ML20127B205
| ML20127B205 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Palo Verde  |
| Issue date: | 11/10/1983 |
| From: | Chilk S NRC OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY (SECY) |
| To: | Bernabei L GOVERNMENT ACCOUNTABILITY PROJECT |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20079P594 | List:
|
| References | |
| FOIA-83-161, FOIA-83-A-9 NUDOCS 8402130007 | |
| Download: ML20127B205 (44) | |
Text
fm
~m
--,7
,.m, Y
h
%g UNITED STATES y, ! ) ),.,
CLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSIOni g g;j y
WAEHINGTON. D. C. 20555 g
pmj November 10, 1983 I
Lynne'Bernabei, Esq.
Government Accountability Project 1901 Q Street, N.W.
Washington, DC 20009
Subject:
F0IA APPEAL CONCERNING PALO VERDE INVESTIGATION (FOIA-83-161)
Dear Ms. Bernabei:
The NRC has completed action on the Government Accountability Project (GAP)'s appeal dated May 13, 1983 concerning a March 29 request under t
the Freedon of Information Act for all records related to or generated by NRC employees in the investigation of certain allegations at the Palo Verde facility. We regret the delay. As you were infonned by Ms.
Nordlinger of the NRC Office of the General Counsel.on July 8, the Office of Investigations (01) identified a large number of documents to be reviewed at the same time it was completing its investigation.
OI was of the view that when the nearly completed 01 work was forwarded, most if not all of the documents, on a list enclosed in a July 19 letter to you, could be released. The 01 investigation was extended, in part, as a response to GAP's concerns, and is now complete. Accordingly, the NRC grants your appeal for most 01 documents subject to your request but denies your appeal for documents and portions of them as indicated below and for three documents withheld from GAP in the initial response.
With regard to 01 documents, one tape and substantial portions of ten other tapes and of twenty-one documents are being withheld under Ex-emption 7A so as not to interfere with the possible referral of part of the investigation by 01 to the Justice Department.
5 U.S.C.
552(b)(7)(A), 10 CFR 9.5(a)(7). Disclosure of such sensitive informa-tion might compromise the ability or willingness of the Department to undertake its own further investigation. Moreover, at this point the public interest favors further investigation and not disclosure. The vast majority of the other investigative documents subject to your request are being released. The exceptions are noted as follows.
These records include portions of twenty-one documents from which names and personal identifiers have been deleted and two entire tapes under Exemption 7D, because the source was promised confidentiality.
5 U.S.C.
552(bi'U (D), 10 CFR 9.5(a)(7). Release of the idenM ties could curtail i
01's investigative work by showing that the NRC was unwilling to back its promises. Portions of three documents were withheld to protect names and personal identifiers of persons at Palo Verde alleged to have 3
used controlled substances.
In view of the fact that these charges were
{
}
h02.L3@?@7%LQX6 I
s
yl a
4
(.
y s
L' 2
not proved, the NRC is withholding this information under Exemption 7(C) as information that, if disclosed, would infringe personal privacy.
5
.U.S.C.-552(b)(7)(C),10CFR9.5(a)(7).
In a limited number of in-stances portions of fourteen documents.and one tape have been deleted to prevent the identities of persons alleged to have been overexposed
.from being disclosed.
The infomation is routinely withheld by the NRC.
5 U.S.C. 552-(b)(6),-(7)(C), 10 CFR 9.5(a)(6)(1), (7). Nine documents, part of a contractor employee's personnel file, and one document, a salary chart,'are also being withheld in their entirety under Exemptions 6 and 7(C).
The disclosure of the above infomation would tend to embarrass these individuals and subject them to public scrutiny on matters where there is no countervailing public interest.
The applicable exemption (s) is clearly noted in the documents where a deletion was made. Where Exemption 7D is invoked it is because those individuals became witnesses under a promise of confidentiality and their continued involvement in the investigation is important to its satisfactory completion.
Where Exemption 7C is invoked, it will be clear from the context that the information was deleted 'to avoid an invasion of personal privacy through an allegation of wrongdoing, such as use of a controlled substance. Where Exemptions 6 and 7(c), it will be clear that the information either about radiation exposure or person-nel history. The documents from which information is deleted to a
-certain extent may have portions deleted for several reasons and all. are listed in the Appendix to this letter, based on the list provided to you on July 19.
All 01 documents will be released to the Public Document Room the early part of next week. An appropriate Notice of Disclosure will be filed in the docket of GAP's pending lawsuit against NRC on this request.
~
Finally, sixteen documents are being withheld for the time being under Exemption 4 because the owners of the documents have raised concerns that they contain confidential business.information. The NRC technical staff and 01 are studying the claims under the criteria in 10 CFR 2.790(b). At this time, the NRC believes that a colorable claim has been made and the agency is not able to disclose the documents in full.
5 U.S.C. 552(b)(4), 10 CFR 9.5(a)(4).
When the NRC's action is completed, j
additional documents or portions of them may be released.
I With regard to the three documents withheld in the NRC's initial partial response, the Comission believes that the three documents should be withheld under Exemption 5.
The documents are a four page paper to the
-Comission from the Deputy General Counsel and the Director of the
- Office of Policy Evaluation (OPE), SECY-83-125, and two earlier undated r
drafts.of the paper.
In SECY-83-125, 0GC and _0PE weigh and evaluate the 5
advantages and disadvantages of alternative ways in which the Comission might approach an imediate effectiveness decision for Palo Verde, culminating in a recommendation for Comission action. The two draft
. documents also contain the above information as well as the changes,
. deletions, additions, qu'estions, and comments of the drafters and
- --~.,- - _.------ _ -- - - --, - -,-- --
3 reviewers that -led to the final document. These documents contain the advice, opinions, and recomendations of two of the principal advisors to the Comission on a pending adjudication and disclosure would tend to undermine the frank exchange of views that the Comission must expect from its advisors. The documents are sensitive predecisional comunica-tions and will be withheld.
5 U.S.C. 552(b)(5), 10 CFR 9.5(a)(5).
However, a portion of a transcript of a March 15 Comission meeting has been found relevant to your request and is being released.
~ This constitutes -final action on your appeal. Notwithstanding your pending lawsuit. I am required by law to infonn you of your right to file suit against the NRC with' regard to the partial denial of this request. 5U.S.C.552(a)(6)(ii). Given the nature of the withholding in this case and the sensitivity of the information to further prose-cution-and the rights of the individuals involved, the Comission requests GAP to reconsider whether litigation regarding this F0IA request is appropriate.
Si
- rely,
/
0%u Samuel J. Ch 1k Secretary for the Comission Appendix enclosed
C
~~
APPENDIX,A t
{.
FOIA'83-_161 i.
j l.~
Memo of Oven C. S1!ACKLETON Jr.,
Director, OI:RV, to Roger FORTUNA, Acting Deputy Director. 01:HQ, forwarding serials 1-43 of Palo Verde Case No. 5-82-011, dated January 18, 1983 (FOIA Request 82-583)
S,ummary notes of SHACKLETON listing serials given to Lou.VORDERBRUECCEN, NRC Resident Inspector, dated March 25, 1983
'3.
Memo of Oven C. SHACKLETON Jr.,
Director, OI:RV, to D. H. STERNBERG, Region V,' captioned Palo Verde -
Allegations Re:
Electrical snd Other Construction Items Made by an Anonymous Alleger. (Bechtel Senior E3cctrical Engineer), dated March 18, 1983 Memo of Owen C. SilA TON J r.,
Director, 01:
, to Lee S. DEWEY, D,' cap ed Palo Verde Nuclear (duplic,hte of Ccnc ng Station (PVNGS) -
document #45) cgati of Current Concern to the p
ASLB in 01 In tigations:
5-82-006, 5-82-009 and 5-8 11, dated March 29,1983 5.
Notes of Owen C. SHACKLETON Jr. on California DMV check on Anthony W.
LAINE, dated April 18, 1983 Documents marked with an asterisk are either being withheld in part or in their entirety.
e e
.s
'k, FOIk Exemption 6.
gotes of Jim EcKHARDT, Region V, for.his telecon with Lynne BERNABEI,
. Attorney for. Patricia Lee HOllR111AN, dated May-19 and May 21,.19S2 7.
Notes of Owen C. SHACKLETOM Jr. on
~
telecon~vith Jim CUMMINGS, Director, OIA, on' reported threat aga$nst the alleger's life, dated May. 24, 1982 8.
Notes of. oven c. SHACKLETON Jr. on meeting with Tom W. BISHOP, Region V, re. new contentions filed by the intervenoz.yith.the ASLB, dated May 25, 1982 9.
Rotes of oven c. SHACKLETON Tr. on 7 (A) telecon with the alleger, Robert D.
CUNDERSON Jr., dated May 26, 1982 10.
Notes of Oven C. SHACRLETON Jr. on second teleco'n with the alleger, Robert D. CllNDERSON Jr., dated.
May 26, 1982
^
11.
Me no of oven c. SHACKLETON Jr.,
7(D)
Region V, to Tom HISHOP, Region V, captioned,Palo Verde - Allegations re:
E3cetrical Construction Received from an Anonymous Source on May 25, 1982, dated May_27, 1982 12.
