' ct .

g.

b p:M '.. p.

>p'

.

>$

.q .3'S.

, ,

-,

-I h r t:< ,:',7 .

J h.. na 1

> ,

Y cf s ,

by;

&u g.u,i

.

W: M y , /,.

.

, ;m, . y+n. +. ., ( . s a s

4, _a v. a, . ,., , u

,

-

.

[(, [;; i - ' 1

• tk my [ . . ,

)',4 u

..a N

Q^

I w' 1. * '

I $ N'-'g'm, e - l ,,

{g&jf f.Q s

.

o

h. . 'Y a g,; ,%.. i l .1 ,,

2: , r:r '; qu. "I.*' n

^

p l' $1h, a i jf, , i

'

-)

%m. ym -

-

s

.d Mv 9 p

d,..

3 . pg . . ,%

,

-

n u.v a, e n .., mw s

-k

.

w.'3p!;

..

,,u

'

i

,, ..

IE qp 'I

'

y

,m [t'hhf ' :w 3'o, +r ",'{ -

3

-U'e  ; ,

h g(ym' . g .A ' D F E 'N I

'

h y [4'f f/ . '/. h c ' 7 3 ju 4 I s , ,

3

.;

j SM. Tdl?d,4Q8jl4 *'yftha t ' '

<^.. ) , i ,, ,

':q

.mL,-...eww-._ + rb w J

a,~

E s- _ .- , . . . .. . . . .._ . l r I

'O '

.

'

l .

- -

REVISION 1

]a APPLICABILITY

..

SURVELLLANCE REQUIREMENTS

__. ,

'

4.0.1 Surveillance Requirements shall be met during the OPERATIONAL MODES or other conditions specified for individual Limiting Conditions for

. Operation unless otherwise stated in an individual Surveillance Requirement.

4.0.2 Each Surveillance m-, m. x,v e Re,quirement s (tu ca shall e p;erformed in 4.4.vva w +% a. m within u imum thew specified itoaq.

+EM"Pid'noTN et tee.4 "L5 % o b De speti 4t td svtutl\l*%. I'1hrvtla

. 7

-:. A ==wi-"- e!!rrib!e exten:!e- net te en ::d OS% ef th; eur.eillea;d inte. ei, L t-

_b, The ;:: tin:d t! inter /e1 #e* e y thr;; ;en;e;stise ;wrv:!'leece

_ in t:rvele .holi nvi .ee;;d ?.25 tf :: th; :p;;ified surveill:::;-

=iate-uel;

4. 0. .) Failure to perform a Surveillance Requirement within the specified -

time interval shall constitute a failure to meet the OPERABILITY requirements

. for a Limiting Condition for Operation. Exceptions to these requirements .

'

are stated in the individual specifications. Surveillance Requirements do not h.ive to be performed on inoperable equipment.

.

4.0.4 Entry into an OPERATIONAL MODE or other specified condition shall not be .

made unless the Surveillance Requirement (s) associated with the Limiting ~

'

Condition for Operation have been performed within the stated surveillance" j interval or as otherwise specified. ., e 4.0.5 Surveillance Requirements for inservice inspection and testing of ASME Code Class 1, 2, and 3 components shall be applicable as follows:

a. Inservice inspection of ASME Code Class 1, 2, and 3 components and inservice testing of ASME Code Class 1, 2, and 3 pumps and valves * '

shall be performed in accordance with Section XI of the ASME Boiler

'and Pressure Vessel Code and applicable Addenda as required by 10 CFR Part 50, Section 50.55a(g), except where specific written relief has been granted by the Commission pursuant to 10 CFR Part 50, Section 50.55a(g)(6)(1);

,

.

.

.

.

'

Call AWAY - UNIT 1 3/4 0-2

.

. - - . - + "m S- , -e- -. - _ --

- - -_ -

-

p -e,

>

v *

,

.,

' '

~- Al'I't.ICAnit

--

11 Y

,

( ggygg,0N ,

c. 1

'\

BASES I

3.0.4 This specification provides that entry into an OPERATIONAL MODE or' '

other specified applicability condition must be made with: (1) the full comple-1 ment of required systems, equipment, or components OPERABLE and (2) all other para- -

meters as specified in the Limiting Conditions for Operation being met without regard for allowable deviations and out-of-service provisions contained in the

,

ACTION statements. ,

The intent of this provisicin is to ensure that facility operation is not initiated witn either required equipment or systems inoperable or other specified limits being exceeded.

