ML20127L458

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Partial Response to FOIA Request for Records Contained in 15 FIN Files.Forwards Documents Listed in App E.Search Continuing
ML20127L458
Person / Time
Site: Indian Point, Diablo Canyon, Zion, 05000000, 05000470, 05000668
Issue date: 10/02/1984
From: Felton J
NRC OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION (ADM)
To: Sholly S
UNION OF CONCERNED SCIENTISTS
Shared Package
ML20127A418 List: ... further results
References
FOIA-84-243, REF-GTECI-A-44, REF-GTECI-EL NUDOCS 8505230001
Download: ML20127L458 (17)
v • d • e


Text

F-i A1 P0(L-Ole

/ 'o

~,,- UNITED STATES 8 g NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION O'  : E WASHINGTON, D. C. 20555

\...../ .00T 0 21984 Mr.-Steven C. Sholly Technical Research Associate

' Union of Concerned Scientists 1346 Connecticut Avenue, NW Suite 1101 IN RESPONSE REFER Washington, DC 20036 TO F01A-84-243

Dear Mr. Sholly:

This is in partial response to your letter dated March 30, 1984, in which you requested, pursuant to the Freedom of Infonnation Act, that the NRC make records related to 15 listed FIN files available for public inspection and copying at the NRC Public Document Room.

The records identified on the enclosed Appendix E are now available for your inspection and copying as requested.

'The staff is continuing to review additional records subject to your request. We will notify you upon completion of this review.

Sinc ely,

. . Felton, Director Division of Rules and Records Office of Administration

Enclosure:

As stated 8505230001 841002 b PDR sh$tths4243

g i

APPENDIX E F0IA REQUEST 84-243 RECORDS IN PDR FOLDER-84-243 .

c FIN -'A0448

1. .07/22/83 Memorandum to Leon L. Beratan, NRC:RES:DHSWM, from Robert E.

' Jackson, NRC:NRR:DE, entitled "Possible Additions to Seismic

. Hazard Characterization Program."

'2 .

08/26/83 - NRC Form '367, "D0E Source Selection Justification for A0448."

3. '10/13/83 -Letter to R. E. Jackson, NRC:NRR:DE, fron D. L. Bernreuter and D. H. Chung, LLNL, entitled " Discussion of Proposed Budget and Schedule Estimates for the Proposed Project: Probabilistic Assessment of._the-Seismic Hazard for EUS' Nuclear Power Plant Sites (FIN - A0448)."
4. 10/26/83 Memorandum:to Robert E. Jackson, NRC:NRR:DE, from Jeff Kimball, NRC:NRR:DE, entitled "LLNL Draft Proposal for Probabilistic Assessment of the Seismic Hazard for EUS Nuclear Power Plant Sites (FIN A0448)."
5. et al., from Bernard L.

11/23/83 Memorandum to Martin Grenier, NRC:NRR, Hayes, entitled NRC:RES,

" Review an TCoordinatio'n of NRR Technical Assistance Projects" with concurrences received from RES IE, NMSS, AEOD, Regions I, II, III, and V.

6. 12/23/83. PPAS Action' Summary Sheet for A0448.
7. 12/30/83' Memorandum to Richard H. Vollmer,-NRC:NRR:DE, from Harold E.

Lefevre, NRC:NRR:DE, entitled " Request for Exception-to Manual Chapter 1102 for Probabilistic Assessment of the Seismic Hazard to Eastern United States Power Plant Sites, A0448."

8. 01/06/84 PPAS Action Summary Sheet for A0448.

-9. 01/10/84 Letter to Richard A. Duval, DOE (San Francisco Operations Office) from Richard H. Vollmer, NRC:NRR:DE, entitled "LLNL Technical Assistance to the Division of Engineering, NRR, NRC -

'Probabilistic Assessment of~the Seismic Hazard of Eastern United States Power Plant Sites' (FIN: A0448)" with enclosed NRC Form 173, Statement of Work, and Proposal Content, requesting a proposal'from LLNL for A0448.

10. 02/13/84 Memorandum to Jesse L. Funches, NRC:NRR:PPAS from Richard H.

Vollmer, NRC:NRR:DE, entitled " Request for Change to DE FIN Plan" with attached, revised PIDS.

L

a F01A-84-243

11. .02/17/84 Letter to Robert E. Jackson, NRC:NRR:DE, from D. L. Bernreuter, LLNL, entitled " Letter Report Covering the January 18-20, 1984 EPRI Data Needs' Workshop - Task 5 of the. Project Probabilistic Assessment of the Seismic Hazard of EUS Power Plant Sites (FIN A0448) with attachment.
12. 02/23/84' Letter to Carol Paugh, NRC:NRR:PPAS, from Clifton Adams, DOE

-(San Francisco Operations Office), entitled "NRC Order No.84-171, FIN A0448-2" with enclosed, signed f,RC Form 173.

13. 03/01/84 ' Memorandum to File from Harold E. Lefevre, NRC:NRR:DE, entitled

" Post-January 10, 1984 Contractual Activities" for A0448.

14. Undated Statement of Work for A0448-(10 pages)
15. Undated Project Identification Summary (PIDS) for A0448.

.16. . Undated Proposed Content - Requirements for DOE Proposals using NRC' Form 189.

FIN A3705

1. 01/03/83 PPAS Action Sumary Sheet-for A3705.
2. 01/04/83 Letter to' Gregory J. Ogeka, DOE (Brookhaven Area Office) from Roger J. Mattson, NRC:NRR:DSI, entitled "BNL Technical Assistance to the Division of Systems Integration, NRR, NRC ' Safety Evaluation of Core-Melt Accidents: CESSAR-FDA; Westinghouse Standard Plant - FDA' (FIN A3705)" with enclosed Statement of Work and Proposal--Content requesting a proposal from BNL.