Memn of oven c. SHACKLEToH Jr.,
Region.V. to Tom BISHOP, Region V, captioned Palo Verde - Elcetr$ cal Construction Received from a Confidential Source on May 26, 1982, dated May'27,1982
.13.
HRC Document received by Region V May 26, 1982 captioned Intervenors Motion to ASLB 'for Leave to File New Contentions and for an independent Investigation e
4 S~
f.
FOIA ExeJapti"n 4
(
I4.
Jfotes of Quen C. SHACKLETON Jr.
~
on initial briefing concerning allegations on electrical instal-lations, dated }!ay 24, 1982 15.
Notes of Oven C. SHACKLETON Jr.
on te3 ccon with Jim CU)e!INGS, Director. OI A, and briefing of
. CREWS 'and BISHOP, dated 1:ay 24, 1982 16.
.iemo of william J. DIRCKS, EDO, to Thomas C. WOODS Jr.
?!ay 26, 1982 I7*
Affidavit of Robert D. CUNDERSON Jr.
~
before the ASLB, dated 11ay017,19,82 18.
Sketch of Quen C. SHACKLETON Jr.
illustrating location of GUNDERSON's home, d, ate.d June 1,.1982 I
l9-Notes of Owen C. SHACKLETON Jr. on 6,7 (C & D) '
interview of Robert D. CUNDERSON Jr.,
7 (A)
~ dated June 1, 1982 20.
Notes of Owen C. SHACKLETON Jr. on attempts ' to locate and interview Kevin BROYHILL, dated June 13 and June 14, 1982
~
21.
Resume of Robert D. CUNDERSON Jr.,
undated kN 22.
Signed sworn 'statem nt of Robert D.
6,7 (C&,D)
GUNDERSON Jr., dated June 1. 1982 23.
Notes of Owen C. SHACKLETON.Ir. on attempt to locate Kevin BROYHILL, dated June 3, 1982 24.
Hemo of Owen C. SHACKLETON Jr. to Rober't D. CUNDERSON Jr. forvarding copy of signed sworn statement, j
dated June 9, 1982 l
a g' r
- ~ ',*. '
4-i FOIA Exemptien t
25.
Hemo of Charles F. TEDFORD, Director,
to L. E. VORDERBRUECCEN, NRC Resident Inspector,' captioned Memora,ndum for e
the Record Related to Anonymous Telephone Caller Reporting Defective High Pressure System Injection (HIPSI) and Low Pressure System Injection
]
(LIPSI) at Palo Verde Nucicar Power Plant, dated March 26, 1982 26.
Memo of Lynne BERNABEI, Attorney for Patricia' Lee NOUR1HAN, to Nunzio PALLADINO, Chairman,NRC, re. new contentions submitted to ASLB and request for independent investigation, dated May -24,1982 27.
, PvNcS QC Procedure'No. 255.0 4
captioned Cable Terminations,-
' dated April 2, 1982 20*
PVNCS QC Procedure No. 255.0, 4
Revision 10, PCN No. 27, captioned Cable Terminations 29.
PVNGS QC Procedure No. 255.0, Revision 10, PCN No. 28, captioned 4,
Cable Terminations 30.
PVNGS QC Procedure No. 255.0, Revision 10, PCN No. 29, captioned 4
Cable Terminations 31.
Mcmo of Oven' C. SHACKLETON Jr.,
Acting Director, OI:RV, to Desk Officer, OI:HQ, captioned Palo Verde - Allegations Re:
Electrical and Oth,er Items, dated July 22, 1982 32.
Memo of Lee Scott DEWEY, Counsel for NRC Staff, to Robert M. LAZO'Esq.,
Chairman, ASLB, re. report concerning the NRC investigation of allegations r
made by an unnamed electrical worker, dated July 29, 1982 9
e p
N M
1" f,.
Sm
-.. ~
.*
- i g- :-
C..
f
-S-
-t
'33.
Memo of' Lee Scott DEWEY, Counsel for NRC Staf f, to Robert M. LAZO Esq.,
Chairman, ASLB, re. preparation of invest'i ative report, dated C
September 3, 1982 34.
Investigations Status Report for Case 5-82-009.'
f 35.
Pcstal check obtaining GUNDERSON's
[
address in Craig, Colorado, dated j
I e
March 8, 1983 i
- 36.,,r, pelo' Verde Intervention Fund Press Release received br OI:RV March.8, 1983
-l 37.
Af fidavits of Robert D. CUNDERSON
- f Jr..vith a'llegations 'against' PVNGS, dated May 17. 1982 a'nd January 8, 1983 38.
Affidavit of Wallace R. ROYCE i
with allegations'against PVNGS, dated. February 25, 1983 39.
Region V Inspection Report of Caston F10RELLI,'NRC Resident Inspector.'re. allegations made by. Wallace R. ROYCE, dated December 27, 1982 40.
NcEspaper article from the Scottsdale (Arizona) Daily Progress identifying Robert D. CUNDERSON Jr.,
dated March 9, 1983 1
4l*
Notes of Owen C. SHACK 1.ETON'Jr.
on postal check for Robert D.
CUNDERSON's new address in Craig, Colorado, dated March 8 1983 42.
Newspaper article from the E1* Paso Times captioned "Palo Verde Foes Release Claims of Poor Inspection,"
dated February 27,1983.
=
p.
m..-
,-~
- n. -,,,, -..,. - _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _, _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _, _ ___
, l. ~:..'. *.
. 7,
(
FOIA Examp' tion
~
?
)
'.~
6-q 43..
Newspaper article from the Albuquerque Journal captioned
" Poor -Vork Claimed of Arizona
' Nuclear Plant," dated February 27, 1983 44.
Memo of Billie CARDE, CAP, to
~
Roger FORTUNA, OI:HQ, transmitting a copy of affidavits and supporting exhibits from the former workers at the Palo Verde nuclear plants.
dated'7ebruary 28, 1983.
.j-45.4" s.
o v.
Memo of Owen C. SRACKLETON Jr.;
7 (D)
Director, OI:RV, to Lee S. DEWEY,
)..'
~
ELD, captioned Palo Verde. Nuclear
~
Generating Station (PVNCS)'-
Allegations of Current Concern to the ASLB in 01 Investigatio6s:
5-82-006, 5-82-009 and 5-82-011,
,(
,1 t
dated March 29, 1983-46.
Memo of Owen C. SHACKLETON Jr.,
Director, OI:RV,..to D. H. STERNBERG, Region V, captioned Palo Verde Special Inspections /Investiga'tions of Allegations made by' Robert D.
CUNDERSON Jr. (01 Case No.;5-82-009),
dated March 29, 1983 47.
Memo of Owen C. SHACKLETON Jr.,
Director, OI:RV, to D. H.. STERNBERC, Region V, dated March 30, 1983, captioned PVNCS - Allegations of Robert D. CUNDERSON Jr. Listed in I
his Af fidavit before t'he ASLB dated January 8, 1983 r.
48.
Hemo of Owen C. SHACKLETOW Jr.,
Director, Ol:RV, to D. M. STERNBERG, Region V, captioned PVNCS - Allegations 4
.l.
of Wallace R. ROYCE, dated March 30, j
1983 s
's 49.
Investigation Status Sheet for j
period January - March 1983 i
..:T-9 y
g
, f* ';.' ',.'. -
.?.h
m j.,*N.,W
,.N-W....,
V, r:
~
. t..
(
, ',{.
.. : e.t,,.Gr~i. 7 ...;.
?.'-
,?.;
%.e.;:...:. :
. m..
.....,2
.s g...
.,. a..
t.
,.E'I*.*"'n ?,*b.Ih ',..
,...,w.
. g,..
\\e..
.s r....
..t 2 *.'*.'.*22 5*.M.<.$*5$ t g;,.,y;
.. i 4g. g...... :
h..........
. :. g.o, a,.....-
..,.s r
..,; pj_.,,.., $.g.js j,,
. 3; g
,3, + g, y,3.,g,,ygg4q,; 3,,,
. a....,
50.-
. Investigation Status sheet for r...
period August - December 1982 51.'
Investigation Status sheet for period August - October 1982 52.
Investigation Status Sheet for
..I.
period August - November 1982
(-
53.
Notes of Owen C. SHACKLETON Jr. on "c
comparative allei,ation from the i
J,- '.'
alleger as it appears.,in,his l'
'~
May 17, 1982 54.
Telephone bill of Robert D.lCUNDERSON
~
Jr. showing his call on March 25', 1982 to Las Vegas. Nevada 55.
Notes of owen C. SHACKLETON' Jr. on i,'
. telephone contact 'with DOE of fice in Las Veg,as, Nevada; dated June. 21.
1982 56.
Notes of.Owen C. SHACKLETON Jr. on
~ comparative allegation from the alleger as it appears in his affidavit to the ASLB dated May 17, 1982
~
57.
Notes of Jim ECKHARDT, Region V, responding to the allegation re.
termi' nation cards, undated 58.t Notes of Owen C. SHACNLETON Jr. on review of 6,0C" terninstion cards, undated 4
- ~.
..=
- . s. n G
'g.
