ML20115F229

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Staff Exhibit S-1,consisting of 901018 Memo Re Potential Discrimination.Partially Deleted
ML20115F229
Person / Time
Site: Neely Research Reactor
Issue date: 05/21/1996
From:
AFFILIATION NOT ASSIGNED
To:
References
CON-#396-17752 REN-S-001, REN-S-1, NUDOCS 9607170155
Download: ML20115F229 (4)
v • d • e


Text

-

MRC/1RM/IRHB/RASS TEL:301-415-6434 Mar 27'96 15:55 Nc.002 P.04/07

p. g

- -,j; }-[.'.~. ;a;,9,

Q, :..Q., '~. '";..,..

,.:. {._

~,..

  • ,r

.r

.;'.~e:: Q :.,':

6

.d. j N RM M.., / -

7.

I i

.. s h.,l.'.IrI II[. '..j/". .'. I.C[h.... :v.I

. g..,;

7. i

,* b l C g g g,fk,..[}

.I S$.

e

.. z-

. i.,..g:g.:

g' ;e.g

.- : r...s > '.... %.. lj;] :;.;;,=..,;.,.,;.

..s smm:

sozarxxI. mememvrrm:<'

O,'

.'...IW:/.s. ;. * <W GEEGIA TEM. M..ch.?.',-

./. -..

,.. c.. Igr TT.tw:.

.R.I1-so-s-o M...': ::

g. x.g ;.'..::, W !.;;. ;9. h :
..:.:.. o.

v.

M:

'95.JLL to..: g o 9 g.'

.."cnsz 11Iz les' 1-

~.

. v...

..,. "...,..1:,.C ? *..

.DME RIENID:

OCICBEIL 18r.-l.1990 '

, J.

. M...,.: l C

<.a.

,.v

. t '

  • TIME RECENED:

8:00am..

.x.r: > 1

n. a N..........'$. g

~

ggyggtW, g;e
_3' e

. f.

q,.]

m>

l 9....g". :..+' <;.'...,

y

.... 1 -..

25/<.1990m DME PREPARED:

rmW

. B P. ~,..

ns.

~.

.,. /. t7 * ?.... F. ',i,

i.

J PREERRED BT.

OSCAR. DEMIRhNDE /i.

...'.:,... h+ !'.< ",/w !,?.

T.'

. s t-TYPE JCEEVITY:'

REEMD OE' PI.M.. E.CCENERSAT.ICIT

',.)... f? -

q.. n....,.

PAREICIPANS:'

TNMNQil, &l7RS0y WN CDECDIT.":i365-6566.:hin't 894-3601 W.,b

U,'i'[l N NO2'l N..h #< 34814ake Sidsi/ Drive'.N.Eul.y 1 v.
c P, Apt:f 2905, *1 =*=,i.G(c3,.0326..;

i.

c s

,i j

,. SMBRT OE' INEGMM'ICN:.C&BOL CCMEEI..advhei RACi.thatG=ha"liaiNxeceived. a '

r*== ciu:fmn'm.6,;.that% had.

receivai a copy of a 1***

me=*iin fnr'Dr BRIEN (MCMT do. is.

.the RSO at.rwnyia Tetit.

tisat:2.be Md.:VioridenShoef.be. received '

s. -

S time.1a++=r as it was cn his desk"this==4M.M zend 'the.letier to'.

. i:

CImEtI, d.irt n-W to.bave 46m 1w fm that wo@i'k lof $yL.---c..ts tis '

y."

., c.$. e.

,. w,,

'.<..,i n..

.,.,:p... p,....

.JRnc, URTC, (INEEI. =dWAIPINE. agreed';WN-wadm1Nfcibtaid.w

....?,$py of.the; '

ici

' 1 A+- fcr car meistr CIMEEI. iobeni~ a V. copy of ~tbIaTaH4N?CM tile SamS

~

.c. -

N

,, day. Ube. letter was revired' by: mM/S"mR who. advised; tidti'iRBCl.sbould

' interview time RSO, " =--.:J tha~ intervier ana. advisa -fodf s ARP n==='b4me a

~

i i ; '
.:t a. ;..

.,..?..;;.il?..> u '..T.y C....- - ".-. ~.