'3. 02/10/83 Project Identification Summary (PIDS) for A3705.

4. 02/10/83 Project Identification Summary (PIDS) for A3705.
5. 02/28/83 Chart of NRC/BNL Programs with 90% Funds Expended.
6. .03/07/83 LettertoDavidSchweller, DOE (BrookhavenAreaOffice),from H. C. Grahn, BNL, with enclosed NRC Form 189, " Project and Budget Proposal for NRC Work," (note that pages 4, 6, 8,10, and 12 are missing from this file copy).
7. 04/11/83 PPAS Action Sumary Sheet for A3705.

Q.-_-____--_____-_____

s F01A-84-243

~

8. 04/13/83 Letter to Gregory J.-Ogeka,-DOE (Brookhaven Area Office), from Roger.J.-Mattson, NRC:NRR:DSI, entitled "BNL Technical Assistance to the Division of Systems Integration, NRR, NRC, ' Safety
Evaluation of Core-Melt Accidents: CESSAR-FDA; Westinghouse-

- StandardPlant-FDA'(FINA3705),"withenclosedNRCForm173to provide initial funding of $50,000 for Tasks I through IV.

9. -05/03/83-' Letter to Diane B. Dandois, NRC:0RM:DA, from Gregory J. Ogeka, DOE with enclosed, signed NRC form 173.
10. 05/18/83 Project Identification Summary (PIDS) for A3705.
11. 05/25/83 Memorandum to Jesse L. Funches, NRC:NRR:PPAS, from Roger J.

Mattson, NRC:NRR:DSI, entitled " Reprogramming of Funds From A-3705 to A-3706.

12. 08/18/83 PPAS Action Sumary Sheet for B8657.

13 .~ 10/20/83 Letter to Gregory J. Ogeka, DOE (Brookhaven Area Office) From Roger J. Mattson, NRC:NRR:DSI, entitled "BNL Technical Assistance to the Division of Systems Integration, NRR, NRC ' Safety Evaluation of Core-Melt Accidents: CESSAR-FDA; Westinghouse Standard Plant-FDA' (FIN A3705)" with enclosed hRC Form 173 providing additional funding of $150,000.

14 _10/20/83 PPAS Action Summary Sheet for A3705.

15. 10/24/83 PPAS Action Summary Sheet for A3705.
16. 11/04/83 Letter to Diane Dandois, NRC:0RM:DA, from Gregory J. Ogeka, DOE (Brookhaven Area Office), with enclosed NRC form 173 signed by DOE.

L17. 02/02/84 NRC Form 367, " DOE Source Selection Justification."

18. Monthly Contract Management Reports " Monthly Highlights" April 1983 May 1983 June 1983 July 1983 August 1983 September 1983 October 1983
  • November 1983 December 1983 January 1984
19. Undated NRC Form 385, " Project Identification" for A3705.
20. Undated Draft Project Identification Summary (PIDS) for A3705.

p l

F0!A-84-243 FIN - A3706

1. 03/18/83 ; Memorandum to Martin Hays, NRC:RES, et'al., from Bernard L.

.Grenier,-NRC:NRR, entitled " Review alid Tdordination of NRR Technical Assistance Projects" with concurrences from AE00, NMSS, RES, Regions I,.!!, III, IV and V.

2. 03/24/83 PPAS.ActionSumEarySheetforA3706.

~3. 03/25/83 Letter-to Gregory J. Ogeka, DOE (Brookhaven Area Office), from Robert J. Mattson, NRC:NRR:DSI, entitled "BNL Technical Assistance to the Division of Systems Integration, NRR, NRC, ' Safety Evaluation of Core-Melt Accidents: Mark-I BWRs' (FIN A-3706)"

with enclosed Statement'of Work and Proposal Content requesting a proposal from BNL. -

4.- 04/22/84 Letter to David Schweller, DOE (Brookhaven Area Office), from H. C. Grahn, BNL, with enclosed NRC Form 189, " Project and Budget Proposal for NRC Work" for A-3706 (note that pages 4, 6, 8, and 10 are missing from this file copy).

5. _05/25/84 Memorandum to Jesse.L. Funches, NRC:NRR:PPAS, from Roger J.

Mattson, NRC:NRR:DSI, entitled " Reprogramming of Funds From A-3705 to A-3706" with enclosed, revised Project Identification Summaries (PIDS) for A3705 and A3706.

6.- 05/25/84 Same as item 5 above with PPAS staff notes in margin.

7._ 06/02/83 PPAS Action Summary Sheet for A3706.

8. '06/03/83 Letter to Gregory J. Ogeka, DOE (Brookhaven Area Office), from Roger J. Mattson, NRC:NRR:DSI, entitled '_'BNL Technical Assistance to the Division of Systems Integration, NRR, NRC_ ' Safety H Evaluation of Core-Melt Accidents: Mark-IBWRs'(FIN #A3706)" l with enclosed'NRC Form 173'providing initial funding of $120,000.

9.- 06/13/83a Note to T. J. Carter, NRC:NRR:PPAS, from Harold Berkson, NRC:NRR:PPAS, entitled " Technical Assistance Request: NRR Ticket TSB-237."

10. 06/14/83 Letter to Diane Dandois, NRC:0RM:DA, from Gregory J. Ogeka, DOE (Brookhaven Area Office), with enclosed NRC Form 173.
11. 10/20/83 Letter to Gregory J. Ogeka, DOE (Brookhaven Area Office) from Roger J. Mattson, NRC:NRR:DSI, entitled "BNL Technical Assistance to the Division of Systems Integration, NRR, NRC ' Safety Evaluation of Core-Melt Accidents: MarkIBWRs'(FINA-3706)"

with enclosed NRC Form 173 providing additional funding of $145,000.

L

F01A-84-243

'12. ~10/20/83: PPAS Action Summary Sheet for A3706.