6 g
q* $ -
vg e
,...e6.s. y* i4%s.r,.. W:
+...e,., -.,. Wj
,7
.. u i ! /.7-":
r
,..fy
-1 o.
_..}
FOIA Exempticn
.-a-p:&. -li.?L.?EE isl$.6iNCM25.:.
.;;y.-. r. -y b. :. ::a.;.. ;.7 ;....i.
.a..;..,a..
,. g
.u..
~
M 424.;f:cQ :.D.if.;.:..:q.G
- G'.b;...:.. OS.;.
p 5** :*.,(
59.
-Notes of Owen C. SHARLE' TON gr. Iisting p*
four electricians who requested copies
,r'*
. of their transcripts, dated August 20, 1982
.~
y60.
., In.ter.vicv. Report of [ dan. d.i.titi.s. Withheld) 7 # ~'
f
~
7 (a) lat Pale Verar.-- (tape recorded), dated June 11, 1982 61,
Interv5e"v Report of Vincent G.
~,
- 7 ( C)...,
' ;. - r
- 8
. Electrical Instrumentation, dated
+.
s l,....:
June 15, 1982 h.'*.
p
-l 62.
- Interyicu Report of. (nane arid-title.I 7(n}..
1' w
'(
. ithheld).,
tape recorded), dated June 16, 1981 -
<.,y -
N, 63.
Interview Report of Cary 7 (A)
WALLERSTEIN, Electrician (tape
.' I recorded), dated June 16, 1982 64.
Interview Report of Philip A.
SOLLAMI, Electrician (tape
' recorded), dated June 16, 1982 i
65.
Interview Report of Torrest J.
~
HALL, Electrician, (tape recorded),
i dated June 16, 1982 66.
sample of a termination card 67.
sample of a termination card 68, samp1 of a termination card e
69.
Intervi'ev Report of Joseph H.
CRANE, Toreman-Electrician (tape recorded), dated June 17, 1982 70 Interview Report of Kenneth H.
sECER, Electrician (tape recorded),
7 dated June 17, 1982 Y.
.r.
7,..
.p
-r
.{
rorx x,,eiro p,.:
,9
~
3..j $~;c,:.jp!<W:-
.,...s :..'!.i.;
^t.-
,,;u g
,kU, ', '
71.
Interview Report of Richard B.
'Y-@.-}p,'.g,..
KEITH Jr., High Vcitage Toreman.
.If *"
- dated. June 17, 1982 r - l-72.
Interview Report of Steven J.
MOODY, Electrician (tape g g) recorded), dated June 17, 1982
- 73.
Interview Report of John Eenry 7(A)
SCHUM, Electrician (tape recorded), '
da~ted June. 17, 1982 v.
....-[..
74.
Interview Report of George A.
}l,l KENNARD, Electrician (tape recorded), dated June 17, 1982 l...
[!
- [5.
, Interview Report of Daniel Je, 7 gg)
HAST, Electrician (tape recorded),
dated ' June 17, 1982 g
76.
Interview Report of Philip A.
ACUAYO, Electrician (tape recorded),
7 (A) dated June 17, 1982
~
-Y Shackleton Notes of Owen C.
77.
Jr. on Review of Tapes dated!
7(3) 6/23/82 g 70*
Interview Report of Charles D..
LECG, Electrician (tape recorded),
7(A) dated June 28, 1982
- 79 '
Interview Report of Joe C.
SANDOVAL, Electrician-Foreman IIE)
(tape recorded), dated June 28, 1982 M.80.
Interview Report of James B.
7 y*
SWEET, Electrician (tape recorded),
dated June 28, 1982 81..
Interview Report of Hector R.
NUNEZ, Central Toreman-Electrical 7(A)
(tape recorded), dated June 29,,
1982 82.
Notes of Ouen C. SHACKLETON Jr. on 7(A) datedMarchgeofHectorR.NUNEZ, review of ta
, 1983 l
f._..p.
R n
.n
- m. j m,.-
r.-
k
,. Q,.
,10
.,..: -, ' ' (.
- I EOIA Exemption n
s t
.-, ;g
. ~......
- 4.. 2,, *..,p m
J. *;,I h..'.
83.
Interview Report of Reginald E.
},p..,,, :,i.
$k ~ '.s -
JOHNSON, Superintendent-Electrical,
%r.s. : -
[-
dated June 29, 1982 p
84.
Interview Report of Mike OSC00D, dated June 30, 1982 4
85.
Draf t transcript of interview of '
7 g)
Joe C. SANDOVAL, dated June 28, 1982 i
.K 86.
Notes of owen C. sHACKLETON Jr. on L
I review of tape and transcr!.pt of 7 (A)
Joe C. SANDOVA1., dated. 3[6/83.[.
u *..,.
.f 3
87 *
- 1*
I '
Schedule of persons interviewed re.
7(ggg) allegation concerning falsification l
.of termination cards, dated March 6,'
l 1983 4
88.
Rough draf t of tape recorded
. 7. ( A).
interview of Hector R. NUNEZ of June 29, 1982
- t., ' ',' ' t I
89.
Notes of Owen C. SHACKLETON Jr. on 7 ( AED.)
journeyman wiremen who have been interviewed, undated Y.'
90 Notes of Owen C. SHACKLETON Jr.'on questions and answers (notes) for 7 gg) interview of Nector R. NUNEZ, dated' April 5, 1983 i
91.
Note's of Eugene J. POVER on questions for Nector R. NUNEZ interview, dated ipril 5, 1983 i
.92.
Notes of Owen C. SHACKLETON Jr. on consents of Nector R. HUNEZ re. his relationship with CUNDERSON, dated l
April 7, 1983 93.
Notes of owen C. SHACKLETON Jr. on comments of Nector R. NUNEZ on his encounter with CUNDERSON at a -
manhole over terminations, dated April 7, 1983 i
l l
l
..t*,,,, ' ;
8 A
'. 3
' " ',c
.e 7
q ^,, -
,n t,
f
~
~
FOIA Exempti'n W-
...r:.T.'.;T.;;.0:.~ii..'$n'*%l...c-
. f. '
Y5hi? '.,!!. '.il *.
.. u. ".i.....,
- s.
r+ a > Q. _., r..
, s.b.... <...
=.
.r....
t
.,;..p.
.~?....,
.n.4,.
4.v.
- n..
- '.n'.PJ ~
.a.
2
.u,.....,._
. ;r a n.; a _
$ 94.
Notes of Owen C. SHACKLETON Jr. on 7 (A) 7? ? ". *
^'?"*
questions and ansvers frnin interview e
~
of Reggie JOHNSON, dated April 7, 1983
[ ',
~
95.
Copy of termination card signed off by Robert D. CUNDERSON Jr. With' "UP," dated November 13, 1981
- J."-
- i,, - '.
T-s 96.
Notes of Owen C. SHACKLETON Jr. on
-7 1
call to Pete BACI, C1 Desk Officer,
~.
... /.
on permission to use a question and
[ 7 *,*f
,3;,
' r..
answer format for signed sworn statement from Hector R. NUNEZ, dated f,7.:
April 5,1983
- f. [.' '
97.
Notes.of.0 wen C. SHACKLETON Ir. on,'
I' comments of Reggie JOHNSON re. When terminations started and when the ~ '
1,.
foreman's log book system started, d,
dated April 8,1983
, 98.
Bechtel Procedure Change Notice (PCH) No. 32 4
, 99.
Bechtel Procedure Changh Hotice (PCN) No. 33. captioned Clarifying 4
, ~ ~ ~ '
Signature of TIRs 100..
Notes of Owen C. SHACKLETON Jr. on comparative allegation from the alleger as it appears on his af fidavit before the ASLB dated May 17, 1982 1 01.
Notes of Owen C. SMACKLETON Jr. on interview of Michael H. OSCOOD, Foreman, dated June 15, 1982 102.
h es Owen
. SnACKL H Jr. on inte Icu of Vin t
. HALLEN,
(duplicato of' Le evel II EQctrical document 161) stallati dj ed June 15, 1982 c
db
- 3. g.
" c+Rn;yy.. c W a p.y;y c'. : _
~.x. 97 ;..;. m i
FOIA. Esem'p'tirn -
. -(,.
.n(.
.i.
^
..s Kg!qgs).=.V%w.1Mb;:&wc"uW. n 4
- : v un : e. "_ : *.. : pw #n......d..
' ?ifl.VWG,;u..
W 'v ' i ::
9.M.YnM. r.
..s, ?:.*;.
- r
..-:.4..42-d c
- v.r.. eq~;., g.n..,y?
- w.:
..e,A p/M
.w.,
..5 9. :. '. *.d.,., ; 3...
103.
Interview Report of Michael B.
.s..: F '. ' 'i COLDBERG, Senior Construct' ion
,..,.. ~. :
. [.*
Engineer, dated June 28, 1982
'/,.f -
('.
y104.
Notes of Owen C. SHACKLETON Jr. on 7 (C)
",i notes of interview of Robert D.
CUNDERSON Jr., dated July 19, 1982
'.'j,,
. ' _ ".. 5 105.
Notes of Owen C. SHACKLETON Jr.
