ML20066C218: Difference between revisions
StriderTol (talk | contribs) (StriderTol Bot insert) |
StriderTol (talk | contribs) (StriderTol Bot change) |
||
| Line 16: | Line 16: | ||
=Text= | =Text= | ||
{{#Wiki_filter:}} | {{#Wiki_filter:. . . | ||
--a k w -n ,-m-, . - - - | |||
- r-- - ~ w ., | |||
:In:h P~ | |||
m 1 ,; - | |||
; .p | |||
...p ....E .Sa--p it.:pq 7i' .i. .0uj e e 4. e rr m t'niL [ r 4 | |||
_,,i : ' | |||
i i. ci | |||
.i- i r | |||
E i' p~i ! b , j . [ - | |||
F-t--+--l-g-F I: _ w _ ._ m_ a 1 ; | |||
_. . - g R _ _ _ _., _ | |||
, ; : i + | |||
i - - | |||
j_g. - | |||
q L | |||
...'.J.2. - | |||
[- . * *- L- L------_ - - - | |||
1- I ; ~*-'--~'' ''-- T ~ - l i | |||
[, I - | |||
b ' | |||
i , | |||
-- --- - r -'.- r -i--E - C .E .n n. I. 1- - ~i - " r i- Tr , . . . .- , . J 82 @'l,4 g*16i . | |||
g | |||
- .a n , | |||
Q g h @, ct omcs or me coum EXECURVE , | |||
: r. : 4 : i .- .y n ,. | |||
emn r. co,- - r> .x m c. ca u m m s - i | |||
.- . ,,a.mc w m cm.eur = : , o o.- | |||
!. j,, i i | |||
-November 8, 1982 I | |||
t li.T""' ' | |||
! ;; ; ~; | |||
3 . ' .'.i . . . . | |||
g ~. m s. | |||
.h c 'r''" r,,,y. v. j ; | |||
;a 1 - o | |||
. c. . | |||
7 The' E' o norable Nunzio J. Palladino. . - | |||
The acnorable Victor Gilinsky ' | |||
* i .' i ' | |||
: a The Honorable ~ James K. Asselstine - - , | |||
The Bonorable John P'. Ahearne | |||
'[TheHonorableThomasRoberts | |||
, , _- U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission ' | |||
f j . l ' "-:.[. Washingy, ;D.C. 20555 i . | |||
, j | |||
.< 3 i ' | |||
d j | |||
==Dear ,== | |||
Messrs.' Chairman and crummissionerst ; | |||
..s . | |||
~,, . | |||
,i 4 ' | |||
I on~ behalf of the ditizens of Suffolk County, I.am writing: i .. . | |||
- to inform you thatL the : hearing on the safety of the Shoreham' a | |||
> ! 'i 2 | |||
.! nuclear power plant is being marred by the procedural, . | |||
. Irreaularity of your Licensing Board. I ask that you promptly intercede to exercise the Commission's supervisory authority . - | |||
3; over. the conduct of the hearing. . | |||
j | |||
: , .a , ,, | |||
9 . | |||
.-h , I Last' week, the Licensino Board tentatively decided to . . h W discard normal hearing procedures on certain critical- issues of '. ^ t d | |||
. ] , emergency. preparedness and quality assurance. The Board stated ~ * | |||
* its intention not to preside 'over the cross-examination of. l lq cxpert witnesses and, thus, in effect not to exercise; its F'.,. 4 M; l ! important role of helping to shape the development of probative . | |||
evidence in ~ the adversarial_ framework established by. law. ! | |||
c | |||
&a ',. ' | |||
t 1 l | |||
Instead, the Board directed the carties to schedule - | |||
(1L .', questioning among themselves by the invention of so-called" evidentiary deposition I | |||
i[ | |||
j .Y in the absence of the Board Members. The Board indicated'that . .i. | |||
it would later rule on the admissibility of portions of the . | |||
.l | |||
: parties' ' question-and-answer transcripts at a brief public session and ask the witnesses any questions the Board might I then have. | |||
e l ..' | |||
. , . i | |||
;g- . | |||
3 ' ' | |||
4 2 | |||
8211090411 821108 PDR G | |||
ADOCK 03000322 FDR | |||
- .uc e , . | |||
)Q2'~ . | |||
el V | |||
... .. z . .: . :2 . ,. ..1 , . | |||
....,T.T.'"."*'.."."..~..?"'"*-",",""."~';"""."*""*--"'"7".'.'.=*"3*==A | |||
." ,g * - .. -. .a _-.;. . | |||
..,v. ~ | |||
= ;;; = .-- ; .-;;.: _ : q . .a | |||
--:- - t - -r _. _.- - | |||
.3 e | |||
-r.,r.2..., a :.;; ; 2; up . m. . L ,c - | |||
- -.t. % A .. .. | |||
.-. p .. . | |||
..n. | |||
. a _. ; n 2. . _ : . . | |||
. .._, . h a _.,. . _-. | |||
-.-- - - - - .s | |||
__;; , 3 j 2 . _. .3 ; . .- | |||
;; j | |||
-- -e ~ w -- - a | |||
: sus- == = mmm ---m M. | |||
: n. . , | |||
L .4 .w - - -a 9 + - -* --* y - . --* W 4 . -t i-d r r;:=ir:=:=:r: | |||
: n--t=t=setc[.2 m}N:n 5 . .; -, d q : - -tr M P-i- ; A f | |||