13. 11/04/83 Letter to Diane Dandois, NRC:0RM:DA, from Gregory J. Ogeka, DOE

~(Brookhaven Area Office) with enclosed, signed NRC Form 173.  ;

14. 12/06/83 Letter to Marc Wigdor, NRC:NRR:DSI, from Kenneth R. Perkins, BNL, with enclosed memoranda related to the Mark-I safety evaluation-(Attachments 1 and 2)_and draft Mark-I containment loading calculations (Attachment 3).
15. 03/22/84 -Letter to Mark Wigdor, NRC:NRR:DSI, from Kenneth R. Perkins, BNL, with enclosed Mark-I presentation at the Containment Loads Working Group Meeting of March 13 - 14, 1984
16. Monthly Contract Management Reports " Monthly Highlights" June 1983 July 1983 August 1983

. September 1983 October 1983 November 1983 December 1983

. Jar.uary 1964

17. Undated Overview of DSI/RSB Scope of Effort in the Area of Severe Accidents.

FIN A-3710

1. 10/19/82 Letter to Gregory J. Ogeka, DOE (Brookhaven Area Office),

from Richard H. Vollmer, NRC:NRR:DE, requesting a proposal for project entitled " Reliability and Probabilistic Assessments for Fire Events," with enclosed Statement of Work and Proposal Content.

2. 12/14/82 PPAS Action Summary Sheet for A3710.
3. 12/21/82 Letter to Gregory J. Ogeka, DOE (Brookhaven Area Office), from
. Richard H. Vollter, NRC:NRR:DE, entitled " Reliability and Probabilistic Assessments for Fire Events," modifying statement of work, providing initial funding of $10,000, and authorizing work to begin.
4. 01/04/83 Letter to David B. Shreve, NBS, from Robert 11. Bernero, NRC:RES:RA, entitled " Interagency Agreement No.83-001".
5. 01/17/83 Note to William Forehand, RES, from Bernard Grenier, NRC Contract '

l: Review Board, entitled " Contract Review Board Review of RES-83-001 l (FIN B8957), ' Framework for Fire Risk Analysis in Nuclear l

Facilities,'" with enclosed Statement of Work.

l l.

I

I F01A-84-243 L ~.

6 01/26/83- Memorandum to Jesse L. Funches, NRC:NRR:PPAS, from-Richard H. ,

-Vollmer, NRC:NRR:DE, entitled "Pevision to DE FIN Plan," with enclosed PIDS.

L 7.- ~ 02/18/83 Letter to David Schweller, DOE (Brookhaven Area Office) from

.H. C. Grahn, BNL,. enclosing NRC Form 189, " Project and Budget Proposal for NRC Work" for A3710.

8. .03/11/83 PPAS Action Summary Sheet for A3710.

L

9. 03/17/83 Memorandum to Martin Hayes, NRC:RES, et al., from Bernard L.

Grenier, NRR, entitled " Review and Coordination of NRR Technical e Assistance Projects" for A3710.

l 10. 03/21/84 Letter to Richard Vollmer, NRC:NRR:DE, from A. J. Romano, BNL, requesting NRC approval for BNL to subcontract part of A3710 to l Factory Mutual Research Corporation.

'11. 03/22/83 PPAS Action Summary Sheet for A3710.

12. 03/23/83 Letter to Gregory J. Ogeka, DOE (Brookhaven Area Office) from L Richard H. Vollmer, NRC:NRR:DE, entitled " Reliability and probabilistic Assessments for Fire Events (A3710)," with enclosed NRC Form 173.
13. 04/04/83 Memorandum to Bernard L. Grenier, NRR, from Benjamin Buchbinder, RES, entitled " Review of NRR Technical Assistance Proposal, Reliability Engineering and-Risk Assessment for Fire Events ,

L (FINA3710)"

! 14 .- 06/16/83 PPAS Action Summary Sheet for A3710.

i.

l' .15. 06/20/83 Letter to A. J. Romano, BNL, from Richard H. Vollmer, NRC:NRR:DE,

! approving BNL subcontract with Factory Mutual Research

. Corporation for A3710.

l

16. 09/21/83 Letter to Gregory J. Ogeka DOE-(Brookhaven Area Office), from Richard H. Vollmer, NRC:NRR:DE, entitled "' Reliability and Probabilistic Assessments for Fire Events' A3710 and ' Operating Reactor Water Chemistry and Corrosion' A3380," with enclosed NRC Form 173 to deobligate $22,000 from A3710 to BNL FIN A3380.
17. 09/26/83 NRC Form 173, " Standard Order for DOE Work" for A3710.
18. 09/26/83 Letter to Gregory J. Ogeka DOE (Brookhaven Area Office) from Richard H. Vollmer, NRC:NRR:DE, entitled "' Reliability and Probabilistic Assessments for Fire Events' A3710 and ' Pipe Crack l -- Evaluation in Operating BWRs,' A3739" with enclosed NRC Form 173 l- to deobligate $18,000 from BNL FIN A3710 to BNL FIN A3739 (NRC

! Form 173 not signed by DOE).

l

l F0!A-84-243

19. 09/26/83 Letter to Gregory
  • J. Ogeka, DOE (Brookhaven Area Office), from Richard H. Vollmer, NRC:NRR:DE, entitled "' Reliability and Probabilistic Assessments for Fire Events,' A3710 and ' Pipe Crack Evaluation in Operating BWRs,' A3739," with enclosed NRC Form 173 to deobligate S18,000 from BNL FIN A3710 to BNL FIN A3739 (NRC Form 173 signed by DOE).

20, 09/28/83 Letter to Gregory J. Ogeka, DOE (Brookhaven Area Office) f ron Richard H. Vollmer, NRC:NRR:DE, 2ntitled "'Pe11 ability and Probabilistic Assessments for Fire Events,' A3710 and ' Fire Probabilistic Model Reviews' A3703" with enclosed NRC Form 173 to transfer $8,000 from BNL FIN A3710 to BNL FIN A3703 (NRC Fcrn 173 not signed by DOE).

