ML091190730
| ML091190730 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Oyster Creek |
| Issue date: | 11/19/2008 |
| From: | Marjorie Mclaughlin NRC Region 1 |
| To: | Barber G, Barkley R, Bellamy R, Collins S, Conte R, Dapas M, Farrar K, Gamberoni M, David Lew, Marjorie Mclaughlin, Mcnamara N, Richmond J, Darrell Roberts, Diane Screnci, Neil Sheehan, Doug Tifft NRC Region 1 |
| References | |
| FOIA/PA-2009-0070 | |
| Download: ML091190730 (4) | |
Text
KarIFarrar From: Marjorie McLaughlin S .- *-
Sent: Wednesday, November 19, 2008 12:02 PM To: Marjorie McLaughlin; Marsha Gamberoni; Darrell Roberts; Richard Conte; John Richmond; Doug Tifft; Richard Barkley; Diane Screnci; Neil Sheehan; Nancy McNamara; Scott Barber; Ronald Bellamy; Karl Farrar; Marc Dapas; Sam Collins; David Lew Cc: Stephen Pindale; Justin Heinly; David Pelton; Jeffrey Kulp; Robert Summers
Subject:
Result of discussion with NJDEP regarding OC PN and Board Notifications Attachments: NJDEP Org Chart.pdf Good Morning, As discussed this morning, I spoke to Pat Mulligan, Chief of the NJDEP Bureau of Nuclear Engineering, regarding the concerns that Dr. Jill Lipoti has with AmerGen's Nov 17 Commission Notification regarding Oyster Creek and to determine if she also has concerns with the NRC's Nov. 17 Preliminary Notification.
Discussion:
Pat informed me that Jill does have concerns with both documents. Her most significant issues are:
AmerGen Commission Notification:
- The licensee did not fully describe the extent of the delamination of the strippable coating applied to the reactor cavity. The licensee did not quantify either the amount of coating affected or the resultant leak rate into the affected sand bed bays (note that the leak rate is provided in the NRC PN).
NRC Preliminary Notification:
- The NRC did not discuss the disconnected tubing from the sand bed drain line poly bottles.
Note: I had previously (yesterday) reviewed with Pat all of the concerns with the PN that had been raised to John Richmond by the NJDEP engineers (Pinney and Zak), including the tubing issue. I explained there had been no leakage in those lines and, therefore, no consequence from the issue, that this was an inspection item that did not warrant discussion in the PN, but may be included in the inspection report.
Today, Pat told me that he had discussed Jill's concerns with Paul Baldauf, NJDEP Assistant Director for Radiation Protection Programs, this morning (see below for a brief discussion of the NJDEP reporting relationships). He and Paul agree that there is no immediate significance to the issues raised by Jill. They intend to speak to her today with the-intent to:
- 1. Achieve alignment that NJDEP will not take any actions (i.e., writing letters) until after the NRC issues its Inspection Report (Pat is well aware of the letter agreement requirements, and does not want to violate them)
- 2. Discuss Jill's issues with her to provide more information and, hopefully, ease her concerns.
Paul's and Pat's planned, official course of action for NJDEP regarding the NRC's License Renewal Commitments Inspection of OC is to observe the inspection exit, read the inspection report, and see how any of their remaining issues (the drywell coating inspection frequency and any remaining issues that Jill may have) are dispositioned. If NJDEP has any remaining disagreements, it will then document those in a letter.
I expressed to Pat that our goal would certainly be to discuss the State's issues and hopefully reach alignment so as to preclude the need for a letter. I told him that we will support any such discussions they wish to have, as we don't want them to have any open questions. Pat agreed, and said he does not feel any discussions will 118
be needed until after the inspection exit. He will contact me after tspeaking with Jill if there are any changes to the above course of action.
NJDEP Organization:
NJ DEP is headed by a Commissioner, under whom there are 2 Deputy Commissioners and a Director of Operations. Reporting to the Director of Operations are 6 Assistant Commissioners. The Assistant Commissioner of Environmental Regulation is Nancy Wittenberg. Dr. Lipoti is one of 4 Directors reporting to her. Paul Baldauf reports to Dr. Lipoti, and oversees the DEP's radioactive materials and nuclear engineering programs. Pat Mulligan reports to Paul, and oversees the nuclear engineers, the environmental engineers, and the EP staff. Rich Pinney supervises the nuclear engineers and reports to Pat, and Ron Zak reports to Rich. An org chart that goes down to Jill's level is attached for reference.