Exceptions to this provision have been provided for a limited number of specifications when startup with inoperable equipment would not affect plant safety. These exceptions are stated in the ACTION statements of the appropriate specifications.

.

4.0.1 This specification provides that surveillance activities necessary to ensure the Limiting Conditions for Operation are met and will be performed during the OPERAT30NAL MODES or other conditions for which the Limiting Conditions for Operation are applicable. Provisions for additional surveillance activities to be performed without regard to the applicable OPERATIONAL MODES or other conditions ')'

are provided in the individual Surveillance Requirements. Surveillance Requirements for Special Test Exceptions need only be performed when the Special Test Exception e is being utilized as an exception to an individual specification.-

1 m cL-1 }

,

~ '

4.0.2 FThe provisions of this specification provide allowable to1siances ~ ..

'

'

forgerforming surveillance activities beyond those specified in tfheh'al surveTT intervali These tolerances are necessary topv4aroperational flexibility be of scheduling and performance co $dfrations. The phrase "at least" associate  % .a surveillance fre y does not negate %ais" allowable tolerance value an s erformance of more frequent surveillance activities.

The toleran ycearitie's', taken either individually o ecutively over three test J tefvals, are sufficiently restrictive'to ensure he rella)$+beyond d(raded tty associated that obtained with thethe from surveillance nominal specified act,1vity is not signifTElmt4(j interval.

-

- '

4.0.3 The provisions of this specification set forth the criteria for determination of compliance with the OPERABILITY requirements of the Limiting Conditions for Operation. Under these criteria, equipment, systems or components are assumed to be OPERABLE if the associated surveillance activities have been

.,

satisfactorily performed within the:specified time interval. Nothing in this l

!

provision is to be construed as defining equipment, systems or components OPERABLE, when such items are found or known to be inoperable although still meeting the Surveillance Requirements. Items may be detemined inoperable

.

during use, during surveillance tests or in accordance with this specification.

Therefore ACTION statements are entered when the Surveillance Requirements  :

should have been performed rather than at the time it is discovered that the ,

tests were not performed.

B 3/4 0-2 s 4

CALLAWAY - UNIT 1 ,

0

,

..e .e-. ~ <e ,e

~ - , -,

,g-,,-

-

,

my , , ,

,

E l

,

, ,

.

u . c ,

.,

j , [.(l

, ..

4 i \ h l.'

l l

.i f .

s .

,

,

, CI} S e v 6 _1.. 1

,

u '

3

!

4 ,

survailan s

-

.,- .

..

~ M,I fpecificationd.0.1 establishes the limit for which the -specified 44me- )

interval for Surveillance Requirements may be extended. It permits an  :

-

allowable extension of the normal surveillance interval tTfacilitate' s surveillance scheduling and consideration of plant' operating conditions

'that may not be' suitable for conducting the surveillance; e.g., transient

,

i

. conditions or other ongoing ~ surveillance' or maintenance ' activities. It i also provides flexibility to accommodate the length of a fuel cycle foF e

'

surveillances that are performed at each refueling outage-and are spec- .

,

'

- i ; 1fied with 2"-tan 18-Enonth surveillance interval. It is not intended .;

l that this provision be used repeatedly as a convenience to. extend surveil- "

' lance: Intervals beyond that specified for surveillances that are not per-  :

formed duM ng refueling outaaes. The limitation of specification 4.0.2 is based on engineering judgement 7 nd the recognition that the most probab1 T  :

result of any particular surveillance being performed is the verification

- of'conformance.With the' Surveillance Requirements. This provision is  !

- sufficient to ensure that the reliability ensured through surveillance '-

p activities is not'significantly degraded beyond that obtained from the L specified surveillance interval. . ., . . u l

d M ok * %4 cd.on ur h.up fo r

.

BaJc 40.I comu f ro m 1

1: G e n e s L. ti4 < v 97-oh +w. v M e r lene f woi ling

+ hd w e r e, chupt en Gmen c s ',) (i 4 h,3 p oi li .n3

!

3 L e tte r O 'l- 14 .

.

l l' l 1 \

.

1

,, 1 l[

'