ML19305D077: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
 
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
 
Line 18: Line 18:
=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:V .
{{#Wiki_filter:V .
* Lic 3/31/80 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
Lic 3/31/80 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of                  )                                ;
,
BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of                  )                                ;
                                         )
                                         )
METROPOLITAN EDISON COMPANY      )    Docket No. 50-289            '
METROPOLITAN EDISON COMPANY      )    Docket No. 50-289            '
Line 26: Line 24:
(Three Mile Island Nuclear      )
(Three Mile Island Nuclear      )
Station, Unit No. 1)            )
Station, Unit No. 1)            )
LICENSEE'S RESPONSE TO THIRD SET OF INTERROGATORIES OF MARVIN I. LEWIS
LICENSEE'S RESPONSE TO THIRD SET OF INTERROGATORIES OF MARVIN I. LEWIS INTERROGATORY NO. SP-25 Review all previous interrogatories to Licensee from Intervenor Lewis with the following change: Wherever cracks are referred to in vent header change to leaks in vent header.
                                                                          ,
INTERROGATORY NO. SP-25 Review all previous interrogatories to Licensee from Intervenor Lewis with the following change: Wherever cracks are referred to in vent header change to leaks in vent header.
(a)  Does this substantially change any answer'to SP-1 through SP-24 interrogatories?
(a)  Does this substantially change any answer'to SP-1 through SP-24 interrogatories?
(b)  If any answer is substantially changed, submit answer.
(b)  If any answer is substantially changed, submit answer.
Line 38: Line 34:
SP-7 Licensee has no knowledge of any leaks in the TMI-l vent header.
SP-7 Licensee has no knowledge of any leaks in the TMI-l vent header.
SP-8 See SP-4 and SP-7.
SP-8 See SP-4 and SP-7.
                                                                          ,
9
9
                                                   *
                                                   *
* 0 414 0 o2s7;
* 0 414 0 o2s7;


_    _
P v  .
P v  .
                                          ,
INTERROGATORY NO. SP-26 This is not only an interrogatory, but also a partial answer to the Licensee's interrogatory No. 2. Presumably the Licensee will present testimony to show that the vent header and filters      ,
INTERROGATORY NO. SP-26 This is not only an interrogatory, but also a partial answer to the Licensee's interrogatory No. 2. Presumably the Licensee will present testimony to show that the vent header and filters      ,
are acceptable in TMI-1. Intervenor Lewis may have to limit his presentation to cross examination of Licensee's witnesses. Send      i the names and qualifications of the Licensee's witnesses regard-    :
are acceptable in TMI-1. Intervenor Lewis may have to limit his presentation to cross examination of Licensee's witnesses. Send      i the names and qualifications of the Licensee's witnesses regard-    :
* ing the Lewis Contention including a synopsis of their testimony.
ing the Lewis Contention including a synopsis of their testimony.


===RESPONSE===
===RESPONSE===
Met Ed has as yet made no selection of witnesses who will testify on the vent header and filters of TMI-1. Since witnesses l have not yet been selected, it is not possible at this time to      ;
Met Ed has as yet made no selection of witnesses who will testify on the vent header and filters of TMI-1. Since witnesses l have not yet been selected, it is not possible at this time to      ;
respond to this interrogatory. However, background and qualifica-tions of any experts who may be offered by Licensee as witnesses will be included in prepared testimony filed with all participants in advance of the hearing session at which such witnesses may appear.                          -
respond to this interrogatory. However, background and qualifica-tions of any experts who may be offered by Licensee as witnesses will be included in prepared testimony filed with all participants in advance of the hearing session at which such witnesses may appear.                          -
INTERROGATORY NO. SP-27 Does the Licensee keep files or dockets or dossiers on the back-grounds of Marvin I. Lewis or Susan Barley? Do these dockets contain hearsay, background checks, criminal records, or documen-tation from governmental agencies? Intervenor Lewis is particularly interested in whether Met Ed or its business contacts keep records of the type recently found to be kept by the Georgia Power Company
INTERROGATORY NO. SP-27 Does the Licensee keep files or dockets or dossiers on the back-grounds of Marvin I. Lewis or Susan Barley? Do these dockets contain hearsay, background checks, criminal records, or documen-tation from governmental agencies? Intervenor Lewis is particularly interested in whether Met Ed or its business contacts keep records of the type recently found to be kept by the Georgia Power Company on anti-nuclear activists.
  ,
on anti-nuclear activists.