21. 09/28/83 Same as item 20 above, except NRC Form 173 signed by DOE.
22. 09/30/83 Letter to Gregory J. Ogeka, DOE (Brookhaven Area Office),

from Bernard L. Grenier, NRR, entitled "'Probabilistic Response and Response Spectra for Category I Structures' (A3721) and

' Reliability and Probabilistic Assessment for Fire Events' (A3710)" which ebligates $22,000 for A3721 and S18,000 for A3710.

23. 09/30/83 Same as item 22 above, except NRC Form 173 is attached. This NRC Form 173 is not signed by D0E.

24 11/29/83 Memorandum to Richard H. Vollmer, NRC:NRR:DE, from Diane Money, NRC:NRR:DE, entitled, " Technical Assistance Contracts A3710 and A3402".

25. 12/06/83 Letter to Gregory J. Ogeka, DOE (Brookhaven Area Office) from Richard H. Vollmer, NRC:NRR:DE, entitled "' Reliability and Probabilistic Assessments for Fire Events' (A3710)" enclosing NRC Fonn 173 to provide $50,000 in increnental funding.
26. 12/06/83 NRC Form 173, s'igned by D0E,
27. 01/04/84 Letter to David Schweller, DOE, from H. C. Grahn, BNL, with enclosed NRC From 189, " Project and Budget Proposal for NRC Work" for A3710.
28. 02/10/84 Letter to Dennis Kubicki, NRC:NRR:DE, from John L. Boccio, BNL, enclosing draft technical report entitled " Evaluation of Available Data for Probabilistic Risk Asscsstent (PRA) cf Fire Events at Nuclear Power Plants and Reliability Assessments of Fire Protectier Systems" by L. M. Krasner, C. S. Ganti, and B. G. Vincent. Prepared for BNL by factory Mutual Research Corporation, Norwood, Massachusetts.

F01A-84-243

29. 03/01/84 Letter to Gregory J. Ogeka, DOE, from Richard H. Vollmer, NRC:NRR: DE, entitled "' Reliability and Probabilistic Assessments for Fire Events' (A3710)" with enclosed NRC Form 173 providing

$40,000 in incrementel funding and a change in Task I of Project II.

30, 4/84 Draft report by M. A. Azarm and J. L. Boccio, BNL, entitled

" Preliminary Evaluation of Selected Fire Protection Measures in Nuclear Power Plants".

31. Monthly Contract Mana9etent Reports " Monthly Highlights" January 1983 February 1983 March 1983 April 1983 May 1983 June 1983 July 1983 August 1983 September 1983 October 1983 November 1983 December 1983 January 1984
32. Undated Letter to Gregory J. Ogeka, DOE, from Richard H. Vollmer, NRC:NRR:DE, er. titled " Reliability and Probabilistic Assessments for Fire Events (NEW)" with enclosed NRC Form 173.
33. Undated Letter to Gregory J. Ogeka, DOE, from Richard H. Vollmer, NRC:NRR:DE, entitled "' Operating Reactor Water Chemistry and Corrosion' (A3380)" with enclosed NRC Form 173.

FIN-A3712

1. 01/28/82 Letter to David Okrent, ACRS, from Garry L. Schott, LANL, with observations re assessment of flammable hydrogen hazard in Zion PRA.
2. 01/29/82 Letter to David Okrent, ACRS, from David C. Aldrich, SNL, with review findings of Site Consequence Analysis portion of Zion PRA.
3. 02/01/82 Letter to David Okrent, ACRS, from Dana A. Powers, SNL, with comments on sections 3, 5, and 9 of the Zion PRA.

4 02/15/82 Letter to David Okrent, ACRS, from Jack W. Hickman, SNL, with comments on Zion PRA.

F0!A-84-243

5. 02/17/82 Letter to David Okrent, ACRS, fron, R. Avery, ANL, with comments l on' Zion PRA.

o L 6. 02/18/82 . Memorandum to M. Bender, W. Kerr, and D. Okrent, ACRS, from W.

! L. Baldewicz, ACRS Fellow, entitled "NRC Staff Questions on l Severe-Accident Phenomenology of the Zion PRA."

7. 11/22/82 PPAS Action Summary Sheet for A3712.

8.- 11/29/82 Letter to Gregary J. Ogeka, DOE (Brookhaven Area Office), from Poger J. Mattson, NRC:NRR:DSI, entitled "BNL Technical Assistance to the Division of Systems Integration, NRR..NRC, ' Safety Evaluation of Core-Melt Accidents: -Indian Point - 0 R. and Zion -

0.R.' (FIN A-3712)" with enclosed Statement of Work and Proposal Content requesting a proposal from BNL.

9. ~12/15/82 LettertoDavidSchweller, DOE (BrookhavenAreaOffice),from H. C. Grahn, BNL, with enclosed NRC Form 189, " Project and Budget  ;

Proposal for NRC Work," (note that pages 4, 6, 8, 10 and 12 are '

missing from this file copy).

10. 12/30/82 PPAS Action Summary Sheet for A3712.  ;
11. 12/30/82 Letter to Gregory J. Ogeka, DOE (Brookhaven Area Office) from Roger J. Mattson, NRC:NRR:DSI, entitled "BNL Technical Assistance to the Division of Systems Integration, NRR, NRC ' Safety Evaluation of Core-Melt Accidents: Indian Point - 0.R. and Zion -

0.R.' (FIN #A3712)" with enclosed NRC Form 173 to authorize  :

530,000 to begin work on Tasks I through IV.