' s. :,..l taken during valk-thru with CUNDERSON l
v.*.,..1;. (
.at PVNCS, dated October 23, 1982
..-j i-
.. ; *i. *-
l yy;...h:"\\-),.
- ?,
106.
Hemo of Lou VORDERBRUECCEN. NRC.'
- '"d,,.:
~~,.:,,.~.. y. -
Resident Inspector, PVNCS, to Owen C.
i
- . i." *.
SHACKLETON Jr., forwarding page 3 e!
c*
S pec. 13-D1-306
-g.
107.
Spee. 13-n!-306, Installation 4
2 Specification for Cable Splicing, Termination and Supports for the 2,;
d Cable Splicing, Termination and Supports for APS for Units 1, 2 and 3, Quality Class Q and R 108.
Notes of Owen C. SHACKLETON Jr. on
~
second interview of Michael N.
OSC00D, Foreman, dated March 8,'1983 109.
Notes of Owen C. SHACKLE 70H Jr. on subject allegation, dated March 8 1983 110.
Notes of Owen C. SHACKLETON Jr. on subject allegation, dated March 9, 1983 111.
Sample Cable Installation Card and Cable Inspection Record 11 2.
Sample Cable Installation Card and Cable Inspection Record 113.
Sample Cable Installation Card and Cable Inspection Record 114.
sample Cable Installation Card and Cable Inspection Record 9
M a
s u
i. y ;.).Q5 *l'.17b :T % W.V':? %. ** i::.'" M.* 2 ^ "..
9 ' '". :P t^.,% i. y :. '
-(_
g
. >... - ~.
t.
.s Q./..Aj.e.;5.Y:. t.: * '-
,.,,.y;.,r.:f p.13.y.)...,.,.. l{.a.; :.',;.
...;,' n..a g, r.,:.:}lj.g,.., -
5: a.. '
3
- 70 -7tT.,A.,-
FOIA Exemotioir... [N
s i.-
}/.,7 f IIS.
PVNGS Monconformance Report I ('f.?.
/g f
No. EJ-1402, dated September 9,1981
- c; -
g.i'.7,
..y -.
p 116.
PVNCS Nonconformance Report
' c; No. EJ-477, dated May
. 20, 1980
.i 117.
NotesofOwen).SHACKLETONJr.on 9.'
,]-
chronology of cable repair, dated 4-March 30,-1983-
- }
s
..f ' g, ; ;
118.
unsigned sworn statement of Michael
- ' ' ' ( :.'.' '
N, OSC00r, undated.
>.e..: :. e..... -
? **,
... ) i s 119.
Notes of Lou VORDERBRUECCEN., N'RC
..T. " -
t'.
'.:.g i Resident Inspector, concerning
, start-up. problems., dated June 16, 1982 s
~
- 120, Notes of Owen,C. SHACXl.ETON'Jr..on start-up a.11egation on information received from Larry SOUZA, QA o
Engineer for APS, dated July 15, 1982 6
1 21.
Start-up Admin. Procedure for 4
Temporary Modification Contr61s, dated December 17, 1981 122.
PVNGS Procedure No. 90CA-0ZZ11, PVNGS Manual, dated May 10, 1982 123.
NCR No. EA' 1937 for Cable Determinations, dated March 19, 1982 1 24.
NCR No. EA 1723 for Cable Determinations, dated January 11, 1982
'l25.
Notes of Owen c. SnACX1.ETON Jr. en Start-up operations - source for info., Bill Mcl.ANE, for electrical workers, dated August 5, 1982 g
o e
i l...:
Q.
I h,,sg.
I 6
e" h
.g g
.-._g e
g 4
g
v..
.. cs -
3
.. ~
... o
.z
,y t
~ ~...,,
2 C,+
.(
~.
n s
lly*;.5f.d.;/.?:",?.7.t'.2.a""s
'Y.9.."'% 2 - ~ f * ' ~' -
-, 9.....
- g..o..te r.
.:. :. e :.....
a...
.s.
@!I.?l.E* '
126.
Notes of oven C. SHACKLETON Jr. on i'.~ f * ' '" '.' '
interview of William E. CRAIC,
' ~
Start-up QC Supervisor, APS, dated August 5, 1982 127.
Notes of Owen C. SHACKLETON Jr. on comparative allegation from the l
alleger as it appeared in the
.,g..
affidavit to ASLB dated May 17, 1982
~. -
128.
Notes of John ELIN, Region V,
.i.
i j.
7 '. '. Ig y'.'
on improp'er insulation materials whid were used on high voltage
,,,,'g/j{;?..
termi ncions.on certain. class. of
- s,'... q a
,... s
. q,.p moto.s, undated
... ~
129.'
', Telex from Bechtel re. Scotch -
2200 Vinyl Mastic dat'ed June 28, 1982 130.
Notes of Owen C. SHACKLETO?i Jr. on comparative allegation from the ~
alleger in his af fidavit-to th'e ASLB dated May 17, 1982 I
1 31.
Nonconfoimance Report in'itiated by B'ROYHILL referring to improper lug installation, dated November *3, 1981 132.
Note referring to NCR written by BROYHILL, dated July 14, 1982 133.
Notes of Owen C. SHACKLETON Jr. re.
info.' sheet on AMP products from Andy ANDERSON, endete4.
7/j4 7
g S
n s
t 9
g me g
g
}~ UW
$ W ~ 7
. ]."
a ^ 'i 1
- r. J.:
=
,,(.
.s ;
,, 2..
e
,g s.
it: '., ; _.:. *i.,,
.,f
. }$
,,,,h
[.,. IN U t
5.2.'*k. *f.-}*.30'YO.h.<,f..,*'*.'
h.+.5,.../....k
.N.+ b.i. (..
Y.,,.t
- 7..,.. $.. T. 5.l ;a' :$W4 :*#
~
c
.., 3.
i.e..,<
.- c FOIA Exemption e
134.
Memo of William M. E1 STER.
Production Manager, AMP Special a
Indusitries, to Oven C. SHACKLETON Jr..~
t-
.[.. '. -
OI:RV, captioned AMF Terminal p,., j 7 Markings, dated September-23, 1982 J )...,,.,,.'
'g. )
135.-
Region V Daily Report dated
'l August 20, 1982 vith info. on improperly crimped " amp" termination j.
~
,.9.;
lugs on Unit 2 PVNCS
- 7. *.
- 1
,. [..,;..
136.
Notes of Owen C. SMACKLETON Jr. on
- ' :.[ *-
W.T, /l,' #
EISTER, Production Manager, AMP
' telephone call from William M.
,',",.(:..
- lt
.'Special Industries, dated 0-
.i September 23, 1981 s;
137..
Notes of* John BVRDOIN, Region V, f.
to Owen C. SMACKLETON Jr. re. subject l,..
allegation received by 01:RV J.uly 21, 1982..
f.
138.
Notes of Owen C. SHACKLETON Jr. on comparative allegation from th's a13eger as it appeared in his
Interview Report of Russell A.
REMFELD, Electrical Quality Control Engineer, tevel II, dated June 30, 1982 140.
Interview Report of William R.
BURDICK, QC Engineer, Level II, dated July 1, 1982 I
141.
QC Record of Merit Raises and FR Due' Dates, dated July 14, 1982 6, 7 (C) s 142.
List of Bechtel QC Engineers assigned to Instrumentation and Electrical, dated July 14, 1982 e
- . 4 3
~
% ;
- i{,6 '.
W.
g,,
=^
.~
g r
s' b. -..
(
,~
~
v b.9,'s,.,,
- ;...~ h..*N.',
- .T5'..# h : :,- *(h,,-[..',.,,,*.2.*.,.'.-
? ' [*..
,g I
FOIA Exemptioff' *-
,..,...,t.--
.- s b : " '-
143.
Interview Report of Robert C.
,,i'.
... I' ' -
.. ~ ~ ' '.
';*~
Electrical-Instrumentation, dated July 15, 1982 j,
t g.* **
144.
Interview Report of Robert C.
RUFF Jr., Electrical Field
..,. - 'y *-
Engineer, dated July 15, 1982 I45.
Interview Report of Clinton H.
..h
~,
ANDERSON Jr., Construction
,, !.,.i
.7-
.;%j.%,i,,'
Engineer Electrical, dated
..t.
,,.$.- l.,-
July 15, 1982 v.
..f ~.j y
.a
.y..
34g*
,, Notes of John BURDOIN,, Region V,;
' i. W on subject, allegation, received by 01:RV July 23, 1982 147.
Notes o'i John EL1H, Region V, on specs. from Anaconda Copper on
. high potential te, sting"of,their cables, undated
- 148.
Bechtel Insulation Resistance and Hi-Pot Testing Procedure No.
4 256.0,Tev.5,datedJune2[1982
- 149.
PVNGS Instilation Resistance and Hi-Pot Tcsting - Appendix 256.0, 4
undated 150.
Notes of Owen C. snACM.ETON 'Jr.' on info. provided by Steve PCNICK on this allegation, dated July 15, 1982 j
- 1 51.
Procedure 13-AM-20,8 re. ilo'ist'ure 4
Seals for Electrical Cabinets, undated e
e e
s I.