===RESPONSE===
===RESPONSE===
Line 63: Line 54:
is outside the service, territory of GPU/ Met Ed.
is outside the service, territory of GPU/ Met Ed.
Normal customer business records may exist if either
Normal customer business records may exist if either
                                                  .


                                                                      - -
r 3-                        ,
r
        .
  .' *
                                        -
3-                        ,
individual ever resided within the service territory of Licensee.
individual ever resided within the service territory of Licensee.
(2)  Voluntary sign-in register logs were maintained at the TMI observation center prior to the TMI-2 accident. Whether or not either of these indi-viduals ever opted to sign such registers is un-known to Licensee without burdensome review of such records, which Licensee has not attempted.
(2)  Voluntary sign-in register logs were maintained at the TMI observation center prior to the TMI-2 accident. Whether or not either of these indi-viduals ever opted to sign such registers is un-known to Licensee without burdensome review of such records, which Licensee has not attempted.
(3)  Licensee maintains TMI security logs and TLD ex-posure data for site personnel, including visi-tors. Although the latter contains no records of
(3)  Licensee maintains TMI security logs and TLD ex-posure data for site personnel, including visi-tors. Although the latter contains no records of either individual, if either Marvin Lewis or Susan Barley were ever issued TMI visitor badges, plant records, in the form of sign-in logs, woule' record this information. Licensee has not at-        -
.
either individual, if either Marvin Lewis or Susan Barley were ever issued TMI visitor badges, plant records, in the form of sign-in logs, woule' record this information. Licensee has not at-        -
tempted to review daily logs to ascertain if such is the case.
tempted to review daily logs to ascertain if such is the case.
Respectfully submitted, SHAW, PITTMAN, POTTS & TROWBRIDGE
Respectfully submitted, SHAW, PITTMAN, POTTS & TROWBRIDGE By:          >    .h            j thih6rge/F. TroWbridge      [
.
* By:          >    .h            j thih6rge/F. TroWbridge      [
Robert E. Zahler Dated:    March 31, 1980
Robert E. Zahler Dated:    March 31, 1980
                                  .
                              *


                ,
    -
              .
  .
S haw, PITTM AN, PoTTs & TROWB RIDG E 1800 M STR E CT, N. W.
S haw, PITTM AN, PoTTs & TROWB RIDG E 1800 M STR E CT, N. W.
WA S H I N GTO N, 0. C. 2 O O 3 6 mAMSar D.POTTS                      STE PHEN S. MUTTLER                                                              Moa) 331 A8CO STEU ART L. PsTTMAN                WINTMROP N. SRowN                                                                      _
WA S H I N GTO N, 0. C. 2 O O 3 6 mAMSar D.POTTS                      STE PHEN S. MUTTLER                                                              Moa) 331 A8CO STEU ART L. PsTTMAN                WINTMROP N. SRowN                                                                      _
GEORot F. TRoweRIDG E              JAM ES e. MAM uN LT E PH E N 0 POTT S                ROB ERT C. IAMLER                                                                  TELECOPIER
GEORot F. TRoweRIDG E              JAM ES e. MAM uN LT E PH E N 0 POTT S                ROB ERT C. IAMLER                                                                  TELECOPIER s',"'J?!".'OSTw                    "?."E^"T .' RO .'!I  ,$                                                    uOa > === Ca.A a a.. ifeo R. TI MOTMY M AN LO N              STEVEN M LUCAS                                                                        _
                  "" "                                * "
s',"'J?!".'OSTw                    "?."E^"T .' RO .'!I  ,$                                                    uOa > === Ca.A a a.. ifeo R. TI MOTMY M AN LO N              STEVEN M LUCAS                                                                        _
GEORGE M. ROCERS. JR.              M ATIAS F. TRAveESO OfA2 JOMN g. RMIN ELAN DER              #fCTORIA J. PERKINS                                                                  TEL EJE
GEORGE M. ROCERS. JR.              M ATIAS F. TRAveESO OfA2 JOMN g. RMIN ELAN DER              #fCTORIA J. PERKINS                                                                  TEL EJE
[KUCE w. CMURCMILL                  JOHN M. O'N EILL J R.
[KUCE w. CMURCMILL                  JOHN M. O'N EILL J R.
Line 107: Line 80:
A copy of these materials is also being forwarded to Ms. Susan Barley, under. separate cover.
A copy of these materials is also being forwarded to Ms. Susan Barley, under. separate cover.
Sin  rely yours,
Sin  rely yours,
                                                                              .
                                                                                                          .
                                                                                                                -
                                                                                                                       ,4syAs or    F. Trowbridge Enclosure cc:      Service List
                                                                                                                       ,4syAs or    F. Trowbridge Enclosure cc:      Service List
.}}
.}}