12. 01/10/83 Letter to Diane Dandois, NRC:0RM:DA, from Gregory J. Ogeka. DOE (Brookhaven Area Office), with enclosed, signed NRC Form 173. i
13. 01/21/83 PPAS Action Summary Sheet for A3712.
14. 01/24/83 Letter to Gregory J. Ogeka. DOE (Brookhaven Area Office), from Roger J. Mattson, NRC:NRR:DSI, entitled "BNL Technical Assistance to the Division of Systems Integration, NRR, NRC ' Safety Evaluation of Core-Melt Accidents: Indian Point - OR and 1 Zion - OR' (FIN #A3712)," with enclosed NRC Form 173 to provide additional funding of $50,000 in FY1983.
15. 02/10/83 Letter to Diane Dandois, NRC:0RM:DA, from Gregary J. Ogeka DOE (Brookhaven Area Office), with enclosed, signed NRC form 173.
16. 03/14/83 Memorandum to Phil Ting, NRC:NRP: DSI, from Bernard L. Grenier, _

NRC:NRR:PPAS, entitled " Transfer of Purchased Equipment From [

FIN A3392" with attached notice from DOE (Brookhaven Area Office) dated February 25,1983, regarding closecut disposition of i equiptrent, f

FOIA-84-243

17. 07/26/83 Moorandum to Jesse L. Funches, NRC:NRR:PPAS, from Sybil M.

Boyd, NRC:NRR: DSI, entitled " Request to Reprogram Funds from ST to OR and CW."

18. 07/28/83 PPAS Action Summary Sheet for A3712.
19. 08/04/83 Letter to Gregory J. Ogeka, DOE (Brookhaven Area Office), from Roger J. Mattson, NRC:NRR:DSI, entitled "BNL Technical Assistance to the Division of Systems Integration, NPR, NRC ' Safety Evaluation of Core-Melt Accidents; Operating Reactor Reviews for Indian Point and Zion' (FIN-A3712)" with enclosed NRC Form 173 to transtr't the remaining $10,000 of FY 19E2 funding for A3712.
20. 08/26/83 Letter to Diane Dandois, NRC:0RM:DA, from Gregory J. Ogeta, DOE (Brookhaven Area Office), enclosing a signed NRC Form 172.
21. 08/31/83 PPAS Action Summi 'heet for A3712.
22. 09/02/83 Letter to Gregory J. Ogeka, DOE (Brookhaven Area Office) from Roger J. Mattson, NRC:NRR:DS1, entitled "BNL Technical Assistance to the Division of Systems Integration, NRR, NRC ' Safety Evaluation of Core-Melt Accidents: Operatino Peactor Reviews for Indian Point and Zion' (FIN A3712)" with enclosed NRC Form 173 to provide $10,000 to continue project during the month of October 1983.
23. 09/02/83 Same as item 16 above, except this copy contains staff concurrences and distribution.
24. 09/14/83 Letter to Diane Dandois, NRC:0RM:DA, from Gregory J. Ogeka, DOE (Brookhaven Area Office) enclosing NRC Form 173.

25, 10/20/83 Letter to Gregory J. Ogeka, DOE (Brookhaven Area Office) from Roger J. Mattson, NRC:NRR:DSI, entitled "BNL Technical Assistance to the Division of Systems integration, NRR, NRC ' Safety Evaluation of Core-Melt Accidents: Operating Reactor Peviews for Indian Point and Zion' (FIN A3712)" with enclosed NRC Form 173 providing $80,000 to complete A3712.

26, 11/16/83 Letter to Diane B. Dandois, NRC:0RM:DA, from Gregory J. Ogeka, DOE (BrookhavenAreaOffice)withenclosed,signedNRCForm173.

l I e j

F01A-84-243 l

~ 27. Monthly Contract Management Reports " Monthly Highlights" January 1983 February 1983 March 1983 April 1983 May 1983 June 1983 ,

July 1983 August 1983 October 1983 December 1983 '

January 1984

28. Undated-NRCProposalContentandContractRequirementDescription(2pages).
29. Undated-ACRSReviewoftheZionPRA(6pages). ,

FIN-A1298 (

1. 03/09/81 Routing Slip to Jayne Ve111ette, NRC:NRR:DE, from Debra Corley, ,

NRC:NRR:PPAS, regarding A1298.

t

2. 03/12/83 Note to A. El-Bassioni, NRC:NRR: DST, from Bernard L. Grenier, NRC:NRR:PPAS, entitled " Maintaining Official Project Files for DOE Work Orders," with attached NRC Form 385, " Project File Justification."  ;

04/08/82 Letter to Raymond Romatowski, DOE (Albuquerque Operations 3.

Office) from Stephen H. Hanauer NRC:NRR: DST, entitled "Sandia Laboratories Technical Assistance to the Division of Safety L Technology, NRR, NRC ' Determination of Event Sequences Contributing to Overall Frequency of Core Melt' A1298)" with enclosed NRC Form 173 (to provide funding author zation of

$90,000tobeginwork),proposalcontent,StatementofWork,and PPAS Action Sumary Sheet for A1298.

4. 04/08/82 Same as item 3 above, except PPAS Action Sumary Sheet is different.
5. 05/06/82 Note to D. Dandois NRC: CONT, from Dennis L. Krenz, DOE (AlbuquerqueOperationsOffice),withenclosed,signedcopyof NRC Form 173.
6. 05/14/82 NRC Form 189, " Project and Budget Proposal for NRC Work," from e SNL for A1298.

t

F0!A-84-243

7. 06/30/82 Note to Stephen H. Hanauer, NRC:NRR: DST, from Dennis L. Krenz, DOE (Albuquerque Operations Office) entitled "SNLA Proposal:

Determination of Event Sequences Contribution to Overall Frequency of Core Melt (Al298-2)."