Actions and Status (changes are in red font):
- 1. Speak to Pat Mulligan, NJDEP, about Dr. Lipoti's concerns with AmerGen's Board Notification; ascertain if she has concerns with the NRC PN; and determine if Dr. Lipoti wishes to speak again with DRS management about this issue.
Owner = McLaughlin Date = 11/19/08 Status: COMPLETE
- 2. Notifiy this distribution of the outcome of that discussion, so that additional next steps may be determined.
Owner = McLaughlin Date = 11/19/08 Status COMPLETE
- 3. Report on this matter at the 0845 to make Regional management aware.
Owner = McLaughlin Date = 11/19/08 Status: COMPLETE
- 4. Inform this distribution of any followup communicaiton from Pat resulting from his discussion today with Jill Lipoti.
Owner = McLaughlin Date = 11/19/08, or later as applicable
- 5. Maintain communications with NJDEP regarding this inspection and respond to any requests for further discussion.
Owners = SLOs & DRS Date = Ongoing Please respond with any concerns or additional proposed actions.
VR, Marjorie 2
NEW JERSEY DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION COMMISSIONER PRESS OFFICE DIRECTOR LISA JACKSON ELAINE MAKATURA COMMISSIONER t COUNSELORSTO THE CATHERINETORMEY F OFFICEOF OFFICE OF ALYSSA WOLFE CONSTITUENT RELATIONS -, DISPUTE RESOLUTION DIRECTOR CONFIDENTIALASSISTANT VACANT DEPUTY COMMISSIONER FOR POLICY & LEGISLATIVE FOR NATURAL & HIST RESOURCES t t DEPUTY AFFAIRS COMMISSIONER JOHN WATSON JENNIFER GODOSKI OFF OF LEGISLATIVEAFFAIRS DIRECTOR DIRECTOR OF OPERATIONS JOHN HAZEN GARYSONERMYEROFFICE OF LOCA GARYSONERMYERGOVERNMENT ASSCISATANCE JASON VARANO I I I ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY, PLANNING NATURAL & HIST LAND USE MANAGEMENT SITE REMEDIATION COMPLIANCE &
AND BUDGET REGULATION AND SCIENCE RESOURCES MANAGEMENT PROGRAMS ENFORCEMENT ASST COMM ASST COMM ASST COMM ASST COMM ASST COMM ASST COMM DIRECTOR JEANNE HERB AMY CRADIC MARK MAURIELLO VED CHAUDHARY NANCY WITTENBERG IRENE KROPP WOLFGANG SKACEL BROWNFIELDS ENF & COMP RESOURCE DIVOF LANGUSE DIVISIONOF REMEDIATION&
OFFICE OF AUDIT WATER DUALITY SERVICES RESTORATION REGULATION POLICY TEAM REUSE MANAGER JOHN SACCO DIRECTOR DIRECTOR VACANT KENNETH KLOO KNUTEJENSEN THOMAS MICAJ r- OFFICE OF HISTORIC PRES OFFICEOF RESPONSIBLE PARTY
DIVOF SCIENCE, ACTINGADMIN DIVISION OF DIVOF WATERSHED DIRECTOR COASTAL &LANDUSE DANIEL SAUNDERS MANAGER RESEARCH & MANAGEMENT AIR QUALITY ENFORCEMENT TECHNOLOGY SHERRYDRIBER DIRECTOR LEONARDROMINO ADMINISTRATOR OFFICE OF DIRECTOR DIRECTOR MARCEDIUS JAMESON RESOURCE LAWRENCE BALER GENERAL SERVICES WILLIAMO'SULLIVAN EILEEN MURPHY DEVELOPMENT REMEDIATION
& SYSTEMS MANAGEMENT& COUNTY ALVINPAYNE DIVISIONOF COORDINATION OPERATIONS ENVIRONMENTAL&
OFF OF COASTAL DIVOF ENV OFFICEOF WATER SUPPLY MANAGER MANAGER' WASTE ENFORCEMENT PLANNING& JULIET DELVALLE SAFETY&HEALTH WAYNE HOWITZ LEASES & DIIRECTOR DIRECTOR PROGRAM CONCESSIONS DIRECTOR COORDINATION MICHELEPUTNAM OFFICE OF JOHN CASTNER MANAGER MARCI GREEN JILL LIPOTI ENFORCEMENT &