Latest revision as of 13:41, 1 February 2020

Response to Mi Lewis Third Set of Interrogatories Re Restart Proceeding.Includes Info Re Selection of Witnesses & Background of Mi Lewis & s Barley.Gf Trowbridge 800331 Forwarding Ltr to Mi Lewis Encl
ML19305D077
Person / Time
Site: Three Mile Island Constellation icon.png
Issue date: 03/31/1980
From: Trowbridge G, Zahler R
METROPOLITAN EDISON CO., SHAW, PITTMAN, POTTS & TROWBRIDGE
To: Lewis M
AFFILIATION NOT ASSIGNED
Shared Package
ML19305D049 List:
References
NUDOCS 8004140038
Download: ML19305D077 (4)
v • d • e


Text

V .

Lic 3/31/80 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of )  ;

)

METROPOLITAN EDISON COMPANY ) Docket No. 50-289 '

) (Restart)

(Three Mile Island Nuclear )

Station, Unit No. 1) )

LICENSEE'S RESPONSE TO THIRD SET OF INTERROGATORIES OF MARVIN I. LEWIS INTERROGATORY NO. SP-25 Review all previous interrogatories to Licensee from Intervenor Lewis with the following change: Wherever cracks are referred to in vent header change to leaks in vent header.

(a) Does this substantially change any answer'to SP-1 through SP-24 interrogatories?

(b) If any answer is substantially changed, submit answer.

RESPONSE

_ Changing the word " cracked" to " leaked" in the previously submitted interrogatories results in the following changes:

SP-4 See response to* Interrogatory No. SP-24.

SP-6 See SP-4.

SP-7 Licensee has no knowledge of any leaks in the TMI-l vent header.

SP-8 See SP-4 and SP-7.

9

  • 0 414 0 o2s7;

P v .

INTERROGATORY NO. SP-26 This is not only an interrogatory, but also a partial answer to the Licensee's interrogatory No. 2. Presumably the Licensee will present testimony to show that the vent header and filters ,

are acceptable in TMI-1. Intervenor Lewis may have to limit his presentation to cross examination of Licensee's witnesses. Send i the names and qualifications of the Licensee's witnesses regard-  :

ing the Lewis Contention including a synopsis of their testimony.

RESPONSE

Met Ed has as yet made no selection of witnesses who will testify on the vent header and filters of TMI-1. Since witnesses l have not yet been selected, it is not possible at this time to  ;

respond to this interrogatory. However, background and qualifica-tions of any experts who may be offered by Licensee as witnesses will be included in prepared testimony filed with all participants in advance of the hearing session at which such witnesses may appear. -

INTERROGATORY NO. SP-27 Does the Licensee keep files or dockets or dossiers on the back-grounds of Marvin I. Lewis or Susan Barley? Do these dockets contain hearsay, background checks, criminal records, or documen-tation from governmental agencies? Intervenor Lewis is particularly interested in whether Met Ed or its business contacts keep records of the type recently found to be kept by the Georgia Power Company on anti-nuclear activists.

RESPONSE

Licensee is unaware of any files, dockets, or dossiers in its possession (or ever were) on the backgrounds of Marvin I. {

Lewis or Susan Barley with the following possible exceptions:

(1) The current mailing address of both individuals  ;

is outside the service, territory of GPU/ Met Ed.