. =i L&- a,-tM=-- | |||
- + y s 4.m:=:u:rt: --:-et- :===2 d=f - = g =t=2 - t--: -- ---- --- y =3=;t=I= | |||
= ::::=::=1: | |||
r--%---z r- :M- 217 f | |||
~-- --- --n-t -' t v | |||
-* m=~~i xi = I ri e::TI i | |||
i l | |||
t h; !!' ! k,'!'!E , | |||
1! ! | |||
l : [ l ' | |||
I | |||
!j.j 2 | |||
*:5e BoaEdis proposal' displays; eith'er ignorance .of or ' i ! i t, l | |||
l l iadifferencej to the meaning .and irportance of a public hearing.!' . .[ [ ! | |||
''! 'The W csa13 1s a gross departure frca the ncrm'and'is. I i 'F 1' | |||
'? F 'I usacceptablei to Saffolk Countp. : Accordinaly, . I tam Instructing ; I 1 .i t the. County's counsel and expert consultants .not ito participate '. 1 * | |||
' I ' | |||
j1 ' | |||
'in the Board's proposed procedures. | |||
' !,) | |||
~ | |||
I' ' * ' | |||
ii,i .ki L i I: ) i. .I s.. .. t : i ;; o. l l: By . jMnha, the NRC',s. Shoreham bearing, .Suffolk County , j 1 | |||
[l ;. 5 . i. I i ' | |||
.'p assomed and aceepted t <. | |||
b: icuetsmesrp preceduyed . We pov :heinsirt applicability thhe:your af establisbed Licensing .Boarsj!rules Qft 3i and' . 2 1 | |||
;8 | |||
. ? , j ' impp1 ' "hdme rblbs ; add 'princedores.' En'. Saffolk 'Ccontyi, a " ablie . | |||
4 y hbas e | |||
i.-i p : bear $an | |||
~ 'au ass jus % }thath mothig, scre ind riothing).lessi. | |||
is a. personal' | |||
$ortus of.ihvolvement, right ==? primof1ege in, which ,to develop,.is ;,4D, | |||
~ | |||
facts j | |||
s py:p{< | |||
.M.[ . | |||
i i | |||
j The . attentive ad Judicators g;}i( . | |||
~ | |||
: t! indispensablel . -Yourl Licensing. Board's invention ' | |||
'f i l ; | |||
l)1iUI 1 ijedicentiiry depositiodsi as a substitute fee normal the;cf jf so-e mited ~ .!i i , j,5.bi h | |||
!1' p h l hea:riiusiprocedbres'. not 'onlyi does fiolence to ithe ' settled ;, s ;. j1.', ' e 1 | |||
i rey ;$both adfwllcatory the.,arwrd' and f~ramework the, parties. of~ to the.the proceeding. | |||
NRC, but' it}. cheapens }! ; thef 't.roIes 4 .U oE bf . | |||
t sidsNsok.th ty utto are affe tdd by. . [, - | |||
LjZ | |||
, {4,' } Claretmast's safety, the We issues hold the Ibard being: accountable Beard by tothe u 11 censing'' | |||
i ''' | |||
i *h ;'i i soard are %erious mattets.'l'nperform its judicial.functic's with and care, tem;Eeramen | |||
! j' :'If ' '. ,. -{ [? (( | |||
. I maturity befitting the high public responsibility with'which it: i' has been entrusted. ' "*he Board's proposal to discard normal .. | |||
'I' '..I- 1: | |||
-^ | |||
I i} hearing that the precedure NFC does'not s incensider this case the is an ' issult public's ' safety - aiconcerns suggestica at": 'i:.,f, i j..u !-{'. $( | |||
; :; shoretuun to be imoortant e agh. to justify following the i , , . j l ,,. } | |||
- ordinary course. -t t ! . i i t. t , | |||
i . ! ; . !, | |||
-l 's , ; | |||
' 1 i i i ! ! ? | |||
i i I ask that you prorptly act to terminate this potentia 11y' l , i; Board to use!. } ! l- )i i | |||
! {! normal divisitepchli~c centroversy hearing by instructing | |||
' procedures the Shorehaus in the Licensineproceeding.; i . | |||
Suf folk Cocnty is not willing to permit the Shoreham safety ' | |||
hearing to becese a laboratory for experiments in regulatory , | |||
procedure. | |||
, Si rely yours, | |||
: f. , | |||
,' , 2 #. | |||
, y . | |||
. i ' | |||
! i , | |||
ER F..COHALAN , : - | |||
i | |||
{ . , { i, SUTFOLK COUNTT EXE''UTIVE l | |||
~ | |||
. cc: Lawrecce Brenner, Esq. . l 1 Dr.; Pete r A. Morris 8 | |||
, I D r .; Ja me s L. Ca rpen ter i - | |||
I l | |||
l l | |||
0 1}} | |||
Latest revision as of 06:00, 17 January 2021
| ML20066C218 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Shoreham File:Long Island Lighting Company icon.png |
| Issue date: | 11/08/1982 |
| From: | Cohalan P SUFFOLK COUNTY, NY |
| To: | Asselstine J, Gilinsky V, Palladino N NRC COMMISSION (OCM) |
| References | |
| ISSUANCES-OL, NUDOCS 8211090411 | |
| Download: ML20066C218 (2) | |
Text
{{#Wiki_filter:. . .