OCCUPATIONAL RUTH EHINGER HEALTH&SAFETY ASSIGNMENT WATER WATER MONITORING -MANAGER MANAGER SOLID & HAZ WASTE COMP & ENF OFFICE OF ENV AND STANDARDS MGMT PROGRAM RONALD CORCORY ADMINISTRATOR JUSTICE
&W 0IDLFE ELEMENT DIVISIONOF ADMINISTRATOR JAMES HAMILTON ADMINISTRATOR BUDGET AND FINANCE
-- D IRECTOR I VACANT PUBLICLY FUNDED LESLIE MCGEORGE DIRECTOR MARIA FRANCO-SPERA REMEDIATION E. DAVIDEARTH AIR MANAGER NEW JERSEY COMP & ENF GEOLOGICAL EDWARD PUTNAM DIVISIONOF DIVISIONOF ADMINISTRATOR SURVEY HUMANRESOURCES PARKS &FORESTRY ELEMENT EDWARDCHOROMANSKI DIRECTOR CONTRACTING &
ACTINGDIRECTOR KARL MUESSIG DEBRA EWALT FINANCIALSERVICES JEANNE MROCZKO MANAGER OFFICE OF OFF OF EQUALOPP & ANTHONY FARRO CONTRACT ENGINEERING&
ASSISTANCE CONSTRUCTION DIRECTOR COMMUNICATIONS&
ADMINISTRATOR PAMELALYONS SYSTEMS APPLICATION DAVIDROSENBLATT MANAGER GEORGE KLEIN GREEN ACRES PROGRAM ADMINISTRATOR EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT DEPOVERVIEW JOHN FLYNN MANAGER OCTOBER 6, 2008 ROBERT VANFOSSEN OFFICIAL DEP ORGANIZATIONAL CHART HAZARDOUS SITE SCIENCE MANAGER BARRY FRASCO
Received: from R1CLSTRO1.nrc.gov ([148.184.99.7]) by R1 MS01.nrc.gov
([148.184.99.10]) with mapi; Wed, 19 Nov 2008 12:01:36 -0500 Content-Type: application/ms-tnef; name="winmail.dat" Content-Transfer-Encoding: binary From: Marjorie McLaughlin <Marjorie.McLaughlin@nrc.gov>
To: Marjorie McLaughlin <Marjorie.McLaughlin@nrc.gov>, Marsha Gamberoni
<Marsha.Gamberoni@nrc.gov>, Darrell Roberts <DarrelI.Roberts@nrc.gov>,
Richard Conte <Richard.Conte@nrc.gov>, John Richmond <John.Richmond@nrc.gov>,
Doug Tifft <Doug.Tifft@nrc.gov>, Richard Barkley <Richard.Barkley@nrc.gov>,
Diane Screnci <Diane.Screnci@nrc.gov>, Neil Sheehan <NeiI.Sheehan@nrc.gov>,
Nancy McNamara <Nancy.McNamara@nrc.gov>, Scott Barber
<Scott.Barber@nrc.gov>,
Ronald Bellamy <Ronald.Bellamy@nrc.gov>, Karl Farrar <Karl. Farrar@nrc.gov>,
Marc Dapas <Marc.Dapas@nrc.gov>, Sam Collins <Sam.Collins@nrc.gov>, David Lew
<David.Lew@nrc.gov>
CC: Stephen Pindale <Stephen.Pindale@nrc.gov>, Justin Heinly
<Justin.Heinly@nrc.gov>, David Pelton <David.Pelton@nrc.gov>, Jeffrey Kulp
<Jeffrey.Kulp@nrc.gov>, Robert Summers <Robert.Summers@nrc.gov>
Date: Wed, 19 Nov 2008 12:01:37 -0500
Subject:
Result of discussion with NJDEP regarding OC PN and Board Notifications Thread-Topic: Result of discussion with NJDEP regarding OC PN and Board Notifications Thread-Index: AcIKPd8+dSgwKcPvRTal uqja8MQugAAls+hQ Message-ID: <2856BC46F6A308418F033D973BBOEE72AA54940854@R1CLSTRO1.nrc.gov>
Accept-Language: en-US Content-Language: en-US X-MS-Has-Attach: yes X-MS-Exchange-Organization-SCL: -1 X-MS-TNEF-Correlator:
<2856BC46 F6A308418F033D973BBOEE72AA54940854@R1 CLSTRO1 .nrc.gov>
MIME-Version: 1.0