Normal customer business records may exist if either

r 3- ,

individual ever resided within the service territory of Licensee.

(2) Voluntary sign-in register logs were maintained at the TMI observation center prior to the TMI-2 accident. Whether or not either of these indi-viduals ever opted to sign such registers is un-known to Licensee without burdensome review of such records, which Licensee has not attempted.

(3) Licensee maintains TMI security logs and TLD ex-posure data for site personnel, including visi-tors. Although the latter contains no records of either individual, if either Marvin Lewis or Susan Barley were ever issued TMI visitor badges, plant records, in the form of sign-in logs, woule' record this information. Licensee has not at- -

tempted to review daily logs to ascertain if such is the case.

Respectfully submitted, SHAW, PITTMAN, POTTS & TROWBRIDGE By: > .h j thih6rge/F. TroWbridge [

Robert E. Zahler Dated: March 31, 1980

S haw, PITTM AN, PoTTs & TROWB RIDG E 1800 M STR E CT, N. W.

WA S H I N GTO N, 0. C. 2 O O 3 6 mAMSar D.POTTS STE PHEN S. MUTTLER Moa) 331 A8CO STEU ART L. PsTTMAN WINTMROP N. SRowN _

GEORot F. TRoweRIDG E JAM ES e. MAM uN LT E PH E N 0 POTT S ROB ERT C. IAMLER TELECOPIER s',"'J?!".'OSTw "?."E^"T .' RO .'!I ,$ uOa > === Ca.A a a.. ifeo R. TI MOTMY M AN LO N STEVEN M LUCAS _

GEORGE M. ROCERS. JR. M ATIAS F. TRAveESO OfA2 JOMN g. RMIN ELAN DER #fCTORIA J. PERKINS TEL EJE

[KUCE w. CMURCMILL JOHN M. O'N EILL J R.

LESLIE A. NICMOLSON. J R. JAf A. EPSTIE N OO*IOO3(I"A*bAW WSH}

M ARTIN Q. M R ALL RAND L. ALLEN CA g Lg "$MawLAw "

ElCM AND J. M ENDALL TIMOTMY S. Me SRIDE J /.Y E. SILSERG ELsSASETH M. PENCLETON ri R a AR A M. ROS SOTTI LUCY G. CLIASOF G EORG E V. ALLEN. JR. PAU L A. M APLAN EDWARD 5. CROSLANO WM. GR AOFORD RCYNOLOS M A RRY M. G LA S Spl[Q EL COUNSEL FR ED A. LITTLE TMOM AS M. McCOR:41Cn FEED ORASNER SUSAN D.FALMSON NATM ANi[L P S R E E D. J R. W I LLI AM P.SARR MARM AUC E N G LIC K JOM N L. CARM, J R.

E%N E ST L. BLAME JR PMILip J. M ARVEY CA R LCTON S. J ON E S ROSCMT M. GORDON TMOM AS A. gAATER JEANN E A. CALDERON JAM ES M. BURG E R SAR s ARA J. MORG EN

  • S M ELDON J. wCIS EL SONNIE S. GOTTWEB JOHN A. McCULLOUGH ALFR ED M. POSTELL J. PAT RIC M MIC K EY SETM M. MOOG AS SAN JAMCS TMOMAS LCNMART SM EILA E. McCAFFERTY STEVEN L. M E LTZ E R DELIS SA A. RIDGWAY DEAN D. AULICM R EN N ETM J. M AUTM AN JOMN ENQCL DAVID LAWRENCE MILLER

..or ..M.en o .. D.c. March 31, 1980 fir. Marvin I. Lewis 6504 Bradford Terrace Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19149 Re: Three Mile Island Unit.1 Docket No. 50-289 (Restart)

Dear Mr. Lewis:

I enclose Licensee's response to your third set of interrogatories. Copies of signed affidavits for these responses are not enclosed, but will be forwarded soon.

A copy of these materials is also being forwarded to Ms. Susan Barley, under. separate cover.

Sin rely yours,

,4syAs or F. Trowbridge Enclosure cc: Service List

.

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML19305D077&oldid=2373942"