--a k w -n ,-m-, . - - -
- r-- - ~ w .,
- In:h P~
m 1 ,; -
; .p ...p ....E .Sa--p it.:pq 7i' .i. .0uj e e 4. e rr m t'niL [ r 4
_,,i : ' i i. ci
.i- i r
E i' p~i ! b , j . [ - F-t--+--l-g-F I: _ w _ ._ m_ a 1 ; _. . - g R _ _ _ _., _
, ; : i +
i - - j_g. - q L
...'.J.2. -
[- . * *- L- L------_ - - - 1- I ; ~*-'--~ -- T ~ - l i [, I - b ' i ,
-- --- - r -'.- r -i--E - C .E .n n. I. 1- - ~i - " r i- Tr , . . . .- , . J 82 @'l,4 g*16i .
g
- .a n ,
Q g h @, ct omcs or me coum EXECURVE ,
- r. : 4 : i .- .y n ,.
emn r. co,- - r> .x m c. ca u m m s - i
.- . ,,a.mc w m cm.eur = : , o o.-
!. j,, i i
-November 8, 1982 I
t li.T""' '
! ;; ; ~;
3 . ' .'.i . . . . g ~. m s.
.h c 'r" r,,,y. v. j ;
;a 1 - o
. c. .
7 The' E' o norable Nunzio J. Palladino. . - The acnorable Victor Gilinsky '
- i .' i '
- a The Honorable ~ James K. Asselstine - - ,
The Bonorable John P'. Ahearne
'[TheHonorableThomasRoberts , , _- U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission '
f j . l ' "-:.[. Washingy, ;D.C. 20555 i .
, j .< 3 i '
d j
Dear ,
Messrs.' Chairman and crummissionerst ;
..s .
~,, .
,i 4 '
I on~ behalf of the ditizens of Suffolk County, I.am writing: i .. .
- to inform you thatL the : hearing on the safety of the Shoreham' a
> ! 'i 2
.! nuclear power plant is being marred by the procedural, .
. Irreaularity of your Licensing Board. I ask that you promptly intercede to exercise the Commission's supervisory authority . -
3; over. the conduct of the hearing. . j
- , .a , ,,
9 .
.-h , I Last' week, the Licensino Board tentatively decided to . . h W discard normal hearing procedures on certain critical- issues of '. ^ t d . ] , emergency. preparedness and quality assurance. The Board stated ~ *
- its intention not to preside 'over the cross-examination of. l lq cxpert witnesses and, thus, in effect not to exercise; its F'.,. 4 M; l ! important role of helping to shape the development of probative .
evidence in ~ the adversarial_ framework established by. law. ! c
&a ',. '
t 1 l Instead, the Board directed the carties to schedule - (1L .', questioning among themselves by the invention of so-called" evidentiary deposition I i[ j .Y in the absence of the Board Members. The Board indicated'that . .i. it would later rule on the admissibility of portions of the .
.l
- parties' ' question-and-answer transcripts at a brief public session and ask the witnesses any questions the Board might I then have.
e l ..'
. , . i
;g- .
3 ' ' 4 2 8211090411 821108 PDR G ADOCK 03000322 FDR
- .uc e , .
)Q2'~ .
el V
... .. z . .: . :2 . ,. ..1 , .
....,T.T.'"."*'.."."..~..?"'"*-",",""."~';"""."*""*--"'"7".'.'.=*"3*==A
." ,g * - .. -. .a _-.;. .