O 8,
b-
. F'.
.. W.:
V
"*~
- 1. 6 v
.(
.r
.. c...
- il -
q......,,., -
p.FOIA Ex'e'mption' "*'.
s.
~ ~ " '
152.
Electrical Cabinet Moisture Seal 4
Schedule, undated 153.
Electriesi Cabinet Moisture Seal 4
Schedule, undated
~
- 154.
Electrical Cabinet Moisture Seal 4
Schedule, undated
- 155.
APS Purchase Order No.
10407-13-EM-009, undated 4
~
156.
Notes of Owen C..SHACKLETON Jr. on N.
J-
.g, alleger's identification of two men who tried' to patch the conduit',-
dated June 1, 1982' 3
157.
Inter. view Report of of Michael 3.
COLDBERG, Senior Construction En~gineer,' dated June' 28, 1982 158.
Interview Report of Louis (NHN)
~.
WILLIAMS Jr., Engineer-Construction Release Orga'nization, dated June 28 1982 s
159.
Interview Report of Robert J. LENTS, Ele'etrician,' dated July 1, 1982 160.
Interview Report of Richard A.
DEAK1HS, QCI, E1cetrical, Level II, dated July 1, 1982 a
161.
Notes of Owen C. SHACKLETON Jr. on info.. developed on Hike AUSWALD, Robert J. LENTS aka "KINCTISH,"
Thurlow 0. STUART, and Bill WILLIAMS, dated July 1, 1982 162.
Notes of oven C. SHACKLETON Jr.
concerning' payroll info on Th'urlov
- 0. STUART, dated July 1, 1982,
e e
i
\\
'b
\\ d.-
ic
.. /..
l
- a.G
> & :..r.v.~.; i n s..Tr.. %..
e m.: +...u -
. w....
j*. *-
-?.
f
,?
s
- 18.
~
. :. 5. :
.. ?,~* : f.,4.. : % 'g..ft. n.;-
....., ' _ ~.
.. ' ~ '.
,,.. ~ ;.,.. g. '
-[ * -
=
.....:.,.. a..
. n n....'
... ~...i.... ' \\ ';g 9...-
.... 3,!
,:p
.z.... a.... -
.::.1::
L <.y.':3 3. :
~
163.
Notes of Owen C. SHACKLETON Jr. on
~
.~
telephone contact with Concrete Coring Inc., Phoenix, Arizona,
~
dated July 1, 1982 164.
Notes of Owen C. SHACKLETON Jr. on telephone call to Harlan FREDERICKS, dated July 1, 1982 165.
Notes of Owen C. SHACN1.ETON Jr. on
~.
telephone call to Bob RICH re.
Mike AUSWELD, dated July 1,19,82
..7..
166.
Interview Report of James Walter j,'.*
}!ichael OSWALD, Electrician, dated
,,. j,
July 2, 1982 s
167. -
Interview Report of Jack E. VISE,-
General Foreman, Electrical, dated July '2,1982 168.
Interview Report of Norman J. '
DOEBLER; Ceneral Foreman, Electrical, dated July 2, 1982 169.
Notes 'of Oven C. SHACKLETON Jr. on discussion with H. Paul'BECKER, Group Leader', Civil Discipline.
Bechtel, dated July 2, 1982 170.
Notes of oven C. SHACKLETON Jr. on info. from Jack E. VISE on Don HOLLY's telecon with FREDERICrdi over Robert LENTS quitting on July 2,1982, dated July 2,19,82 171.
Notes of owen C. SHACRI.ETON Jr. on address and telephone number for the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers Local 640, dated July 2, 1982 172.
Notes of owen C. SHACKLETON Jr.' on recontact with H. Paul BECKER, supra, serial 14, dated July 13, 1982
".b.
4 8
g I e
- o
- ~.
.:. a 1.
+-
- { ** * *. Q.
. {'.
- 2. **'.'
- t -?
. M
I ~".$.'*:.:$%t.','&~.?;r ~.'. E 'n '
b
- s,.
- ~
,.N...
, ~.
. - (.-
19. '
.. t.
..2.. ;.- ~... :.
?....p-
.s..
,;;,... v..:, :..
,.c. L '.\\.
173.
Cable Pulling Work Sheet with NCR i
~..
attached, dated September 22, 1981
. ~ '
l;..; *
-174.
6 Cable Pulling Work Sheet with NCR attached, dated September 22, 1.981
- 175, of Oven HACKL.
- r. on (duplicate of i
e iew of o
rt D.
ERSON Jr.,
document #104).'
ted July
',.19 2 176.
NCR No. EC-1304 for cutting of conduit during core drilling.
. ; i !...'i-dated August 4, 1981
' r*.. * -.':,.
l.
'.'s..".'
177.
Notes of Owen C. SHACKLETON Jr. on
- ^
l :,
- telecon with local 640 concerning Coleman V. SMITH, dated August 2,,
1982 et 178 Notes of Owen C. SHACKLETON Jr.. on informants change'of location of damaged conduit, dated August 3, 1982 179.
SHACK 1.ETON's sketch of NE corners of varp around area,of the Auxili,ary Building, Unit 1, listing of six 4" conduit nos. coming out of the. val.1,. and list of numbers of imbeds joined to the externa),
conduits, dated. August 3, 1982 180.
No'tes o'f' oven' C. SHACxtET0x Jr. on Coleman V. SMITH (" Buck" SMITH), ~
CT-Electrical Unit 1, dated August 3, 1982 181.
Notes of owen C. SHACKLETCH Jr. on invesfigation into core drilling allegation, dated August 3, 1982 182.
Notes of Owen C. SHACKLETON Jr. on review of Racevay Installation Cards, dated August 4, 1982
- 183, Notes of Owen C. SMACKLETON Jr. on review of Core Drilling Records for MS$5 and Auxiliary Building, dated August 4. 1982
. ~ * -
t *.j's a4 i
....~n y:.3
...::.- 7;..yy3;
.v., q:.,.,; y 9 q.,g. 3 - g g,. y
. r
. - t.
, gat:.. -
4.
p=.
7
- .:. g..
(
g
. ;. r '
r.
,;.... gg _.
e...
- z...
1." ,."h*'
184.
. [VNCS - Request No.1E-105, dated I
. September 26, 1980 e
185.
Notes of Owen C. SHACKLETON Jr. on
's
... l sketches of NE aree at vraP-around area of the Auxiliary Building,
[
dated August 4, 1982
". }
186.,
Notes of Owen C. SHACKLETON Jr. on l
comments of Dick HA)!ELIN, Field i
Engineer for Bechtel on HSSS Building, dated August 4,*1982,
1.
- %{ ',
'.' l.
187.
Notes of Owen C. SHACKLETON Jr. on
.. N".
additional comments'made by f *.. -
g-
[..,'l*****..
HAMELIN, Field Engineer for.;.
'J
),
'. Bechtel, dated August 4, 1982 l
188 Notes and records obtained by Lou
," - [.~
~
VORDERBRUECGDI, NRC Resident Inspe.ctor, on the concrete placement for the commonvall between Auxiliary Building and MSSS, Unit 1, dated E;
3 August 4, 1982
{
t 189.
Comments of, Buck SHITH on his findings on. Jerry STEWART (ph) and 3.111 WILLI AMS, da t ed August 4,'1982 190.
Notes of Owen C. SHACKLETON Jr. on developing sources for STEWART and WILLIAMS, dated August 4, 1982 191.
Memo to File 5-82-00'9 from Ouen C.
SHACKLETON Jr. captioned Review of r*
Personnel Files to Identif.y and Locate Jerry STEWART and Bill WILLIAMS, dated August 5. 1982 192.
Notes of Owen C. SHACKLETON Jr. on interview of Mark ALEXANDER, Assistant Lead Discipline Field Engineer, Bechtel, re. core d' rilling i
of Unit 1, dat.ed August 4, 1982 e
g
'g S
a
7 ,%.] ' * ].*.Q," 7 3.
J.[t( < -
.! T l.,a
,v"T,.,g *...c,
@ *),, [.
., :.,i
(
",U ",
= ',
- 7... &.. '. -;.i.,..?. T N :* *.- *.:.. :.-::~ i. ' * :' ' ;.
' ' ~
,.,x r
[
t' 193.
- Notes of Owen C. SHACK 1.ETON Jr. on review of Race Way Installation Cards, dated August.3, 1982 194.
Notes of Owen C. SMACK 1.ETON Jr. on i'
interview by telecon with Robert CUNDERSON re. c' ore drilling and 20/20, dated August 25, 1982 195 Notes of Owen C. SHACK 1.ETON Jr.*.on attempts to locate parties to th's.
core drilling / damaged conduit
{..,.
allegation, dated August-26, -19,82
~
v.
196.
Notes of Owen C. SMACKI.ETON Jr. on
/*,..
.,,. 5 interview of Bill RODGERS, Welder /
- ~-
Electrician, dated August 26..[1982 g
t 197..
Diagram of Unit 1 showing area where c'or'e drilling took placer.
undated 198 Three photos taken of 100' elevation in the Wrap-Around area of Auxiliary Building at the NE corner,. Bldg.J1, undated
~
199.