8. 08/18/82 Letter to Raymond Romatowski, DOE (Albuquerque Operations Office) from Stephen H. Hanauer, NRC:NPR: DST, entitled "Sandia Technical Assistance to the Division of Safety Technology, NRR,

" Determination of Event Sequences Contributing to Overall Frequency of Core Melt' (A-1298)" with enclosed NRC Form 173 to provide $65,000 to continue A1298.

9. 09/08/82 Memorandum to Diane Dandois, NRC:C0f T. from Dennis L. Krenz, DOE (Albuquerque Operations Office), with enclosed, signed NRC Form 173 for A1298.
10. 09/08/82 Memorandum to A. W. Synder, SNL, from Dennis L. Krenz, DOE (Albuquerque Operations Office), entitled "FY 1982 NRC Authorization:

Determination of Event Sequences Contributing to Overall Frequency of Core melt (A1298-2)".

11. 09/29/82 Note to A. El-Bassioni, NRC:NRR: DST, from Barnard L. Grenier, NRC:hRR:PPAS, entitled " Maintaining Official Project Files for DOE Work Orders."
12. 09/29/82 NRC Form 173 for A1298, transferring $10,000 from A1295 to A1298,
13. 10/14/84 Memorandum to A. W. Snyder, SUL, from Dennis L. Krenz, DOE (Albuquerque Operations Office) entitled "FY 1982 NRC Authorization: Determination of Event Sequences Contributing to Overall Frequency of Core Melt (A1298) and System Interaction Methodology Application - Phase !! (A1295)."
14. 12/04/82 Menorandum to A. El-Bassioni, NRC:NRR: DST, from Bernard L.

Grenier, NRC:NRR:PPAS, entitled "00E Work Ordtt Expiration Notice."

15. 02/01/03 Letter to Raymond G. Romatowski, DOE (Albuquerque Operations Office) from Themis P. Speis NPC:NRR: DST, entitled "Sandia Technical Assistance to the Division of Safety Technology NRR,

' Determination of Event Se ofCoreMelt'(r!NA-1296)quencesContributingtoOverallFrequency

" with enclosed NRC Form 173 transmitting

$15,000 in additional funds and modifyin9 statement of work.

16. 02/01/83 NRC Foren 173 signed by SNL.
17. 02/17/83 Memorandum to A. W. Snyder, SNL, from Dennis L. Krenz, DOE (Albuquerque Operations Office), entitled "FY 1983 NRC Authorization:

Determination of Event Sequences Contributing to Overall Frequency at Core Melt (Al298-3)".

F0!A-84-243

18. 07/07/83 Letter to Raymond G. Romatowski. DOE (Albuquerque Operations Office) from Themis P. Speis. NRC:NRR: DST, entitled "Sandia Technical Assistance to the Division of 51fety Technology, NRR,

' Determination of Event Sequences Contributing to Overall Frequency of Core Melt' (FIN A-1298)" with enclosed NRC Form 173.

19. 07/07/83 Memorandum to A. W. Snyder, SNL, from Dennis L. Krenz, DOE (Albuquerque: Operations Office), entitled "FY 1983 NRC Authorization:

Determinatior. of Event Sequences Contributing to Overall Frequency of Core Melt (A1298-3)" with enclosed, signed NRC Form 173.

20. 07/07/83 Same as item 18, except NRC Fom 173 is signed by DOE.
21. 09/19/83 NRC Forni 173 to provide $10,000 in incremental funding in accordance with Revision I dated July 1983.
22. 09/21/83 Letter to Raymond G. Ronatowski, DOE (Albuquerque Operations Office) fror Themis P. Speis. NRC:NRR: DST, entitled "Sandia Technical Assistance to the Division of Safety Technology, NRR,

' Determination of Event Sequences Contributing to Overall Frequency of Core Melt' (FIN A-1298)" with enclosed NRC Form 173 providing incremental funding of $9,000 for A-1298.

23. 09/21/83 NRC Form 173 signed by DOE.
24. 12/02/63 Memorandum to Sarah Davis, NRC:NRR: DST, from Bernard L.

Grenier, NRC:NRR:PPAS, entitled " DOE Work Order Expiration Notice." t 25, 12/27/83 Note to Contract File from Sarah Davis, NRC:NRR: DST, regarding FIN A-1298.

26. 1983 Memorandum to A. W. Snyder SNL, from Dennis L. Krenz. DOE (Albuquerque Operations Office) entitled " Transmittal of Statements of Work (Three FINS: A1296,A1298,A1302).

l l

I

F01A-84-243

27. Monthly Business Letter Reports January 1982 F(bruary 1982 April 1982 '

Juna 1982 July 1982 September 1982 October 1982 November 1982 December 1982 April 1983 May 1983 June 1983 July 1983 August 1983 September 1983 October 1983 November 1983 December 1983

28. Undated Letter to Raymond G. Romatowski, DOE (Albuquerque Operations Office)fronStephenH.Hanauer,NRC:NRR: DST, entitled *Sandia Technical Assistance to the Division of Safety Technology, NkR,

' Determination of Event Sequences Contributing to Overall Frequency of Core Melt' (A-1298) and ' System Interaction Methodology Application - Phase 11' (A-1295)" with enciased NRC Form 173 dated September 29, 1982, transferring FY 1982 funds from FIN A1295 to FIN A1296.

29. Undated Note to Bernard L. Grenier entitled " Disposition of Accountable Property / Equipment Under FIN A1298".
30. Unda tt.d " Modification to FIN A1293".

FIN A372) e l

1. 01/20/83 NRC form 367, " DOE Source Selection Justification" for A3721,
2. et al., from Bernard L.

01/24/83 Memorandum Grenier, NRC:NRR:PPAS, to Martin Hayes, entitledNRC:RES, "Revi iJ and Coordination of NRR Technical Assistance Projects" with attached Statement of Work for A3721 and concurrences from Regions 1, II, 111, IV, and V. '

l and AE00, N*,55, and RES.