. ~..

v ;.On 10/25/90; 6 9:30,,9:56 amp.tfidi ~RSO'Iha Rac.:p6r..Rac'h hq.=.t.wh'M,

Y:

's; was.a=====arge Inft co tiie' RSO's3== = wig weh4mk..:Wei.dih=ad.the latter f

and -in per+M'1=v.the' =*m::ie ifant states,."I also, ob%ct(hci/J_.;.,=4. lens' '

l

. frcxn y-~1F ami Dr. Rersin that
I dW1E"nat, 'iifths futdre,! anr==et, W - W1 regulatnry'vinleimes.or y1@M n.r. -M W[u.:.RAC asked.,

.:the RSO to <~nlain what the.n==im was of_that.1- /_ +->= aniidn'pa:Mmale-c

.were there any. safety inew==%hich wer-Q" --;1ved';; i 3be Eso.said that Adie t

.his enployment pe,a at Georgia.Toch he/.4M4fiM ! safety.14 h.htt mat all.

of them have been resolvsi.92he'RSO snio that he.Ws.Li?.hi.td &-2 <---' 'N -

l

..;4. safety icev= and sugges+-irm'forii w.m.-

soi.tha' 1.there'.wouldier.a 4+ -

t

.of the issue that would.=W-.. U fdr..his% -+4 hili $eis..cthe?SO.said that

.'.;. : /,.ne'gottha 4,

  • d:n fmn EAREN.and. RE USIN that.iti'was.n66,reem==rT to

~

Anr===F israea.of this nature.-fcBBC askini.the:R$D :if'.1EREMiand'RP5Kt4 i

d his letfor of r==Wn*farivith'liim.E'ihikRSinmid thatither wena.

i.

. '(.A amacabsth sorry to see him' leave maJthat tiiey.bothM4' s

Athat bes:,the REDr must 4

tis.lQ.heved.hadda j=rNm with f

Ubif both M Q'i 1

' ~ '. have mb..-h-i Wm-t';:- Q:....g.;?.f

. him ? '- -. --.' im safety +===5

~

.. ;....v :. :

,iRac asked the RSO if.he.liad:.ang. safety.1M.thathi'.#---3".shm1 A havn been s.....

...e._2. i and were noF nna.W.RSo w? %Unol.tbati.he'.always Anrwaanted 1L : ' --i A - - E' 'r='=na MWhed his:

unfs=ey i==ww ami program bM,kn.or.%pm 1Jcamsidp;at.a1. Taw data

-r memos widely so eat if the @l 3.,.t.< ;.l:3.;...;..:. j g >

,. L,... ~.... *

.,G:.

c m,

a "s

. y

~

..d *.

. :.-.u. :a>

NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION Docket No.

J' o -/- (o c-O A.)

EXHIBIT NO.

l 2

l'

,;t.',.U?

in the rnatter et /So. AA/

~

. 9607170155 960521

'.A'..'il '.vtaff D Applicant D intervenor D Other PDR ADOCK 05000160 G

PDR M./

G rdentified Ey6ceived D Rejected Reporter LO ( bd 6

Witn OC

.. Dat.e-37

' *:);*:. t.s g:?..: C.%.\\ 4./.4..:.6c.7. :.e.ss

.../

r v.

?!.* M. G. %, m. '.

d.

v-a q.

)

Mar 27'96 15:56 No.002 P.05/07 RC/IRM/ZRMB/RASS TEL:301-415-6434 y..;

pr. '......:~.. >

q'

^

. s ;., A q.,..,.

-.,.i.

..r

.  ; s

..,s..,r.

,g,

.n'*

.t LCX2trnED.4;:' j,6 -

4._.f.y.

PES T.,*'"

.RII-90-&O178

~

. :.:. '..,,10-15-90 p!,.

a.'

?:

be war,1d xx:rt be held ra~,, a-ihli. --in.cre: case #nN raerdva tiF. n-credit in the -

. F.' f P......",: '., '

~ '.,. l..'. l n's. '

0.' ;. F..

J' c...other case.

.1 3

  • y

.. s..,,... - =.. >.

=. _..,

y.,-

.s..:... y.

.-:., 7

. RAC askad. the RSO.tkiy.be _merirmna: ani.the. RED m~ s--%that.be felt that he" aian't have the <=ymieir=1l fW '- to =narje anin4T14hrrt ethe M4 a+4m.

safety. p.eg

.at Georgia, Tech 4.RBC askna:,the.BSO,.,'to %Tv4nina the.RSO s=vfM that everytime he would,th-+' a'gd.mi ial..safet:y;;bl gor b e.4wv-M, Land that all be had.to cb was.4mWi M44,ui.+.Aiy.:ti).f-:g--L the 4arw.