Notes of Owen C. SMACK 1ETON Jr. on interview of Rodger B. RAMOS re.
core drilling in Unit 1, dated August 5, 1982 200.
Notes of Owen C. SHACK 1.ETON Jr.
taken during walk-thru with CUNDERSON at PVNCS, dated October 23, 1982 201.
Notes of Owen C. SMACKL.ETON Jr. on inspection notes of Auxiliary Building, MS$5, Control Building -
Unit I with Larry SOUZA, QA, APS, dated October 25, 1982 202.
Notes of Owen C. SHACK 1.ETON Jr. on comments of Faul BECKER, Croup Lead, Civil Engineer, Bechtel, X2286 on his knowledge of core
?
l e
O~
$. i.
- e e
O g
r~..
'E N.- (.'- M. -
(. v
- . i.'.;,E
- 2
?. ?
Y "T.
.T -
- 3. -
- R
,2
\\
22,-
...j..
u.
. 4,:
1,.
..m.t z.".?
.g
-- - c-FOIA Exentbtion x
drilling into conduit in'the Auxiliary Building with NCR.
example, dated October 25, 1982 203.
Notes of Owen C. SHACKLETON Jr. on review of termination records for Hi-Voltage termination in
. ' n.'
termination boxes.lENANZ440 and.
1ENANZ450 with attachments (2),
dated October 26, 1982 s
204.
Memo to rile 5-82-009 from Owen C.
SHACKLETON Jr. captioned Physical
.,,, f.f.p.,(*
Inspect' ion of Two Suspected-
/
. '. y ^.
Conduits fo'r Damage from Core
' " ~ 7 '.J.e
~
(.
Drilling, dated' October 27,'1982
.i:
.p.
s..
205.
Memo to File 5-82-009 from Owe'n C.
?
SHACKLETON'Jr. re. r'esults'of* ' f interview of H. Paul BECKER, Croup 4
b,.
Leader, Civil Discipline, Bechtel, showing no core drilling was ever done through the subject wall; dated October, 27, 1982,
206.
Memo to rile 5-82'-009 from Owen C.
SHACKLETON Jr. captioned Documenta-tion of Repair to Damaged Condu'it, dated October 27, 1982 with attachments (13) 207.
Prin. tout identifying the conduit that was damaged by core drilling, dated October 27,, 1982 208.
Sketch of SHACKLETON sh'owing subject conduit run, undated 209.
Ndes of Owen C. SHACKI.ETON Jr. on interview of Dale E. HORNER, Supt.
Electrical, and Eilt T. ERDMNN, Journeyman Elec., dated October 27.-
1982 210.
Notes of Oeen C. SuCKLETON Jr. on the actual examination by bore scope of the two conduits that were suspect, dated October 26, 1982 2
e
p.
- . q ? m p v q T e r 7 p -
t m,.y e.. m~..:.1
+.
o
.. p r..~....-
y.
,.n. g3 yL.G;g. = y., %.VW n ' *.ip.,:.;;;. :b :....,S'::-% n--.
.+
- ...* -?.....4. :y;a.. -
}..'4)r
,a,., '....,.:
.?..
' Thr
=
211.
Interview Repo. of John T. HANZE, c
f
~
Level-II QC Enginer, dated J'ly 1, u
1982
?
212.
- one photo of subject conduits'in Wrap Around Building (Auxiliary Building) 10.0' Elevation, Unit 1,
~
PVNCS, dated March 9, 1983
,f 21 3.
Bechtel Drawing No. 13-E-ZCC-015, Rev. 18, of the Hain Steam Support Structure Conduit and Tray Plan at Elevation 81 ft. and,100 ft.,
dated March 10, 1983 214*
N.otes of Ow'en C.,SHACKLETON'Jr. on,
~
l.
~.
core drilling with list of-leads to follow, dated'Harch 9 'nd 10, 1983 a
215 Notes of John ELIN, Region V, on
~
, findingsloh the', splicing of smaller cables to f3ela run cables, undated 216.
Notes of Ouei C. SnAcKLETON Jr. on comments of Jim ECKHARDT, Region V, that several 50.,55(e) reports iere submitted on the pancis, dated May 27, 1982 -
217.
Memo of w. C. BINcHAM, BPC, to
'W. J. STUBBLEFIELD, BPC, re. ANPP Job 10407 Electrical Separation in Main Control Board, dated March 23, 1982 Il0' Hemo of K. KOPANS, Project Manager, Consip Inc., to W. C. BINCHAM, Bechtel Power Corporation, re. Bechtel 1
Deficiency. Evaluation Report No. 81-53, Rev. 0 (Bechtel NCR Nos. 1668 and 1669), dated, March 24, 1982 1
e
?..
8 O
M h,*
g e
o,
s.
.s - 4'.-;..;.N.+'. 3 ; :,).
,4 %. - y.',2.*
],
y.
.t-
.s e
- .u
.e m
, ~.
L
- 24
- ? '.:'
e,.a.. :. =..>v. c : ?:. x.>. W. M.. a..:s u
.e.......:...n.....;.k;m.:Gu%a s.:-
- i. >....,.,......
~
wM;..w.v:
.i..
.u m; y.. ;e. c..,..:-
x s. r.*... :..
.w.
m,..;. v.
. %.9.:gf....g.
t.,.: <, :. 5 -
.s.y....-
..W j,.3. ?
219.
Memo of E. E. VAN BRUNT Jr,,
.. y;v>.. j.;
APS, to T. W. BIS 110P, NRC RV, re. Final Report - DER 81-53, a 50.55(e) Reportable Condition Relating to Unit 1 Main Control Panel (JM-200) Violates Wiring
. Separation Require.ments, dated' May,24, 1982 220..
Memo of E. E. VAN BRUNT Jr...
APS, to.T. W. BISHOP, NRC.RV, captioned Time Ex. tension fok; Report - DER 81-51 a 50.55(e)
PoteEtially Reportable
.'l
. Deficiency Relating to Unit'l Diesel Generator Cont'rol Cab,inetti Wiring not Separated Between:.
Class 1E and Non-Class IE, dated May 24,,.1982, 221.
Memo of Charies F. Tedford to L. E. VORDERBRUECGEN, NRC Itesident Inspector, captioned Memorandum for the Record Related to Anonymous Telephone Caller,
~
Reportitig Defective High Press,ure Syste,m.Irijection (111 PSI) and Low Pressure S'ysit'em Infection (LIPSI) at Palo Verde Nuc1 car Power P1, ant..
dated Mar,ch 26,'1982 222.
Mem'o.of Leon E. BROWN, PvNcS, to
~
Charles F. TEDFORD, APS, re..
potential problems with the Unit l HPSI and LPSI. pumps, dated April 14, 1982 223.
Bechtel Deficiency Evaluation Report (10 CFR 50.55(e)) - Main Control Panel wiring is installed in violation of IEEE 384-1974, dated December 17, 1981 I
I i
is e,
,%b e
y
...o,.e.
... e,v r... e:....
a.,.,....gs,...,.,...-.c m...,...,7 7 ;.... x
.....s.,
...a u.
m
...;..... t
.; 7 o 7,, _:
p, 7..
.. - m-
.g
- t
- J-FOIA Exemption i
~
s.'.'..
i@.5 %%;ihUi:hid.:}ha '*'$:@.$.2 9.l+? ??? M. :W..:;$*,.?.::a. -.$..;::..e-?..'
ad.9;...-X.;;..l')
.eh:4. ;:;1t' e?.C t.*.':" ;*.:."..V. p. s.'., ;;-ps n.. *W..*s,.. *. 4.. w /i:r.;. yr-
- "Lh.d *.UJ'JJJ%\\ ** * **.=.s1 D* N ;....n...,..~ - y. s
.O< :.x.d,*...vn,.,:);i..
. t *...* t d M*.-...
s s
- f
( ". -
o... #
.. v. --
s ' M'- *."..u -1..:..w...bW a.
. * *.h* %:.(s.. y
.i ",tly.
.d. ' S a,
4,s,pr :.s
=.. *;
224.
Notes of oven C. SHACKLETON Jr. on
~ ' ' '
comparative allegation from the alleger as -it appeared in his
~-
af fidavit to the ASI.B dated May 17, 1982 225,.
Electt>de Clas ifications from the American Velding Society, undated g 226. '
so'tes or oe,n c7SP.ACK1.ETON Jr. on "
~
discussion vith Frank WENSI.AWSKI, V(D)
~
i KV.,. on' exposures',,of (names w[tl)hil.d.)]
, dated June 3/1982 '
~
y
........-.j
.. ~
227.,
hoftes of oven c. SH.Acx1.ETON. Jr. on
. ' how to contact (names withhe.ld)'at 6,7 (C&D)
' HTS, dated June 9,1982
~
1 y 228..
Notes of Ouen C. SHACKLETON Jr. en 6,7 (C&D) hoV to contact (cames withheld)-
f a.t NTS, dated Ju.ne 9. 1982.,._
229.
Notes of Oven C. SHACKLETON Jr. on' i,7 (C&D) how to ' contact (names withhe.T..d,)'at. '...Y -
NTS, dated June 9, 1982
/~
~
of (name withheld)_.
k230.