..,v. ~
= ;;; = .-- ; .-;;.: _ : q . .a
--:- - t - -r _. _.- -
.3 e
-r.,r.2..., a :.;; ; 2; up . m. . L ,c -
- -.t. % A .. ..
.-. p .. .
..n.
. a _. ; n 2. . _ : . .
. .._, . h a _.,. . _-.
-.-- - - - - .s
__;; , 3 j 2 . _. .3 ; . .-
;; j
-- -e ~ w -- - a
- sus- == = mmm ---m M.
- n. . ,
L .4 .w - - -a 9 + - -* --* y - . --* W 4 . -t i-d r r;:=ir:=:=:r:
- n--t=t=setc[.2 m}N:n 5 . .; -, d q : - -tr M P-i- ; A f
. =i L&- a,-tM=--
- + y s 4.m:=:u:rt: --:-et- :===2 d=f - = g =t=2 - t--: -- ---- --- y =3=;t=I=
= ::::=::=1:
r--%---z r- :M- 217 f
~-- --- --n-t -' t v
-* m=~~i xi = I ri e::TI i
i l t h; !!' ! k,'!'!E , 1! ! l : [ l ' I
!j.j 2
*:5e BoaEdis proposal' displays; eith'er ignorance .of or ' i ! i t, l
l l iadifferencej to the meaning .and irportance of a public hearing.!' . .[ [ !
! 'The W csa13 1s a gross departure frca the ncrm'and'is. I i 'F 1'
'? F 'I usacceptablei to Saffolk Countp. : Accordinaly, . I tam Instructing ; I 1 .i t the. County's counsel and expert consultants .not ito participate '. 1 *
' I '
j1 '
'in the Board's proposed procedures.
' !,)
~
I' ' * ' ii,i .ki L i I: ) i. .I s.. .. t : i ;; o. l l: By . jMnha, the NRC',s. Shoreham bearing, .Suffolk County , j 1 [l ;. 5 . i. I i '
.'p assomed and aceepted t <.
b: icuetsmesrp preceduyed . We pov :heinsirt applicability thhe:your af establisbed Licensing .Boarsj!rules Qft 3i and' . 2 1
;8 . ? , j ' impp1 ' "hdme rblbs ; add 'princedores.' En'. Saffolk 'Ccontyi, a " ablie .
4 y hbas e i.-i p : bear $an
~ 'au ass jus % }thath mothig, scre ind riothing).lessi.
is a. personal'
$ortus of.ihvolvement, right ==? primof1ege in, which ,to develop,.is ;,4D,
~
facts j s py:p{<
.M.[ .
i i j The . attentive ad Judicators g;}i( .
~
- t! indispensablel . -Yourl Licensing. Board's invention '
'f i l ;
l)1iUI 1 ijedicentiiry depositiodsi as a substitute fee normal the;cf jf so-e mited ~ .!i i , j,5.bi h
!1' p h l hea:riiusiprocedbres'. not 'onlyi does fiolence to ithe ' settled ;, s ;. j1.', ' e 1
i rey ;$both adfwllcatory the.,arwrd' and f~ramework the, parties. of~ to the.the proceeding. NRC, but' it}. cheapens }! ; thef 't.roIes 4 .U oE bf . t sidsNsok.th ty utto are affe tdd by. . [, - LjZ
, {4,' } Claretmast's safety, the We issues hold the Ibard being: accountable Beard by tothe u 11 censing
i i *h ;'i i soard are %erious mattets.'l'nperform its judicial.functic's with and care, tem;Eeramen
! j' :'If ' '. ,. -{ [? ((
. I maturity befitting the high public responsibility with'which it: i' has been entrusted. ' "*he Board's proposal to discard normal ..
'I' '..I- 1:
-^
I i} hearing that the precedure NFC does'not s incensider this case the is an ' issult public's ' safety - aiconcerns suggestica at": 'i:.,f, i j..u !-{'. $(
; :; shoretuun to be imoortant e agh. to justify following the i , , . j l ,,. }
- ordinary course. -t t ! . i i t. t ,
i . ! ; . !,
-l 's , ;
' 1 i i i ! ! ?
i i I ask that you prorptly act to terminate this potentia 11y' l , i; Board to use!. } ! l- )i i
! {! normal divisitepchli~c centroversy hearing by instructing
' procedures the Shorehaus in the Licensineproceeding.; i .
Suf folk Cocnty is not willing to permit the Shoreham safety ' hearing to becese a laboratory for experiments in regulatory , procedure.
, Si rely yours,
- f. ,
,' , 2 #.
, y .
. i '
! i ,
ER F..COHALAN , : - i { . , { i, SUTFOLK COUNTT EXEUTIVE l
~
. cc: Lawrecce Brenner, Esq. . l 1 Dr.; Pete r A. Morris 8
, I D r .; Ja me s L. Ca rpen ter i -
I l l l 0 1}}