3. 01/24/83 PPAS Action Sunriary Sheet for A3721.
4. 01/26/83 Letter to Gregory J. Ogeka DOE (Brookhaven Area Office) from Richard H. Vollmer, NRCINRRIDE, with enclosed Statement of Work i and Proposal Content requestin9 a proposal from BNL. i

F0!A-84-243

5. 03/02/83 NRC . Form 189. " Project and Budget Proposal for NRC Work," with attached project description (note that pages 2, 4, 6, and 8 are ,

missing from this file copy).

6. 06/13/83 Note to T. J. Carter, NRC:NRR:PPAS, from Harold Berkson, NRC:NRR:PPAS, entitled " Technical Assistance Request: NRR Ticket TSB-232."
7. 05/13/83 Memorandum to Jesse L. Funches, NRC:NRR:PPAS, from Richard H.

Vollmer, NRC:NRR:DE, entitled "kevision to DE FIN Plan" with attached, revised PIDS.

8. 03/09/83 Letter to David Schweller DOE (brookhaven Area Office), from H. C. Grahn, BNL, enclosing NRC Form 189 " Project and Budget Proposal for NRC Work," and proposed project description.
9. 05/24/83 Note to Ashok Thadant, NRC:NRR: DST, from Bernie Grenier, NRC:NRR:PPAS, requesting Thadani restew Ehl proposal for A3721.
10. 05/24/83 Note to Ed Frigillana, NRC:NRR: DE, from Bernie Grenier, NRC:NRR:PPAS, entitled " Return of Contract Action FIN A3721,"

with attached, marked up NRC Form 173 and PPAS Action Sumary Sheet for A3721 d6ted 05/24/83.

11. 06/07/83 Note to Debra Corley, NRC:hRR:PPAS, from Ed Pentacnst, NRC:NRR:DE, and response to Ed Pentacost from Debra Corley, regarding DE revisions to A3921 project.
12. 06/29/83 LettertoGregoryJ.Ogeka. DOE (brookhavenAreaOffice)from Richard H. Vollmer, NRC:NRR:DE, entitled "DNL Technical Assistance to the Division of Engineering NRR, N9C 'Probabilistic Response and Response Spectra for Category I Structures' (FIN A3721)" with attached NRC Fom 173 and Modification to Statement of Work.
13. 06/29/83 PPAS Action Sumary Sheet for A3721.

14 06/30/83 Letter to David Schweller, DOE (Brookhaven Area Office) from H.

C. Grahn, DNL, enclosing NRC Form 189, " Project and Budget Proposal for NRC Work."

15. 09/29/83 Letter to Gregory J. Ogeka, DOE (Brookhaven Area Of fice), from Richard H. Vollner, NPC:NPR:DE, entitled "BNL Technical Assistance to the Division of Engineering, RNR, NRC 'Protiabilistic Responic andResponseSpectraforCategoryIStructures'(A3721)"with enclosed hRC Form 173 and Statenont of Work Modification.
16. 09/29/83 PPAS A: tion Sumary $heet for A3721.

F01A-84-243

17. 09/30/83 Letter to Gregory J. Ogeka DOE (Brookhaven Area Office), from Bernard L. Grenier, NRC:NRR:PPAS, entitled "BNL Technical Assistance to the Division of Enginneering, NRR, NRC 'Probabilistic Response and Response Spectra for Category I Structures' (A3721) and ' Reliability and Probabilistic Assessment for Fire Events' (A3710)" with enclosing NPC Form 173.
18. 01/19/64 PPAS Action Surrary Sheet.
19. 01/23/84 Letter to Gregory J. Ogeka DOE (Brookhaven Area Office) from Richard H. Vollmer, NPC:NRR:DE, entitled "BNL Technical Assistance to the Division of Engineering, NRR, NRC 'Probabilistic Response and Response Spectra for Category I Structures' (A3721)" with enclosed NRC Form 173.
20. 02/06/84 Letter to Diane Dandois, NRC:0RM:DA, from Gregury J. Ogeka DOE (Brookhaven Area Office), enclosing a signed NPC Form 173.
21. Monthly Contract Management Reports " Monthly Highlights" July 1903 .

August 1983 September 1983 October 1983 November 198?

Decemb*r 1983 January 1984

22. Undated Letter to Gregory J. Ogeka DOC (Brookhaven Area Office) from Richard H. Vollmer, NRC:NRR:DE, entitled "BNL Technical Assistance to the Olvision of Engineering, NRR, NRC 'Probabilistic Response and Response Spectra for Category I $tructure' (FIN No. A3721)"

with enclosed Statement of Work.

j

UNION OF

' CONCERNED SCI E NTISTS im c.........i. ... A ...... u . . s. i n,i . w....i......... nc une . unam. . ,

30 Hsrch 1984 Hr. J. M. Fe1 ton, Director FREEDOM OF INFORMATION Divielon of Pules and Records Office of Administr6 tion ACT REQUEST U.S. Nuclear Begulatory Commisalon

  • Wanhington, D.C. 205$5 YM b

@ /g y ,j ,,

RE: Freedom of Information Act hequent for Documents Pertaining to NRC FIN 0-0783, A-1296, A-3726, A-3728, A-3711, A-3705, A-3706, A-8625, A-3748 A-3712 B-2526, 64-24) A-3710, A-0428, A-0446, and A-3721 (Sholly FOIA tear Mr. Felton:

Pursuant to the Freedom of Information Act, plehoe make atallable e t. the Commiasion'a Wt. n h i rig t o n , D.C., l'ublic !>ocument floom copies of documenta in the following c a t ,i g o r i c a ,

1. All documenta pertaining to the following resenroh programs aponsored by t h e: NHC with tha listed NBC FIN numbers (these requents specifically include the Form 169 reporta, applications, drnft periodic progrena reports, ntatun

,tporto, final reporte, memorandk, lettern, conference papero, and other documents pertkining to the listed programa):

FIN B-0783 ("Innights in PRA Methodology")

FIN A-1290 "tvunt avguenuta Contributing to overk11 Coro Holt Frequency")

FIN A-3726 ("Probhb111ntic Evaluntion of LCon")

r!N A-3728 ("Outdhnoo and Criterin for Ro116b111ty A11ochtion")

PlH A 3711 ("0E03AD -- ASTP0 Mathoda")

FIN A 370$ ("W A0WP, Wentinghounc Advanced I' W il " )

FIN A 3706 ("Ponch Dottom, Mark I Containment")

I'IH A 8625 ("Hitightive renturca")

Nf ) )Y -

si . ,, o, n. .