Interviev Report at'NTS., dated June 11, 1982 k231*
Ecmo.of 00en c. SHACK 1. ETOH Jr.,
I 7.egion V, to (name withheld) 9 6,7 (c),
transmitting documents, borrowed.
j 7 (D)
~'
from him re. his radiation exposure, dated June 25, 1982 N 32.
~
2 Notes on meeting with Frank A.
VENSLAWSKI, Chief', Reactor 6,7 (C),
i Radiation Pro,tection Section, 7(D)
I i
j 1
g..
n
.,q.,
- c. - w.
., w..-.
. ~ -
a c
w
. C. -
.' 26 -
N)
~
g
FOIA Exanptio.n.
.=
s;.
1,.
s Narry S. NORTH, Radiation Specialist, and Ouen C. SHACK 1.ETON Jr., Senior Investigator, on appraisal of radiation exposure of (name withheld)., dated June 25,
$982' 23hO N'otes of 6uen c. SkACKI.ETON Jr. on e.
I interview of Sus YOSH1HOTO,
~
Forer.an-Electrical,'da'ted J'uly 13, 1982 v
s 534
, Interview Report of Rapnond W.
~
'f00D, Superintendent-Electrical, hechtel V'it 2, dated July 13, 198,2 n
~
- 235,
' Notes 'of Oueri C.. SHACK 1.ETON Jr. on meeting with Donald B. FASNACHI, Nuclear, Construction Mana'ger',':APS, '
re. narcot.ics use on - si'te.: dated 2
June 16,,1982 23Es' of Owen C. SHAC ON Jr. on
..i te. Lev..of
. ert C..ND KSON, (duplicate of
. document flp4) 7-'
". ste'd Jdly
..1 2,.
7(C)
- ~
/^ 237, Notes of Owen C..SHACEETON Jr. on.
~ iriformant's comme' pts on doye -
~
useage at PVNGS to be given 'to Donald B. FASNACHT, Nuclear Construction Manager, APS, dated August' 2, 1982.. ' ~
~
23Gk N tes of Owen C. SHACK 1.
N Jr. on
[.,
wal thru vit UNDER of Unit 1 (duplicate'of a
.S, da 0.cto er 198'2 document.#200) g t.
t1..
t
~
g
' ~
i e
4*
I.
()
__.. =,. _ _
m 27 (1
(~
239*
Notes of Owen C. SRACKLETON Jr. on Auxiliary Juilding, MSSS, Control Building,t! nit 1, with Larry S30ZA, QA,2 : APJ, dated October 25, 1981
- i, i.-
24Q.
Notes of Owen C. SHACKLETON Jr. on subj,ect allegation, dated March 8.,
.1983.
)
- 241.
Note's of Owen C. SEACKLETON Jr. on subject allegation, dated March 23,
-1983 242.
Five photographs of three conduits and:their terminations at PVNGS,'
tak(nMarch8,1983 243.
No'tes of Owen C. SHACKLETON Jr2 on comparative allegation from ths alleger as it appeared in his affidavit to the ASLB dated.,
May-17, 1982 244*
. Notes of Owen. C. SEACI5.ETON Jr. on
, APS. purchase order with Raychem corporation,' PO No.10407-lf-Di-1063,
~
r.
~
, Revision'3; dated February 1,1983 (purchase order attached),.dat.ed November 17, 1981)-
245 Notes of Owen C. SHACKLETON Jr.':on comparative allegation from the alleger as it appeared in his affidavit to the ASLB dated May 17.-1982 e
s g
E J
~.
_. :p.
(
r -
.7 3.
246.
Interven' r'fHotion For Leave To File New Contentions o
1; .
And For,Iridspendent Investigation, In The Matter Of
~: '
~
Arizona.Public. Service dated May 26, 1982.
247.
Construct'isin. Inspection. Planning For Concrete Preplacement Job Ho. :10407. dated 12-4-79.
-s
.248.
SECY-83 '65? ! Subject-December 28,1982 ASLB Initial Decision
, J.1 Relatedlto Palo Verde Nuclear Generating Station, Units,1, 2 and'3.
jd.'-
s.
249.
Palo Verde Summary, undated.
- g. j..
25_0.
Summary;of.01 Investigati~ons, undated.-
j c _-
t 2 51.
HandwritteEnotes ref:. Original Electricai Contention.
252.
Handwritten note: ref:
Pslo Verde.
'253.
Memo for Sa'muel Chilk from William Dircks ref:
Staff. Requirements Discussion /possible Vote on Contested, Issues in'Palo Verde Full Power Proce~eding, dated 3-29-83.
254.. Memo for Simuel Chilk-from Ben Hayes ref:
Staff Requirements Discussion /Possible' Vote on Contested Issues in Palo Verde full Power Pr.oceeding,10:00 a.m., Ivesday, March 15, 1983,
- Commissioners' Conferenc,e Room, D.C.. Office-(Closed,--EX.10) dated 3-25-83..
255.
Letter to Roger Fortuna.frcrn Billie Garde, Louis Clark, Lynn
'Bernabei, and Thomas Devine of GAP, d'ated 2-28-83, Letter to Nunzio Palladino from T. Woods, Arizona Public 256.
Service Company, dated 5-11-82.
29
[~,
~
257.
- Rough notes of SHACKLETON dade during the one telephone call by the anonymous alleger to SHACKLETON's residence on 5/25/82
~
s 258.
SHACKLETON's Summa'ry of Investigation setting forth information developed as of 6/23/82 259.
' SHACKLETON's Summary of Investigation setting forth information developed as of'6/25/82 260.
SHACKLETON's notes on attempt to locate and interview Anothony W. LAINE Postal check on Anthony W. LAINE in 261.
Phoenix, Arizona on.7/2/82 262.-
SHACKLETON's memo to Desk Officer on the case status a
9 9
e
SHACKLETON's notes an investigation to
~
263..
locate and irtterview Anthony W. LAINE i
dated 8/23/82 264.
SHACKLETON's notes on negative att,empt
^
to contact and locate Karen FRIEND by l
telephone on 8/23/82 SHACKLETON's. notes dated 8/23/82 on 265.
. covering logical leads in this case 266*,
SHACKLETON's notes of 8/24/82 on.the concerns expressed ~ by the a11eger 267*
SHACKLETON's investigative ' plan as of 8/24/82-268.
3HACKLETON's notes on the interview of Jack T. BOMBARD on 8/24/82 269.
SHACKLETON's notes 'on ethe interview of Ved ARORA on 8/24/82 g.
270.
SHACKLETON's notes on the Interview' of John S. HECK on 8/24/82 271.
SHACKLETON's notes on attempting to identify an.NCR on 8/24/82 272.
SHACKLETON's notes on 8/24/82' Documentation of separation requirements 273.
for field cabling within enclosures received from-Ved ARORA on 8/24/82 PVNGS Specification Change Notice 27 &.
13-EM-306 275.
Post Office check for Anthony W. LAINE 276.
SHACKLETON's sketch.of MCC snits examined on 8/24/82 277.
NCR No. E-C 1668 dated 12/16/81 278.
NCRNo.E-C1669 dated.12/16/81 O
O e
ee e
e.+
9 e
e
m
'n p
FOIA Exsmptien f
l
~
279.
NCR No. E-C 1676 dated 12/16/81
\\
280.
Handwrit' ten memo to file by SHACKLETON dated 8/25/82 on the examination of 2-E-NHN-H0317 281.
Haridwritten memo to file by SHACKLETON
. dated 8/25/82 on the review of the personnel file of Anthony W. LAINE 282.
Handwritten memo to file by SHACKLETON dated 8/25/82 listing members of Bechtel management contacted re. the anonymous allegations SHACKLETON's notes on the interview of 283.
. Carl Leonar,d FISHMAN on 8/25/82-
- 284*
Copy of Bechtel.emp_loyment application 6' 7(c) for _
' dated 9/20/81
-~
- 285. _
Copy of resume ofi l
6, 7 (c)
Copy of certificate No. 4274' E from the
- 286.
6, 7(c)
Georgia State Association of Power -
Engineers, Inc. in the name of. ** fi i
- 287.
Copy of Georgia State Board. of 6, 7 (c)
Electgal, Contractors certificate for.
- 288.
Copy of Bechtel worksheet completed 6, 7 (C) by Copy of interoffice memo from John 1 dated 6, 7 (c)
- 289.
L. HANSEN to
~**
3/12/82 Copy of resignation to Bechtel by 6, 7 (c)
] dated 4/29/82 290.
Copy of withdrawal from resignation.by 6 ' 7(C)
[ dated 5/25/82;
- 291.
- Denotes the name of a former Bechtel Co. employee 9
sk j
c-c l
i FOIA Exemption Copy of Bech{el retioest to the University 6, 7 (c) f Minnesota dated 5/27/82 to verify the 292*
earning.of a BE E.E. degree by
~ !
/
Copy of APS correspondence to NRC RV
, 293.
dated 5/24/82 concerning the Final Report - DER 81-53, A 50.55(e),
Reportable Condition Relating to Unit 1, Main Control Panel (JM-200) Violates Wiring Separation Requirements 294.