- be.was told by RE75IN.or: PAREM that itivas' rw.?lhe.ESO nio..itdit dm ba dia.

5

+he=wyh, it had.. to be1+hr=m 1da.....

single daily 4=14w-w 1.aLion offthe.gc.,:g.p/ Beddas, ther.were, involved in every '

yG'Jbes RSO 'said that

> riot'.evin.alltued to M -~

'm

~

' '..}:f g' ',;,g.g;w what his.:n y prinritics were;{

... s,.

,e, :

s r h RSO mia that REUSnt objectxxi to hisl.s,m, 'h,e,.....m-H Harxi' mfr=ty

,.. o..-

-. 4 =>vw he waald rhm-t bar==a'be.sa.r@ that itdrr4.how;das;a bar=*ive

..rdiae+4m cn bcr past perfn=6en 'asphn had previm41f -been.the RSO. 'Iba 7, he das hMrry mir ro-managedia' i elected;to I-v other

RED said that hwir 11 n
  • T mymm+.
  • 1 F.,'

.$.9:..

1

, :.;r.7,.., W. <.s <

.o

. /Ihe 5so said that.beiVill'be aEGeorgia~ Tech tr:til71D2/90k;dn:Ixrmin in this'

. area.for anotbcr.t:o wooks. ' elho RSO~ r=do cthat;ho:.will:bo'.ntning to Ios Angelis,;

..crto work at_ a bnmital but '.that be. has)not received the offer in. writing as.

'k t

'4 W:....J...,.

of yet.

~

4

-PAC asked the RSO.if he had'ainyN154Hesliinfo-MedbE:v....

.t,

.la i ho to di am"

, armi be resptxx*.ei.noE Enc. advised'.the EED..thattwe w&zid I=hhip xxyt be takinJ -

- L. fdr!+hr>i h tr=Mne*

.'any ar+4m cn the mLL.w.o+hr r than a1<>rtirxy m%,#

in nna - W a hy the ESO wl aih414 ties..ani in+=-Fne=;withimnapa.uL for

_4 w %;%e.nSo.agrool.that mo.tsrar+4m:was s.repired'lx.this mti,

r 4, m. -

land'in fact stated tint.3GECtand REUSIN were sozMt6..see him leave. h; BSD said that they vmla.have.pm% rrr'L that bosstay;hrv-m%cf.the b,f.b,i

' ! %.',.',;,.,' @,.[

1

" RED S..

~. ' :.J -m of recruiting. a IT %,,-

1-F;c%fm ad the BSO'.that ourw-H ierrwald cc'rist4Maflosure of this

..Mt v and that if any nadiMe=1'. 4h.oripaMc(ci:x:e,to hind to feel free to cer+ne t re.." 'Iba ESO agreed.with. the. r-l'.+.:4m of'.this caso..

e.,. v.a..,

,,.,...,,>, ;. 'y

  • si S

r w

c. s.

o,y:

y L, Q.. y '.

5*..

n tz. :.'

s

\\

r, y.1 2.

.v

.,.f,,

w. ' ;

m

  • ..l., b y :

..; :..:V..;. -

'. :,~ f,

Q,.[

.,' i d '.'[$*' 1;,.,. ':-l [-[.} U,

/

t.

.v G...i V

.g, ',.!,

p. s.

a w.

s...

.p.....

s.,j p,q,

,..,..,,,('.-

,s.

+ :.} t x,;,

i,.'.

s

,.a.

l t:,

.a

.c. -

,f-

.t.'.

c.,y v

.:4 i

.ly ; *,

S:lf,

z e

i

-,,...,,..';..', ' ',...(,',

g

,'S * : !

..\\ *

[1

.,8.,.',.'.l'..,

.[..

1,.,e,

.t) t,'l l,r.

'..1 ;'.6

-l
f.., ', ' \\

..v..-e.s

.;i.-

.8.,

j t,..

...r

. *;. ? ~,

.,s *

,'.s,,.e.,c.,

s s i :<.

e,';..,....,:-

2.* :.. P. <

.. -, *s

, s"...

s I

.n'*

s e,f.

.,.,s-- r.

4.,.,

s e. r ?,.

c.s.*

.,.h*,.