2,, o,,,,, ,, s. , ,, , . c. ,,, n. .. , . . si. .... .. .... . . mu, . m ,. n e.m

.o. -2

  • - TIN A-3748 ("M111 stone-3 and shoreham")

FIN A-3712 (" Review of IP/ Zion PRA's and IP Hearings")

FIN B-2526 (" Analysis of Containment Performance During Severe Accidents")

FIN A-3710 (" Reliability and Probabilistic Assessment -

for Fire Events")

FIN A-0428 (" Seismic Hazard Characterization of the i Eastorn U.S.")

FIN A-0448 ("Probabilistic Assessment of the Seismic Hazard for Eastern U.S. Power Plant sites"), and FIN A-3721 ("Probabilistici Response and Response '

Spectra for Category I Structures").

Should you or your staff have any questions regarding this request, please contact me at (202) 296-5600. Your cooperation in responding to this request is appreciated.

Sincerely, f 4!%Cs Steven C. Shelly Technical Research Associate l

L I

1

I .. . ..s o UNITED STATES

',, t

]5 e NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION WASHINGTON, D. C. 20SSS g04 {$

%,*****/

JUL 2 21983 MEMORANDUM FOR: Leon L. Beratan Chief Earth Sciences Branch, DHSWM FROM: Robert E. Jackson, Chief Geosciences Branch, OE

SUBJECT:

POSSIBLE ADDITIONS TO SEISMIC HAZARD CHARACTER!ZATION PROGRAM On June 14 and 15, 1983 both Jeff Kimball, seismologist, Geosciences Branch, and myself visited Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory (LLNL) to discuss the Seismic Hazard Characterization Program. As a result of this meeting Jeff has proposed that the attenuation scope of work be increased. His specific comments as a result of the treeting were sent via memorandum dated July 19, 1983 from Jeff to myself, a copy of which you received.

We are requesting that the Solsmic Hazard Characterization Project Managor, Andrew Murphy, request that LLNL send us a proposal on how they would expand the attenuation scopo of work. Attenuation is likely to be one of the most scrutinized topics within the hazard work and should be an area which LLNL delivers the best product possible. LLNL should be prepared to initiato this new work soon after we accept the updated proposal with scopo of work changes.

It is ' ur o estimate that this increase would be about .3 to .4 sy which would bo in the neighborhood of 40 to 60 thousand dollars. Presently those costs have been split equally botn en ORES and NRR. We anticipato no significant prolems in supplying at least one half of the above funds in FY 84 If ORES is unable to supply one half the additional costs, wo -

may also be able to fund this deficiency.

I am available to discuss thoso comments with you if necessary.

./ Ec fe 4 obert E. Jackson.

Goosciences Branch, Chief DivisionofEjgincoring cci J. Kimball R. Vollmer L. Reitor C. Pentecost

5. Broccum J. Knight H. Lofovro T. Sullivan A. Hurphy D. Guzy

, gg --

(Q () ( ,

b

__- w

= = = .n,. n r v.s. v:c.s4A ucuou cc e.uss cr.  ;

**'*8' DOE SOURCE SELECTION JUSTIFICATICN .

A0448 8 *" 8. Probabilistic a sessment s of the Seismic liazard for Eastern United States Nuclear Power m.. e %

. w..a .u .w. .. ., ... .

NRR. DE. GSB

s. w ht..s...s.sst... 4aa 6-f4

=an...s.. o.;; w 4ase , ,

l *

, s [/ / , . ( *. ' > ' ' ' '

i*

, _ Haro ld L te fh / .

,.a -

a re

i. w , . u.s . # a.. . .. . . . . ., ,. . , . . ...m. . ,. .. . .. . .

/ .

Lawrence Livermore' National Laboratory is uniquely qualified to perform the tasks described in this FIN. LLNL has been, and is presently involved in its*capacityasoneoftheFederalgovernmentsnationallaboratories,In developing and testing.the methodology which will be utilized to calculate the seismic hazard curves as described in this contract. Continuation of

  • LLNL's effort in the areas, directed toward NRC's goals is much more cost effective and efficient than'that'which would oth'erwise,b'e possible throu~gh-~-

individual contractors not experienced in this particular area. LLNL's role

. in the area of seismic hazard characterization is particularly unique in that the laboratory has been deeply involved in both the Systematic Evaluation Program and updating the hazard methodology through the Seismic Hazard Characterization l

Program for the Eastern United States. The current project is formulated to directly utilize the SEP/SSMRP methodology that is being updated by LLNL.

LLNL's role in developing and implementing the seismic hazard methodology cannot be easily duplicated by another organization and would not be cost effective for the government.

I -

e

/

., 'N , ." /

. .y . .

l 4

. . a . . : . . - . . . . .y ,

7 ,. g

,  ; p.,i ,

j

, f( Sob Jackson' " Chief.g'058 g J '7,s l ' ..<. n ,.. ...e.... .. .... n . .,

', ' k rd H. Vollm ,ON r D[ '

P

. \

4 4

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20127L458&oldid=3465820"