Copy of SHACKLETON's letter to Ms. Jill MORRISON dated 7/9/82 Investigation Status Report for.the 295.
-period.of 8/1//82 through 10/1/82 Investigation Status Report for thi 296.
period 8/17/82 through 11/1/82 SHACKLETON's memo to file dated 10/7/82
~
297.
setting forth an investigative sumary Investigation Status Report sent to 298.
01:HQ on 10/19/82 Investigation Status Report for the.
y 299.
period 8/17/82 through 1/10/83 l
t' I
- Denotes the name of a former Bechtel Co. employee l
l
^--
- - ~ - - - -
c.
c s.
33 Document Description Data Facsimile Transmittal Request'of 300. -SHACKLETON.to WARD transmitting 11/19/82 Report of Inquiry 05-82-003 to OI:HQ Region V Allegation Data Form for undated 301'.
ROYCE allegation (s) 301A. Regioh Y Inspection Report No.
12/28/82 50-528/82-32 regarding-inspection-
~~
of ROYCE's allegation (s)
+
- r
- ~t...
302.
~ " ".',:~--
Memorandum'of NARBUT to STERNBERG 3/23/83
'et al re: Responsibility for Palo
.'Verd,e Affidavits 303.
Handwritten memorandum of.SHACKLETON to YOUNG re: Palo Verde Unit 1 -
11/17/82 Allegations'Re:
Start-up Program by
'Wallace R.'ROY,CE,
O e
I l
g m
~
Report of Inquiry dated 11/18/82
- 3o4, SHACKLETON's notes on telephone conversation 305*
with Wallace R. ROYCE on 11/19/82 SHACKLETON's notes on telecon with 306.
Senior. Reactor Inspector (Operations)
. at Palo Verde on 11/19/82 SHACKLETON's notes on meeting with 307.
Region V management on 11/19/82 DOL letter to Bechtel Corporation re:
308*
.Wallace ROYCE vs. Bechtel Corporation dated 12/20/82 DOL Employment Information Form dated 309 11/21/82 with attachments: DOL letter to Bechtel Corporation Legal Department dated 11/23/82 and D0L 1etter to Wallace ROYCE dated 11/24/82 4
4
,-~-t--er.~.-.,
n-
cks
(
s Memo o'f MORRISON (Palo Verde.,,-
~
~
310.
Intervention Fund) to. GARDE (GAP) Re:
Allegations at PVNGS, dated December 7,
- 1982, NARBUT (RV) memo to Distribution 311.
captioned Responsibility for Palo Verde Affidavits, dated March 23, 1983 f>
Notes of SHACKLETON re: contact with J. J. CUMMINGS (OIA) concerning death 312.
threat on Robert D. CUNDERSON Jr.,
dated May 24, 1982 Notes of SHACKL$ TON re:information received from T. W. 31 SHOP (RV) on 313.
allegations received from Robert D.
l t
CUNDERSON Jr., dated May 25, 1982 I
O 9
6 4
4 e
b-36 FOIA Exemption
~0 Letter to (name withheld) from 314.
the Arizona Radiation Regulatory 6, 7 (C&D)
Agency (ARRA) dated May 4, 1982
- Letter of GEO Construction Testing 6, 7 (C&D) 315.
to (name withheld) dated April 26, 1982
. Page 8.29-12 from the U.S. Nuclear
- 316.
~ Regulatory Commission Regulatory Guide 8.29 O' Copy of signed statement by 317.
(name withheld) dated January 22,-1982 6, 7 (C&D)
Copy of signed statement by P. Aguaro 6, 7 (C&D) 318.
py signed statement by (name 319*
withheld) 6, 7 (C&D)
Affidavit before the Atomic Safety 320.
and Licensing Board of Wallace R. Royce in the Matter of Arizona Public Service Company dated Feb. 25, 1983 with handwritten notations Letter to Arizona Public Service Company from J. L. Crews, 321.
Subject:
Special flRC Inspection of Palo Verde Units 1, 2 and 3 dated 4-22-83.{
Letter to Arizona Public Service Company from D. H. Sternberg, l
322.
Subject:
Special NRC Inspection of Palo Verde Units 1, 2 and 3 dated 4-25-83.
e e
o P
'7~
(.
C TAPE RECORDED INTERVIEWS Date of FOIA
_Name.
Job Title Interview Exemption
- 323.
- AGUAYO, P.A..
Electrician 6/17/82 7 (A) t
- 324.
- ANDERSON, Electrical 7/15/82 Clinton M.,
Jr.
Engineer 325.-
BAKER, William M.
Journeyman 7/15/82 Wireman
! 32 6._-
- BUNTING, 7/13/82 James Terry
,327.
- BURDICK, QC Engineer 7/01/82 William R.
!328.
CRANE, Joseph H.
Foreman 6/17/82 Electrical
!329.
DEAKINS,_ Richard A.
QC Engineer 7/01/82 Level II-Electrical 4
330.
DOEBLER, Norman J.
General Foreman 7/02/82 Electrical
'331.
GOLDBERG, Michael B.
Sr. Construction 6/28/82 Engineer
- GUNDERSON, Former 6/01/82 7 (C) i332.
Robert D.,Jr.
Electrician 7 (D)
I at PVNGS 333.
HALL, Forrest R.
Electrician 6/16/82 l334.
HANZE, John T.
Level II 7/01/83 QC Engineer 1
- 335.
KEITH, Richard B.,
Jr.
High Voltage 6/17/82 Foreman i336.
- KENNARD, G.A.
Electrician 6/17/82 7 ( A)
'337,
- LEGG, C.D.
. Electrician 6/17/82*
- 7. ( A) 338.
- MAST, D.J.
Electrician 6/17/82 7 (A)
'339.
- MOODY, Steven J.
Electrician 6/17/82 7 (A)
(
38 Date of FOIA
,Name Job Title Interview Exemption 340.
- NUNEZ, Hector R.
General Foreman 6/29/82 7 ( A)
Electrical
~
341.
OSWALD,' James Electrician 7/02/82 Walter' Michael 342.
REHFFLD, Rursell A Electrical QC 6/30/82 Engineer 343.
RUFF, Robert C.,
Jr.
Electrical Field 7/15/82 Engineer 344.
- SANDOVAL, Joe G.
Forman 6/28/82 7 (A)
Electrical 345.-
- SCHUH, John H.
Electrician 6/17/82 7 (A) 346.
SEGER, Kenneth H.
Electrician 6/17/82 347.
SOLLAMI, Philip A.
Electrician 6/16/82 348.
- SWEET, James B.
Electrician 6/28/82 7 ( A) 349.
VISE, Jack E.
General Foreman 7/02/82 Electricial Start-up 350.
- WALLERSTEIN, Cary Electrician 6/16/82 7 (A) 351.-
WILLIAMS, Louis, Jr.
Termination 6/28/82 Engineer 8352 YOSHIMOTO, Sus Foreman 7/13/82 Electricial 353.
- (withheld)
(withheld) 6/16/82 7 (D) 354.
- (withheld)
(withheld) 6/11/82 7 (D) 7 (A)
C-D 39 u...
'355.
Memorandum for Desk Officer, OI HQ (V-82-Oll)
.from Owen C. Shackleton Jr., Acting Director, DIRVF0,
Subject:
Palo Verde - Allegations from an Anonymous Alleger Re: Electrical Installations (dated July 22, 1982 356.
Investigation Status Sheet of Owen C.
Shakleton,
Subject:
Palo Verde -
Anonymous Alleger Re Electrical (6/9/82) 4 4
e
r.
p 40 FOIA Exemption 357.
- Undated Six-page draft of 4/5/83 Memorandum to 5
i the Commissioners from James A. Fitzgerald, Assistant General Counsel and John E.
- Zerbe, Director, Office of Program Evaluation,
Subject:
"Palo Verde Immediate Effectiveness Decision".
358.
- Undated Five-page draft of 4/5/83 Memorandum to 5
the Commissioners from James A. Fitzgerald, Assistant General Counsel and John E. Zerbe, 1
Director, Office of Program Evaluation,
Subject:
"Palo Verde Immediate Effectiveness Decision".
359.
- 4/5/83 Four-page Memorandum (SECY-83-125) to the 5
Commissioners from Martin G. Malsch, Deputy General Counsel and John E.
Zerbe, Director Office of Program Evaluation,
Subject:
"Palo Verde Immediate Effectiveness Decision and Review of ALAB-713".
4 j
\\
e
-,m~m.__=_-
.ss
___i 41 0.
f'
' Relevant Portions of NRC Comnission Meeting 360.
Transcript Ret Discussion /Possible Vote on Contested Issues in Palo Verde Full' Power Proceeding (dated March 15, 1983)
The released portions are the following:
- p. 2 (lines 21 - 25), p. 3 (lines 1 - 9),
- p. 19 (lines 14 - 25), p. 20 - 40,
- p. 41 - (lines 1 - 22), p.
44 - 46, p. 47 (line 1) cnd p. 55 (lines 3 - 10).
Other portions of'the transcript deal with resolution of the cdjudication and are not relevant to the investigation and are not within the scope i
of the request.
e 4
l i
I e
I