. ;l{

. ',. p...,.

s r

.... s s i r,

-l:

~,

. ~,

[n [.'.g*..*".'i... 5 f..

<,.,l,..

\\ r~

., s.:,. '.....,

. V.,s,',hi". l*:... /%.

. j (*.

' ' '.~.

r

.I:.*.

~

s.

s.$.. '. *-

g# ; y *l *.; c;...'.. e,

1 tRC/IRM/IRMB/RASS

,TE,L:301-415-6434 Mar 27'96 15:58 No.002 P.07/07 GeGrgia Institute of Technology NEEl Y NUCLEAR RESEAACH CEENTER 900 ATLANTIC CRfVE ATtu<rA ssasmamassaoms i

90 DCT 28 A10 : 22 " ***

l October 8, 1990 Dr. R. A. Karam, Director Neely Nuclear Research Centar Georgia Institute of Technology Dear Dr. Karams 4

I regrat that I must offer my resignation from the position of Nannger, Office of Radiation Spfaty and Senior Research Scientist offective November 2, 1990 After carefull consideration I feel that it is impossible for me to work effectively within the structure of the radiation safety program at Georgia Tech.

I believe that the Manager, office of Radiation Safety (M.O.R.S. )

lacks sufficient operational freedom to adequately conduct the radiation safety program.

Specifically, health physics staff appear to be under the dual control of the H.O.R.S.

and the facility Associate Director.

On a personal basis, I have been discouraged from j

==Mng even minor decisions without first consulting you and Dr.

Revnin.

I also object to suggestions from yoursplf and Dr.

i Revsin that I should not, in the

future, document observed 1

regulatory violations or proposed program improvements.

I cannot, in good conscience, take responsibility for a program whose priorities I cannot set and in which I must comprcmise my professional judgments.

Sincerely, 7

[.-,I Q

Brian Copeutt, Ph.D.

cc: Dr. B.K. Ravain Dr. Gary Poehlein Fa-ban, Nuclear Safeguards C

  • ttee

~

r e - =a a m ty. a a***'59 m

r g

MM N

a thw he w

  • s'h

t

! 4RC/IRH/IRMB/RASS TEL:301-415-6434 Mar 27'96 15:57 No.002 P.06/0i

~

Georgia Institute of Technology OCT 181990 c

M NEELY NUCLEAR RESEARCH CENTER NOC#O y

eco ATLANTC CMfVE ATL.ANTA. GEo AGtA 3C33e-04e5 po43 e October 8, 1990 Dr. R. A. Earam, Director

/(,

Neely Nuclear Research Center 1

Georgia Institute of Technology N

M11~-90-A-6/

Dear Dr. Karen:

I regret that [ y:ust_ offer, ry, pes.ignatioy from the position of Mannger, Office TNa~cfiation

!$1fety and Senior Research Scientist effectivo November 2, 1990.

1 After carefull consideration I feel that it is impossible for I::e to work effectively within the structure of the radiation cafety program at Georgia Tech.

I believe that the Manager, Office of Radiation Safety (M.O.R.S. )

lacks sufficient cperational freedom to edequately conduct the radiation safety program.

Specifically, health physics staff appear to be nnda-the dual control of the M.O.R.S.

and the facility Associate Director.

On a personal basis, I have been discouraged frcm making even ninor decisions without first consulting you and Dr.

I also object to sug thEI~~sTciuld ' n5f'~1H 'gestions from yoursel and Dr.

Revein.

~fRE~fiffu 6~"" dom (~ obYe~rM 7

~

1 Revsin

'r"egEIWtic27'Tri&IiffiBEF"cf"pr$~pIissinf'p'Ed WFxqir6Fements.

i 6

e_.=

, -..,.,,,....... - -,= __

I cannot, in good conscience, take responsibility for a program whose priorities I cannet set and in

.dtich I must compromise rf professional ludgments.

r b?

n.s,.

e. ~~

(* /,% f.j NV--

Sincerely, T

C

(

& S & ?.A 4.-;L d b

7 n. A N Y'"@X Brian Copt:utt, Ph.D.

, s c s h u i,, $ 5 6 1 cc: Dr. B.K. Revsin Dr. Gary Poehlein Members, Nticlear Safeguards Ccumittee roc o.4e44 noev.s.osas.4sso r

rec.c usarciniacAAtt Aa fear E*mmon we r=ser=== oneos.*v a u-a e r= % srs== w ***p=

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20115F229&oldid=4288554"